Pink Floyd | Ten Best Songs
Vložit
- čas přidán 2. 08. 2024
- Pink Floyd what are their best ten tracks? These in my opinion are good places to start your interstellar journeying into the heart of this band's extensive oeuvre.
Please like, share, and comment!
Support my channel: / classicrock
Check out the Facebook page: / 1968rock
All music used in my videos come from the Free Music Archive: freemusicarchive.org/
#pinkfloyd #best - Hudba
Lysergic Tourette’s
I love it. Keep them coming. I love your opinions on these classic songs.
1-Dogs, 2-Shine On, 3-Us and Them, 4-Echoes, 5-Pigs Three Different Ones, 6- Great Gig In The Sky, 7-High Hopes, 8-In The Flesh, 9-Fearless, 10-Time
Dogs #1 outstanding
That album IMO their best
1 - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I -IX)
2 - Echoes
3 - Time
4 - Dogs
5 - It's What We Do
6 - On the Turning Away
7 - Summer '68
8 - Mother
9 - High Hopes
10 - The Narrow Way (Part 3)
1) Wish you were here (this is basically my favorite song of all time!)
2) Comfortably Numb
3) Time
4) Echoes
5) Shine on you Crazy Diamond
6) Great gig in the Sky
7) Sheep
8) One of these days
9) Keep Talking
10) Sorrow
1. Echoes
2. Flaming
3. Lost For Words
4. Breathe
5. Careful With That Axe Eugene
6. Wish You Were Here
7. Alan's Psychedelic Breakfast
8. Cymbaline
9. Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
10. Mother
1.Brain Damage-Eclipse
2. Dogs
3. Hey You
4. High Hopes
5. Pigs
6. The Trial-Outside the Wall
7. Nobody Home
8. Shine on you crazy diamond 1-9
9. Gunners Dream
10. Us and Them
Remember a day!!! So nice to see that it gets some attention. Dogs being first is a great choice and I agree with you that Rick Wright was correct about Echoes.
The meddle album and Echoes got me hooked on pink floyd.
It was Fearless for me, but Meddle definitely got me into PF
1 Allan's psychedelic breakfast
2 Us & them
3 Set the controls for the heart of the sun
4 Learning to fly
5 Time
6 Echoes
7 The division bell
8 Have a cigar
9 several species of small furry animals gathered in a cave & grooving with a pict
10 See Emily play
@@stephenclarke1640 Awesome list! I have a growing appreciation for AHM, it's probably in my top 3 now, so seeing Alan's at anyone number 1 is nice to see
Yes I loved echoes
1 - Echoes (like Waters said "Dark Side's Mother and Father")
2 - Mother (Live version, with extended solo)
3 - Time / Breathe reprise
4 - High Hopes
5 - Have a Cigar
6 - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (full)
7 - One of these Days, etc. (Pompeii)
8 - Dogs
9 - The Great Gig In The Sky
10 - Astronomy Domine (Love Voivod's cover, so is a GREAT song)
interesting choices. Think I would pick: 1) See Emily Play, 2) Arnold Lane 3) Bike, 4) Corporal Clegg 5) Another Brick in The Wall Part two, 6)Time, 7)Us and Them, 8)Shine on you Crazy Diamond, 9) Have a cigar, 10) Echoes.
Good analysis. I actually learned some things I didn't know. A good friend of mind has said his favorite Floyd song is the one he's listening to at the moment. Well said.
Dogs is my no.1 as well, man that guitar work is serious business. Animals contains Dave’s most ferocious, angry, dramatic playing. If you haven’t heard it, listen to the Oakland 77 bootleg. It’s a real treat to hear Dave improvise and stretch out his solos. My favorite Floyd is the early stuff by a long shot however, I really connect with the dark, spacey, avant garde psychedelic jamming they used to do. Cheers!
The Pulse live version of Coming Back to Life has always been one of my top Floyd songs.
1 lucifer Sam
2. Candy and a currant bun
3. Atom heart mother
4. See Emily play
5. Stay
6. The narrow way
7. Shine on...
8. Lucy leave
9. Remember a day
10. Interstellar overdrive
Awesome list
I love lucifer Sam. Interesting no echoes.
Excellent selection, although my own list would have to put _"Comfortably Numb"_ in the top spot, probably with _"Dogs"_ at the second spot. The remainder of my top 10 would include almost all of the songs in your list, although not in the same order. It's really nice to see _"High Hopes"_ mentioned. When _"The Division Bell"_ was released I felt it was a relatively weak album for Pink Floyd, but eventually noticed that I was playing it over and over again without getting tired of it, and that's especially true of _"High Hopes"._
Almost agree with you, except for Darkside and Division Bell.
One of my all time favorites is the A Side of "Atom Heart Mother". Glad you have Saucerfull Of Secrets and The Piper Of The Gates Of Dawn on your list.
Thank you for your contributions. Stay healthy :)
10) Sorrow
09) One Of These Days
08) Welcome To The Machine
07) Comfortably Numb
06) Sheep
05) Time
04) Breathe (In The Air)
03) Pigs (Three Different Ones)
02) Shine On You Crazy Diamond pts. (I - IX)
01) Dogs
Ooo, _"Sorrow"_ is a good song to mention in a top 10 for PF.
Just got a thumbnail of 'Julia Dreams' from a rather charming 1968 black and white video from the band, with a youthful Gilmour appearance that's completely charmed me. I was never the greatest fan of Floyds more, fey, Lysergic- infused- offerings- per se, with the exception of say, Grantchester Meadows, Fat old sun and Green is the colour perhaps, but this tune is quite the revelation.
There's an incredible number of weird and wonderful bands coming my way lately via thumbnails from the glory days of the early 70's, e.g-Camel, Werewolf, Caravan...all with at least a smattering of 'keepers'- songs for the mp3.There's even stunning archive concert footage trickling through as well; in particular a Genesis,1973 appearance at Paris, Bataclan that is unfathomably good in cinematic quality. What a great tragedy Floyd didn't get their Wall concerts adequately filmed.
Really enjoyed this, brings back memories of first hearing Floyd. For my top 10 I could've just said the Animals & Wish You Were Here albums. Instead my top 10 are:
1. Sheep
2. Comfortably Numb
3. Fat Old Sun
4. Childhood's End
5. High Hopes
6. Two Suns In The Sunset
7. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
8. Cymbeline
9. Time
10. Echoes.
Wow, you really went deep with your explanation. I think you made some great choices and I also love AHM too. I just think we need to love the songs. The great thing about ALL Pink Floyd music is it can mean something different to every lister and no one is wrong. This added with the fact their music is as relevant today as it was the day it was written makes it even more special!
I agree
Dogs is a stellar choice for your number one Pink Floyd song.
I don't think i've ever listend to this song without playing it all the way through, it's just that good.
Atmospheric and subtle, but gloriously metaphoric in it's tones, it really is a tour-de-force of Pink Floyd at the peak of their powers.
Love this song ❤
Great video 👍
1. Atom Heart Mother Suite
2. Echoes
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
4. The Great Gig in the Sky
5. Wish You Were Here
6. Us and Them
7. Fearless
8. Comfortably Numb
9. Childhood’s End
10. Stay
Another great vid! I was so pleased you dedicated that much time to MEDDLE..."One of These Days" is still huge in my life...when I worked overnight "progressive" rock radio, I/we (all the jocks did it) used to play "Dogs" and count the number of times the word echoes through the piece -- that's how boring overnight radio can be! (And none of us ever had the same word count!) I must agree with Roxanne Walsh below...I did love me some "See Emily Play." Thanks, Barry!
Thank you for taking the time to watch and comment.
1- Dogs
2- Brain Damage / Eclipse
3- Atom Heart Mother
4- Echoes
5- Comfortably Numb
6- Carefull With that Axe Eugene (Live at Pompeï)
7- Embryo (Live at the BBC)
8- Grandchester Meadows
9- Fat Old Sun
10- A Pillow of Wind
* Honnorable mentions: Fearless, Green is the Colour, Astronomy Domine, Let there be more light, Shine on you crazy diamond, The Post-War Dream, Nobody Home, Julia Dream, Pigs (Three Different ones), Cymbaline
Completely agree with top 5. Well done. You nailed the descriptions
1) Comfortably Numb
2) Echoes
3) Shine on you crazy Diamond
4) Sorrow
5) One of these days
6) Us and them
7) Time
8) On the Turning away
9) High Hopes
10) Sheep
This was great. Thanks for sharing.
My pleasure... do subscribe and check out my other videos.
@@classicalbum : yes I have sub. I found your channel about 2 months ago. The J. Tull, RUSH and best live albums were so indepth. Exit...stage left has always been my favorite. Geddy's bass is so clear. Anyhow, I'm done bothering you. Take care.
Thoughtful video, well done. My list would be similar although I'd only include "Mk. II" Floyd songs from Meddle to The Wall, when the band figured out who they were and truly peaked. Fat Old Sun and Remember A Day are great songs, but they would have to be honorable mentions. Curious that Mr. CAR didn't rate any of The Wall tunes as good enough to make his cut. It's tough to leave off Comfortably Numb, which arguably has not only the best guitar solo in their catalog, but it might be the greatest guitar solo in Classic Rock history, no offence to Mr. Page.
#1 Shine On You Crazy Diamond Pts. I-IX (the entire song, perhaps technically a medley). In fact, it's my favorite song in all of music for all the reasons Mr. CAR describes. Beautiful, haunting, timeless.
#2 Time (includes another eye-watering guitar solo)
#3 Wish You Were Here
#4 Comfortably Numb (as mentioned, includes greatest guitar solo of all time)
#5 Echoes
#6 Us And Them
#7 Welcome To The Machine
#8 One Of These Days
#9 The Great Gig In The Sky
#10 Dogs
Wow. This video was truly a pleasure to listen to. Thank you for your in-depth and passionate explanation. While I find it difficult to create my top ten tracks, I can say that ‘Mother’ is my favorite track from a PF album. However, David Gilmour’s ‘Echoes’ from Gdańsk album is my favorite PF track.
Since I'm still catching up on videos since I started watching your channel, I just came upon this one today, and it is very good.
Your thoughts were well articulated, and I liked how you were all over the spectrum, particularly early albums, which made me very happy.
Absolutely agree with Atom Heart Mother...simply stellar album that I play regularly.
Meddle, being my favorite, I completely agree with your thoughts on the two songs...
I'd like to mention that before the pandemic, Nick was talking about how his wonderful band, Saucerful Of Secrets, were thinking about adding Echoes to a future set list.
Anyway, rambling...just a well done video...✌
The joy of these lists is that no-one is right and no-one is wrong. I love Atom Heart Mother but hardly ever play Animals, an album I don't care for. There, I said it...
10. Poles Apart
9. A Saucerful of Secrets
8. Sorrow
7. Comfortably Numb
6. The Great Gig in the Sky
5. Echoes
4. Dogs
3. Time
2. Astronomy Domine
1. Shine on You Crazy Diamond (Parts i - ix)
I appreciate the breakdown that you give your particular topic. I find it difficult to compile lists, but here goes. 1. Great Gig in the Sky, 2. Dogs, 3. One of these Days, 4. Shine on you Crazy Diamond, 5. Wish you were Here, 6. Atom Heart Mother, 7. Brain Damage/Eclipse, 8. One of my Turns, 9. Pigs( Three Different Ones), 10. Echoes.
1. Welcome To The Machine, 2. Dogs, 3. Time/Breathe Reprise, 4. Sheep, 5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, 6. Comfortably Numb, 7. Have A Cigar, 8.Pigs (Three Different Ones), 9. Wish You Were Here, 10. (Tie) On The Turning Away & Hey You
When it comes to songs it is worth mentioning their beginnings: when I was still a child and before I knew any of the LPs they had some singles that were almost like from another band altogether - Arnold Layne, See Emily Play, Scarecrow and - best of all - Paintbox.
10. Green is the Colour
9. Careful With That Axe, Eugene
8. Let There Be More Light
7. Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
6. Cymbaline
5. Fat Old Sun
4. One of These Days
3. Time
2. Echoes
1. Wish You Were Here
I made the list prior to watching the video, so I am astonished how many matches we have...
@@roxannewalsh Great minds think alike - thank you for taking the time to watch
@@roxannewalsh PF should do a song about your outstanding red hair, Roxanne !
My second favorite pink floyd song is Jugband blues. I have a soft spot for Syd and this song paints a painful picture of feeling alienated from his band and bandmates. We'll never know how much acid he took and the ultimate toll it had on him and I think the lyrics are surreal with him telling how he was something to be in charge of. He never wanted to be an icon of great attention or accept the demands from his producers and bandmates alike to create money making hits to no end. I still cry at the end of shine on you crazy diamond.
My top 10 goes:
1) Shine On You Crazy Diamond
2) Comfortably Numb
3) Breathe in The Air
4) In The Flesh
5) Time
6) Dogs
7) Wish You Were Here
8) Us And Them
9) Pigs (Three Different Ones)
10) One of These Days
Awesome list! Well explained!
My Personal Top Ten:
1. Comfortably Numb
2. Time
3. Shine On You Crazy Diamond I-V
4. Brain Damage/Eclipse
5. Dogs
6. Pigs (Three Different Ones)
7. Learning To Fly
8. In The Flesh (Both ?And!)
9. Wish You Were Here
10. Fearless
Also Floyd-Tracks that would be in my Top Ten, but couldn't hence there are only ten spots:
Mother, One Of These Days, High Hopes, Echoes, Fat Old Sun, Have A Cigar, Sheep, Hey You, Interstellar Overdrive, Set the Controls For The Heart Of The Sun, Keep Talking...
Someone has mentioned Interstellar Overdrive at last. Thanks.
Mine is
1 Dogs
2 Time
3 Pigs (Three different ones) 2018 remix
4 Comfortably Numb
5 Have a Cigar
6 Shine on you crazy diamond
7 Money
8 Echoes
9 Sheep
10 Wish You Were Here
1 - Echoes
2 - Comfortably Numb (Live)
3 - Pigs (Three Different Ones)
4 - The Great Gig In The Sky
5 - Shine On You Crazy Diamonds (All Parts)
6 - Money
7 - Us & Them
8 - Another Brick In The Wall (Part 2)
9 - Wearing The Inside Out
10 - Wish You Were Here
My favorite PF song is A Pillow of Winds. It's so cosmically romantic. The whole Meddle album is in a world apart from their other albums. It was raw and pure, taking from the innocence of the Barrett years, and going another step beyond, into uncharted territory. I really like Julia Dream, as well.
Mine would be... 1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond, 2. Brain Damage/Eclipse, 3. Echoes, 4. Sheep, 5. Comfortably Numb, then in no particular order, the entire rest of DSotM, Welcome to the Machine, Sorrow, Yet Another Movie, High Hopes, Hey You, Dogs, One of These Days, and Let There Be More Light.
I'm a huge fan of 'DOGS' also. I saw Roger perform this in So. Florida at an outdoor amphitheater . The mood, temperature, and ambience was perfect. IN THE FLESH tour, I think.
In no particular order (they are all masterpieces): Echoes (a turning point in their career, true prog masterpiece). Time (possibly their greatest song, all 4 members as writers, it has everything, clocks, legendary solo, great lyrics, two vocals, everything), Us & Them (lyrically and musically sublime), The Great Gig in the Sky (can make a grown man cry), Wish You Were Here, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (ode to their friend and colleague), Dogs (arguably best Gilmour guitar work?), Comfortably Numb (what more to say), On the Turning Away (very very underrated song in their catalog, very moving piece), High Hopes (best post-waters song and certainly top 5 best songs of Pink Floyd).
Huge Floyd fan since the mid 70's. If I had to recommend 10 songs to someone who's never heard Floyd and I wanted them to get a true taste of their music (In the 70's) this would be my list. (in no particular order)
1) Dogs
2) One of these Days
3) Hey You
3) Pigs (three different ones)
4) Have a Cigar
5) The Final Cut
6) Time
7) Goodbye Blue Sky
8) Any colour you like
9) Wish you were here
10) Welcome to the machine
Welcome is in my top 10, also. You're the first one I found in agreement !
It would be very difficult for me to produce a list of PF's ten best songs, but I do know that "Childhood's End" would be on it. Thanks, Barry.
Chidhoods End is in my top 5 Pink Floyd songs. So understated.
@@Blue_Dingo It was the last song they recorded with the classic lineup that Roger Waters didn't have a writing credit on. It was all Gilmour.
@@b2tall239 So nice that Nick Mason's Saucer Full of Secrets, added it to the Lineup.
@@Blue_Dingo Yeah. Saw them in Miami Beach and was thrilled when they played it.
@@Blue_Dingo I saw one of those concerts on YT and if memory serves their entire play list that night preceded DSOTM. You can find a lot of good music in those old albums even though they're not as popular as the ones in the 70s.
I can’t really do a top 10, but I could tell you my favs (chronologically)
Arnold Layne
See Emily Play
Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
Summer 68’
One Of These Days
Fearless
Wot’s Uh….The Deal
Us And Them through to Eclipse
Dogs
Sheep
In The Flesh?
Goodbye Blue Sky
One Of My Turns
Don’t Leave Me Now
Nobody Home
The Fletcher Memorial Home
The Final Cut
Two Suns In The Sunset
On The Turning Away
Sorrow
Poles Apart
A Great Day For Freedom
Coming Back To Life
Keep Talking
1. Time 2. High hopes 3. Pigs (three different ones) 4. Nobody home. 5. Comfortably numb 6. Your possible pasts 7. The final cut 8. Hey you 9. Not now John. 10. Us and them
Time/ComfNumb/Sheep/Echoes/Fearless/WelcomeToTheMachine/HaveaCigar/Cirrus/HighHopes/SOYCD
What about sheep in the top 10 the ending is second to none. Saw Roger waters do it twice. That was the most memorable part of his concert to me. It just leaves you wanting more.
Again 'The Wall' gets overlooked.
I've got a great ladder.
🌳Nice✨ Remember A Day by Rick Wright🍇
I met Syd Barrett about two months before he died he was fascinating.
San Tropez-Mademoiselle Nobs-Biding my time-Jungband blues-Summer of 68-Stop-Two suns in the sunset-Speak to me-Apples and oranges-Pow R Toc H- The Grand vizer's garden party-Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict
Yes I'm kidding..........but San tropez is so good
Treat yourself to a peach old sport..
Enjoyed this. Not sure if ure on spotify but I've created this playlist - would be a good addition to the channel if you could include this.
Difficult...but today is:
1.shine on...
2.echoes
3.dogs
4.C Numb
5.Time
6.The great gig...
7.Hey You
8.Summer 68
9.fearless
10.careful with that axe...
1. Shine on 2. Echoes (Pompeii version) 3. Terminal frost 4. Time 5. Welcome to the machine 6. High hopes 7. Wish you were here 8. One slip 9. Dogs 10. WoT’s a deal
Picking ten is a really hard task when their best albums are much more than a collection of songs. My choice would come from those four classic albums from Dark Side to The Wall. The trouble is, just looking To the track lists and eliminating some feels like destroying part of my history for the last 45 years.
I think I know my favourite track from each of those four - Us and Them, Shine On, Dogs and Comfortably Numb.
1. Time
2. Echoes
3. Wish You Were Here
4. See Emily Play
5. Comfortably Numb
6. A Pillow of Winds
7. Sheep
8.Careful With that Axe Eugene
9. Shine on you Crazy Diamond
10. High Hopes
(bonus: Seamus, Money, Great Gig in the Sky, Learn To Fly, Us and Them, ABITW)
1. Time
2.Great gig
3.Shine on
4.Sheep
5.Pillow of winds
6.Arnold Layne
7.Breathe
8.Dogs
9.Wots uh the deal.
10.Wish you were here
Echoes, sheep, dogs, shine on you crazy diamond, astronomy domine, us and them, remember a day, summer 68, time, waiting for the worms
Excellent list although I could not have omitted "Set the controls for the heart of the sun" as I consider that song along with "Echoes" as a preamble to Dark side.
There's no way I could pick a top 10 - it would be like trying to pick a favourite child. My favourite is always the one I'm listening to at the time.
Swap Great Gig for Comfortably Numb, and Fearless for Hey You. I agree with the other choices.
1. Dogs
2. Childhoods End
3. Pigs
4. Summer 68
5. Julia Dream
6. Time
7. Breathe
8. Mother
9. Is There Anybody Out There?
10. Let There Be More Light
Time / Great Gig in the Sky. ( come on , these two songs belong together )
Wish You Were Here
Us and Them
Wot’s......Uh , the Deal ( from the underrated Obscured by Clouds )
Nobody Home
Shine On You Crazy Diamond
Any Colour You Like ( one of my favourite instrumentals of all time )
Comfortably Numb
Echoes
Brain Damage / Eclipse ( I know , but these two go together as well )
With apologies to :
Interstellar Overdrive , High Hopes , Have a Cigar , If , Stay , Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
The Waters flowing.....
1. Dogs 2. Time 3. Echoes 4. Comfortably Numb 5. Wish You Were Here 6. Hey You
7. Welcome to the Machine 8. Sheep 9. Astronomy Domine 10. Pigs (Three Different Kinds).
For me, a top ten list of Pink Floyd songs would just be a snapshot in time. The order, and even many of the songs listed would change on a monthly basis. However, Comfortably Numb would always be number one. A song that rarely gets mentioned would also make the list somewhere: The Gold It’s In The... from Obscured By Clouds. Just wanted to give some love to that deserving bit of joy.
This must have been a tough one to compile. So many different eras and sounds.
Really hard to do...
#1 - "Echoes"
#2 - "Animals" (whole album)
#3 - "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (all parts)
#4 - "Time"
#5 - "Comfortably Numb"
#6 - "Atom Heart Mother"
#7 - "Us and Them"
#8 - "Hey You"
#9 - "High Hopes"
#10 - "Green is the Color"
15: Sheep
14: Atom Heart Mother
13: Money
12: High Hopes
11: Pigs
10: Welcome to the Machine
9: Brain Damage/Eclypse
8: Us and Them
7: Shine On You Crazy Diamond
6: Dogs
5: Another Brick in the Wall - part 2
4: Echoes
3: Time/The Great Gig in the Sky
2: Wish You Were Here
1: Comftorably Numb
Yes; Sheep, Welcome, Dogs, and Time are in my top 15, also.
1. Echoes
2. Sheep
3. Shine on you crazy diamond
4. Time
5. Atom heart mother
6. High hopes
7. Hey you
8. Matilda mother
9. Welcome to the machine
10. Dogs
1. The Great Gig in the Sky
2. Dogs
3. Time
4. Shine On Your Crazy Diamonds - Part I-X
5. Echoes
6. Pigs(three different ones)
7. Sheep
8. Goodbye Blue Sky
9. Comfortably Numb
10. The Final Cut
Top 10 (this week) 1. Dogs 2. Have A Cigar 3. Fearless 4. Time 5. Hey You 6. On The Turning Away 7. Summer of 68 8. Echoes 9. Comfortably Numb 10. Cymbaline
I especially like Echoes, not only for being an amazing song, but it plays right after Seamus on Meddle which had me like,,, damn.
1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
2. Us and Them
3. Dogs
4. Time
5. Comfortably Numb
6. The Great Gig in the Sky
7. Wish You Were Here
8. Any Colour You Like
9. Echoes
10. Atom Heart Mother
The definite core of my top 10 would be the main 3 songs from Animals, and the other 3 epics (Echoes, Shine On, AHM).
Strong contenders for my remaining 4 would include some too-often overlooked gems...
Sysyphus
Grantchester Meadows
Give Birth To A Smile
A Pillow of Winds
Burning Bridges
Stay
Any Colour You Like
Don't Leave Me Now
Nobody Home
Your Possible Pasts
The Gunner's Dream
Fletcher Memorial Home
The Final Cut
1.Dogs
2.Echoes
3.Shine on you crazy diamond
4. Wish you were here
5. Comfortably numb
6.Time
7.Breathe
8.Sheep
9.Pigs
10.Money.
1. Echoes
2. Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts I-IX
3. Time
4. A Saucerful Of Secrets
5. Comfortably Numb (Live at Pulse 1995)
6. Pigs (Three Different Ones) (Live Oakland Ca 1977)
7. Dogs
8. Welcome To The Machine (Live Long Island Ny, Ny 1988)
9. Money (Live at Oakland Ca 1977)
10. High Hopes
DOGS!!!!!!! Yes indeed. I've saying this since the Animals album came out. Thank you,friend ...
My pleasure.
1. Run Like Hell
2. Every other PF song
(not that deep but I just love them all)
Just checking you out (I've subbed) you clearly enjoy Pink Floyd, haven't check all your back catalog but you don't seem to mention the Final Cut...a hater ?
I don't hate anything Pink Floyd... but I do prefer the more band centred albums.
High hopes
Time
Us and them
Lost for words
Fearless
Shine on
Pigs three diff ones
Wish you were here
Hey you
Confirmably numb
TIME is my favourite:😃
Certainly high on my list as well
@ Classic Album Review ... I stated 'Time' as being my favourite before I had heard any of your other choices beyond 'High Hopes' ( which I also really like; it actually reminds me a little of 'Breathing' by Kate Bush ) . Anyway they do say that " great minds think alike" lol. BTW my favourite line on 'Time' is ... " No one told you when to run ... you missed the starting gun" !
Great video. You talk very well about the music you life, it's always a pleasure to listen. Here's my top 10
1. Echoes
2. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (all parts)
3. Time
4. Atom Heart Mother
5. Dogs
6. The Great Gig In The Sky
7. High Hopes
8. Wish You Were Here
9. Astronomy Domine
10. check my username
For me personally
(1) Shine on you crazy diamond (all parts)
(2) Comfortably numb
(3) Us and them
(4) Wish you were here
(5) Echoes
(6) Time
(7) Money
(8) Hey You
(9) wot's uh the deal/have a cigar
(10) Mother/ What do you want from me
Sorry but none from animals in the top 10 for me. Although I like the album. Just can't personally put any above those I have listed. My personal opinion. 👍🏼
I'm pleasantly surprised to find Dogs at the top here, and so much of the album on others' lists. I always felt Animals was under appreciated.
Fearless/ynwa, time, wots uh the deal, 2suns in the sunset, is there anybody out there (acoustic), if, nobody home, welcome to the machine, dogs(of course).
Have you ever heard of the Finnish 90's band Kingston Wall? They made three albums and never got a record deal.. The guitarist/singer committed suicide in 1995.. Worth listen sometimes.. Records II and III Tri-logy are absolutely great albums and the first album is also good but a little bit different.. Or how to say it now.
Not sure what my top ten Floyd songs are, but what I do know is that Roger Waters appears on all of them.
What do you think of the video for High Hopes ?
hi may be many asked you the same ...but what is the music to introduce your videos? ...thanx ...
It was a piece of music from the Free Music Archive - I cannot remember the title
Nothing from the last 3 albums would be anywhere near my top 10.
What are your views on Comfortably numb?
Echoes
Shine on
Time
Dogs
Pigs
Sheep
Great Gig in the Sky
Comfortably Numb
Eclipse
Atom Heart Mother
It's funny when I think of Wish You Were Here....If you'd have asked me 10 or 20 years ago, I would have definitely put it in my top 10 Floyd songs. I don't know why, but I started disliking the song a few years ago and I don't know what made me feel like that.
Maybe I've listened to it too many times, and it's suffered the same fate that so many 'classic' rock songs have.
I say it's funny because there are other Floyd songs that I've listened to roughly the same amount of times that haven't had the effect that WYWH has had....in fact if anything, I've liked them more.
So yeh, it's funny the effect that some songs have on us 😎👍
It's more cut back. Less going on, so doesn't lend itself as well to released listens
Arnold Layne.......better than anything they did after
More than one spacey song from Syd tho: how about Interstellar Overdrive?
There's loads of spacy stuff from Syd