Recap Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard Trial Day 18: Rocky Pennington, Whitney Heard & More
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 7. 09. 2024
- On the stand today - Rocky Pennington, Josh Drew, Whitney Heard, Elizabeth Marz and Melanie Inglessis
#AmberHeard #DeppVHeard #JohnnyDepp
Become a member -
www.youtube.co....
Amber Heard's witness list: www.fairfaxcou....
Johnny Depp's witness list: www.fairfaxcou....
đŽ Do you or someone you know need to speak to a real lawyer about a case? Or do you find yourself needing legal advice? Please reach out to our firm and we will make sure to answer your questions or find someone who can. Our consultations are always free and confidential. You can call our firm at (727)441-9030 or email us at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com.
â For business inquiries contact me at lawyeryouknow@gmail.com
â Let's connect: www.tragoslaw....
Twitter - @tragoslaw
Instagram - /tragoslaw
Facebook - /tragoslaw
TikTok - /tragoslaw
â Join our email list here - bit.ly/33lV3Mb
Get your Lawyer You Know merch here - bit.ly/LYKMerch
đŽ NOT LEGAL ADVICE
AH kept saying that "pledged" is the same as given. I would have asked her if she would have been satisfied if her divorce settlement was pledged to her.
Lol đ They are definitely different!!! Lol đ
This! Perfection
Good one!
Hahahahhaha love it!
Hahah , even I, as a non native English speaker, know what pledge meansđ
Tough point on the stairs incident by Witney. She claims she was coming in between to stop HIM from charging AMBER. Yet she explains that she is standing with her back to HIM. If someone is aggressive and a threat and. you want to stop him, it's very unlikely that she had her back on him. Unless she was stopping Amber, as she told her friend and colleagues.
Why would Johnny bring this to trial to save his reputation if he knew all of this was going to come out! If he abused herâŠhe would never have brought this case against her.
He brought it against her because she keeps going after him for money. She's a gold digger and Elon Musk saw it after he paid 500,00 bucks to a charity for her just to screw her, where as the 30 other guys got it for free. my opinion. How many people were living off Johnny?
I felt this way from the start⊠especially since he is very private person and until now we havent heard anything about his lifeâŠher side isnât right a lot of staged events and bunch of freeloaders
Iâm totally with you but,just to make conversation, imagine that he did it just because he thinks he could get whatever he wants because he has money? Conspiracy theories đ€Łđ€Ł
Well right now nobody knows. You can't use circumstantial reverse logic to argue a case. It requires hard evidence and in this case without actual security footage to prove it then it's just hearsay and testimony which is pretty shaky but it's better than nothing.
Legal bytes also mentioned that Lance Armstrong sued people vehemently for accusing him of doping⊠and we saw how that turned out.
"Swearing under oath" clearly doesn't mean anything. Some people are definitely lying while under oath.
The audio tapes presented are what put me on JDâs side. Never have I heard a DV victim speak, yell and laugh at their abuser like as AH does.
Agree! Sheâs horrible
She pushed and pushed and pushed.
To be fair, he never sounds scared of her, but those audio really sound like the opposite of her testimony. She claimed that "the monster" was when Depp would take drugs or drink and get violent as a result. So you would assume that she would be scared of him if he's drunk or on something. But in most of those recordings, he's clearly on something, but he's never violent toward her in any of them while, far from being scared, I would characterize her part in those recordings as straight up emotional abuse.
I agree. The one where she mockingly laughs like a maniac show who the actual abuser is. Verbally, they most likely were both abusive. I don't think Johnny ever got physical tho past the point of shoving her back and restraining her.
she sounds like a howling from hell. I cannot imagine to live with a person so evil.
I think itâs important to point out that not only were these people living for free but they were living a lifestyle that they could never imagine in their wildest dreams. Penthouses, gyms, pools, expensive wine , lots of free drugs, etc. We are not just talking couch surfing here.
Amber was taking a stimulant drug most likely used for weight loss.
Yes they sound like a bunch of entitled losers... besides Johnny's friend the artist dude (can't remember his name). The guy who seemed genuinely thankful and was emotional early in the trial.
@@ivory8581 If she had succeeded in her divorce extortion , the party would still be happening.
@@ivory8581 yess Isaac Baruch was the only one that really appreciated Johnny's generosity the others were completely ungrateful đ
Why is Johnny's legal team not hammering witnesses who said there was huge messes in the penthouse since police said they looked around and there was no mess.
Staged
In her testimony AH said they had a regular housekeeper. I wish they wouldâve deposed her to clarify some of the messes. Especially the glass supposedly left all over the floor and the turd in the bed.
I heard a good argument around this question. All Ambers witnesses were hearing about the abuse from Amber, they never witnessed it first hand - they took Amberâs word. So as long as they prove Amber as the liar, all the other witnesses lose credibility by extension.
As far as I can remember, the âheadbutâ was described by JD when AH was going crazy and he tried to hold and control her. He admitted their head collided.
What I don't understand is that if Amber wanted to show abuse why did she never go to the Dr's or hospital to absolutely prove the abuse? Maybe because she had no injuries for them to see.
Precisely đŻ
Victims donât typically want to show they are abused and often lie to protect their abuser. Also, most bruises and minor injuries donât require medical attention. Iâm not an Amber supporter, just think we donât need to disqualify all victims in the process to prove a point.
Exactly
@@jsnow4379 this is very true and a great observation. In AH case in particular though she is an exception as she has shown herself to put all of this out for ALL to see SO with this personality her story doesn't fit and seems to be just that.. a story!
@@jsnow4379 I agree, but for me it's when JD was out of the country and before Amber went to court why didn't she go to the hospital in the days after the assault or the day she went to court, after all she seems to have an injury? to me this makes no sense if you are going to report abuse in court why not go to the hospital before the same day or the day before and yes most victims do that and we saw it with JD with his finger he protects her and today they use this against him
Most of these witnesses were present for the trailer campfire Kelly Sue moment and none of them said JD grabbed her wrist, threatened her and made her cry, something that wouldâve been incredibly memorable.
Oooh snap! Didn't even remember that line because literally nobody brought that one up ever again!
Where is this Kelly Sue, I wonder?
One thing that didnât make sense to me about Joshâs testimony is when he said that him and Rocky used their key to get into the penthouse because they were worried about Amber since she wasnât responding to them, and when they got in there and seen how messed up the apt was and how they could tell something was wrong and Rocky told him to go back to their apt while she ran up to check on Amber đ€đ€ Ok⊠So, yâall see that there is some destruction but yet the man, a decent sized man at that, is sent home to wait for a text/call while his fiancĂ© is left alone to find another petite woman?? Whoâs man would do that? Knowing that Johnny has supposedly been violent before.
Good point!
Because they are all lying ! Rocky is not credible.
I thought the same
Excellent point! It's 100% RATIONAL THINKING! My HUSBAND, WOULD HAVE NEVER ALLOWED ME to GO INSIDE THE PENTHOUSE ALONE/WITHOUT HIM. *Just Saying!* đ€
Also, I truly feel that Whitney, loves her sister, but in My Opinion, I feel like Whitney, Is MORE AFRAID OF WHAT AH Would Do to Her, If she didn't Stick to "The Story!" ... AH, Has already Beat Whitney's A$$ before (Came out on a video from a Reality Show that Whitney was on a few years ago, Right after it happened to her.) It's On CZcams, peeps! Oops.. Sorry, Pete!đ€«
âđŒđđŒâ€ïž THANKS, #PeteTragos #TragosLaw for ALL of YOUR TIME SPENT WITH US & YOUR AMAZING ANALYSIS, AS WELL as YOUR DAD & THE PROFESSOR. #GreatJob âïžđđŒđđŒđđŒâïž #JusticeForJohnny #PrayForTheJury #DeppVsHeard #Day18 #May18th2022 âđŒâ€ïžđșđž đșđžâ€ïžđșđžđđŒ
This is what I was thinking! He said he didn't hear from her for 10-15 minutes. I'm sorry but someone could kill her in that time. If you came to your own house trashed are really going to let your wife go in alone and wait outside for 15 minutes. It's illogical and sounds a little insane.
Loved your comment regarding Drew's testimony - "But everything that he testified to is what he saw but not how it happened." That sums it up perfectly.
I feel Whitney was not credible because I feel like she has lived off Johnny for 10 years-doing coke-partying- now that gravy train is over she HAS to say whatever Amber- who HAS abused her-wants her to. She is a minimum wage worker. Whats she going to do? resume her "career" as a coke head?
She was soooo DISGUSTING!!!
It's a 100m counter suit. You think AH won't buy her deadbeat sister a coke house for going along with her lie?
She lost me when she said he took a ziplock back full of pills..... She couldn't even get her story straight about the staircase. She said he hit her but Amber said he didn't because she clocked him before.
@@blossywossy100 Amber's roster of friends and sister all suspiciously use the same wording in describing events and Johnny's behavior, with very slight deviations. What further cements to me that this is rehearsed is when Whitney said she was hit (Amber tried to sound heroic and desperate to stop another Kate Moss moment, no way she'd misremember Johnny actually hitting Whitney) and then Racquie couldn't remember seeing Amber put on makeup the morning they got the TRO (Amber was trying to establish a pattern of herself always concealing the injuries, and wanted to hammer home that Racquie said NOT to hide them that morning--no way Racquie would forget saying thay).
Imagine, an actress with a face projected on screens 45-65â wide x 30â tall staying in a relationship where most of the claimed injuries are on her face. Not buying it. Full stop.
If you notice the depos are from 2019 but body cam wasn't produced yet so they thought it was their word against the cops
Good point! The timeline gets so confusing, on purpose I think.
A simple explanation for why her 'friends' aren't friends anymore: The wheels fell off their gravy train the moment they got evicted and they've all realized there's no reason to continue slogging barefoot through the mud with her, even while still believing Johnny beat Amber.
Yep. A bunch of grifters who got what they could and moved on. That includes Amber and her family.
My fellings exactly.
Rocky and Amber are friends. They are saying they aren't because they think it will make their testimony more credible. One thing I noticed is that Io, Rocky and Whitney all used the same "flowery" language Amber did to describe Johnny when they first met him.
100 percent I have said the same. Rocky, Oi Tillett Wright are saying they are not friends because it will make the jury think they are no longer biased against Johnny. It is a Amber fake job.
No they are not friends anymore.
@@dextermoore278 yes they are..besties
@@sportsbadcalls334 NO ROCKY SAID THEY WERE NO LONGER FRIENDS. ARE YOU ILLITERATE? ARE YOU HARD OF HEARING??????
deafness runs in my family. Thanks for asking.
The thing that needs to be remembered is that AH demanded 3 penthouses for her friends in the divorce 'extortion' letter. The friends at the time stood to benefit from the divorce.
Did the testmony in AH favor happen after JD removed them from his property? If so they could have been angry about it and wanted to hurt JD.
Just because Amber had bruises on her face it doesn't mean that Johnny put them there. Amber is a Psychopath and could of gave them to herself. Go watch Gone Girl.
Thatâs what happened
Or one of her wild girls sheâs with..
I had a friend in college many years ago who had bi-polar disorder. He was so up and down, eratic and paranoid at times it was exhausting and very emotionally draining to be his friend. That did not last. It is very plausible to me that AH lost her friendships due to the chaos that was her life with BPD.
That, and the gray train ended
Ted: did someone verify or claim her to be bipolar?
@@maureenhammack9826 Not sure, I was responding to other comments in chats on the topic. Wasn't sure if I had missed it or if folks were just commenting on the 'seems like' scenario.
Amber does not have Bi-Polar Disorder. She was diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder.
@@HaleyCarebear Thank you for clarifying. I misunderstood BPD to mean Bi-Polar Disorder, when I saw it in chats. I certainly don't want to put labels where they do not belong.
I also have issues with the fact that all the recordings they have are AH being antagonizing and bullying and admitting she was hitting him yet none of JD. And her demeanor with it is not scared at all. It just doesn't add up to DV IMO
Also to me the acting coach looked hurt when Camille essentially spelled it out for her that amber hadnât contacted her in years until she needed her to be a witness and after wining and dining her and outing her heart out to this former friend, she then asks her to be a witness.
We shouldn't believe JD because he is a drug addict, but believe AH sister that is a drug addict đ€š
The acting coach confirms she can't cry for shit. I'm like yeah we know she can't cry while acting, no shit! đ
LMFAO đ€Ł đ€Ł đ€Ł đ€Ł
The make up artist, when asked to describe AH's bruises, she said it looked as if someone could have "HEAD BUTTED" her lightly. This is why I discredit her because AH said JD allegedly head butted her. How does someone look at somebody's bruises on their face and determine that it was caused by a head butt.This is the only social media I have by choice, so I hope you see this comment. It doesn't look like you reply to anyone, but I thought I'll try.
She all so said her split lip was on the right side and her bruised face was the right but all pictures of her face show the left side
Well observed, they are well rewarded by ScAmber using Funds meant for kids hospital.
didn't johnny say while restraining her after her attack he lightly butted heads doesn't this collaborate that.
Samantha McMillan - Amber's stylist, testified in the UK trial that she spent all afternoon and evening with Amber on the 16th December, before she went on the James Corden show. She testified that she saw NO injuries on Amber whatsoever. So that tells me that this make up artist is lying.
TOTALLY AGREE ! Was thinking the exact same thing
How could those depositions even make into the trial with SO MUCH HEARSAY and Speculation in them? Shouldn't they have redacted all that?
Right??? and no cross??
Wondering the exact same thing ! Hope someone answers your question cuz u wanna know !!
They are all edited out ahead of time depending on what the lawyers object to and what the court says. They do the same (defense, plaintiff, defense or vis versa) it's just hard to tell the differences in the voices doing the questioning.
There was cross in those. I definitely thought the same thing about all the hearsay, but now that I think about it I think most of it was about people who gave their testimony as well, so I think that's why it's admissible.
Ms. Iglesias-makeup artist-said she could not be friends with Amber due to it becoming overly consuming relationship.
Ive had lots of facial plastic surgery and any of the facial pics could be from the nose surgery, eyelid and lip surgeries I KNOW Amber had. Being an actress you dont let people pummel you!
Was the nose area painful when touched especially day after
If JD did everything that's she said he did I would think there would have been some permanent damage. She would have scars on her face if he hit her numerous times in the face wearing all those heavy rings. Would have taken weeks to recover from such injuries.
I agree itâs a possibility that the jury will say FU to the whole thing.
Hes soo much more likeable which is why we didnât want to believe her in the first place, and then she helped us doubt her more for lying to us all.
Whitney lost ALL credibility when she said Johnny hit her on the staircase. To me it was such a blatant lie about Whitney getting hit , ithrew out her entire testimony.
Wasn't Amber's testimony that she stopped JD from hitting her sister? Now the sis says Jd beat on her too?
@@NamPham-jk5zc yeesssss, when she contradicted her own sister by saying Johnny hit her, I threw out her entire testimony.
@@sydneysomer9958 Could't agree more
@@NamPham-jk5zc yes and Amber testified that Whitney came down the stairs and stood between her and Johnny. Whitney said Johnny ran up the stairs behind her (no danger of being pushed down the stairs).
@@sydneysomer9958 it's really quite a feat that Amber's side of witnesses trotted out almost the exact same story but weren't quite on point on certain details.
Whitney exaggerated the story to the point she was beat herself.
Rocky can't remember seeing Amber putting on makeup, yet AH said Rocky stopped her because it would have went further towards getting the TRO approved (plus they had her publicist there--they wanted eyes on the spectacle)
I feel so sorry for these jurors. I was on a jury for a knife attack and it only took 3 days - and it was exhausting. So glad I wasnât on one like this.
Some of those depositions were rough. Rocky literally put me to sleep. She seems a bit slow in the head. đ
I do believe JD can be an obnoxious jerk when he overdoes certain substances, but I don't believe he assaulted her. I believe AH staged stuff and injured herself because the photographed injuries are so minor. The makeup artist said the bruised coloring was faint and she seemed unsure as to what type of lesion was on her lip and how to describe it.
yup there's no evidence that johnny hit her. amber's evidence are all set up
Yes! That's why the injuries were never serious bc she did it to herself.
HÉr lip looks like a cold sore
Agreed, there are definitely half truths sprinkled in but at the end of the day I don't think he beat her the way she says. Now verbal abuse is one thing, but their recordings show that was more than a fair fight. She was often the aggressor and more belligerent of them both.
I think AH wants to desperately live within this con because her marriage brought out the worst in her.
@@j.whiteoak6408 from sleeping around perhaps
It could be nothing, but Josh Drew didnât answer ânoâ to some key questions about staging and makeup. He answered those questions with ânot that I sawâ or ânot that I was aware of.â
It's called CYA~
And the fact that AH team reached out to them only right before this but they haven't talked in years beforehand, seems a bit odd too.
Rocky, during the cross with Camille, said that she and Amber arenât friends anymore because âthey grew apart because she wanted to spend more time with other peopleâ.
This is classic Borderline abandonment behavior wanting to monopolize all of one persons timeâŠ.
Johnnyâs Witnesses: All Professionals
Amberâs Witnesses: Bunch of Freeloaders
She has no friends- just freeloaders who she rounded up few months prior for this- sheâs needy .. & like Johnny, they all wanted space from her- she is making a mockery of DV victims-she continued to play mind fencing games to force JD to engage- he has issues but I donât believe he is an abuser âŠlike a child she wanted attention whether positive or negative- she truly needs help w/her deep issues starting w/her abusive father & abandonment issues- hope she gets help & JD sobers up - regardless he won bc we know the truth now & he cleared his name - may he rise up stronger than ever!
I really believe that JD is going to have to go the way of Robert Downey JR. get sober, maybe just weed and get back to his craft.
Johnny supported Amber, most of her dead beat friends and circus family members. Now all they have left to maintain their lifestyle is Amber. Simple to figure out. All one has to do is listen to the tapes. Ambers behavior is abhorrent. That says all I need to know. NO REASON to treat someone as she has.
Itâs telling that none of these people are her friends anymore. Even the makeup artist cut ties! She must be a horrible awful person.
Human Leaches.
Earlier this evening my dog accidentally hit my lip with his snout (heâs so cute) and my lip swelled up a little! Seriously if someone is hit on the face with rings the skin would be broken, open with wounds to say the LEAST! Iâm a survivor of DA and AH is the ABUSER!
I have my reservations when I listen to miss Pennington's testimony, during her first testimony she suddenly started to tell that she appeared in the master bedroom and had seen a broken bottle of red wine with the glass all over the bed. Now what did she suddenly have to do in the master bedroom, without any reason to be there. Found her to adopt a certain annoyed attitude from the start that seemed rather strange to me and then that overly tearful reaction when she looked at Amber's virtually unscathed face in those photos, it was clearly acted out. I see this lady more as Amber's accomplice. Be aware there is not one witness which stated that they saw that MR.Depp assaulted miss Heard. Everything is from hersay from miss Heard.
Could the tears brought on from the pictures be due to the guilt felt at remembering what was really done to give Amber redness in those pictures...
Yeh, that girl is fake.
I was thinking about how freely these people all wandered through Johnnyâs home! The penthouses connected over the top and entered on the level where JDâs bedroom was. I donât wander into my own brotherâs house without going to the front door and when inside, I would not dream of wandering into their bedroom!!! Such disrespect! No wonder Johnny eventually snapped and told them all to get out. They were a bunch of freeloaders taking advantage of Johnnyâs good nature and generosity. No one tried to stop the drinking and drugging culture in that house. Who knows how things would have been in that regard had they all butted out. He seems to have had no privacy in his own home! I notice it wasnât his family living off him!
Crim lawyer here: Can we please talk about the fact that Amber leaves the clump of hair on the floor for around 20 hours? Seems like this is a clear attempt to make sure as many people as possible see it but how weird is it to leave hair on the floor for 20 hours. I don't see any victim actually doing this and being reminded of the abuse over and over that entire day, just weird.
COPS BODY CAME VIDEO HADNT BEEN RELEASED AS OF YET WHEN JOSH MADE HIS DECLARATION BACK IN 2019 WHEN HE DID SAID DECLARATION SHOWN TODAY !
That is a great point that a lot people are missing.
Body cam showed his testimony was nonsense!
Whitney was overcoached. I do not believe Whitney. If you watched her tell her version of the story, you could see Elaine reading her script at the same time and noting her head affirmatively and turning the pages. Watch the videos!
Spot on!!
I felt same way. She responded to each direct question MUCH quicker than cross. Direct answers were way too immediate like she knew questions. Showed no thought process before answering, esp for stuff that happened years ago.
OF COURSE, they talked about the case. That makes NO SENSE they call him after 2 yrs and NOT talk about the case? I just could not buy it!!!!
@@basketballman1854 I agree, but I saw so many on-line attorneys saying he was credible. But the part of him meeting with Amber after not speaking for 2 YEARS told me the meeting was all about what to say in his testimony.
The thing about josh that i dont believe is , he stated he and rocky went in to the penthouse because they haven't heard from amber , the house was a mess , something wasn't right he stated , Rocky tells him to go wait in their apt so he goes????? Then you have Amber n Rocky there alone for at least 15 mins ??!!!! I dont believe their story , i don't believe Josh about leaving his wife there alone to look for Amber knowing something isn't right , i believe the whole thing was staged!!!!
Josh Drew stated that he was also a victim of abuse. By whom? Was it Rocky? Inquiring minds want to know.
I thought he was talking about childhood abuse, which is something that JD also experienced, so gave them common ground to bond over. But I might be remembering incorrectly.
Just pondering here. If you say that Whitney's testimony was credible, and that she was in good talking terms with JD, then I think what she didn't say, was that her sister was actually the cause of the problems. That her sister was the abuser, and she ( Whitney) was JD's consoler. .. đ€
Whatever the outcome of the trial, the next guy or gal that gets involved with Amber is in for living hell!
It wasn't the makeup artist that said she didn't see anything. It was the stylist that worked with her all day. Elaine asked her about her before she ended direct to lay doubt before she is mentioned. I'm an mua and the concealer and color she said amber uses is far too dark for her complexion so I didn't believe some of what she said.
Yes!! I wish I could super highlight this comment.
Of course I have no idea what people were tweeting to LYN, but it was definitely the STYLIST who said she didnât see injuries. All the advance info I saw said makeup gal = yes I saw, stylist = nope.
@@valhallaw 100% and the MUA confirmed that the stylist was with Amber before she did her makeup.
From what I saw Whitney testified today to the exact opposite of what Whitney said in some deposition in 2016 in regards to the stair thing.
@@2rific_2 Don't worry, the reason they let Whitney go on and on is that they got the most important admission out of her...that she was very close to Jennifer Howell, her former boss who Whitney stayed with for about a year to escape her abusive sister--and whose testimony is going to impeach Whitney big time.
They already testified in a UK court, now if they would change their testimony it would look like they perjure themselves. The fact that all of them are estranged from Amber is very significant.
For some reason, no one is telling why. I think there are several reasons, but the most important most likely is that they regret supporting her from the beginning of this situation. Some of them help her to create this drama. Maybe they were counting on some monetary rewards or something else. Most of them were at that time angry with Johnny Deep because he basically throw them out, they lost all the benefits they abundantly enjoyed.
Some later learned about the dark side of this creative drama that's why they broke up with each other. and so on.
Regarding if I believe them?
No!
Of course, they are saying partial truths, but this is the old known base of propaganda to mix truthful staff with confabulation. It is much more effective than all lies.
Everybody knows that Johnny is very gracious, besides ppl know that they were living on his back like leeches for a long time. Rent-free, vacations in Europe, the Bahamas, on the privet yacht, and so on. Everything for free. Pointless would be to denayed.
To not write a book here, I will mention the chunk of hair that Amber supposedly lost as a result of Johnny's attack.
I COMPLETELY disagree with that statment.
If somebody tells me that saw a similar situation, then please write me about it.
The hair in the picture looks like a bunch from the extensions.
It is impossible to tear out a bunch of hair like that without the roots. And if somehow somebody would manage to do that then this place would be a bloody empty.
Hair behaves like a rope, that's why sometimes we can see people doing all sorts of things with hair: pulling heavy items like a car, hanging, and so on.
BTW The resemblance of little blood can be applied very easily.
This is an ABSOLUTELY staged situation.
You are completely right đđ»
As far as Iâm concerned Ambers witnesses are heresay and coached. Amber used a bruise kit to create a bruise for show. Deep cuts were self-inflicted cutting relapse from relationship stress.
#justiceforjohnny
Agree, I think she cut her own arms...
Agree. I don't believe her AT ALL. She has been caught in many lies.
Yes. Self-inflicted. Right in line with her disorder.
yup all hearsay. no evidence. and their audacity to freeload on johnny's penthouse!!! i can't
@@sydneysomer9958 Same! đđ»đđ»đđ»
As someone who has education in trauma informed training, in my own observations about AH and JD's backgrounds, they both come from abusive households. Johnny's coping mechanism for his trauma seems like substance abuse, and resentment/aggression towards a woman figure (his mother was abusive). Ambers also has substance abuse as well but also resorts to aggression and violence (she has a lot of masculine traits) and a lot of projection (perhaps anger she feels towards her own father). The way she described Johnny as a "dead beat father", and how she always wants him to "get sober", is almost like she is projecting her anger and resentment towards her own father and her upbringing with him as an abuser and substance user. A lot of trauma stems from childhood, so also the fact that Whitney was "okay" with her sister still being with an "abuser" can be because they are used to knowing "love" as abuse. I also feel like both Johnny and Amber had a trauma bond, and with similar experiences in their childhoods, but instead of "healing" together, they didn't heal their own wounds - they just bonded over their pain and it was a toxic relationship with a lot of inner-child wounding. Really sad honestly. I hope that when this is all said and done, they can both find a good support system to really heal. I am not condoning either of their behaviours, I also do not believe Amber's story is consistent. I'm also a former DV victim, and her energy just doesn't sit well with me intuitively. I am simply stating an opinion and observation.
Gave you a thumbs up for taking the time to explain your point of view.As a tip going forward remember the you tube viewers rarely read long posts like this to the end.Keep going but try for a concise post? All good though you be youđ
Agree totally with your observations.
I agree 100%. What bothers me the is how AH used the legal system, which is automatically weighted in a woman's favor, in the worst possible way, then jumped on the #metoo movement with the obvious intent to ruin him. She's a disgrace to all REAL victims of partner abuse.
I think I disagree. I will read longer post if I find some substance in it and there is plenty of that in this one. To be honest it kinda resonates with me.
I agree with the majority of your comment and explanation. Well stated. I respectfully disagree with a response that your comments are too long especially when it has substance. I personally don't see Johnny as aggressive at all but rather one of his coping tools is avoidance which when coupled with Amber's abandonment is a driving force in her spiraling events. I do believe she "wants" to change but does not have healthy tools OR at least utilize them. It seems she needs intense counseling and my hope is that she may begin to recognize and accept her personality disorders and work on them with a professional skilled in her specific needs.
I don't believe any of her user friends. He was so terrible yet they all stayed for the freebies. No one told her to move out. Disgusting people. In addition, they all speak about only the same three incidents, nothing new. I call bull.
it seems to me that all these users wanted Johnny's perks but didn't really want him around. They are a younger click and the old guy was in the way
No makeup artist said it was painful to apply makeup on her. After a couple of days its not sensitive. A banged up nose ( she says with no verification) can start bleeding when touched. Especially next day and it is painful as hell. If the makeup artist added that to her comment I would of believed her. PAINFUL AS HELL TO THE TOUCH
Rockie....feeling horrible guilt can make it easier to cry.
21:30 I believe people were referring to Samantha McMillan who indeed said "I never noticed her having two black eyes" when working on AH for the James Cordon show.
Amber had a "Bruise Kit" ...NOT one that COVERS bruises... one that CREATES bruises for tv/movies/stage. The makeup artist was covering FAKE BRUISES !!!
She also had/has very bad skin conditions, a number of them side effects of the medications she was taking...
I'm blond/ fair- sensitive skin, and I get worse red spots on my face even by only feeling worked up...or a pillowcase with too much softener in it ..
Iâve NEVER heard ANYONE call a human being as a spirit animal! EVER! Bizarre!
Would you leave your wife in a wrecked penthouse with her abused friend if you felt there was a danger? Would you not want to make sure she's safe and Depp is not there if he's a threat? Why did Rocky tell him to leave...why did Joshua just walk away?
Thank you!! I noticed that as well.. Made no sense. Itâs almost like that was his out to say that he didnât know of anyone staging. I donât think He was involved with it, but I do think he knows they did it and was just like whoa, Iâm outta here
@@nikitathomas7513 totally agree. Maybe they didn't tell him but I think he knows something is off.
I heard Whitney say she had her back to Johnny in the stair situation. Didn't the witness for Johnny say Whitney put herself between AH and Johnny? She was trying to stop AH. That would put her back to Johnny.
Lol...do you really think ALL of Amber's family and friends who are afraid of losing their meal ticket aren't going to have the same "story"?
Exactlyyyy
Sm, old saying:
"if it's not about the money, it's about the money."
Grifters gotta grift, eh. If they can't grift Johny anymore, they'll try to grift Amber if she wins.
I wish Johnny's team had done a layover of those two pics allegedly showing her injured cheek. They were identical. The only thing that is different was the saturation and size of the photos. Every single strand of hair is 100% identical.
Also, I do believe Amber had some slight discoloration. I think it's caused by Botox tho. She had several procedures done. She look a different person now.
What a great job you did, thank you so much for pushing to the point of exhaustion, bless your heart. I really love your channel and hearing your views, I may not always agree, but it helps to see different points of view anyway. Have to say I am definitely on JDâs side and so badly want him to get back his credibility after all the hurt and pain he has gone through in this⊠but I hope they both get help for the problems they both clearly have.
Well said Trudie
There was also the moment when Rottenberg asked Rocky about one particular incident finishing the phrase with "is this right?" and as an answer, she asked him back if that is what she testified previously. He replied: "that's what you testified previously, yes", only then did Rocky say "Yes that's what has happened then " is this actually allowed?
Make up artist went into how shes made bruises for fx and then realized she said it and said AND covering it. I also noticed josh said that her attorny told them to get together and do a fact of statement or what ever. Also, theres 2 make up artist. The one whos depo (ive read) was mentioned in the make up artist depo. And she said that she was there before her
Yes! Josh was told by Ambers team to âget togetherâ with the other witnesses and get their stories straight, which would explain why they sounded the same and totally REHEARSED.
It's the stylist Samantha McMillan, who testified in the UK trial, that she saw no injuries on Amber. I believe her deposition over the make up artist's. I wish it had been brought up.
Peter, what did you think about what AH told the acting coach about how JD lost his finger? What AH told her, according to her, lines up more w/ JD's version (a broken bottle vs a phone).
I find it very curious about all the pre depo contact. Suspect!
Watching his trial makes me so sad. Clearly both Johnny and Amber had very unloving, unstable childhoods and now they are hurting each other so much, as they did when they were together. Often what people believe to be love is so far from love, but instead created in addictions that end up creating s ouch pain and suffering, which is so obvious and clear in this situation. Having said all this, while Johnny was verbally abusive Amber seems to be the one who was physically abusive, but the Truth is no abuse is justifiable. I pray for them both and hope they both find the help they need to heal from their experience together. Thank you Peter for being such a kind, generous and caring person. The world needs more lawyers like you and your Dad.
Agree with you the background of their lives is now coming into their relationship which causes a volcano into their emotions mentally.
I think she's too young ( 4 Depp) and acted like a teenager. Luckyfor amber she has no childrenof her own.
@@missingremote4388 sadly she does have a child.
I'd be inclined to agree with some of your points Peter, however, I can't get past knowing that the majority of AH's "friends" were freeloading mooches who lived off Johnny's dime, in every way. To me, that speaks to their integrity, honesty, and moral compass.
The jury did not respond well to Whitney. They wanted to get her off the stand ASAP.
Sounds like a smart jury đŻ
Wait until a rebuttal witness impeaches Whitney's testimony. www.ifod.net/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/HOWELL-US.pdf
Those Witnesses were so obviously coached even for a lay man like me ccan tell,Amber story has alot of holes if she is lying those friends of hers are lying for her too and it shows.
I also found Whitney somewhat credible, but later I was watching some streaming of this same portion by The Body Language Guy behavior analyst and during the break after her testimony he went back and really studied that portion of video with one camera angle on Whitney and the other on Elaine and also showing JD and Ben Chew. For most of Whitney's testimony he was commenting that her responses and body language seemed credible. But he did comment that the speed of her responses were very quick and seemed very well prepped and rehearsed. At the moment when she stated JD grabbed AH by the hair and started hitting her, JD reacts sharply and takes his glasses off. It seems JD was not shocked or surprised or even disagreeable to her testimony up to that point. TBLG also noted both Whitney and Elaine seem very tense during this portion of the testimony. Elaine is pensive in anticipation of her responses and nods with each point she makes. It just seems that this was a very carefully planned and rehearsed testimony. Thoughts? Maybe AH team decided to go for this version after knowing they were losing badly and needed a strong win?
Her sister is so obviously lying.
You know Whitney is lying through her teeth for her sister.
Body language guy also compared Ambers testimony to show it was at odds with Whitneyâs testimony. Whitney also said Johnny may not have actually hit her she wasnât sure
It was a super toxic relationship. Amber has some serious psychological issues and was young and Johnny had a substance abuse problem, and it caused a lot of anger and jealousy on both of their parts. But I think that Amber is lyingâŠa lot. She embellishes all the encounters and makes them sound like sheâs a saint and heâs a violent abuser. I donât believe for a second that he sexually abused her. I think she was the violent one and he also ended up hurting her physically during the altercations (grabbing her and moving her by the hair/arms, holding her from hitting him and head butting her while she squirmed, throwing things and accidentally hitting her). So I guess itâs really up to the jury to decide if thatâs abuse đ€·ââïž But I mean, anyone in his position could only put up with so much. I donât think he deserved to be cancelled because of all these lies she told. Especially when she likely played the roll of the abuser herself. How is it fair she gets to do aquaman but Johnny gets kicked from pirates and fantastic beasts?? Itâs not. Even if he loses, I think itâs good that the world knows the truth about Amber Heard now. Sheâs gonna have to rethink her entire life and career path, because nobodyâs going to want to touch her with a 10 foot pole after this. I donât think the same can be said about Johnny. Just my 2 cents.
Well said! Thatâs exactly how it feels! I donât think he intentionally hurt her but itâs possible in a moment he could have grabbed or pushed her away and he admitted to it in his deposition and in the recording when he apologized for her toes in the door! He admits to his actions! He doesnât deserve the public humiliation she created on him and his children that is just unacceptable!
There is a more recent audio that came out of Amber walloping Johnny on the ear, it's horrible. She is very much like a former friend of mine who ended up attacking me and my son. That former friend has BPD. She also abused her husband. It's truly sick.
I tend to agree with you on this
Exactly. I think that he should have said that for the phone accident. This was a mistake by his side. If he had said âyes, I pass out sometimes, yes my abuse makes me say and do maybe worse things, maybe I reacted sometimes too hard, but I was reacting, not abusing. I threw the phone and accidentally hit her in the faceâ This would have been more credible, because that is the most evident and more documented injury of all.
@@SereFenzi83 yes, I completely agree. I think the jury wouldâve understood. Many people have gotten angry and thrown a phone. It hit her, he was overreacting, he effed up the apartment, and it sucks that happened, but I wouldnât personally view that as abuse. And it wouldâve been much more believable.
If you hear the same testimony (word for word) in a group of friends... surely they agreed. Nobody sees, hears or perceives in the same way!
Exactly. Plus Whitney described Amber hitting JD on the stairs as the first time Amber actually hit JD. How would she know that if she knows they've had a tumultuous relationship and knows her sister is physically violent..? It was as if she was quoting Amber.
My question disappeared so Iâll repeat it - Are witnesses in danger of being prosecuted for perjury if their testimony doesnât match the UK trial? Who would even investigate since itâs not a criminal trial? I think thatâs why theyâre still lying. Not for love of Amber.
They are all claiming they are exfriends, but you know damn well they are still friends. They just want to make them seem like they are credible witnesses
I think Rocky did cry, not because the situation was bringing up an emotional or traumatic experience, but because of the dilemma she was in.
Fact is that she has a child now, her life is no longer filled with drugs and partying, she's grown up into a woman, but here comes the consequences of her involvement with Amber heard threatening to collapse it all - even just having to do a video depo puts her into a super stressful situation, and worse yet, she has no path forward except having to continue the lie, because in the event she doesn't, I don't even know what kind of consequences she will face, but safe to say that society in general will not show her any mercy and this lack of mercy will also affect her child.
Could such a situation bring a person to tears? Add a big spoonful of guilt in addition to another spoonful for once again having to lie and condemn an innocent man for something he did not do, then yeah, i think it could actually be enough to emotionally break a person to the point of tears.
I agree.
Rocky has her lifetime reputation to uphold and is nost important for her as a mother now.
I agree with this! I think now sheâs ashamed for backing up Amber before, and was crying from remorse at being forced to help Amber destroy Johnny even further.
I so agree with this, I definitely felt that she was feeling guilty for having to lie under oath for whatever reason
Is her former assistant going to be asked to give evidence again, as she has said the bottle incident actually happened to Kate James while travelling in South America during a terrible rape incident many years ago, and Amber has claimed part of her horrific story as hers. She needs to be recalled .
I think Amber Heard hurt herself ( minimally) and that all of her friends believe that Johnny did it. I think she would absolutely do something like that, especially if she does have those personality disorders.
Amber has the strangest tics involving her mouth. Once IO got tired in testimony, they started doing it too. Then saw Rocky doing weird things with her mouth too once she got tired in testimony. So strange. Feels like that old story that used to go around about how young friends take on each otherâs tics. It used to be a big thing in media.
I donât do drugs but ,Iâve heard that people look like theyâre chewing something, fidgety mouth, while on coke
As a dog owner, I can tell you that there is a huge difference in size between a small dogs poop and a humans! He admitted that the dogs were small and one was so small couldnât climb stairs.
Agree đ with your assessment totally.
I can't help but notice the sister has the same earring on the right side, middle of ear, gold clasp, as AH did in her alleged photos of facial bruises. I totally had to do a side by side of the sister and photos admitted as evidence. đ€
I notived the same
. I think it is whitney in some of these photos
@@yogijaya2897 I have to agree with you!
Iv been watching a few CZcams channels who are following the case but your channel is the best itâs like watching a football match and having the commentator sitting with me , learning heaps about court trials along the way .
It's still strange that all of her friends and family have never actually seen him hit her. They were around Johnny and Amber all the time. Someone would have seen something. If they knew he was an addict and he was dangerous why did they continue to party with him? Maybe because they had substance abuse problems too. Johnny was a free ride for all of them. He supplied them drugs and a roof over their heads free of charge.
JD's generosity contributed to his downfall. He didn't expect those grifters to turn against him. AH probably had smth on each of her "friends".
Peter, I read a sworn statement by her makeup artist the other day saying she saw no injuries, so I was surprised too. Apparently it was her stylist, not another makeup artist who was also there on the day who said she saw no injuries.
I think that you are completely missing something with Josh Drew, what he testified to about the police is not only in contradiction to what the police say but also the bodycam footage. He testified that he took the second officers to view the damage and that they walked over the wine stain the corridor.....well the bodycam footage completely contradicts that!!!
Body language wise I feel the only slightly credible witness was Rockyâs ex. Whitneyâs answers were most assuredly rehearsed as she took zero time or thought before answering.
None of these people truly cared for Johnny but instead were afraid of losing their golden cow. I think they ALL were only there for their own personal gain.
My question to AH would be on day of TRO WHY did she walk out the FRONT door of courthouse into the sea of paparazzi instead of using the side door that exists for high profile persons? She walked out front door because she KNEW the paparazzi would be there waiting.
There's been a L.A lawyer on "popcorn planet"
Saying how AH didn't need to be ANYWHERE near the courthouse to get a temporary restraining order !
He says in L.A they fill out the paperwork in office then send one of their " runner's" over to the courthouse to get it approved NO probs.
He also said in L.A because of celebrities - there IS an underground entrance that's not accesable to press specifically for celebs !
TOTALLY STAGED - the whole thing.
AH herself described the colorations of her own bruising over days .
She said red bruising only lasts for a day & went through the colours specifically over days - by day 6? She said its green to nothing - YET turns up unneededly at court on day 6 with big red briuse ??
Oh yeah the lawyer also said - the day she turned up in court - no one in thecourthouse knew anything about it & they didn't understand why she turned up there like that.
AND it's illegal to take pictures inside -BUT at least 2 were shown in court as evidence not taken by paparazzi but taken bu AH's people & released !
W - T - F !
Best point that I heard today⊠Even if this case concludes that its a âhe said she said/ they are both as bad as each otherâ situation⊠That in itself says that Ambers Op-ed was and is misleading and contains a false impression of what was really happening. meaning Johnny wins.
I donât believe a word sheâs saying and đŻ % believe and support Johnny. He deserves a PUBLIC apology from Disney
Does being 'under oath' even mean anything anymore? So many people, I feel, have lied
I agree
They are PAID
And will get rewarded if AH wins..no doubt
About the dogs..jd and ah traveled so much so I'm fairly certain that they had dog walkers and pet sitters to care for them. The dogs shouldn't be blamed for the bed incident đ
Maybe they destroyed the closets too? đ€Ł
I agree- none of these people are going to starve.
BPD and self injuries go together. Amberâs witnesses seemed to only tell parts of the whole story. Sister seemed to say more, but she was ok with ambers behaviors? Iâm sure Johnny had his bad moments, and amber stuck around? Why? She argued about what? They all got drunk and high not just JD. And why were all these people living free under JD? Abusers isolate their objects to fully control them.
there's an important thing also, according to dr. curry, people with BPD can't maintain friendships and the fact that all of her witnesses no longer friends with her backs up Dr. Curry's testimony further
@@radwaelmaghraby4463 yes they have very unstable relationships because they become suspicious of them too, and turn on them out of nowhere. they have very unstable view of themselves and others.
Itâs confirmed, the attorneys ARE watching this. After your comment on camaraderie on Depps team, Heards team is giving hugs all around and getting in huddles sharing chuckles. Today, they have sat her in between the two attorneys.
Miss Heard planned this long ago to make Mr. Depp's life miserable. Miss Heard had known for a long time that this marriage had no chance of success, partly due to the fact that she could not control her own emotions for that, Mr. Depp had too much of an adult character. Miss Heard with her manipulative behavior got but not Mr.Depp in her power. What Miss Heard had done time and time again with other men, she now became increasingly frustrated. It is very clear from her escalating behavior that this was purely aimed at provoking and confronting Mr. Depp, but this just backfired. The more the provocation, the more Mr. Depp distanced himself from her. That is why she has also recorded all her so-called abuses of violence by Mr. Depp with a lot of photo material that also includes many photos to form a certain incorrect image of Mr. Depp, this material had to form supporting evidence for her destroyed article which she published in the Washington Post. That's why she didn't think it was necessary to package this with doctor's reports as well, this would be also much more difficult because the abuse never took place. However, Miss Heard has made a capital mistake and Mr. Depp thereby largely underestimated because she never expected that Mr. Depp would sue her for libel and defamation. Well that's going to pay off now. To stand to her allegations she was forced to lie, this acting of lying has become so clearly established that she dug her own grave with this, which she fits well into with all her despicable lies. Now all of her "close friends" including her own sister took several detail pictures from all of the so called incidents , how odd is that. Such pictures you only take when they must serve a certain purpose, simple
Exactly the same thoughts, I like your comment very much.
For clarification Jennifer Howell was introduced during WHâs cross approximately 4 statements were made WH worked for her, lived with her for a year, confided in her, and considered her a âsisterâ. JHâs depo is on the witness list-possibly rebuttal is the thought! I couldnât chat last night while watching but I truly did not find any of her witnessâ creditable, while I thought Josh came close his statement about the significant injuries but then agreed to the photo was what he saw, these do not come close to Rihannaâs injuries in which I would clearly state those WERE âsignificantâ not Amberâs. I wonât dismiss that Amber may have been subjected to some abuse but I feel AH brought it on and was the instigator, I do NOT think JD was dramatic and started any of the arguments that escalated. I am all about âkeep it realâ AH not taking any responsibility for her own actions left me with only one conclusion, so far I cannot vote in her favor. As a poss juror I would definitely give a win on the title to JD I do not believe she experienced SA. I am disappointed in AH for making a mockery of DV. While I am an adult and do have some empathy for AH and do not want anything bad to happen to her, I still believe she thinks she is an âentitledâ woman and should âlearn from this very damaging error on her part. Keeping it real! Love your channel, your knowledge, and experience thoughts.
Today in court, Amber Stood up when someone else walked in or when they were leaving, and I saw a dime-sized bump/nodule on the left side of her forehead. I think she has BPD meltdowns and harms herself. God knows Camille would have triggered the hell out of her, yesterday.
How would Josh Drew's testimony have changed if he had known about the body cam footage? That depo was before the body cam footage was released.
AH is the reason the jury members have to waste 6 weeks of their life on this trial. If she didn't try to ruin him, they'd be no trial. He paid out nearly 1 mil (taxes included) for every month of marriage to her.
My abuser was so adept at gaslighting me. Unlike many other abusers he never apologized after hitting me, nor did he ever even acknowledge having inflicted any injuries. He would literally look at me stone cold serious & say he had never touched me or that I must have done it to myself (broken noses, black eyes, chipped tooth etc.) I felt totally insane. He would do everything he could to drain my energy & talk in circles. He constantly instigated fights. Followed me from room to room. Busted down doors & ripped them off the hinges if I locked myself
In a room for safety. He kept me sleep deprived for years. He lied to all of his friends & family & told them I was crazy & he put on an act of being a long suffering victim. He loved to hit me, push me, spit on me & verbally abuse me to try & get a reaction & if he finally did get one he would whip out his phone & film me âbeing out of controlâ then send it off to my family or his friends to humiliate & discredit me. He actually had kids born during our marriage with other women/secret families on two continents which I ended up finding out about!!! My abuser always told me how worthless & unlovable I was & that no one would believe me. That if I spoke up he would âexpose meâ for the awful person I supposedly was & everyone would hate me. Eventually I started to believe him. I was terrified of going to trial as well as obtaining a restraining order even though I had a slew of hospital records & photographs. A couple of years after I left him I started to heal & realize just how warped my thought process had been & how twisted with shame & fear I was. It felt very therapeutic for me to finally tell the truth & share my story. It was my way of coming to terms & making sense of what had happened to me. Sharing what happened to me & clearing my name didnât feel petty. It felt like reclaiming reality & taking back my dignity. Perhaps Johnny feels the same. đ„ș
They were all ex friends! That's my thought if they did make it up, they couldn't perjure themselves by admitting it. So they added to their testimony that they're not friends anymore (read between the lines). They are subliminally saying we don't support or believe Amber's stories anymore. Remember Amber has BPD and their charisma gets people believing them. I feel the friends did stage stuff but now they have grown a lot since then, plus they've seen other sides to Amber since so they want jury to know they're not friends. It seemed like a script? The acting teacher revealed that when acting she is no good at CRYING! That was hilarious as I immediately thought back to her own testimony about rape etc...were made up.
I also think they are doubling down with their statements for fear of perjury in the British case.
My step brother (George BrezIna Jr) was a personal injury lawyer in Tampa for many years! He died in his early 60âs s in a tragic ski boat accident in St Augustine. Gone too soon along with his passion for law as well! You remind me of him in many ways.