I gotta tell ye man, I've seen this video at least 20 times since it came out, way before I was even making videos. it's so enjoyable, it's relaxing, educational plus the Knives rock, it made me pull the trigger on my GNS knife. really excellent content.
That review should be the benchmark for knife vids. Excellent job Joe! As similar as they are, you really do want both. Tough to explain to a "non-knife" person. I was looking at both, but couldn't remember why I went with the Genesis. After looking at your vid, I remember it was in the handle. I got the impression the scales were thicker. Too many of my smaller knives has thin handles. But, even having the Genesis, I still want the GNS. It's a classic Bushlore clone.
northof50now Wow man, thanks! Humbling words my friend and they truly mean a lot, thank you. It really is hard to choose which is better. That being I do personally find the handle on the Genesis to be superior. Thanks again man.
Don't forget you can get both knives in either Scandi or Saber grind. So, it's really a choice of 4 knives. Unfortunately, I like the thinner tip of the GNS, but the handle of the Genesis. : )
Good review man. Thanks for doing this review. I love the handle on my Genesis, its the best I have ever found. I love the A2 steel as well. Having said all that the GNS looks like one heck of a nice knife!
Your statement about the GNS handle is what drives me crazy about my Benchmade bushcraft. There is nothing there for the little finger to get a good wrap on. Enjoyed your video.
Say Heah, A while ago I bought two Himalayan Imports M-43 Khukuris, The reason I got a smaller one because I wanted to carry it on person because it is lighter. The first one came with a black Buffalo Horn Handle which I ordered. The smaller one came with a White Bone handle, It's a beauty so I kept it. But I like to match knives in atleast pairs, I didn't have a white handle knife. I got a e-mail on a new knife from Battle Horse so I pulled a trigger on it because it's similar to your knives and I like those blade shapes, I have a Blind Horse Bushcrafter similar blade shapes, But the Attitude is a 5"+ blade which is great for me and I had it thinned down and a High Scandi Grind. Now I have a knife to match my white handle Khukuri. Believe me this video helped more than you think, Thanx.
I just ordered a Genesis the other day I tend to like the broom stick type of handle looking forward to using in it. thanks for the video very. good information atb John
Turtle Bushcraft That is my leaning as well. They are both comfy in their own way but I think the Genesis handle, for me, is more comfortable. Thanks John
I don't think I asked this, but I was thinking it. I'm still up in the air, but I'm thinking a GNS in scandi. still up in the air though. Thank you for the comparison man!
Funny Joe. I measured my Genesis. My scales are coming in at 1" at the butt end. It seems to look more like the "one foot..." version without the liners. I wonder if, over the course of production, they changed the shape slightly, or is there a difference from one finisher to the next. My guess is the latter. I think the "one foot..." version is thicker primarily due to the liners. Again, excellent review.
northof50now I honestly couldn't tell you. I would imagine that there would be slight variations between knives as they are hand made. I have had 2 (regular) Genesis's and the handle felt the same on both but I didn't measure the first one. Thanks again!
While this was helpful it has become dated as I have the GNS in AEB-L stainless steel and a scandi grind. I'd love to see a comparison of these knives with the same grind and steel but we can't expect you guys to have everything lol. Great video thank you for what you do!
Good review, Joe, & thanks for your thoughts. I owned an original GNS & so wanted to love it, but sold it after several months of use. Overall good knife, the handle was very comfortable in the hand & it is a sharp looking piece. However, after using Moras for years, I found the GNS to not perform as well for the feathering. I believe it is because for me the blade angle is different, so required holding it differently. I've had several other Scandi edge blades & for me that is the best angle. I'd like to see a comparison between the Genesis & the Scandi GNS if possible. Had the Scandi GNS been around from the start, I would have grabbed one & I'm sure would still have it. Keep up the good work! ~Steve H.
I like this review a lot. It's only in the last several months that I've started to take notice of LT Wright Knives. There are others in his line of blades that I also have an interest in but the Genesis and the GNS are a good beginning for me. I have a passion for knives, both hunter and bushcraft, and LT Wright Knives are nothing less than beautiful in every way. They are icons.
Excellent video my friend,im thinking of getting the LT.Geneis,i have very big hands triple X gloves and I really appreciate the details you did about the handles.Stay safe.
+MrRapper85 I differ from most (I think) and I use the very tip for processing most of the game unless I am cutting deep into the meat so honestly they both work just as well. That being said, I'd choose the Genesis only b/c I prefer that handle. And thank you very much, I greatly appreciate it!
Great video, you just made my point and why my Benchmade Bushcrafter #162 is one of my fav's the saber grind is similar to the G.S.N. but as far as edge retention the S30V is a good one too.butvthen my Rod Garcia Skookum Bush Tool is a great slicer too and it's a scandi grind, I think it's all how thin the edge is too because my John Bradley World's Finest Camp Knife has a very thin full flat grind with a Zero Edge and talking about slicing, but as far as a stronger grind my fav is a saber vex grind, so my Benchmade Bushcrafter #162 is used alot but then so is my Blind Horse Bushcrafter grrrrrrrrrrrr I'm confused heh heh heh, should I go on heh heh heh.
I recently picked up a genesis. The shop I bought it from had the one foot in the wild edition and I really wanted that one but the handle was just too fat for me. I think it's the difference between no liners vs. liners. Really liked the sheath though.
+Garen Osborn Yep I concur. And the scales are rounded just a bit more to accommodate the the thickness of the liners as well. Ironically, I am constantly "complaining" about small handles due to my large hands, yet I didn't like the larger handle on the One Foot into the Wild edition because it was too fat. Weird, huh? How are you liking that Genesis?
GNS Handle Style is called the: 'Border Patrol handle' (taken from Randall Knives). Examples include Terava Jarriikapuukko 110 and 140, Peltonen Sissipuukko M95 and some Randalls can be optioned with the handle. IMHO, it is the best handle in the world that gives the best compromise of heavy duty work (75%), then defence (25%). It is a very sure footed and comfortable handle IF done right and imo the GNS was NOT done right. The best working handles have no guards whatsoever, Lagom Bush Knife for example. Where MOSt manufactirers fail at Kepharts, Puukkos and most hard use knives is they make the handles too short. I would rather have a blade shorter than my handle. Blade 3.7". Handle 5". This is perfection for an EDC knife, IMO.
+Matthew Jeffres Both in my opinion. The saber grind of the GNS would have a longer last edge I think but the Genesis has a bit more belly so it has pluses too. LT does make a Genesis in Flat grind and that would be a superb field dressing knife I think. Thanks for watching!
I know its about a year late, but I was wondering what that "sheet" or bag is that you're kneeling on? I wont ask about the knives as I feel you have more than explained every a response to every question which might come into my mind about either knife. My own preference would be governed, after all other considerations, by what I feel would fit my hand best. Great video and thanks for sharing it!
+MrTatts64 Not a problem bud! And ask away if you do happen to think of a question, I don't mind a bit. That bag/sheet is what I call my Firecraft Pad. czcams.com/video/u2IfJUyHtv8/video.html I had hopes of getting it made and on the market but no one really wants to touch it. I "thought" is a good idea lol Thanks for the support man!
+Feral Woodcraft Many thanks for that mate. I cant imagine what sensible reason any company would have for not wanting to be involved with your Firecraft Pad. From the first video I saw you in (via Gaunlet TV), you were using it and I saw right away that you had a good thickness of material between yourself and the floor. Very important when it's cold and / or wet. Before you told me the name of it just now, I could see its value when knelt at the fire cooking or even just building the fire. Then most important of all, keeping your butt warm and dry whilst having a coffee ;) I suppose there are not enough bells and whistles attached to it. Seems that things "need" to have that something extra these days. Heaven knows why because since the days of plonking your butt on a patch of mammoth hide, simple has proven to be not only the best, but the least likely to fail as well! Perhaps it needs an "X" added to the name? Firecraft-X Pad, lol. Ironically, I was watching your review of the Genesis, from nearly two years ago when your reply on this thread came through :) Keep up the great work and the excellent videos. Thanks, Andy.
+MrTatts64 Thank you very much Andy. I do have further ideas for it but I'd need someone to make prototyps etc etc. I keep telling myself, I'll just sit down and sew them one day (I actually can sew OK) but I just simply don't have time for it to be a regular thing. But you are likely right, not enough flash lol Thanks again!
I know this video is a year old, but I wanted to comment on what you said about the grip on the GNS. I have read that LT designed the grip so that when carving near the base of the blade you choke up on the knife and hook you thumb over the front of the grip. This gets the back of your hand higher on the grip and into the palm swell making it more comfortable to do things like push cuts. Have you ever tried using it that way?
Have you since sharpened the micro bevel out of the Genesis? If so, have you noticed any real difference in performance? I ask because I was watching another youtube and knife maker use two knives that he made, both scandi but one had a micro and the other was zero ground and he noted that they performed as two very different knives. If I understand correctly, that makes perfect sense as by adding a micro bevel you are adding a small secondary that is more obtuse than the primary grind which is going to bite into the wood at a before a zero grind would. As an aside, from my own testing I find that something such as a full flat or saber, IE knives with a secondary will make, at least for me, narrower curls when feather sticking whereas a scandi tends to make wide feathers. Also, scandis seem to hog off wood like a plane blade. Anyway, just curious to hear your experiences if you have since zeroed the grind.
I've owned 2 Genesis scandi blades. 1 I removed it and 1 I didn't. Overall, I prefer the micro bevel. It, for me, has less over bite and is much more controllable. And I do agree with you. Saber, flat, and convex tell d make thinner curls much easier. That's not to say scandi can't do it but the more obtuse as you put it, the more easily they are controlled on the finer work. At least that's been my experience. Thanks!!
+Feral Woodcraft I am buying a new knife this weekend, should I get the Genesis DWX edition the GNS or a bark River bravo 1 ? For bushcraft.. I really like the bark River bravo 1 too but love the GNS and Genesis. I never owned either blade this will be my first. Please help me out
I received my L.T. Wright Genesis yesterday. To say I'm disappointed is putting it mildly. When I removed it from it's paper wrap I noticed thin white marks on the handle that wouldn't wipe off. After closer inspection I realized they are cracks in the wood. There's a noticeable pit in the wood too. The white seems to be buffing compound embedded in those small cracks. The knife edge has more grind on one side making it uneven. The lanyard tube is unrefined on the inside making the edge sharp. The knife came sharp but not very sharp. Grinder marks on the edge also. As a bonus the sheath is rough as a brick on the inside. For $235.00 I have a knife that has been amateurishly and indifferently produced. My first and last L.T. Wright knife.
I really hate to hear that Billy and it honestly really surprises me. I have no idea how something like that could have slipped past their QC but I'm sure that LT would want to address it. May I suggest giving LT a call? LT's warrantee is one of the best in the business and I feel certain he'd work with you to make sure you are satisfied.
Thank you for your reply and advice. I used a .45 cal. bore brush on the sheath and it is now soft on the inside and as a whole the entire sheath more pliable after hand rubbing it with Neatsfoot oil. The knife is now sharp after elbow grease and water stones. I'll keep it but have no faith in that company. I can live with the handle imperfections. Take care.
Say Heah Joe, Yeah, We defenetly have similar taste. I had my Battle Horse modified, I had a Slight curve added to it by taking the high point on the pommel down and I had the droo point lowered giving it a slightly curved look . But by lowering the drop point it helps when I push cut with my thumb. I like a little more belly this helps me when I carve when doing some fine task's. I also got a high scandi this too allow's for a thinner apex gaining sone cutting adventage, I stropped a micro convex to help with adding strength too when I baton and stab and twistvmaking kindling, I don't like a sausage handle and the Attitude cines with a nice flaired pimmelband a hand swell, Just the way uh huh, uh huh I like it. I also got a white G-10 handle with blue liner's, It came out Beautiful, So I ordered a matching Mad Hatter and that came out as if a drubk boy scout made it, DISAPPOUNTED. !!! I guess there Moto is One Out Of Two Isn't Bad heh heh heh, Man then Atlanta 's kicking butt, nit a good day for me, I might have to take it easy with my cigar's or the new knives I was going to order grrrrrrrr. ,, .
That is definitely a good option. A better option for just a few more dollars is the Deer Creek Forge Kephart. It's a tad more expensive then the condor but a far better blade. Thanks!
I have one of each I have a PT limited Genesis full flat with the micro bevel and I also have the Gns scandi both a excellent tools I do prefer the handle on my Genesis a bit more and the full flat do incredible at feather stick's and carving the scandi GNS how ever is a thicker blade so I feel in an abuse situation if it came down to that I would be less concerned not that I haven't done a fair amount of batoning with my Genesis just prefer to use my hand Axe in concordenence with the Genesis out side of the knife I designed Genesis is my favorite so far either way Lt wright makes an incredible tool and look forward to owning more want a Genesis scandi in the as you wish model when tax return makes it in
Thank you for the video,. You did a great job on covering what each knife is capable of doing in handling wood, but you did not mention anything about sharpening the knives, or game processing, or camp chores. Unfortunately, I can only afford to buy one knife and to be quite honest with you, I can not even afford to do that at this time. I have several questions and if you have a chance to answer them, it would mean a great deal to me. First of all: Is it as hard to sharpen a Saber Grind in he field as people say? Is the Scandi grind really that much easier to hone up and sharpen in comparison? Which grind works better for game processing? Field dressing game? Skinning Game? Processing Game? Which grind works best at camp chores? Meal preparations such as cutting up potatoes, and vegetable? Slicing meats, fish, and cheese? Cutting cordage? In addition to processing wood, it very important to be able to maintain an edge in the field and to cut and process the fish, game, and wild edibles in which we harvest or pack in. I know I am asking a lot, but because you already have the experience with these two types of grinds, the question I have to ask is this? IF YOU COULD ONLY HAVE ONE. WOULD YOU CHOOSE A SCANDI GRIND OR SABER GRIND? Thank you for you time and you efforts. Sincerely, Donny Zarra Pittsburgh, PA
I would have been interested in his reply. What did you end up getting, and why? I doubt I am sophisticated enough to notice any difference, as long as the knife is sharp and comfortable in the hand.
Valid question. Don't hold me to this 100% but I believe the GNS was designed a collaboration between LT, Dave Canterbury, and SRI as the be all end all bushcraft/survival knife. It does look like it is influenced by the classic European Woodlore style but I have read nothing directly saying that it was. I wish I had a more specific answer for you but that is all I know; I hope it helps!
Great review, but since the Genesis and GNS both come in scandi grind, wouldn't it be a more fair and balanced comparison to have both knives in the same grind ? I understand you were showing the difference in the attributes of the blade grinds and your demonstration is excellent to that purpose, but it gives a false inpression of the two knife models the way it is presented. I know a little about L.T.Wright knives, I own a GNS scandi, but someone else might think the Genesis only came in a scandi grind and the GNS in a saber grind from watching this video . IMHO
I am pretty sure I covered that in there somewhere, maybe I didn't. It's been a long time since I filmed that. Anyway, those were the knives that I had at the time and folks were requesting it, so I answered with what I had and what they had been seeing on the channel.
Guillaume Bergeron Thanks! That test is mainly to mimic the process of cutting the notch out for a bow drill set, cutting notches for primitive trapping, etc. Thanks for watching!
I am curious though, what would you say is your overall favorite knife grind for a general purpose knife? How about a bushcraft specific knife? I would like to get my hands on a full flat Genesis, or even a saber Genesis, not to mention the scandi GNS... I've got a bit of a knife "problem"... Thanks again!
That problem is a common condition many of us share lol. As to your question. Hmmm. For straight up bushcraft specific I'd have to go scandi all the way but saber isn't far behind. For general purpose saber is best for me. But again, I think "the best grind" is by in large user preference. Thanks again!
Feral Woodcraft I can see that. I certainly agree about user preferences. I will say that I'm really starting to warm up to a saber grind. I despised it when I first got the SRI knife, but several sabers later it's now pretty high on my general purpose knife list. Keep up the great channel!
Buying the one foot in the wild edition this week. Just bought a Granfurs small forest axe so that set me back last week.abg advice on good ferro rods?
looked at this video over and over and the saber will be better at push cuts to over the scandi if you knock of the shoulders on some stones brother just thin it above the cutting bevel :-)
+Modernbushcraft I actually did do that after this vid with the Worksharp Blade Grinder attachment. It worked so well. Though, I will say, no blade with a vex or a secondary will push cut as well as a scandi. A nice thin hollow ground blade can come close though. One of these days I am going to get a GNS again, I miss that blade. A buddy gave me an offer I couldn't refuse for the one shown here. Thanks!!
Say Heah Joe, The $64,000.00 question, GSN vs. Genesis ?. Oh, I got my GSN in 3V, I wanted to put some of my touches, But Ekaine told me their not taking any custom orders, She told me they do that once a year and they are working to finish last cutom orderes so I got a GSN in the Coyote Black G-10 and a 3V Saber.,,.
+Modernbushcraft I honestly don't think you'd go wrong with either. I do have to admit that I am itching to try the Genesis with a full flat. Granted it's size renders it in a completely different class but I have a coyote from LT with a full flat and I really enjoy it. Thanks!
No, I haven't used an Enzo but I have been very tempted to grab one on many occasions. I've used a similar blade, the Entrek Forester and I absolutely loved it. I had a Bark River Aurora a couple years ago but gave it to a friend. Honestly, I miss it. It was a great blade and it could take a beating. I never had issue with chipping or had any sub par performance issues with it. Is there a particular model BR you're wanting information about?
+Overlap TheWorld you know what, I got the videos confused. I thought you commented on the Next Gen video I just posted. This genesis is black and the gns is natural. My apologies!!
No problem bud. I prefer maintaining the micro bevel. I go over how I do that here on the LT Wright Jessmuk. It's a different blade but the exact same process. czcams.com/video/KGJGMwxDzxI/video.html
+bushcraft fancy I apologize for the tardy response here, I've been offline for the holidays. Yep that will definitely do it. Careful with the strop though. If you do it too much, the slight give in the leather will allow for a slight convex to form. I know a lot of true zero ground scandi guys use either staged grits of super find sandpaper on a board or Japanese waterstones. I've used the former and it works well, but can be time consuming. The later I have not I am afraid. Please let me know how it turns out!
Ok,thanks for the reminder and I always keep a strop in my pack and have stropped my mora many times (and when i mean many I mean MANY times, I rarely have to sharpen my knives ) and have never even gotten close to a convex, maybe its because of the compound I use.
Have you used both of them to make statement like that? Both have totally different shape of the handles. Both must feel different when you hold them and when you use them. There's no question about that. Maybe you could say that it's not a big deal but for someone who's going to drop $180 on a tool, it matters.
dirtime yea I can say that...I wont say 100% I made a mistake.. but 99% guys watchn this video & even all the self proclaimed “ bushcrafters “ “survivalist” who put out same video’s of them making “feathersticks” & “batoning” a piece fucking wood would’nt know the difference between a $30.00 Schrade & a $400.00 TOPS..... I could put ironwood scales thrown on a couple bubinga liners on a Schrade SCHF 36 $30.00 blade & noone be the wiser... “ Bushcraft “ “ Survivalist “ has become nothing more than infomercials to sell products, get subscribers.....
@@baroneroberto3400 Schrade and TOPS are both shity knives. I think it's just you that can't understand what good performance is. Pick up a good bush knife someday. Then you'll know.
I gotta tell ye man, I've seen this video at least 20 times since it came out, way before I was even making videos. it's so enjoyable, it's relaxing, educational plus the Knives rock, it made me pull the trigger on my GNS knife. really excellent content.
Im waiting on a Genesis.
Your review is one of the best reviews I’ve ever seen. And I’ve seen at least 400 million reviews, give or take a few.
Holy cow man, just an amazing review... Thank you for this and man you knocked it out of the park! Best one yet!
The Bearded Burton Thanks Jonathan! I appreciate it a lot. I am glad you enjoyed it bro.
That review should be the benchmark for knife vids. Excellent job Joe! As similar as they are, you really do want both. Tough to explain to a "non-knife" person. I was looking at both, but couldn't remember why I went with the Genesis. After looking at your vid, I remember it was in the handle. I got the impression the scales were thicker. Too many of my smaller knives has thin handles. But, even having the Genesis, I still want the GNS. It's a classic Bushlore clone.
northof50now Wow man, thanks! Humbling words my friend and they truly mean a lot, thank you. It really is hard to choose which is better. That being I do personally find the handle on the Genesis to be superior. Thanks again man.
Don't forget you can get both knives in either Scandi or Saber grind. So, it's really a choice of 4 knives.
Unfortunately, I like the thinner tip of the GNS, but the handle of the Genesis. : )
Good review man. Thanks for doing this review. I love the handle on my Genesis, its the best I have ever found. I love the A2 steel as well. Having said all that the GNS looks like one heck of a nice knife!
***** It is Larry. I know I've said this before but I have a tough time picking between these two. Thanks!
Your statement about the GNS handle is what drives me crazy about my Benchmade bushcraft. There is nothing there for the little finger to get a good wrap on. Enjoyed your video.
Entertaining people with knowledge and experience. Thank you for your time.
Michael StJohn Thanks for the feedback, I really appreciate it!
Thank you for that. Been torn on the two for a while now and this really did help.
wpsaints I am glad it helped! Thanks for letting me know it did!
It's hard to see a review this great.
Say Heah, A while ago I bought two Himalayan Imports M-43 Khukuris, The reason I got a smaller one because I wanted to carry it on person because it is lighter. The first one came with a black Buffalo Horn Handle which I ordered. The smaller one came with a White Bone handle, It's a beauty so I kept it. But I like to match knives in atleast pairs, I didn't have a white handle knife. I got a e-mail on a new knife from Battle Horse so I pulled a trigger on it because it's similar to your knives and I like those blade shapes, I have a Blind Horse Bushcrafter similar blade shapes, But the Attitude is a 5"+ blade which is great for me and I had it thinned down and a High Scandi Grind. Now I have a knife to match my white handle Khukuri. Believe me this video helped more than you think, Thanx.
I just ordered a Genesis the other day I tend to like the broom stick type of handle looking forward to using in it. thanks for the video very. good information atb John
Turtle Bushcraft That is my leaning as well. They are both comfy in their own way but I think the Genesis handle, for me, is more comfortable. Thanks John
I don't think I asked this, but I was thinking it. I'm still up in the air, but I'm thinking a GNS in scandi. still up in the air though. Thank you for the comparison man!
Me as well bro
The Otter Outdoorsman The GNS in a scandi I think would be a game changer to this comparison ;)
I completely agree.
Thanks for the comparison between them, as I was looking at them and wondering just that.
Sidney Landrum It is a very common question lol. Thanks!
Funny Joe. I measured my Genesis. My scales are coming in at 1" at the butt end. It seems to look more like the "one foot..." version without the liners. I wonder if, over the course of production, they changed the shape slightly, or is there a difference from one finisher to the next. My guess is the latter. I think the "one foot..." version is thicker primarily due to the liners. Again, excellent review.
northof50now I honestly couldn't tell you. I would imagine that there would be slight variations between knives as they are hand made. I have had 2 (regular) Genesis's and the handle felt the same on both but I didn't measure the first one. Thanks again!
Feral Woodcraft great curls with the both blades. Nicely done video mate.
Donny B Thanks Donny.
I guess the best way for me to solve it is to get both . I do have the genesis now and enjoy using it, but there is nothing wrong with more options.
millster101 I like the way you think!! LOL!
While this was helpful it has become dated as I have the GNS in AEB-L stainless steel and a scandi grind. I'd love to see a comparison of these knives with the same grind and steel but we can't expect you guys to have everything lol. Great video thank you for what you do!
Good review, Joe, & thanks for your thoughts. I owned an original GNS & so wanted to love it, but sold it after several months of use. Overall good knife, the handle was very comfortable in the hand & it is a sharp looking piece. However, after using Moras for years, I found the GNS to not perform as well for the feathering. I believe it is because for me the blade angle is different, so required holding it differently. I've had several other Scandi edge blades & for me that is the best angle. I'd like to see a comparison between the Genesis & the Scandi GNS if possible. Had the Scandi GNS been around from the start, I would have grabbed one & I'm sure would still have it. Keep up the good work! ~Steve H.
I like this review a lot. It's only in the last several months that I've started to take notice of LT Wright Knives. There are others in his line of blades that I also have an interest in but the Genesis and the GNS are a good beginning for me. I have a passion for knives, both hunter and bushcraft, and LT Wright Knives are nothing less than beautiful in every way. They are icons.
Teachering I agree. Both of those knives will serve you well. You've chosen a great starting place. Thanks!
Excellent video my friend,im thinking of getting the LT.Geneis,i have very big hands triple X gloves and I really appreciate the details you did about the handles.Stay safe.
which knife would you prefer for processing game? Fantastic reviews-precise and articulate.
+MrRapper85 I differ from most (I think) and I use the very tip for processing most of the game unless I am cutting deep into the meat so honestly they both work just as well. That being said, I'd choose the Genesis only b/c I prefer that handle. And thank you very much, I greatly appreciate it!
Great comparison Joe
BlackChrome84 Thanks!
Would have loved to see this review with the same grinds. Good stuff nonetheless.
Great video, you just made my point and why my Benchmade Bushcrafter #162 is one of my fav's the saber grind is similar to the G.S.N. but as far as edge retention the S30V is a good one too.butvthen my Rod Garcia Skookum Bush Tool is a great slicer too and it's a scandi grind, I think it's all how thin the edge is too because my John Bradley World's Finest Camp Knife has a very thin full flat grind with a Zero Edge and talking about slicing, but as far as a stronger grind my fav is a saber vex grind, so my Benchmade Bushcrafter #162 is used alot but then so is my Blind Horse Bushcrafter grrrrrrrrrrrr I'm confused heh heh heh, should I go on heh heh heh.
+paulie 4x if u jump from a really high place head first u might not be as confused, there will be less huge comments and more air for all of us
I recently picked up a genesis. The shop I bought it from had the one foot in the wild edition and I really wanted that one but the handle was just too fat for me. I think it's the difference between no liners vs. liners. Really liked the sheath though.
+Garen Osborn Yep I concur. And the scales are rounded just a bit more to accommodate the the thickness of the liners as well. Ironically, I am constantly "complaining" about small handles due to my large hands, yet I didn't like the larger handle on the One Foot into the Wild edition because it was too fat. Weird, huh?
How are you liking that Genesis?
I like it a lot so far. Its made me not want to buy another knife for a while. Thats pretty unusual.
Great video! I have the Genesis and i love it. Great knife for every task out there.
Henrique Lundgren I agree, I love mine. Both are truly great blades. Thanks!
Wow. Both great looking knives. I would probably choose the Genesis. Thanks for sharing
Excellent comparison, thank you.
GNS Handle Style is called the: 'Border Patrol handle' (taken from Randall Knives). Examples include Terava Jarriikapuukko 110 and 140, Peltonen Sissipuukko M95 and some Randalls can be optioned with the handle. IMHO, it is the best handle in the world that gives the best compromise of heavy duty work (75%), then defence (25%). It is a very sure footed and comfortable handle IF done right and imo the GNS was NOT done right. The best working handles have no guards whatsoever, Lagom Bush Knife for example. Where MOSt manufactirers fail at Kepharts, Puukkos and most hard use knives is they make the handles too short. I would rather have a blade shorter than my handle. Blade 3.7". Handle 5". This is perfection for an EDC knife, IMO.
@@LubberKing "No lol" is not a supported arguement.
Would either of these knives make a good hunting knife? Field dressing and camp task being the main use. Thanks.
+Matthew Jeffres Both in my opinion. The saber grind of the GNS would have a longer last edge I think but the Genesis has a bit more belly so it has pluses too. LT does make a Genesis in Flat grind and that would be a superb field dressing knife I think. Thanks for watching!
Thanks! You have an awesome channel!
I know its about a year late, but I was wondering what that "sheet" or bag is that you're kneeling on?
I wont ask about the knives as I feel you have more than explained every a response to every question which might come into my mind about either knife. My own preference would be governed, after all other considerations, by what I feel would fit my hand best.
Great video and thanks for sharing it!
+MrTatts64 Not a problem bud! And ask away if you do happen to think of a question, I don't mind a bit. That bag/sheet is what I call my Firecraft Pad. czcams.com/video/u2IfJUyHtv8/video.html
I had hopes of getting it made and on the market but no one really wants to touch it. I "thought" is a good idea lol Thanks for the support man!
+Feral Woodcraft Many thanks for that mate. I cant imagine what sensible reason any company would have for not wanting to be involved with your Firecraft Pad. From the first video I saw you in (via Gaunlet TV), you were using it and I saw right away that you had a good thickness of material between yourself and the floor. Very important when it's cold and / or wet. Before you told me the name of it just now, I could see its value when knelt at the fire cooking or even just building the fire. Then most important of all, keeping your butt warm and dry whilst having a coffee ;) I suppose there are not enough bells and whistles attached to it. Seems that things "need" to have that something extra these days. Heaven knows why because since the days of plonking your butt on a patch of mammoth hide, simple has proven to be not only the best, but the least likely to fail as well! Perhaps it needs an "X" added to the name? Firecraft-X Pad, lol.
Ironically, I was watching your review of the Genesis, from nearly two years ago when your reply on this thread came through :)
Keep up the great work and the excellent videos.
Thanks, Andy.
+MrTatts64 Thank you very much Andy. I do have further ideas for it but I'd need someone to make prototyps etc etc. I keep telling myself, I'll just sit down and sew them one day (I actually can sew OK) but I just simply don't have time for it to be a regular thing. But you are likely right, not enough flash lol
Thanks again!
+Feral Woodcraft Wood make a good topic for a video series??!!?!?!
I know this video is a year old, but I wanted to comment on what you said about the grip on the GNS. I have read that LT designed the grip so that when carving near the base of the blade you choke up on the knife and hook you thumb over the front of the grip. This gets the back of your hand higher on the grip and into the palm swell making it more comfortable to do things like push cuts. Have you ever tried using it that way?
Have you since sharpened the micro bevel out of the Genesis? If so, have you noticed any real difference in performance? I ask because I was watching another youtube and knife maker use two knives that he made, both scandi but one had a micro and the other was zero ground and he noted that they performed as two very different knives. If I understand correctly, that makes perfect sense as by adding a micro bevel you are adding a small secondary that is more obtuse than the primary grind which is going to bite into the wood at a before a zero grind would.
As an aside, from my own testing I find that something such as a full flat or saber, IE knives with a secondary will make, at least for me, narrower curls when feather sticking whereas a scandi tends to make wide feathers. Also, scandis seem to hog off wood like a plane blade.
Anyway, just curious to hear your experiences if you have since zeroed the grind.
I've owned 2 Genesis scandi blades. 1 I removed it and 1 I didn't. Overall, I prefer the micro bevel. It, for me, has less over bite and is much more controllable. And I do agree with you. Saber, flat, and convex tell d make thinner curls much easier. That's not to say scandi can't do it but the more obtuse as you put it, the more easily they are controlled on the finer work. At least that's been my experience. Thanks!!
Thanks for sharing!
+Feral Woodcraft I am buying a new knife this weekend, should I get the Genesis DWX edition the GNS or a bark River bravo 1 ? For bushcraft.. I really like the bark River bravo 1 too but love the GNS and Genesis. I never owned either blade this will be my first. Please help me out
very good comparison between the two... i went for the genesis and removed the microbevel :)
I received my L.T. Wright Genesis yesterday. To say I'm disappointed is putting it mildly. When I removed it from it's paper wrap I noticed thin white marks on the handle that wouldn't wipe off. After closer inspection I realized they are cracks in the wood. There's a noticeable pit in the wood too. The white seems to be buffing compound embedded in those small cracks. The knife edge has more grind on one side making it uneven. The lanyard tube is unrefined on the inside making the edge sharp. The knife came sharp but not very sharp. Grinder marks on the edge also. As a bonus the sheath is rough as a brick on the inside.
For $235.00 I have a knife that has been amateurishly and indifferently produced. My first and last L.T. Wright knife.
+Billy Two Knives Forgot to add that that knife will be the only knife I will ever purchase fron L.T. Wright.
I really hate to hear that Billy and it honestly really surprises me. I have no idea how something like that could have slipped past their QC but I'm sure that LT would want to address it. May I suggest giving LT a call? LT's warrantee is one of the best in the business and I feel certain he'd work with you to make sure you are satisfied.
Thank you for your reply and advice. I used a .45 cal. bore brush on the sheath and it is now soft on the inside and as a whole the entire sheath more pliable after hand rubbing it with Neatsfoot oil. The knife is now sharp after elbow grease and water stones. I'll keep it but have no faith in that company. I can live with the handle imperfections. Take care.
Great job brother
Say Heah Joe, Yeah, We defenetly have similar taste. I had my Battle Horse modified, I had a Slight curve added to it by taking the high point on the pommel down and I had the droo point lowered giving it a slightly curved look . But by lowering the drop point it helps when I push cut with my thumb. I like a little more belly this helps me when I carve when doing some fine task's. I also got a high scandi this too allow's for a thinner apex gaining sone cutting adventage, I stropped a micro convex to help with adding strength too when I baton and stab and twistvmaking kindling, I don't like a sausage handle and the Attitude cines with a nice flaired pimmelband a hand swell, Just the way uh huh, uh huh I like it. I also got a white G-10 handle with blue liner's, It came out Beautiful, So I ordered a matching Mad Hatter and that came out as if a drubk boy scout made it, DISAPPOUNTED. !!! I guess there Moto is One Out Of Two Isn't Bad heh heh heh, Man then Atlanta 's kicking butt, nit a good day for me, I might have to take it easy with my cigar's or the new knives I was going to order grrrrrrrr. ,, .
Would you say that the Condor Woodlaw is a good budget alternative for someone who cant afford those knives?Thanks.
That is definitely a good option. A better option for just a few more dollars is the Deer Creek Forge Kephart. It's a tad more expensive then the condor but a far better blade. Thanks!
Thanks,i'll see if i can get it somewhere here in Canada.
"tad more"???? try $80 more!!
120$+ for 1095? Ehhh
I have one of each I have a PT limited Genesis full flat with the micro bevel and I also have the Gns scandi both a excellent tools I do prefer the handle on my Genesis a bit more and the full flat do incredible at feather stick's and carving the scandi GNS how ever is a thicker blade so I feel in an abuse situation if it came down to that I would be less concerned not that I haven't done a fair amount of batoning with my Genesis just prefer to use my hand Axe in concordenence with the Genesis out side of the knife I designed Genesis is my favorite so far either way Lt wright makes an incredible tool and look forward to owning more want a Genesis scandi in the as you wish model when tax return makes it in
Thank you for the video,. You did a great job on covering what each knife is capable of doing in handling wood, but you did not mention anything about sharpening the knives, or game processing, or camp chores. Unfortunately, I can only afford to buy one knife and to be quite honest with you, I can not even afford to do that at this time. I have several questions and if you have a chance to answer them, it would mean a great deal to me.
First of all:
Is it as hard to sharpen a Saber Grind in he field as people say? Is the Scandi grind really that much easier to hone up and sharpen in comparison?
Which grind works better for game processing? Field dressing game? Skinning Game? Processing Game?
Which grind works best at camp chores? Meal preparations such as cutting up potatoes, and vegetable? Slicing meats, fish, and cheese? Cutting cordage?
In addition to processing wood, it very important to be able to maintain an edge in the field and to cut and process the fish, game, and wild edibles in which we harvest or pack in.
I know I am asking a lot, but because you already have the experience with these two types of grinds, the question I have to ask is this?
IF YOU COULD ONLY HAVE ONE. WOULD YOU CHOOSE A SCANDI GRIND OR SABER GRIND?
Thank you for you time and you efforts.
Sincerely,
Donny Zarra
Pittsburgh, PA
@@LubberKing maybe he didn’t see it? Maybe he doesn’t know? Maybe he doesn’t care?
@@LubberKing thank you
I would have been interested in his reply. What did you end up getting, and why? I doubt I am sophisticated enough to notice any difference, as long as the knife is sharp and comfortable in the hand.
Great video. I just ordered the GNS solely from this video. I also subbed my new friend! Eat carbs says thank you as well....
Thanks! Let me know what you think of it when you get it! And it's good to meet you, any friend of Mark is a friend of mine.
I've heard so many good things about the Genesis. I want one. Lol. Always a want though
***** Yep, too many wants lol I completely understand! Thanks Travis!
Amazing review...Thank You!!!
I'd like to see Lt put one out that would be pathfinder class specs as far as Dave's requirements that would be a very sweet tool
That would be a sweet setup. I've heard a rumor that LT is making them in O1 as well now but I have not verified that.
Is the GNS LT Wrights version of a Ray Mears Bushcraft Knife?
Valid question. Don't hold me to this 100% but I believe the GNS was designed a collaboration between LT, Dave Canterbury, and SRI as the be all end all bushcraft/survival knife. It does look like it is influenced by the classic European Woodlore style but I have read nothing directly saying that it was. I wish I had a more specific answer for you but that is all I know; I hope it helps!
Great review, but since the Genesis and GNS both come in scandi grind, wouldn't it be a more fair and balanced comparison to have both knives in the same grind ? I understand you were showing the difference in the attributes of the blade grinds and your demonstration is excellent to that purpose, but it gives a false inpression of the two knife models the way it is presented. I know a little about L.T.Wright knives, I own a GNS scandi, but someone else might think the Genesis only came in a scandi grind and the GNS in a saber grind from watching this video . IMHO
I am pretty sure I covered that in there somewhere, maybe I didn't. It's been a long time since I filmed that. Anyway, those were the knives that I had at the time and folks were requesting it, so I answered with what I had and what they had been seeing on the channel.
Good job, great detail
doomedtroll Thank you so much, I appreciate it!
Subbed,
First time I see this push test on a piece of wood...
Guillaume Bergeron Thanks! That test is mainly to mimic the process of cutting the notch out for a bow drill set, cutting notches for primitive trapping, etc. Thanks for watching!
I am curious though, what would you say is your overall favorite knife grind for a general purpose knife? How about a bushcraft specific knife? I would like to get my hands on a full flat Genesis, or even a saber Genesis, not to mention the scandi GNS... I've got a bit of a knife "problem"... Thanks again!
That problem is a common condition many of us share lol.
As to your question. Hmmm. For straight up bushcraft specific I'd have to go scandi all the way but saber isn't far behind. For general purpose saber is best for me. But again, I think "the best grind" is by in large user preference. Thanks again!
Feral Woodcraft I can see that. I certainly agree about user preferences. I will say that I'm really starting to warm up to a saber grind. I despised it when I first got the SRI knife, but several sabers later it's now pretty high on my general purpose knife list. Keep up the great channel!
Don't forget you can get the gns in a scandi grind as well.
You are quite correct, they do make scandi versions as well. I probably should have mentioned that, huh? thanks!
Feral Woodcraft That's ok my brother's genesis is a special edition flat grind ;-)
excellent review
Would u b able to make a comparison btwn the two knives in the same grind.. let's say scandi grind.. What other deciding factors should I look at???
it's because that one has liners the thick 1 which makes it thicker
Buying the one foot in the wild edition this week. Just bought a Granfurs small forest axe so that set me back last week.abg advice on good ferro rods?
I realize this is four years old, curious what you went with? I’ve had good luck with the Chinese bay it’s rods on Amazon, but always like new info.
Thanks for the great vid
Damn bro.. outstanding review.
I think you just sold a few knives for them. lol
Thanks for the video
Eat Carbs ha ha thanks Mark, I really appreciate it. Have you tried your GNS yet?
Sadly no.. it's been raining cats and dogs lately. On nicer days.. I am working 12 hours
But don't get me wrong I love my gns in a sabre grind, like you said even someone like me can make some really nice feather sticks with it :-)
kantill Now I didn't mean that in a demeaning way! I was just saying I think it naturally curls better :-P
Feral Woodcraft just was messing with ya :-)
good answer.
Thanks! Good to see you here :)
Well done, thank you!
Damn I'm really torn on which one to get.
hollywoodhefner2 I totally understand that lol! If I had to pick only one I'd have a really hard time making a decision too. Thanks for watching!
Feral Woodcraft I ordered the Genesis. Between the history of the design and the broader blade, the Genesis won
You won't regret it. Enjoy!
looked at this video over and over and the saber will be better at push cuts to over the scandi if you knock of the shoulders on some stones brother just thin it above the cutting bevel :-)
+Modernbushcraft I actually did do that after this vid with the Worksharp Blade Grinder attachment. It worked so well. Though, I will say, no blade with a vex or a secondary will push cut as well as a scandi. A nice thin hollow ground blade can come close though. One of these days I am going to get a GNS again, I miss that blade. A buddy gave me an offer I couldn't refuse for the one shown here. Thanks!!
+Feral Woodcraft yes sir :-)
Say Heah Joe, The $64,000.00 question, GSN vs. Genesis ?. Oh, I got my GSN in 3V, I wanted to put some of my touches, But Ekaine told me their not taking any custom orders, She told me they do that once a year and they are working to finish last cutom orderes so I got a GSN in the Coyote Black G-10 and a 3V Saber.,,.
Paul'ie 4X did you get your custom gns?
great video im thinking of going with a genesis full flat grind, like a2 better stain resistance and toughness :-)
+Modernbushcraft I honestly don't think you'd go wrong with either. I do have to admit that I am itching to try the Genesis with a full flat. Granted it's size renders it in a completely different class but I have a coyote from LT with a full flat and I really enjoy it. Thanks!
+Feral Woodcraft jupp and a little easier to modify to each his own :-)
+Feral Woodcraft ever tried enzo trapper in o1
+Modernbushcraft or bark river? heard bark river are chippy and often break. enzo i had before and loved it great scandi grind on it :-)
No, I haven't used an Enzo but I have been very tempted to grab one on many occasions. I've used a similar blade, the Entrek Forester and I absolutely loved it.
I had a Bark River Aurora a couple years ago but gave it to a friend. Honestly, I miss it. It was a great blade and it could take a beating. I never had issue with chipping or had any sub par performance issues with it. Is there a particular model BR you're wanting information about?
Please tell me: what's the micarta color on your Genesis? Black or natural?
+Overlap TheWorld Yes? Lol its black and white micarta. The scalloping gives it a striped look. Thanks!!
Thanks FW! So it's a black micarta I guess... I'm about to buy a Next Gen and would like to get a beautiful knife too... :)
+Overlap TheWorld you know what, I got the videos confused. I thought you commented on the Next Gen video I just posted. This genesis is black and the gns is natural. My apologies!!
Thx mate! :)
Have you had any experience with the Sospes?
how would you sharpen the genesis? as a normal scandi or how??? plz reply
No problem bud. I prefer maintaining the micro bevel. I go over how I do that here on the LT Wright Jessmuk. It's a different blade but the exact same process.
czcams.com/video/KGJGMwxDzxI/video.html
so i sharpen like a normal scandi on my dmt stone and them finish with strop? (I plan on removng the micro beval any tips)?
+bushcraft fancy I apologize for the tardy response here, I've been offline for the holidays. Yep that will definitely do it. Careful with the strop though. If you do it too much, the slight give in the leather will allow for a slight convex to form. I know a lot of true zero ground scandi guys use either staged grits of super find sandpaper on a board or Japanese waterstones. I've used the former and it works well, but can be time consuming. The later I have not I am afraid. Please let me know how it turns out!
Ok,thanks for the reminder and I always keep a strop in my pack and have stropped my mora many times (and when i mean many I mean MANY times, I rarely have to sharpen my knives ) and have never even gotten close to a convex, maybe its because of the compound I use.
I'm in
Thanks for another very educational video.
You obviously are very schooled on knives. I may be picking your brain in the future.
GNS scandi vs Genesis scandi?
As usual I want the GNS with the genesis handle😒
For 100% people watching this video it would NOT make a difference which knife they used, nor would they know the difference in using either knife....
Have you used both of them to make statement like that? Both have totally different shape of the handles. Both must feel different when you hold them and when you use them. There's no question about that. Maybe you could say that it's not a big deal but for someone who's going to drop $180 on a tool, it matters.
dirtime yea I can say that...I wont say 100% I made a mistake.. but 99% guys watchn this video & even all the self proclaimed
“ bushcrafters “ “survivalist” who put out same video’s of them making “feathersticks” &
“batoning” a piece fucking wood would’nt know the difference between a $30.00 Schrade & a
$400.00 TOPS.....
I could put ironwood scales thrown on a couple bubinga liners on a Schrade SCHF 36 $30.00 blade & noone be the wiser...
“ Bushcraft “ “ Survivalist “ has become nothing more than infomercials to sell products, get subscribers.....
Barone B which one is better for heavy duty bushcraft
@@baroneroberto3400 Schrade and TOPS are both shity knives. I think it's just you that can't understand what good performance is. Pick up a good bush knife someday. Then you'll know.
great video, this helped me make my decision. I just subbed, Eatcarbs sent me over. Check out my channel as well...thanks
To bad the gns wasn’t scandi
those who have time for reviews don't really use them knives
+alin pop Thanks for the feedback alin. Have a look around; I think you'll find that I use them a decent amount.
benchmade bushcrafter