Medievil's Many Remakes (and one sequel)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 29. 06. 2024
  • My Twitter: / b_mask_
    My Patreon: / bmask
    My Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/b_mask
    Discussing Medievil, the remakes, the sequel, and its future.
    Timestamps
    00:00 The Original
    03:51 The Remake
    07:15 The Reimagining
    12:45 The Sequel
    17:15 The Future (?)
    23:22 End card + thanks
  • Hry

Komentáře • 428

  • @GreysToons
    @GreysToons Před rokem +271

    0:26 "I don't go back to old media because I want to experience what's possible now. I go back to see what was possible then, to connect with how people expressed themselves in the context of their time." Well said! 🍻

    • @lance_with_both_nuts
      @lance_with_both_nuts Před rokem +8

      Right? You hardly hear someone read the illiad or look at a DaVinci and say "meh, it was alright back in the day but this style just doesn't hold up today"

  • @lichlame
    @lichlame Před rokem +156

    The original PsOne game has some of the most iconic sound effects of any game. They really seared deep into my mind as a child.

  • @GirtheAlienGoldfish
    @GirtheAlienGoldfish Před rokem +47

    MediEvil holds a special place in my heart. As a kid, I would watch my mom play it. She really enjoyed the game. She also liked Skullmonkeys and Oddworld.
    But MediEvil was my favorite. I would watch her play it for hours. I really liked Dan as a character because even though he was a skeleton, he was really friendly-looking and silly.
    To this day, I still really love MediEvil. I hope that if we do get a sequel that it will capture the spirit of the first game. I just really miss that sense of whimsy and silliness that games had back then.

    • @EmilXOM
      @EmilXOM Před rokem +11

      Your mum sounds based

    • @TheRavenir
      @TheRavenir Před rokem +3

      I've had a similar experience in that both of my parents would help me with the game as a kid. My parents are boomers and don't play any video games, so they still think it's "the best video game of all time" and pretty much anything reminds them of Medievil, such as the sound of a rusty gate opening. It's cool to at least have one video game we all know and love (well, technically two, since they also helped me with Medievil 2), since they basically know nothing about all the other video games I've also played. Still, Medievil and Medievil 2 are among my favorite games of all time, especially the original one.

  • @HyMyNameIsMatt
    @HyMyNameIsMatt Před rokem +73

    Finally proof that someone else cares about the turmoil Dan has been subjected to.

    • @EmilXOM
      @EmilXOM Před rokem +3

      We stand with Dan

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem +3

      @@EmilXOM Sir Dan is peak PlayStation protagonist

  • @Adrian-hj7ih
    @Adrian-hj7ih Před rokem +41

    We REALLY need better game preservation. As someone that never had any next-gen console(due to financial issues, especially in my country) all I had to play was the old stuff, because of that I learned to see those games with the right eye and appreciate the achievements and importance of them, and most important, fall in love with the media. And I hate how companies treat old games as inferior or outdated, as you said in the video, even if those games have problems, even if they are outdated, even if other games have improved upon, they still have value, but sadly... the frequency that are remakes being released isn't helping.

    • @marcinkrz3140
      @marcinkrz3140 Před rokem +8

      I have an opposite problem. Since a lot of older console producers (especially Nintendo) weren't that keen on realising consoles in my country it's paradoxically harder to obtain an older console (like n64) then a new one. Remakes and Remasters are often the only way I can experience older games from those systems.

    • @Adrian-hj7ih
      @Adrian-hj7ih Před rokem +5

      @@marcinkrz3140 Interesting, I don't have any problems with remasters but I think it should be the standard to include the original game in the remake, like in Metroid Zero Mission. But we often see stuff similar to the GTA Trilogy Remaster where they removed ALL the original versions from all platforms(maybe it was just steam I don't know), so unless you emulate, play on the original hardware or whatever, you're screwed.

    • @tylerfreal6472
      @tylerfreal6472 Před 3 měsíci +1

      then do it ...

  • @DragmaKerp
    @DragmaKerp Před rokem +26

    To me Medievil is very difficult to sequalize, but still, feels so short and tiny. I feel like they made a great big world and lore… that you don’t see or experience ever.

  • @PepsiMan666
    @PepsiMan666 Před rokem +19

    Zarok in Japanese is voiced by Norio Wakamoto AKA Cell from DBZ, M. Bison from Street Fighter, Chiyo's dad from Azumanga Daioh and a whole bunch of other roles.

  • @pawcanada
    @pawcanada Před rokem +19

    As a Darkstalkers fan, you're point about holding potential sequels to ransom unless a rerelease/remaster of a predecessor does well really hits the nail on the head. Even a good remaster that captures and supersedes on the original is likely to only appeal to fans of it and maybe a few more, but taking a chance with a new entry with its own spin has a stronger chance to open it up to more.

  • @bizarduno
    @bizarduno Před rokem +8

    Still an idealistic, I see. The problem is that companies have become VERY risk-adverse in recent years. I’d much rather see a sequel or even a new IP, yet here we are with remakes/remasters of TLoU *sigh*.

  • @NoCloutJoey
    @NoCloutJoey Před rokem +17

    MediEvil 1 & it’s remake are some of the best art pieces of gaming ever created. All nostalgia and flaws aside, there’s just something so special about the world. I feel like you can hop into this game blind and still feel the same amount of magic that this title delivers. Thank you for this video 🔥

  • @Saintbow
    @Saintbow Před rokem +6

    Sir Daniel Fortesque, always a legend and holds a place in all 90's kids hearts.

  • @EnbyNomad
    @EnbyNomad Před rokem +11

    When I was in highschool I didn't have cable, didn't have a console, but I did have my neighbors wifi and an offbrand tablet. Equippped with both, I would watch Tekking101's let's play of Medievil the second I got home from school.
    Never played the games but love them as if I did.

  • @superstarm304
    @superstarm304 Před rokem +31

    THANK YOU! This is one of the few games that has had multiple remakes and it's such a interesting topic of discussion! Also I just love Sir Dan as a character

  • @harrigan4162
    @harrigan4162 Před rokem +17

    I wish that when they remade games like this, they included the old version of the game with it, since I feel like it wouldn’t be that hard to include an emulates version

  • @adamdonnelly6470
    @adamdonnelly6470 Před rokem +6

    MediEvil is so underrated. Sometimes it’s more interesting to try and appreciate a flawed game than gushing over a 90+ Metacritic darling. Sir Dan’s clumsiness and the game’s cartoon horror would make for a great parody of the Soulsborne genre if they ever decided to bring it back.

  • @johndavidtibbetts7320
    @johndavidtibbetts7320 Před rokem +33

    fun fact for me, Medievil Resurrection was my first exposure to the game. When I was a kid and the PSP had just come out, I got it for christmas. So seeing all this stuff from the original and Resurrection being called the odd duck is hilarious to me

    • @Moorb0y52
      @Moorb0y52 Před rokem +3

      Same, it's the only version I've played and I loved it.

    • @mrego886
      @mrego886 Před rokem +3

      Same

  • @traewilson5127
    @traewilson5127 Před rokem +115

    The thing about MediEvil is, this is one series where you could absolutely have it go out into SPACE, and have it be completely believable. It's always awesome to see ancient medieval sorcery butt heads with raygun Gothic sci-fi technology. Assassin's Creed this sucker; every installment a new distinct time period and a distinct take on Gallowmere.
    But I honestly wonder how the series can continue without Paul Darrow as Zarok. The personal feud between Sir Dan and Zarok feels so important to the world. The idea of these two bumbling buffoons butting heads throughout history is a hilarious one. As much as I liked the villain of the second game, that personal animosity that made Zarok and Dan's relationship so great wasn't there. He's just another baddie Dan has to slice up. But how could you possibly recast Zarok? Paul Darrow so perfectly played him with what little time he had, even in MediEvil Resurrection, it'd almost feel wrong to have someone else play the role. You could get somebody to do an impression, but unless you're really lucky it wouldn't be the same, OR just change actors completely, likely leading to such fundamental differences the audience might wonder why they just didn't make a new character instead. It's not an easy situation for a followup.
    Just, no matter what you do, maybe drop the ethnic stereotypes, eh? Doesn't do anybody a lick of good, that.

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +42

      Funnily enough that level in 2 where you deal with aliens was heading towards this idea- early plans for a potential 3 did have Dan going to space on a Buck Rodgers style adventure. However the plans were /really/ early and never amounted to anything, which is part of why I didn't mention them in the video, but I'd absolutely be down for that if it were to ever happen.
      Agreed with your thoughts about Zarok as well, who they also were planning to bring back for Medievil 2 to work with Dan against Palethorn for pretty much the same reasons you outlined. I think he'd always feature in some form if they were ever to continue, but as I was getting at above, it's a big if.

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem +3

      @@BMask The second game was originally gonna have a new protagonist with Dan's descendant but it was scrapped

  • @PieLordCollin
    @PieLordCollin Před rokem +183

    Babe wake up new B-Mask

  • @dk1shotte884
    @dk1shotte884 Před rokem +5

    I played Medievil Resurrection as a Kid and i loved it. For me it was the italian dubbing that sold it to me. It was bad , but bad that was good and funny. I played the ps1 version even when i was littler but never finished, it scared me lol

  • @zthoop64
    @zthoop64 Před rokem +8

    20:05 "its all very well holding a new game hostage, on the condition you buy a new game or two." In the case of some companies, this statement is very literal. Capcom is probably the best example with their infamous "capcom test" they pull, re-releasing an old game on a new console and seeing if people will buy X-amount of it to convince the higher ups a new one is worth the money. Its pretty much the reason so many capcom fighting games havent seen a new sequel and only get character cameos.

  • @ShenDoodles
    @ShenDoodles Před rokem +8

    As much as I respect your opinion and loved the video, I've gotta say: I'd kill for a remake of 2. There's a lot more that can be fixed by a remake there and it would give the devs the necessary practice and insight to make a Medievil 3 that would encapsulate everything great about the franchise. There's so much potential for the future of this franchise and I can only hope Sony feel the same way.

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem +1

      I just wanted them to pull a FF7 remake for MediEvil II by giving the story and characters a complete overhaul

  • @coolpizzacook
    @coolpizzacook Před rokem +19

    Seeing Oddworld pop up did make me interested in seeing your thoughts about that series. As one that I hold relatively close to my heart, it always interests me to seeing other people's thoughts on it.

  • @erikbihari3625
    @erikbihari3625 Před rokem +27

    Fact is that spyro had a machine Gun wielding goon replaced in the remake with paintballs! So I agree wholeheartedly.

    • @Coolpiss123
      @Coolpiss123 Před rokem +4

      It feels so goofy and eye-rolling that there cannot be an enemy with a machine gun in a “kids game” when execs know well and good children as young as 6 are playing Fortnite. That is not a slight to anyone who enjoys that title, it’s more lamenting the fact that something I loved as a kid was needlessly changed.

    • @blibdo3216
      @blibdo3216 Před rokem +7

      @@Coolpiss123 At least Pinstripe kept his.

  • @ATalkingSock
    @ATalkingSock Před rokem +24

    Sad that remakes are still so prevalent over sequels. Glad at least to keep hearing your well-founded assessments and contributions to the discourse.
    Playstation in particular has PLENTY of dormant IPs that could totally get away with new entries sellable on their own merits. War of the Monsters, Ape Escape, Vib Ribbon, Puppeteer, the list goes on.

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem +5

      Sony is currently interested in remaking games to tie in with their respective new films/tv shows from PlayStation Productions

    • @michaelriverside1139
      @michaelriverside1139 Před rokem +1

      I'm still bummed that PS4's Medievil and PS5's Demon's Souls exist as separate Remakes when they could've been merged into one gnarly, Tim Burton-Henry Selick take on the Souls Genre that incorporated more platforming and humor over Miyazaki's grotesque athmosphere & drip-fed lore that hasn't changed since the original launch of Demon's Souls...
      Puppeteer could be an awesome experiment with VR by placing the player in a dynamic "Theatre" akin to Paper Mario The Thousand Year Door where the audience was as much of a hindrance as a help, while stuff like searchlights dropped from the stage itself...
      I really enjoy stuff like Horizon and God of War, as they excel at what they're trying to do, but Playstation doesn't feel the same as it did when Gravity Rush 2 launched between Uncharted 4 & Horizon Zero Dawn or when The Last of Us was followed by Puppeteer, which is rather sad.

  • @kaelisprime9087
    @kaelisprime9087 Před rokem +14

    An absolutely amazing video. The end bit about remakes is something I've agreed with a lot for so long. They're cool and all, but I feel like it would've been much better to get a sequel. Its much like Banjo-Kazooie fans wanting a remake when the originals and the Xbox versions exist. If we got a remake, we would just get the same game again with a few changes.
    Also can't wait for Medievil 3 to be announced months after this video

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +7

      Thank you! I tell ya, if there really is an announcement, my paranoia's going to go through the ROOF

    • @michaelriverside1139
      @michaelriverside1139 Před rokem

      My good fella, if Medievil 2 doesn't even seem to be considered for a Remake by current Playstation, I'd place such announcement right next to Wild Arms 6 and Sly Cooper 5 as:
      Eccstatic if they happen, wouldn't hold my breath for them.

  • @UberShyGuy
    @UberShyGuy Před rokem +6

    so tl;dw: make *medievil: it's about bloody time*

  • @stevena488
    @stevena488 Před rokem +5

    See, MediEvil felt (to me) to be a 2000AD comic strip adaptation because it's so insane. Like Pat Mills (Back when he was slightly LESS crazy) and Kevin O'Neill went "Let's make a video game about a complete tosser of an upper class git who can't survive without the player". I know people who said it felt very Tim Burton, but it's so utterly 2000ad's mad cap sense of humour and insanity. To the point where I wish that more stuff was inspired BY 2000AD so that we could get more mad stuff like this. Granted, the folks at Rebellion and the Prog are brilliant people who are all fun and a bit mental (I know a few of them and they're just as mad as the comics they make)
    Also, Paul Darrow is a national treasure. An absolutely amazing guy who I met at a convention in Glasgow. Glad to hear that they didn't mess around with his takes.
    EDIT: - Gah... I hate this. RIP Kevin O'Neill.

  • @M01st_Nu6g3t
    @M01st_Nu6g3t Před rokem +5

    I think the one thing Medievil's did that was good in my opinion is just make it more accessible, not everyone has a ps1/2 and if they did, they may not have been able to get their hands on a game that isn't made anymore. The remake just let it have a new platform to be enjoyed on.

  • @kendalflongbeard2935
    @kendalflongbeard2935 Před rokem +4

    I can tell you without a doubt, Medievil was my favorite PS1 game I never owned. I had a friend who owned it and I'd constantly loan him newer games that I'd pick up to play through this. I just recently snagged the ps4 remake to play on my PS5. Here's hoping for the best. The ability to unlock the first game seems a no brainer.

  • @tero581
    @tero581 Před rokem +3

    Just so frustrated they didn't remake the sequel at the same time as the original. It'll never happen now.

  • @majinpikmin
    @majinpikmin Před rokem +4

    As someone who grew up as a wee lad playing medievil, I loved the video. Absolutely would love a proper sequel that we’ll probably never get. I do at least have to say that at least we got what we got and it is amazing that it even happened to begin with. Hopefully sir Dan has more adventures in the future.

  • @talonj8116
    @talonj8116 Před rokem +6

    Absolutely amazing B-Mask. You always come through with excellent videos. This one has great composition and you keep a honed edge the entire time. This is the kind of content we need more of these days.
    Keep it funny little British man

  • @TheBlueGhoul
    @TheBlueGhoul Před rokem +4

    I have not thought about the wiggles in quite a long time. You have opened up many repressed memories.

  • @robosmith8513
    @robosmith8513 Před rokem +3

    I knew you were a vampire because you and you're work is timeless

  • @majorbuginator549
    @majorbuginator549 Před rokem +5

    I'm not gonna lie, the MediEvil remake was probably the most exciting thing I was looking forward to in 2019. As it stands, a reimagining of MediEvil II would be great in about... 10 years given the track record of the series. Pumpkin Jack has been really close spiritually. I think MediEvil needs a shot in the arm, but they really need people that know what they're doing. It's a series you could probably do anything with, but you need to understand the tone of it all and know why you're throwing in what you do. MediEvil II and the Fate's Arrow comic, to me, show failure on that part. Probably more so Fate's Arrow.

  • @mistergremm735
    @mistergremm735 Před rokem +57

    Great to finally see skeletons representation in this channel,
    feels home indeed...

  • @WarriorVirtue
    @WarriorVirtue Před rokem +4

    I think we need a digital museum or something to preserve old media like video games.

  • @InaudibleSlinky
    @InaudibleSlinky Před rokem +5

    Oh bless your soul. Just replayed the PS4 remake so will love to watch this.

  • @AugustBurnsRed181
    @AugustBurnsRed181 Před rokem +5

    Medievil is one of my favorite games of all time and the remake is so good only cemented it more I’ve played the remake multiple times collecting all the chalices multiple times.

  • @shawnc292
    @shawnc292 Před rokem +2

    I think you are the one creator who I get EXCITED for new videos. They are like christmas!

  • @NickAstalos
    @NickAstalos Před rokem +6

    wow i just played Medievil for the first time yesterday (ps4 remake on ps5) and I was so shocked at how much i loved it. i thought i'd like it, but wow, i fell in love. going for the platinum now. super surprised and excited to see this video from such a talented creator as yourself

  • @stupidfathobbit4262
    @stupidfathobbit4262 Před rokem +5

    I recently took the kids out for Halloween with friends and family and I had the remakes Soundtrack setting the mood playing on my phone while we walked. I had at least 10 people ask me they liked the spooky music and what I was listening too. I told them “Let me tell you about the true life story of Sir Dan!?!”

  • @BrennySpain
    @BrennySpain Před rokem +5

    Apparently, with medievil resurrection on psp, they were planning to make a new game in the series but development time got cut short, so the team decided to remake the original ps1 game instead.

  • @BrennySpain
    @BrennySpain Před rokem +2

    I have never been more generally entertained by a video. Honestly, it's so funny to refer to the MediEvil series as clunky, when that's the gameplay mechanics in a nutshell. No other series could match how heavy Sir Daniel Fosteque feels to play as lol

  • @BAD361
    @BAD361 Před rokem +5

    amazingly written review, great points, time well spent watching this, thanks!

  • @lizardguyNA
    @lizardguyNA Před rokem +3

    The thing about remakes is that they're safe. Companies think they can invest on the old fan's love of the series while potentially bringing in new ones with something that has proven viable. I get your gripes and do share them. At the same time though, I didn't have a PS1 and didn't get to experience Medievil until the PS4 remake, so the whole thing was a new experience to me.
    It's a conundrum with no right or wrong answers, we can only hope it gets easier with time.

  • @EmilXOM
    @EmilXOM Před rokem +2

    Man, this was honestly the EXACT game I wanted to hear you talk about, after watching the Crash and Spyro videos. I would've personally loved a thorough dissection of things like art direction and all that, but you explained why you weren't going to do that, and that's perfectly fine. This was still really nice to see! I just love art analyses above all else, cos I'm a knob lmao

  • @spaceace9103
    @spaceace9103 Před rokem +26

    I would love to see you tackle the Oddworld games. I hear theres a lot of mixed feelings on the newer ones.

  • @NotOrdinaryInGames
    @NotOrdinaryInGames Před rokem +4

    Medievil is one of the FEW perfect HD remaeks.

  • @thetickcartoon1453
    @thetickcartoon1453 Před rokem +4

    If I'm being honest: a B-Mask video going over the Medi-Evil titles was not the place I was expecting to find a Wiggles reference... but it *was* a good place to do so.

  • @Hero1922
    @Hero1922 Před rokem +9

    thanks for this video i really liked medievil, 2, and the 2019 remake and it's cool to hear someone talk about the series. Dan's story really resonated with me (redemption for not really being the hero history knows him as and then in the sequel becoming a hero again against a new foe)
    I would be curious to see a medievil 3 though i have no idea who or what they would bring into it, and I liked Winston also (i'm american, so the cockney isn't AS grating for me)
    anyway keep up the awesome work :)

    • @bamban_garcia5562
      @bamban_garcia5562 Před rokem

      Medievil The Prequel Comic its basically Medievil 3 created by the original team

  • @GuileWinQuote
    @GuileWinQuote Před 4 měsíci +1

    Absolutely fantastic video. Subbed!!

  • @Sundji
    @Sundji Před rokem +2

    I had been trying to remember the name of this game from my childhood for so long and this pops up in my suggestions. I was about 3 or 4 when I first played this game and I loved it! Medievil 2, Tekken, Odd world, mega man and Soul Reaver are the first games I can remember playing

  • @kyledodson2992
    @kyledodson2992 Před rokem

    Great opening statement on remakes (and I love remakes) but yeah man. This was fantastic. New sub

  • @madgizmo2212
    @madgizmo2212 Před rokem +2

    *walking around through youtube and sees Medievil. Sudden record scratch before going to watch video on childhood*

  • @godonomas
    @godonomas Před rokem +1

    Man spitting when it comes to remakes.
    Never really thought about the subject in that way

  • @GrandMasterEdge777
    @GrandMasterEdge777 Před rokem +3

    That all being said, I still want a MediEvil 2 remake with the same quality as the first one.

    • @bamban_garcia5562
      @bamban_garcia5562 Před rokem +4

      Could happen since Other Ocean Emeryville is still an independent contract studio that could take the job to remake it

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem

      I wanted them to pull a FF7 remake for MediEvil II by giving the story and characters a complete overhaul

  • @Vanisonic
    @Vanisonic Před rokem

    Sold big time on finally giving this a shot. Thanks B-Mask

  • @bellboy7809
    @bellboy7809 Před rokem +1

    I see that Paul Finch cover B!
    (Legit, thank you for sharing those stories, they are cool)

  • @crashtefano
    @crashtefano Před 7 měsíci +1

    So, as a fan of the series, I'd say:
    - the original MediEvil is the classic everyone deserves to play at least once (so glad it was included in the remake; I know there are other remakes with the original game being fully available in the more modern version but I still wish this was done more often);
    - MediEvil 2 is my personal favorite (with the first one still being a masterpiece in my opinion, but I slightly prefer the sequel);
    - MediEvil 2019 might be the remake anyone could pick up if they thought the original was too outdated and they wanted a more modern experience (or if they lack the original hardware the game was made for and they couldn't just emulate it);
    - Resurrection is that version we could play if we ever wanted a significantly different twist on the first game that puts our muscle memory to the test (I don't think it comes even close to the original, but after playing it for some time I have learnt to show it some respect for what it tried to do as a launch title for PSP).

  • @inkredibill6352
    @inkredibill6352 Před rokem +1

    Man. Thank you for being straightforward and fair. Awesome video.

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +1

      Thank you! Just hope I can maintain that.

  • @UltimateMovieMaster
    @UltimateMovieMaster Před 10 měsíci +2

    When it comes to whether or not a game needs to be remade, as opposed to a remaster, is all down to a case-by-case basis. Some games have become so outdated in technology and/or game design that they benefit from a ground up reworking, while others just need a bit of a polishing to truly let their quality shine. I will say emulation does complicate this, since with features like save states that help to lessen the impact of dated game design, it brings up if a remaster is even needed.
    As for using remakes, remasters, etc. as a testing round or attempt at reintroduction to general audiences, it's something that should be used sparingly. Along with things like stealing the hype of a new entry and use or resources you mentioned, there's also the fact that those kinds of things succeed and fail for all sorts of reasons and aren't reliable indicators for future success. Another aspect of using remakes/remasters as testers is that the longer you go without a new game that can grab attention the further into obscurity you'll fall into, especially if you only try after multiple years long absences. Basically, creators and publishers should just take the risk because the longer they try and play it safe the greater the chance the safety net of nostalgia and name recognition will go away.

  • @jankygrunt
    @jankygrunt Před rokem +4

    Caddy got me to play the remake from at few years ago when he made one of his Halloween specials, the ps1-2 eras were really experimental and kinda messy with the games being made, but unique, I really liked that

  • @twoshirts1842
    @twoshirts1842 Před rokem +2

    I just recently played Medievil and loved it. I had a demo disk with it on it.

  • @thetabo8648
    @thetabo8648 Před měsícem +2

    7:23
    I thought I was the only person who still remembers the gauls!

  • @paulaner37
    @paulaner37 Před rokem

    Great video mr man!

  • @TheGodlessCosmonaut
    @TheGodlessCosmonaut Před rokem +2

    As someone who's been an avid fan of the series since the first came out, this video hits pretty hard. Seeing the first game reiterated on two seperate occasions instead of any attempt at a continuation two decades after the sequel is tiring and frustrating. I have massive nostalgia for the original as many others do, but seeing the same beats regurgitated (to varying degrees of success) instead of evolved and explored in a modern context has worn thin and soured my expectations for the series. Even a remake of 2 would've had more to offer given its story structure failings and sometimes limited design scope, aspects that could've easily been fine-tuned by a modern, hungry studio.
    In any case, fantastic work as always and thanks for giving a series that's so dear to my heart a spotlight!

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem

      MediEvil II deserves the FF7 remake treatment

  • @ninjaws
    @ninjaws Před rokem

    Thanks for mentioning the Klonoa remake(s), it was on my mind during the entire video until you brought it up. D'you think you'd ever make a video on Klonoa (in any manner, not necessarily the remake)? It's one of my favourite series so I'd love to hear you talk more about it.

  • @monotonallizard
    @monotonallizard Před rokem +2

    You got me to replay the Spy trilogy, you won't get me to replay MediEvil (Who am I kidding), but great video! You summed up my thoughts on remakes and originals better than in my own head, especially with this game in particular.

  • @MrVideoScape
    @MrVideoScape Před rokem +2

    I remember playing the original as a kid and was scared. But this made the memories flow back.

  • @LinkiePup
    @LinkiePup Před rokem +2

    I do think Remakes have a place in making a game more accessible to a new audience, who wouldn’t have ever gone out of their way to get a PS1, the game, the saving card, controller(s), and the analog to HDMI cables.
    Its an investment to play old games.
    So I think remakes do have a place in game preservation.

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +4

      Not only was this addressed in the first few sentences of the video, this ignores that those who choose to withhold the original versions from being available on new platforms is what makes it an inaccessible investment to begin with.
      They have a place, but only because it's a self fulfilling prophecy.

  • @GlivGluv
    @GlivGluv Před rokem +4

    Good video lad

  • @DoctorInk20
    @DoctorInk20 Před rokem +2

    Like Sir Dan's old shame, the shadow of _Sly 4_ hangs over you. Happy Halloween. 😈

  • @kingoftropes922
    @kingoftropes922 Před rokem +22

    It might just be because I'm more than a little burned out on revisiting old franchises after this years long refocusing from both consumers and executives on digging on the old mines of nostalgia, but I find the discussion towards the end about remakes and reimaginings over just making a sequel to hit on something very poignant.
    Personally at this point in my life I'm almost always going to to more excited for a wholly new entry or even a new franchise than I will remake or remaster or reimagining. The past is the past for a reason and while there are a few things I'd like to see brought into the modern for any number of reasons, perseveration and properly fulfilling their potential of course being chief among them, latching onto them as the golden grail of what can be only hinders exciting, new opportunities. Least we forget everything, even the most well established parts of our culture that we have come to value nowadays was once a risky new idea with nothing to its name. I think its time to start taking that risk again.

    • @TheArkhamjester
      @TheArkhamjester Před rokem +1

      I mostly agree with one exception, when formerly exclusive titles (mostly japanese exclusives) getting a second chance at a world wide release. Live A Live and the upcoming Front Mission 2 come to mind. Feels somewhat more justified. Otherwise just put the old game on digital storefronts.

  • @girlpower987654321
    @girlpower987654321 Před rokem +1

    The king has returned!

  • @LelloDalamiq
    @LelloDalamiq Před rokem +2

    Honestly? I'd have liked some of Resurrection's VAs with some of that charm in the PS4 remake.
    Or maybe I just wanted Tom Baker's Death and all of his charms preserved in a true-to-form remake to really add that british touch. That 'oh yes, everything's gone to shit and we're almost quite fine with that, really' touch.

  • @ColeoIsCooleo
    @ColeoIsCooleo Před rokem +2

    I will always solely believe that restrictions force people to be more creative. Even if there are limitations, theres still work arounds for the dedicated ones. The ease of everything being at the reach of everyones hands at all times has made people not feel as inspired to push through to something new. Theres the exception but for the most part people rush things out because people go batshit insane for leaks, and get mad realistic wait times for how long it takes to make a decent game of by pressuring people and it always feels like little heart and thought went into it.
    If a game is made to be updated, it's not a finished game and shouldn't be sold as finished product

  • @DonkeyBoyVids
    @DonkeyBoyVids Před rokem +8

    I have a soft spot for Medievil Resurrection, and while I still enjoy looking back at it, you're completely right about the tone.

  • @Kriss_ch.
    @Kriss_ch. Před rokem +4

    Thanks for the Halloween video!
    As far as remakes or sequels go, it's always gonna be on a case by case basis for me. Sometimes a new sequel like Metroid Other M is a bummer, while a remake like Metroid Zero Mission is really cool. Especially if the series has been out of the hand of the original creator for a while, and the new people involved might not be a good fit to creating something new that feels like an authentic follow-up. Or if it's not a game with a concept that lends itself well to sequels, but the original would still benefit from a remake. For instance, Odin Sphere Leithrasir reinvented those original mechanics and made a much better game. I'd also call the Tengo Project remakes of Wild Guns, Pocky & Rocky and Ninja Warriors really wonderful remakes that took what was there and made something better. Considering it's the original, now very old developers redrawing all those sprites with way more frames and detail for widescreen and recording the songs again, it also feels as authentic as it possibly could.
    At the moment I'm hoping the Resident Evil 4 remake turns out good. A tall order, considering it's easily my favorite in the franchise so it's easy to imagine any changes being negative ones. But this might also the only chance I get to see another Resident Evil game as fun as RE4 considering nothing else in the series has come close for me since the original. Neither direct nor spiritual sequels have recaptured RE4, so hey, let's try a remake instead. Worth a shot.
    Sometimes old games feel super outdated. Time often marches on from a game, and you gotta put on blinders for clunky bits and bothersome mechanics. Even games that are still outstanding suffer from changing standards for TVs, with low-res textures, text and UI elements meant for a small screen and restrictive non-widescreen viewpoints. The ideal remake for me isn't some reimagining that only keeps the name, it's a game that feels like the original but still substantially updates it, keeping what's good and improving what could use improvement. But of course, it'd be a relief if it was just easier to play all these old games, too. Especially legally. But I don't think remaking is inherently dumb. It's just good or bad depending on how it turns out, and what fits the original game the most.
    It's not at all important for me that a new sequel is better for _conversation_ though, lol. Whether it's a new direction or stuck in the past, the important thing is it's a great, quality video game.

  • @seanbuck2310
    @seanbuck2310 Před rokem +3

    My dad completed this for me when I was a kid- him and mum would steal my PlayStation and play it when I was in bed. Well that’s how it started 😂 I loved the second game as a kid.

  • @foulhooked2438
    @foulhooked2438 Před rokem

    Love seeing Colonel Freddie Fortesque in the wild, great video!

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem

      Thanks! Old chap deserves all the exposure he can get

  • @gaianexv2109
    @gaianexv2109 Před rokem

    Man, I can't wait to hear your thoughts on Sly 4.

  • @LexioLTG
    @LexioLTG Před rokem +1

    2:37
    THIS AWAKENED BURIED MEMORIES WITHIN ME
    I NEED THE NAME OF THIS THING

  • @MrDeliworker
    @MrDeliworker Před rokem +1

    I was so on board with this video already 30 seconds in and it just kept getting better. The remake/remaster trend has been infinitely frustrating to me because obviously the games that have the most critical cache are the ones that are the "safer bet" to spend effort on. But maybe counterintuitively, the "really good beloved games from 20+ years ago" are still by and large good experiences that can hold up by themselves. It's just inherently uninteresting to put a new coat of paint on something that already nailed it. And even in some cases where things do get updated for the better, as you said, it's still "just this game again". Maybe if every remake we got was on the level of the original Resident Evil 1 Remake then maybe I'd complain less, but all too often producers are scared to go off the beaten path so they take the safe option of keeping things largely identical. I feel like I'm just re-stating your video but it's something I've been struggling to articulate properly for a while so I appreciate the work you do, as always.

    • @bamban_garcia5562
      @bamban_garcia5562 Před rokem +2

      Remakes are literally meant to rebuilt the original on newer tech to make it as accessible as possible for modern audiences, what you are looking for is called a reimagining or a reinvention

  • @Walkman-
    @Walkman- Před rokem +8

    This video kinda perfectly explains why I dont really care for remakes much anymore

  • @edgyemogirl666
    @edgyemogirl666 Před rokem +1

    I was gonna comment that I hope one day you talk about a spooky game where you don't play as a cartoony mascot guy but then it hit me... most of the games you talk about star cartoony mascot characters lol. Might be cool to step outside a comfort zone but eh you do you. Nice video as always :)

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +1

      Lmao I do play a lot of non mascot horror games- Resi, silent hill, evil within, I guess Doom is kinda in that bracket, stuff like that, but I just never really get that fired up about them or have the same kind of knowledge to impart. There have also been so many good videos by other creators covering those subjects, and it's less about stepping out of my comfort zone and more not wanting to say what's already been said so well before.
      I do try to make up for this with the videos on other subjects in tv, film and such, which bounce around the map, and I guess if I get fired up enough to talk about a game outside that world one day I totally will. Now that i'm making my way through most of my old favourites, maybe that'll start to happen!

    • @edgyemogirl666
      @edgyemogirl666 Před rokem

      @@BMask AH okay that makes sense :) Yeah don't feel like you gotta force yourself to make anything. Like I said, you do you :)

  • @JohnDoe-uf3lj
    @JohnDoe-uf3lj Před rokem

    He’s back!

  • @amberalvia1101
    @amberalvia1101 Před rokem +1

    Cool thumbnail art for your video.

  • @TheKellster94
    @TheKellster94 Před rokem +3

    I played the Remake during covid lockdown and loved it!

  • @zendariun101
    @zendariun101 Před rokem +2

    There he is

  • @szymonlewandowski9690
    @szymonlewandowski9690 Před rokem +4

    I kid you not, I clicked on this video right after finishing a session of Medievil Ressurections.
    And yeah, Im currently playing through Medievil Ressurections, and to be honest, I am quite enjoying my time with it! It is also the only Medievil game I ever played, so yes, I propably would enjoy the other games a lot more and im not denying the criticisms of the game.
    What I found interesting though, is your description of Medievil 1, how it's Dan - a goofy character, being contrasted with a still cartoony, but primarly dark and dangerous world.
    In Medievil Ressurections I really get the opposite feeling. Dan is the straigth man, interacting with the weird and wacky characters, often reacting with confusion and/or annoyance at their shenanigans.

    • @BMask
      @BMask  Před rokem +2

      Just another reason why I felt it missed the point completely.

  • @Shinobits
    @Shinobits Před rokem +2

    I've been hoping for a MediEvil 2 remake for so long but it seems like it's a lost hope...

  • @alexandreturcotte6411

    I never knew I would need Dan fighting gremlins on a plane before seeing your video.

  • @SweetTaLe
    @SweetTaLe Před rokem +3

    Medievil is no doubt one of my favorite games. Partly due to nostalgia, and partly due to the games style and atmosphere. Medievil was my rough start at action games, if you can call it that. I remember one halloween when I tried to replay the original PS1 title and realized just how janky the game was. I still loved it, but good lord the platforming and the camera were horrendous. That's why I'm really happy it got a modern remake. They fixed most of the issues with the camera and platforming making the playing experience so much more enjoyable. The original really only has the low poly style to it, so if that's really important it's still there. You can even play the original within the remake, which is so goddamn cool. I do hope that one day this series will get a proper sequel. I'd love a dark comedic souls-like. Well maybe don't exactly make it like a souls game, MediEvil has its own flair. Just a modern sequel with updated combat and a good sense of humor would go far!

  • @bamban_garcia5562
    @bamban_garcia5562 Před rokem +2

    I been waiting for a Medievil 2 remake or Medievil 3 since 1999...
    Any decade now it will happen!
    Any month now...
    Any day now...

  • @jean-lucchessher7065
    @jean-lucchessher7065 Před rokem +1

    The original looks so much darker than the cartooniness of the remake

    • @KaminoKatie
      @KaminoKatie Před rokem +4

      The artstyle of the remake is based off of concept art for the original game

  • @butters9354
    @butters9354 Před rokem +1

    You should do a video on the og mgs1 and the twin snakes it's a very interesting reimagining

  • @JMandJJ7797
    @JMandJJ7797 Před rokem +5

    As someone who wanted to play these games and can't access the originals easily without emulation, I am fine with remakes like the Klonoa games, Medievil, and the first Pac-Man World getting one. Though while we are on the topic while are all PSP remake games stuck in PSP limbo and never got released on the 3DS or Switch? Is it licensing rights or something? Cause the PSP FF remakes are the best versions especially graphics wise but instead of rereleasing those for the Pixel Remaster they made something else instead.

    • @Kriss_ch.
      @Kriss_ch. Před rokem

      Well hey they're giving Tactics Ogre a makeover now.

  • @jeggsonvohees2201
    @jeggsonvohees2201 Před rokem +5

    For all its faults MediEvil 2's ending opened up the endless possibilities of seeing Dan's adventures across time, yet sadly we never got to experience it. Imagine Dan in feudal Japan, or ancient Egypt, heck even in the far future.

    • @bamban_garcia5562
      @bamban_garcia5562 Před rokem

      You can at least read it though

    • @jeggsonvohees2201
      @jeggsonvohees2201 Před rokem +3

      @@bamban_garcia5562 Not really, the comic just mostly goes back to Gallowmere instead of somewhere new.

    • @VerdeMorte
      @VerdeMorte Před rokem +2

      Maybe for the best, a different team handling it could've been a Thieves in Time debacle...

  • @tehparol
    @tehparol Před rokem +1

    new video! yay