New Zealand's Biggest Pig Farm - Exposed
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 07. 2022
- Largest pig farm in New Zealand is located on the banks of the Hurunui River, North Canterbury, South Island. Sending over 100,000 pigs to market each year.
This footage shows what industrial scale intensive pig farming looks like and hopefully raises deeper conversations about how we treat animals and our environment.
Email the minister (link to template letter):
geoffreidnz.com/blog/nzs-largest-pig-farm-exposed
Music by talented Calla Knudson
bit.ly/3HityF6
Help support my work via: www.patreon.com/geoffreidnz
Nothing really concerned me watching this, looking forward to my next load of bacon though.
As far a pig farms go this looks pretty good. Disasters can happen occasionally on farms and its never in the farmers best interest for that to happen.
The pigs shown look very clean and healthy. The breeding sows outside in the huts is so much better than the farrowing crates.
Scarey music and one worker's overhyped edited comments shows a very one-sided report.
This is a huge improvement from fully enclosed piggeries. Where you have livestock you've got dead stock. That's farming.
Agreed this farm is better than enclosed. Yet it's still making most people uncomfortable to see what goes on in an industrial scale operation. This is a part of the farm that most people will never witness. Disasters happen more often when farms grow to this scale.
@@GeoffReidNZ nope, most people will actually see the pigs having good happy lives, strange that vegans hate that.
@jvisch delusional
@@jvisch you haven't seen pigs farmed correctly then. comparing bad shit to really bad shit doesn't turn bad shit in good pork. Hope more Kiwis see this. fucking disgusting.
when you overcrowd stock to maximise profits the deaths go up from stress, that is the truth of it.. No need for such intensive practices in NZ.
"This is a huge improvement from fully enclosed piggeries" is deliberately hyper lowering the bar to make a low bar acceptable.
Wow! Im stunned by how many people think this is ok. Deeply saddening.
These people have timed the filming to perfection once again , waiting till the snow is rite down to the flats , wouldn’t mind betting the snow has just melted to capture the farm at it’s worst to give viewers the impression that it’s a bog all year round much like they do with the dairy farms , just BS . People need food it’s that simple, all this idealogy sweeping the globe is like a cancer & it’s failing at a catastrophic rate one only has to look at what’s happened in Sri Lanka the people are starving because they banned synthetic fertiliser .
Timing it till it looks its worst..? You must be having a laugh.
Dosent have to be a bog all year round to cause harm... Its the wet months when the damages is done.. thats what people are trying to highlight. mud and pathogens being mobalised and flowing into the river.. animals living in their own filth a lot of the time nowhere dry to lie down.
We never used to farm like this so why are we now? There is always a better way
“ Its the wet months when the damages is done.. thats what people are trying to highlight. ”
Well why don’t you explain that better in your vids , for example you could “highlight “ that for 10+ months of the year farming practices are fine , perhaps make the odd summer time vid when the grass grows & suns out to show them that it’s not a bog for 12 months of the year & it’s only maybe 2 months of the year (if it’s been wet or some extreme weather event has occurred) your concerned about , because if you only film after lots & lots of rain & snow all the time people would assume animals live in mud 12 months of the year , people like you & I know it’s not like that all the time , but the views don’t…I find that very miss leading & I do like Nz grown pork it’s very tasty…oh for some salted crackle , I would hate to see pig farmers forced out of farming only to have a substandard product imported with very questionable animal rites regulations , perhaps you could travel to Poland then skip over to Ukraine & film the pig farmers there for a comparison.
Dont shoot the messanger.. if there is room for animal welfare wouldn't you want to encourage that?
According to the world animal rites index Nz is number 1 , we along with 3 other countries are in first place , let that sink in for a moment.
By my count that farm has over 100 sheds to shelter the pigs & they look to be in great condition . You have chosen to show case the farm at the wettest time of the year.
So to answer your question I’m going to say no , with the country in the position it is in & a world food crisis looming I say let the farmers get on with doing what they do best , the country supplies what forty or fifty million people with food ? ,I bet Sri Lanka could do with some ? , did ya know Geoff they banned synthetic fertiliser & now the country is bankrupt & starving , bet they would love some of that pork , I don’t believe people like you will ever be happy until we are all vegans .
@@GeoffReidNZ if you have suggestions on ways to improve which science agrees with then give them. In my experience vegan extremists don't want the industry to improve, they just want it gone.
The standards in farm animal welfare are significantly higher in NZ than they are in Canada. This farm has a lot of pigs on it, but they have straw bedding, have access to the outdoors, and can interact with each other. Not to mention that the pigs all have their little curvy tails (so no tail docking, as I can see). Tail docking is common industry practice in Canadian industrial farms. In Canada, such a farm would be considered organic and of very high welfare standards.
I'm sorry to hear this. Things must be terrible in Canada. Do you think by comparison it makes it ok? The pollution leeching through the land is a huge problem here. Also can't be organic if they're feed not organic foods
This is very Grim Footage, Geoff. Good on you for bravely sharing these stories. As people we need to know how are choices are interlinked with this type of activity. We have to confront the reality of this way we treat animals in industrial scale agriculture. At the end of the day people choose to eat these products or choose not to. Your work is so important, Geoff, to help us make the right choices. With 8 Billion plus people on the planet today, we have to question what essentially qualifies as food and what is a frivolous luxury, the consumption of which is facilitated by corporations marketing falsehoods, lies. Kia kaha Geoff et al.
Very well said and absolutely the truth. Couldn't agree more 👍
Thanks. Where is this location and any names my friendly little pig keeper
Patoa Pig farm. Hurunui
@@GeoffReidNZ keep pushing without the this awareness people wouldn't see what's going on. We need to be eating and farming our own meat a veg, society is completely wrong in what a comfortable living is
Woa so great
Looks like a well run operation, pigs are clean and healthy. I
Are you sure your commenting on the right video?
@@GeoffReidNZ yea mate completely, there was a couple of sick animals, and a lot of the examples given by the lady we’re human error and accidents not maltreatment. I’ve got two very loved dogs, doesn’t mean they don’t get sick or ill. Same with humans, it’s part of life. The production here is a lot better than other pars of the world were our imported meat comes from.
@@zechbro if animal welfare standards can be lifted wouldnt that be a good thing? Yes it would drive the price of pig flesh up... thats fine.. put tariffs on inported flesh to match it so we dont push the problems somewhere else. And extra high tariffs in imported flesh from countries that can verify high aw or enviro standerds are met. Win win?
Are you saying it is ok and fine because its not as bad as other countries?
@@GeoffReidNZ mate I’m saying you don’t highlight how bad other countries are, we import over 60% of our pork, put the tarifs on, demand approved standards for the imported pork In your video make that part of your story, don’t just slander NZ pork without providing a pathway to making it better. From there you then have a position to demand higher standards in NZ. What specifically do you have a problem with the farming operation you videoed?
Only thing I see bad here is the illegal flying of a drone over private property
Yes, thats all most that are in denial see. What about the Nitrate seepage into the ground water and the river?
@@GeoffReidNZ proof? Suppose you want to shut all of the dairy farms down aswell?
@@joshphillips5071 if it is in the wrong place and done in a way that is intensive ie causing harm to people, animals and the environment then yes. It will save us in the long run.
@@GeoffReidNZ your vegan extremism is your opinion and that's okay but don't go trying to force people into getting on all fours and eating grass. Totally unrealistic. This country would be screwed with out farming full stop.
Also proof on the nitrate seepage getting into the Hurunui from that farm in particular?
Looking at this compared to many farms i visit this is one of the best .
That's very sad...
How to apply,?
Hmmmm nothing to see here , looks like farming to me and they look like pretty dam healthy pigs , to a city slicker it would seem a bit overwhelming
I understand and agree that was horrendous, but it begs the question still, next time you are buying pork at the supermarket, how many of us are checking the cost per kg?
It's a fact that industrial farming produces cheaper food. Whether those cost savings are passed on to you is debatable but market forces say they probably are. Ultimately one must ask are you prepared to pay more for your food in order to stop industrial farming and the extra costs involved to advert their environmental impact. On top of this is govt money printing inflating away the store of value of your hard-earned labour. This is also causing food prices to rise. Then we have what we see now with the farmer protests in the Netherlands (coming to a town near you in NZ) debatable climate change goals imposing a very heavy cost burden. I'm not saying do nothing. I'm saying be aware of the of the causes and consequences.
The only real solution is human population control
An alternative would be to just stop eating animal products altogether
@@economadic2103 whenever i ask vegans to expand on that they all say by massive culling of them so not better.
Interesting. Most I speak to thonk they should bebleft to live their lives out in sanctuaries where they are protected and not force impregnated so they breed more. Wonder what vegans you're talking to.
@@GeoffReidNZ you mean like Asha sanctuary where they are in worse conditions than a vegan propoganda movie? Vegan sanctuaries often go bankrupt and animals suffer when they run out of money and cannot afford medical treatment nor food. Give money to proper sanctuaries, not vegans wanting to feel good ones.
Do you also have pet food facilities there? Because here in good ol “Tyson Country” the “farm dead” resulting from frequent culling for defects and diseases plus gang violence amongst the poultry is sent to a nearby protein plant that processes those putrid corpses plus everything else from the regular surrounding processing plants that doesn’t end up on the dinner table.
It all becomes what I call “Soylent Brown” aka poultry meal plus feather meal and the ultra disgusting blood meal shipped to major pet food facilities as a main ingredient for their products. Even Charlton Heston does not approve…
Nice huh?
I personally think pigs are too smart to eat plus there’s the risk of contracting trichinosis. It’s only a matter of time until they organize and rebel. It won’t be pretty,the Hebrews already knew this thousands of years ago.
This is why many people do not eat pork
So true
free range pork is in NZ.
humanely grown and butchered. This pork is bound to taste like the shit the pigs wallow in.
Does anyone know if there are pig gas chambers in New Zealand?
Who is in charge of seeing to the amount of pig meat is actually sold to consumers, how much wastage is there from the supermarket’s ect?
What are the standards to gain a welfare tick and approval from the SPCA?
I’m not a vegan or vegetarian and won’t ever be by free choice but I believe that farms for meat should be smaller and the amount of meat that is consumed is in this country can be far less.
This is a great farm. They do a really good job, and despite what people say they do care about there animals
Yep! Tey do a really good job of polluting the ground water and the local river.
Not sure if they care about their animals when they send them to the slaughter house to get killed...? Please correct me if im wrong.
Yip your wrong. Just because you have a set of beliefs doesn't make there business wrong.
This is already as decent as a pig's life can be already. Far far better than so many other farmed animals raised in other parts of the world. I would call this "going out of way to alleviate the suffering of them".
So its better than most.. but couldn't it get better?
@@GeoffReidNZ I think if u really care about animals u should make more farms informed how they could learn from this one.
Why add the music too it
Did you mean to place a question mark at the end of that sentence?
Geoff loves dramatic music!
Taking music recomendations for my next exposé video. Please LMK if you have a track in mind that may work better than this. Cheers
This is bad. The scale of it affects the animals and the land. I've been on the land for 45 years and have seen attitudes to animal welfare and care for the land improve. Most people involved with animals do care, even though they don't always get it right. Factory farming is several steps beyond that. It is gross and cruel and because it is all about numbers the animals will never come first. SPCA approved eh? why am I not surprised. Good work Geoff, this needs to stop.
Well saod. Thank you Maryjane. 🙌😊
Factory farms don't exist, that is a vegan term with no consistent definition
@@jvisch Cambridge dictionary has a fairky constant definition...
Factory farming
noun [ U ] PRODUCTION
UK US
A way of producing meat and other animal products quickly and cheaply by keeping animals in small spaces in buildings and feeding them special types of food:
eg 'Factory farming is often considered cruel, and consumers need to weigh this up against the benefits of cheap meat and eggs.'
@@GeoffReidNZ that is cage farming, vegans also call barn farming factory farming. Factory farming is not a term used by farmers, it is commonly used by vegans which is why it can appear in dictionaries. You would think they would at least know what it means.
@@jvisch what’s your deal julian 😅 where’s mum?
Never knew stuff like this happened in New Zealand, quite sad to see
Mate look at what we import so easy to make video's like this without a complete pics or is it as long as it dont happens in nz we are great but we still import mass amount of pigs from over seas where the farming is way worse and if we farm the way you seem to have it than we have not enough for all humans or is it we should be eating vege only i get sooo tierd of this easy point scorring.
Mate Thanks heaps for uncovering this. I live in Australia but really wanted to move to NZ in a few years. Some of these animal farm and environment issues are really heartbreaking. Keep up the great work 👍
What you get with this video is very selective designed to maximize the shock factor. Viewers should view it with that in mind. Much was not mentioned. This area had masses amount of rainfall in the last 2 months. At huge expense the paddocks are being recontoured to improve the conditions, create more space and a tree planting programme for shade. The claim that the compost area drains into streams and into the river is false. The claims about accidents such as water not working happens with all types of animals even pets. Nothing is 100% foolproof. This style of video will be very hurtful to the many good people that work at this farm. Why didn't you go and talk to the owners and learn the full story. You haven't answered the question about getting drone footage in private property. Anyone watching this should think about how they would feel if someone droned them undertaking activities in their backyard. Yes standards definitely can improve but these sorts of videos ignore the huge amount of great work farmers are now doing for the betterment of the environment and animals.
I agree ,I didn't think the video showed disgusting conditions at all , for the most part the pigs appeared to be well-fed and clean. I think it's very misleading to film when, going by the amount of water lying in the paddocks, Canterbury has had a huge amount of rain in a very short period. I'm sure you waited on this weather advent & rushed out to the farm to film ,shame on you sir!
People must be aware of the routeen neglect that occurs when operations of this size go unchecked.
Talking to farmers that only see dollar signs is not the best use of time. Rain happens.. shouldnt be a suprise. Farming tens of thousands of mammals on leechy stoney river bed is a recipe for groundwater contamination and poor river health.
These farmers have many opportunities and platforms to tell their stories (lies). Its call greenwashing marketing and the best way to demand better practice is to tell the truth to the people. Regional council are filled with farmers... so how can we trust that the regulators are doing their jobs? The rural advocacy network sounds like a group set up to defend, deny and deflect any changes to status quo $$$.
A few trees being planted for shade?? A few decades on and millions of pigs later.. wow. They fit 1000 into those barns you know. They only get shade.
@@GeoffReidNZ lots of assumptions, no facts seems to be the morale of your story. Obviously you haven't talked to the farmers with your (incorrect) assumption they only see dollar signs. 4 of the 14 regional council are farmers, hardly filled with farmers. Basing an understanding of an organization on how its name sounds - is that how you draw conclusions? Your false claims and misrepresentations meet the definition of greenwashing marketing - of a different shade. I take the attitude that for now at least animal farming is here to stay so lets get working with the farmers to improve the environment right now as time is of the essence.
There are many issues with what you say, the biggest ine being higher animal welfare standards are not at all sustainable financially or especially environmentally. We are already in a climate crisis largely because of animal agriculture, if we move to less efficient strategies to kill billions of animals per year, we will rocket towards the tipping point. that's the word I don't like in this context "efficient" why should we have the right (regardless of environmental issues) to efficiently kill billions of innocent animals who did nothing wrong. In summary there is no sustainable way of mass murdering animals and the only option is to switch to a plant based food system, we have a choice, keep animals in horrible conditions and eventually die out as a species, keep animals in better conditions and we largely die out faster, or the best option, the only option would be for people such as you to stop green-washing, to stop lobbying and let people know the truth, we are dying and you are hiding that from people. shame on you.
Milked NZ documentary and facts.
milked.film/
This documentary should answer many if not all of your questions and statements, please watch it with an open mind, the website contains many links to studies and various papers.
Some vegans on CZcams that have good information in general however I always recommend people fact check but do so carefully as there are many industry funded studies and random papers that are bias or are rooted in no fact what so ever.
@Earthling Ed
czcams.com/users/EarthlingEdChannel
@Mic The Vegan
czcams.com/users/MictheVegan
@Joey Carbstrong
czcams.com/users/JoeyCarbstrong
@Hench Herbivore
czcams.com/users/HenchHerbivore
Remember these are just online figures, do not take everything they say as fact but instead read the studies they present.
Thank you for reading and make sure to take the time to consider what I say.
@@GeoffReidNZ when do vegan extremists tell the truth?
Greetings from North Carolina in the US. We have a town called Smithfield where there is a large industrial pork factory. Look into it. Its sickening as well. Keep up the good fight. Enough voices will be heard. Smithfield is so large they justbuy their way through the Govt.
take this video down now
Thanks for the shocking enlightenment, Can you design a farm where this doesn't happen and deliver to the minister. Then public pressure him to mandate it.
Could the issues be solved by sizing up the space do you think.!
Thankyou Geoff, I have included this in my submission to NAWAC. Your video shows that there's no right way of doing the wrong thing.
You realise this video uses illegal footage and can result in video owner being fined or jailed?
@@jvisch julian, stick to being a public servant
Supporting you Geoff
I don't see where the problem is? Apparently, once they grow big they run out of space. But there is no footage or evidence of this. On the contrary, the footage in closing shows a lot of space. There were examples of several accidents taking place. Not abuse. If incidents are not reported etc and not rectified then yes major issue. But no evidence was offered. Struggling to see the issue here beyond the video's dramatically loud music.
Some of these comments are ridiculous, it would be awesome if you could do a response video to them. Amazing video, thanks for all you do💚.
Good idea thanks!
The whole video is stupid and illegal, hopefully the owner of video will get charged
@@jvisch charged for what? Exposing and atrocity.
@@Ruben-L-Trimble-mttsbf trespass, flying a drone on private property without permission, flying a drone out of line of sight, taking photos or film on a farm without permission (this law was created because of misleading videos like this as vegans have reputation for lying) .
@@jvisch to be honest julian a public servant on here saying what you are saying?? You should definitely be more careful not to be so disrespectful
I'd like to know if this film crew had the relevant permission to do this filming?
"We weren't allowed to take photos on the farm" - whistle blower
@@GeoffReidNZ which means drone footage is also illegal, can we give your name to aviation authorities and police for your illegal footage?
So do i take this as a yes, or will you turn yourself in to the police for multiple illegal acts?
@@jvisch this video seems to have really upset you.. why?
@@GeoffReidNZ i hate vegan disinformation and how vegans think they are above the law.
Feeling sick to my core after seeing that. "Freedom farm" an absolute disgrace to the meaning of freedom. Thanks Geoff for sharing. Love your mahi.
@Geoff Reid NZ your claim the river is getting trashed and terrible smell is false. The river is called the Hurunui and it is a beautiful river as it meanders out of the mountains and across the plains. It did have high EColi counts at one stage and some people were blaming the pig farm and neighbouring dairy farms. DNA testing by the local authorities proved it was a native bird seagull colony on the river so the local council in conjunction with the Conservation Department poisoned the birds because they predate on a lot of the less common native birds. In summer locals swim and fish in the river and some drink straight out of the river. I have lived next to this river all my life and you are showing a huge amount of disrespect to our river by making sensationalist claims.
Unfortunately the river quality is still bad, we use to stay at balmoral camp ground but haven't for the last couple of years as there is signs up from ecan saying it's unsafe to swim.
@@haydennicol7826 Two things. The signs were because of the EColi triggering the warning level. They found the EColi contamination was from the seagull colony 1 kilometre above the swimming site. The other tests they were doing came from a stagnant stream coming out of the Balmoral forest at that time that the swimming hole was disconnected from the river when floods changed its course. The authorities admitted they were using this incorrectly to portray the Hurunui River. None of that was to do with farming. The signs are a trigger requirement and not reliable. Using commonsense many locals still swim in the river and some even drink it.
You are the only person who has said the river is getting trashed.
The lady made one mention of the river.
Geoff said nothing about the river in the video or in the description other than saying the farm is beside the river.
No mention of ecoli was made.
@@kevinjpluck Geoff made 2 references in his replies below including this one - "GOOD CALL! I have never smelt anything like this. Rotting bodies, ammonia and shit can be smelt from miles away. The river is getting trashed!" The lady's claim about the river was also false.
@@ruraladvocacynetworknz6155
Balderdash. These intense farming enterprises have one thing in mind.. MAXIMUM PROFIT. with little or no regard for the surrounding nature or animal welfare except to the point where it might threaten their profit. I'm an avid gold prospector and bushland trekker and I support decent sustainable mining, agriculture and manufacturing etc but I see the same thing here in Australia where vast amounts of forest are bulldozed to shove on as many head of cattle as possible with massive displacement and injury to koala bear, bird life and other mammals as well as huge amounts of erosion and sediment runoff.
The logging industry in Tasmania just clear fell everything in sight and leave over 90% of beautiful millable timber to rot.
My grandfather, father and uncle were old time sheep graziers and were never greedy and always said you have to look after the land that looks after you.
Unfortunately these days, the modern large scale animal farming industry have lost all sense of natural heritage stewardship and sing the same old song" poor hard done by farmers just trying to make a living"
If it wasn't so bloody serious it'd be a joke!
NZ is just going to end up a fouled up mess especially due to intense dairy industry.
Why don't you have a good shake up and start considering that you can still make some decent profit and an honest living whilst being stewards of the landscape that provide you with that living..
Horrifying. Ka pai te mahi Geoff, thanks for doing this important work and opening Kiwis eyes to these shameful truths about our "clean green farming nation". This WILL bring about change my friend. Keep it up
You have no idea how bad it really is if you think anything in this video was shocking...
I agree. Its worse than anyone could imagine. 😔
Thanks Geoff for exposing this
No wonder I don't eat pig well apart from thee old bacon but this is gross an cruel even effecting the dam rivers but how many other farms like this
Every farm pollutes the surrounding area hence why all the lakse have high counts of nitrogen...pathetic
That's fucked thanks for reporting on this bro That's not good
Great looking bacon. Should cut em loose up lake sumner
Wrecker!
It'll be truly free range hahah
Theyd probably starve em selves out
The video showed mostly extreme circumstances.. weather events etc... most farmers do gaf about their animals. all my experiences with farmers in the south island.. animal welfare is the first priority. animals killed in extreme circumstances sucks... the farmers will feel the loss of life and pain intently.. they are good people, they lose sleep when stuff like this happens. I bet they were out in the middle of the night trying to do what they could but it was too much. Farming animala is important for NZ peoples health and well being. The farmers for the most part are excellent at handling their livestock as humanely as they possibly can to it being a point of pride...
Yea extreme alright, massive farm! Weather is mostly predictable though... so are soil types etc
I dont think farmer bashing is helpful either this is why I never call out individuals as it is the intensity of the system that are causing harm to people, animals and the environment.
I do hear a lot of some farmers saying they love their animals... This is good but it does make one wonder; when does the mourning for their lives end? When they're put on the truck for slaughter, when the truck leaves the gate or when they are at the pub with their mates drinking their profits? 🤔
Never call out individuals Geoff?? But happy to clearly highlight the farm name! You are a danger to society!
@@benjaminjaunay6884 oh that’s your problem with the comments above 😂 Geoff is absolutely right, the farmers who make their animals welfare number one… yet send them off to be slaughtered??? 🤨 I mean if you just think about that … it actually would show they don’t really care at all 🤷🏻♂️
Feeding the human race. I’m not willing to sacrifice a single human life, or an ounce human of opportunity or prosperity, for an animal. The consequences of this assertion are appalling. I accept them.
This woman is describing significant loss though. The plan runners should’ve listened to her.
thanks for your great work
You are welcome! I hope it can bring about some level of change. Cheers
This is despicable
Thank you for your work exposing this appalling practice
Thanks for that Harry
Hemp crops and food Forrests would heal this mess in a generation
I agree.
The farmer is worth millions. Clearly following greed. The river is trashes and the smell is next level!
@@GeoffReidNZ another lie
@@jvisch what’s your deal Julian? What are you trying to achieve by your little snide comments, hey take it from me you should definitely lay off the meat….. it’s not good for your health or your appearance 🙃
Poor piggys:( thats why ill always buy meat from organic places
Gee I've seen some horrific organic scenes.... Yikes
GREED $$$ at the bottom of everything FOUL.
Animal welfare issues, ethics , transportation & slaughterhouse experience ; Animals LIVE A HOLOCAUST OF ABUSE EVERY DAY.
MEET YOUR MEAT....it would probably be your friend if you gave it the opportunity.
Thanks for the effort to expose these conditions - we need to change the practices and also our own eating habits to a plant based diet!
Kia ora John. Couldn't agree with you more. Cheers!
Truly horrific and not a one off. This is very much standard practice across the world.
Thank you for exposing this Geoff. This is hell on earth. We need to have a good look in the mirror as a nation and ask ourselves if this is who we want to be.
'World leading' pig farming... More like world leading in how mean people can be. Shame on the corporations for tricking consumers with false claims of "freedom farms".
Ka pai for the mahi on this exposé and to the interviewee for speaking out.
All I feel is sick to my core and really mean things to the people involved thinking this is okay. I hope your toast burns in the morning
Tbh , it didn’t look too bad to me, however I wonder whether the drowned pigs became food? I’m assuming so….
So if you drowned it wouldn't be that bad because you'd become food for worms
@@coffeemoth665 hey bro! actually the "however" in my statement separates the two assertions I wanted to make. "Didn't look too bad to me" was comparing the footage to caged animal farms. The drowned pigs becoming food was fearing the carcasses of the sadly drowned animals were then sold to supermarket wholesalers as if nothing out of the ordinary had occurred. The "not too bad even though they drowned" isn't what I m saying at all. Btw I would never drown, I'm a really strong swimmer
It's this kind of farming why I've gone 100% plant based. I don't want to pay for this cruelty. 😫
GOOD CALL! I have never smelt anything like this. Rotting bodies, ammonia and shit can be smelt from miles away. The river is getting trashed!
It is this type of farming why i will never go plant based. If vegans lie and this the best they can do to demonise lol
Well that says a lot about you, what age were you when you lost your empathy for animals?
@@bradwindust6657 i care for animals more than any vegan, i just don't believe the vegan propoganda and disagree with their philosophy that genocide of all animals is the solution.
@@jvisch as I've told you before there is no such thing as sustainable animal agriculture. I don't understand why you continue to use the same arguments I debunk time and time again with SCIENCE, not your bull-shit. Please tell me again what's your "argument" for eating animal products? Where do you think all these animals food comes from, this is the driver of rainforest destruction climate change, species extinction and even world hunger, where's the logic in filtering a huge amount of our crops through animals?
OMG thats an absolute disgrace im not an animal lover im not a vegan i do eat meat i tripped over this video by mistake but holy c***. Top job and good on your for exposing it. I really hope they lock the owner in with them poor animals and as for the SPCA im not allowed to post my thoughts on that.
I am curious what you think the farmer is doing wrong? The pigs are happy and healthy.
@@asdfaasdf2144 we need to eat to live. All diets result in deaths of animals, farm animals live long happier lives than they would in nature. Animal products are also used to make tyres and cellphones. But sure throw away your car and phone.
@@asdfaasdf2144 i thought you said you weren't a vegan and yet you use language only vegans use like factory and suffering (farm animals don't suffer)
@@asdfaasdf2144 veganism is about reducing as many animals as possible, their policies only increase animal suffering by denying animals healthcare
Oh wait, not same person
Very sad
Grow your own don't bye their pork
They need to put this on TV when they are talking about the "humane" way NZ looks after its animals.
The video is illegal and shows pigs all happy and healthy so would just land the vegan in jail for illegal use of drones
@@jvisch 🤣😂🤣😂😭
@@jvisch dipstick 🙄
@@jvisch how did you miss the dead pig in the drainage channel, or the pig so disfigured it couldn't even walk properly? Not the image of perfect health to me bro
this was so sad to watch
Horrible.
this was hard to stomach
Doubt the land owners knew about the drone flying on there property, not that I support bad practice farming ill make that clear. But many of you who won't acknowledge human error or unexpected mounts of rain should dig a bit deeper instead of watching a 5 minute video of again most likely illegal drone flying about the only thing that looks bad in this video is the pigs in the trailer but shock to some pigs die from all sorts of things. How else do they get rid of them full grown pig could weigh 200kg plus. Maybe just food for thought me personally not going to stop eating them. Sorry to those this may offend, we are allowed our own opinions are we not?
Hi Sam, Yeah sure you we can have our own opinions... even those the perhaps dont want to "dig a bit deeper".
Human error and unexpected amounts of rain is no excuse for bad practice (poor planning, not farming to the conditions, harm).
It is my belief that Mud farming indefensible and so is this level of pollution.
@@GeoffReidNZ Agreed people don't want to dig deeper and also dont look at other sides of the story. I do ask the question have you ever worked on a pig farm or farm at all? It's winter and it rains how is that bad practice? Again human error of not tightening a bolt up is not bad practice. Would you mind answering the question about the drone flying were the land owners notified?
The scale of this farm brings into question the amount of pollution flowing off it and into the groundwater. The size of the compost and dead pig pile is MASSIVE and will be leeching Nitrates into the river. Anyone ask the public if they could pollute the river?
Cant confirm if they farmers allowed the drone or not and no Never worked on a pig farm... no aspirations to either thanks.
@@GeoffReidNZ who recorded the video? If they did nothing wrong why won't you say?
@@jvisch Julian you should really move on my bloated fellow youtube user...
Thank you for sharing this. It is impossible to think that a small country that has such unique wildlife can build it's economy on something so unsustainable and cruel. A plant based food system is the answer 🌱🌻🌞
Thanks for leading the way!
Plant based diet is unsustainable. There is already a food shortage
@@jvisch misinformed!
@@GeoffReidNZ i know you are. There are lots of educational resources like country calendar to educate yourself.
A vegan diet is less sustainable than one that includes meat.
Do you know New Zealand 🇳🇿 Government getting the pork now from Philippine and it’s so bad that this and that why we bloody paying more tax coz people like you doing this go get a life man and leave those farmers alone they trying to help Nz get a life man
Please prove that its thebgovt doing it. You sure its notnthe super market?
If pigs have a better life than here, isnt that a good thing? Put tarifs on the flesh like other countries do to us. If they cant prove enviro and animal welfare standards are met then we shoulndt be taking it, simple.
Why we going overseas and getting pigs there rather then we farming here and we know what we eat and our farmers can have a benefit from it mean the government put our tax higher coz we going overseas and getting meat there. Do you know how the other countries looking after their pigs nz farmer way better than when our pigs meats coming from leaving those farmers a lot man they trying to help nz and they are paying more tax then you man
This is next level disgusting 🤬🤬 awesome mahi exposing this practice Geoff, people need to see the reality of intensive agriculture and demand change 👊👊
Yuck!
Wtf nz is turning into.
Looks like concentration camp!
Hardly. The pigs have tons of space (which they deliberately leave out of video) but pigs like to hug
@@jvisch Julian, have you been through this farm? You speak with such conviction yet you actually are misinformed and very dim …
Yuck, shame on New Zealand
Keep on to feed the growing population, FORGET THE NONSENSE OF WOKE ENVIRONMENTALISM BELIEF. The big farm like this could be managed properly, it's not hard to manage but the MAFF has to do their DUTY PROPERLY. 21000 PIGS IS NOT A BIG WORK. CAN BE DONE BY 7-10 EMPLOYEES. KEEP ON TO FEED THE WORLD. CUT OUT THE CLIMATE CHANGE RELIGION AND ENVIRONMENTALISM BELIEF NONSENSE.
What about 80000 pigs and the nitrates getting into ground water throughout Canterbury and causing illnesses thought the population?
Now you know the truth
Pigs love mud and shit! Looks good
do they also love being crammed up?
I imagine they probably quite enjoy each other’s body heat at night, gets cold down there
Moron
Did you take anything else from this video?
Ignore him Geoff. There's always one.
So sad that this is allowed in this beautiful country!!
It is not Aotearoas largest pig farm. It may be New Zealand's though
What a dick comment. I suppose your mantra is “Take up your pitchforks and hang the coloureds!”?
Please explain yourself, Graham.
Not in Kansas anymore 🥲WTF! Thanks for opening my eyes .
Right!? thank you