Thank you for an engaging analysis. Your gentle voice and accent are very charming and engaging. Thank you very much and keep up your fine analyses.🙂😊🤝🏼🤩
The use of ' that " here can be understood not only referring to Yeats' physical distance from his own country , but also to his psychological distance , i.e., how the poet feels psychologically distant about homeland. That mans , the country he loves is no good place for him and the like , but for the young only . It is the alienation and neglect he feels where the country no longer cares for him for he is now in the final chapter of his life . Many thanks for the interesting presentation you made.
بجد شرح حضرتك تحفة ياريت بجد الواحد يلاقي كل القصائد والشرح زي الpoem دي ، جزاك الله خيرا ♥️♥️، Please keep going for more explanation and analysis for another poems
Yes of course it means a branch in a tree, but when he said (set upon a golden bough) he meant standing on a golden bough of a tree, which leads us to conclude that he wishes to be a golden bird standing there since we all know that birds stand on boughs of trees and sing.
دكتورة عدنا امتحان قريب بالشعر..وشايفات الفديوهات انا الخاصة بالقصائد الداخلة بامتحانه..لكن... علما اكتبهن من الفديو..واكتب تلخيص وشرح حضرتج..فالامر ياخذ وقت طويل جدا..فهل من الممكن بعثهن pdfs..؟
دكتورة، قبل كل شيء؛ شكرًا كبيرة، والهمّ الزيادة في عطائكِ. وبعد.. امتحان الشعر سيكون بعد غد، يوم الثُّلاثاء؛ فهل لي ان ذكر القصائد التي ستدخل في الامتحان طالبًا ارسال روابط التحليلات التي تقومين بها هنا... مع جزيل الشكر طبعا.
@@user-xy5fo8cb6p أغلب القصائد يوجد راب في صندوق الوصف للمحاضرة بصيغة pdf في حال وجود قصيدة لا يتوفر فيها رابط يمكن التعليق على فيديو المحاضرة حتى أضيف الرابط الخاص بها
Im listening it again.. thank U again ! And.. i noticed at the last you said there will be more explanation of themes and our questions you'll receive to answer...so where is that video?
@@zahraataher90 doing this just there will bring us to hope to be one of your students or not to be at all! All the best doctor. And wish of you to speak about themes , symbols, (or in general) poetical devices of each poem in future soon.
I do explain the poetic devices and figures of speech in class mostly letting my students locate them by themselves. I don't include them in the videos because I trust that students are able to locate them.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله , قرات في احدى التعليقات انه من الممكن ان تبعثي هذا الجهد على شكل pdf>> شاركين لك هذه اولا.. وثانيا ساحرص على التعليق عللى القصاىد التي نحتاج ملفاتها .. التوفيق والعطاء ان شاء الله ... دكتورة.
@@zahraataher90 okay.thanks fro responding. And mam..may i be allowed to communicate with u somehow? I am a last year Student.so it’s become very necessary to make a plan to finsih my task.but i am not getting how would i do it..will u be kind enough to me?
@@cadredeux1047 I think what is intended here is the idea of aging itself, the passing of time means we are getting older regardless of what age we think is middle age, old or very old.. you might be in your twenties and worry about getting thirty because you think you are starting to get older... even if you are a poet! aging here is regarded as a fact
@@zahraataher90 My original post was meant to be humorous. However I do some what disagree with your interpretation. My interest with this specific poem comes from Cormac McCarthy’s use of it in the title of the book “No Country for Old Men” and the Border Trilogy. So it’s through his eye’s I interpret his poem. I believe he uses the poem as a contrast and not as an explanation of the novel. Yeats talks about a detachment from nature. Those dying generations-at their song, The salmon-falls, the mackerel-crowded seas, Fish, flesh, or fowl, commend all summer long Whatever is begotten, born, and dies. CM embraces nature and his characters identify with it. ‘All the Pretty Horses” WBY escapes the natural world and withdraws into the imaginary world of Byzantium an idealistic world of Gods and myths. CM recognizing the connection to nature and shows the dark side along with the beauty. I can go on, but I will leave it up to you if you want continue this discussion.
@@cadredeux1047 I agree with you on Yeats' detachment from nature, indeed I spoke in the video about Yeats' preference of the artificial (here it is the artistic creation) over what is natural because it lasts and does not go through the natural decay of the body. He wants to be taken out of the natural body and become a golden bird singing for Byzantine lords and emperors. I think it is a desire to be immortal in his artistic ability to sing what can be heard and aesthetically valued throughout ages, and a desire of a (materialistic) immortality as well, just like the relics of the ancients that are made of gold and are still preserved after centuries
Thank you for an engaging analysis. Your gentle voice and accent are very charming and engaging. Thank you very much and keep up your fine analyses.🙂😊🤝🏼🤩
The use of ' that " here can be understood not only referring to Yeats' physical distance from his own country , but also to his psychological distance , i.e., how the poet feels psychologically distant about homeland. That mans , the country he loves is no good place for him and the like , but for the young only . It is the alienation and neglect he feels where the country no longer cares for him for he is now in the final chapter of his life . Many thanks for the interesting presentation you made.
Please i well be waiting for ur lecture kindly keep it up the good work. May Allah protect and guide your steps
بجد شرح حضرتك تحفة ياريت بجد الواحد يلاقي كل القصائد والشرح زي الpoem دي ، جزاك الله خيرا ♥️♥️، Please keep going for more explanation and analysis for another poems
Thank you Asmaa
Thank you very much in deed for your efforts. God bless you Miss. Keep doing that.
رررقرر٣ث
Wonderfully explained. Very detail.
Thank you and please upload other poems and essays and stories too.
Thanks 🙏 alot for this brief summary Dr.
From Kerala.... Lots of love... Good class
Uh have worked very hard to explain this difficult poem in a more simple version ....... Thank uh ❣️
Thank you 🙏🏻🌸
Thank you so much for your efforts and your clear explanation 👏🏻♥️
Nice mam very vividly and clearly described
شدعوه هلگد شرحج حلوووو 🤍✨
توضيح موفق جدا، شكرا جزيلا
Thank you miss
ممنونين جداً ع جهودك استاذة Alaa jafar
Thank you very much dr. for a great explanation
It is amazing explain ❤
Thank you
Now we can skip real life lectures. Thank God for youtube
you are already doing that
Amazing explanation
Really great thanks 🙏🌹
Most useful explanation thanks
Thanks 👍
ممكن قصائد فلبس لاركن
At the grass
And to the church
قريباً إن شاء الله
Bough means a branch in a tree.
Yes of course it means a branch in a tree, but when he said (set upon a golden bough) he meant standing on a golden bough of a tree, which leads us to conclude that he wishes to be a golden bird standing there since we all know that birds stand on boughs of trees and sing.
Awesome....
So nicely explained. Thank you very much but may be valuable comments I missed bcz I don't know Arabic 😔
You are really amazing
Very very good
Thank you 😍
دكتورة عدنا امتحان قريب بالشعر..وشايفات الفديوهات انا الخاصة بالقصائد الداخلة بامتحانه..لكن... علما اكتبهن من الفديو..واكتب تلخيص وشرح حضرتج..فالامر ياخذ وقت طويل جدا..فهل من الممكن بعثهن pdfs..؟
www.mediafire.com/file/irccggzy9ldxugg/Sailing_To_Byzantium.pdf/file
دكتورة، قبل كل شيء؛ شكرًا كبيرة، والهمّ الزيادة في عطائكِ.
وبعد.. امتحان الشعر سيكون بعد غد، يوم الثُّلاثاء؛ فهل لي ان ذكر القصائد التي ستدخل في الامتحان طالبًا ارسال روابط التحليلات التي تقومين بها هنا...
مع جزيل الشكر طبعا.
@@user-xy5fo8cb6p أغلب القصائد يوجد راب في صندوق الوصف للمحاضرة بصيغة pdf في حال وجود قصيدة لا يتوفر فيها رابط يمكن التعليق على فيديو المحاضرة حتى أضيف الرابط الخاص بها
ال pdf والشرح جدا واضح، ممكن احصل ع ال pdf الي د تشرحين علي حضرتج !؟
www.mediafire.com/file/irccggzy9ldxugg/Sailing_To_Byzantium.pdf/file
@@zahraataher90 شكرا جزيلا استاذة 🌿
@@zahraataher90 thank u sooo much ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Nice explanation
Thank youu !! ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
ابدعتي 🤎🤍
Good explnation.
شكرا ست
Make a video on Byzantium Mam
Thanks sir
Im listening it again.. thank U again !
And.. i noticed at the last you said there will be more explanation of themes and our questions you'll receive to answer...so where is that video?
I did not upload anything else about this poem, I gave my students the themes and questions online.
@@zahraataher90 doing this just there will bring us to hope to be one of your students or not to be at all!
All the best doctor. And wish of you to speak about themes , symbols, (or in general) poetical devices of each poem in future soon.
I do explain the poetic devices and figures of speech in class mostly letting my students locate them by themselves. I don't include them in the videos because I trust that students are able to locate them.
@@zahraataher90 Much of thanks Doctor.
استاذة الله يخليچ ممكن تنزلين الملف على التلي ، وإذا عندچ قناة هناك نزلينا معرفها فضلاً 🙏
الملف موجود بصندوق الوصف تحت الفيديو مباشرة اكو رابط
Consume my heart away ,sick with desire
شنو تحليل هل مقطع اريد جواب يكفي عشر اسطر🥹
poemanalysis.com/william-butler-yeats/sailing-to-byzantium/
شكرا
عاشت ايدج ست
In which university you're teaching?
Ahlulbayt university, Iraq
@@zahraataher90 you are instrumental, you know! Bless you
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله , قرات في احدى التعليقات انه من الممكن ان تبعثي هذا الجهد على شكل pdf>> شاركين لك هذه اولا.. وثانيا ساحرص على التعليق عللى القصاىد التي نحتاج ملفاتها .. التوفيق والعطاء ان شاء الله ... دكتورة.
where are you from ?your accent seems you are from middle east
Iraqi
@@zahraataher90 okay.thanks fro responding. And mam..may i be allowed to communicate with u somehow? I am a last year Student.so it’s become very necessary to make a plan to finsih my task.but i am not getting how would i do it..will u be kind enough to me?
دكتوره عزيزتنا عندك قناه عل تلكرام
لا ما عندي قناة رسمية لأن بصراحة ما عندي وقت دائما أنشر فيديوهات و أتابع
‘He wrote the Poem at 61, as you can see he was really old”. Really?☹️
how old is really old?
Not, 61. 61 is old for an athlete but not a Poet.
@@cadredeux1047 I think what is intended here is the idea of aging itself, the passing of time means we are getting older regardless of what age we think is middle age, old or very old.. you might be in your twenties and worry about getting thirty because you think you are starting to get older... even if you are a poet! aging here is regarded as a fact
@@zahraataher90 My original post was meant to be humorous. However I do some what disagree with your interpretation. My interest with this specific poem comes from Cormac McCarthy’s use of it in the title of the book “No Country for Old Men” and the Border Trilogy. So it’s through his eye’s I interpret his poem. I believe he uses the poem as a contrast and not as an explanation of the novel. Yeats talks about a detachment from nature. Those dying generations-at their song,
The salmon-falls, the mackerel-crowded seas,
Fish, flesh, or fowl, commend all summer long
Whatever is begotten, born, and dies.
CM embraces nature and his characters identify with it. ‘All the Pretty Horses”
WBY escapes the natural world and withdraws into the imaginary world of Byzantium an idealistic world of Gods and myths. CM recognizing the connection to nature and shows the dark side along with the beauty.
I can go on, but I will leave it up to you if you want continue this discussion.
@@cadredeux1047 I agree with you on Yeats' detachment from nature, indeed I spoke in the video about Yeats' preference of the artificial (here it is the artistic creation) over what is natural because it lasts and does not go through the natural decay of the body. He wants to be taken out of the natural body and become a golden bird singing for Byzantine lords and emperors. I think it is a desire to be immortal in his artistic ability to sing what can be heard and aesthetically valued throughout ages, and a desire of a (materialistic) immortality as well, just like the relics of the ancients that are made of gold and are still preserved after centuries
لازم تنطين اشياء توضيحيه باللغه العربيه تره كل الاساتذة يشرحون مثلج ماكو فائده
اللي يريد عربي مو صعبة يلكى اساتذة يشرحون على اليوتيوب اكو هواي