I meant, theoretically, if Arthur woke up after the Lenny mission (where they get drunk), he would have known not to visit Thomas Downes. He would never have gotten infected, could have worked against Micah and a thousand other things. Its a nice thought, but of course it wouldn't fit the story and mood at all.
Charles, Sadie, etc didn't die but were busy not being scumbags. Arthur didn't want them there to avoid anyone getting killed. John wasn't supposed to be there either, which meant Arthur had to change plans to save him instead of going after Micah and Dutch suicide style.
I can believe Micah, Dutch, and Bill betraying him, but I really don't understand how everyone else did. Dutch was too stupid and arrogant by the end where I knew that was going to happen, the entire storyline events were sabotaged by micah's help with planning things out, and it always seemed like whenever he was involved or knew about something it went south. I knew he was going to be a main problem once i found myself slaughtering half a town because of him. Bill was always acting completely arrogant, selfish, and out of pure greed and didn't care if anyone got in the way. The way they act in rdr1 makes so much sense playing this game now, and John's descriptions of all of them are spot on in character
@@Elite02k "You know, you're the most loyal one out of all of us" Arthur to Javier, so it maks sense why Javier stood by too, but he never pointed his gun at Arthur in the camp during the stand-off
Am I the only one who longs to be able to play a game like this again? I try to come to terms with the fact that no other game compares to RDR2. This was an absolute masterpiece.
I never really understood why so many people loved this game so much. To me the plot was visible from a way away, a theme that annoyed me was that the gang keeps making mistakes and talking about them then running in and doing the same exact thing all over again. Arthur was a great character but didn't seem to be this greatest character of all time to me. I know it's hard but could you explain why its so perfect?
@@alisongreat3756 wdym without talking to people. I agree it was a really solid game I put like 100 hours in a week 😭. But I get addicted to stuff easily.
@@muffincakes3768 you're probably the kind of guy who doesn't play video games to enjoy the narrative. My advice is. Breathe. Look around. Listen. Observe. Everything in the world of RDR2 is full of story and character development. Don't rush the main story and call it a day bruh..
16:08 Help John escape with Low Honor - Arthur dies by getting shot in the forehead by Micah. 26:13 Go for the money with Low Honor - Arthur goes for the money, gets stabbed in the Sternum by Micah and then in the back while he is crawling away, leaving him dead. 26:13/29:25 Go for the money with High Honor - Arthur goes for the money, he cuts Micah’s left eye, leaving him blind and crawls away to die by Tuberculosis in Beaver Hollow looking at the sunrise. 30:46 Help John escape with High Honor - Dutch and Micah leave Arthur to die from Tuberculosis looking at the sunrise. btw it doesn't show the actual part where Arthur dies and shows John visiting his grave on the last one so that's it.
I’ve been gaming since the early eighties, and this game is the most detailed, most immersive and most emotional game I’ve ever played in my life. The voice acting and animation is crazy good. The game looks beautiful too, especially the weather effects and the lighting. Gorgeous.
I started gaming as a teen in the mid-90s and this is what I always wanted games to be like. About the only thing I could wish for that it doesn't have is individual personalities/learning from experience for companion animals (which I expect to come along in future games, it's just a matter of processing power and coding) and the ability to pet cats.
The fact dutch believed micah over arthur was heartbreaking arthur had spent his life with dutch since he was a boy and micah was with them for a year.Arthur will always be better than all of them
Dutch had gone crazy after hitting his head in a trolley crash and losing Hosea. So Dutch just lost his care for other people and wanted to escape, and he trusted Micah because Micah would always agree with him.
My guess is that instead of making a plan that benefited everyone, Dutch and Micahs plan was either to off everyone or drop them to hide and live in wealth. Which wasn’t Dutches original plan but that was his last resort to have his “henchman” (Micah) to live with him
I find it amazing how Arthur could hold his own against Micah whilst having TB imagine how he would have destroyed him without it I wanted to make a lil edit here: Arthur could have coughed in Micah’s mouth, he had plenty of chances too, but he only coughed when he knew no one would be infected, because at that point in the game he changed as a person and didn’t want to do that to someone else, also my ADHD hyper attention has worn off 🤯
Rule Number 1 of Red Dead: Never get too attached to the main character Edit: 11 Months later y’all still comment on this. That’s insane to me. Have a nice day if you’re reading this. Morse 11-12-20
Have you ever noticed that arthur says he wants to die watching the sunrise, in both high honor endings he dies watching the sunrise, I both low honors he gets killed and dosent get to watch the sunrise. Truly the best game ever story wise. 11/10 story
What a game! The story, the characters, the setting, the details, the action... Rockstar had outdone themselves with this one! Will be replaying this masterpiece for sure!
Arthur is the only character in ANY game that I’ve played that had me crying when they died. Edit-(Bruh everybody telling me games in the comments. I’ve played most of those games. THEY HAVENT MADE ME CRY! So I made this comment based on my experiences)
Dutch showing up and shooting micah just expands his character so much more in the last final bit. He knew he shoulda done that a long time ago, before he went insane.
If you had a dry eye your first play through, you have to have no heart! The best game I have ever played. Story wise and graphics combined to make something truly amazing.
I never cried. Whenever someone of the gang died, I was just feeling anger and bloodlust against the person or group who killed them. If I got the death at the sunrise, I would maybe cry, as I wouldn't have anyone to hate. But I got shot in the head by Micah. I still am pissed off at that son of a wench. I am making sure to play honorably this time.
Ok I hate to spoil, not that it already has by someone else but... (press read more for spoil)
Red dead redemption 1 is set about 15 years after rdr2 is set, therefore the rest of, or most of, the gang members left in rdr2 are alive. Dutch in rdr1, I assume, goes completely insane or gets something wrong with him like depression and jumps off a cliff killing himself.
Just finished it for a 2nd time and still hurts, as soon as he started telling Abigail Sadie and Jack goodbye I started crying cos I knew what was coming 🤧 One of my favourite games of all time!!! A true masterpiece, just like The Last Of Us, this needs to be made into a series! But ONLY if the cast is absolutely perfect, no changes needed, just so more people can witness the great storyline
My first run thru I got a good ending. Mica didn’t kill Arthur. I helped John escape and didn’t care for the money. Dutch walked away and so did Micah. Arthur crawled and sat up and died looking at the sunset. It was sad but compared to the ones I’ve seen. I was content
I was just below high honour bc i was bad at the syart but when i knew he got TB i started doing better and fixing up his life. I didnt care for the money but i still got the black wolf. In the end i still know that my arthur was a good guy, fighting until his last breath, not fearing death or begging for mercy. A true selfless warrior and helped john instead of money
no. in a movie there would be no honor system, no multiple endings, no immersion with shaving, bathing, eating, changing clothes based on temperature, etc...
Damn, this guy gave up his time just to watch Arthur die 4 times in a row. This man is strong Edit after 2 years this comment is still my most liked comment ever lmao
Best game I ever played. I beat this game for the first time last night and I was finding myself tearing up at work today a couple of time thinking about the game. The action, adventure, friends that I made, people I’d saved and people who saved me, how flawed the characters were but they were trying to survive and be better people. I really tried to be a good person in this game and I made decisions based off of what I think I’d actually do in real life. I became like Arthur in my mind and how people treated Arthur in the game felt like a true of my own personality in real life. I have never felt like that playing a video game. Never. Maybe I’m just being too dramatic but I really love this game. I love it like it’s a valuable family heirloom. If I have kids, im going to tell them about it. Hopefully they’ll play it too and appreciate it as much as I do. I hope the people responsible for this game never lose that spark that inspired the creativity required for this work of art and I hope they make another and another. God bless, brothers and sisters. This is a great time to be alive.
This is the first game in my entire life that made me both attached to a character and cry!! The last ride to the camp and the "Thank You" to the horse opened the floodgates. I was lucky to have ended the game where he dies peacefully in the mountains as the Sun comes up. Arthur Morgan deserved it!! First thing I did as the Epilogue started was visit his grave and pay my respect!!
I think I made the perfect ending. For the whole game I saw the wolf, I never saw the stag once, my honor was very low, I tried to play as an outlaw would. When Arthur gets diagnosed, I was still seeing the wolf, but I thought about how Arthur wanted to be a better man; not a good man, but a good man amongst bad men. I started playing as a good Arthur, never took rewards from people and I always tried to help any strangers I found. In the end, I chose to help John escape; after I fought Micah, both he and Dutch left Arthur to die in the mountain, and I finally saw the stag after the sun set on a redeemed Arthur. I had never cried at the end of a game before this. It felt so perfect.
'That's the way it is' gets me every time. I play a bunch of songs on my record player when handing out candy on Halloween. Mostly Horror movie, and Horror game music, but that's always the last song of the night.
The fun thing about tuberculosis is that you can die of it and still not be infectious to others. Arthur's TB has progressed fast and he had several episodes of coughing up blood. This means that that his lungs could have still been in a decent shape, unlike his lungs' blood vessels. It's shown that he's pale (anemic) and can't eat (because this triggers his cough reflex).
The part where arthur is riding to save John. And the song plays. It just hits different every single time. So much time spent, to feel the end coming soon. Just makes the soul sad. When you know. You are happy.
Highest honor is probably the best way to have arthur die... he told hosea, when his time comes he'd like to die facing the rising sun.. I believe this ties up nicely with Arthur's character, he tries to be the best man he can be before his impending death while being loyal to the gang.
I find it cool how helping John involves climbing a mountain, being very high in the sky as though it is symbolic for heaven, where as going back for the money has you go back down to your burning camp, symbolic for hell.
I love how it kinda goes full circle from the first mission: now as John, you must brave the snowy mountains much like Arthur did for him. As John goes up the mountain, the music and cues from the first game come on, evolving him into the John we all know and love.
This is by far the best game , ever. It had everything, the emotions at the end of the game is something else . Your horse dying , Arthur saying goodbye, and then arther himself dying . The story , the characters, the graphics, its seamless. Its a must .
Fun fact: when Javier points his gun up instead of at John and Arthur, that was actually requested by the voice actor for Javier. The voice actor didn’t think Javier would side with Dutch so that’s why.
I’ve played both endings, but saving John only seems right, like John says before *American Venom* “None of this would’ve happened without Arthur,”. That’s why I prefer helping John then going for the money, and being greedy.
I’ve never been one to cry over video games, but this one, this game right here had me crying over my computer. Never while I was downloading it did I think I’d become so emotionally attached to video game characters. Good job Rockstar, definitely the best game I’ve played in a while!
And he didn't fully won, because on his last moments, Arthur planted the seeds of distrust in Dutch's head. It was only a matter of time before Dutch puts a bullet through Micah's chest.
@Karkat Vantas I love the ending because at face value it seems almost like the bad ending, but once you know the context it really is one of the best ending you can get
Dutch is one of the most tragic characters I've seen, I think he was truly a good guy who got his mind scrambled by the events he's been through and Micah ofcourse.
No, I think it was Hosea keeping him in check that kept him "good" at first. Dutch was always a horrible person, it was just the loss of his best friend, the increased stress from the Pinkertons, and the paranoia of there being a rat in the gang that revealed who he truly was.
No dutch became weak after hosea did and he realized that he might not be the planner and visionary that he thought he was. He then retreatet into himself letting micah do all the planning. This is why he said "I ain't got much to say these days" before he left in the mountains. So sad to see this broken man😢
@@CptStankFanger I was actually opposite. My honor was kinda low because I kept robbing people for money. It wasn't until Arthur got sick and I tried to get my honor up. It was too late anyways.
Me too.. I cant imagined arthur died in that way. I hooked wtih him so much.. When im playing as john i cant stop myself to cry i remember everything arthur did.. I cnt moved on.
By the time I started, I was dissapointed that I didn't get to play as John. By epilogue I was annoyed to be playing as john. Rockstar's character development in this game was genius
Same. My bf said before rdr2, he thought there is no wayitd have a better character to be than john, then they blew johns character out of the water. Plus every time i get to epilogue, im like how tf im supposed to play this when im GRIEVING TEARS IN MY EYES AND ALL AND YALL JUST ACT LIKE ARTHUR NEVER EXISTED.
I still like John more, but maybe because I grew up playing him. Playing someone else in this game and having John as an AI felt like an out of body experience. Never got used to that.
The only reget I made was taking White Arabian from Lake Isabella. When she died, I really felt like lost a close friend and cried. When the death came to Arthur and watching sun set with him. I felt really at ease. Farewell, Morgan. You became a part of my heart from now on.
The only fight Micah ever won was against a diying, beaten man with tuberculosis who somehow survived a ten meter fall and kept fighting for his life until TB got him on the ground.
As soon as he got diagnosed with TB by the doctor in saint denis the whole way through after that I kept doing the rest of the missions thinking shut the fuck up oh my god oh I’m hurtin Arthur yeah well I have fucking tuberculosis
There is another ending where if you choose to stay with John you don't get shot by Micah. They leave you there dying, Arthur crawl over the edge and you die just watching the sunshine.
Tilly: "Hey Arthur, if I were to kill Ms. Grimshaw, would Dutch be mad?" Arthur: "Yeah, probably." Micah: *Kills Ms. Grimshaw* Dutch: *Sides with Micah*
At the beginning of chapter 3 and at the end of chapter 6 Grimshaw argues over the camp's safety with Dutch where he gets angry that's why he didn't care about her death
I just finished this game for the 6th time! 10 out of 10! A masterpiece! I really liked how John had his happy ending with Abigail, their home, barn and family just like the first RDR but without him being killed! I hope there will be a next chapter in South America with Mrs. Sadie Adler as the main character! that would be awesome! Sadie was and will be the best female character ever that Rockstar games made!
The extra secret ending is Micah kills both Aurthor and John and the character you play after is Uncle the main objective is to cure his lumbago. I got the Uncle ending
@@Max-fu3hp absolutely. But it services the story. John ran and ran, but he eventually couldn't outrun his past and settle down at the same time. Arthur stopped running when he realised he was dying and could save others instead of just dying.
I am glad that I lived during the times of arthur morgan's rdr2. Lucky to live the life of the most awe aspiring fictional character accross all the platforms, be it analogue or digital, in the history of content creation.
When arthur said "not molly, not miss grimshaw, not even colm" he almost sounded like the tone in his voice was similar to like he was pleeding for his life like they have similar tones in their voice
I just replayed the game after a few years, and I was able to max out my honour during the final mission where you choose between helping John or getting the money.
I legit got mine shot off picked it up as 4 were shooting at my and head shot all of em. Also during free roam I I lost Arthur’s hat and it’s not on my horse any one got some ideas to help me get that hat back
@@jansenstokes7064 if it's not on your horse it should be in your main wardrobe, the place at camp or an inn room where you can see all of your outfits.
![[Vowel]물고기는 물에서 살아야 해🐟🤣Fish have to live in the water #funny](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3G9MH063Cx4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Vowel]물고기는 물에서 살아야 해🐟🤣Fish have to live in the water #funny](/img/tr.png)
The wtf ending: Arthur wakes up after passing out in the bar with lenny
I WISH
lmao the whole game was a dream
Was the Lenny mission before the tuberculosis one? Because then he would know what to do.
@@kamontana2657 lenny died before Arthur found out he had it
I meant, theoretically, if Arthur woke up after the Lenny mission (where they get drunk), he would have known not to visit Thomas Downes. He would never have gotten infected, could have worked against Micah and a thousand other things. Its a nice thought, but of course it wouldn't fit the story and mood at all.
It’s sad because the ones who’d died during the game would have been the ones that stood with Arthur
They did Lenny dirty man
Charles, Sadie, etc didn't die but were busy not being scumbags. Arthur didn't want them there to avoid anyone getting killed. John wasn't supposed to be there either, which meant Arthur had to change plans to save him instead of going after Micah and Dutch suicide style.
Hosea is a legend
Atleast I hope Lenny would stay with Arthur... Hosea definitely would though and I'm pretty sure Lenny would too.
@@bingobongo781 hosea, lenny, and im sure sean would have too
Guys imagine if Hosea, Lenny, Sean, and Kieran were alive to team up with Arthur 😭
All that because of Micah
Prettyu sure kieran would have died anyway, with or without rats in the nest, micah ratted to the pinkertons, not the o'driskolls
if hosea was alive none of it wouldve happened
Dutch would've been crened
@@zironcat5265 kieran woulda lived
Just replayed the full story for the 3rd time and it still hits just as hard. 😭 Losing my horse, GucciMane, just doesn't get easier.
why i named mine meatbag, hell I even named my horse meatbag in online aswell
Gucci mane 🤣😂🤣😅
Named mine Isaac after Arthurs dead son , RIP
My horse land biscuit will not be forgotten
I lost Chief Keef too on my second playthrough, I feel your pain
When my horse died i literally said: GIVE HIM A HORSE REVIVER, I HAVE THREE
right😭😭!!!
Yeah I'm glad you never had your horse die instantly by a headshot or falling off a bridge. No reviving that 😐
Gotta keep stocked amr
Ott is vannak a magyarok❤
I did the same thing
Micah: *shoots Grimshaw*
Dutch: Who amongst you is betraying me
Dead oRedHood ikr
Dead oRedHood they both are just a mess
well, there's only one way for Dutch to know it... A pLaN
story was so-so, they over did it imo.
@@artic9756 gEt MoRe MoNeY
Arthur was a good man, he saved everyone when he couldn’t save himself. Can’t believe Dutch and a few others betrayed him. He was loyal til the end.
I can believe Micah, Dutch, and Bill betraying him, but I really don't understand how everyone else did. Dutch was too stupid and arrogant by the end where I knew that was going to happen, the entire storyline events were sabotaged by micah's help with planning things out, and it always seemed like whenever he was involved or knew about something it went south. I knew he was going to be a main problem once i found myself slaughtering half a town because of him. Bill was always acting completely arrogant, selfish, and out of pure greed and didn't care if anyone got in the way.
The way they act in rdr1 makes so much sense playing this game now, and John's descriptions of all of them are spot on in character
@@Elite02k "You know, you're the most loyal one out of all of us" Arthur to Javier, so it maks sense why Javier stood by too, but he never pointed his gun at Arthur in the camp during the stand-off
@@aliemiratakk çok iyi yakalamışsın detayı.
@@aliemiratakkLook at Javier again 7:33
Am I the only one who longs to be able to play a game like this again? I try to come to terms with the fact that no other game compares to RDR2. This was an absolute masterpiece.
I never really understood why so many people loved this game so much. To me the plot was visible from a way away, a theme that annoyed me was that the gang keeps making mistakes and talking about them then running in and doing the same exact thing all over again. Arthur was a great character but didn't seem to be this greatest character of all time to me. I know it's hard but could you explain why its so perfect?
@@muffincakes3768 bro just play it without talking to people and you rate it without giving it at least an 8 out 10
Its a masterpiece alright but this ain't the only one
There are other masterpieces out there as well.
@@alisongreat3756 wdym without talking to people. I agree it was a really solid game I put like 100 hours in a week 😭. But I get addicted to stuff easily.
@@muffincakes3768 you're probably the kind of guy who doesn't play video games to enjoy the narrative. My advice is. Breathe. Look around. Listen. Observe. Everything in the world of RDR2 is full of story and character development. Don't rush the main story and call it a day bruh..
Micah : shots miss grimshaw
Dutch : WhO Is BeTrAyInG mE
Damn that brain trauma did fucked up Dutch.
That and his pride, man. He didn’t want to admit his wrongs. You could tell he wanted to take Arthur’s side so bad.
And the rest of the gang too, like grimshaw is dying by Micahs hand and they side with him... they deserve to get killed every one of them
Oof, Miss Grimshaw's death sounded painful
I'm also ur one thousand liker :P
Yeah wasn’t Arthur working with Dutch since he was a kid and Micah started like a month before the black water job?😂
Just imagine if Arthur wasn’t sick he would absolutely school Micah
Would’ve Absolutely destroyed him
Would've kicked Micah's ass
Yeah Micah almost lost to him even when he was he was literally a few minutes from death lol
@@thatsabingo6695 a rat can't stop a grizzly
would've spammed ''ez'' after the death then fortnite dances on him
16:08 Help John escape with Low Honor - Arthur dies by getting shot in the forehead by Micah.
26:13 Go for the money with Low Honor - Arthur goes for the money, gets stabbed in the Sternum by Micah and then in the back while he is crawling away, leaving him dead.
26:13/29:25 Go for the money with High Honor - Arthur goes for the money, he cuts Micah’s left eye, leaving him blind and crawls away to die by Tuberculosis in Beaver Hollow looking at the sunrise.
30:46 Help John escape with High Honor - Dutch and Micah leave Arthur to die from Tuberculosis looking at the sunrise.
btw it doesn't show the actual part where Arthur dies and shows John visiting his grave on the last one so that's it.
Was looking for the timestamps thanks!
I need to get arther with high homer then cuz i am not prepared for him to die 😭😭😭😭😭
Damn i am so glad i didn't play a low honor arthur.
High honor and going back for the money is what I did my first playthrough. It still feels like what Arthur as a character would have done
@@ringofasho7721I don’t think so. He said vengeance was an idiots game.
I’ve been gaming since the early eighties, and this game is the most detailed, most immersive and most emotional game I’ve ever played in my life. The voice acting and animation is crazy good. The game looks beautiful too, especially the weather effects and the lighting. Gorgeous.
I started gaming as a teen in the mid-90s and this is what I always wanted games to be like. About the only thing I could wish for that it doesn't have is individual personalities/learning from experience for companion animals (which I expect to come along in future games, it's just a matter of processing power and coding) and the ability to pet cats.
It’s not immersive
correction. You didn't find it immersive.@@collins1860
@@collins1860 Have your opinion but could you care to explain instead of just leaving a dull statement
Your mom is immersive
Secret ending: Arthur arrives in Heaven and sees a well dressed man. "Hello. I'm Gavin."
Lmao
We need this as a canon
You know where he is?!
He's a londoner , cockney big block
he arrives and says: "ah, found ya lenny!"
The fact dutch believed micah over arthur was heartbreaking arthur had spent his life with dutch since he was a boy and micah was with them for a year.Arthur will always be better than all of them
Dutch had gone crazy after hitting his head in a trolley crash and losing Hosea. So Dutch just lost his care for other people and wanted to escape, and he trusted Micah because Micah would always agree with him.
yh literally without hosea and arthur, dutch would be a mess.
He wasn’t even with them a year. About 6 months at the most. Dutch is weak
I believe he finally realized that and shot Micah at the end while sparing John
My guess is that instead of making a plan that benefited everyone, Dutch and Micahs plan was either to off everyone or drop them to hide and live in wealth. Which wasn’t Dutches original plan but that was his last resort to have his “henchman” (Micah) to live with him
I find it amazing how Arthur could hold his own against Micah whilst having TB imagine how he would have destroyed him without it
I wanted to make a lil edit here: Arthur could have coughed in Micah’s mouth, he had plenty of chances too, but he only coughed when he knew no one would be infected, because at that point in the game he changed as a person and didn’t want to do that to someone else, also my ADHD hyper attention has worn off 🤯
i find it hard to believe that micah managed to fight him as an equal even if Arthur was sick
Micah was strong, but nothing againsz arthur prime
Micah was weak on his own and arthur had TB if he hadn't micah wouldn't have dared to go fist to fist with him
This is why micah never goes against Arthur before, it's only after Arthur got sick did he start putting him down against Dutch
Arthur would def kill Micah with 3 or 4 hits
Rule Number 1 of Red Dead:
Never get too attached to the main character
Edit: 11 Months later y’all still comment on this. That’s insane to me. Have a nice day if you’re reading this. Morse 11-12-20
Oh if only it was that easy
And your horse...RIP Buell
To late
@@bogptica0309 fucking rip man
Now you tell me
Ultimate ending: Arthur with his last breath sees Gavin and his friend hugging
Tukhvatullin Rafael GAVIN
Jinx 1234 the last true secret of shadow of the colossus was gavins location.
Who Gavin
YungCashRegistir F, seems like someone doesnt play story too much
Gaaavin... Where are yoooouuu?
Have you ever noticed that arthur says he wants to die watching the sunrise, in both high honor endings he dies watching the sunrise, I both low honors he gets killed and dosent get to watch the sunrise. Truly the best game ever story wise. 11/10 story
If you have high honor, Micah won't shoot you and you'll see that third ending.
"Thank you."
- Arthur to his horse, 1899
Thats deep man.
Literally I cried yesterday when I finally finished the game... my horse after 3 months playing 😢😢😢😢
I cried like a little bitch and that's when it hit me I was at the end :(
@@kalekales im sure many did, I dont cry much anymore, but it almost got me.
DR. ANÍBAL PADILLA OCHOA - PEDIATRA - wow. It took u three months to finish this!? Did u do like two missions a day?
The true, best ending is where you help John with high honour and die peacefully on the mountain. Arthur was meant to be honorable.
Red dead redemption for a reason. Amen
Omg this post
Tru
I liked the knife fight because it’s badass but too each his own.
I agree it really is the true ending.
Did anybody else start crying when Arthur was riding back to beaver hallow on the final mission.
YES.
What a game! The story, the characters, the setting, the details, the action... Rockstar had outdone themselves with this one! Will be replaying this masterpiece for sure!
Waaay better than the GTA series. This game makes u feel like you're in 1899.
@@DonYoGi8331also it's way more emotional with it's story and characters
I cried when Authur said thank you to his horse before he died. And when he was killed too.
Niko Bellic same that’s sad 😞
Poor old Auther, too bad Arthur wasn’t there for him
Roman: there there Niko...... Wanna go bowling to feel better
I'm sorry its an ugly city
Bro I literally did no joke
Arthur is the only character in ANY game that I’ve played that had me crying when they died. Edit-(Bruh everybody telling me games in the comments. I’ve played most of those games. THEY HAVENT MADE ME CRY! So I made this comment based on my experiences)
Thanos lee from the walking dead
Season 1
Same
Ghost, Soap, Dom, Cayde-6, John Marston and Trigger(rd2 Horse) all hit me in the feels
Thanos I cried when Lee died in the first walking dead series by telltale
Dutch showing up and shooting micah just expands his character so much more in the last final bit.
He knew he shoulda done that a long time ago, before he went insane.
If you had a dry eye your first play through, you have to have no heart! The best game I have ever played. Story wise and graphics combined to make something truly amazing.
I had a dry eye the hole game except when Lenny died
I didn't cry in my first game because I always skipped all the cinematics xD
I never cried. Whenever someone of the gang died, I was just feeling anger and bloodlust against the person or group who killed them. If I got the death at the sunrise, I would maybe cry, as I wouldn't have anyone to hate. But I got shot in the head by Micah. I still am pissed off at that son of a wench. I am making sure to play honorably this time.
I laughed my first playthrough
My heart is screaming. But my face is not showing anything.
Rumor has it that to this day Dutch still has a plan
He still needs more money just a lil more
@Etruriano only the ones that have some goddamn faith!
Herm Man one more big take
Dutch died in 1911 he killed himself the last gang member was Jack Masrton
Ok I hate to spoil, not that it already has by someone else but... (press read more for spoil)
Red dead redemption 1 is set about 15 years after rdr2 is set, therefore the rest of, or most of, the gang members left in rdr2 are alive. Dutch in rdr1, I assume, goes completely insane or gets something wrong with him like depression and jumps off a cliff killing himself.
Imagine at the end on the cliff arthur spits on micah and laughs
*Micah* : what's so funny black lung ?
*Arthur* : nothing black lung
That would be so epic
What's more epic is if Arthur could have killed Micah. :)
This is canon to me
@Josh Aha if Arthur wasn't sick I would beat the life out of that bastard. I wish as John though we could have beat him up. :(
@Josh Yeah I have
Just finished it for a 2nd time and still hurts, as soon as he started telling Abigail Sadie and Jack goodbye I started crying cos I knew what was coming 🤧 One of my favourite games of all time!!! A true masterpiece, just like The Last Of Us, this needs to be made into a series! But ONLY if the cast is absolutely perfect, no changes needed, just so more people can witness the great storyline
brad pitt would be good for the casting of arthur morgan
Great idea! I would love to see that someday!
We all know micah was a pussy hr waited to he got tb to fight him micah a weak ahh character he wouldn't even last 3 seconds with prime Arthur
depends how close he can get the accent, the voice is already perfect, i wouldn't compromise @@CripticK1ng
@@CripticK1ngno.
Lenny was my favorite character behind Arthur and when he died my whole body just jolted in shock
Fellow Lenny fan
My first run thru I got a good ending. Mica didn’t kill Arthur. I helped John escape and didn’t care for the money. Dutch walked away and so did Micah. Arthur crawled and sat up and died looking at the sunset. It was sad but compared to the ones I’ve seen. I was content
I feel the same way thats the ending i got to
Did you have high honor to get that ending??
@@ThtShottaRock223 yes high honor
I was just below high honour bc i was bad at the syart but when i knew he got TB i started doing better and fixing up his life. I didnt care for the money but i still got the black wolf. In the end i still know that my arthur was a good guy, fighting until his last breath, not fearing death or begging for mercy. A true selfless warrior and helped john instead of money
Arthur: *Tells Dutch all the things he did and the years he spent with him*
Micah: He's sick
@Jacob Wood Dutch: I sure agree, my dear boy
Mans got covid
Dutch didn't help Arthur cuz he knew he was wrong or didn't go with Micah cuz he was the rat
But he went with micah just for money all he could think was tahitian mango and not loyalty to arthur
@goshty plays looool exactly hahah
If Arthur never contracted TB, everybody that turned on him and John, would be dead real quick. None of them were match for Arthur in his prime.
TheOracle123 a healthy Arthur would’ve killed Micah before he would’ve exposed him.
TheOracle123 especially with his insane deadeye skills
@@INCONTINENS not even John. Especially before John met Landon Rickets
Dutch, Charles, Javier, John, bill etc. Don’t underestimate them, especially Dutch. Dutch taught Arthur everything he knows.
JustTac but we all know what happened when John tried to do that 😬...
The best story game I've played in my life. It deserves an Oscar.
oscar is for movie actors fool.... It is a game
@@DylanClements98 u are ridiculus.
No matter what ending you get, this game will always hit hard😢
Low honor is allot more depressing
Am I the only thinking the red dead stories are both good enough for movies, like just word for word
Me nd my cousin was just talking about this
no. in a movie there would be no honor system, no multiple endings, no immersion with shaving, bathing, eating, changing clothes based on temperature, etc...
@@wapiti7151 a netflix film, where you can choose like black mirror bandersnacht would be good
Except for that they are probably longer
You are not wrong movie directors please make these into movies
Damn, this guy gave up his time just to watch Arthur die 4 times in a row. This man is strong
Edit after 2 years this comment is still my most liked comment ever lmao
4 ? I only saw 3
@@JeSuisUnFRUIT help john good bad honor and get to money good and bad
You only see him die 3 times but it exits 4 endings
Just save right before
@@jonmann4980 well obviously, but it still takes time and a toll on your heart. Watching Arthur die four times is hard to do.
Best game I ever played. I beat this game for the first time last night and I was finding myself tearing up at work today a couple of time thinking about the game. The action, adventure, friends that I made, people I’d saved and people who saved me, how flawed the characters were but they were trying to survive and be better people. I really tried to be a good person in this game and I made decisions based off of what I think I’d actually do in real life. I became like Arthur in my mind and how people treated Arthur in the game felt like a true of my own personality in real life. I have never felt like that playing a video game. Never. Maybe I’m just being too dramatic but I really love this game. I love it like it’s a valuable family heirloom. If I have kids, im going to tell them about it. Hopefully they’ll play it too and appreciate it as much as I do. I hope the people responsible for this game never lose that spark that inspired the creativity required for this work of art and I hope they make another and another. God bless, brothers and sisters. This is a great time to be alive.
This is the first game in my entire life that made me both attached to a character and cry!! The last ride to the camp and the "Thank You" to the horse opened the floodgates. I was lucky to have ended the game where he dies peacefully in the mountains as the Sun comes up. Arthur Morgan deserved it!!
First thing I did as the Epilogue started was visit his grave and pay my respect!!
I think I made the perfect ending. For the whole game I saw the wolf, I never saw the stag once, my honor was very low, I tried to play as an outlaw would. When Arthur gets diagnosed, I was still seeing the wolf, but I thought about how Arthur wanted to be a better man; not a good man, but a good man amongst bad men. I started playing as a good Arthur, never took rewards from people and I always tried to help any strangers I found. In the end, I chose to help John escape; after I fought Micah, both he and Dutch left Arthur to die in the mountain, and I finally saw the stag after the sun set on a redeemed Arthur. I had never cried at the end of a game before this. It felt so perfect.
That is so perfect.
I did the exact same actually, it was beautiful
Lucky you i was just below the good honor and got the bad ending
Damn wish I hadn’t played with the lowest possible honor hahaha I played like a little kids first time on gta. Your’s sounds like canon though tbh
My playthrough was exactly the same
High Honor Author: 🦌
Low Honor Author: 🐺
Micah: 🐀
😭💀 I JUST DIED, lmao i was crying until i saw this comment now i’m crying of laughter... i need to go to bed lnao
lmao*
Author lol
Edgar Ross:🐀
Micah high honor:🐍
Dutch high honor:💰
Low honor dutch:plans
how on earth can a game make us connect with each character so well emotionally, one of the bests.
'That's the way it is' gets me every time. I play a bunch of songs on my record player when handing out candy on Halloween. Mostly Horror movie, and Horror game music, but that's always the last song of the night.
There should have been an ultimate good honor ending where Arthur spits on Micah during their fight
Thats what he shoulda done. Damn
But honorable people don’t spit on dead bodies
That should have been a karma ending. But fuck rockstar .
@@drewhendrickson2467 And rats
Maybe that’s the ending where you have neutral honor...
the whole time arthur and micah were fighting in screaming
"COUGH ON HIM"
"COUGH ON HIM"
"COUGH ON HIM"
The fun thing about tuberculosis is that you can die of it and still not be infectious to others. Arthur's TB has progressed fast and he had several episodes of coughing up blood. This means that that his lungs could have still been in a decent shape, unlike his lungs' blood vessels. It's shown that he's pale (anemic) and can't eat (because this triggers his cough reflex).
@@ramiabiakar2391 damnit well maybe micah got some symptoms
@lanar faret you literally connected nothing from the original dudes comment. Pipe down mate
@lanar faret Don't copy and paste shit from Google that you got no damn clue what they mean
Germs can kill good people, but they can't kill the devil, and that's who Micha is.
The part where arthur is riding to save John. And the song plays. It just hits different every single time. So much time spent, to feel the end coming soon. Just makes the soul sad. When you know. You are happy.
Highest honor is probably the best way to have arthur die... he told hosea, when his time comes he'd like to die facing the rising sun.. I believe this ties up nicely with Arthur's character, he tries to be the best man he can be before his impending death while being loyal to the gang.
Bad honor, get the money: greed
Good honor, get the money: revenge
Bad honor, help John: forgiveness
Good honor, help John: REDEMPTION
Nice
Bad honor help John is the most brutal ending for Arthur getting shot in the face
@@austintufnell7529 lucky me who ofc got that one
@@manylandy1280 same, just finished the game after having it For 3 years.
@@AlbertoBalsalm bro same 😂
I find it cool how helping John involves climbing a mountain, being very high in the sky as though it is symbolic for heaven, where as going back for the money has you go back down to your burning camp, symbolic for hell.
I didnt thinked that way :0
Tbh I went back for the money, I saw it as getting the money to help John to set himself up, alas it didn’t quite work out that way
I went for the money with high honor, took out michah's eye and died with satisfaction.
Not really
I love how it kinda goes full circle from the first mission: now as John, you must brave the snowy mountains much like Arthur did for him. As John goes up the mountain, the music and cues from the first game come on, evolving him into the John we all know and love.
This is by far the best game , ever. It had everything, the emotions at the end of the game is something else . Your horse dying , Arthur saying goodbye, and then arther himself dying . The story , the characters, the graphics, its seamless. Its a must .
The little saying "we aren't criminals were outlaws" just stuck I love that little part
Fun fact: when Javier points his gun up instead of at John and Arthur, that was actually requested by the voice actor for Javier. The voice actor didn’t think Javier would side with Dutch so that’s why.
@@trajanranae9772 look it up ya lazy fuckin bitch!!! find the source like most us do........
I agree. I was extremely surprised when Javier stood with Dutch.
Whoaaa that’s awesome!
Gunflyze in red dead 1 he didn’t side with dutch , he was by himself
@@delusionalperson4848 Thats the way it is.
19:25 press x to crawl
Mica: you aint gonna reach the gun.
* stressed x bashing *
@Sploady Cat reeeeeeeeeeeee
i dont think ive tapped that fast in my life ever
I’ve played both endings, but saving John only seems right, like John says before *American Venom* “None of this would’ve happened without Arthur,”. That’s why I prefer helping John then going for the money, and being greedy.
Sploady Cat same dude it’s crazy
PeltzoDelzo lmao same
In the last Arthur Say "Thank You" to his horse that hit me on another level ❤
I’ve never been one to cry over video games, but this one, this game right here had me crying over my computer. Never while I was downloading it did I think I’d become so emotionally attached to video game characters.
Good job Rockstar, definitely the best game I’ve played in a while!
I wish Arthur would just respawn like normally
Me too
Me too
(WARNING CURSED)
me to
TastySmooth how so?
Me too
Even when on his death bed
Dying from TB
After falling off a cliff
Beaten and bruised
Exhausted
Authur still nearly won.
And he didn't fully won, because on his last moments, Arthur planted the seeds of distrust in Dutch's head. It was only a matter of time before Dutch puts a bullet through Micah's chest.
He did win
@Karkat Vantas I love the ending because at face value it seems almost like the bad ending, but once you know the context it really is one of the best ending you can get
He fully won
@@superrexer6816 which ending?
I was shocked when micah goes "i got the all the money from blackwater" and then the part where dutch pops out of the cabin
25:54
Just shows how scary and badass of a villain Arthur would make
The only time micah seemed human was in chapter 1 when he said “Morgan I think there’s a dead body right here”
gel mibson I think he saw Dutch, and Arthur mercilessly killing, and looked up to them
Varelity
im pretty sure micah was just worried about his own ass dying.
615 W ikr
First time i though it was john
Yeah I remember then I thought Micah was an ok character but later I hated him. He did seem pretty worried about the dead body.
An asteroid is heading for earth and will wipe every thing
Dutch: I have a plan
But I need money
All Male gang members (except John): "Shit Abigail is pregnant"
Dutch: "I have a plan... oh John!?"
We make a gatlin gun that fires mangos from our farm in Tahiti to pulverize the asteroid
We just need some moar muneh
Ill just walk away
Dutch is one of the most tragic characters I've seen, I think he was truly a good guy who got his mind scrambled by the events he's been through and Micah ofcourse.
No, I think it was Hosea keeping him in check that kept him "good" at first. Dutch was always a horrible person, it was just the loss of his best friend, the increased stress from the Pinkertons, and the paranoia of there being a rat in the gang that revealed who he truly was.
No dutch became weak after hosea did and he realized that he might not be the planner and visionary that he thought he was. He then retreatet into himself letting micah do all the planning. This is why he said "I ain't got much to say these days" before he left in the mountains. So sad to see this broken man😢
22:03 TENNIS BOAT 🎾🛶
I feel bad for everyone who’s game had Micah kill them, that’s the most disrespectful ending
Terribly Drawn History we had it coming really
I became a rotten "Arthur" when he got sick. I was upset with the game that he was getting sicker and it came out as being a bad person in game.
It’s who ever had low honour
@@CptStankFanger I was actually opposite. My honor was kinda low because I kept robbing people for money. It wasn't until Arthur got sick and I tried to get my honor up. It was too late anyways.
Terribly Drawn History thankfully mine didn’t do that
I have never been so attached to a character that I cried when he died
Dude same I began tearing up when John came back after he almost died I was like "dam bro crap got real deep"
I no joke cried for 35 minutes and i couldn't even start the Epilogue 💀 I got the Good, High Honor ending
Me too.. I cant imagined arthur died in that way. I hooked wtih him so much.. When im playing as john i cant stop myself to cry i remember everything arthur did.. I cnt moved on.
Same
@@KittiesnCrochets same, I just, I’m taking a breather rn
This is the best open game I’ve ever played. I’ve got 425 games and this tops the list, played it 4 times and never get sick of it ❤
I love how in the 1st One Sadie comforts Abigail just as Abigail had in the beginning of the game
I got a good ending but Micah didn’t kill me? Anyone else get the one where Arthur crawls to the top, watches the sunset and then peacefully dies?
Me
yes its in the video
Meh
If u have a good honor level then that happens but if u have a bad honor level then u get shot by micah
Micah shot me in the head
By the time I started, I was dissapointed that I didn't get to play as John. By epilogue I was annoyed to be playing as john. Rockstar's character development in this game was genius
same bro, i almost wanted to quit after arthurs death
@@sashakys I did. I only played as John long enough to go visit Arthurs grave.
Same. My bf said before rdr2, he thought there is no wayitd have a better character to be than john, then they blew johns character out of the water. Plus every time i get to epilogue, im like how tf im supposed to play this when im GRIEVING TEARS IN MY EYES AND ALL AND YALL JUST ACT LIKE ARTHUR NEVER EXISTED.
I still like John more, but maybe because I grew up playing him. Playing someone else in this game and having John as an AI felt like an out of body experience. Never got used to that.
@@hales6547 Yeah in Redemption 1 they act like half these huge characters don't exist lol. Shame.
The only reget I made was taking White Arabian from Lake Isabella. When she died, I really felt like lost a close friend and cried. When the death came to Arthur and watching sun set with him. I felt really at ease. Farewell, Morgan. You became a part of my heart from now on.
The biggest betrayal in the history of gaming is Dutch to Arthur
Also when Big Smoke and Ryder sold out CJ and Sweet to Ballas and Crash
Factsssss smfhh
But cj still manage to kill them and prove himself. Most important he was alive.
Up there w Gen. Shepard
No, dutch to everyone
Arthur: dies and goes to heaven
Arthur: HeRe YoU ArE LenNYyyy!
Poor Arthur,so sad :'(
Angel I laughed, and I know I’m a terrible person lmao
This made me feel so much better ngl
I thought Arthur was gonna go to hell ngl
No they met in hell
I can not possibly imagine what's going on in Arthur's head while he makes that last solitary horseback ride. That scene rocks so hard.
Thank you so so so much for showing me every way to pass it
Abigail: **crying** "Oh, Arthur-"
Arthur: "Don't you "Oh, Arthur" me..."
Mary Linton: **cowers in fear**
@@victory8992 lmfaooaoaooakaaklapqmwn
😂😂
haha yeah😂 thats what he said 😭 its sad he dident make it
How do you get the different endings
The only fight Micah ever won was against a diying, beaten man with tuberculosis who somehow survived a ten meter fall and kept fighting for his life until TB got him on the ground.
And still took forever to win
@@herbyhancock9340 Yeah XD
And the little girl he killed
Why Arthur didn't spit in his mouth I will never know
As soon as he got diagnosed with TB by the doctor in saint denis the whole way through after that I kept doing the rest of the missions thinking shut the fuck up oh my god oh I’m hurtin Arthur yeah well I have fucking tuberculosis
There is another ending where if you choose to stay with John you don't get shot by Micah. They leave you there dying, Arthur crawl over the edge and you die just watching the sunshine.
Thanks for letting us know
When the music started playing I cryed a little
Tilly: "Hey Arthur, if I were to kill Ms. Grimshaw, would Dutch be mad?"
Arthur: "Yeah, probably."
Micah: *Kills Ms. Grimshaw*
Dutch: *Sides with Micah*
Lol I remember tilly saying that
At the beginning of chapter 3 and at the end of chapter 6 Grimshaw argues over the camp's safety with Dutch where he gets angry that's why he didn't care about her death
Well Dutch loves Micah.
Dont know if you noticed but dutch kinda WENT INSANE
@@princessstarlaixyarixes8103 but dutch shot micah
I made a new save and now I antagonize Micah everyday
these chips are good Bless 😩😩
I wish I would've
these chips are good
I did it anyway. Never liked how he called Arthur “cowpoke” all the time. Disappointed Arthur didn’t strangle him on the ridge
Thx
Lol I always did from the start I never liked him
I just finished this game for the 6th time! 10 out of 10! A masterpiece!
I really liked how John had his happy ending with Abigail, their home, barn and family just like the first RDR but without him being killed!
I hope there will be a next chapter in South America with Mrs. Sadie Adler as the main character! that would be awesome!
Sadie was and will be the best female character ever that Rockstar games made!
The extra secret ending is Micah kills both Aurthor and John and the character you play after is Uncle the main objective is to cure his lumbago. I got the Uncle ending
Reported
Uncle goes to mount hagun and uses lumbago eye to kill micah
“Author” lololol
Author right tus haha
But uncle dies in rdr1
The TB kills Arthur’s body, but saves Arthur’s soul
makes sense, without realizing he was doomed he probably wouldnt have been able to be that altruistic
Or ‘redeemed’ his soul
@@emon2689 get out
@@watsoncouch3800 ?
@@Max-fu3hp absolutely. But it services the story.
John ran and ran, but he eventually couldn't outrun his past and settle down at the same time.
Arthur stopped running when he realised he was dying and could save others instead of just dying.
This is my favorite game of all time. The emotion that this game can give to a person is unreal. Arthur Morgan is the best video game character ever
John: What are you doing here Dutch?
Dutch: Same as you, I suppose.
Yeah Dutch was there to kill Micah all along, no doubt about it.
Micah: *shoots Ms Grimshaw*
Dutch: wHo iS bEtRaYiNg mE?
He thought she is betraying him
@@Heisenberg929 aww shit wasup dude im sorry for your horse
@@Heisenberg929 wow your trump an arthur cool
@@Heisenberg929 you're right
Ms grimshaw sided with Arthur and dutch, so in his eyes, she a betrayer.
Red Dead Redemtion 2 felt like a goddamn movie.
Then it was the best movie I've ever seen
Started as a goddamn movie, ended as a goddamn movie.
More like wild west breaking bad lol
And it wasn't just like some games where it's like 90 percent movie ten game it's like a solid 50 50 interactive movie
I kind of consider RDR2 more of an interactive movie than a video game.
I am glad that I lived during the times of arthur morgan's rdr2. Lucky to live the life of the most awe aspiring fictional character accross all the platforms, be it analogue or digital, in the history of content creation.
I miss my horse Taya, sleep well girl
please when Arthur puts his hat on John all i see is an older brother telling his little brother to run
😢
man..
I got chills reading that
I feel like Arthur was a teacher to John kind of
@@doflash9210 like an older brother kinda
After Arthur Morgan died, remember from his conversation with Rains Falls. Arthur's son was waiting for him, Arthur can be with his son again.
Omg I never even thought about that
That's actually made me feel better about him dying
Thank you so much
What son?
TRexx 070 Arthur’s son
@@dbdbdbdbdb123 When did he have a son?
TRexx 070 he had a son with Another wife who died, Arthur’s son and his ex wife both died in a shooting .
When you pump 12 shots into to Mika’s body, it is definitely the most satisfying kill in the entire game.
What??
When arthur said "not molly, not miss grimshaw, not even colm" he almost sounded like the tone in his voice was similar to like he was pleeding for his life like they have similar tones in their voice
I love how Arthur still almost wiped the floor with Micah even though he is literally on the brink of death
I know you whooped his ass
Yeah you beat the everlasting fuck out of him
Arthur could throw a mean punch.
I have a question:
Why Arthur can't just throw Micah out of a cliff with him or without?
Sorry for my bad English
@@deancientwhomst6648 Probably because Micah can resist being thrown off a cliff by a man on the brink of death...
wish i could wipe my memory and play this masterpiece again
You can just focus
Brandon Jay Doluta I beat it once and waited another 2 years to beat it again, still cried like a bitch both times
Random Cancer01 the game ain’t even been out for 2 years
@@tristincasares4294 i got ADHD, i cant focus that much
Random Cancer01 I know you ain’t talking bout rdr2 this game only been out for alittle over a year
I just replayed the game after a few years, and I was able to max out my honour during the final mission where you choose between helping John or getting the money.
i remember it felt like i lost everything, especially when i lost my horse. it felt like a shot through my heart.
Did anyone else put on Arthur’s hat on John just so he could be a part of Micah’s death?
andy lujan i did
I did
i purposely always wore arthurs hat, even when the game switched back after a mission
I legit got mine shot off picked it up as 4 were shooting at my and head shot all of em. Also during free roam I I lost Arthur’s hat and it’s not on my horse any one got some ideas to help me get that hat back
@@jansenstokes7064 if it's not on your horse it should be in your main wardrobe, the place at camp or an inn room where you can see all of your outfits.
Arthur's voice when he begged Dutch to do something about Micah was just heartbreaking
I started crying
I felt that too
Murv the ending on the mountain