Why Did the Holocaust Happen?
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 01. 2017
- On January 17, 2017 historian Peter Hayes spoke at the US Holocaust Memorial Museum to discuss his new book, "Why? Explaining the Holocaust." In his book, Hayes addresses what scholars know about the Holocaust, and answers important questions including: Why were Jews the primary victims? Why were Germans the instigators? Why did murder become the "Final Solution"? And, why didn’t the international community do more to help?
“Everyone had something more important to do”. The sorrow of that statement is overwhelming.
These days it is stand around with a thumb in a stinky place and a hand out saying "give me everything despite my lack of effort to get it myself".
It's the way not only of America, but the world. Nobody cares about nobody, which is why the world won't last.
Unfortunately it's true, fighting the Palestinian people instead of liberating their own Polish Jewish countrymen...
The Irgun Stern and Hagannah Jewish military fought the native Arabs instead of Nazis I still scratch my head why??
They took on 22 Arab countries but the same army didn't go to fight the Nazis.
It's brilliant strategy and it worked 💪
I almost cry when I see your sentence ....
Silly shows about everyday people. Everything from paranormal to normal, featuring the talents of unknown and amazing actors.
Why r u stop to make ur great Video ?
Why did it happen? Look around the playbook is being run again, this time on a global scale.
protocols of zion
In UK we’ve had tv/ radio shows with the subject of the program - is it time to unfriend your unvaccinated friends ?- not many care . Now they’re giving kids experimental injections . The lack of outrage is shocking . There’s millions of us protesting but mostly it’s just carrying on . People have fell for it completely and won’t listen to their well meaning friends .
@@clairelees6718 I agree it is very alarming how tyranny try's to make all complying there rules that don't make sense. Cause they created the germs in a laboratory in wuhun China the who. And fauci and u.n. plans the world domination they have plans again.
@@cherrybell2995 yes it’s shocking . If people would only connect the dots , it’s so obvious but they’re just not looking properly - I get laughed at when I say it’s a u n agenda and they’ll probably use different armies to control us . But these are the same people who don’t even know who Fauci is .! Right now I want to leave them all to it and let them find out the hard way
@@clairelees6718 Here in nyc if you don’t have the jab have been turned into second class citizens.
No Jab No Job.
It’s Disgraceful & Disgusting
According to the Hebrew prophets, the world will see this again only on a much wider scale. An astute student of history, current events and the words of the prophets can see these same dynamics brewing again. God help us.
We are barreling toward a Nazi Germany again, as fast as we can. Oh, may God help us. Yes. Steve, I’m in total agreement with you.
There is no doubt that a tyranny such as the world has never seen is being prepared by Satans minions. Im so surprised God hasnt already destroyed this evil world.
God tolerates it.
Who against?
@@vippilla1688 ?
Slowly we are losing everything America stands for and we must stand up against the erroding of our freedoms NOW...
Thank you for your comment. However, your problem is a little off-topic. Might I suggest that you voice your opinion on a content piece that is more relevant to your statement? This topic is mostly about the Holocaust in the 1930s, not about standing up against the freedoms that you don't want to erode.
Acknowledge the Holocaust against the Native Americans.
SUCH AS?
Totally agree!
Um what?
Just look around it's happening again history works like an anasthetic.
What is it actually happening again?
@@peramoredellanalisi4341 another dehumanization process is happening. Pay attention.
@@kenolson3064 Are you kidding me!? What is the "dehumanization process"?
@kylekataryn And you compare the holocaust with US policy? Are you fxxxxxx kidding me??
What constitutional rights are denied exactly?
@kylekataryn native black Indians have been denied for yrs
Mans inhumanity to men seems to unending, being 89 and having spend 3 1/2 yrs in a Japanese prisoner of war camp, as a 20 yr. old, in WWII in S.E. Asia, I can attest to that! What does not kill you, will make you stronger! WP
Sorry. 10 yr. Old.
@W P God bless you, it breaks my heart to think of you as a 10 yr old child in Japanese POW camp
@Dude Sweet so he made a mistake. 10 instead of 20 years. But you already showed DISRESPECT to an elderly. Not nice. Not polite.
@@holistichealthlifewellness2182 I agree, was very disrespectful to an 89 year old. Back then, 10 year olds were drafted into the military. America was tough back then.
Heartbreaking...and you wonder what lessons were learnt here. Children as witness to such atrocities is truly hearbreaking. I'm not Jewush but every time tge issues of the holocaust comes up, I think of those people and my heart breaks again and again for them.
"Power magnifies the ideas of those who hold it. And when people who hold beliefs that are regarded by the general society as not quite acceptable become enormously powerful, their beliefs become steadily more acceptable". Peter Hayes
Yes, this makes sense to what is going on in the US now.
This is exactly what's happened with vaccine mandates in various countries across the world, and attitudes towards those who take a stand against the infringement of their human rights. Frightening how easily people can be influenced to think that the unvaccinated/Jews deserve to be discriminated against. History repeats itself in so many ways.
@@tessadrake824 oh my God are you seriously comparing unvaccinated people to Jews in the Holocaust?
If you consider doing something for the greater public good on par with being rounded up and gassed to death, honey, you have bigger problems than a shot or wearing a mask. Please get psychiatric help for whatever your problem is.
Yes, I agree. There have been vaccine mandates for years, for myself and my children and my grandson. My 9 year old grandson has finally gotten the COVID vaccine and I am relieved. There has been blatant rhetoric of hatred and racism that has come to be acceptable. Empathy has to be taught to our children and it seems some have failed. I was asked why I chose to wear a mask and get vaccinated and I said so I won't get it and spread it to someone who might die from it, my grandson??? Have some empathy for the people around you. We are growing into a society of it's all about me. Is history repeating itself? I sure hope not.
It is important that we study EACH OTHERS HISTORY! Thanks for posting.
Great lecture, parts I had never heard. All of humanity has value. We are our brother's & sister's keeper.
I'm crying because I see how many other countries are going through this right now (although not necessarily for the same "causes", but genocides) and because I see my own country about to fall over this edge, the U.S. It's so close, we can almost smell it. When we go there will be no one left to help us. No one willing, that is.
I´m crying because I can´t say anything unless I agree with everything.
Speak up against this regime as much as you can. All around the world we can see what's going on in America.
As a German, I can literally imagine to go to war against an US dictatorship. It would be as part of the EU - not Germany fighting a war, but the point is that I feel something like a duty to do that, if the international community agrees it is the right thing to do.
I'm not worrying about an US dictatorship for now, and yes, it was so close I could smell it.
@@vsiegel thank you.
We got ourselves into this. We helped get the world into this.
No atonement would be enough to show how sorry we are or how wrong... And most folks don't even get it. They believe the old hype from the Cold War days. The fall of the Berlin Wall all that b.s.
We set up puppet governments. Occupied unnecessarily. Took advantage of states with labor laws we ourselves deem illegally abusive.
We gave citizens rights to corporations, legally defining them as equivalent to people, to individuals when Clinton was in office. That's why we see bodily autonomy ideas changing now. That and China's infiltrating influence.
We stopped growing food. We stopped manufacturing things. We devalued oil and gas.
We went from one of the world's biggest lenders to largest debtor nations.
What we gonna pay that back with now we're out of valuable commodities?
People. Human bodies. Human capital may be all that's left.
So, we are redefining human being to mean the larger scope of the greater human body, each of us only active cells serving it.
That's what the mask and shots symbolizes that we all act as each other's white blood cells, helping stamp out disease - if we don't, we're dehumanized as helping death with the dirty business.
For the record, I'm not anti mask or anti vax. I wear mine happy to contribute a little bit more safety, but I see an overarching theme.
If there was a conglomeration richer, bigger, and more powerful, that encompasses and controlled world governments or didn't have to bow down to them... We might be at a dangerous precipice.
We opened this flood gate
We opened this door.
The whole world must come together to shut it.
And it won't.
I'm not that religious, but it might take a level of power only divine sources can manage.
So, I pray for you, and for the world. What mistakes my country has made. Creating enemies we pretended to be friends.
What a mess we might be in.
I hope I'm crazy and have invited many minds to help show me how. It's easier to be crazy. There's treatment for that: meds, therapy, recovery. But to see things this way without being able to offer anything helpful...
All I can do is pray.
@@brightpage1020 I think the situation is not that pessimistic.
Of course, there is a lot broken in the US, currently, and some of it goes deep. The important point is that the US did not become a dictatorship.
We need to see ourselves as a global community anyway.
To me, it does not so much feel like there is a large country far away with huge structural problems, and hopefully they figure it out.
We live in a global society, but are still learning how to do that. Nobody did that before, so that's not surprising.
For example, we have this conversation - and we are in no meaningful way separated, except for the physical aspect.
What is important here is that we both live in a society, let's call it the western world, and there are regions with serious problems.
I'm basically interested in getting the US into working conditions just like you are. We are in the same team, and cooperate. Germany works very well in part because of very strong support. from the US after the war. Our constitution was written from scratch learning from problems with the US constitution, basically by some political scientist, and with US veto power.
We were recently in a situation so much darker than the US is in now. Unfortunately, the US situation is much more complex. The US helped us getting out of it literally giving lives of it's citizens.
With that support, we had the opportunity to figure some useful stuff out, like running a democracy, and free education.
We are more than happy to give something back. A US student can literally just go study in Germany, and spend a lot less money than at home, he may even return debt free. I would be proud to see it.
Again, we are on the same team, nationalism between USA and EU does not even make sense anymore.
Now, there are some deeply broken things, and we know where they are. Students literally write about things as homework.
And the US has really brilliant politicians. For example many of the Democrats candidates.
If the only resource that can be exported would be people: Most western countries have declining population. We can pay by educating.
And then Joe Biden, a politician who has the highest amount of experience that is physically possible, including vice presidency. That's mind blowing!
So glad to have found this video! I have been sitting with his exact question of Why did this happen? The interviews with surviving Holocaust survivors rose many questions within me and this video answered a large percentage of the questions.
Hitler is the reason why the holocaust happened. His demonic theories about what to do with the jewish people were put into action by his evil followers
And now, we just need to switch on TV and see the early development LIVE.
If we forget the past, we are doomed to repeat it…let us never forget
We have, we are killing unborn children world wide!
Quite true. We must remember the innocent victims of the Holocaust. Not only Jews but other people, such as the Slavs, Roma, among others whom the Nazis deemed unfit to live. After all, who are we humans to judge as unfit for life? No one that I know of.
We did forget a long time ago
It almost happened January 6 Donald Trump. It is so sad how people want to be so mean to humans
The victors write the history.
"The revolution won't happen with guns, rather it will happen incrementally, year by year, generation by generation. We will gradually infiltrate their educational institutions and their political offices, transforming them slowly into marxist entities as we move towards universal egalitarianism" --- Max Horkheimer.
Horkheimer was one of the leading 'juice' marxist of the Frankfurt school, which pioneered cultural marxism.
"When we get ready to take the United States, we will not take it under the label of communism; we will not take it under the label of socialism. These labels are unpleasant to the American people and have been speared too much. We will take the United States under labels we have made lovable; we will take it under liberalism, we will take it under progressivism, under democracy. But take it we will." Alexander Trachtenberg, National Convention of Communist parties 1944.
"We made a monster, a devil out of Hitler. Therefore, we couldn't disavow it after the war. After all, we mobilized the masses against the devil himself. So we were forced to play our part in this diabolic scenario after the war. In no way we could have pointed out to our people that the war was only an economic preventive measure."
James Baker US Foreign Minister 1992
"If the 'hulcust' you talk about is real, why don't you allow the subject to be studied? One can freely research any issue except this issue which is sealed. It is a black box which they do not allow to be opened or examined. They do this in order to exploit it."
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
"When the National Socialist and their friends cry or whisper that this war is brought about by 'small hats,' they are perfectly right."
--The 'Juice' Magazine Sentinel of Chicago October 8, 1940.
"The war now proposed is for purpose of establishing 'Juice' hegemony throughout the world"
---Brigadier General George Van Horn Mosely, New York Tribune (March 29, 1939).
"My spirit will rise from the grave and the world will know that I was right"--- flodA retiH
I learned a lot from this lecture. Appreciate the expertise. Thank you.
Yea I did too, how propaganda and brainwashing works...
It sounds to me like he is explaining HOW the Gernan administration executed the holocaust rather than WHY they did it.
I think the “why” was the “concept of contamination”. At around 12:00. And the people who listened to the “concept of the source of all trouble”.
And then the “all life is struggle” and “us against them mentality”. The “how” is the exploitation of these evil beliefs.
Internal division of the Jewish people at 37:00.
The doctrine of “non-interference”.
Resistance to immigration, US nativism.
How interesting! And very well delivered.
It's always good to look at things from different perspectives and depths.
It happens when you demonize a group of people blaming them they are "privileged" and "guilty" regardless what an individual did - he/she is "guilty" by association with his/her group.
Yep! Like the left is doing to white people these days.
Damn..I never realized the parallel..👏
You are right, years earlier, students were already burning books on the college campus. The battle of minds was already fought and won by the academics and media of that time. Several Nobel laureates like Erik Gottfrid nominated Hitler for the award even though it didn't fall through later. In 1938 Time magazine named him the man of the year.USAToday published an article in the "Fact check" section claiming that "Time magazine did not praise Hitler in that issue, but they condemned him" Basically, these folks are telling you to ignore empirical facts and believe their fact-checking. Americans are busy looking for the second coming of Hitler in the wrong places. Throughout the history of humanity, all dictatorships have always won the hearts of the majority. None of them has ever told their people what they don't want to hear.
Sounds familiar. They are already building concentration camps too and people are still justifying it.
Absolutely! When you can dehumanize your enemy you’re half way there and that’s exactly what the left tries to do to its opponents.
This is the most informative and effective explanation of these basic questions that I have ever encountered. We all need to transfer what we learn about the Holocaust to genocides that are happening right now all over the world.
Hate is contagious. Elie Wiesel advocates "hatred for the German". There should be no double standards. If we find Larry Davis humor moraly depraved we should call it out not kill Larry David.
The ongoing genocide in Palestine/Gaza , which the Congress (beholden to the Israeli lobby)in an ultimate sadistic irony declared as an attack by the (besieged , beleaguered )Palestinians on Israel and it’s people , closing their eyes to the staggering disparity in casualties and the sheer and lopsided advantage that Israel has in terms of weaponry and resources .What’s true of the Congress is true of the US establishment generally and an odd voice which dares to call out Israel for it’s brutal atrocities is forthwith branded as anti-Semitic , and faces assault from all sides , with death threats and other social and financial overtures .
@@uncatila
X
@Boo Baal Very true . The conscience of the so called “liberal democracies” has been in a deep coma , regarding Israeli atrocities (which have relentlessly gone on now for more than seventy years)in occupied Palestine !
@Boo Baal May be there would be a divine intervention (like Nebuchadrezzar hauling them off to Babylon or the Romans dispersing them all across the globe) which could be likened to chemo-therapy or radiation .
Thank you for posting. Very interesting.
🙏🌞Thank you for the lecture and for uploading the video.
Many countries essentially enabled Hitler's Germany by refusing to accept refugees. At least one country stood out and willingly accepted and embraced Jewish refugees who sought asylum there. That country is the Philippines, so far away from Europe yet did what rich countries had refused to do. In the end, many of these Jewish refugees elected to stay there and assimilated. That's the reason Israel accords so much respect for the Philippines.
True! Maraming salamat!!
Japanese-occupied China took something like 20,000 Jews at the time also (in Shanghai) and managed to hold off the Germans who demanded they be handed over. I don't know what Israel thinks of Japan, but I would expect the same.
America is one. We made it hard for all the victims to get in, while at the same time making it easy for perpetrators (not even including the "operation paperclip" portion of it) and provided immediate pardons to Bayer, Basf, IBM, Merk Etc etc, wich is why only the chairman of board of a few of these companies was tried.. Only to return to the company at an elevated position and pay within 1-12 years.. Rather than hang like those who followed their orders.
Didnt know that...very interesting.
And the Jewish leaders in the United States fought to keep Jewish refugees out.
This man looks EXCELLENT for 70 years old.
Damn sure does
Damn sure does
I couldn't guess he was 70 at all.
That lady was right about Communism/Bolshevism. The truth can be denied or suppressed; it can end up being ignored or distorted and that is what opens the door. History must be an exercise in honesty...it must be faced head-on for the benefit of all.
You are absolutely correct, however as there are ALWAYS political beneficiaries of such
actions, there is ALWAYS substantial (and often very successful) political pressure to sweep such things under the carpet of history.
Look at WHO were the majority of the leadership of the Young Turks, involved in the genocide of Armenians and Greeks.
Look at the history of the Zionist movement and their actions.
Hitler said who remembers the Armenians ?, and when you look at the history of the last 120 plus years much of it has been swept under the rug in plain sight of the population.
I suggest an old U Tube interview with Norman Dodd chief investigator of the 1953 House Unamerican Activities Committee investigation into the tax free foundations.
You will find it illuminating.
Dear sir please read this book, on the eve by author Bernard wasserstein before making any more comments on commùnism
@@theodorepage6087 How about YOU make the points yourself instead of appealing to the authority of others.
@@peterjones4180 Are you seriously comparing the Zionists with the Nazis?
That lady is 100% polish and she wouldn’t be standing there if it wasn’t for "communist" forces
Thank You For Sharing. 😭
A few years ago, Peter Hayes was my thesis advisor. One day, when we met to discuss my thesis, he received a phone call that he put on speakerphone. The man on the other end said he was from some historical review organization and wanted to interview Prof. Hayes about something he'd written about Auschwitz. Prof. Hayes immediately and furiously told the person on the other end to never call him again.
Confused, I asked him why he reacted like that. Wouldn't it at least be a little flattering to be asked for a interview?
He sighed. "They're Holocaust deniers. They call every so often."
So that was a good reaction, just run away from it. xD
@@RREDesigns It would have been a waste of the Professor's time.
I've got a friend, or had, who now thinks we fought on the wrong side of the war and is a holocaust denier. Conspiracy you tubes are lucrative and apparently convincing to uneducated people. It's embarrassing. Holocaust deniers and all conspiracy theorists just need to be right, as a revenge or something. Because they had a hard childhood and usually didn't graduate high school. The ones I know, anyway.
@@Mrpastry909 Considering how bad it is to have a denier, I believe his time his worth if he manages to convince those callers. So no. I get it though, it is just easier to walk away when you can't do something.
@@joecook5689 The best known revisionists are highly educated people, so that you just said is garbage. Sorry.
A most interesting explanation for antisemitism by Germans during the 3rd-Reich but it left out the reasons for antisemitism by other countries and before Hitler.
Anti semitism Jew hatred because the church brainwashed those countries
@@Barbara-ld4ug Reasons go back far earlier to Ancient Egyptian times - Mosses led 600,000 Jews out of Egypt in the middle of the night for fear of being slaughtered.
They were accused of undermining Rulers ( Pharos) and their authority by way of spreading hate, agitation, dissent, incitement, chaos, rebellion of the local Egyptians !
@@daveoliver5838 talmud/mossad (isis): by deception, we make war....
Regretfully Germany was the lesser anti Semitic nation in Europe compared to France and Russia... but the Treaty of Versailles switch the whole country due to injustice
Well, before Nazis anti-semitism was mainly about religious differences/Jewish people being generally most successful class in society and didn't have the racial aspect.
BTW there are at least 4 million non Jews that also died in the concentration camps. So all together over 11 million . Every last person has to be remembered!!🙏🙏🌹🌹🙏🙏
Wow, this is an amazing presentation. Saw so many things in a new perspective here
Completely off the topic, but you are holding together really well for 70 years old.
It happened because people gave in to fear...and gave up their rights for security...exactly what is happening today
Wow hes speaking of exactly what is happening today in this administration..
And yet we do nothing!!!!!!!!!!
@@leskobrandon4518 Remember that historian said - "History never repeats itself, people always do".
All government is equally dirty.
You are nuts how dare you compare the holocaust to anything like a vaccine.
This mess has been planned as far back as the start of this country . Old british money founed this country and never left . This is just a throw off sister country.
As a jew that grew up with survivors, sadly It is clear to me that We have forgotten.. and wow, great lecture and a warning for what's going on right now
As a Jew that grew up with those people is it true Hitler held a grudge against the German Jews because they sold out Germany in the first world war? When the World Jewry declared war on Germany and the German Jews worked with them and helped them from inside the country?
Evil and anti Semitism is infecting our government. Pelosi does NOTHING to stop it in the many members of the US CONGRESS- Rashida Tlaib, AOC, and the vile EVIL REPUGNANT Ilhan Omar, to name a few. I am deeply concerned & frightened for our country!
Pelosi is a zionist and Israel has a massive nuclear arsenal what else do they need the whole middle east
BTW Muslims and Jews are semitic people what's the difference
@@hapatim28 You are an echo of The Nazi.
Henry hills-- learned alot thank you sir... That is a so sad for wemen and children or any human to ever had to go through past future or present...my heart goes out to all of the survivers of the Holocaust and all who were lost
Very good lecture on the Holocaust. As unpleasant as it is, we must remember the innocent victims of this dark chapter. We also learn to reject Anti-Semitism and other forms of hatred against people , whether they are Jewish or black or however different they are from us. Every human being is made by God, whether black, white, regardless of creed, belief, race, or gender. It is our responsibility to love one another, and to treat each other the way we want other people to treat us, as Jesus Christ commanded us to do.
the god of jews muslims christians commanded ABRAHAM 2 kill his son ...????
All humans are made by single cell organisms and natural selection. But yes your right that we all need to accept those of all races and cultures
Would you like to address your well meaning words and ideas to the Zionist right wing party in Israel !
@@harpar1028 If you are going to tell a story, tell the WHOLE STORY. Jehovah STOPPED Abraham from sacrificing his son. Jehovah was testing Abraham's loyalty. 😳😳😳
@@liesdamnliesandstatsweird1934 Exactly, three rules of properly exegetical Bible reading: CONTEXT, CONTEXT, CONTEXT
Am I really so crazy to think this is happening again? Maybe in a different form and with different outcomes.. But am I?
Not at all crazy it's definitely headed for it quickly if people don't wake up and say enough is enough!
You're not crazy but correct
@@paulie6709 sadly Pauly.... sadly... Im already being villified and ostracized.. family have already denied me visiting them. Simply because I'm not at all confident that the currently available vaccines are effective enough to convince me to get them.
Yes unfortunately you are, but just stop consuming media and all these fantasies will end.
@@JanaBuvari vaccines are not the problem , it's anti immigrant , anti homosexuality , anti women , anti peaceful freedom of speech , anti voting rights , anti race etc. Vaccines save lives , more often than not , the others cause destruction of a civilised country.
I learned so much. Thank you for doing this talk. I will look for your book right away.
The answer for the question “why” needs to be looked at from a deep psychological perspective. What is it about human psyche that allowed them to think this kind of annihilation is ok? What allowed them to be bystanders and choose to let it go on? The power of persuasion....
Answer SIN
we live in a fallen world since garden of Eden
Satan roams to and from seeking non believers in Christ.
Every veteran of war will tell you that they were conditioned to view the 'enemy' as inhuman which makes it easier to kill. The same thing happened when Nazis demonized the Jews.
Godless-period.
You cannot blame it on Christian theology. In fact, it is the opposite. Hitler corrupted religion and weaponized it.
@@David.lovesU Satan loves to feast on Christians as well.
Though perhaps on a somewhat smaller scale, we face similar ethical dilemmas regarding partners left behind in Afghanistan. I was stunned when the speaker said what America could have done for the Jews was help more of them get out in the 1930s when they had a chance. Over the last 10 years, America understaffed and under resourced the effort to process Special Immigrant Visas for qualified Afghans who had assisted NATO during the intervention. Similar anti-immigrant forces that were active in the 1930s are present in the 21st century. Now we face dilemmas for hundreds if not thousands of Afghans that we should have helped when circumstances were better to do so.
I wish they were able to be helped, it makes me feel bad because I know so many people in Iraq and Syria who would die to be here, I am a Christian from Mosul who immigrated here. It bothers me more than any thing when people come here illegally ans take the spots of those who could be helped. I love America and the American people who carry American values, but its the American political elites that do this.
America should have never been involved in the middle east to begin with.
@@g00glechr0me8 Without intervention, it will be much harder for people to change their lives for the better: they can do without their religion and theocratic-dictators ;-)
@@JohnStopman let someone else do it then...taxpayers from another country (America) should never be forced to pay for anything for another country...let people VOLUNTEER to help as it should be....its NEVER good when its forced on people in the form of taxes and spending someone else's money.
@@g00glechr0me8 You don't care? What do you think to get? Lower income tax when we stop funding actions that should put an end to war?
Very informative lecture & also a great presenter. I must say I learned many new things about the Holocaust. Thank you Peter.
What is this Holocaust of what you speak I do not know
Incredible lecture. I also wanted to emphasize how impressive the speaker's response to the critical question. She was late, missed some points, asked too much, but clearly spoke from a place of legitimate emotion; his response was reasonable and empathetic. We need that on inconceivable dialogues like the Holocaust.
The Holodomor was worse. At least some lived. This HORROR comes from the banking families.
Thank you for this very important educational presentation!
Im AMAZED that this comment section is open 😂
Just going to head to new and see whats going on
Amazing Speech i could listen to Peter Hayes all night,thank you.
This is a fantastic presentation. I’ve been studying this for over 20 years. I’m not a historian but I’ve read books about it and watched a lot of documentaries and this had a ton of info I’d never heard before.
I’m always reminded of that line by Shia in the movie Fury! He is talking to Norton and say’s, “wait till you see” to which Norton replies, “what” and Shia says “what one man can do to another, just way till you see” 😳 that was a powerful line about the Holocaust and just the war in general! 😢
I live in northern Illinois and we saw a very good movie when I was in grammar school. We needed our parent’s permission to see it. It was very graphic and left an impression on me that I still remember til’ this day.
What’s the name of the movie?
Yes i saw these movies at home it was unbelievable
Sounds like Schindler’s list
@@ecc2924 SOLDIER BLUE
Ukra did 70 % of Holocaust
Incredibly illuminating.
This is very very important video. Hence please add English subtitles for wider audience. Thank you
Great presentation and I have heard quite a few over the years as well. Much appreciated.
This describes exactly the situation we find ourselves in today :(
I don’t think is exactly as you mentioned and i think is very very disrespectful for all the people who died, lost their homes family and EVERYTHING they had in the holocaust. Please don’t be insensate.
No
True Jesse and the propaganda now is 100 times worse than Hitler's and on a global scale. His dreams are happening globally.
@@gabsv4412 The ideology is the exact same. The end result - the same. Don't make the mistake of thinking 'this time, it'll be different'. If anything, recognising this, and making damn sure it can't happen again (which, clearly - it can - people have go along with the easy narrative of lockdowns and social control during Covid) is the ultimate sign of respect for the murdered of the Holocaust.
@@SolitaryReaper666 Well debated, sir! ;)
Great presentation, highly fresh with information, no repeating from other docs, books, documentaries
What was the name of the book you mentioned to read to learn about the Holocaust from the beginning to the end, top to bottom? I can not understand what the title is. Thank you. It's at the 9 minute mark.
Exodus by Leon Uris was a fantastic historic novel that covers most of Europe and Palestine pre and post WW II.
"Yet even today there are those who want to forget the past. Worse still, there are even those filled with such hate, total hate, that they want to erase the Holocaust from history. Those who deny the Holocaust are an accomplice to this horrible evil."
- DJT's speech writer
Why would you cite a writer for a would-be fascist? There are thousands of people who have said exactly the same and were not employed by a horrible human lik DJT
trump is similar to trump I suspect he’s read mein kamf several times based on his language and behavior and those that enable him are like minded. Very dangerous and fatal to many.
@Who am I ? No one! Except someone with DEEP psychological issues.
The ongoing genocide in Palestine/Gaza , which the Congress (beholden to the Israeli lobby)in an ultimate sadistic irony declared as an attack by the (besieged , beleaguered )Palestinians on Israel and it’s people , closing their eyes to the staggering disparity in casualties and the sheer and lopsided advantage that Israel has in terms of weaponry and resources .What’s true of the Congress is true of the US establishment generally and an odd voice which dares to call out Israel for it’s brutal atrocities is forthwith branded as anti-Semitic , and faces assault from all sides , with death threats and other social and financial overtures .
@Who am I ? No one! Get help.
Another explanation of "How" .....but not "Why"
He does discuss it a bit around 11:55
Bill: People want to fit in. If the majority of people (especially under the banner of authority) say it's OK. Most folks will comply and avoid conflict. The government can seriously scare any citizen. People tend to be tribal and the herd instinct is strong. A survival mechanism ...I suppose. Sadly, I suspect morality has little to do with it.
A fundamental human trait is to want someone to look down on. Every nation has appealed to that basic need and dehumanised and belittled their enemies in war. the people in the lowest strata of any society have to look to foreigners. In the case of the Jews, not a nation but a stateless diaspora, there was an established history of their official low status throughout the world, including Britain. For an introduction to that history try a book called From Prejudice to Genocide.
Keep looking... God will give you the answer.
“Knock, and the door shall be opened.”
That is if you are sincerely looking...
Rather than looking to be ‘right.’
Mans hungar for power!! Evil hearts!!
Can anyone tell me which book is mentioned on the begginig ? Also, I can not see english subtitles ....
Thank you so much for your insight clarity especially in the lack of ability of united states air forces and army air corps. I my self being a military child and service personal. Never understood why and was suspicious of the way it was never made clear. It is a blessing to the state of my life that I understand this so clearly.
God bless you for your support and the way of explaining the way it was.
Camps for unvaccinated in Australia, seems a step down this path again...
@@lcunningham1776
We have camps as well. Aussie or America.
@@lcunningham1776 I WILL SHOOT 2 K I L L
An excellent and one of the most scholarly talks on this subject. It is incredibly essential for all of us to remind ourselves about this unprecedented tragedy. But sadly many poweful politicians are using the same method of spreading the hatred against their target groups.... hope we never see this kind of horror to unfold again.
It's happening in Xinjiang and for the most part, the world is silent.
¹Peter Hayes forgot to mention one important fact: Polish government opened its borders and invited half a million of Jewish refugees who were persecuted by Stalin. Mr.Hayes evidently did not watch feedler on a roof. 500.000 Jewish refugees Poland accepted! A young couple from Feedler arrived in Krakow.
DONALD TRUMP IN THE USA
@Carl Ferrigno let me see: God, guns, guts...right? I'm just wondering what kind of God, or more to the point, which God would sanction the use of guns on another soul?
@Carl Ferrigno They are not. That’s an exaggeration by right wingers
I’ve learned so much. Incredibly scary to think that there are people who will repeat similar violence and those people live inside the boundaries of the US.
Would be terrifying to see society lose its mind .
What happened to my post censorship?
@@toddrose3739 wtf
Good point. People do not realize that America is rallying around The New World Order, gaining support from all the major corporations, media and Hollywood. The NWO contains a major depopulation agenda and is, in fact, a Neo=Nazi approach.
You are absolutely right . Witness the murder the mayhem and the sadistic, senseless destruction that was rained on the beleaguered and blockaded Gaza Strip which could only respond with crude and primitive fireworks .
I'm sorry...the Jewish lady said that Jewish bolshevicks were fighting for human rights...dear God, please forgive her because she doesn't know what she's saying... sheer insanity
She had so very little time to explain herself and her thoughts. She was also so nervous and a little overwhelmed, she moved tangentially accross different aspects I found her difficult to follow. I would watch a video on what she had to say, from her perspective.
@@paoemantega8793 Bolsheviks were equally cruel and murderous as German Nazis. The difference is Soviets won’t the war and Germany lost.
@@natalias50 I agree on that.
@@natalias50 No, they were not, otherwise the USSR wouldn't have had any population at all. One of most important reasons of the USSR victory was the fact that the Germans were much worse than the Soviets
I am 83 years old and I have always questioned why this happened and was. Always told that they did not know. Now I understand this better and still question my fore generational leaders how could we have helped these people! I regret this could happen and still hear people say they don’t like or hate the Jewish people. I love Gods chosen people,
No longer God's chosen
Why no one asks if Palestinian people now deserve to be punished and apartheid by gov of Israel!?!
Are you that different from those who closed eyes on holocaust?!
@Cinde everyone should love their neighbour, no matter what their religious belief or lack of same.
Is history getting ready to repeat itself here !
thankyou
What he said at 18:00-18:30 mark is EXACTLY what has happened in the USA today, and continues to go on. We say, "NEVER AGAIN! ", BUT IT IS HAPPENING AGAIN, RIGHT BEFORE OUR EYES!
Been going on in America last 400+ years in America. Hitler copied their ways
I have been saying the same thing for months Nazi playbook just different word play
@@christinavance1128 Hitler's America model book tells all. I haven't read it all yet
@@chrissmith6774 is that the name of the book “ Hitler America “?
@@christinavance1128 Hitler's American model. United States and the making of nazi race law
By James Q. Whitman
Whites in America refuse to acknowledge any of our past so I'm forcing it down their throat and I have a way. Racism is at an ALL TIME HIGH
incredible presentation.
The speaker at 1.09 has a mighty axe to grind. Her disruptiveness does her no favours.
I am so grateful for the scholarly dedication of Professor Hayes and of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Thank you for this brilliant lecture.
people living in glasshouse shud refrain from throwing stones
The main reason for understanding the Holocaust is to prevent it from happening again. Looking at todays Genocide this has not been very successful. There can be just one explanation for this sad phenomenon: the power structures of the last couple of centuries have not changed one bit.
It already is happening again in Palestine
America made rest of the World hate blacks as well
Some lady I talk with gave me a bible tract about the genocide killing of babies in the womb to be in the millions. Just something we should all repent to God for in my homeland I love u.s.a. but I don't like this indifference to a failure to protect the most innocent lives.
@@chrissmith6774 Not quite. The Democrats fell long ago, and their successor has kept the name and skin.
Much like "sheep's clothing", they appear to pass freely through the populace, and spread disease, creating hatred among them, like rabies.
The populace winds up as masses of "mad" animals, who attack anything in their sight.
Divide, segregated, pit against each other to decimate the ranks, conquer, eliminate the survivors as needed until they are no longer a threat.
@@aq1184 oh? How so?
Excellent lecture, thank you so much.
Very insightful and informative for all to listen and learn about things they didn’t know 📚💯 !!!!
we are all human beings.. love is the thing that only matters.. hate destroys everything we cherish..
Thank you so much. I needed to learn this. A tribute to a loving aunt who taught me to look
I recently went to a national museum and I walked around in the museum with my people from the program
If we don't pay close attention to this question now, right now, we may not have the privilege of that chance later.
Exactly why I'm here.
Brilliant speaker, thank you.
On a different note, I think the quarter system is great at university, On a separate note, I went to a quarter system University and loved it, I was always very grateful to be on a quarter system rather than semester.
This is an amazing documentary..I have heard it more than once. It's so sad that this even happened. No one deserves to be treated like that. Peter Hayes explains it all in simple terms.
Don't fret none of it is true it's all just sympathy begging and very very bad historical analysis never forget that it was the communist who actually managed to seize Germany and almost destroyed it that was the impetus for what came next they were traders to their nation
Is this, or has this a beginning here and now in America
?I see it.
With Trump? Absolutely. Trump is tapping into the insecurities and fear of white America. It's disgusting.
@@mdaze9753 one more thing you say Trump's doing this kind of thing what about Biden saying he won't do anything about the Chinese killing and putting uighur Muslims into death camps? We have monster in China that needs to be dealt with! biden is in love with china trump had the balls to go at them on the worlds stage.....so say what u will...you are wrong🤦♂️
@@mdaze9753 Trump has been totally vindicated as we see the hate-filled and hate-inspiring regime we are experiencing now in the US.
@@ryanbratoc You could learn about China, and what kind of monster it has.
Biden is a total puppet an shell of a broken shell. His VP is disowned publicly by her father for shaming the Jamaican people.
By default is Trump good? Maybe? I don’t know. However, Trump has had a chummy relationship with the killing Clintons. He spent time with the Rockefeller’s puppet Henry Kissinger? Did Trump owe a favor to big bank for bankruptcy forgiveness? Why wasn’t any of the swamp drained ? Could it be one big show of political theater? The vaccines are very controversial yet no leadership has taken a stand for more research or vaccine companies to be financially responsible for any injury....
I see the NWO aka UN as globalization of Nazis.
The question of why this happenned is answered in several of the comments below and on CZcams in general; ignorance, unquestioning obedience, hatred, intolerance, entitlement and prejudice to name just a few.
Wow! Thank u for this information. The elderly lady was just emotional and yet cruel in calling u superficially. Great presentation.
Yes, she came with an agenda.
A well presented and insightful presentation of your research. Thank you. And yes, the problem and protagonists were more than just one evil man. So many stood as bystanders and did not act, many from fear and many more from indifference.
What research? Go read an actual research.
It is really fine to you that there is literally zero proofs and only "proof" is eyewitnesses that were busted for lies time and time again over decades and decades?
Well ... talking about people pretending not seeing what was happening in the Nazi Germany, just try Rwanda genocide (1994). I don't know why but I do remember the news on TV saying two tribes were fighting each other. Just that.
Absolutely and maybe things like that are still happening we are just not hearing about them
The England Catholics were out there and owned the Africans as slaves and also some of the other ethnicity of Catholics were and are still in Africa as well because they have taken over the diamond mines and other valuable resources of Africa. They have forced the Africans in slavery to work the diamond mines and they are searched when their work day is done and if even one small diamond is found in the hem of their clothing they are severely beaten or slaughtered and that is why they are called blood diamonds.
The Hutus and the Tutsis yes. Right on.
@@greensorrel6860 sadly it’s not “maybe” , horrible atrocities are happening right now
@@decruzyserao6994 yes at least 4 countries in 1 year have reliably reported local genocide. I can think of 1 or 2 that can be assumed although no word is getting out about it.
Why didn't they show the Dr. Seuss illustrations? They were the only illustrations the cameras didn't show us.
Dr Sues is apparently racist and has been canceled. I am also apparently racist because I can't see how I was indoctrinated by the good Dr. Instead of learning to read the new generation needs to learn about gender dysphoria.
Copyright
Thank you for this very informative presentation.
Ever since I first saw this picture with the little boy with his hands held up,I get a lump in my throat and tears down my cheeks.This made me renounce my Christian faith.
Sounds familiar about how a person was voted in!
As a mild criticism, some people will think you're talking about Trump, others will think you're talking about Biden. That's where we are today. It's so hard to be clear in comments!
Paperclip that..
They take turns
They take turns
What about that woman who lived it? I hope you have her do a book.
We are in similar days right now. Fight with words against the evil ideas pushed forward by top politicians or ‘build back better’ etc. Fight hard for freedom decency goodness by speaking up and defending free speech.
Yes Sir!
Donald trump is the new Hitler the republican party is the New as
@@pascalgonsalves1499 what!!!? Nonsense, fuehrer Biden is in charge of the USA or at least he’s the front man, along with the mad laughing clown of Harris
The ongoing genocide in Palestine/Gaza , which the Congress (beholden to the Israeli lobby)in an ultimate sadistic irony declared as an attack by the (besieged , beleaguered )Palestinians on Israel and it’s people , closing their eyes to the staggering disparity in casualties and the sheer and lopsided advantage that Israel has in terms of weaponry and resources .What’s true of the Congress is true of the US establishment generally and an odd voice which dares to call out Israel for it’s brutal atrocities is forthwith branded as anti-Semitic , and faces assault from all sides , with death threats and other social and financial overtures .
Delusion you suffer not to mention maga and the hate filled clown and incompetent Trump.
Great lecture, thank you Peter
The sound is too low. Thank you for the video and looking into this sound issue.
The truth is told by who lived this history, not who wrote it.
Thank you. I learned so much and now understand more deeper what, when and why China did almost same thing to Tibetans.
Uighers (sp?)
Or the US to Americans
KKKKK you are watching media too much!!
Are Tibetans demonized?
I think that perhaps war itself made the Holocaust easier, things more "invisible"
How sad that my deaf daughter cannot follow this which would give her so many answers to her questions regarding her history - Please, is it not possible to allow for sub-titles. So many of the deaf are denied important information such as this excellent podcast.
Same reason America is.falling now...
I agree “Lo”!
I DO fear all too often that America is on our way into full blown communism 😔😡
@@Larsen3306 not communism but freedom is not like it was..
@@loismayette2747 nope, wrong, the USA is well on the road to full blown communism.
@@feolender2938 More like full blown fascism...
@@feolender2938 communism is the Luciferian economy
Which one are you referring to?
The Japanese one?
The Russian one?
The Chinese one?
The American one?
The French one?
The British one?
The Cambodian one?
What about the Native American one?
Good point !
India....Africa....King Leopoldo in the Congo....my god this is very depressing....to see it like this.....
@@andresmonreal8521 Or the Palestinians
What about the Armenian genocide in 1915 during the WWI. The holocaust would not have happened if the Armenian genocide was recognized and the Turks were held accountable. In Hitlers words: who remembers the Armenian genocide?
Is there is transcript of the lecture??
I’m reading the comments and it never fails, there’s always one or two geniuses who have all the answers. Professor Hayes has clearly dedicated many, many years of his life researching topics surrounding the Holocaust. After delivering a brilliant lecture, he kindly opens the floor to questions! Questions not critics. Those of you so called intellectuals whose comments are uncomplimentary and malevolent, step out of your mother’s basement and take a deep breath. Professor, thank you for the continued service you provide to those of us eager to learn and those with a keen interest in comprehension.
Agreed, Stockton California. The ignorance of some of these comments are mind blowing, especially considering the deep scholarly research represented in this lecture.
In other words no one should question!
It happens every time with every subject. There are always those who know more than anyone else. Does Donald Trump come to mind? Thank you for your comment. I agree with you 100%.
I agree 200 %,always a Karen in the crowd unfortunately.This lecture,was very informative and well done , Bravo!
The only real experts of the Holocaust are those who lived through it!
This was my third time learning from this excellent lecture and teacher.......it took twice for me to digest the information, then this rime to really understand. This is THE best, by far, understanding of why and how the terrible Holocaust happened......and in my 65 years, I’ve seen many.
Thank you, Professor Hayes, from an ER/Trauma RN who could never quite get it....why the highly educated and culturally significant Germans did this. You keep your audience very interested, and your kind “handling” of the (there’s always one) Arguer was quite impressive. May God richly bless you and yours, Praise Jesus for a gifted teacher. 🕊💖✝️✡️🙏🙋♀️🌟
I also think that the Bosnian War should be mentioned to illustrate how ethnic can and has happened since to show to the younger generations that this isn't just something that happened a long time ago.
How bout them peoples in Rwanda Hootsis and Tootsies hacking each other to death or Pol Pot in Cambodia trying to out do Chairman Mao in death per capita.
I learned so much from this lecture. Thank you Peter!
u must live in a well
I just didn't think this was the type of speech to b disagreeing with or angry about... that 1 lady was upset and I really couldn't figure out why ...
Just a big ego.
It’s puzzling
Palestine that’s why
The Palestinians deserve their homeland.. how can the Jews justify that the land is solely there’s? As if the Palestinians just immigrated and showed up. Well they did show up! More than 2K years ago!!
@@michaelluna1968 and there it is