Goebbels Speech about the State of the War- 28 February 1945
Vložit
- čas přidán 1. 04. 2023
- As public appearances became more and more difficult for Goebbels, both because organizing such mass events under the threat of allied bombings was almost impossible, and because most stadiums, halls etc. where such large events could be held were already destroyed, Propaganda shifted more towards the radio, as it was the only thing that large parts of the German population still had access to.
This speech is from late February 1945, and in it, Goebbels tries again to motivate and stir up the Germans people defensive will.
-
Subtitles made by me.
Remarks:
03:12 Baranov-bridgehead: The Sandomierz-Baranów bridgehead was a Soviet bridgehead on the left bank of the Vistula in Poland, which the Red Army established in late July 44 and from where they started their Vistula-Oder offensive in January 45.
03:58 OKW-report: A daily report of the German army high command.
06:15 “The Prussians don't shoot that quickly” is a German proverb meaning “things don’t happen that fast”
10:08 A quote, supposedly by Bertolt Brecht “Only the most stupid/biggest of calves vote for their own butcher."
25:47: Fredrick II. was a famous Prussian king, who managed to defend Prussia during the 7 years war (1756-1763) against a massive enemy superiority.
54:15 The battle of Hohenfriedberg on June 4th, 1745 was a decisive Prussian victory against Austria and Saxony in the Second Silesian War.
😢
@@filmoljubac1 What was upsetting about what he said?
Not a fan of Nazis ,but his enunciation and articulation was impeccable.
11:15 The translation is wrong.
"Das uns Deutschen! Ist einer unter uns, der angesichts dieser Furchtbarkeiten -- die sich normalerweise ein menschliches Gehirn nicht einmal ausdenken kann, die aber hier von in Menschengestalt einherwandelnden Scheusalen tausendfach begangen wurden -- vor seine nationale Führung hinzutreten wagte mit der Forderung, Schluß zu machen und einem solchen Feinde seinen Willen gegen unser ganzes Volk zu lassen?"
"And this (was done) to us Germans! Is there (even) one among us, who in the face of these horrors -- which normally a human brain cannot even think out, but which here have been committed by monsters walking in the shape of humans -- would dare standing before his national leaders and ask them to pack up and let such an enemy have his way against our whole people?"
Has anyone noticed that there seems to be radio-"chatter" or interferences in the background of this record? I would love to know if this was some other important stuff running in the next room or the same frequence...
goebbels got a better microphone than half the guys on cs:go
Made in Germany
Deutsche Qualitäts Arbeit, vs. China 😀
German technology. Neumann microphones etc.
Bro xD
German audio technology was incredibly advanced for the time. Simply extremely good engineering and know-how with regards to sound. Still to this day they're(the microphones of this era) are some of the best microphones ever made. The Germans of this time really knew what they were doing regarding audio tech and its use in a very modern, forward thinking way.
I was doubtful before, but after listening to the full speech, I think they can still win.
😂😂😂
We will winning
In Germany we say...America first but Deutschland Förster
Hahahahahahahahaha!
Ein grosser Lügner ich hoffe er schmoren in der Hölle den da gehört er hin
“…the war situation has developed not necessarily to Germany advantage…”
meaning---The enemy is at the door'.
I'm learning German and I've been listening to his speeches because he speaks German very clearly haha
if you learn german like he is speaking you will be ahead of most native speakers today
that's exactly what I'm doing, just found it.
You’d better never order a beer with this kind of German expression. 😅
Sehr gut mein Herr
It is made on purpose, a very hypnotic sound for propaganda
I remain convinced that what you are sharing with us are rare and extraordinary documents of European history that must be remembered and not censored at all. History has no barriers or divisions.
It's our story.. it's everyone's story!!!
Many thanks for these documents.
Really appreciated!
It's not censored. It's called put into context. If it would be censored you wouldn't see it here.
Perhaps this will only be available for a short while because of copyrights. All the transcripts of nazi-leader-speeches are available in the 'Bundes Archive'.
@@tobiasstieber There are those who want to censor this and anything like it. Many things today are indeed censored and many things cannot be said. We've already lost free speech in Europe.
@@tobiasstieber he never said it was censored, he said it shouldn't be censored. It's called reading comprehension.
@user-ii5ns1qs5lwho is they?
the quality of the microphone for that time is really f***ing good
German engineering
As is the quality of the recording.
Pretty much all high-end microphones you can buy today are based on german microphones of that era. And it’s really been that way ever since the war.
"Telefunken" or "Neumann" as the brand is called today is still making one of the best microphones
I mean they flew ufos so a microphone ain't nothing.
Me struggling with my homework assignment, and too intimidated to start working on it
Then I imagined having to make an hour long speech about Germany's war efforts in february 1945.
The same sentiment is felt by me! I struggled a lot to complete my homework. 😞
To be fair he's mostly just rehashing his usual complaints.
What is really amazing about this is that Goebells was a lot of things but one thing he wasn't is dumb. He knew full well by this late date that there was 0 chance of a german victory.
He is also very well-spoken. It really shows. That's what makes the Nazis so terrifying, they were not dumb, but rather smart.
@@hardcorehardo What makes the Nazis (and the Soviets, and every other mass murdering regime in history) so terrifying is how easily they get your neighbours to go along with murdering you and your entire family.
Well, Hitler made a lot of irrational and straight out dumb choices when it comes to military action. Also the whole eradication of the Jews was very time-consuming and it cost material and menpower that could have been used elsewhere, it was dumb to do
IQ tests were made of the nazi leaders at the Nuremberg trials.
Here are the results for all 21 Nazis tested:
1 Hjalmar Schacht 143
2 Arthur Seyss-Inquart 141
3 Hermann Goering 138
4 Karl Doenitz 138
5 Franz von Papen 134
6 Eric Raeder 134
7 Dr. Hans Frank 130
8 Hans Fritsche 130
9 Baldur von Schirach 130
10 Joachim von Ribbentrop 129
11 Wilhelm Keitel 129
12 Albert Speer 128
13 Alfred Jodl 127
14 Alfred Rosenberg 127
15 Constantin von Neurath 125
16 Walther Funk 124
17 Wilhelm Frick 124
18 Rudolf Hess 120
19 Fritz Sauckel 118
20 Ernst Kaltenbrunner 113
21 Julius Streicher 106
(Scores of 65 or less were classified as “defective,” between 80 and 119 as normal, and 128 and above was “very superior.” Only about 2.2 percent of the population scored in that range.)
@@hardcorehardo yep. nothing shows this more than having lard-ass ww1 war hero & drug addict like Herman Goring chosen Plenipotentiary of the Four Year Plan in 1936, As 2nd most powerful man in nazi wunderland he was entrusted with the economy & mobilization of entire country for war despite having no background in economics. Another winner Heinrich Himmler and another 2nd most powerful nazi was failed chicken farmer and head of the Gestapo & SS .
He seems much more soft-spoken than I would have imagined
He was speaking on the radio. When he spoke to crowds, he wasn't so soft spoken.
And he was probably resigned because he knew they would loose despite what he was saying
Danke für das Hochladen dieses wichtigen Zeitdokumentes.
Blimey - he almost convinced me there that Germany might still win...fascinating to see how he tried to combine a reasonably honest assessment of the military situation (eg 'England will continue to destroy our cities') with a geopolitical analysis designed to offer some hope
God damn, im actually impressed by the quality. I never knew the recordings where THAT clear.
After the war, some British people listening to German radio late at night, were astonished to hear high-quality classical music. They thought the orchestras must be awake, doing some kind of weird night shifts. Actually, it was just recordings. Germans pioneered recording high quality audio to magnetic tape. Until then, only live broadcasts would have been near that quality. Recordings from phonographs/ vinyl records, wax cylinders or metal tape were really poor at the time.
Very interesting, thanks for sharing!
Today the brand/company "Grunding" is not well known among young people, , but they were a great deal of the german economy rebuilding, among other german companies of this sector, in the post-war. They made stuff of the highest quality or that other foreign companies simply weren't able to make in the late 40s-early 50s.
@@Alvar2001 It's "Grundig", not "Grunding"!
NACH dem Krieg kannten sie bereits den Trick (das Tonbandgerät). Nur vor seinem Ende konnten sie verblufft werden. Schau mal nach Jack Mullin, der die Apparate für sie "nutzbar" gemacht hat.
U.S. troops stole some of recording machines took them back to the U.S were they were copied and put on sale to the public
Honey, turn up the radio. Doctor Goebells is speaking
The speech had low ratings. The minute people realized he was going to tell his lies again, they tuned out.
Another tremendous contribution from one of the most important channels on CZcams.
Thank you for this.
Nowadays I'm learning to speak German and this video helps me to improve my listening skills.
Thanks for uploading
Bro 😂😂
I'm sure you can find more tasteful sources of German speaking than this...
This dude going to be speaking German like: "Where is the Auschwitz? I mean toilet! Haha, blitzkrieg - I MEAN EXCUSE ME!!" 😅
MF was learning Arabic by reading the Necronomicon I guess
Oh, man, what a silly thing to say!! I hope you'll never find yourself in a situation as to use any of these language.
The top Nazi's weren't stupid, by Autumn 1944 they knew the war was lost. But the same seemed to be true for 'England' in Autumn 1940, and Goebbels repeatedly draws inspiration from this in final speeches.
They knew the war was lost but still hoped for some peace settlement or break-up. They really clung to straws
@@conorbrown792 They didn't want peace or capitulation, Hitler said several times that he would fight to the last man, so much so that he could leave Berlin but preferred to stay there until the end. And on the other side, the allies and Soviets would not accept any request for peace or capitulation they would only stop in Berlin, this was said by some authorities.
@@fireatthecrime9422 really ? but the nazis could have capitulate to the allies while fighting the russians..that woukld habe ended the war ealrier. i cant imagine the allies not accepting that
His 1945 microphone is better than the one I can get today. How is that even possible in 1945 to have mic this insanely good??..
German engineering
this are digitally restored tapes
Siemens AG
The microphone he uses here would probably be among the best available at that time. To me it sounds basically like a microphone you could buy for 50 dollars today. A standard, cheaper studio mic like the AT2020 sounds way better than this and only costs around 100 dollars. But yeah, it sounds really good because the technology behind audio recording has not had any revolutionary developments since the 40s, unlike for example computers
Well, good audio technology is not a new thing. For example the Neumann U87 is still a reference for vocal recordings in studios, it is still in production, you can still buy it (for about 2700 €) - but it was released already in 1967.
Thank you in all your efforts of uploading and helping preserve history. This is very important.
I totally agree with you...this must never be banned or shunned...it is a classic example of propaganda and racial insanity of all time that ironically goes from generation to generation but in different forms, yet the end result is death
Thank you for uploading this, the quality is excellent. Im currently reading his diaries and find him very fascinating, he certainly played his part in the early successes of the nazi era.
Thank you for your efforts. This is an important historical document.
Excellent recording. I wonder how it made it unscathed through the next few months of war. Goebbels had such an unusual cadence, different in this one than in his earlier speeches. You can hear him slip back into his old triumphalist ways at 10 minutes -- but he slowly slips back into an almost nostalgic cadence. Thanks for uploading.
Nice summary, nostalgic cadence spot on. Very clear speaker and well written, of course that does not excuse being a Nazi and what he was part of.
I appreciate your effort in translating these for the English world. If you don't mind me asking, where do you access these from? Deutsche Nationalbibliothek? If there is any way to access these online I'd love to know. Thank you for your either way.
Thank you very much for your nice words!
I get these from a variety of sources, most are from the Internet Archive, others are from German Radio Archives, and some I find on Soundcloud of all places...
So just a lot of different sources.
They're all on the Internet Archive.
Microphone technology barely evolved since then. This is the reason why it sounds so good.
Jajaja😂
Besser und motivierender als jeder TED Talk. Hab jetzt richtig bock zu husslen. 😁
an interesting choice to use Russia's and Britain's crises and subsequent resurgences as comparisons to Germany's current situation. I doubt that was particularly reassuring to the German people, knowing that those resurgences were not against some third party, but against Germany itself, and that the people Goebbels was talking about were now knocking on Germany's door.
Yeah...I seriously doubt any of this was reassuring to the German people given that the United States of America was steam rolling towards them and had 100% control of the skies over Germany. lol. It was game over baby, and Gerbils knew it.
Exactly. I thought the comparison to be demoralizing, actually.
Top-notch translation. Thanks!
please also upload his speech for hitlers birthday 1945
Is there a link? Please share.
And 1946. The "fuehrer" lives forever... Some fascists still believe that hitler is still alive :-)
Many thanks for posting these invaluable recordings . Primary sources of information equal true unadulterated history!
It's more than likely AI. Then again, so your comment could be also 🙂
No real information, only propaganda
@@karlscher5170All known history is.
Perfektes Deutsch!
Noch nie so klares Deutsch gehört 😅
Annalena kann einpacken.
Er betont das „r“ an Stellen wo man es eigentlich noch hat tut
@@laibachshoden-wohl2048 Was hat das mit Annalena zu tun? Auf welche Art ist hier überhaupt ein Vergleich zu ziehen?
Die Grünen wohnen ja wirklich mietfrei in deinem Kopf. Also ich stelle mir das ja schrecklich vor. Aber musst du selber wissen.
Yes, he certainly could speak very well. And at the same time tons and tons of mere verbiage.
mit Kölsche unterton
A beautifully-enunciated, eloquent speech in pure German, not peppered with English loan words, and with superb audio. Powerful.
Not powerful. The doomed report by a man who murdered his children and bit down on a cyanide capsule just 61 days later. His soul is now burning for all eternity in Hell. What an Evil man.
and then they murdered their children , powerfully vile
@@danielmclaughlin5546 What he said was not about whether he was a moral or a good man. His speech was eloquent and actually convincing without listening to it with hindsight and knowing what you know about history, and it is a fact.
@@JgvnkhgbbKhrfhutfhk Great point. Anyone can listen to this knowing nothing of history, logic or sense. Nazis can flourish only in such situations.
@@JgvnkhgbbKhrfhutfhk Lying eloquently is still lying. He didn't need hindsight because he had all the facts and knew Germany had no chance of winning. Yet he still demanded that people wasted their lives in a hopeless struggle. Didn't see him picking up a weapon to fight for Germany though. The (and I use the word loosely) man was a disgrace.
Thanks for the Speech.
You can hear the depression and sense of defeat in his delivery no matter the words…
Just like johnwright below comments, by this time Herr Doctor was committed with his wife to die for that guy...and imagine working all those hours and all those years spewing lies, bullshit, nonsense and the demonic insanity of so called racial purity that the world recognized as insane...you are correct in that he was running out of things to say and tired of the same ole same ole, but it is still a brilliant diatribe of trying to give hope to the hopeless with the same ole crap
For those who don't speak German - like myself-, CZcams's auto-translate feature seems to work pretty well on this video. It's not perfect, but you can get a pretty good idea of what Goebbels is saying.
Thanks, I had forgot about those. He speaks so clearly that it catches every word at least👍
I'm German and I checked out the English subtitles for a few minutes. For the most part they were quite accurate!
Thats because it is hand written, the owner of the channel really puts care into his videos and writes and translates transcripts of the speechs he uploads.
It can described in just to german words: „Gestelztes Dummgewäsch“
Fraglich ob Dummheit genügt, um dieses erbärmlich aufgeblasene Geschwätz ernst nehmen zu können. 😅
Wow, incredibly interesting! Keep them coming, thanks!
At this time the Soviet line was on the Oder, with bridgeheads. The Western Allies were on the Rhine. A week later the Americans seized the Remagen bridge and a couple weeks after that Monty crossed the lower Rhine.
Six weeks later the Soviets opened their Berlin offensive, breaking the German defence and penetrating to the Berlin suburbs in four days. By then the British and Canadians were approaching Hamburg and the Americans were on the Elbe and in the south, at Stuttgart and Nuremburg. Sorry old sport.
I think most of the german people were happy that war was over soon. After nearly 6 years.
@@MARKUS4123Not really...
I am surprised how honest and blunt he is about the military losses.
After all i have heard after the defeat in Stalingrad the german (cotrolled) media lost a lot of trust in Germany. In Februrary 1945 if they wouldn't talk a little bit honestly about the situation everybody would stop listening. He still is lying and spreading conspiracy theories. i.a. 28:21
Agreed, considering this is a public speech from the man in charge of propaganda, the first five minutes have essentially told everyone the game is up (if they didn’t already realise it). Considering that people were punished to the very end for talking about a German loss in the war, it’s quite something coming from him!
The country was full of refugees on the move from the East, energy and food was all but non existence and the cities were in rubble, he is polishing it as much as he can.
Yet is kind of funny how Goebbles apologzies for his honesty by stating that some things are commonly known in the meantime.
He lied as long as he could! The game was up in feb 1945
Two months later he blew his head off... this is jewel of history, and should always remain available for new generation to study. Thank you uploader!
& murdered his six children -- that's also an important data point.
@@andraskovacs517 Heide, Hilde, Holde, Hedwig, Helmut und Hedda. Das Verhalten, seine eigenen Kinder umzubringen, war aber nur konsequent, denn es gab laut Goebbels keine Zukunft für sie. Sie wurden mit Morphium ruhiggestellt und erhielten dann die Zyankali Kapsel, wahrscheinlich sogar von Magda Goebbels. Hitler und Eva Braun waren zu diesem Zeitpunkt schon 1 Tag vorher gestorben.
He took pills.
Shot himself and wife
And hes wife killed all their children!
Unreal, in saying the situation is not disastrous, he cites the Russian and British comebacks when things were grim for both, somehow failing to see the significance that both of these huge swings in war momentum were inflicted on his Nazis…
Another excellent upload!!
Hitler didn't have the BALLS to face a microphone, let alone reality
His German is really beautiful, the word choices and grammar structure and all, one can't appreciate it unless you know German. As an East Asian foreigner who will start a job in German consulting industry in fully German-speaking enviornment, this is the kind of German that I want to emulate.
this is definitely not beautiful German. If you want to listen to a real "master" listen to Adorno.
Sorry what the f**k ?
@@Audioventura Both, Goebbels and Adorno spoke beautiful german.
@@derick3482 Basically every sentence is as if it were carefully crafted and sounds literary. The beautiful use of both Konjunktiv I and II, Partizip I and II, Genitiv, Präteritum, nested Nebensätze, as well as the literary word choices, often with metaphors and historical references. I don't know what examples you want, every sentence is an example. It sounds so good that I almost want to print out the entire transcript and repeat the speech myself until I familiarize myself with it completely.
@@Audioventura in your perspective, how is Adorno's German visibly superior to Goebbels's? Not that I'm denying that Adorno speaks beautiful German, but just want to know how is Goebbels's German less beautiful.
Never before have so many metaphors been deployed in a lost cause.
How on earth does this sound so good. Most people are impossible to understand in 2023! Guess the answer is to get a 1940's german mic
Annunciations. He is projecting really, really well, making deliberate pauses, exaggerating consonants to be better understood.
I heard that one of the reason why many people are so hard to understand on TV or radio nowadays is because they rely too much on the quality of the microphone and slur their speech.
Back then the microphone worked against you and so you had to speak clearly.
It's restored, but also they understand the impact of production value with propaganda.
this is very nice to learn your "listening" and "speaking" for learning German
Could you please update the Testament of Stalingrad on radio? I cannot find it anywhere. They spoke about the heroic fight and the survive of Western Civilization.
Seems the legendary Göring's Speech .......
Listening to this while 0-4 behind in League. Same vibe
Ich muss sagen, dass einiges voraus gesagt wurde.
Wie z.B?
stimmt die U Boote haben danach den Krieg noch gedreht. Das Volk ist fanatisch dem Feind entgegen getreten und hat lieber seine Vernichtung hingenommen statt zu kapitulieren, sonst wären wir ja jetzt auch nicht hier.
Zum Glück hatten wir U Boot Plot Armor, nicht auszudenken wir hätten den Krieg verloren
Ein sehr eleganter Sprecher. Klar und alle Buchstaben betonend. Er war wohl der intelligenteste des Regimes, daher auch der gefährlichste.
Seine Aussprache ist tatsächlich sehr klar und präzise, die ganze Phonetik ist quasi nach DIN Norm
Guten mänchen
tatsächlich wurden bei Tests festgestellt, dass Göring den höchsten IQ der NS Führung hatte. Überraschenderweise.
@@MrJeffersondarcy das ist absicht den es handelt sich um rundfunkt
Erstens ist es für die damaligen Rundfunkgeräte unabdingbar gewesen, so deutlich zu sprechen. Selbst der Soldat im Feld sollte ihn verstehen. Zweitens denke ich, dass diese Rede auch dem Feind und dessen Übersetzern gewidmet war. Deswegen die klare Aussprache und der langsame Erzählfluss. Natürlich bemüht Goebbels als Historiker alle möglichen geschichtlichen Beispiele. Dass er sich so zu Friedrich dem Großen hingezogen fühlte, wusste ich nicht.
Was ich mich frage, wer hatte damals noch die Muße, sich über eine Stunde lang diese ausgefeilte wahnhafte Rede von Goebbels anzuhören? Die Menschen waren mit anderen Dingen beschäftigt am Ende des Krieges. Wer glaubte noch an das, was er sagte? Er klang wie aus einer anderen Welt.
Am 1.05.45, einen Tag nach dem Suizid Hitlers und seiner Frau, tötete er seine 6 Kinder ( Heide, Hedda, Holde, Hedwig, Hilde und Helmut ), seine Frau Magda ( die ebenfalls sich dazu entschied ) und sich selbst. Am 08.05.45 war auf dem europäischen Kontinent der Krieg zu Ende.
Very interesting to hear Goebbels repeatedly praising the Soviets, makes you really question how much conviction he must have had at this time.
Goebbels was originally flirting with Communism before he settled on National Socialism. Let's not mince words -- Nazism IS reworked Communism based on Blut und Boden instead of the proletariat
He was right about the British Empire victory by the allies precipitared the British Empires collapse
"Shit's fooked and we didn't invest in WMDs like the good guys(tm) did"
Holy shit, what are you doing here haha
„Es ist klar, dass wir uns die Gebiete, die wir verloren haben zurückholen werden und müssen. Wann und wie, darüber kann natürlich heute öffentlich noch nicht gesprochen werden.“
Preußenland von der Nachkriegszeit bis heute: 🇵🇱
🇪🇺
😉
Jeder Versuch endete mit noch mehr verlorene Gebiete. Beim nächsten Versuch wird Deutschland auf Ostfriesland reduziert. 😅
@@diginilo855 Dann spart man was beim Oktoberfest - bezahlen auf Zloty :-)
Danke!
Bitte sehr!
He's brilliant at framing. He never has to lie, he just gives a compelling reason why the truth has a different meaning.
A surprisingly honest assessment of the war situation from Goebbels.
DO US ALL A FAVOUR AND TRANSLATE THE LOT
Überraschend ehrlich?
Wenige Tage später stand der Russe in Berlin.
LG
Yes and No.
Goebbels knew the end was near, but he was in deep denial still.
Two months later he was the only one to stay in the bunker with Hitler in Berlin underneath the "Reichskanzlei". The rest of the Nazi leaders tried to flee or clear their names by resigning to the Allied troops.
You have got to be kidding. It was all over but the shouting
it was already over when he said this
I love these long speeches!
what ? LIES ?
@@MrDaiseymay I assume that you haven’t even listened to half of the speech.
I've tried to listen to bits but by god does goebbels love his own voice.
Im Februar 1945 noch eine solche Rede fertigzubringen, aber alle Rhetorik kann die Realität nicht verändern.
Where can I find archives with all these speeches?
Sein Ausdruck, seine Wortwahl und die stets korrekte Anwendung des Konjunktiv und anderer grammatikalischer Dinge zeugen schon von einem gewissen Bildungsniveau, das er gehabt haben muss.
Q.I from Dr. Goebbels is Q.I 140.
Ich liebe die Deutsche Konjunctiv ;)
Aber hör mal anderen aus der damaligen Zeit zu. Die konnten alle noch gut sprechen.
He had a Ph.D, which is why he was called "Dr. Goebbels". Most Ph.D. holders are pretty good at grammar. He was an excellent public speaker, second only to Hitler in the regime.
Ein gewisses Bildungsniveau? Vergleiche seine Reden mal mit einer von Baerbock. Danach formulierst du das wahrscheinlich etwas anders.
It's incredible to think about how many recorded speeches have been lost to physical ruination and Allied asphyxiation.
Most of them were actually destroyed by the Germans themselves at the end of the war.
For god sakes!, who would wanna hear this?.
@@JL-mj9tr "Me"
@@GermanWWIIArchive Stop with your facts!
@@JL-mj9tr Learn about the past - understand the present
I wonder if it would be possible to use the Artificial Intelligence tools of today to enhance and boost the audio quality of this 1945 recording to a HD high quality studio recording, as as it was recorded yesterday.
You very well can restore and fix and ehance old audios, but again, I chose to upload these speeches in their original state, unaltered.
Its legit the best English Auto-Translate i´ve ever seen... Greets from Germany BONN (West-Germany)
> best English Auto-Translate i´ve ever seen
It is because the original German transcript is excellent
Interesting that he tells the German people to remain hopeful saying that for Russia and Britain it was also a hopeless situation where they then came out on top eventually. To the cost of… Germany of course. But he doesn’t mention that
Yes i thought the same...its a very weird comparison and its hard to imagine that this will bring anyone's hopes up...
why not ?
No no. Fist it is never bad to give the people hope. and i think he just hadnt enough faith and knowledge about military things. Plus they didnt had the right informations, they lied each other the generals told storys and numbers the leader told anyone its all good jst a little throwback...and such thing. if the generals and hitler and other told him, yes yes we had htorwbacks and bad situations but we will strike back and oyu have to hold up the peoples hope and faith.....then he did that. normaly. why not. i bet he didnt belived or knew how close the end really was because of faith and infotmations about his country and army. . thats more the truth. so there is nothing special on that. i dont belive he was an complete eveil person he was indoctrinated and a child of his time he belived and lived this shit.
Yes, he forgot to mention that for Britain and Russia there were untapped reserves. The whole meaning of the Blitzkrieg for Nazi Germany was to quash its enemy before it can use its reserves in full. Once they failed to achieve this... That was it... But in 1945 there was no untapped reserves for Nazi Germany left, so all comparisons with the situation of Moscow and Leningrad were utterly wrong.
He kind of forgot the United States of America in that comment...didn't he? Gerbils still could not forgive us for making Gone with the Wind, which even 6 years later was driving him crazy with jealousy.
His calculated tone is that of a loving and benevolent fatherly shepherd of the people. The Nazis were very cunning indeed.
His eloquence cannot be denied..
His murder of millions of people outweighs your virtue you utter cnt.
Huh what? He has a concious choice of words but if you are German his narration and delivery is rather boring and unremarkable.
@@phil3114 der sollte damit ja auch keinen entertainen
For a German: completely boring.... "eloquence" and goebbels? No way! This guy way a minion of hitler and his regime. Totally irelevant when listened from outside Germany.... "Heiliger Zorn, deutsches Volk"... All just bullshit.
@@ruffnexs4470 nööö, der wollte nur "ganz Deutschland" in den Krieg "führen".... und seinen "führer" "entertainen"...
Die Rede ist im Kern nicht schlecht...
This evils mf voice tone is so calming that for a moment i almost closed my eyes and magically started to understand german, shit almost made me asleep
incredible
Do you have Hitler's speech in November of 1942 as the Battle of Stalingrad was going on? I would love a translation of that.
He no longer posts any speeches from Hitler. That might get the channel striked out.
@@davidnavarro4821 does he have those on rumble or any other site?
Here you go peeps. Hitler's Stalingrad speech Pt1
m.czcams.com/video/n8PKXO4xfMU/video.html
@@davidnavarro4821 is there anywhere else one can find that speech or other speeches translated?
The audio quality is very good
Has anyone noticed that there seems to be radio-"chatter" or interferences in the background of this record? I would love to know if this was some other important stuff running in the next room or the same frequence...
This was recorded on tape. Winding of tape for a long time can cause a very light electronic copy on the underlying tape. I do not know about this tape, but BASF / IG Farben made PVC backed ferro oxyde tapes. Maybe that is what you are hearing. Another option is that a tape is re-used and not completely overwritten.
Fanatischer Wiederstand:Magda,wo sind die Zyanid Pillen?😅
As. German myself , I got to give it to goebbels, he has a very clear and distinct German ,you can almost say his German is beautiful in an auditory standpoint . He talks clearly , I understand that hitler made him the minister of Reichsministerium für Volksaufklärung und Propaganda. Or propaganda minister , I don’t idolise the man , he was a fool, but had great auditory skills .
Chlling with its exquisite cultured diction and grammar it brings to mind Goethe's Mephistopheles beguiling Faust in his study:
"Reason and science you despise
Mans highest powers
Now the lies of the deceiving spirit bind you
With those magic arts that blind you..
..to ruination"
How did you get these audios?
So glad I can watch this first hand.
You watch with your hand?
Great podcast voice
Imagine if there were 1 hour 'conversational' broadcasts directly from the Austrian Painter himself. The only one we have is the indirect ''Mannerheim Recording".
His Munich beer haal putsch annivesary speeches are pretty conversational.
He gave a short ( 5min) broadcated last speech a little later.
@@karlmehltretter2677 how ?
I saw this information everywhere. "The only sound recording of AH "not shouting" and speaking his day to day voice". It's just not true. I wasn't digging too much but I found at least one original video with his voice. I don't remember if it was in weekly DW or some other source but Germany was visited by I believe it was English diplomatic "mission" where AH, with calm voice, praises what Italians and especially Duce did with the transformation of northern swamps and reshaped them into usable farming areas.
Edit: And I also wanted to say I strongly believe there must be TON of original material, audio and video, which never saw light of the day and even until now is stored somewhere in the archive or personal collection.
@@Tobi-ln9xr You realise even saying his name, or the informal name of his party that starts with 'N', will get your comment shadowbanned on here? Surely you're not this stupid.
thank you so much
Don’t worry, Shteiner will save the day.
Herkenbare stem. Bijzondere intonatie en sterk grammaticaal articulerend.
I’m not a native German speaker but is it correct to say that he has a strong accent? Is that the accent of Düsseldorf? Or is that him just speaking in an overly clear radio voice..
Joseph Goebbels was born in Rheydt near Mönchengladbach! and speaks High German with a Rhenish colored dialect! I think it's good when people from other countries are interested in the German language, keep it up my friend!
@@ibinitschlecht Actualy, you can hear the influence of the Rheinland Area in his pronounciation pretty good.
Wow, you speak german so well ! how did you improve ?
me : well... it's complicated
buen material saludos desde buenos aires argentina
TL:DL: "We're fucked"
How they had such a good mic in 1945
Modern microphones aren't really any better than old ones, the tech had already been brought to a sufficiently high level by the 1940s. And the one Goebbels used would have probably been top of the line, hand made rather than the cheap mass produced ones which most people use these days.
Goebbels got new Blue Yeti for this speech
It was a German microphone.
faszinierend mal sowas zu hören... Solche Dokumente sich wichtig, um allen Generationen als Warnung zu dienen sowas nie wieder zu dulden...
A T34 has just pulled up out side his window !
Can you upload with subtitles hitlers 11 December 1941 speech? thanks.
No, I will not upload any speeches of Hitler.
@@GermanWWIIArchive Ok, your channel, your rules. anyway its really good content, keep going.
@@GermanWWIIArchive Too risky?
@@SirChristian100 Basically yes. There are just some stuff that probably would get banned immediatly on CZcams, same with certain very anti-semitic speeches.
@@GermanWWIIArchive I understand, sadly. Still looking for a complete archive of all his speeches, etc.
This is the first time I regret that I don’t know German and I have to read the video instead of listening
There are some voices in the background after 39:00... can anyone understand what it is?
Its some kind of feedback loop. It is him, but just like 1 second earlier
That is "print-through" on the analog tape. Any time you hear it, if you listen carefully you will hear that a second or so later, he pronounces something sharply and the print-through has simply anticipated the sound, due to the magnetism being transferred from one layer of the tape to the next. In terms of recorded levels this tape was obviously being pushed to the limit and beyond; you can hear that from the spittiness and smearing of the "s", "sh" and "st" sounds, and to record at such high flux levels also invites print-through.
I really hope you channel won't be banned.
The cyclus repeats it again
He:" Life is beautiful, right before the Storm from the East!"
"The victories kept getting closer and closer..."
I hope not. There are too many documentaries about this era all using recycled material. However would you consider translating the videos on "In respect of Maurice De Wilde" ? As I believe only personal accounts from the other side are of interest now. Consider TIKs Stalingrad videos are only averaging 100,000/200,000 views despite the huge effort that goes into making them. Also I've contacted a few publishers asking them about translating more books from the German perspective; and the overall message was: interest in the era is falling, finding the owner can be difficult, and each book is a gamble as to whether they'll make a profit or not.
I'm not a German speaker but it's obvious he had a very pleasant and reassuring voice -- surely a way to mask his evil and manipulative ways (biggest womanizer of the regime as well). A small and unpleasant looking man, he certainly had some talent for communication.
The english subtitles do not show up
Need a link to a crash corse in German so I can understand this figured out the sub titles it works