You know the track is underrated and underappreciated when a member says that it is sad that the song didn't do well on the charts. And I agree. Wind flower deserved so much more. I think the reason it is so special and healing is that it talks about experiencing heartache and getting over it. Getting over heartbreak is difficult but not impossible. And the song as well as the album captures this message so well. Like the song goes you “get better day by day”.
Charts aren’t everything though! Most likely it didn’t do great because of competition, but it actually had the second highest sales out of all the 4 seasons albums and I think every moomoo agrees the song is really good. What matters most is that they were able to share and communicate emotions with moomoos and whoever else listens to it, which is why so many people say it’s one of their favorite title tracks. As long as we continue to show love for the song it’s ok❤️
@@minie9956 Sadly, it did not do as well as other Mamamoo songs. But I am glad that it made you a moomoo. It is definitely one of my favourite tracks from them.
they're not considered an underrated group but why do i feel like they lowkey are....like i think they should be theee girl group, their level of fame should be bigger to match how fucking amazing they are. they're truly a breath of fresh air in the industry
Some groups can be popular but not their songs. Sometimes people only stan them because of their visuals and its sad. Some people nowadays just dont appreciate real music.
Honestly I believe they deserve even more hype than blackpink :/ No offense to blinks its just my opinion :) I use to LOVE BP but since they don’t have a lot of songs I got a bit bored :/
@@marianafm7382 a lot of gg deserves better actually. Such as red velvet, they are famous though but they never receive the hype like bp and twice. When theyre super talented. But i do believe that bp has talents but its sad that yg is hidding it by not giving them much songs :(
They’re not underrated, underappreciated is what I would say instead. They’re honestly incomparable to other ggs and we all know why MMM is always top tier.
WIND FLOWER SUPERIOR. I find moomoos like Wind Flower more than the general public. This song has still been on my playlist since it came out. It's such a perfect song to listen in the car, walking to work, or studying. I wish more people liked it and that we could have got them a win for it. Edit: Also check out my Mamamoo explanation videos on my channel! There's one for Wind Flower, love to know what people think of their own theories!
Can we just say how freakin perfect Jung Wheeins vocals are?, from her crystaline clarity, her low tones, her breathy falsettos, her power, her high notes. And it always looks like she does it without even trying 🤧💕🥰
Rough interpretation of what Hwasa said for intl MOOMOOS . ( Disclaimer : I am not a native Korean speaker ) - It has already been 6 years since MAMAMOO made their debut . In these 6 years , they've been able to develop themselves as singers , topped the charts and thankful for all the love they've received but there was one thing that they wanted to do so bad but didn't get the chance to do which was a comeback show . While preparing for her solo comeback , she wanted to do a comeback show . She thought a lot about what would it be like if they did a comeback show ? What type of stages would be nice ? She thought about it a lot and that's why she(they) prepared this song : Windflower . - Back when they (MAMAMOO) first heard this song , all of them loved it so much . They thought to themselves , " Will people love this song as much as we love it ?" But in this world , things don't always turn out the way we want them to . About a year later after this song came out , she remembers listening to this song again together with her members . Later that night , she went back to her house, into her laundry room and played this song again but all of a sudden tears started rolling down her eyes . She thought to herself , we loved this song so much but I guess people couldn't understand it well . She felt sad because people didn't love this song the same way they(MAMAMOO) did .
@@Mana1620 the timing was bad and it got zero tv promotion as well. They went straight to award season and most of the performances were Starry Night and Egotistic unfortunately
I’m new to Mamamoo, seeing all the comments about how this song didn’t get the hype it should have shocks me. This song is so absolutely beautiful, wholesome, empowering. Not to mention it slaps. Let’s continue to get better day by day everyone👍
so basically hwasa said mamamoo is a wind flower supremacist and they're sad because wf didnt get that much of recognition, i'm also a wf supremacist and now i'm sad. str3am wind flower alongside aya everyone lmao
Lets all remember that Music charts dont define a good song,Wind flower is truly one of the most beautiful songs with such a heartfelt meaning i cannot put into words how much this song makes me feel
I gonna say that Wind Flower is an absolute bop, and this performance took it to the next level that I teared up because of joy. As always, MAMAMOO vocal queens. 😊
@@ChrisMaxima why did you say moomoo slept on it?, we streamed and voted like a crazy at that time, hoping mamamoo to get at least 1 trophy, but at that time many big groups made a comeback too, it was really hard at that time and now you say 'moomoos slept on this song' wow
Yeah! But tbh she's not playing piano, there are some parts in the beginning where her left arm should be moving more (like towards the lower keys) and yeah...LOL
I knew Wind Flower was special the first time I heard it. I heard Starry Night and Decalcomanie first but Wind Flower is the reason I became a fan just recently. I feel humbled because of this and sad at the same time for the same reason as Mamamoo’s. Don’t feel sad about it not getting the hype! We love it and honestly the best songs don’t always top the charts!
윈드 플라워에 대한 개인적인 생각을 몇자 적어보자면, 우수하고 능력있는 천재 형제들 사이에서 내향적인 성격을 가진 노력형 천재의 느낌이 남. 형제들이 너무 뛰어나서 빛을 못보는 것 같아 너무 아쉬움. 마마무 노래 중에 처음 듣자마자 바로 내 취향인데? 했던 곡이 윈드플라워였고, 뮤비 또한 너무 취향이어서 이야, 이거 무조건 대박각이다 라고 생각했는데. 혜진이가 그런 생각을 하고 있을 줄은 몰랐음. 혜진이의 여린 감정과 깊은 생각에 다시 한번 놀랐고, 나에게도 아픈 손가락같은 곡이라서.. 아야 들으면서 윈드 플라워도 같이 들으러 가야겟다 ㅠㅠ
@@MC-ko2mx to focus more on dance. Haters use this to say that mamamoo can't dance and is a bad idol group. Though I love to listen to their beautiful voice
@@ksou972 Pretty much. Though based on what Moonbyul said, I thought they were *never* using head mics again, choreography or not. She was 100% hating on how distracting and uncomfortable they were LMAO They definitely can dance (look at Hip), but they are, first and foremost, superb vocalists. Like you, I love their vocal prowess. These queens sound better casually harmonising on a Happy Birthday song, than most idols do in the recording studio.
I just love Wind Flower... imagine walking through Hongkong at night or any city, while listening to this song. Such a mood. Then go to Mcd and buy an ice cream.
Wind Flower is make me fallin' love with Mamamoo, i know this is the one. They're so different from the start. They are not kpop, they are the genre. The genre is Mamamoo
안녕하세요~ 지나가던 팬입니다. 화사님 슬퍼마세요. 마마무 앨범 전부 다 합쳐서 개인적으로 윈플 앨범에 모든 수록곡을 베스트라 생각합니다. 노래 폴더에 이 앨범만 담아서 거의 4개월을 틀었던것 같아요. ㅋㅋㅋ 뭔가 여태 나온 맘무 노래들 중에 제 심금을 울렸던(?) 노래들이어서 지금도 자주 생각나서 계속 듣고 있는 베스트 앨범이에요. 앞으로도 이런 좋은 노래 많이 내주세요~
Honestly one of their best songs, and Blue ś is one of their best albums. When each song flows together so well u know its been well thought out. Blue ś does that, sadly the sales didnt reflect that. I feel their sadness. This version with opening jazz style is BRILLIANT !!💕💕
wind flower is the only title track from the four seasons project that I listen to on a daily basis, cause it just helps me get through the day and feel like not all is lost it's very sad to see it didn't get the recognition it deserved when it was released, but going through the comments I feel comfort in knowing many people feel the same way as I do about this masterpiece of a song
I love this song so much everything about it the tune the symphony the rythm the meaning the message and the persons singing it. I always wanted to go to a MAMAMOO concert but i can't afford to travel yet still i hope they come to our country and have a concert. Philippine Arena is waiting for Mamamoo and so am i.
Wind Flower along with the songs in Blues Album will always be my favorite Mamamoo's chill vibe song. I'm still in disbelief that some people slept to it :(((
In order to gain more popularity and recognition they deserve, they need to aggressively target an international audience. More than 80% of the comments are in English, which proves that your larger fan group locate outside S. Korea. Why is English subtitle not here, focusing on only a small group of fans in S. Korea. Please, write and sing in English once in a while. Test your limitation and expand your possibility!!!! You never know what the outcome would be.
its really hard for their company to promote mmm overseas since they dont really have those type of connections. if they did I think they would have done it back in 2017-2019 era becos tahts when mmm were the most active an popular. they have gone overseas to hold fanmeets in brazil, jakarta and various other places around asia i believe but in terms of international cities and international status its really hard for them to breakthrough. a good example is a group like blackpink - they do so well overseas (that some say its thanks to themselves not their company etc) esp in usa/NA is also becos their members can also speak english and communicate decently w their fans there. Their company has good relations with overseas media groups to help them promote the group and get their feet on the ground too. they actually aren't as popular in s korea becos the market is already so saturated and full of every type of idol g group... if u think about it there arent many s korean groups or singers who have made a good international debuts (BoA is probably the best example) for many reasons but the main thing is still language barriers and companies not having those connections to create overseas opportunities (BTS being another good example some of them are basically American /canadian korean). its costs a lot of money to invest into overseas activities as well. blackpink performed at coachella and has worked with various overseas artists which is huge for their popularity and their song style matches those audiences over there a little more however mmm has not really done a lot of collabs since they are already a group so its hard to break from that and juggling priorities while producing songs. hwa sa is a good example though - her solo album went to #1 (rel 2019) its staggeringly successful and has been popular overseas as well. she was acknowledged well by dua lipa and been called beyonce of korea etc which is insanely cool shes getting really good at creating her style of music and knowing what she wants. its also an industry thing - boy groups v girl groups have very diff standards and fanbases. so depending on their media company they will try to see how they can milk money off the fans as well...
윈드플라워 나오자마자 노몰드라마랑 같이 얼마나 들었는지 몰라요.. 노래방가면 그 두곡은 꼭 부르고.. 노래 잘 모르던 친구들도 듣고 너무 좋다고 하면서 자주 듣던 노래였어요!! 지금도 자주 듣고있구 ㅠㅠ 진짜 완전 띵곡인데 홍보를 알비덥이 제대로 안해서 그렇지 ㅎㅎ.. 제 인생 명곡중에 하나입니다 윈드플라워 !! 울 마마무 언니들 화이팅!!
@@Eievuy no i think the backtracks they mean is the vocal doubling. Mnet (sk shows in general) usually does this for the "perfect effect" so if the singer makes a mistake, it's "saved" by the backtrack. This is so unnecessary and annoying tbh because it's mamamoo :/
2년 동안 My 최애 곡은 wind flower 였어요 생각보다 모르시는 분들이 많더라구요 ㅠㅠ 이 노래가 진짜 명곡of명곡인데... 저는 Friday에도 subway에서 이 노래 들으면서 갔는데!!!! 무한 replay해도 안질리고 너무 좋은 노래에yo 잔잔하고 감정있고 무드있지만 바람에 날리는 꽃같은, 설명하기 어려운 정말 띵곡!! 뮤비 꼭 보세요 좋아하실 분들 정말 많을 듯합니다^^ mamamoo ❤
wind flower remains my ultimate fave from the 4 season 4 colors project. i agree with hwasa, it is sad that this song doesn’t get more recognition, but knowing fans really treasure this song makes it more special and i think it’s really beautiful
This underrated bop hits differently thinking about their journey & how far they’ve come, It’s such a shame Windflower never got the wins it deserves but I’m glad it’s appreciated today!. I’m soo proud of our hardworking Queens!. Stan Talent, Stan MAMAMOO!!
Omg! Usually I tend to overlook Solar amd her voice, but damn! She slayed this performance. Wowww! Her voice sounded so elegant here. Ugh! This is really her song.
윈드플라워 진짜 명곡이었는데... 이 엄청난 명곡이 빛을 보지 못한 이유는 솔직히 외적인 이유가 더 크다고 봅니다. 휘인이랑 화사 메이크업도 많이 파격적이었고, 코디도 좀... 가장 암흑기가 아니었나 싶은ㅠㅠ 안무도 댄서 넷이랑 함께했었는데 좀 산만한 구석이 있었고 노래는 정말 좋았지만 그 외적인 요소들이 받쳐주지 못해서 시너지를 일으키지 못했고 무대가 관심을 못받으니 자연스레 음원성적도 좋지 못했죠ㅠㅠ 그치만 매년 가을마다 찾아듣게 되는 곡이고 수록곡 중 솔라솔로인 hello도 너무너무 좋아하는 노래라서 소중한 앨범이니 마냥 빛을 못봤다고만 생각할 필요 없어요! wind flower 아픈손가락 아니고 자랑스럽고 뿌듯한 손가락입니다!
Wind Flower is my safe space.. It may not be as famous as their other title tracks, but this holds a special place in every moomoos heart. Those who truly understand will be the only ones that could appreciate. It's been 3 years since this gem was brought to the world and I couldn't thank Mamamoo enough for this.
i feel so bad, Wind Flower deserve hype. Hearing them saying that people didn't like this song as much as they do was devastating. I became a moomoo in the hip era, i wish i stanned them earlier and streamed this song like crazy :((( we love you MAMAMOO
진짜 맘무 활동 안할때도 항상 내 플레이리스트있는 노래가 윈플인데 혜진이가 울었다고 하니까 세상이 몰라주는것같아서 속상하다고 진짜 근데 너무나도 좋은곡이고 공감 많이 받을 수 있는 곡이 성적이 좋지 않아서 내가 더 속상하고 미안했어요... 괜히 더 열심히 홍보를 나라도 했으면 혜진이도 멤버들도 속상하지않았을텐데 눈물나게해서 미안해요...
@@dazzlingmoo5813 The one with Wheein: czcams.com/video/J_bZJIXkafc/video.html The Cover: czcams.com/video/ePT5cC5Unmw/video.html czcams.com/video/f-hNTaxlY0k/video.html
![[Comeback Stage] MAMAMOO - Wind Flower, 마마무 - Wind Flower Show Music core 20181201](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kmtRnUHC7JQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MV] 마마무(MAMAMOO) - Wind flower](/img/n.gif)
One of their best title tracks it’s sad that it didn’t get it’s deserved hype
one day they'll shine, trust me!
@@jeannekeithfelipe5797 aww love this 💚
ikr i can't believe it was this that underperformed out of the 4 seasons project songs
Probably my favorite of their title tracks
I agree
POPULAR OPINION: WIND FLOWER DESERVE MORE
yeeeeeaah
It sure does
Popular opinion wind flower best mamamoo song
imho it was their best comeback, but it was never appreciated enough
This is better than Labsek ghorls Juks
You know the track is underrated and underappreciated when a member says that it is sad that the song didn't do well on the charts. And I agree. Wind flower deserved so much more. I think the reason it is so special and healing is that it talks about experiencing heartache and getting over it. Getting over heartbreak is difficult but not impossible. And the song as well as the album captures this message so well. Like the song goes you “get better day by day”.
it makes me so sad because wind flower is my favorite title track of theirs and blue;s is my favorite album :(
Charts aren’t everything though! Most likely it didn’t do great because of competition, but it actually had the second highest sales out of all the 4 seasons albums and I think every moomoo agrees the song is really good. What matters most is that they were able to share and communicate emotions with moomoos and whoever else listens to it, which is why so many people say it’s one of their favorite title tracks. As long as we continue to show love for the song it’s ok❤️
whaaat it didn’t topped on charts? This song actually made me stan mamamoo
@@dede1842 Mine too. :')))
@@minie9956 Sadly, it did not do as well as other Mamamoo songs. But I am glad that it made you a moomoo. It is definitely one of my favourite tracks from them.
they're not considered an underrated group but why do i feel like they lowkey are....like i think they should be theee girl group, their level of fame should be bigger to match how fucking amazing they are. they're truly a breath of fresh air in the industry
Some groups can be popular but not their songs. Sometimes people only stan them because of their visuals and its sad. Some people nowadays just dont appreciate real music.
Honestly I believe they deserve even more hype than blackpink :/ No offense to blinks its just my opinion :) I use to LOVE BP but since they don’t have a lot of songs I got a bit bored :/
@@marianafm7382 a lot of gg deserves better actually. Such as red velvet, they are famous though but they never receive the hype like bp and twice. When theyre super talented. But i do believe that bp has talents but its sad that yg is hidding it by not giving them much songs :(
They’re not underrated, underappreciated is what I would say instead. They’re honestly incomparable to other ggs and we all know why MMM is always top tier.
This
WIND FLOWER SUPERIOR.
I find moomoos like Wind Flower more than the general public. This song has still been on my playlist since it came out. It's such a perfect song to listen in the car, walking to work, or studying. I wish more people liked it and that we could have got them a win for it.
Edit: Also check out my Mamamoo explanation videos on my channel! There's one for Wind Flower, love to know what people think of their own theories!
It's the song that got me into mamamoo
i know right!! so underrated
Wind flower has got that chill I want in my life
One of most beautiful songs ❤️
@@Lafilledlapluie aww me too! Plus no more drama
Such an underrated song. To think this didn’t even get one win.. 😣
This is one of my favourite songs 💚😍 i just don't understand how such a great song can be so underrated 🥺🥺😭💔💔💔💔💔
I know right. How could this song not get any wins? I like this song a lot!❤️❤️❤️
It's nice in its own way, but for me it's still not better than Piano Man or Ahh Oop, neither of which won awards either.
This is not underrated. Its actually one of the fav by many
Legit one of my favorite song ever
Can we just say how freakin perfect Jung Wheeins vocals are?, from her crystaline clarity, her low tones, her breathy falsettos, her power, her high notes. And it always looks like she does it without even trying 🤧💕🥰
Wheein vocals is always lit
Rough interpretation of what Hwasa said for intl MOOMOOS . ( Disclaimer : I am not a native Korean speaker )
- It has already been 6 years since MAMAMOO made their debut . In these 6 years , they've been able to develop themselves as singers , topped the charts and thankful for all the love they've received but there was one thing that they wanted to do so bad but didn't get the chance to do which was a comeback show . While preparing for her solo comeback , she wanted to do a comeback show . She thought a lot about what would it be like if they did a comeback show ? What type of stages would be nice ? She thought about it a lot and that's why she(they) prepared this song : Windflower .
- Back when they (MAMAMOO) first heard this song , all of them loved it so much . They thought to themselves , " Will people love this song as much as we love it ?" But in this world , things don't always turn out the way we want them to . About a year later after this song came out , she remembers listening to this song again together with her members . Later that night , she went back to her house, into her laundry room and played this song again but all of a sudden tears started rolling down her eyes . She thought to herself , we loved this song so much but I guess people couldn't understand it well . She felt sad because people didn't love this song the same way they(MAMAMOO) did .
Thankyou so much! I feel terrible that it didnt get enough attention... If only we as moomoos had done our best :(
I will never understand why wind flower stays irrelevant to general public. The vibe, the message, the sound is so beautiful and soft to chill out.
Its so good :) maybe people just didn't like a mellow or chill vibe song idk but moomoos really love it i love it so much than any song!
Windflower is my fav song 💔 and even my friends love it so much
@@Mana1620 the timing was bad and it got zero tv promotion as well. They went straight to award season and most of the performances were Starry Night and Egotistic unfortunately
This song will always have a SPECIAL PLACE in my HEART
Same!! 😭❤
Same here ❤️
same!!
Anytime Wind Flower comes on in my playlist I'm always taken back to a warm winter feeling
@@shortboypinoy same
The most underrated title song honestly. Wind Flower is a gem! And Yongsun playing the pianooooooo
I love how Moonbyul is always folloewd by a bunch of men like she's the leader of them all hahha
I’m new to Mamamoo, seeing all the comments about how this song didn’t get the hype it should have shocks me. This song is so absolutely beautiful, wholesome, empowering. Not to mention it slaps. Let’s continue to get better day by day everyone👍
I think we can all agree that Mamamoo Comeback Show: Monologue is just their excuse to hold any sort of mini concert.. Queens just love concerts
Ini hadiah pemenang Queendom mas, hehe. But I agree that they love concerts 🧡
I see no lie here lol.
Lmao indeed
@@gicchi gw rasa tujuannya mereka menangin Queendom yg paling utama ya buat gini sih.. kesenengan konser mereka wkwkwkwk
truth! they love their audience
*Wind flower the underrated queen*
so basically hwasa said mamamoo is a wind flower supremacist and they're sad because wf didnt get that much of recognition, i'm also a wf supremacist and now i'm sad. str3am wind flower alongside aya everyone lmao
Lets all remember that Music charts dont define a good song,Wind flower is truly one of the most beautiful songs with such a heartfelt meaning i cannot put into words how much this song makes me feel
I gonna say that Wind Flower is an absolute bop, and this performance took it to the next level that I teared up because of joy. As always, MAMAMOO vocal queens. 😊
one most beautiful filmed mvs too using hong kong
@@hossetttren253 I agree with you, it's one of the most beautiful MVs out there.
Windflower was slept on by literally everyone, but it's such a good song 😭
Except Moomoos
@@itzmayy Moomoos slept on it, though.
Wind flower is my top-tier also for woke moomoos LOL
I wish I was a moomoo at the time😭I would have streamed the heck out of it. I discovered them too late😢
@@ChrisMaxima why did you say moomoo slept on it?, we streamed and voted like a crazy at that time, hoping mamamoo to get at least 1 trophy, but at that time many big groups made a comeback too, it was really hard at that time and now you say 'moomoos slept on this song' wow
"get better day by day." slowly helped me climb out of depression
Same buddy same.
same here
Same
I was singing this in a psych unit not too long ago. Now I'm smiling better day by day!!! 🌬🌺
내 최애곡이 윈플인데 잘 알려지지 않아서 많이 아쉽죠ㅠㅠ 혲이 많이 속상하다니..ㅠㅠ 지금이라도 많이 알려지면 좋겠다..갓띵곡 윈플은 평생 못잊을꺼야ㅠㅠ
울엇다길래 너무 슬펐던 무무ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 좋아하는 노랜데... 뮤비 안무 전부다..
저도 최애곡ㅠㅜㅜㅜ
아니 윈드플라워 진짜 너무 좋은데 나왔을 때는 몰랐음. 좋은 걸 몰랐다는 게 아니라 존재를 몰랐었음 하 왜? 솔직히 홍보만 잘 돼도 엄청 떴을텐데 진짜...
HOLD UP. SOLAR? PLAYING PIANO? FOR WIND FLOWER? THIS IS A TRUE MASTERPIECE 🤩
Dang I come back to 69 likes an hour later-
Yeah! But tbh she's not playing piano, there are some parts in the beginning where her left arm should be moving more (like towards the lower keys) and yeah...LOL
@@heatherko6246 She had me fooled too lol. I wanted to believe that she was playing. 😂
@@rayking6042 ikr! Her facial expression was so good. Our solar queen
Yeah i thought it was real at first...sad
Windflower is the song that introduced me to mmm. This song will always have a special place in my heart.
Sameeee, the aesthetics of the song will forever be superior
@@she5786 ikr :)
Windflower and Better than i thought is my ult fav.
Same
Yeah me too
Same oml
I knew Wind Flower was special the first time I heard it. I heard Starry Night and Decalcomanie first but Wind Flower is the reason I became a fan just recently. I feel humbled because of this and sad at the same time for the same reason as Mamamoo’s. Don’t feel sad about it not getting the hype! We love it and honestly the best songs don’t always top the charts!
윈드 플라워에 대한 개인적인 생각을 몇자 적어보자면, 우수하고 능력있는 천재 형제들 사이에서 내향적인 성격을 가진 노력형 천재의 느낌이 남. 형제들이 너무 뛰어나서 빛을 못보는 것 같아 너무 아쉬움. 마마무 노래 중에 처음 듣자마자 바로 내 취향인데? 했던 곡이 윈드플라워였고, 뮤비 또한 너무 취향이어서 이야, 이거 무조건 대박각이다 라고 생각했는데. 혜진이가 그런 생각을 하고 있을 줄은 몰랐음. 혜진이의 여린 감정과 깊은 생각에 다시 한번 놀랐고, 나에게도 아픈 손가락같은 곡이라서.. 아야 들으면서 윈드 플라워도 같이 들으러 가야겟다 ㅠㅠ
I missed seeing mamamoo holding hands mics thats the best part of there performance please don't give up on hand's mic
I don't think they will ever give up hand mics.
They hated head mics so much during the Hip era, I was surprised they used them again for Aya stages.
@@MC-ko2mx to focus more on dance. Haters use this to say that mamamoo can't dance and is a bad idol group. Though I love to listen to their beautiful voice
@@ksou972 Pretty much.
Though based on what Moonbyul said, I thought they were *never* using head mics again, choreography or not.
She was 100% hating on how distracting and uncomfortable they were LMAO
They definitely can dance (look at Hip), but they are, first and foremost, superb vocalists.
Like you, I love their vocal prowess.
These queens sound better casually harmonising on a Happy Birthday song, than most idols do in the recording studio.
I don't think they'll give up their hand mics, byul said they were really expensive.
윈드 플라워 ,,, 진짜 너무 좋은데 ,, 개비답이 홍보를 너무 잘해서 ^^
음주가무에서 언니들이 윈플 얘기하는데 진짜 마음 찢어지더라 ,, 마마무 홍보좀 잘 해줘요 제발 ,,
개인적으로 마마무 앨범 중 제일 애정하는게 윈드플라워가 있던 블루앨범... 제일 성적이 안나온게 아이러니ㅠㅠ
회사가 홍보를 못한거죠 그 시기엔 특히나 일을 못했었고..ㅋㅋ
암튼 지금도 날이 쌀쌀해지면 밤거리를 걸으며 꼭 듣는 노래에요
많은 사람들이 많이많이 알아줬으면 하는 곡..
Justice for Wind Flower 😭
I know I liked this cool, chill song but it wasn’t popular 💀
@@kevinscheeseballhair9720 Bcoz of bad timing & not enough promos
I just love Wind Flower... imagine walking through Hongkong at night or any city, while listening to this song. Such a mood. Then go to Mcd and buy an ice cream.
Yes you're right, this song really reminds me a lonely night lol
@@bebetpunyichannel7521 yes. Walking and evaluate ur life
Mood.
So beautiful and introspective.
Perfect song to listen to late at night while watching the Hong Kong landscape through the window of a tram.
I love your comment!
This is my favorite song. I promise someday do exactly what you said.
@@selenesalazar6711 pls tell me the experience later on
Wind Flower is make me fallin' love with Mamamoo, i know this is the one. They're so different from the start. They are not kpop, they are the genre. The genre is Mamamoo
안녕하세요~ 지나가던 팬입니다. 화사님 슬퍼마세요. 마마무 앨범 전부 다 합쳐서 개인적으로 윈플 앨범에 모든 수록곡을 베스트라 생각합니다. 노래 폴더에 이 앨범만 담아서 거의 4개월을 틀었던것 같아요. ㅋㅋㅋ 뭔가 여태 나온 맘무 노래들 중에 제 심금을 울렸던(?) 노래들이어서 지금도 자주 생각나서 계속 듣고 있는 베스트 앨범이에요. 앞으로도 이런 좋은 노래 많이 내주세요~
막 이런거 어?! 윈드 플라워 이런거 어?! 내가 좋아할 줄 알았어?! 환장할 줄 알았냐고!!
어......맘무언니들이 막 그렇게 간드러지는 목소리로 윈드플라워 부르면 환장한다고.........
BLESS RBW FOR BRINGING THIS MASTERPIECE BACK!!!!!
Honestly one of their best songs, and Blue ś is one of their best albums. When each song flows together so well u know its been well thought out. Blue ś does that, sadly the sales didnt reflect that. I feel their sadness. This version with opening jazz style is BRILLIANT !!💕💕
I’m so shocked I didn’t know Solar play the piano
She’s so talented
ikr. Check this out.
czcams.com/video/ePT5cC5Unmw/video.html
@@loveisallyouneed274 I found more.. even better czcams.com/video/J_bZJIXkafc/video.html
WHEEIN AND HWASA ALSO PLAY PAINO
블루스 앨범 진짜 다 명곡들이었음.. 너나해하고 고고베베가 신나는 댄스곡이어서 묻힌 경향이 없잖아 있지만 진짜 맘무의 가창력을 제대로 뽑아낸 앨범은 블루스였던 것 같음.. 특히 인트로는... 진짜 이걸 못 들은 사람들이 안타까울 지경...
진짜 블루스 앨범은 4시즌 4컬러 아니고 그냥 냈으면 더 떡상했을 그런 앨범 ㅠㅠ...
수록곡 다 띵곡
진짜요...... 모닝이랑 생각보다 괜찮아도 진짜 갓띵곡이었는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@user-bx9fi3vi1r 노몰드라마도 마마무 특유의 데칼코마니에서 느껴지는 파워풀한 보컬이 넘나 매력적인 곡이라구요 ㅠ
@@hughbyun 하 노몰드라마 안무도 제 취저였는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
진짜 저도 블루스 젤 좋아하는 앨범ㅠㅜㅜ
TALENTED, BRILLIANT, INCREDIBLE, AMAZING, SHOW STOPPING, SPECTACULAR, NEVER THE SAME, TOTALLY UNIQUE, COMPLETELY NOT EVER BEEN DONE BEFORE
only 200k views ?? its ok ill make it 1m
Yes queen
YOU DOING GODS WORK
얼마나 아쉬웠으면 노래가 생각보다 성적이 잘 안나와서 아쉬웠다고 컴백쇼에서 털어놓았을까....
무무여러분 언니들위해서 스밍도 열심히 돌리고 그럽시다 알비덥분들은 울언냐들 더 밀어주세요ㅜㅜ
2:08 Wind Flower
피아노 천재와 음색천재 4명이 조화를 이루는 역주행 해야하는 믿듣맘무의 띵곡 윈플🍃
Finally Solar playing piano again and OMG their voice are so beautiful
지짜 윈드플라워 너무 좋고 블루스앨범은 가을만되면 꺼내 듣는다,,,,,♡ 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
wind flower is the only title track from the four seasons project that I listen to on a daily basis, cause it just helps me get through the day and feel like not all is lost
it's very sad to see it didn't get the recognition it deserved when it was released, but going through the comments I feel comfort in knowing many people feel the same way as I do about this masterpiece of a song
Omg I didn’t know Solar plays the piano. What a talented woman
And she can also do pole dance!
Yea she’s so talented and beautiful ✨❤️
Me to
Yo you guys should check out solar and wheein's cover of "no cool, I'm sorry" where solar played the piano
czcams.com/video/ePT5cC5Unmw/video.html
czcams.com/video/f-hNTaxlY0k/video.html
진찌 원드플라워는...역대급 명곡임...ㅠㅜㅠㅜㅠㅜ 다시 역주행했으면 좋겠다....윈플 온세상 사람들이 다 알아줬으면..ㅠㅜㅠㅜ
My fav thing about all MAMAMOO’s performances is SOLAR singing to all the parts
I love this song so much everything about it the tune the symphony the rythm the meaning the message and the persons singing it. I always wanted to go to a MAMAMOO concert but i can't afford to travel yet still i hope they come to our country and have a concert. Philippine Arena is waiting for Mamamoo and so am i.
Mamamoo simply are TALENTED
YES THEY ARE 🤩
I was surprised to learn that Solar plays the piano. Stan talented Queens!
마마무와 무무의 아픈 손가락 숨듣명 갓띵곡 윈플🍃
나의 여름 혜진아 무무들은 절대 윈플 못잊어,,ㅠ
내마음속 블루스 최고였어👍
@김유진 윈플 정말 최고다
저 이거 나오고 매일 들었었는데ㅠㅠ항상 안타까웠던 최고의 곡!!ㅠㅠ
윈플 이렇게 가을겨울 넘어갈 때 무조건 듣는 노래라 멤버들 그리고 무무한테 아픈 손가락이라는거 상상도 못했는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 윈플 최고야 언니들 사랑해❤
Are you kidding me? This is one of your best songs. “Get better day by day.”
Are you a fucking hater?
This song is beautiful definitely my favourite followed by gogobebe and Mr piano man
@@shia6757 Mr.Piano Man is so good as well. Underrated.
AMO WIND FLOWER, mas realmente quase não escuto, obrigado por este presente MAMAMOO ♥
si
eu amoooo
SOLAR SO FREAKING HOT GORGEOUS AND SO TALENTED. STAN THIS REAL QUEEN
Wind Flower along with the songs in Blues Album will always be my favorite Mamamoo's chill vibe song. I'm still in disbelief that some people slept to it :(((
Anyways amazing performance as always ❤️
In order to gain more popularity and recognition they deserve, they need to aggressively target an international audience. More than 80% of the comments are in English, which proves that your larger fan group locate outside S. Korea. Why is English subtitle not here, focusing on only a small group of fans in S. Korea. Please, write and sing in English once in a while. Test your limitation and expand your possibility!!!!
You never know what the outcome would be.
email this to their agency, their agency is RBW (Rainbow Bridge World)
Omygod you are right!
its really hard for their company to promote mmm overseas since they dont really have those type of connections. if they did I think they would have done it back in 2017-2019 era becos tahts when mmm were the most active an popular. they have gone overseas to hold fanmeets in brazil, jakarta and various other places around asia i believe but in terms of international cities and international status its really hard for them to breakthrough. a good example is a group like blackpink - they do so well overseas (that some say its thanks to themselves not their company etc) esp in usa/NA is also becos their members can also speak english and communicate decently w their fans there. Their company has good relations with overseas media groups to help them promote the group and get their feet on the ground too. they actually aren't as popular in s korea becos the market is already so saturated and full of every type of idol g group... if u think about it there arent many s korean groups or singers who have made a good international debuts (BoA is probably the best example) for many reasons but the main thing is still language barriers and companies not having those connections to create overseas opportunities (BTS being another good example some of them are basically American /canadian korean). its costs a lot of money to invest into overseas activities as well. blackpink performed at coachella and has worked with various overseas artists which is huge for their popularity and their song style matches those audiences over there a little more however mmm has not really done a lot of collabs since they are already a group so its hard to break from that and juggling priorities while producing songs. hwa sa is a good example though - her solo album went to #1 (rel 2019) its staggeringly successful and has been popular overseas as well. she was acknowledged well by dua lipa and been called beyonce of korea etc which is insanely cool shes getting really good at creating her style of music and knowing what she wants. its also an industry thing - boy groups v girl groups have very diff standards and fanbases. so depending on their media company they will try to see how they can milk money off the fans as well...
윈드플라워 나오자마자 노몰드라마랑 같이 얼마나 들었는지 몰라요.. 노래방가면 그 두곡은 꼭 부르고.. 노래 잘 모르던 친구들도 듣고 너무 좋다고 하면서 자주 듣던 노래였어요!! 지금도 자주 듣고있구 ㅠㅠ 진짜 완전 띵곡인데 홍보를 알비덥이 제대로 안해서 그렇지 ㅎㅎ.. 제 인생 명곡중에 하나입니다 윈드플라워 !! 울 마마무 언니들 화이팅!!
Please make the backtracks quieter :( we want to hear their vocals and the backtracks are just too loud :(
Whats the back track?
@@Eievuy the music with no lyrics and voice
@@Eievuy no i think the backtracks they mean is the vocal doubling. Mnet (sk shows in general) usually does this for the "perfect effect" so if the singer makes a mistake, it's "saved" by the backtrack. This is so unnecessary and annoying tbh because it's mamamoo :/
윈드플라워 가장 좋아하는 곡중하나인데 이렇게 듣게되서 너무 좋아요!! 이번기회에 많은 사람들이 들었으면 좋겠어요!
Wind flower is the best song to me.
Moomoo from Hong Kong.
윈플 진짜 좋은데... 말로 설명할 길이 없네 하 혜지니 그 때 그 심정 공감 백배라 더 슬프다ㅜㅜㅜㅜ윈플 모르는 분 없게 해주세요 흐규규
Wind Flower is my healing song. The ending is cute 😄
I want another ‘wheein accidentally sings solars part’ 😅
I thought that was for Starry Night.
@@3rationalfans yeah it was, I just meant I wanted another one of those moments with any comeback not just starry night
2년 동안 My 최애 곡은 wind flower 였어요
생각보다 모르시는 분들이 많더라구요 ㅠㅠ 이 노래가 진짜 명곡of명곡인데... 저는 Friday에도 subway에서 이 노래 들으면서 갔는데!!!! 무한 replay해도 안질리고 너무 좋은 노래에yo 잔잔하고 감정있고 무드있지만 바람에 날리는 꽃같은, 설명하기 어려운 정말 띵곡!! 뮤비 꼭 보세요 좋아하실 분들 정말 많을 듯합니다^^ mamamoo ❤
wind flower remains my ultimate fave from the 4 season 4 colors project. i agree with hwasa, it is sad that this song doesn’t get more recognition, but knowing fans really treasure this song makes it more special and i think it’s really beautiful
Hwasa has worked so hard these times and she need to have a rest 😭MAMAMOO are queens forever!!!!Love this powerful team so much!!!
Madina Maulenova yea! Vote for them for mama2020✨✨✨
아ㅏ.....심장아파.....범인은.......
마마무
Wheein's voice is like silk or honey. dang girl!
windflower is an UNDERRATED MASTERPIECE, it's such a good song but so many people sleep on it :(((
I'm so proud of you girls.
i never knew i need yongsun playing wind flower in piano in my life.
"let's go"
-Hwasa
Then she smiled realizing there's no audience 😂
정말 사랑하는 곡 wind flower를 이렇게 멋진 무대로 볼 수 있게해주셔서 넘 감사해요 ㅜㅜ 멋진 무대 보여준 맘무 넘 사랑해♥
아아아아아아앙 Wind Flower 진짜 너무 좋아요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
티이틀 곡에서 재일 좋아했던 것 같애요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
1위 못했지만 저 맘속에 1위예요 !!!!!!
Of course I like all songs of Mamamoo. But I listen to "Wind flower" every day.
What a masterpiece!
Solar's outfit, nail color, hairstyle, swag, voice.....her existence kills me
This underrated bop hits differently thinking about their journey & how far they’ve come, It’s such a shame Windflower never got the wins it deserves but I’m glad it’s appreciated today!. I’m soo proud of our hardworking Queens!. Stan Talent, Stan MAMAMOO!!
I just realized how I missed them performing WindFlower. My most favorite title track. ❤
Windflower is the best song ever. It is very sad that it didn’t get it’s deserved hype. This song is underrated.
Omg! Usually I tend to overlook Solar amd her voice, but damn! She slayed this performance. Wowww! Her voice sounded so elegant here. Ugh! This is really her song.
That’s one of the most beautiful song I’ve ever heard. Not in , you know, Kpop way, but generally
3:45 moonbyul be like "i'm the boss"
윈드플라워 진짜 명곡이었는데... 이 엄청난 명곡이 빛을 보지 못한 이유는 솔직히 외적인 이유가 더 크다고 봅니다. 휘인이랑 화사 메이크업도 많이 파격적이었고, 코디도 좀... 가장 암흑기가 아니었나 싶은ㅠㅠ 안무도 댄서 넷이랑 함께했었는데 좀 산만한 구석이 있었고 노래는 정말 좋았지만 그 외적인 요소들이 받쳐주지 못해서 시너지를 일으키지 못했고 무대가 관심을 못받으니 자연스레 음원성적도 좋지 못했죠ㅠㅠ 그치만 매년 가을마다 찾아듣게 되는 곡이고 수록곡 중 솔라솔로인 hello도 너무너무 좋아하는 노래라서 소중한 앨범이니 마냥 빛을 못봤다고만 생각할 필요 없어요! wind flower 아픈손가락 아니고 자랑스럽고 뿌듯한 손가락입니다!
그때 마마무언니들 엄청 힘들었는데ㅠㅠ 알비덥이 컴백한다고 알리지도 않고 진짜 날리였죠ㅠㅠ 팬중에서도 컴백했는지 모르는 무무들도 많았고요ㅠㅠ
@Ha geromenick 그래도 평소에는 컨셉에 딱 어울리는 착장 몇개씩은 있었는데 윈플때는...ㅎㅎ 할많하않
@@user-js3bx4rb6z 맞아요... 홍보도 잘 안됐었어요. 당시 음주가마무에서도 멤버들 많이 아쉬워하길래 마음 아팠는데 오늘 컴백쇼보면서 저렇게까지 힘들어한줄은 몰랐어서 또 슬펐네요ㅠ
전 윈플착장 개좋앗는데
안무동선이 발카를 고려안한 안무라 만족이 안되엇던고같아요
@@user-ni8nf1nu8u 전 이 말에 더 동의되네요!!
Wind Flower is my safe space.. It may not be as famous as their other title tracks, but this holds a special place in every moomoos heart. Those who truly understand will be the only ones that could appreciate. It's been 3 years since this gem was brought to the world and I couldn't thank Mamamoo enough for this.
i feel so bad, Wind Flower deserve hype. Hearing them saying that people didn't like this song as much as they do was devastating. I became a moomoo in the hip era, i wish i stanned them earlier and streamed this song like crazy :((( we love you MAMAMOO
눈물 많은 우리 마마무 언니들....ㅠㅠ 나도 속상해ㅠㅠ 아 진짜 마마무 노래들 다 흥행되고 이래야 되는데ㅠㅠㅠ
다음에는 더 폭주하고 흥행될거야!!
항상 응원하고 레전드 노래들 더더욱 난리 될거고 그랬음 좋겠어!!
마마무 항상 응원하고 고마워~~!!!!!
the ending is everything
진짜 맘무 활동 안할때도 항상 내 플레이리스트있는 노래가 윈플인데 혜진이가 울었다고 하니까 세상이 몰라주는것같아서 속상하다고 진짜 근데 너무나도 좋은곡이고 공감 많이 받을 수 있는 곡이 성적이 좋지 않아서 내가 더 속상하고 미안했어요... 괜히 더 열심히 홍보를 나라도 했으면 혜진이도 멤버들도 속상하지않았을텐데 눈물나게해서 미안해요...
진짜ㅠㅡㅠ 이때 우리 언니들 컴백했는데 아무도 몰라해서 직접 홍보하러 다녔는데ㅜ 진짜ㅜ 노래 진짜 좋아여 언니들
My gosh solar looks hot with that piano....🔥🔥🔥
Get better day by day🥺❤️
다시모르는척하고 앨범내주세요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이띵곡을 왜세상사람들이 몰라!!!!!!!
들어주세요!!!!!!!!!!
I CANT BELIEVE WE FINALLY GOT A WINDFLOWER STAGE. MY HEART IS SO FULL.
ughh i was smiling and being all emotional during the whole song!! wind flower will always be amazing to me ❤︎❤︎
I need more performances with Solar playing the piano.
If you haven't watch it yet, Solar covered Love is You with piano too. And her duet with Wheein, No Cool I'm Sorry.
@@dazzlingmoo5813 The one with Wheein: czcams.com/video/J_bZJIXkafc/video.html
The Cover: czcams.com/video/ePT5cC5Unmw/video.html
czcams.com/video/f-hNTaxlY0k/video.html
@@andreaflorenza7906 yup those two :)
This song is just everything and more I can’t believe it didn’t get the recognition it deserved
I need all these performance audio on Spotify 😭❤️
내 최애곡 ㅠㅠ 뮤비랑 같이 보고 들으면 여운이 두배....
윈드플라워ㅠㅠ 갓띵곡인데ㅜㅜ 너무 좋아했는데ㅜㅜ 이렇게 다시 많이 알려지기를ㅠㅠ
mann windflower was the song that got me into mamamoo too
Yong on the piano is really making me fall deeper in love with her ~~~ I wished it was longer...