Syed Muzammil Shah on Political Science, Journalism and Philosophy.
Vložit
- čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
- Journalist, News Analyst, Anchor, Political Scientist, Philosopher Lover.
Twitter: SyedMuzammilOFL?s=20
Facebook: / syedmuzammilofficial
CZcams: / @syedmuzammilofficial7067
00:00 Introduction or Lack thereof
00:12 Educational Background
01:31 The Role of Institutional Education (Chomsky)
02:35 How to remain a student in this educational system?
03:39 Thinkers are born not furnished.
06:36 Hitler and Nietzsche, Anti Semitism, Marxism.
11:54 'I don't follow Nietzsche thats not the point'
13:54 Problem with ultimate solutions.
17:50 The theory of Everything Futile Endeavour?
23:36 The benefit of Utopian Ideals and Practicality of current mediums and Politics
27:13 The role of propaganda
33:48 Skepticism and Curiosity
36:03 The rise of Celebrity politicians and entertainers.
39:49 How to keep journalistic integrity
43:51 Combating Right Wing Radicalism.
48:05 Fighting Defeatism and Nihilism
51:00 The unsuitable Truth.
54:26 Is morality Innate?
01:01:53 How to create a Democratic individualistic Society.
01:05:21 Why Bad News Spreads more than Good News.
01:07:21 The TV News Casting pitfalls.
01:17:06 George Carlin and Syed Muzammil Shah Life Parallel
01:18:32 Resistance by TV Channel
01:20:06 Machiavellian Tactics
01:23:15 Nation State and the Pashtun Movement
01:25:53 Pan-islamism
01:29:04 Israel-Palestine Conflict, Kashmir-Pakistan India Conflict
01:33:06 How china is treating muslims
01:35:20 A glimmer of hope
I am an Indian hearing first time you program. Really very impressed. Pakistan needs young intelligent educated people like you both to bring your nation out of the present situation
thank you for inviting a great person Muzamil i am Pakistani Christian and i started my youtube chanel to see Muzamil and keep doing positive work
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ixbro agr aap confuss ho to aap beech k ho na idhr k na udhr k
@@DingDong-lh4ixAho jo banda sach bolo woh islam ke kelaaf lagta hai aap jahilo ko
@@DingDong-lh4ixtjodi common sense ayegj to auto mein non Islamic ho jayega 😂
@@DingDong-lh4ixya centrist term keb search ki google pay?
When minds are nurtured out of the box. Exceptional thought process, loved it.
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ix hr jga yhi copy paste ker rahay ho😂 pehlay comment mai jwab do a kay😎
@@DingDong-lh4ixactually tum hud confuse ho, na idr k na udr k, islamic history parho to pata lagy enhi baaton pa 1400 saal pehly imam hussain (a.s) ny apny pury khandan ko zibbah krwa dia tha ur zibbah krny waly tmhary jese confuse muslims thy.
@@DingDong-lh4ix Agreed to some extent
I am from India...I watch both of you guys videos...today's podcast is best one.. I'm watching it at 3:34am
better than Ind vs Wi 😂
@@balajzafarr ab man hi nhi hota cricket dekhe
Public speakers in 🇵🇰 are generally ignorant about history, philosophy, or any complex subject.
Here, @SyedMuzammilOFL on @Mooroo4 podcast just butchers history as he goes.
This is the reason I'm teaching a free beginner-level course on global history based on good academic 📚.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
Most of his followers are RSS HINDUTVAs and Pakistani Liberal
hahhahah dream xi kitt 😢😢
Two of my favourite Pakistani CZcamsrs together. That’s treat for my eyes
Muzammil sir has changed my life
Muzammil beta I am so very proud of your independent thought process, your analytical and logical approach. Wish more of us start using our brains independently but also logically and sensibly.
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ix islam is already outdated sir
@@21stcenturylucifer ye ap ki soch hai.. outdated to wo marzai or liberals hain jin ko koi or kam nai mila to muslmano k bhais main ghoss k muslmano ki buraian karny lag gyyyy 😂😂😂 in marzai or libreals kooton ki jaga gatar main hai. Simple 🤫
@@DingDong-lh4ix Islam is a joke
@@cauliflowerhead2735 your mother is a joke 🤫
Muzammil is such an inspiration for young rational minds out there ! ❤❤❤
No.He is centrist. Na idhr ka na odhr ka.
Muzammil is such a well read 📚 individual ! In this day and age when u hardly meet youth who are into books, muzammil is a breath of fresh air and an inspiration for so many
نطشے
czcams.com/play/PLCiuv4p_-l1VedpnCnIkZ_ESNQToilV9s.html
He is not youth.
Why cant he speak in proper Urdu or proper English?
Kaala angraiz isiko kehtay hain.
@@becooldontfreezBhai youth or not he definitely is destroying youth minds by making them believe there was no good in east and presents atheist philosophers as the solution....
Old Urdu saying for his victims:
اندھوں میں کانڑا راجہ
No.He is centrist. Na idhr ka na odhr ka.
Im a jewish pakistani , living in Zurich ... Pan islamism is the reason my grand parents were harassed and they finally had to leave karachi in the early 80's...
Books mentioned in the Podcast
1- The greatest minds and ideas of all time ~ Will Durant
2- The Story of Civilization ~ Will Durant
3- The Geography of Thought ~ Richard Nisbett
4- Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media ~ Noam Chomsky
5- Brain Droppings ~ George Carlin
Amusing Ourselves to Death ~ Neil Postman
Thus Spoke Zarathustra ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
Nietzsche and the Nazis ~ Stephen Hicks
Pakistan: A Hard Country ~ Anatol Lieven
The German Ideology by Marx
Public speakers in 🇵🇰 are generally ignor@nt about history, philosophy, or any complex subject.
Here, @SyedMuzammilOFL on @Mooroo4 podcast just butchers history as he goes.
This is the reason I'm teaching a free beginner-level course on global history based on good academic 📚.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
Rise and fall of the third Reich by William L. Shirer
Here, @SyedMuzammilOFL on @Mooroo4 podcast just butchers history as he goes.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
Two of the young Pakistanis, who give us hope.
More power to you guys !!!
✊️👊🤛🤜
Hope or disappointed?
Hope it is.
Muzammil is a kind of surgeon we need very badly. He gives you sour pills but these medicines based on facts and rationality are very important and better than those sweet lollipops, which are based on lies, falsehood, & self deception.
Mooroo's tolerance for the opinions of his guests is admirable.
@@NiazHJafri sour or biased. Trust muzamil is not in the position to give sour pills to anyone. He is nothing but busted sheep.
Their is no hope in kuran. Don't fool people 😅😂
260k views on this video and ducky daily gets million views. This summarises Pakistan’s intellectual growth.
Syed muzammil shah us 1000000 times better than Ducky Bhai 😢😊😅😂
When two of your ideals meet and reiterate their ideas. Both are gems. thanks for keeping our quest for knowledge alive. ❤😊
No.He is centrist. Na idhr ka na odhr ka.
@@DingDong-lh4ix hr jga yhi copy paste ker rahay ho😂 pehlay comment mai jwab do a kay😎
@@DingDong-lh4ixahe kathmule har jgh gndu dal rha hai top ka hai kya 😂😂😂😂
Christians are the most confused people on earth. They can not decide who is real god😂😂.
What a beautiful Podcast.
So much to learn & self improvement.
Thank you Mooro ❤
Nice to see atleast two sane people having frank conversation in Pakistan, who see the truth and not blinded by religion. Lots of love from India.
This is one step away from the rotting Pakistani mindset but still within the 'Stockholm Syndrome'.
I wonder do they really not realize that they have literally destroyed Urdu/Hindi by constantly, relentlessly mixing English words. Might seem minor to you but in social/psycho-behavioral sciences there is a reason for this syndrome.
If they were using only English, I would know its for international reach, but you see its not that its plain old S-Syndrome.
Why do you think these guys did not find any ideals in eastern philosophy ?
Nothing personal, just sharing my thoughts.
😂 अपने देश में पुरा धर्म ने नाम पे तमाशा चल रहा है ऑर् हमें पाकिस्तान मे liberals चाहिए 😂
Our relegion open our eyes not blinds us.
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio..
Muzamil is 'Sane People' 😂
Kia he khob ho wo achi trha philosophy parh lay. Baywaqof waqti CZcams or jahil logon ki Wah Wah sun K parhnay say bhe gaya. . Sad
❤❤I love every podcast of Muzamil. Such a deep thoughtful person. Save this man at all cost if journalism had to survive in Pakistan.
He is.not.a journalist just try to be intellect..by using words qoutes thats it...he is.not.doing true journalism..thats y dont worry he is save
@@umairmalik7419yea true journalist is Imran riaz and sabir Shakir?😂
@@umairmalik7419 he is working with bol network
Love this guy muzzamil, keep it up up brother, you are doing an excellent job.
Muzammil is very bold person . He is not of this world. Huge respect for him. May God bless you Muzammil and keep you safe.
Syed muzammil is so sharp and make us think ❤
I am an indian from up currently preparing for medical studies
Once I randomly found muzzamils channel and after listening him since past few months I am very impressed by him and I also got a way to analyse things without biased views and I give a lot of credit to him for this
No.He is centrist. Na idhr ka na odhr ka.
Ye centrist hai. Na idhr ka na odhr ka. Ye logon ko islam sy door kar raha.. bacho in jaise logon sy... ye kisi b bat ko kisi b tariqy sy sahi sabit kar k.logon ka point of view change karty hain. Ta k ziada sy ziada logon ki soch islam sy hata k ose angraizon ki trhan modern world k naam py zindagi guzarny py laga dain.. yehi to hai 5th genration war. Bachoo in sy pakstanio
Good luck for neet
Simply excellent. Based on facts, information and harsh truth.....
The most awaited podcast ever.
Mooroo you're the finest among All. Whatever you do it is always like no one can do better than you. Really blessed to have you among us.
Syed Muzammil is universally admired by all Indians who have listened to his views.
So much to learn from this podcast! Keep up the good work! Best wishes from India!
Exceptional podcast! Extremely thought provoking and informative!!
I love this man, he's the true personality 🙌🏻
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ix sahi
@@DingDong-lh4ix hr jga yhi copy paste ker rahay ho😂 pehlay comment mai jwab do a kay😎
@@khumaix sahi kay chahay pehlay comment vist ker aur daikh is bacharay ki phet kay jath mai ai howi hai😂
@@awaisahmed8095 han na copy paste kar k logon ko bta raha k ye marzai or libreals ki halat daikho.. muslmano k bhaisss main ghoss k muslmano ki buraisn kar rahy 😂😂😂😂 in kooton ki jaga gatar main hai.simple 🤫
Learn alot thanks for being such a nonbiase critics love for both of you ❤
This guy is the most sincere person I've ever seen
One of the best podcasts by Mooroo. Immensely meaningful and enlightening dialogue. Cleared most of my confusions on a personal level. Would look forward to more podcasts like this.
Love him. Very Informative thoughts. Great Podcast.
Thoroughly enjoyed. Thanks
Finally! Was waiting for this one
Love from india and I think he can definitely create an impact by his Excellent articulation and knowledge.syed muzammil shah should do more such podcasts.
You should focus on the madness going on in your own country first.
Pakistan is about to Collapse
@@tbh7436?
@@tbh7436 negativity at its peak.
@@tbh7436 madness in our country
bossdike jaake aata dundh pehle bheekari
Young scholars and intellectuals like Muzzamil and Mooro should form a society of intellectuals and start a channel with lectures and debates and key insights to enlighten our young people who will soon be building the future of our society. Keep it up young men ! You are making a great contribution 👏👏👏
Yes definitely, a society for all nutjobs. This guy is a narcissist , he is calling Iqbal a Pan-Islamist...proving that he has no clue about Iqbal and this is not me saying just search for Javed Iqbals interview on YT, three part and see yourself or even look at Dr. Mubarak Ali's works. Iqbal was never a Far Right nutjob as this guy constantly tries to portray.
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ix hr jga yhi copy paste ker rahay ho😂 pehlay comment mai jwab do a kay😎
very taught provoking and informative,
Two Best people in one frame❤❤🎉
A great podcast.🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Most awaited podcast ever!
Such a pleasure to hear you both speak. Fresh, good knowledge level, analytical and realistic! So refreshing to see such a good standard of discussion!
Muzammil...thoughts..rationality..respect from IN🇮🇳
Muzzamil is very articulate and clearly reads extensively. His research is deep and he makes so much sense 👏
Such individuals are a glimmer of hope amidst the bleak ignroance that prevails in this country. Bravo!
(The instant thing I did after listening to this podcast was to write a paragraph to my friend about how this and other podcasts changed my life. Therefore, I'd like to share it with you lot)
*How to change your life through listening to podcasts.*
Firstly, listening to podcasts has indeed changed my perspective on how to shape things and form an opinion throughout my life. I have subjectively developed critical thinking through listening to podcasts. It has given me the power to think outside the box; the will to criticize if one opposes other's opinion peacefully and think rationally; debate on controversial issues so one can expand their knowledge; get to know more about *others* and not just get along with the cancel culture that has been going on. I love the idea of a "podcast" as it doesn't involve the political agenda of using mainstream media for their gain and the paradigm itself differs entirely from the news channels. Furthermore, It is unprecedented and this idea has been innovated in this decade or so. Consequently, I'd encourage others to watch productive podcasts about AI or the future. However, if you wanna go in deep I will suggest Syed Muzamil if you're intrigued to political science, Jordan B Peterson to learn about philosophy or religion, and Joe Rogan as I adore how he invites intellectual individuals on his podcast. Lastly, if you don't like to watch podcasts; take my word and read books. 💓
Twitter: @WR_Shani (if anyone wants to talk about it in detail)
Truth कोई भी सुनाएँ, शकून मिलता है, I Like it.
I feel so lucky to be inspired by such a critical mind like syed muzammil. Enjoyed alot the whole podcast and and not to be bored even for e second
Long awaited podcast by King
All hail Muzammil
Wow, watch complete video. You must have to say he is a gem of a person. Some of his words are just chilling, Learning video.
I like listening to Shri syed muzammil..... Extraordinary person.
He is a genuine intellectual person love to hear his thoughts.
Muzamil is a gem and belongs to the world , salute sir
I pray and Hope that these two flourish in their careers and continue to change the thought process of the majority of people
Very Insightful talk.
Some really thought provoking discussions moments in the podcast. Kudos to you both. Even though I didn’t fully agree with a couple of inferences but I could understand the logic behind it. The host was equally contributing to the discussion. Loved it. Thank you for this wonderful educational session.
Even in so called best universities of the world , questions are not encouraged. It totally depends on the teacher/professor. If you’re lucky you may get a passionate and good teacher who encourages questions and thinking out of the box
I as a doctor, who are perceived as so called most intellectual beings in our society, feeling literally dumbbb after listening to u guys😵💫
Just got a reality chk where i stand😶😶 and how much it will take to dive into these complex thoughts
A never ending process of learning
I disagree. They know very less when it comes to your field of expertise. For it to be known to you, you have to dive into their domain of interests or know what interests you!
Good point ..
@@hashamnasir8090
Everyone has expertise in their respective domains BUT I believe real magic comes out when a person dives into multiple domains and links/connects them.
I believe that would bring something enlightening for the world.
Just my 2 cents !
WOW, such brilliant people they both are and one thing I have the pleasure of clinking a selfie with Muzamil is still in my phone 😍😍
Syed muzammil shah's every word is PRECIOUS
Excellent interviewer, interviewee and interview
Public speakers in 🇵🇰 are generally ignorant about history, philosophy, or any complex subject.
Here, @SyedMuzammilOFL on @Mooroo4 podcast just butchers history as he goes.
This is the reason I'm teaching a free beginner-level course on global history based on good academic 📚.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
Enjoyed each minute of the podcast
Very Interesting conversation 💥
Can listen unlimited
Brilliant conversation. I don't agree with everything, but I love the ability to sit and talk after THINKING and LISTENING
The only Pakistani who give me hopes for the future is syed Muzammil. He sounds very rational and intellectual. I love him very much. Love from India ❤
I am a very ordinary, common man trudging along aimlessly, listlessly. I can't refrain myself from admiring something good. I have come to know Syed Muzammil Shah through the courtesy of CZcams only very recently, say just a few weeks ago. As a young man Muzammil is a highly analytical and realistically thoughtful and dynamic young personality. There are so few, just a very tiny fraction of even one percent of the whole lot. One can count on one's fingers. I believe that in a country like Pakistan one never expect to have a person like him at the helm of affairs. My salutations and commendations to Muzammil.
As an Indian, I can say that I love to hear Muzzamil Bhai. Pakistan should use such talents and its a pity that they don't. I have been hearing him for a long time and greatly respect him.
His every word is philosophy in itself ❤
out standing Podcast Mooroo.......... specific question and refined ans... Love to watch unstoppable😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
This is my first time commenting on this channel, and I absolutely adore this podcast. Muzammil Bhai is doing an exceptional job. However, the issue lies in our confined and pessimistic mindset. I wholeheartedly concur with Muzammil when he mentioned his father's perspective - 'vote for this and you can't do anything.' Taimoor Bhai, your dedication to delivering quality content is appreciated.
Our islamyat sir told us that people are converting students to "atheism" in Universities. they are scared of this growing numbers of critical thinkers and honestly it amuses me.
Qynat ko banane wale allah ko atheist ⚛️ se darr lagta he. 😅
Seriously , you called it critical thinking ... ??? he is just an athiest doesn't believe in god ... and thats it .... yeah his language ... i mean urdu polluted with english 😂😂
It was a great and intellectual discussion. There is so much to learn in this podcast. I'm a great fan of both speakers.
Ye centrist hai. Na idhr ka na odhr ka. Ye logon ko islam sy door kar raha.. bacho in jaise logon sy... ye kisi b bat ko kisi b tariqy sy sahi sabit kar k.logon ka point of view change karty hain. Ta k ziada sy ziada logon ki soch islam sy hata k ose angraizon ki trhan modern world k naam py zindagi guzarny py laga dain.. yehi to hai 5th genration war. Bachoo in sy pakstanio
Thanks for quality content ❤
Muzamil. One of the best pod cast it’s 4 20 am other side of the world and I am still watching.
Ye centrist hai. Logon ko baton maib laga k islam sy door karty hain.. bachoo in sy
What a great courageous young man with great knowledge and articulation. Love, regards and wishing immense strength to him. From a retired Indian Soldier 🙏🏻
Still islam seerah and Quran is the ONLY REAL and practical and result giving solution for EVERYTHING. Sad that muzzamil sahab understands NOTHING about islam. DUNIYA ki her cheez deeply samaj li per aik seerah or Quran nhi deeply samjhaa geya in bhai sahab say.
Islam say zaada Sikhaa hi kon skta hai baaki sub bhi or critical thinking etc bhi. Mujhay aaj tak JITNI critical thinking sikhaayi sirf islam nay or JITNI solutions or knowledge bhi di sirf ALLAH nain, islam nain. Islam is the ONLY solution to EVERYTHING
@@Random_Human321 yes like pedo nabi mohommad who marry a 6 year old girl and give permission for sex slavery and all the things thank god i become ex muslim.
@@Random_Human321 Yeah your country is pretty Islamic, how many people want to move to you country for a better future? How many Pakistanis want to leave Pakistan and move elsewhere? Even other Islamic theocracies have liberalised and moved away from Islamic teachings to be taken seriously by the world. If Islam was so great and provided such great solutions then all Islamic countries would be at par with America and Canada. Yet there are more muslims traveling to these countries for a better future than the other way round. Please stop embarrassing yourself!
@@cauliflowerhead2735Our country ain’t Islamic. No one’s actually following the book in this country, all they do is pray once in a week and then back to their westernised lifestyle. Some other countries like saudi are doing better but they aren’t even close to what our ummah was at one point when we were actually Muslims and following everything that Islam teaches us. We shall rise again, Insha’Allah.
@@Random_Human321 agar Aisa hai to saalo se bacche madarsa jate rahe log quran padhte rahe phir bhi pakistan ki aaj yeh halat kyon? yeh simple sa sawal aaj tak koi nhi de paya bas bahane marte hai
Half of the nation would not even understand the level of knowledge and wisdom both of them are spreading i wish one day we as a whole nation could understand such quality content.......
😂😂😂
Public speakers in 🇵🇰 are generally ignor@nt about history, philosophy, or any complex subject.
Here, @SyedMuzammilOFL on @Mooroo4 podcast just butchers history as he goes.
This is the reason I'm teaching a free beginner-level course on global history based on good academic 📚.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
Oh yeah. Exactly nation cant understand his lies and how he twists the truth...
Here, Syed Muzammil on Mooroo podcast just butchers history as he goes.
This is the reason I'm teaching a free beginner-level course on global history based on good academic 📚.
The absurd ideas that "Greeks" (idk what was he referring to? Sparta, Athens, or Macedonia?) developed "critical thinking" because geographically they are open, and that Afghanistan is conservative because it is geographically landlocked is total garbage.
1. The geographical category of "Afghanistan" is a little more than 100 years old.
2. The region we call Afghanistan today has occupied the centre stage of the world for 3,000 years.
3. The Silk Roads, the organic trade routes that connects Eastern Pacific with the Mediterranean is the region where the greatest civilizations of the world were born and flourished (Mesopotamia, Banylonian, Persia empires)
These trade routes are 3,000 years old.
)):map
4. The northern region of Afghanistan has always been a flourishing centre because it is situated along these trade routes. All the materials from the East or West crossed modern-day Afghanistan.
5. And contrary to the nonsensical claim, Afghanistan had absorbed the influences of many great civilizations of the past.
The Greek culture, Buddhism, Judaism, Christianity and Islam.
Even today there are 9th century Graveyards with Hebrew inscriptions on them.
)).Map
6. This region through which the Silk routes passes have been the center of the world for millenia.
The rise of the western European nation-states is a recent phenomenon and quite an unexpected one.
7. Plus, the category of Europe itself is a problem as it is a newly invented geographical category. Jean Monet aka The Father of Europe was the one who came up with this term. Before that it was Christendom where identity was primarily derived from religious affiliations.
8. Since the heart of Asia was the center of the world, it was natural that Alexander the Great would conquer Asia and not Western which offered nothing at all.
Here is the expedition of Alexander the Great. Cities like Alexandria, Kabul, Jalalabad were built by& named after him.
)))map n image
9. The Southern Europe is not organically related to Western Europe.
The British, French Germans are not the true heirs of Greek civilization, nor are they related to the Roman empire.
(THE SILK ROADS, p. 219)
))two images
On the construction of Europe as a category:
twitter.com/_titanslayer_/…
References
Europea, Norman Davis vol 1
The silk roads, Peter Frankopan
Europe (in theory), Roberto M. Dainotto
))..Three Images
Via Twitter
Serseh @_titanSlayer_
beta zaida hogia tum jahil hoge hum nahi.
One of the best podcasts I have seen..
.Wonderful Podcats
this podcast is such an amazing not just because of the answers. but the questions asked by a our new philosopher :).
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
@@DingDong-lh4ix hr jga yhi copy paste ker rahay ho😂 pehlay comment mai jwab do a kay😎
@@DingDong-lh4ix😂😂😂😂😂 bechara sabke tarle kr rha hai
@@amanohri7742 tm logon ki sachai bta raha... tatoooo ho tum log.. jalti hai tmhari 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@DingDong-lh4ix lo ji bs ye hai logical javab mene pucha tere islam ne esi kon si chij ijad ki hai jis se duniya ka fayda ho rha hai or tu bolta hai jalti hai abe sadka zakat pe jeene vali kaum se kya jalegi 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
Very informative Podcast ❤
My favorite Syed Muzzamil Shah 😊
Much appreciated 👍🏻
So happy to see sensibility in talk.U guys Muz doing gr8,best wishes.
Muzammil is a young boy having the thoughts of a legend ..
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
Thoughts of which legend?
@@DingDong-lh4ix Madrassa chhap spotted ..🙂🙂.
@@ymab-styleshoot mandir chahp spotted. Cow ka mootar peeny wala spotted.. koota marzai libreal spotted 😂😂😂😂
@@DingDong-lh4ixI saw your same comment on another video where he’s lecturing in Peshawar. Seems like you’re obsessed with him. And there’s nothing wrong in being a centrist except for cases like wars and crisis. He’s a journalist and it’s okay if he’s a centrist.
I have listened to many interviews of Muzammil, and assumed that that almost everything will be repeated, but kudos to the host for navigating to fresh topics and some of the stuff he hasn't discussed yet
exactly the same with me. I was not going to watch thinking lot of it will be repeat since I've seen pretty much all videos of Muzammil on youtube, but will watch now after reading your comment.
My favorite journalist Syey muzammil Shah
waited for so long for this collab!
I love to hear this podcast. I learned a lot from you, Mooroo. Our youth should watch this type of content to think critically and create their own opinions on any topic.
Great work 😄
Muzammil got a nice approach, quite in time with modern dynamics of how news works and how to disseminate rationality in an age of ifocracy, necropolitics, populism and cult politics.
Ye centrist hai.. na idhr ka na odhr ka.. ye sahi or ghalat k darmyan main khailty hain. Logon ko confuse kar k islam sy door karty hain.aise log ziada khatrnak hoty hain. Bachoo in sy pakistanio...
Amazing convo, more power to you SM
One of my Favourites! Thankyou for inviting him❤️
Muzammil is such a treat to listen
Syed Muzammil Shah is gem 💎👏👏
😊😊
Good one. Very interesting 👌
I love to hear this podcast.
Such a great time with you guys ❤️☝️
Two favs in one frame. Beautiful. Invite him again.
Love and respect from India. Intellectually orgasmic feast it was. Want more!
The Best Ever Podcast 👍
A true intellect ♥️
It was at least one hour short. I liked it but Junaid's podcast was the best of the lot.
the most knowledgable and criticl thinker unbiased anchor journalist etc person in Pakistan
Great rational & moderate approach towards problems