The Dinosaurs of Path of Titans Have an Identity Crisis
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 07. 2024
- This is a video that I honestly wasn't sure that I would get through with finishing. This is very much an opinion and I'm worried of people thinking I'm nothing but a sourpuss. But with feedback with my friends and other members of the community, I've been encouraged to release. Hope you can see where I'm coming from.
Discord - / discord
Patreon - www.patreon.com/user?u=82257937 - Hry
A spec evo dinosaur game with entirely fictious species is slowly becoming a better and better idea to me ngl
oooh
@@extrack2059 The idea is mainly for Dinosaur enthusiast. Something more like Keenan Taylor's Kaimere than Monster Hunter or Ark
Wonderful idea actually. You could use insular dwarfism or somesuch as an excuse to make everything more relatively sensible size-wise.
@@manglisaurus3537 they are paid though important to point that out. But tbh its catching these stand alone games fast! POTs playerbase is definitely young enough to jump onto roblox so I expect Prior to grow a lot in the next year!
@@ghidorahmagnus1185 bruh real dinosaurs are better
i know it isn't perfect and agree with everything you said, but the fact that Pot supports mods and update much more often than The Isle, makes it the best dinosaur survival game we have today, at least for me
100% agree, Even if you do not like pot as a gams, you can definitely respect it.
Yeah and not like PoT is meant use dinos that aren't remotely close to isle creatures plus Isle is adding a lot of creatures that were originally in PoT
@@sammcorbett-ip7im The Isle actually came up first with some of the concepts. It's just that the game never gets updates and the few it has don't always include new dinosaurs.
Agreed honestly
Yeah, modding does make the playing experience much better.
Still waiting for my sweat baby boy, apatosaurus.
Unlike the Isle Path of Titans does seem to actually _care_ about their dinosaurs somewhat even if they are misguided. This niche genre is probably going to be forever cursed, but PoT is probably the _least_ cursed.
creature accuracy they care about but creature quality ehh...
Regarding accuracy, yes, quality debatable. Yes, the Isle releases their dinos at an abysmal rate, but they have way more thought put into them.
@@stefanmoorejr As long as the isle insists on its Jurassic world knockoff raptor, naked gallimimus and similar bullshit, that game is dead to me.
@@tjarkschweizer Well....... ackchewally🤓 Its not utah its""""""oooommmniiii""""" and im pretty sure they're going to have a feathered option in the future.
Plus, ovi, hypsi,austro, and cherry have feathers, and they look great.
@@stefanmoorejr In case you didn't notice, feathers are far from my only issue with the isle.
Still have no idea why someone bought barsboldia despite lambeo being planned already, could have easily just been edmontosaurus. Same goes for deinonychus and laten.
Edmontosaurus just looks alot better than THE AMAZING BULK impression PoT barsboldia gives.
Plus bars is know from a single backbone while Saurolophus which literally coexisted with it has so much more info on it
And pot barsboldia is just kinda ugly imo
I'm fine with the designs not being completely accurate, I've come to expect it and I'll do that myself.
But there does come a point where it becomes dumb. I was legitimately interested in pycno as a large 3.3t abeli (nearly 4t if you scale it to a spec. adult size) but the lead dev photoshopped horns onto the silhouette and turned it into a carno, one of the cringest things I've seen in a while.
The roster size wise would have been fine if they planned it from the beginning, but since half of them are paid for and weren't planned, there is a lot of overlap. Like seriously, what is mirigaia going to do that you couldn't just give to kentro or stego?
Poisonous spikes miragaia : )
(No kidding, have seen that be discussed in the discord lmao)
he's the kind of person that kicks down the door, sais, what *should be* obviouse shit, and walk away like he did not cause the most conterversial topics to come back again, but i love it
"sais?" did yah mean sighs*?
@@vh4-rr545 Says
Honestly if I made one of these games, I’d name all the dinosaurs dubious genus names like Tyrannosaurus rex being Dynamosaurus Imperiosis or make a chimera of several dinosaurs in the same group(closely related) like Spinosaurus Chimerus. Another idea is to use fragmentary dinosaurs so you can fill in gaps with realism and imagination.
Craziness
For the thumbnail it should’ve been an image of Bar and a Cow
hmm. As much as I enjoy this game and like a lot of their design choices, I also enjoy hearing your opinion and watching your vids. I'll hear you out, though we may not agree.
Then again though, its not like I'm on board with *every* choice they make and I'm curious to see where our critiques line up and where they differ.
See you at premier :)
I feel like these dinosaur games have severe balance issues nowadays, and often reject a creature that has a chance of playing differently for "being too similar"
Its clear POT fall in the realm of clearly knowing what it is and just taking other ideas and calling it "inspiration" or for some of the dinosaurs "speculation"
Either I can't wait to watch this video, as it's another Scanova the Carnotaurus video,and those are always amazing
Hope y'all have a wonderful day
“It’s speculation guys don’t question my shit design choices “ - Matt the bird 🦅
Matt doesn't really know much nor care about dinosaurs at all, I just hope those choices aren't entirely made by him, but I wouldn't be surprised, lmao
@@maverick2560 the dinosaur dev doesn’t care about dinosaurs 💀💀💀
@@darthdistix1895 matt is the programmer not the modeler
@@Leaf-tf5oo leaf mf on his way to realise what a satire joke is and why are you always trying to defend the game in every video I see 💀
@@darthdistix1895 😂precisely
Learning more about this game, such as the fact that there are actually unlockable skills and things that are obviously unrealistic such as buffing and healing roars, Metri's poisonous bite doesn't bother me so much anymore. I just think it would have been better as an unlockable skill later on as an option if the player wants it.
I feel like the thal is suffering in preparation for one of the other official flier of the game, hatzegoptertyx, which i feel is more 'famously' a bludgeoning, frightening azhdarchid. some of this can be 'fixed' with the planned battle system update in my opinion, but as path of titans stands... well, like you said, i exclusively play on community servers. its gameplay loop is generally broken atm- the idea of questing, in theory, is understandable. you want players to move around and be more likely to encounter one another. but the map is still just way too big for its server size, and without passive growth, moving from one area to another feels like wasting time. plus, without nesting, adult dinos basically serve no purpose but to walk around and hope you can pick a fight with somebody. as an Adult With A Job(tm) not losing an entire dinosaur to death makes path of titans the most preferable for the time and mental energy i have. i've just accepted all dino games have Problems and i have to pick my battles, lol.
Yeah thats what the general feeling is on official servers, also the reason kosing is so previlent on official
Well the thing is.. and I don’t really understand this mentality people have but! Community servers absolutely blow d@ck especially the people on there! And I mean the dog sh@t rules n the cry babies that abuse those rules and in general become kill joys to go up against especially once your and adult looking for a good fight!
These are all valid critiques for the game tbh, but I noticed the devs do moderate accuracy nowadays (which is better than none at all) . The point you mentioned, "the ability to be unique was right there and they didn't take it" is so strong. This game could benefit from more abilities that make these playable more intriguing and there's def hope for that
Great to see another video essay from you, Scanova!
It feels weird too
That some dinos are odd to not be there
Or they just choose the sams creature with a different name
Like the Carno. It's not a Carno but it looks like a Carno
So why not just go with Carno. Which is a modded Dino
Also why don't they just add the Modded creatures to the main game. Like pay the creators and add them
All the work is done
Like tbh u can say that about a lot of games like Minecraft and even ark! But at least path of titans does modded creature shout outs! That’s something at least.
@@No_name8374 Ark does make mod official
Primitive + and Ark + mods became part of the main game
@@kiryuthedragonwarrior2746 well yeah community maps! But ummm primitive plus is kinda dead 😅
Because some mods are just op and don’t fit in with the stats of the official Dino’s
Since Pycno got added to the game, now I how annoying it's to have a obscure dino you like only for it to be misunderstood with a famous relative. Now it's doesn't bother me too much that Pycno in game is basically a copy of Carno, but every time I play as a Pycno, I will always pick up P.imperator, which is the only one that doesn't look like Carno (and just like I said when it was first added, I have nothing against Carnotaurus, but I hate that Pycnonemosaurus in game is just a Carnotaurus with a different name. And the "but they're from the same family" is a stupid excuse, because lion and tiger are from the same family, but they do look different from each other). Man, I swear if I get to know how to make mods for this game, I will remake Pycnonemosaurus.
The worst part is, Tigers and lions aren't only in the same family, but they're literally the same genus (Panthera) meaning that there could of been just as much variation within the genus Pycnonemosaurus, as their is from a snow leopard to a lion.
It honestly would have been NO issue if they had _only_ made the attack subspecies look like carno.
When making a dinosaur product, in general, you need each dinosaur to have a unique feature not only in appearance, but also in playability, so that not everything is the same. Example, they could put Tyrano as a devastating predator but weak with large prey like Brachio, but instead would be an Acrocanthosaurus, which with its bite would rend and inflict more damage on large animals, but would be weaker than the rex.
Campto getting updated gives me hope that the rest of the playables will be updated in the same manner. I really can't give a shit about Thalassodromeus with it being a Pteranodon clone, but if it turned into a more accurate or at the very least more mainland based animal it will make me much more interested in playing it.
Next PoT herbivore revealed! A small Ornithischian dinosaur (like Dryo or Parksosaurus) that ends up being a Camptosaurus reskin
Animal/Dinosaur games should be the f*cking easiest thing to balance in the entire universe. Like bro, It's already balanced for you! Just learn how the probably acted/interacted and (logically) fill in the gaps. Stegosaurus and Allosaurus are already a balanced matchup, because they co-existed, they had to be. Same goes for Tyrannosaurus and Triceratops, or Dasp and Lambeosaurus. Just choose you're dinosaurs wisely, choose ones that co-existed and you're good.
Dinosaurs often feel empty and boring. The easiest way in my opinion to fix this, is by giving them more than 2 basic damn needs. Real animals aren't eating, drinking and fighting robots. They need insulation, ways to cool off, sleep, rest and in general it takes a lot to maintain yourself. Should be the same for these games, This distracts players from KoS'ing, griefing and being annoying, whilst also feeling like you actually have to play the game. Kills two birds with one stone essentially.
Nice Video comparing the dinosaurs from Path of Titans to other dinosaur related games especially The Isle in my opinion and I pretty much agree with most points that you’ve made on the video.
I do like the dinosaurs in Path of Titans but I’ll admit that they’re not as great as the dinosaurs from The Isle, Saurian and Prehistoric Kingdom which those are way better in my opinion.
Great work analysis and keep it up.
This is good, I’m a pot enthusiast and fan, you point out all the issues and etc, thank you for making a video on this.
Could someone explain to me what exactly a "burst damage, hit boxer type fighter" is? I'm actually rather curious as to what its previous combat niche could have been.
Honestly, I was on the fence about getting POT because I could very much tell they were trying to go very "Legacy Isle" in concept, but when they released Thalassodromeus and it was just a knockoff BOB/Isle Ptera hybrid that pretty much decided for me I don't want the game. If they aren't willing to try and come up with their own playstyles in concept, the game is really just riding off the tailwinds of BOB and The Isle. If you're going to pick an animal with a well known behavior, either real or theorized, and just ignore that, why even pick it? It's not even like they were "subverting expectations", because they just went and turned it into the thing that Pterosaurs are normally known for.
Thal can do exactly what it did irl in game, it also has gotten a wave of land based abilities, thal is the generalist flyer, the middle ground between hatz and rhamp, anyone who complains about thal not being able to 1v1 the mid tiers need to rethink why they even bother bringing up the fact that it had the strongest known bite force of pterosaurs despite already knowing what it did with that bite force.
@Leaf making it focus on aquatic food is what I'm talking about. I have never played the game so I have no idea how it matches up to midtiers, but it's pretty clear they intend for you to dive into the water to catch fish with it. Which makes absolutely no sense and doesn't even look right.
@@FlishonyanKing most thal players dont fish but scavenge off of food left behind by other predators.
Also, since the game is going for an rpg experience, they should lean harder on that aspect and make each genus (esp those that are more similar) have more unique abilities and stats
They already do to an extent, but they should amp it up a bit so that choosing each animal feels more commited to a certain playstyle
I’ve suggested on servers I play on before that we don’t add the Edmontosaurus mod, because it’s just roster bloat, it’s just going to be Barsboldia but it can graze and maybe is a tiny bit better.
Edmon will be COMPLETEY different from bars because it will probably use its head and have a stomp attack while bars depends on its tail as its head but and bite are terrible for pvp unless you wanna nip something as a warning
@@sammcorbett-ip7im that’s not “completely different”. And besides, the vast majority of modded creatures have extended abilities when the official creatures do not. also a bite and a stomp attack? Wow, I sure don’t think any other of the 5 apex herbivores have that, and that’s excluding the 4 modded ones that are common amongst servers. Theri, Amp, Argent and Para.
@@weaversong4377 One man's 'Roster Bloat' is another man's 'Enjoyable Variety'.
I wish we could just get ONE accurate dinosaur game! The isle had a great opportunity with their Evrima remaster but they wanted to cash in on the Jurassic Park designs instead, path of Titans is just bad and Saurian is pretty much dead because it hasn’t had an update in 7 years, and even then it’s not entirely accurate. At the moment we’re just looking at Ark II which although not meant to be accurate, has the most accurate depiction of a dromeosaurid since prehistoric planet. And the most accurate sabertooth depiction of any prehistory media!
Like tbh I say path does a good job on accuracy! Tbh it’s there more recent designs that really miss the ball. Like kawaki, pycno, pachy and of course sarco especially in the way it moves on land 💀 there is a reason why people consider the isles deino the better croc out of the two! But besides that and a few out liars I think path does a decent job 👍
@@No_name8374 yeah I do like some of their designs but although they care more about accuracy than say, Jurassic world. It’s still not a priority. And I believe that accuracy is the TOP priority! I do plan on eventually trying to make a game with accuracy being the sole focus. But if it does happen, don’t expect it for like a decade. Especially since I’m still (at least what I would consider to be) a junior palaeontologist in training (although I have been studying for 16 years)
@@DreadEnder Accuracy is not a top priority.
That is what Saurian tried to do, and now it is in development hell because accuracy keeps changing as we learn more and more.
@@charchadonto for some things like spinosaurus that is true, but our understanding of tyrannosaurus has not changed much apart from being stockier and having lips since 1999 and saurian had a lack of support early on, a development team of only 2 and started making the game before attempting to get funding, along with infrequent updates, bad graphics, not a very good plan for future development and it didn’t even have accuracy as it’s top priority. The Tyrannosaurus was inaccurate it’s time along with the dakotaraptor. And they were apparently planning on implementing an ability based system like Ark. which worked for Ark because it’s not based on accuracy. It didn’t work for saurian.
@@charchadonto and when accuracy is a top priority, you get the correct funding and pre development exposure, you get prehistoric planet. The most influential and popular media piece EVER released on Apple TV
ive played all three religiously, and i still think evrima is the best out there. especially after the new update. It's combat feels rewarding and the diet system makes sense to accelerate growth time. it doesnt matter what you play as, if you're skilled you can make it on evrima. POT no matter what server i play seems to be this giant carno moshpit or carebare simulator. always groups of 10+ different species dino's hanging out at the local hang spot on each map. Its really unimmersive.
The least they could do is split them into different combat categories e.g; power, DoT or hybrid kinda like legacy Isle. I think they kinda have a thing going with the ability to choose defense, speed etc but its super bare bones and would love to see it shine more like mmo's (I could go on a tangent...). I feel like there's not much you can do if you're taking an archetype e.g; anky being a tank and making ano mimic that playstyle because in the end I feel like players will rag on it either way. They're gonna brush it off as "just another anky like all the other games" or "oh look anky in disguise". Like what do you even do with the dino's identity at that point? Make it a tank or innovate and turn it into something of a hybrid, CC/displacement creature? The game has so much potential... I just wish the skillsets weren't so generic & bland.
Thalassodromeus is strange to me. It has the stats of a smaller dinosaur - why not simply make it the right size? As for its role in the game? I have no idea what they were going for. Without other fliers to contextualize its place it is a glorified spectator in most cases. I think the single thing I find most distracting in the game is that facts are changed about a dinosaur (like the Bars, Met and Ank) when one could simply find a dinosaur of the appropriate size and quality to put in the game and it would be a better game for it effort.
It is a shame that the design philosophy seems to be, "Change a dinosaur to meet the desired gameplay." Rather than, "Find a dinosaur to meet the desired gameplay." It isn't a hard task.
Kaiwekia should be a herbivore. Why not? I see no logic here except that they wanted to add an aquatic predator.
There are plenty of examples of Aquatic predators - put them in the game and it will be a more immersive and enjoyable experience, and we might even be able to argue there is some educational value to the game.
Bird and flying creatures are always lighter than they look
@@tommygarrosh2941 That's a fair observation. I think my point still stands given that the Thal doesn't have more than a few proto-feathers. Birds are smaller than they appear because the feathers offer additional visual weight without much actual mass. We don't have many bats in my country so I don't have any personal experience with that animal.
Additionally, the Thal is imagined in the game to be an aquatic animal that dives for prey. From what I understand, most birds that do this tend to be heavier boned simply to allow for the impact and stress of diving several metres below the surface. Maybe I'm wrong, but the Thal simply seems oversized to me.
you know what, after this video, i want animation with quetz doing "God slap" to the plane. pretty fair points, especially sucks that thal and kai are just ptera and plesio
I can agree with kai
But thal is just a weird mixture of land based and fisher, the devs wanted it to he the generalist, which I can get behind.
@@Leaf-tf5oo I think thal is like 60% land predator 30% fish because like nobody wants to just fly and eat fish while it's fun flying above grand plains spotting a deinon or laten and swooping down and biting it
@@sammcorbett-ip7im yep! Agreed
The next combat update will add a lot of unique abilities to each dinos.
You did a great job of pointing out how some dinosaurs were made to be nothing like what they were actually in real life in order to have their own version of isle dinos ie. bars being made twice the size to be PoT's shant despite being half the size irl, and thus making other herbies that could've filled its role, such as amarga, irrelevant and pointless
Campto glow up was so needed and good
I’m assuming this has been edited because for some reason it now says 1 hour ago even though most comments are from 8 hours ago
I agree with your general points, but I do have hope in the PoT dev team to not disappoint players. It's in an early release stage, And it also has a public test server. I wouldn't give up hope this soon tbh
If i am not mistaken, kiwekia wasn't actually a filter feeder, it was morturneria a related aristonectine.
You are correct, kai is believed to be a sifter not a filter feeder
Yeah, that's was alredy said that are not so many evidences in fossils that Kaiwhekea was a filter feeder.
Kaiwhekea and other Aristonectines are bottom filter feeders, where the sift the bottom. It’s not filter feeding in the way people typically think but that’s what it’s called
@@Leaf-tf5oo By whom?
PoT still has some of my favorite spino depictions ever
2:43 meanwhile Australovenator is over there in the corner seething cause that is basically exactly what it did. I remember Achero and Armin talking about this years ago when the roster was slowly been anounced and Achero had fliped because of the miss oportunity for Australo to be in a game XD . Fun times, I must admit I never had thought about some of the issues these animals in particular have aside from Kaiwhekea , Thalaso and Pychno to a degree. Tho I will say the issue I have with the latter 2 is the fact that they dont start out with the "base default" one been Carnivore ground hunting Thalaso and base Pychno looking....like Pychno and not discount Carno. But yeah aside from the issues mentioned here, in terms of moded ones I think there alrightish, tho Primordeal Tyrant ones are in my honest opinion THE best no ofense to other mod teams out there (discounting the Noviana has too many abilitys) Giga is great to play as an Apex, Para can ACTULLY defend it self pretty darn well, its insaine and rightfully so for such a large animal and Argent. For once a sauropod is the imovable mountain it should be. Once your adult nothing can touch you, and most attacks basically one shot everything,especially the stomp which while hard to aim does like 9000 damage. The Deinosuchus mod is pretty neat to even if its just Sucho with a few extra stuff. Cant wait to see the Quetz mod be availabe looks great from the previous
I agree with Metri, Thalasso and Pycno...but I disagree with Kaiwhekea and Anodontosaurus, Kaiwhekea never was a Filter feeder, but instead a normal plesiosaur, Anodontosaurus I see the problem, but I can't see a way to make him unique but balanced at the same time, so they picked the easier way to balance him instead of making something unique but at the same time very complex to balance.
Kaiwhekea is an aristonectine, and Aristonectines are known to be substrate filter feeders.
Personally I'm fine with Anodontosaurus, precisely because it's so much like Anky that they're pretty muh the same why not go for the lesser known genus
In that regard I'm more annoyed at Pycnonemosaurus
Because one of the species being a Carnotaurus lookalike for fanservive would be fine by me, but two of the three? C'mon, that just undermines he whole premise of using unpopular animals
What's the Best Dinosaur to play in Path of Titans? (For starters)
metri yeet kick when
Although The Isle does do Dinos very well, being as the mechanics are detailed and intrinsic to each Dino (not hot buttons), the PoT does pump out the playables at a high rate which gives players a lot to play with, the Isle being a hard core survival with perma-death can be frustrating for many, Pot being mmorpg/survival lite is far more accessible to casual players which is nice
This is one of PoT's flaws but it still has the most potential and the source for this problem might be the fact that they said that they want to add unknown dino species so for example they want a certain dino but its too small for the role they want for it so they chould use a different dino from the same family but since its known they just scale up and completely change the smaller dino
I'm suprised he didn't mention how Allosaurus is litterally the size of Saurophaganax.
When pot allo was scaled up to saurophaganax’s size A.Maximus was still believed to be the correct classification for sauro.
So thats why allo feels so big comperred to cerato
@@Leaf-tf5oo umm I’m pretty sure that still and was a debated topic on whether or not the two are the same species or different species all together. So no excuse on path of titans on that part! But then again fair enough?
@@Leaf-tf5oo wasn't it intended to be Torvosaurus though? I remember seeing smth about that and the genus switch to Allosaurus was a last minute decision
@@IndominusRex-wc1ey yea allo was originally going to be torvo but was swapped to allo because it was a fan favorite
Then later down the line a perk owner from the crowdfunding campaign rebought torvo only to back out and switch it for the secret backer
You're saying the devs copied the Isle? LOL no. The Isle is a dumpster fire anyway.
Thalaso really is just wasted potential
Not really, it can do exactly what it did irl in game
Thal is like 3x than its irl version
Was a land hunting pterosaur and not a pteranodon like pterosaur
They "again" could of used another pterosaur to fill that niche like Geosternbergia or f****** Pteranodon
@@Pyroraptor635 thal has gotten a wave of new land based abilities, thal is the middle ground of the flyers
Rhamp will be the fisher
Hatz will be the land based hunter
Thal is a mixture of both
Seems fitting to me, plus thal in game can hunt exactly what it could irl, small lizards, mammals, and dinosaurs.
@Leaf that's good that they improved it now hopefully they do the same to kai by making it a filter feeder
@@Pyroraptor635 well if they did that they would get called out for "copying " Isle or BoB
Path of Titans is fun but I feel like if it holds up it will probably be moreso thanks to mods and unofficial servers than anything else, ngl. I guess they might become more than a Primal Carnage Freeroam server with PvP and nutcollecting minigames eventually, tho.
Also, because I feel like it, have some Path of Titan roster predictions:
Tlatolophus (with two long-crested variants)
Velafrons (big)
Barbaridactylus (Nyctosaurus, Pteranodon, and PP variants)
Anzu (designated egg thief)
Prenocephale
Siroccopteryx (large aerial hunter)
Eoabelisaurus (They accidentally copied The Isles Rugops before they could notice that it is useless and does nothing)
Ankylosaurus
2:28 i might be misunderstanding here but are you saying there's anodontosaurus and ankylosaurus in the game? Because that isn't true. There's only anodontosaurus.
what he meant is that they enlarged their anodontosaurus to the point where it takes on the exact role and matchups as ankylosaurus
Agreed, but atleast mods and private server customization relieve this issue quite a bit, which is more than you can say for any other game of the genre. Also out of place, but I think you should definitely do a Prior Extinction tier list. If not now at the end of the year, it may unironically be one of the best animal survival games out there, through it still has its own issues.
I tried prior extinction, it's not for me, unsure about others though.
@alexsookhoo9919 That's fair; it's still very much a WIP project, and being on roblox certainly has its limitations, not to mention it can be fairly hard to start out with. Through the amount of progress they've made in only a year is astonishing, and I think given another year will genuinely be comparable to the big steam games of the genre but free (they also rebalanced the game recently so smaller animals are more viable)
Why not make a hyperealistic dinosaur platformer/spectacle fighter?
Path of titans is a extremely flawed game and the designs range from bad to questionable and just straight up lazy! But it has its merits! Like people say path of titans is gonna be the first of the big three to die or whatever but tbh that couldn’t be further from the truth! The game has a strong modding community that will keep it a flout even if official development stops! And the game is actually really beautiful and runs really well! And combat is pretty neat! Not perfect but definitely better than the isles! INFACT!! I think path is a game we’re it’s much easier to learn how combat works and is forgiving enough we’re u can actually get good at the game! And the fact u don’t have to completely start over every time u die allows more room for improvement and to better hone your skill! The isle fails in every conceivable way with trying to teach u it’s combat! In the isle it’s very easy to die especially if ur inexperienced! And losing hours of growth can be very unmotivating and puts a time gap until u reach your full potential as a certain creature so u can try again! So overall path of titans has its merits and I’m excited for its future! A lot can be improved like questing and in general the herbivore and pack biased the game has and growth on officials. But still out of the big three path has become my favorite! With bob only being in last place because I could never get into and actual server unfortunately and had to refund it 😔
the game wont be dead yea I can agree with that and its really fun to play... sometimes but the thing with POT that is super anoying is the fact that one person complains about a tiny thing like "____ is too strong you need to nerf it" and its always anoying because ether they don't really change anything about the animal or they make it so trash its almost not even fun to play anymore for example the t. rex and dasp situation on the other hand we have a creature that is a tyrant that is the strongest thing in the game (if mods are not included) that runs almost as fast as allo and on the other hand we have a tiny much weaker rex that almost no one plays anymore because its only slightly faster than rex.
It’s sad seeing that this is an issue with path of titans because the devs have shown since nearly the beginning their ability to make their playables something more than the bland isle like playables with almost no variety in gameplay other than inherent ones that come with size (evrima seems like it’s looking to rectify this which is good but they still have a long way to go) the example of this that always comes to my mind when I think about this topic is concaveonator. It literally looks like it would be doomed to be pushed into the bland “4-6 ft tall theropod” category since it’s design is generic in every way but the weird dorsal fin like growth on its spine. Except the path of titans devs didn’t do that, they instead went with the ambitious concept of a dinosaur that becomes semi aquatic later in life and isn’t garbage on land (in its own weight class, it’s not soloing rexes or anything stupid like that) and they got this idea from its name which partially means “shark tooth” (haven’t looked up the exact translation yet) this is basically creative gold and spared concaveonator from being a generic playable that had no place in the game outside of being an obscure dinosaur. So glad they haven’t left concaveonator behind when updating megalania (the other playable that later in life becomes semi aquatic) to be more effective in water in the current ptb, because he is basically the symbol of what path of titans aims to achieve with it’s playables in terms of varying playstyles in even the same species of dinosaur in some cases (like again, concaveonator, because most concaveonators ether spec into full aquatic mobility builds or full dps builds with dive as an escape option)
Path of titans devs, get your shit together again, please.
I understand the fact that they didn't want anky cause it's famous which is fine but at least they could have added the largest ankylosaurid with a club tail that wasn't anky
I mean, like I said before I don’t mind path of titans I’m actually glad that it’s on the PS4. I wish the isle was on the PS4. And I hope that they will make more changes/updates on some of the dinosaurs much they are but let’s hope they do more.
All these games are imperfect, what does a perfect dinosaur simulation game look like??
1:00 dam i had no idea the mods in pot acted like this
Random thing but I've always loved your voice.
Cheers
Hello everyone this is your daily dose of internet
I fail to see what's wrong with a dino that has to fear everything and has to run away, personally find it quite fun
I agree I mean not like a small fast raptor or thal if gonna fight everything because it can't
Save that for struthiomimus rather than a car-sized beef cake that should be running a raptor over rather than fleeing from it
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurus Ha hilarious
Do you plan on making a video about the recent ark controversy? I would love to hear what you have to say about it
I really don’t. My general opinion is that Snail Games is dragging Wildcard down with it. I personally don’t have faith in ARK2 or, Wildcard surviving in general within the next few years due to their influence.
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurus Do you think It would be possible for Wildcard to get away from Snail games? Or for the situation to improve in anyway?
@@Eeeeeee-sh2zn There’s a chance but that’s about it.
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurus seems about right. Btw are you gonna submit the gorgonopsid to the new creature vote? And do you plan on getting A:SA at all? Or are you just done with the game like a lot of people are? I'm guessing you're not gonna buy it?
@@Eeeeeee-sh2zn I quit ark after the roadmap came out.
Yayyyy!!! New scanova video coming out soon!!!!
the fact that eo is literally like 2 times its real size is a crime eo was smaller than trike just had a big head ;-;
annoyingly rex was never planned and was just added in console release to please the 7 year olds and die hard jurassic park fans.
its introduction made dasp obsolete, it could do more damage, it could tank more hits and in a pinch could even outrun a iguanodon. really don't know what they were thinking.
Good news is in the PTB metri got a revamp to have rapid fast strikes and a slower venom bite along with basically a thorns hide, it doesn't do much to help but its something to differentiate itself from the rest of the roster.
And sorry if I seem a bit aggressive but this is my favourite game and it is a much younger game and has a lot to catch up on and who doesn't like a black horse (under dog)
You know, I really don't like that about PoT dinos it really feels like they want to bring in new faces but then they just copy the "cooler" and more recognizable species.
Also, unrelated but while I like The Isle more pot is definitely the better game right now (just because of mods) and I've been enjoying watching Beaver play it.
Honestly I would love to play as a
Dominion sized hatze tho not accurate it would be cool and plus that plane scene was my favorite in the movie although not making much sense 😂
Did you guys know that Pycnonemosaurus might be Largest Abelisaurid, because it's bigger than Carnotaurus
The subadult specimen is already bigger than carnotaurus at 2.5 tons, with fragmentary remains likely belonging to an adult that suggest a size double that. Easily the largest abelisaur by a wide margin.
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurusDamn! I really didn't know that, thanks for the info.
I mean the t rex being most powrrful in every game is cause of rexy literally she is infected with the spring trap fluid she always comes back a video with the dominoin giga and rexy dies and looses but doesnt that rex from vid look familiar to he rex we currently have in every frwaking movie.
Still the best Dino survival game out to date. Always going yo be something to pick at no matter what. I agree with some things you’ve said, like the size exaggerations and putting out Dino’s that’s aren’t accurate at all. But also disagree with some things. Good video nonetheless.
Yeah i do agree with your points and i can see rather clearly some dinos ingame have been changed to make it more balanced some more then others you put barsboldia at 6.5 tons in the video while ingame it has 7 thats not such a big deal spinosaurus has 7 while irl it had betwene 7 and 8 so also just a bit but t Rex has been down scaled a lot in game he has 7 tons but irl astimates are around 10 tons Yes i know theres ppl who hate that its so strong in games and all but it was the largest land carnivore based on weight with the most powerful bite in the whole world need to give him some credit also im not saying it needs a buff just saying how it would be if path of titans made it fully acurate
we will see kai remodel in 2 years
Wait THATS HOW BIG THE THALASSO IS?
What's even the point of making it so huge if you don't make it a terrestrial hunter? What about being a generic fisher required them to buff it to such a ludicrous size.
Jiggy mistook the measuring as 2 meters not 2cm, that is how we ended up with hatz size thal
PoT should fix the scaling for accuracy.
1:00 DONDER CAMEO
While I agree with most of this, the Rex is the most powerful is not true. It’s one of the most powerful in Path. But a good Eo or a decent Ano can easily put a Rex down. Hell I’ve done it before on my Ano, and have gotten away from a pack of 4 Rex’s and a Spino because of Ano. While saying that Ano is also surprisingly balanced, it’s a defensive powerhouse that’s supposed to deter you from attacking it. There’s a couple problems with it but the main thing is that Rexy, while it has a say in the top of the roost, she doesn’t rule it.
While I disagree about how most the dinos are just dinos from the isle, can't have a dinosaur game without stego anky rex and spino after all, I can however agree that most dinos are redundant or given a stupid purpose that's either overshadowed or doesn't make sense like metris venom. Many dinos have a trope that they get overshadowed in and there's little to no reason using the worse one over the better one, an example is trex and dasp. Both bone breakers but dasps all over the place stats and smaller stature along with worse attacks as apposed to trexs amazing stats and tall stature with much better attacks makes playing dasp worthless. Most dinos just copy another to be unique with their name like ano and pycno. Those dinos should just be renamed I'd rather a popular dino that's accurate to it's irl self vs an unpopular dino that's more accurate to a popular dino than itself
There's one very notable difference in between these games and it's how the community interacts with their devs. See when the isle makes a mistake, when the isle releases something half way broken, their player base is ready to rip them in to pieces. But when PoT releases something unplayable, unfun and insanely unequipped to exist in the game ( amarga...kai...) the community is ready to stand in defense of their devs...to a fault.
I love both of these games very much, they are entirely different experiences. But I'm tired of seeing "pot good, isle bad" just repeated constantly. Neither is perfect, but the other is held to a higher standard.
The "knock off ___" has always annoyed me.
It's not a knock off. It is literally another dino of the same family. They are found in different regions or time periods. Making you learn about more dinos than just the basic ones we all know and love because literally every form of media use them (T-Rex, your basic Trike, Anky, etc.)... and the Rex actually wasn't even a planned dino for the game. Someone paid them to put the Rex in the game. I honestly found this pretty cool, as it took me back to googling these dinos and learning more about them. I wouldn't be doing that if they were just the basic dinos. They even advertised the Pycno specially to their Brazilian players because it was found in Brazil.
The game is in development, and EVERY dino is being revamped with new abilities to give each dino their own niche. What we have currently is only a placeholder.
I imagine every dino just about will be getting reworks, given they spoke about needing to redo animations for better hitboxes/attack localization.
In terms of deign; they also never claimed to be going for a 100% realistic depiction of these dinos, and have noted they will take some liberties (i.e. horns on pycno I think is a common one?)
The problem with Pycno is that it’s not even taking inspiration from carno. It just straight up is carno. They took carno’s identity and now pycno doesn’t have any of its own. It’s just the carno lookalike (when it didn’t look like carno in life in the first place)
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurus Hmm, alright, fair. I will say, though. I remember a butt-load of complaints on the version that doesn't have horns (stam?). Bc then it wasn't "carno enough" or looked goofy or something. Really just not able to please everyone.
Oof I’ve been called shitty lol. I at least try to have a civil conversation.
And yeah, I do agree that some dinosaurs have been kinda forced into roles that more popular ones are in. Eotriceratops is of course going to be the generic Triceratops of the game cause it has Triceratops in the name. Barsboldia is, as I can agree with, oversized compared to what it’s believed to be as sized. T.rex of course is in the game cause people just want T.rex when we have Daspletosaurus among other stuff that you have said Scanova. I just hope when the combat update comes, many of the dinosaurs will have niches different from one another but we know thats going to take a while.
Sorry, I haven’t seen the whole vid but i listened to the par where u said Rex is th strongest like all games… why tf can’t the eotrike face tank a Rex, look at the goddamn size of the thing!!
Tbf! I don’t think eotrike should be able to just face tank a Rex that seems a bit unfair for Rex players and just feeds into this games herbivore biased! But then again I think it is a bit bull sh@t when things smaller than you are able to take a hit from u and even do damage to you! And I mean juives n adolescents! There is a reason why the path of titans devs gave sarco BONE break!?
@@No_name8374 I guess, but a Rex it can keep running from an do, it has faster walk speed, and better stam
@@masontoymaster5149 well if Rex can run away then fair enough! I was under the impression that Rex n eotrike are around the same speed n stuff! Granted I don’t play as either.
@@No_name8374 ikr lol, I don’t like play style of Rex or eo tbh
On the ptb eo trike can face tank rex and win
Combat update will fix these issues with pot
well we don't really know about that
@@TheTinyTyranid but we do know
4:06 and kill denio, laten, alio, and in a pair, conca
Path of Titan indeed does have its praises and issues. As a paleo-accurate dinosaur lover, this game earns my respects for it and its plethora of species. However some of its species are illogical on stats and niches.
Like Alioramus having 400 health while a smaller, lighter animal like Raptors having 500 health? I get it's to balance them out, but no, it's health should be based on its respected weight.
I was there from the start, and ya'll are just posers... *Campto Gang Supremacy*
I agree wholeheartedly with all that you say...but come on...we ACTUALLY have a playable roster...while The Isle...💀💀💀
Hard agree with everything here. Way too much corner cutter and "easy way out"-ing
PoT has its issues, but is by far the best dinosaur game out there. You complain about Path of Titans having no inspiration for their dinosaurs and that they are copies. But the isle dinosaurs are literally made after Jurassic parks dinosaurs 🤷🏻♂️
Agree to disagree. PoT models are (mostly) quite nice and (mostly...) accurate, but Isle makes them feel much more real and is generally a more immersive experience. But then again, while I prefer the gritty, challenging survival aspect and immersion over repetitive questing and little to no penalties for dying with copy-paste playables and abilities, I understand others prefer to just play casually without having to pay full attention at all times. To each their own!
It’s not the isle stop calling it a rip off
I’m not calling Path of Titans itself a ripoff, it absolutely is not, but do I think certain playables are intended to replicate what the Isle did, despite there being alternatives? Yeah.
@@ScanovatheCarnotaurus give it a chance there is still much for it to work on it’s only just getting interesting for the game be patient
@@TheRunDanceKid It's been 2 years KARN. I'm not calling the entire game a failure calm down.
Well yeah POT designs are nice but all i can say is "Unoriginal"
Barsboldia design aint the best all i can say
Ill continue my view
Megalania just upscale komodo
Metri: yeah thats a dumpster fire
Just replace Anodonto and Eotrike with Anky and Trike jess POT
Also Campto when i started playing POT felt like dryosaurus or Othnielia than Camptosaurus and like they should just replace campto with dryo
@@Pyroraptor635 meg irl was a upscaled komodo
Metri is the second strongest mid tier, definitely not a dumpster fire
Replacing ano with anky and eo with trike wont change anything? Eo and ano were literally just smaller versions of their cousins?
Campto is fine as is
@@Leaf-tf5oo I agree with what you say about megalania
Metri being venomous while we have Megalania was a bad desicion on there point why I said dumpster fire not in gamdplay but in design
Eotrike and Ano was somewhat smaller than there more popular name sakes but feels the same as them
Campto never felt like campto more like Dryosaurus
Sorry had to makr edits to my comments
Tend to forget what im saying while typing
@@Pyroraptor635 *sigh* Jesus....... megalania is a komodo on steroids yes but metri isn't a dumpster fire the reason why they gave it venom bite is because without it it would just be slightly faster weaker allo and PoT goal is for 1 or 2 dinos to have a special mechanic they also wanted to stick out by not having very popular dinos and giving less popular dinos to be recognised and also the reason why you felt like you were playing dryo while playing campto is because they are close relatives smh
Pycno is super op.
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀 Pycno op what the hellllllllll
@@darthdistix1895 pycno isnt op but it isnt bad either
@@Leaf-tf5oodude fr fr Pycno has the worst matchup in with the dinos in its own weight class full speed allo can out speed it 💀 and outtank it to dasp is jsut a straight up counter with the bb sty and Alberta are better at Pycno at its own game with their own charge attacks it only has decent matchs against dinos like cera conca pachy etc mega and metri also counter Pycno in a fight with the venom straight up removing Pycnosaurus charge attack even skilled Pycno players like indoraptoad etc want a buff for Pycno it’s sad and at the moment it’s in a same category as amarga for how unfun it is as a solo playable
Uninspired? The devs just add what nature once added. If you wanna blame someone for being lazy, then it's the nature with it's "uninspired" ideas. xD
Didn’t watch the video?
Alas, looks like someone doesn't know what we actually know about these animals. Thalasso irl was not a piscivore, pycno irl didn't have a species name of sastrei and horns to boot, and kai wasn't generic plesiosaur #69
Blub
To be fair I feel like a filter feeding kaiwhekia would be boring and it would do like no damage
Then why even add it in the first place. Why not add something like elasmosaurua
To its credit kaiwhekea is currently boring af anyway. People play herbivores. Idk why an aquatic equivalent of a herbi would be different
@@ggsmrdoink you make a good point idk why they didn't pick a different plesiosaur maybe they just wanted to be unique idk
Don't aristonectines like kai have big ass flippers? Why not give kai a giant flippers smash that let's it deal higher damage than its bite?
They literally should just rename Kawikea to plesiosaurus, because it’s THAT GENERIC.