bost h i speak as a person who knows Nightwish since yesterday: her voice is really pop-like and actually has nothing peculiar or special, while Tarja has a soprano voice who gave to songs a special atmosphere... then it's always hard for fans to see the band changing
@@meriemc5475 you fans never do. I like her the best out of the three because she wasn't simply invited as a member. She had to fight her way into the band. Tuomas almost turned her down, but she fought back. Especially after some performances, she may have had some downfalls, but came back with a vengeance at the next one. Tarja and Floor simply had the better ranges than Anette, but they never had to carry the burden of criticisms that Anette did. You refuse to accept the change because you're so fucking bullheaded that you automatically go for the one with the better sound, which was Tarja and/or Floor. Anette was overshadowed by a lot of fans like you who refused to accept the change that Nightwish made. Give her the chance before being so quick to judge her.
@@jeremybarker5510 OMG!! I ve nothing against her or anyone else, I just said simply that we (people) don't accept change, cause that true, on so many things is hard on humans in general to let go, so for me this may be the reason people don't like her, and honestly I like Tarja more cause she was there when I heard the band's song for the first time, and I'm not saying that Tarja is the best or whatever what made you thing that I'm just a stupidass B** or bullheaded as you said, next time think twice before writing something, cause I didn't say I don't accept change but i said we don't accept change
I'm having trouble deciding which I like more. Both are completely different and both are very talented. They both bring a completely different sound to Nightwish. And both of those sounds are great!
That is good to hear, nothing is more satisfying than giving people good advice and then being told they already follow it. Makes you have a much higher opinion of said person.
In all honesty, I find that up until the vocals, I can't tell the difference between Tarja's Nightwish and Annette's Nightwish. That just proves that the band is the same and their instrumentation is just as good. That's why they still have tons of fans.
This video epitomizes why I like this band and ones like it more than most of the mainstream metal bands, not that they are bad necessarily, but just look at these guys when they are playing, they are ROCKING up there, the passion, I love that
Finally the hills are without eyes They are tired of painting a dead man's face red with their own blood They used to love having so much to lose Blink your eyes just once and see everything in ruins Did you ever hear what I told you? Did you ever read what I wrote you? Did you ever listen to what we played? Did you ever let in what the world said? Did we get this far just to feel your hate? Did we play to become only pawns in the game? How blind can you be, don't you see? You chose the long road, but we'll be waiting Bye bye, beautiful Jacob`s ghost for the girl in white Blindfold for the blind Dead Siblings walking the dying Earth Noose around a choking heart Eternity torn apart Slow toll now the funeral bells "I need to die to feel alive" Bye bye, beautiful It's not the tree that forsakes the flower But the flower that forsakes the tree Someday I`ll learn to love these scars Still fresh from the red-hot blade of your words How blind can you be, don't you see? That the gambler lost all he does not have... Bye bye, beautiful (:
I must to say that i´m a lover of metal add deathmetal, i know this its very comercial however i admit that it´s very very good, not yet i say for the girls hahaha, Nightwish is for me a awesome band, ANETTE sings fantastic it´s true, TARJA got a talent opera voice and FLOOR got energy so much
+Анатолий Шариков Это все от того что мы привыкли брать ложку рукой и есть, а теперь нам ложку вставляют в ногу и говорят что так тоже можно кушать. Но нет мы так не хотим, Ария без Кипелова и найтвишь без Тарьи - это ложка в левой ноге. Можно никто не спорит но это уже не то.
rather than bashing Annette and bellyaching how you miss Tarja, enjoy the music. Annette has a great voice and vocals, and while it's true that she doesn't have the practiced voice of Tarja, she is unique in her own way, and should be given respect, not derision.
I've always wondered what is the technic behind Marco's screaming. (At "bye bye beautiful" -part) Its unique and and very powerful sounding effect. Its like high vocal rasp without falsetto on bottom...??? Iam confused :D
I think he's actually yelling, like I might if I were angry. The song is an angry, edgy one anyway, by what everyone seems to take from the lyrics. In this case, though, that also shows his vocal talent and skill; yelling within proper key. His vocal control in that case, well, he makes it seem easy! God, if I only had half that talent!
No matter what your nationality is be proud of your heritage, do not hate what you cannot change. Though you should still embrace other cultures as long as they are not oppressive and/or condemning. Not mastering a language is not a big deal as there is hundreds of them, as long as you have a basic understanding of a few major languages you should be able to get far. I am not a native English speaker either, but my love for classic English poetry have vastly increased my vocabulary.
I really like the way the camera doesn't really focus on the models playing their instruments especially the drummer. All very creative and keep a very nice illusion.
This was shortly after Tarja split from Nightwish- as I understand it, having models that very clearly can't replace the band members was to accentuate that Tarja would never find a replacement for the band and that they'd already replaced her.
What I have read recently says she was turning into an uncooperative bitch. As much as I like her voice better, Im glad she got the hammer of justice in the face. I hate people with attitudes.
heres a quick recap: Tarja was fired because because she was a bit of a bitch, also his husband/agent was a dick too. Anette came after that. Sang until 2012, left from the band because of musical differences, Floor Jansen came and replaced her after that.
To each their own, bud. I think they both are great just because they don't have the same style. So they are great in their own respects. But I know people have favorites. No big.
A group of girls of near-model appearance, while appealing in it's own way, is definitely not what I picture when I think of the people who play this song. It's quite interesting to watch it switch to the chorus for the first time.
I quit Nightwish when Tarja went away. I never listened to anything else except for now. I started the video and I was like "WHAT!? NIGHTWISH IS NOW ONLY GIRLS!? WHAT!?" Then I was relieved, but still this is "Nightpop" wtf seriously. Next step will be.... seeing Hayley Williams singing on Nightwish? (I love Hayley btw)
+LinkSaya Well, if you are just now listening to a Nightwish song agian. Why do you listen to a over 7 years old song? Also Anette isn't even in Nightwish anyomore.
Am i the only one that likes all the Nightwish singers ( Tarja, Floor and Anette)?
No, you're not the only one because I like the three singers too.
Me too
Bye bye beautiful! Adiós Tarja! Lo grandioso de Nightwish se fue con ella.
FINALY!
I remembered the clip and finaly i found the band and song.
Now its time to enjoy nostalgia
Did you notice? Roadrunner fixed the audio of every Nightwish video!! :D
Nice how they can make such a good song about kicking out their old lead singer
From what I heard, it was a very bitter departure. I guess they're trying to send her a message that she just wasn't getting....
Not quite as nice as the song they wrote about the Nightwish fans murdering Anette Olzon.
*If you would pay attention to the lyrics, then you would have find the line "...you chose the long road, but we'll be waiting."*
I like most songs like this from NightWish, where the balance of the male and female singer is balanced.
I don't understand why everyone hates on Annette, sure she's different, but she's not bad.
bost h i speak as a person who knows Nightwish since yesterday: her voice is really pop-like and actually has nothing peculiar or special, while Tarja has a soprano voice who gave to songs a special atmosphere... then it's always hard for fans to see the band changing
Boston Heaford I think because she is a ‘bright’ sounding singer and Tarja is a Dark mezzo. It’s a totally different sound.
Cause we don't accepte the change
@@meriemc5475 you fans never do. I like her the best out of the three because she wasn't simply invited as a member. She had to fight her way into the band. Tuomas almost turned her down, but she fought back. Especially after some performances, she may have had some downfalls, but came back with a vengeance at the next one. Tarja and Floor simply had the better ranges than Anette, but they never had to carry the burden of criticisms that Anette did. You refuse to accept the change because you're so fucking bullheaded that you automatically go for the one with the better sound, which was Tarja and/or Floor. Anette was overshadowed by a lot of fans like you who refused to accept the change that Nightwish made. Give her the chance before being so quick to judge her.
@@jeremybarker5510 OMG!! I ve nothing against her or anyone else, I just said simply that we (people) don't accept change, cause that true, on so many things is hard on humans in general to let go, so for me this may be the reason people don't like her, and honestly I like Tarja more cause she was there when I heard the band's song for the first time, and I'm not saying that Tarja is the best or whatever what made you thing that I'm just a stupidass B** or bullheaded as you said, next time think twice before writing something, cause I didn't say I don't accept change but i said we don't accept change
Is this a Loreal commercial?
hahahahahaha
X'D
hahahahaha
+MrArchDelux Yes. And they are worth it.
And they make this for free.
I'm having trouble deciding which I like more. Both are completely different and both are very talented. They both bring a completely different sound to Nightwish. And both of those sounds are great!
I first discovered this band around 14 years old and it still makes me headband
So unbelievably UNDERRATED!
This video is so much fun to show to dudes. "Ok, bunch of hot girls, I can dig it. Wait. WHAT THE FUCK"
pixymae That is pretty hilarious. Lol
pixymae That's quite presumptuous and misandrist
I too just hit the " what the fuck moment " lbvs like where the hell the women go?!?! Lol
+pixymae This music video is secretly a trap thread from 4Chan
I have HD-remaster of this video! Best quality!
T
Where ?
@@Agonized_Soul follow the blue circle )))
@@HDFactory-HD I did, u have other night wish songs but not bye bye beautiful
@@Agonized_Soul search for "bye bye 4k" )))
Marco Hietala is a fucking hero! I saw Nightwish live in Amsterdam yesterday and it was soo awesome!! :D
Honestly...both singers are extremely talented, I won't doubt that. :) In the end, I love 'em both!
Pretty sure the girls represent a parallel dimension where "Lylith" lives in all men.
***** yep, the original outlook of socialism placed the women above the man. Praising the sinasarus and her sinista
***** seems to be what the lyrics are about. Who he's asking if they understand it I'm sure is her
I love Nightwish, their music is great.
Even after years the song is still great
Why would time make great songs not great?
This is the first time that i hear a female voice coming from a woman in this kind of metal
That is good to hear, nothing is more satisfying than giving people good advice and then being told they already follow it. Makes you have a much higher opinion of said person.
It was through this song that I slowly but surely started to get one of my teachers into metal back in high school >:D
my younger brother did that with my teacher, but he did it with Apocalyptica XD
Jonathan Jensen Apocalyptica was the second band I introduced her to, so that makes sense.
Your younger brother sounds cool lol
you have balls, call this metal!
what?
JK Quinn do you think this is metal ?? lol
Bye bye beautiful, bye bye to Nightwish.....
Kyra Hultz - keyboards (Tuomas Holopainen double)
Ines Brigman - guitar (Emppu Vuorinen double)
Alicia Sixtor - drums (Jukka Nevalainen double)
Leslie Crow - bass (Marco Hietala double)
In all honesty, I find that up until the vocals, I can't tell the difference between Tarja's Nightwish and Annette's Nightwish. That just proves that the band is the same and their instrumentation is just as good. That's why they still have tons of fans.
I love this band because they just keep on going from one extent to the next. Very dependable for my imagination. Marshall Wright
this was the music that got me to the world of metal
This video epitomizes why I like this band and ones like it more than most of the mainstream metal bands, not that they are bad necessarily, but just look at these guys when they are playing, they are ROCKING up there, the passion, I love that
100% agree, she treated them like dirt even though they carried her to the top. Good luck Anette.
nightwish should get their singer back
This is literally the least subtle song Nightwish has ever written.
I agree, they are both good. It's just annoying how ppl go onto songs that anette sings and complain about her and how Nightwish "isn't the same".
Holy fuck, I forgot I liked this in Middle School.
When i first saw this video i didn't know much about nightwish and i thought it was a girl's band.
HAHAHA oh man thanks for that. Gave me a chuckle.
Finally the hills are without eyes
They are tired of painting a dead man's face
red with their own blood
They used to love having so much to lose
Blink your eyes just once and see everything in ruins
Did you ever hear what I told you?
Did you ever read what I wrote you?
Did you ever listen to what we played?
Did you ever let in what the world said?
Did we get this far just to feel your hate?
Did we play to become only pawns in the game?
How blind can you be, don't you see?
You chose the long road, but we'll be waiting
Bye bye, beautiful
Jacob`s ghost for the girl in white
Blindfold for the blind
Dead Siblings walking the dying Earth
Noose around a choking heart
Eternity torn apart
Slow toll now the funeral bells
"I need to die to feel alive"
Bye bye, beautiful
It's not the tree that forsakes the flower
But the flower that forsakes the tree
Someday I`ll learn to love these scars
Still fresh from the red-hot blade of your words
How blind can you be, don't you see?
That the gambler lost all he does not have...
Bye bye, beautiful
(:
1904
I love Anette's hair in this video.
Cool! I would like more of this kind of songs "Bye Bye Beayutiful"! Under this song wants to come off on the full! I can listen to of a long time!
I must to say that i´m a lover of metal add deathmetal, i know this its very comercial however i admit that it´s very very good, not yet i say for the girls hahaha, Nightwish is for me a awesome band, ANETTE sings fantastic it´s true, TARJA got a talent opera voice and FLOOR got energy so much
could not agree more :D
my best music is bye bye beautifull and i love nightwish music
@xXPROMETHIUSXx i wish there were more people like you who supported nightwish no matter what
I wished Anette kept her hair like in this video, she looked really well with it.
Still miss Tarja!!
I'am so sad because Marko is gone.....
Marco Hietela is holding all the solos alone..
Agreed so much. He gives the songs so much more variety. Songs with both him and Anette like this one are my favorites.
Love this song. All of Nightwish vocalists have great voices, Tarja, Anette, Marco and Floor, but Floor seems to be the best for Nightwish.
Найтвишь без Кипелова не Найтвишь...
жжош )))
xaxaxaxaxa
цой жив
+Анатолий Шариков Это все от того что мы привыкли брать ложку рукой и есть, а теперь нам ложку вставляют в ногу и говорят что так тоже можно кушать. Но нет мы так не хотим, Ария без Кипелова и найтвишь без Тарьи - это ложка в левой ноге. Можно никто не спорит но это уже не то.
This is a good song, it's sad that Nightwish won't be playing it live anymore
Can't stop missing Tarja. Ofc Anette is good too but still old Nightwish is really close to my heart
Symphonic Metal :333
2019 who still listening?
которая на барабанах, вообще шикарная!!!
rather than bashing Annette and bellyaching how you miss Tarja, enjoy the music. Annette has a great voice and vocals, and while it's true that she doesn't have the practiced voice of Tarja, she is unique in her own way, and should be given respect, not derision.
I've always wondered what is the technic behind Marco's screaming. (At "bye bye beautiful" -part) Its unique and and very powerful sounding effect. Its like high vocal rasp without falsetto on bottom...??? Iam confused :D
Jani Laaksonen most likely an overlay, to make it more epic, it's still good tho
I think he's actually yelling, like I might if I were angry. The song is an angry, edgy one anyway, by what everyone seems to take from the lyrics.
In this case, though, that also shows his vocal talent and skill; yelling within proper key. His vocal control in that case, well, he makes it seem easy! God, if I only had half that talent!
TARJA= NIGHTWISH
This is the video that got me hooked and started it all, back when it came out. Such a great song too.
szacun dla tego co ogladal ;d
He make this because he want told Tarja how he feel all that what happened 2005
nina sihvonne what happened?
they kicked Tarja out of band because they said she start acting like diva.
Oh I didn't know that
QUE HERMOSA VOZ .
Nightwish ftw.
No matter what your nationality is be proud of your heritage, do not hate what you cannot change. Though you should still embrace other cultures as long as they are not oppressive and/or condemning.
Not mastering a language is not a big deal as there is hundreds of them, as long as you have a basic understanding of a few major languages you should be able to get far. I am not a native English speaker either, but my love for classic English poetry have vastly increased my vocabulary.
....again in 2016..
I can't watch this video (I listen to it) because I get too distracted by the eye candy to actually listen to the song...
Yes, same here. Took me about fifteen playthroughs to realize it, too. Then, from out of the blue, "Wait, WHAT?!" lol
Teddi Darling
the
Teddi Darling Too right, the female bass player is unbelievably hot!!!
ythinder, they're ALL incredibly hot! This is from 2007; I wonder where they are now?
James Curfman In my bed!! 😉
I really like the way the camera doesn't really focus on the models playing their instruments especially the drummer. All very creative and keep a very nice illusion.
you are so right !!!
those girls, really don't know how to play those instruments...... deep inside me, I feel disappointed.....
+angelo bangz models...
+angelo bangz
They aren't there as musicians, they are there for the bewb effect.
what bewbz?
psy, maybe you should realize they are stand ins for the band in the video not actually the ones playing the song
This was shortly after Tarja split from Nightwish- as I understand it, having models that very clearly can't replace the band members was to accentuate that Tarja would never find a replacement for the band and that they'd already replaced her.
her voice is very pop for this music
Also her movements.
Totally agree,I thought that only I think like that xD
Absolutely wrong, everyone miss Anette, actually Nightwish is navigating in oblivion for their bad decisions
Listen to Imaginaerum and stfu
Lol
Great song
I agree, he's the best of the best
Ben Stiller on drums
Hello. I come back ofter 10 years of not listening. Who is this woman? Where tarja? Did i miss something?
DreamVikings Im sorry but she is gone.
DreamVikings she is already gone 10 years ago :( you probably missed the introduction of two singers
What I have read recently says she was turning into an uncooperative bitch. As much as I like her voice better, Im glad she got the hammer of justice in the face. I hate people with attitudes.
heres a quick recap: Tarja was fired because because she was a bit of a bitch, also his husband/agent was a dick too. Anette came after that. Sang until 2012, left from the band because of musical differences, Floor Jansen came and replaced her after that.
Well, Marcelo Cabuli is Argentinian. Being one myself, I can certify he is probably a scumbag. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
i feel stupid, and i thank you!
Under her caress angels bleed
Cemented by their stare drinking the tears like wine we
spilled
The singers (women) shoes change in 2:18 and 2:24
in response of female band to male band - i noticed it too.
they change multiple times
lo siento pero Nightwish sin Tarja es como comerse un helado con la lengua envuelta en plastico...
eso mismo ejejejeje
Sin duda...
Amén
Psychosadistic Design spanish comes from Spain
thanks finally somebody has taste for music
als ich 7 wahr hab ich das immer mit mein dad gehört jetz habe ich es endlich wieder gefunden
The girl playing org ❤
I agree!
the only time where my sexual desires for the band members other than the lead singer are okay.
this video.
Amazing band ❤️ ❤️ ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Still i cant bear to listen to The NIGHTWISH without the sound of TRAZA in it :( this is so sad :(
I miss Annette
I miss Tarja...
i miss hot-dogs...
I miss my socks
I cant be the only one who got a SAW theme feel at the start xD
CjGaming. Just a bit now where you mentions it. Can never hear the song the same way again now 😅
Me too, had the same feeling after the first listening session in 2007.
awwww sta genial est video me encanta......!!!!!!
To each their own, bud. I think they both are great just because they don't have the same style. So they are great in their own respects. But I know people have favorites. No big.
what's the name of girls playing guitars?
The name of the guitar player is Ines Brigman....what a beautiful woman
Prefiro a Tarja
Без Тарии нет больше группы Найтвиш!
For me, this is the best song with Anette...
you dedicated this to Tarja,now I dedicate this to you.Bye Bye
King :))
Nightwish have won enough new fans....so bye-bye also to you...
u ll never change the fact that TARJA was best :D
Bye Bye Beautifuls, jai liked this
The guy with the long blonde hair, i got to shake his hand at the end of the concert last year at sydney enmore theater i'm not even 12 yet XD
Without Tarja, its like normal metal band, like not Nightwish.. :/
+Viktor Lozanoff i really cant tell the difference
Since Tarja left the band Nightwish became a simple pop rock band.
A group of girls of near-model appearance, while appealing in it's own way, is definitely not what I picture when I think of the people who play this song. It's quite interesting to watch it switch to the chorus for the first time.
they arean awesome band whoever they have as there lead singer but the way they treat there lead singers is unbelieveable
I'd laugh if Annette turned into a boy for the chorus!!!
I quit Nightwish when Tarja went away. I never listened to anything else except for now. I started the video and I was like "WHAT!? NIGHTWISH IS NOW ONLY GIRLS!? WHAT!?" Then I was relieved, but still this is "Nightpop" wtf seriously. Next step will be.... seeing Hayley Williams singing on Nightwish? (I love Hayley btw)
+LinkSaya Well, if you are just now listening to a Nightwish song agian. Why do you listen to a over 7 years old song? Also Anette isn't even in Nightwish anyomore.
miksu2222 Because I love the old an original Nightwish. The answer was obvious.
Floor, is quite good and is not as poppy as Abette. Tarja was mysterious but Floor is powerful. Try listening to the live wacken concert with floor.
Well that escalated quickly.
miksu2222 Yeah, we are speaking kindly and with respect, and then this guy appears xD
This song is written for Tarja so that she has to think about 9 years she worked with this band
I always hope that Tarja could be back
I like nightwish, before and after. They adjusted well to the singers and the amazing music and lyrics still come with it.