Gotta agree with sixstring . Arrogants and confidence go hand in hand in this setting. Segovia is known for protecting the art. Hes simply watching out for his baby.
Wow! Not only are you an excellent player, you must have nerves of steel to play that very difficult music to The Maestro Segovia in front of an audience. A mortal would have been a nervous wreck.
A Wonderful Performance. More than just "Very Good." Proves without a doubt that Michael was and is a world class guitarist of the highest order. Hats off to Segovia, for actually letting him play.
Michael is a great player.Such ravishing phrasing and tone. His genius and musicality moves me just as much if not more than Segovias and thats saying something! he, just like segovia, conveys something magical and extra special when he plays which is truly rare. I feel honoured to have watched and heard him. Bravo to yet another youtube guitar genius. But hey, there can never be too many for me.
I can’t believe what I’m reading on this time line There must be some great guitarist out there who are speaking Ill of the great Segovia Maybe I’m in the twilight zone Next thing I know someone is gonna say Bach wasn’t very good Then I’ll know...I am in the twilight zone!!....
Hay comentarios de que solo queria impresionar a Segovia y bueno al final Chapdelaine se sorprende de haberlo logrado ya que no cualquiera lograba tan titanica tarea...Segovia no era arrogante ni egocentrico, solo queria sacar lo mejor de sus alumnos como cualquier maestro, que el metodo no fuera el mas amable estoy de acuerdo ::: Two thumbs Up !!
Segovia was 93 years old here. If and when you are 93 years old you will probably find that when you don't like something you may be quite abrupt in letting others know. I do agree, he was playing very well.
Its Alexander Tansman's Preludio from Cavatina. The first one is Scherzino form the same Cavatina. This suites called Cavatina won the first prize in International Cpompetition for guitar in Shiena in 1951, and was dedicated to Andres Segovia.
People going to Segovia's master classes expect his feedback. It isn't like Segovia walked into someone's concert and criticized him. They are looking for critical feedback that will help them hone their skill. If all Segovia did was sit back and applaud, they wouldn't have anything for their effort but an autograph. Segovia is not being arrogant or rude. Rude is when you play for your end-of-term juries & the professors are chatting and checking their email on their phones.
so it was only in the last performance that segovia lost his rag. If i ever made it to 90 the last thing i would want to do would be listening to students playing a piece of music that i thought i could play better specially if i was not feeling particularly well and who knows whatever else was going on in his private life etc
The Maestro was deeply impressed. He remained modest about it but you can tell. Bravo Michael! Your version might actually be better. The thing is I still enjoy listening to the Maestro's old fashioned execution. Brings me back in time to another age.
This is the third movement"Scherzino " from Tansman's "Cavatina." (1951) Edition Schott: GA165. Edited by Andres Segovia. We have it in stock. Hal Leonard Cross Reference # 49010727.
If one serious Classical or Flamenco guitarist in a thousand thinks Manitas de Plata rates higher than Segovia, he or she must be mad. He's not even rated by flamenco players. He was fun, flashy, and entertaining. And Segovia can be excused a lot, after what he did for the guitar. Keep listening!
Say what!... I have to honestly say I could never ever personally say anything bad about any of the players that do this type of music for me at least that isn’t possible
maybe he does play in clubs. He has to play covers because the paying public find classical music boring. Its not for everyone and he has to put food on the table. No matter how good you are the world does not owe you a living, look at Eva cassisdy! Your comment sounds very mean. maybe your having a joke. One stroke of luck could change his life, look at Susan Boyle. People do not always get their fair dues, MC is one of them. If he was this good at football he d be doing Ok. Be nicer dude!
@z192012 first off stop acting like he's a clean player he's not second he was a jerk for no reason and third and most of all stop acting like guitar never existed before Segovia he was even know to talk badly about Tarrega and Villa Lobos. Not to mention Celedonio was 10 times the classical guitarist he was. After all your nonsense do not tag or confront me online ever again. The things you said to me esp name calling you'd never say to me in person good day sir
"@z192012 first off stop acting like he's a clean player he's not second he was a jerk for no reason and third and most of all stop acting like guitar never existed before Segovia he was even know to talk badly about Tarrega and Villa Lobos. Not to mention Celedonio was 10 times the classical guitarist he was. After all your nonsense do not tag or confront me online ever again. The things you said to me esp name calling you'd never say to me in person good day sir" #ytmostidioticcomments
Who did Segovia have masterclasses from? No one. he used his own judgement and so should MC. J Williams uses very different fingerings to Segovia and its stupid to say there s one way only to finger classical guitar pieces. The whole mystery of the instrument lies in the beguiling choices to be made. I feel sorry for those who want us all to be Segovia clones. he was a great, but its time to move on. Segovia like other prima donnas is known for the odd cruel moment. He was a man, not a saint.
San Diego to USC is hardly thousands of miles. You analogizing what you would do in Segovia's place is absurd. I am sure you are the pioneer of classical guitar and hold master classes yourself that Chapdelaine attends. Of course Chapdelaine went on to be a great guitarist. Good thing he had the foundation to build on. Wonder where he got that.
Il faut que celà soit bien clair. Ségovia était un grand guitariste et on lui doit d'avoir replacé la guitare classique au rang qu'elle méritait... Mais Ségovia était aussi un affreux conservateur et réactionnaire... sur cette vidéo c'est quasi un vieillard et on ne peut pas lui en vouloir d'être si désagréable en face d'un beau et talentueux jeune homme!!!
I made no playing. I have not heard you play, I wouldn't do that, and if you were awful I would commend you for your efforts.. What I called into question was your contribution to music and the guitar as directly compared to Segovia. If you think there is a comparison then I don't know what to tell you. Chapdelain had a foundation, where do you think he got it. In the 60s you were either directly or indirectly taught by Segovia. That is just a fact. Your use of the word tantrum is excessive.
Different ears different generations. The sentiment of a guitar feels different to different teachers. Chapdelaine is a great player but the feel of the sound and technique just was not up to Segovia's standard. Francisco Tárrega is a great composer and player but I am willing to bet that Chapdelaine could not replicate him he just has different mechanics. He is a very good player but he has not impacted the way we play guitar today.
I think in these master classes technique is not discussed. I might be on a different topic here, the topic I am on is subtleties in taste. Technique must be assumed before reaching Segovia. Music is more abstract then pictorial art. The subtleties of taste are harder to discern in music. We can hear easily if a piece we know is being rushed. In my case I was not an advanced player but I was pretty good. I had maybe a dozen decent pieces of classical guitar at my fingertips, all memorized that I could play nearly perfectly. One of them was Tarrega's "Lagrima". Since I didn't have a lot of material I would milk what I had for all it was worth. In retrospect I might say I played that song like a screaming drama queen. Know what I mean now? There I was, very good technically, but still embarrassing myself and I didn't even know it. My friends thought I was great, but my teacher said, "This is just so shmaltzy". And there are higher levels, finer aspects of taste that come into play, I mentioned a crude one so I could be understood.
I know what I am listening to. At the moment I am listening to an idiot. I am sorry, that is rude, but that is how you come across. Only an idiot would say "took his lunch money" in reference to anything musical. It is not a competition. Nobody is taking anyone's lunch money, nobody is winning anything.
Just learned that Michael passed away. RIP. These videos will live forever
What a sad news😢
Maestro started to enjoy his playing, kept asking him "another thing" Segovia must have seen his greatness. 👏
This is a golden film. Indeed Chapdelaine confirmed his status.
His postings are always at the top.
Despite the fact that he wasn't prepared mentally to perform the prelude he nailed it. The best version I've ever heard.
Michael is so skilled it mesmerizes you, incredible player! Tops, man!
Gotta agree with sixstring . Arrogants and confidence go hand in hand in this setting. Segovia is known for protecting the art. Hes simply watching out for his baby.
he is very very smart at the fingering
that make his prelude sounds so freaking colorful
probably the best rendition on youtube
Wow! Not only are you an excellent player, you must have nerves of steel to play that very difficult music to The Maestro Segovia in front of an audience. A mortal would have been a nervous wreck.
A Wonderful Performance. More than just "Very Good."
Proves without a doubt that Michael was and is a world class guitarist of the highest order. Hats off to Segovia, for actually letting him play.
Michael is a great player.Such ravishing phrasing and tone. His genius and musicality moves me just as much if not more than Segovias and thats saying something! he, just like segovia, conveys something magical and extra special when he plays which is truly rare. I feel honoured to have watched and heard him. Bravo to yet another youtube guitar genius. But hey, there can never be too many for me.
I can’t believe what I’m reading on this time line There must be some great guitarist out there who are speaking Ill of the great Segovia Maybe I’m in the twilight zone Next thing I know someone is gonna say Bach wasn’t very good Then I’ll know...I am in the twilight zone!!....
Beautiful Master Chapdelaine.
Hay comentarios de que solo queria impresionar a Segovia y bueno al final Chapdelaine se sorprende de haberlo logrado ya que no cualquiera lograba tan titanica tarea...Segovia no era arrogante ni egocentrico, solo queria sacar lo mejor de sus alumnos como cualquier maestro, que el metodo no fuera el mas amable estoy de acuerdo ::: Two thumbs Up !!
Well said. Thank you!
era bien culero el sego
My Dear Chapdelaine, in my opinion that night you played like a GOD and SEGOVIA was jealous!!!!
Marcelo Ramirez WRONG! WRONG!
Yes! Jealous!!!!!!
segovia said very good to his interpretation
Ma cosa mi tocca leggere....
***** y porque no?
Si un gran maestro algun dia me dijera "very good"... me moriria de dicha.
Segovia was 93 years old here. If and when you are 93 years old you will probably find that when you don't like something you may be quite abrupt in letting others know.
I do agree, he was playing very well.
Its Alexander Tansman's Preludio from Cavatina. The first one is Scherzino form the same Cavatina. This suites called Cavatina won the first prize in International Cpompetition for guitar in Shiena in 1951, and was dedicated to Andres Segovia.
to be great you have to be somewhat "arrogant"...that's just the way it is...it's really just confidence of the utmost degree..
You are Proud in any way, my Friend. Segovia was a Master, too...DO ALSO YOUR WAY!Congratulations! ajc 2018
RIP Mr. Chapdelaine
People going to Segovia's master classes expect his feedback. It isn't like Segovia walked into someone's concert and criticized him. They are looking for critical feedback that will help them hone their skill. If all Segovia did was sit back and applaud, they wouldn't have anything for their effort but an autograph. Segovia is not being arrogant or rude. Rude is when you play for your end-of-term juries & the professors are chatting and checking their email on their phones.
so it was only in the last performance that segovia lost his rag. If i ever made it to 90 the last thing i would want to do would be listening to students playing a piece of music that i thought i could play better specially if i was not feeling particularly well and who knows whatever else was going on in his private life etc
Chapdelaine was GREAT!!!
Just because Segovia was a legend doesn’t mean he was right. He was not.
What's funny about it is that all the players in the master class have far cleaner than Segovia better tone and tech. Something to think about
What's even more funny is that Segovia was 93 when this was filmed .
Bravo.
Shapdelaine is a Genius... Jaajjajaj .
@navazguitar It's arrogant to assume that Segovia's fingerings are definitive and there are no other options that are just as good, if not better.
Segovia's boy ("Boy, leesohn! If you are going to play my transcription, play my transcription!")
The Maestro was deeply impressed. He remained modest about it but you can tell. Bravo Michael! Your version might actually be better. The thing is I still enjoy listening to the Maestro's old fashioned execution. Brings me back in time to another age.
This is the third movement"Scherzino " from Tansman's "Cavatina." (1951) Edition Schott: GA165. Edited by Andres Segovia. We have it in stock. Hal Leonard Cross Reference # 49010727.
If one serious Classical or Flamenco guitarist in a thousand thinks Manitas de Plata rates higher than Segovia, he or she must be mad. He's not even rated by flamenco players.
He was fun, flashy, and entertaining.
And Segovia can be excused a lot, after what he did for the guitar.
Keep listening!
Sweet redemption or should we say even revenge?
Nope, he is humble af.
Being judged by Segovia is the closest thing to be judged by God himself.
What is the name of the pieces please?
1-Scherzo/Cavatina-Alexander Tansman
2-Preludio/Cavatina-Alexander Tansman
what was the first song he played in this video?
Segovian expects guitarists play the way he would and limits other players from being themselves .
@z1g2012
doubtful you would anyways I don't know why i'm wasting my time on someone who doesnt even play guitar good day
I have watched all of the master class videos I can find on youtube and just can't find any real example of what you are claiming.
What was the first piece Chapdelaine played?
scherzino from Tansman's Cavatina
I can admit that I have never liked Segovia's playing.
Say what!... I have to honestly say I could never ever personally say anything bad about any of the players that do this type of music for me at least that isn’t possible
This young man plays way better than Michael Chapdelaine does....that's a joke ...or is it?
They had another masterclass a day before that , and Segovia pretty much kicked him out.
Too much of a generation gap ....
@z1g2012 then you don't know what your listening to. Segovia was sloppy. Celedonio would have took his lunch money
maybe he does play in clubs. He has to play covers because the paying public find classical music boring. Its not for everyone and he has to put food on the table. No matter how good you are the world does not owe you a living, look at Eva cassisdy! Your comment sounds very mean. maybe your having a joke. One stroke of luck could change his life, look at Susan Boyle. People do not always get their fair dues, MC is one of them. If he was this good at football he d be doing Ok. Be nicer dude!
You need to get some things strait before you go making comments like that.
Meant "I made no assessment" of your playing.
@z192012 first off stop acting like he's a clean player he's not second he was a jerk for no reason and third and most of all stop acting like guitar never existed before Segovia he was even know to talk badly about Tarrega and Villa Lobos. Not to mention Celedonio was 10 times the classical guitarist he was. After all your nonsense do not tag or confront me online ever again. The things you said to me esp name calling you'd never say to me in person good day sir
"@z192012 first off stop acting like he's a clean player he's not second he was a jerk for no reason and third and most of all stop acting like guitar never existed before Segovia he was even know to talk badly about Tarrega and Villa Lobos. Not to mention Celedonio was 10 times the classical guitarist he was. After all your nonsense do not tag or confront me online ever again. The things you said to me esp name calling you'd never say to me in person good day sir" #ytmostidioticcomments
Who did Segovia have masterclasses from? No one. he used his own judgement and so should MC. J Williams uses very different fingerings to Segovia and its stupid to say there s one way only to finger classical guitar pieces. The whole mystery of the instrument lies in the beguiling choices to be made. I feel sorry for those who want us all to be Segovia clones. he was a great, but its time to move on. Segovia like other prima donnas is known for the odd cruel moment. He was a man, not a saint.
San Diego to USC is hardly thousands of miles. You analogizing what you would do in Segovia's place is absurd. I am sure you are the pioneer of classical guitar and hold master classes yourself that Chapdelaine attends. Of course Chapdelaine went on to be a great guitarist. Good thing he had the foundation to build on. Wonder where he got that.
Anywhere but here
He seems quite accomplished here before segovia even opens his mouth
Il faut que celà soit bien clair. Ségovia était un grand guitariste et on lui doit d'avoir replacé la guitare classique au rang qu'elle méritait... Mais Ségovia était aussi un affreux conservateur et réactionnaire... sur cette vidéo c'est quasi un vieillard et on ne peut pas lui en vouloir d'être si désagréable en face d'un beau et talentueux jeune homme!!!
Quase velho 93 ele já passou de ser.
I made no playing. I have not heard you play, I wouldn't do that, and if you were awful I would commend you for your efforts.. What I called into question was your contribution to music and the guitar as directly compared to Segovia. If you think there is a comparison then I don't know what to tell you. Chapdelain had a foundation, where do you think he got it. In the 60s you were either directly or indirectly taught by Segovia. That is just a fact. Your use of the word tantrum is excessive.
Different ears different generations. The sentiment of a guitar feels different to different teachers. Chapdelaine is a great player but the feel of the sound and technique just was not up to Segovia's standard. Francisco Tárrega is a great composer and player but I am willing to bet that Chapdelaine could not replicate him he just has different mechanics. He is a very good player but he has not impacted the way we play guitar today.
I think in these master classes technique is not discussed. I might be on a different topic here, the topic I am on is subtleties in taste. Technique must be assumed before reaching Segovia.
Music is more abstract then pictorial art. The subtleties of taste are harder to discern in music. We can hear easily if a piece we know is being rushed. In my case I was not an advanced player but I was pretty good. I had maybe a dozen decent pieces of classical guitar at my fingertips, all memorized that I could play nearly perfectly. One of them was Tarrega's "Lagrima". Since I didn't have a lot of material I would milk what I had for all it was worth. In retrospect I might say I played that song like a screaming drama queen. Know what I mean now? There I was, very good technically, but still embarrassing myself and I didn't even know it. My friends thought I was great, but my teacher said, "This is just so shmaltzy". And there are higher levels, finer aspects of taste that come into play, I mentioned a crude one so I could be understood.
Why is he looking at Sevoaibia? Just concentrate in your playing.
He was playing to him. That's concentration. Incredible I might add.
I know what I am listening to. At the moment I am listening to an idiot. I am sorry, that is rude, but that is how you come across. Only an idiot would say "took his lunch money" in reference to anything musical. It is not a competition. Nobody is taking anyone's lunch money, nobody is winning anything.