This doesn't seem live though (but JYP did sing live). I'm not saying they can't sing, I like their voices (specially Minju and Wonhee's), but their pitch here is perfect, live vocals never sound perfect when dancing no matter how great a vocalist is. Also, the volume of their mics is super stable (as if they had used a volume compressor) while JYP's volume fluctuates a lot more. Low notes are usually harder to hear when singers are singing live, but here they sound even clearer than the higher notes (in the case of ILLIT's members)... I highly doubt these are live vocals, and if they were, they were heavily edited after the performance.
low notes are difficult for moka in magentic tho (the part leading up to the "boy~") so...? i dont think its the vocal range thats the problem, but the tone of voice used in magnetic...
i think they struggle most with low notes.. moka struggled with it in magnetic and this song is also pretty low the issue probably is how hybe forces them to sing in a cute tone
@inimmz Yes there are different tones people sing in and different vocal ranges as well but it's very clear when someone strains their voices to sing a certain way and that's what I was saying. Also Illit's Criticism was necessary but not the hate. Especially when they are trying to do better. And stop telling random people on the internet to "Grow up" that's like the most childish thing you can say.
@@boredintrovert4282 they are absolutely not straining their voices to sing the way they do in a "cute voice" as you call it, im literally a professional singer i would know what a strained or forced voice sounds like and thats far from it. and why are you bringing up illits hate? which most of it was hate, not criticism because criticism is supposed to be helpful not telling them to die and disband because they had one bad live performance. the most childish thing you can say is not "grow up" babe be fr. its more childish to act like you know what youre talking about or making shady ass backhanded compliments.
@inimmz I gave my opinion here, and you were the one who replied with "grow up oml" so you were clearly the one being "shady". And idk who you are neither do you know who I am, so there really isn't any justification to ur "its more childish to talk abt something you don't know". And I brought the hate up because why else reply to a comment abt them doing better without the forced voice. Also, I'm not sure what "backhanded compliment" ur talking abt. Even on the survival show they were in it was clearly that they suit a stronger concept rather than the cutesy one, hence why it seems so forced. It was one comment of what I thought, and I don't feel the need to justify myself anymore, so i won't be replying to you after this.
why did they have to do cute concept? they fit girl crush/retro/or dark concept more, and retro fits minju’s cursive voice and moka’s deep voice fits dark concept/girl crush
@@minlvrs seriously. If they did retro and became basically 5th gen wonder girls they’d avoid the drama of being a “NewJeans” clone. They’d still get away with retro and y2k music but when you think about it there really isn’t any girl group doing what wonder girls did right now IMO
I always think that JYP is the best vocal teacher, his advises regarding the vocal and singing techniques work very well for all artists most of the time, they can sound very natural even for live performance, and that's why I admire him so much. I'm so happy that he gives all Illit members the chance to perform with their real voice, they sounds very natural, relax, and enjoying the stage ❤ And to be honest, Moka really nailed this performance... even with the small part only, her voice, facial expressions and her dancing lines and moves were totally beautiful and matched throughout the whole song ❤ her voice sounds very natural, no force, and I really love it!
JYPs tips seems to work well for everyone but himself 😂😂😂 jkjk jyp is a bit of a clown on stage but I do love him as a coach. He always gives great feedback and I especially appreciated his supportiveness on his a2k and nizi project shows (I haven't watched the boys nizi project though).
@@rhiannn3416 😂😂😂 well, he is actually very very smart to take "the clown" looking concept for his works but become very serious, helpful, and professional when producing others. Many people love that uniqueness part about him, right? 😉 Not only Nizi Project (Boys), I recommend you to watch the Golden Girls Project too... it's so cool more than I expected!
I wish he did this with some of his older groups like Twice and ITZY but he's definitely gone back to actually giving vocal training to his idols which is great.
@@RemyReviews712 Everyone knows that JYP was Bang Si-hyuk's mentor, right? When Bang Si-hyuk wanted to go independent, JYP didn't see it as a betrayal but instead supported his independence, which allowed Big Hit to come into existence. Similarly, Bang Si-hyuk lent Min Hee-jin 2 billion KRW to support her and allowed her to buy shares of Ador. He helped her turn 2 billion into 100 billion and aided her in becoming independent. However, when Min Hee-jin asked for 450 billion instead of 100 billion, they ended up fighting. It seems she was thinking of taking over not just Ador but even HYBE itself in the absence of BTS.
@Elio.h right? He's a great producer tho! I think he should stick to producing music nowadays. I think his singing days need to stop bc I can't stand his vocals. Don't get me wrong, he also teaches vocal techniques well ecen if he can't do them lollll
I think JYP knows Illit’s vocal range better 😆 I’m sure he choose to collab with them cause he knows the song will fit their voice 😊 JYP daddy is very supportive even tho they’re not from his company 💗💗💗
Who said they cant sing? We, fans know they can sing and we always know the problem is the Magnetic vocal range.. but the haters keep saying they cant sing, lucky girl syndrome and midnight fiction suits them more and they are more comfortable singing that songs
I don't wanna be that person, but these are probably not live vocals. The vocal range used in this song is not that different from Magnetic's. There are still many low notes, and it's natural for soprano singers, like those in ILLIT, to struggle with low notes unless having trained enough. Also, dancing while singing low notes is very difficult... If you compare JYP's vocals to ILLIT's, you will hear a clear difference between rough live vocals and pre-recorded or heavily edited vocals.
If they performed this live they did such a good job. I think this is their actual vocal range and Hybe needs to consider that. They sound so much stable and beatiful even while dancing around
I actually liked this collab 👌🫶, the girls sing better than their given credit and Jyp low key slays, I know it’s fun to mess with him, but he’s got that performer rizz ❤😂
I am glad thw hate train is dying down girls took the critism and came back stronger they improved and as someone who doesn't stan illit I respect the improvement
THIS IS ILLIT.....they sing better when they focus on that part but these slow less autotuned songs are their strong point. I wish the girls were trained more properly before being given upbeat energentic songs especially to perform live.
Thousands of girls wants to be in Hybe girl groups, but only 5 of them were selected among all the other girls so they must have some potentials which we shouldn’t forget. They're still rookie. Let's give them time.
Wonhee is sitting because she injured her ankle. So she's advised to not do the choreo
oh i was confused why she was sitting
I can't believe Hybe replaced Youngseo with JYP 😭
Fr 😭
Shhh…thats HYBE secret🤫
Frrr lol😭😭😭
😂😂😂
Shhhh no lo digas en voz alta, spoiler de re-debut
Now this song fits moka's vocal range, you can hear that her voice is deeper and her voice doesnt sound forced
This doesn't seem live though (but JYP did sing live). I'm not saying they can't sing, I like their voices (specially Minju and Wonhee's), but their pitch here is perfect, live vocals never sound perfect when dancing no matter how great a vocalist is. Also, the volume of their mics is super stable (as if they had used a volume compressor) while JYP's volume fluctuates a lot more. Low notes are usually harder to hear when singers are singing live, but here they sound even clearer than the higher notes (in the case of ILLIT's members)... I highly doubt these are live vocals, and if they were, they were heavily edited after the performance.
low notes are difficult for moka in magentic tho (the part leading up to the "boy~") so...?
i dont think its the vocal range thats the problem, but the tone of voice used in magnetic...
@@Kenneth_MJ okay gaslight youerself that this is not a live HAHAHA
@@PrincefriceBagaindocI mean it’s not 🫤 let’s not lie to ourselves rn
@@hueyitlahtoani9242it could be live but still edited afterwards. But it sounds live to me, especially in fancams
Belift take notes, THIS is what fits ILLIT'S vocal range.
not really, Illit cant say magnetic properly because it was in the lower range. This song is even lower, I doubt that they could sing this live.
i think they struggle most with low notes.. moka struggled with it in magnetic and this song is also pretty low
the issue probably is how hybe forces them to sing in a cute tone
@@user-uf6qe5fu8z?? Magnetic is super high
@@meowtwosthe low notes in magnetic were lower than this whole song, but over magnetic is higher than wwd
They’re probably still gonna give them high songs because of their concept 😭😭 but moka’s deep voice be hitting different
Yunah, Minju and Moka did so well here when they're not forcing the "cute" voice.
be fr 💀 do you not know the difference between forcing a voice and just singing in a different tone? grow up oml
@inimmz Yes there are different tones people sing in and different vocal ranges as well but it's very clear when someone strains their voices to sing a certain way and that's what I was saying. Also Illit's Criticism was necessary but not the hate. Especially when they are trying to do better. And stop telling random people on the internet to "Grow up" that's like the most childish thing you can say.
@@boredintrovert4282 they are absolutely not straining their voices to sing the way they do in a "cute voice" as you call it, im literally a professional singer i would know what a strained or forced voice sounds like and thats far from it. and why are you bringing up illits hate? which most of it was hate, not criticism because criticism is supposed to be helpful not telling them to die and disband because they had one bad live performance. the most childish thing you can say is not "grow up" babe be fr. its more childish to act like you know what youre talking about or making shady ass backhanded compliments.
@inimmz I gave my opinion here, and you were the one who replied with "grow up oml" so you were clearly the one being "shady". And idk who you are neither do you know who I am, so there really isn't any justification to ur "its more childish to talk abt something you don't know". And I brought the hate up because why else reply to a comment abt them doing better without the forced voice. Also, I'm not sure what "backhanded compliment" ur talking abt.
Even on the survival show they were in it was clearly that they suit a stronger concept rather than the cutesy one, hence why it seems so forced. It was one comment of what I thought, and I don't feel the need to justify myself anymore, so i won't be replying to you after this.
Wonhee too
not only this song is in their vocal range but also this concept fits them sm
JYP the hidden member of ILLIT!
The hidden ace of ILLIT !
@@suzyocean7392 frr
😂
All girl groups can unlock this bonus character
@@frederickbroshe4452 😂😂😂
their low tone voices are to die for, especially moka. belift take notes😍
So beautiful
1:27 They need to stop gatekeeping moka’s deep vocals. I want more of this! They sound so good
REAL
FR
FINALMENTE DEIXARRAM ELA CANTAR EM UM TOM FAVORÁVEL E FOI A JYP QUE TREINOU...CERTEZA!!!
So beautiful
fr cuz the only reason she has bad vocals is because she has to pitch up her voice so high 💀
A retro concept would match them ngl😔🙏🏻
I think they could cover wonder girl songs well actually
@@metanymphFR
why did they have to do cute concept? they fit girl crush/retro/or dark concept more, and retro fits minju’s cursive voice and moka’s deep voice fits dark concept/girl crush
@@minlvrs seriously. If they did retro and became basically 5th gen wonder girls they’d avoid the drama of being a “NewJeans” clone. They’d still get away with retro and y2k music but when you think about it there really isn’t any girl group doing what wonder girls did right now IMO
If they did retro i believe people would hate them more bcs NJ is y2k and 90s :((
NOT JYPAPI MAKING WHOLE HYBE HIS BACK DANCERS😂😂
Lol fr he’s the center of attention he did it with enhypen too
We are so happy JYP having fun with HYBE artist we love JYP
LOLL FR
😂😂
the theme of this year's weverse con is actually JYP, hence why lol
I always think that JYP is the best vocal teacher, his advises regarding the vocal and singing techniques work very well for all artists most of the time, they can sound very natural even for live performance, and that's why I admire him so much. I'm so happy that he gives all Illit members the chance to perform with their real voice, they sounds very natural, relax, and enjoying the stage ❤
And to be honest, Moka really nailed this performance... even with the small part only, her voice, facial expressions and her dancing lines and moves were totally beautiful and matched throughout the whole song ❤ her voice sounds very natural, no force, and I really love it!
JYPs tips seems to work well for everyone but himself 😂😂😂
jkjk jyp is a bit of a clown on stage but I do love him as a coach. He always gives great feedback and I especially appreciated his supportiveness on his a2k and nizi project shows (I haven't watched the boys nizi project though).
@@rhiannn3416 😂😂😂 well, he is actually very very smart to take "the clown" looking concept for his works but become very serious, helpful, and professional when producing others. Many people love that uniqueness part about him, right? 😉
Not only Nizi Project (Boys), I recommend you to watch the Golden Girls Project too... it's so cool more than I expected!
because jyp knows talent and doesnt hold back the artist on his label like hybe does
I wish he did this with some of his older groups like Twice and ITZY but he's definitely gone back to actually giving vocal training to his idols which is great.
@@RemyReviews712 Everyone knows that JYP was Bang Si-hyuk's mentor, right? When Bang Si-hyuk wanted to go independent, JYP didn't see it as a betrayal but instead supported his independence, which allowed Big Hit to come into existence. Similarly, Bang Si-hyuk lent Min Hee-jin 2 billion KRW to support her and allowed her to buy shares of Ador. He helped her turn 2 billion into 100 billion and aided her in becoming independent. However, when Min Hee-jin asked for 450 billion instead of 100 billion, they ended up fighting. It seems she was thinking of taking over not just Ador but even HYBE itself in the absence of BTS.
It’s crazy that when a group is given a song in their vocal range they’re good. Hybe needs to learn
Literally Moka sounds ethereal with her deep like voice in this song then in magnetic
Yes. Their deeper voices are lovelier and also, this concept slays for them. Prefer it over their act cute Lolita concept
Minju and Wonhee siren dreamy voice
Yünah and Moka deep mature voice
Iroha calm and cute voice
this is more in illit's range than jyp lmao tbh
Well hes singing live while dancing so theres that..
@@rahafmasa6774same with illit?? whats ur point? plus he’s been in the industry longer than majority of the idols now lmao
Did you see the performance with Jay? 😅 poor jyp.. I think he was tires because he disnt sound fine
Exactly like, illit sounded great here but tf was up with JYP? I don’t mean to be rude but he sounded so 😭
@Elio.h right? He's a great producer tho! I think he should stick to producing music nowadays. I think his singing days need to stop bc I can't stand his vocals. Don't get me wrong, he also teaches vocal techniques well ecen if he can't do them lollll
Moka gives the vibes of a 70's japanese star. So pretty 💕
This suits their voice so much
I think JYP knows Illit’s vocal range better 😆
I’m sure he choose to collab with them cause he knows the song will fit their voice 😊
JYP daddy is very supportive even tho they’re not from his company 💗💗💗
Its not JYP it's jypapi😫💖
@@Seung_berrystayyor jaywhypee
eventho we always make fun of him. but actually jypapi is very good and competent in this field❤😂
@@xzyzyx02 that’s true 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Let's appreciate Minju's vocals more
she's always serving
그리고 이로하
Minju since day 1 !!
I feel like everyone only talks about minju and yunha when it comes to vocals anyway though
I'M SORRY ILLIT DEEPER VOICES?? CAN'T GET ENOUGH 😩
1:27 I'm obsessed with MOKA's part here! Her expression and her voice are captivating!🪩🫧
Wowwww I didn't expect that, my dear Illit with Jyp
so random 😂
@@626wnhleefr 😭🙏
so it is not that they can’t sing… it is the vocal range that Magnetic has.
Who said they cant sing? We, fans know they can sing and we always know the problem is the Magnetic vocal range.. but the haters keep saying they cant sing, lucky girl syndrome and midnight fiction suits them more and they are more comfortable singing that songs
of course they can sing. are you dumb ?
I don't wanna be that person, but these are probably not live vocals. The vocal range used in this song is not that different from Magnetic's. There are still many low notes, and it's natural for soprano singers, like those in ILLIT, to struggle with low notes unless having trained enough. Also, dancing while singing low notes is very difficult... If you compare JYP's vocals to ILLIT's, you will hear a clear difference between rough live vocals and pre-recorded or heavily edited vocals.
@@Kenneth_MJсмотрите фанкамы , они поют вживую.
@@Kenneth_MJ do y'all ever stfu? This is literally live vocals
If they performed this live they did such a good job. I think this is their actual vocal range and Hybe needs to consider that. They sound so much stable and beatiful even while dancing around
Yess I even eatched yhe fancam an it was amazing
They didn’t, the only one who’s live is jyp
@@discodeaky8225 They did sing live
@@NotSmartPeppa with zero movement in the voice? Of course
@@discodeaky8225 Jyp himself confirmed it and you can clearly hear their breaths when they sing sooo...
illit should do a party concept they fit so well ! especially moka and minju
Now this fits them I love it, JYP knows what he's doing
illit just songs that fit their vocals, like moka ate, BUT WHY IS EVERYONE PERFORMING WITH JYP HELPP
jypapi is simply a legend
@@lavendertiles nah he's a zionist fiend who loves attention
@@lavendertilesfr
weverse con tributes an artist as theme each year, and this year is JYP, hahaha that's why.
It's their blessing if he does this!
Moka’s vocals omg 😮😮
we need someone like JYP to unlock this illit
Yea I may not like how he inserts himself into things but this might be a genius move
I want illit to have songs like this because it fits their vocal range and I love this kind of concept
minjus voice just sounds so good😭
IKRR
I really salute Wonhee.. eventhough she's injured she still find a way to perform..❤❤❤
Hybe please make songs for these girls that fit their range. There voices are beautiful here ❤❤.
i need moka fancam so much
she looks so pretty and for what 😭😭😭
They even fit in this concept more😢
Yunah slay❤❤
1:27 moka deep voice 🫶🏻
127?????? NEO GOT MY BACK
PUPUPUPU POW POW LET ME LET ME INTRODUCE U A NEW DANCE 💥
Im crying because its too beautiful
GUYS MOKA'S LOW VOICE IS SO GOOD?!
MOKA VOICE IS SO ADDICTING AH
FR!!
best girls they deserve nothing but the best
yess
Moka ate this ✨💅 watch their behind video if you still believe they can't sing
Wonhee's voice here is soo beautifull. And Moka's too. I'm so proud!
Same obsessed with Wonhee
😂😂
JYPって本当安心するのよこの人
their outfit are so gorgeous
Awesome! Great to see a legend and the youngest group of K-Pop performing together.❤❤❤❤❤❤
They are not the youngest Kpop group lol
2nd youngest actually
I don’t think anybody had this on their K-Pop 2024 Bingo Card.
Illit's vocals are so good wait-
It was always been good. You should watch their performances from RUNext survival show😊
I actually liked this collab 👌🫶, the girls sing better than their given credit and Jyp low key slays, I know it’s fun to mess with him, but he’s got that performer rizz ❤😂
Minju with veil on is so hot!!❤❤😻😻
Yunah in her element
omg. i would love to see illit do a disco concept
yes, me too
ILLIT’S voices sound so magical! Such an unexpected COLLAB though!
moka face said "now see the voice I have is much better than those of you who hate"
Illit ร้องเพลงนี้ได้ดีมาก comment ที่แสดงความเกลียดชังขอให้ก้าวข้ามไปค่ะ ขอเป็นกำลังใจให้ค่ะ
可愛いすぎ😍
Love this. Love illit
I love Moka’s facial expressions 💕 she looks like she is always having fun 🥰
When we disco🪩
The illit magnetic end pose is everything 😭
なんと凄いコラボ😱💦
特に、イロハちゃんは、JYPや日本人の演歌の血まで感じられる歌いっぷりで、素晴らしいです‼️
Wonhee's vocal is spectacular, I love her voice!! She's unique, I love her
完璧でした❤
I love how Wonhee participated even while being injured here
Iroha is sooooooo good she eats every dance
I am glad thw hate train is dying down girls took the critism and came back stronger they improved and as someone who doesn't stan illit I respect the improvement
ilIitちゃんも餅ゴリも最高😀✨
色々あった分これから思いっきり楽しく過ごしてほしいです💙💙
actually Yunah really fits JYP style of singing
Never thought I'd see Jyp and illit collab 💀
THIS IS ILLIT.....they sing better when they focus on that part but these slow less autotuned songs are their strong point. I wish the girls were trained more properly before being given upbeat energentic songs especially to perform live.
I have been playing this song nonstop because of illit ,this lower tone fits them so much and hype should take note.
1:27 love her deep voice!!!!!
i was so in shock with moka’s voice omg, I hope hybe gives them some with this range 😢😢 my beautiful minju and her vocals amazing as always ❤❤
And they say ILLIT can't sing, they're so talented and i love Moka's deep voice!
people who say that will never convince illit stans who were there from the beginning of illit's journey
YUNAH MATCHING CONCEPT JYP
Every member performed this so well, but Jline totally owned this song 💖
Moka’s deep voice 🤩
Now people can stop hating on illit, their vocals here fit them so well.
Agree…wished yeseo had joined the group. She can sing too.
@@inquisitvem6723 you mean youngseo? or yeseo?
@@teaCAFE0 the one that didn’t debut with them
I love themmm😭😭
Thousands of girls wants to be in Hybe girl groups, but only 5 of them were selected among all the other girls so they must have some potentials which we shouldn’t forget.
They're still rookie. Let's give them time.
This is one of my favorite JYP songs so ILLIT is a plus!!!
So happy these girls got to show their talent.
Ok but minju and moka vocals are amazing
Wow they improved themselves 😊 I hope this going to be a fresh new start for Illit
Thank you JYP for this collab and for saving the girls from the bad image that hybe gave to them with songs that don't swits their vocals~~~♡♡
the ending😭😭i was not expecting that lmao
Illit sings so well 😍😘😘
2:30 how do they not laugh😂
Iroha was laughing lol
thats why they are called idols...proffessionals from such a young age
Cz he is singing live and they can't
get well soon wonhee ❤
What happened to Wohnee ！？
@@Jennie_Blink215she has an ankle injury so she sang off stage since she was medically advised not to dance.
1:41 Wonhee vocal❤🥰
😂
MOKA ATE AND LEFT NO CRUMBS
truly impressed
Woah, the girls' voices sound so rich with this song! This song is actually showing off their vocals more than their own debut EP did 😂
bro the way i will never forget this collab TT GIVE THEM SONGS LIKE THIS PLS
this is perfect, ty jyp for making this happen
3:49 Wonhee looks kinda different here..
Nah that’s youngseo
lmaoo
LOLLL
looks mature 💀
honestly illit could be wonder girls 2.0 this style suit them well
ウォニの椅子が遠いのよなぁぁぁ(´;ω;｀)
Yo , Moka rockin' with those low tunes ~!
moka slayed this song😍😍
JYP the new member of illit
They should do concept like Wonder Girls i swear 💯