Beware that there’s a lot of miss information in the comments. When it’s safe for me to do so, I’ll tell you why the Govt. came for me (with proof). But right now if I do that, my blacklisting could be extended. Plus we’re in the Delhi Hight Court fighting, so that process must happen first. ✍ Please help us by signing our petition www.change.org/BringBackRock Ep 2. "Asking the Indian High Commissioner for HELP When My Wife Has COVID 😷" czcams.com/video/x2_iMUn22AE/video.html For more information, read my blog post blog.karlrock.com/why-i-havent-seen-my-wife-in-269-days-blacklist/ पिछले २६९ दिनों में मैं अपनी पत्नी से क्यों नहीं मिला #ब्लैकलिस्ट blog.karlrock.com/why-i-havent-seen-my-wife-in-269-days-blacklist-hindi/ (Hindi)
I'm a Japanese. I'm living in India for past 4 years. I know my limits in india, One can't protests against or favour for govt by having tourist visa.. I think u would have heard about jakob , A German who was studying in IIT Madras had forced to leave india bcoz of his participation in Anti CAA protests. Same goes for U.. Now don't act like a victim. Being a foreigner u should have more concerned about the visa policy of India. Wishing u would meet ur family ❤️
Agreed Bro...Watch some of his old videos.He is Fighting with Poor sellers and labeling them as Scammers...this is totally against there self respect what if his son sees that Clickbait Edit : thanks for you're likes and care
There are more problems government should be concerned of. . . . They are busy building ram temple collecting 5000 crores. 😕😕 when people are dying of Covid they are scamming people by blocking all other vaccines and pushing funds to Serum institute .. they wont touch currupted politicians assets , they wont touch currupted government employees assets ,, they wont touch swiss bank list (promised in demonization but never done 🤣) . We the people just believe that some day some miracle will happen like they show in movies some youth taking over country but it wont happen at all. 😕😕
he participated in Protest in india. According to law, no foreigners is allowed to participate in any protest in indian territory. Its violation of visa rules. Though i do hope ban is lifted on him.
so government should tell the reason atleast if they have done so. why silent on the reason. atleast his wife can go to court to see reason is justified or not
Then this should have been in the reason to ban him. And most of all he is husband of Indian National. Even if he is not Indian, Indian government should think it twice and warn him before banning him. He is not shahid afridi or daaud abrahim. He is a gentle person, loves India, trying to make India better. But why is our government behaving like Kim Jon and Hitler? Government should at least behave professional and ethical, unless government had admitted that they lack self-respect and it will continue
1.He went to restricted areas where no one is allowed to visit 2.He participated in anti Caa protest (any person who does not have Indian citizenship is not allowed to protest) 3.He did business activities in India without having citizenship which is illegal too He broke so many laws what did he expect
I was all in support of you Karl, but these questions needs to be asked: 1. Did you participate in Anti CAA protest though knowing you would violate Visa laws as a foreigner? 2. There are rumours you got blacklisted cause you do business, work, earn money on a tourist visa, which is also not allowed? You should adress these questions asap, else this video will not age well.
Simple thing is he violated the visa norms Acc to Indian law, no foreigner is allowed to take part in protests. Similar laws are there in countries like Australia. Let’s hope this issue gets sorted soon and he gets removed from the blacklist
I am a foreign in India and I have been living in India from the past 7 years, I never participated in any protest. ..but Karl Rock participated that's why you're blocked 😅😅😅
@@denzelheden4256 yeah he think he can broke the law of india what if i broke the law of new Zealand they will kick me out that's the same thing what indian govt did..and he talking about indian culture by eating beef 🤦♂️.. stop making fool people
You can get a Billion petitioners to sign but the law will not be reversed, unfortunately. Your wife, as a civil services aspirant, has not read Indian polity.
Karl Rock participated in a political movement in a foreign country, a direct violation of visa norms. He along with his wife participated in the Anti-CAA protests in December 2019. Karl Rock well deserves to be black-listed. I stand with my Government.
You can protest here after getting citizenship. Few years ago a Bangladeshi actor got booted from India and got blacklisted because he was participating in political rally. Sorry for you and your wife but Govt need to protect the interests of us.
@@vaishalidhawak304 aag laga die poore Delhi me aise log jab sab support kr rhe the un jhadiyion ko . Itni himmat buland unki aise logo ke karan hi hui thi
My brother was deported from Australia, because he was driving a taxi while he was on a student visa, it was my brother's fault and not the fault of the Australian government, people need to follow the rules of the land.
@@Aayushrn25 in normal world when you marry citizen of some country you are getting citizenship trough that marriage, but anyways everybody knows India isn't normal country....
His father in law is in opposition party in government, thats why he is doing protest against CAA... without knowing, that same law is in NZ where he is from.
@Jock Ma he is here on a tourist visa, in terms it's mentioned that someone on a tourist visa cannot take part in protests or other similar activities.
I am from bhutan, I was surprised to see what Karl was doing on tourist visa with traveling everywhere, running protest, supporting parties, etc etc… a tourist visa has limitations internationally. If it was for bhutan .. this stuffs are instantly not permitted canceling the visa. But I was amazed that’s easy go in India. I think his multiple protocols overlook took off his visa. Besides he is nice guy.
@@samir98753 look at how pathetic u r, calling others poor as if u r the richest person of the world but i guess no one taught u its ur appearance which matters more than "how rich u r", if u "rich" people have no manners and respect for others, then it's better to be poor instead and we can see how well u r representing ur "rich" country which is unfortunately poor in teaching manners and respect.
A senior retired Supreme Court judge Markandey Katju has to say “However much one may feel sorry for him because he has been unable to meet his wife for one year, the External Affairs Ministry action cannot be faulted. He broke the law. If one comes on a tourist visa one cannot do business. To do business in India one must obtain a business visa. Grant of visa is the government’s discretion, not a right ( unlike a passport which is one’s right, as held by the Indian Supreme Court ).”
@@whytemonkey6969 he said ''majority of Indians'' and yes it is true, The people who doesn't stand by the government's decision in this case are in the 'minority'.
"Your involvement in a protest in India" violates the Visa Rule as per the information received. Anyway we know how honest and open minded you are. Feel so bad for what happened to you. our support is with you. stay safe and hope you return home soon.
its interesting how much he has done for india, and foreignors coming to india and yet they do this. But what do you expect? why werent the police following that same law for corruption, taking bribes etc?
@@FM-dm8xj what do you think would happen if foreigners randomly started coming to india and taking part in protests and supporting political leaders the situation would become worse .karl is not the only foreigner who can come he is a good man but not everybody is imagine if people from pakistan or another country with which we dont have nice relations come and do something like this it can even lead to riots
According to Indian law No foreigners can participate in Any protest in India but you did it in During CAA protest .Probably this is the sole reason behind your blockage. Otherwise you are a good man and you never show India in a Bad light so we are hoping that govt will lift ban on your entry
@Incredible India but we can see your agenda , if you never understand a person when he makes almost 90% video about India and show us amazing places in India and show his love about India in Pakistan you can't accuse someone with fake CZcams account 🙏
It is a law of every country not about india but also of USA Canada UK France Israel.. As a foreigner u can't protest against the govt of any country..
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 thats illegal but if you are not part of a country he is a serious criminal ,try to create rift is serious offence and you know what happened after that protest ,how many people died .
Petition signed. IMHO, after watching a number of your anti-scammer videos, I would have thought that India would be very proud to have an adopted 'son' like you, on their side, in the never-ending fight against corruption and exploitation - against their own people, and against people from other Nations. In fact, they should be rolling out the red carpet for you, and for your brave wife. Good luck and nil desperandum.
Wer were U when he being a tourist joined campaigns which is against the law Wer were U when he talks about religion of that country being a Tourist Wer were U when he makes 8-10 lakh inr/ month on the videos he makes in India If he loves india so much why can’t he respect the rules U can’t pull this shit in other countries They’ll debarr a person for a lifetime So plz don’t listen to one sided stories & make ur opinions I think he is digging his own grave by talking all this nonsense online Basically he is saying how shit Indian govt is for blacklisting him For doing watever he is doing Which he knws he can’t do even in his own country !
Me too buddy, this all has happened on purpose with an agenda against Karl mate, and all of the replies you're seeing rn, are mostly triggered after they watched some XYZ creator's vid about Karl. How can one possibly think of separating a husband and wife, very nasty indeed.
MHA official: Karl Edward Rice, a New Zealand national, has been restricted from entering India till next year due to violation of terms and conditions of his visa. He was found doing business activities on a tourist visa and also violating other visa conditions
He was blacklisted because on December 19,2019, he posted a ground report video wherein he participated in the anti-CAA protests against the ind govt. Foreign nationals cannot take part in political movements because foreigners who are here in india under tourist visas are not allowed to process against laws passed by the ind parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of foreigners act,1946 and foreigners (amendment) act 2004
That's true...Even though I admire him so much, I completely disagree with what he did...It was a law meant to give citizenship to persecuted minorities of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan...he and his wife had no business to participate in that protest....!!!
The reality is he break law in india as as a foreign person he participated in anti caa protest which volitaes foreign act 2004 thats why he Has been blacklisted by government
He should be. He shouldn't be involved in such things. You deserve it bro. You should have taken cared of indian laws before getting involved in such protests etc.
I’m sorry for what you are going through I was born in Mexico back in 2006 I became a US citizen. Now im struggling for resident applications for my wife I totally understand I personally don’t know you but I feel for what you are going through take care of yourself and your family as much as you can
@@pinkaxolotl2446 Read again,he said back in 2006 he became US citizen,he wasn't born in 2006,he became a US citizen in 2006,I guess it's not totally your fault because he didn't use comma to separate the sentences,but still if you use logic you can understand what he meant
Hey mr karl rock, Imagine I An Indian guy goes to New Zealand on a tourist visa and starts business activities which is prohibited by law there also takes part in anti government protests which is also against the law of New Zealand. Now government of New Zealand blacklists me on these grounds and I start playing victim card to gain sympathy. Please judge accordingly. 😑
Bruh please shut the fuck up. Guy has been seperated from his wife for nearly a year, he isn't playing the victim card here, he's genuinely distraught. Of course you would have no concept of that given your complete lack of empathy in regards to his plight. He has tried to appeal, and reach out for answers and has been treated with a cold shoulder. I don't know how true it is that he was conducting official business without the proper certificates, but even so, people make mistakes. He is nowhere close to be considered a criminal, and as an Indian myself, I could say he probably loves the country more than most indians I know lmao.
@@shadkunt9387 your statement is not convincing enough. It might sound good but for a matter of fact he was also a part of the Anti CAA protest so no one gives him the right to do all the things on tourist visa. Kandhe pe bithane ka yeh matlab nahi k koi kaan mein mutne lagega. Sorry if my words sound harsh but this is the reality now a days if the scene stays same no one will value the words and laws of India.
@@shadkunt9387 He should've thought of his wife before doing stupid shit. Is it really so difficult to follow the law? The action of the government wasn't even unreasonable. Any other sovereign country would've done the same.
He was found doing business on a tourist visa and has been barred for one year; his visa has been cancelled and in addition to that when it comes to visa norms will newzealand government allow indians to work on tourist visa if yes than I'll get tourist visa . Playing emotional card does not change rule of a country
morover he and is wife prejudice could be seen in a video where she said this right wing govt has made law on the basis of discrimination in religion if muslims want the citizenship of india than what was the purpose of giving pakistan and bangladesh to them????
A Pakistani here, family is really important but you need to follow the rules. Its high time tourists start acting like tourists. If you'll start participating in political activities the indian government has every right to ban you.
What you are saying is very wrong. Imagine you are banned from the country you live in, where u have your family. Karl is not a tourist! And he has every damn right to participate in political activities. Im happy I live in germany where this could never happen, because the government isnt working like its the 18th century. I feel bad for karl and hope he can get back to a normal life.
@@lennarts6170 lol FYI he is on tourist visa.. Being on temp visa and if u go against the govt not only India even Germany will ban people.. and I want to tell you one more thing NZ (from where Karl originated ) have stopped migrants on temp visas to come in which caused lots of split families..
@@lennarts6170 nothing is wrong he said right who are you to speak against anyone's God culture ..who the hell are you. .!! So it's better to kick such person out of the country ..garbage should be dumped outside of the house so we are cleaning ..so before speaking nonsense about India now think 100 times.
Really sorry to hear of your situation Karl. I have followed your travels through India and I can attest that you truly have contributed to make India a better country by your love and devotion for this place and your wife and family. Hope things clear up to allow you back in India with your family where you belong.
the problem was -he participated in political protest,started bussiness and all that under tourist visa,, which is not allowd and is against the law,,,,so yeah he kinda deserved this 1 year blacklist
@@ayusharyan3899 Bro doesn't that made karl an easy target then. I don't think he shouldn't be punished so much, he has help many tourist and showed much respect to this nation
I've lived here in Thailand for 35 years as a foreigner married with children. The way to survive visa-wise is to keep your mouth shut, watch what you do, don't piss anyone off and especially don't criticize the royal family or the government. Asian countries' governments HATE vloggers they are considered political dissidents and not wanted because they do not mind their own business.
India pretends not to be a tin-pot dictatorship. We are the world's largest democracy, and so we are supposed to act like it. However, if you insist on following the path of the authoritarians, then I'd prefer a government like our East Asian neighbours have... at least they have their economies sorted. On the other hand, we are stuck with retarded politics and a retarded economy. Let's not get too comfortable living in the Stone Age?
@@vighneshpillai7996 Foreigners who are here in India under tourist Visas are not allowed to protest against laws passed by the Indian Parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and and Foreigners (Amendment) Act, 2004.
I'm a UK citizen and I've lived in China, Singapore and Qatar and, no matter how I felt about the politics of the country, or about the laws, I would never have been involved in anything political, both out of respect to the nation that was hosting me and because it would be likely I'd be kicked out.
yeah the possibility of get kicked from the country is a good reason not to be involved in such things especially in countries with lack of freedom where you can just be jailed and never come out of prison
David, I totally agree with you dude..if I as an Indian was living in some other nation, I would respect their rules and regulations...and Karl should play a bit safe because he is making videos mainly about IND and PAK ....he wouldn't have involved in any political protests of Pakistan...if he were to do that, he wouldn't have returned alive...but filming that anti CAA protest thing is like living as a guest at someone's place and then poking nose in their internal matters and talking about their fights in public
@@avantikanarvekar4415 Exactly. I've also travelled a lot to the USA and been asked by Americans on numerous ocassions what my opinion of their president is. I've always replied that I'm just a visitor and it's none of my business.
All idiots want to protest in USA, UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand. PM goes and says Ab ki Baar Trump ki Sarkar ( interfere internal politics ) but if someone says right thing suckers get upset. I say F^CK YOURSELF !!
@@dreamon1643★ selling his book, on his website. ★protesting against a caa nrc, which later converted into one of the deadliest riots in our country's history ★coming to india on visitors visa, and going to the restricted area of india like POK, and also coming under the surveillance of one of the terrorist intelligence agency 🇵🇰
Good decision by the govt. First he isn't a citizen of this country uske baad me chutiye ne protest me part liya vaise toh ye gora apne app ko bhohot bada samajhta hai ye.
Who is after world affairs But karl you should understand indian laws and respect it Ask for forgiveness and admit your mistake then I think our court is good enough to allow you back
Dude he is not been given a reason , if its his mistake he will admit but I guess he never done something wrong but made videos on wrong things happening here
@supertramp2.0 Indians with Indian Flags had stormed Capitol Hill as Trump supporters, that was also a so called protest, a violent one. Then if the US Government cancells thier visa, you will say that democracy is in danger and when the Indian government does the same you will justify it! Some Indians are blatant hypocrites.
@@gamingforlife1419 ooooo no you just got this sooo wrong ....see USA itself is liberal about this matter and allows foreigners to protest ..soo basically it not against their laws. But here in India it is against the law ..now hey you can't disrespect the law of a country.
@@saurabhswarnakar6829 How do you know those are temporary visa holders? They could be permanent resident. Good that this guy is banned. He should never come back to India. We don't need him.
Update: Home ministry have replied by saying that he violated Visa rules by doing business activities on a tourist visa. Suspension stays till next year.
Sources are saying that he was involved in CAA-,NRC protest so wait for the reply from government before you judge government. As per rules and regulations no foreigner is allowed to protest in India due to security reasons.
Earlier he himself posted a video on CZcams, where karl and his wife are protesting in CAA... Later on he deleted the video...now i get it why he deleted that shit
New Zealand origin vlogger Karl Rock has been blacklisted by the Government of India for violating multiple visa norms," a ministry official told ANI on this day, "He was found doing business on a tourist visa and has been barred for one year; his visa has been cancelled." He also took part in CAA protest which is against visa norms for a person living on tourist visa.
@@sakshamtyagi9652 yaa indeed I agree, violating Indian laws is such a bullshit reason to ban someone. Like its all ok for foreigners to come to India and violate laws and not expect them to either get banned or arrested. Totally fine !
Brother I feel bad for you but you should have considered this outcome before joining the caa protest. Your visa was to travel India and create content but you decide to protest against the law of a country which you don't even belong to. Overall I hope the government will allow you to be with your family once again.
@@devastator01ful so government is beyond God now? A legal marriage can be broken by the government? Ye kaunsa law hai? Besti to beta India ki hi hogi, bhakti kitni bhi kar lo.
Sometimes I feel we should keep rule aside one who loves India should be allowed a chance .. And we can't forget he has done many efforts in scam related issue.. I hope u get to return soon brother..
@@voyagerx2133 aisa nahi hota dada rule is rule goro par bharosa kar ke hum bohot badi bhul kar chuke hai ab aur nahi scammers kya hota hai inhone hamse he 45trillion loote tha aur ye kutre hame he scammers kah rahe hai 😡🤬
Despite of being his follower I think that he should be blacklisted from the country...bcuz Foreigners who are here in India under tourist Visas are not allowed to protest against laws passed by the Indian Parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and Foreigners (Amendment) Act, 2004. Also, it can attract provisions of Section 121 of the IPC that deals with waging war against the Government of India or abetting the same. for us the laws of our country matters the most don't they ? if INDIA removes his name from blacklist then the foreign youtubers (mainly the reaction channels, street interviewers who are gaining view by using INDIA's name) they all can come in INDIA and start protesting. So this is the reason why I am totally in favor of INDIAN govt. I am bounded by my country's law and would not tolerate if any other person especially foreigners would try to violate them....
@@superboobs890 yeah thats what i was thinking . if it was some random foreign guy we would not have cared but he has a family in india and a indian wife so blacklisitng him would be wrong maybe some other way could have been done
Your wife is hard core politicians daughter right? they are from Haryana, opposition party if not wrong from congress. Saw your 22nd Aug 2019 video participating your in laws political rally. naturally she will take congress's line participating Anti CAA protest, but you should respect Indian constitutional rights & Visa offered to you. She also said bad words for Indian god Lord Krishna in your Andaman visit video. We like you & your videos Karl Rock but keep politics away. You are getting involved & victim of In laws politics.
Had a British Indian friend - born and raised in the UK. Someone in his extended family back in India died and he was obliged to travel to India to deal with the affairs of deceased. He could not understand why he could make no progress. The simplest arrangements went wrong. Mysterious obstructions to everything. Incredible last-minute snags. When he finally talked to the family friends there, everything was explained. He wasn't 'talking' to the right people! And, 'talking' there means paying bribes. Lots of bribes. Nothing in India happens without.
@@PhilipMarcYT Sorry, fella. Being American you know little of the British Empire. Until 1947, the country was officially known as 'British India' the army was known, for example as the 'British Indian Army'. So yes, Yankee friend, you CAN be British Indian.
@@alastairbarkley6572 um no you cant be british indian as you yourself said it was until 1947 .also we dont want british related to any part of india other than trade
Reason for is blacklisting is violation of article 15 of general policy regarding visa matters in Indian law. He participated in anti CAA protest in India which is not allowed for non citizens of India.
As a Pakistani, I'm not signing his petition as that may complicate his case further due to similar reasons. I hope more Indians sign his petition in droves so he gets to go home ASAP.
@@ashishsawant122 and what if a foriegner is supporting caa ,, would'nt he be considered getting political as well ,,, everyone is political whether you support caa or not ,, that does'nt mean that its threatning national security ,,,, many indians participate in protests in usa , european countries they dont face such trials ,, perhaps that is what you call a democracy ,,
What? Article 15 says that the state cannot deny access to public services for anyone in Indian territory. Where is this law about foreigners not being allowed to lawful public assembl that people are talking about?
Sources in the Ministry of Home Affairs said that the vlogger was found doing business activities on a tourist visa, which is in violation of the terms and conditions of his visa. He has, therefore, been restricted from entering India for a year. His visa has also been cancelled by the government.
@sahannadinesh , Karl Edward Rice(Karl Rock) in his one of the videos he participated in the Anti-CAA Protest. According to the Indian Constitution, no foreigner can take part in any Protest in India(Protest against any Domestic Matter of India). I think it would be the main reason why the Indian Govt Blacklisted him. Due to this kind of reason many foreigner (a total of 5 foreigner) were Blacklisted/Deported/Asked to leave India. I do not want to harm anyone's sentiment . It's what I think " may be " the reason.
My sympathy is with you and your family. You are very good person. But one thing you must remember that anyone is not above law of land. You should avoid involving in protests(you have posted a video of anti CAA protest on your channel what you made private later) or involving any business. There should be some reason for what you have been blacklisted.
Its a long History that Anti Nationals also do something which hurt sentiments of masses or violates IPC Laws but then either they apologize for their mistakes or they are granted with bail, thats disgusting. INDIA should set a hard example so that it should not be repeated. Everyone ahould respect the law of land ie INDIA ! ⚔ Jay Hind !🇮🇳
BTW 6 years of civil service preparation she should have known its illegal for a foreigner to protest against govt under foreigners act and visa term and conditions . This is what you expect least from an aspirant.
Yup bro He protested on CAA and he is not an Indian I know this is so bad that he is unable to met his wife. But on a travel Visa he shouldn't have done that.
Hey, would you mind sharing a link of the law where it mentions this being illegal? I’m from Brazil and I’m trying to find it, but unable to. Would like to learn more. Appreciate the help.
Also, Shivam, if Karl is married to an Indian, I’m sure he doesn’t have a tourist visa, but an entry visa or a business one (in case he receives his earnings through an Indian company). He can apply for OCI after 2 years of marriage. Not sure if this law is only for people under tourist visa or foreigners of all visa categories
@Nitin Singh Negi Exactly, make videos on New Zealand. About the Maoris, the indigenous people of New Zealand. A white privlieged guy has no business maligning a country that has suffered so much under white colonialism and Islamic invasions.
@@heroinuser.5913 Still its the white leftists who wanted to assuage their guilt who came up with their half baked ideologies that led to this situation which is now spread globally. The leftist aligning themselves with the Jihadists, Antifa BLM extremists and attacking their nations. This is a thought form, an energy that is spreading and will have consequences. Karl, like many believe in those fake narratives spun by leftist msm and hence feel entitled to attack India. After so many decades of impoverishment, India now has a strong leader who works day and night for the upliftment of all Indians and development of India and yet fake news persist and leftists and Islamist are working even harder at their agenda.
It's amazing to see so many comments in support of the Indian government and the rule of law. India I am impressed by your citizenry. I hope this situation can be resolved as I have loved and learnt a lot from Karl.
Even our 💔 is broken but CAA is a serious issue even we faced internal war like situation and read about vishal jood who is in Australia every country does the same
@@abhakandpal2948 leave the guy alone, he probably wasn't aware of it, from his channel he seems like a nice dude, he's getting rid of scammers, guiding other tourists/indians just imparting knowledge, he's himself learning hindi and haryanvi out of passion and love for the country, let's not downplay his content as something disingenuous without proof.
Hey Karl, I'm sorry you have to go through this. I checked your case. The most possible reason for you getting blacklisted is the participation in a political protest. According to Indian Law, foreign nationals cannot participate in political activity such as protests against the Indian parliament. This law has been in existence since 1946.
He knows that, he knew it when he went and protested in the first place. Because he started protesting AFTER the news went viral of 5 foreigners being deported for protesting.
That doesn't matter here... What matters is HUMANITY. You aren't standing up for the country, But this MAN did even though he is not from our nation. He is bold enough to fight these silly issues created by these shit things. According to me the only mistake from his side for telling that the CHAI from india is good rather than in Pakistan. This was the only mistake that happened in the recent. AND I REALLY DONT ACCEPT THIS IS A MISTAKE. HE IS STRAIGHT FORWARD WITH THAT. Except this, He was only showing us the thing that what INDIA ACTUALLY IS.... AND WHAT IS ACTUALLY SAID TO BE. NO MATTER WHAT, HE HAS TO BE SAVED.
The External Affairs Ministry has said he came to India on a tourist visa but was doing business in India. That is illegal. If u come on a tourist visa u can’t do business in the host country. For that u need a business visa. And also some visa rule violations
Why can't a foreigner protest against India? When Indias were being harassed in Australia few years ago thousands of Aussies came in support and demanded justice for Indians. Do you have to be a German only to criticize the wrong doings of Hitler. I don't think so. Get your brain evolved a bit if you can.
@@sidpanjr Because allowing foreigners to protest over Indian laws in India can have serious consequences. Imagine Bangladeshis or Pakistanis hijacking protests in India and driving the protest according to their own narrative. Most of the democratic countries have such rules.
@@amitarya5690 thousands of NRIs protested against Trump...no one called them "external influence" because expressing your opinion is not influence and I believe anybody can do that irrespective of citizenship or not.
Just saw your 16 December video and now this video. I can't say I can relate to you 100%, yet seeing you, a random CZcamsr out there whose videos I just discovered a couple hours ago, going through such terrible pain. Just breaks my heart. Not a person of religion, I wish you and your wife to be reunited again and live happily ever after from the bottom of my heart. Stay strong, Karl and Merry Christmas!
@@mrnobody9762 - why don't you educate me. What rules did he violate? It's not like that sort of information is ubiquitous. That's like me telling you to educate yourself about the starfishes destroying the coral reefs around the world, which are contributing to global warming.
@@sztypettto With tourist visa, you can't take part in any political matter and he had done this multiple times, he had join in protest too and FOREIGNERS ACT 1964 AND FOREIGNERS AMENDMENT 2004 u can read about this😊
@@anxiety6230 it's not about fascist brother it's because if we allow foreigners to protest they will overtake the protest and mold it in their own way
The act which will give citizenship to persecuted Sikh, Hindu, Cristian,Jain,Parsi minority of paxtan, Bangladesh,Afganistan. Why to protest against that ?
@@randomcodes4183 this guy karl rock is a foreigner for indian soil and he was found protesting against the CAA bill passed by the govt. He uploaded anti caa videos in twitter n social media and as per the indian law foreigners are not allowed to protest or interfere in indian affairs. They are coming to india for tourist purpose so visit have fun and get the fuck out of here... as simple as that.... so does every other country in the world does it. He can go anf make videos in new zealand. But the problem is that he will only get views and content in india. His earning will stop if he is not allowed entry in india. He can make scam videos for the countries across the world, why is he being specific to india? Arent there scams goin on in other countries?
@@randomcodes4183 He went in Anti - CAA protest in 2019 with his wife...but according to Indian Law a foreigner cannot join a protest(riots)...If you live in India married with a Indian girl doesn't mean you are a India citizen...
If we go to any country and violate their visa rules , we will be blacklisted , not only you karl bhai. So you should accept your mistake and hope for the best❤
@@DraakMD CZcamsr Karl Rock Visa Violations: Not Allowed under X1: 》Taken Part in Anti-CAA Protests 》Made Video & Spread Propaganda 》Hurt Religious Sentiments X2: 》Published Book 'Indian Survival Guided' 》Visited Restricted Area 》Coverage of Anti-CAA Protests on CZcams
@@JohnCena-ch3lc what's wrong with taking part with anti CAA protest? Apart from it religious propaganda? Really 😂? Literally people in India are taking anything on thier religion and call it propaganda. Get a life and leave people alone.
A guy from foreign land, speaks our language, married to an Indian, promotes tourism in india, more Indian than the actual Indians who just wants to leave india is being treated like this ? SHOCKED
Look what happens to him is wrong,but he was clearly not promoting any tourism after he got married. He is a defacto spokesman of his father in law party and communists.
Ekdum sahi reply diya aapne, foreigners expect much more from India but when it comes to the treatment of an Indian in foreign, their misbehave is normal.
You don't have right to interfere in domestic issue and protests before doing such acts plz read foreigners ACT 1946, and 2004 and you voilted this law India is Very powerful man.
@@abhishektandon8373 Where did I say let foreigners protest but if Indian government is so strong in implementing laws as in original comment then why half of the MPs and high profile scammers not in jail. If only this much attention they would've given to some public issues.
@@Purana-Pappi Atleast mere jaise logo se desh aage na bhi badhe to pata to chalega ki desh ruka hua hai, Varna aadhi janta ko India superpower 2018 se dikh raha hai .
foreigner are not allowed to participate in protests against the laws of india passed by the government....& he is on tourist visa he is not a citizen of india.....he participated in many protests in india like caa nrc in delhi.... same law is in every country tourist has to behave like a tourist not like a citizen of the country in which he is traveling
Alright. If you think a tourist cannot be part of protests in favor of indian citizens, then why are the right Indian not doing the right thing. Why a tourist has to be the eye-opener for you guys?
but still government should give the reason to him that you done so so and so thats why blacklisted. atleast his wife can go to court seeking justification
@@chandranshpandey1929 reason diya h Ye tourist visa pr h to koi bhi tourist Indian protest m part nhi le skta ye tourist visa k rules k khilaf h to ab rule toda h to bugatna Pedga rules are rules
Well the reason could be the vlogger is praying to get more significant. This makes great drama and the masses are starving for drama. Getting banned might be the goal of some people. I am not assuming that it is his goal. Its just fascinating to think that it might be. He gets to to start a new chapter and his Pakistan vlogs are interesting. So why was he banned?
@@Majk246 he joined anti CAA protests being tourist. If he would have Indian citizenship then Rock might have been different and he might be chilling in Delhi having samosas but alas law is law
sir you shouldn't had involved in indian domestic issues. because according to Indian laws no foreigners have right to participate in any kind of protest.and your not the only one who has been blocked. and also CAA was very sensitive topic. for participating on same topic 4-5 people's visa are blocked and sent back to their native nation. you should have behaved as laws suggest. we all hope you will meet your family as early as possible.(we all know for a human family is everything) but on future follow law's and respect laws.
Leaving aside politics and all It was a blatant abuse of law and as we know ‘ignorantia juris non-excusat,' or 'ignorance of the law is no excuse,' This thing was bound to happen. Let’s hope that this issue gets sorted out quickly and he is able to return to India Because as it is Pakistan isn’t very safe
I don't understand why CAA has to do with this, by that logic Tarek Fatah, Francois Gautier etc should also be blacklisted for openly taking stands and taking part in a political discourse while being Canadian/French Citizens?? Or is it just that those who oppose the govt will only be subjected to the law? Anyway blacklisting Karl Rock will only affect tourism in India. It's our loss because of this government's pettiness
@@ObitoUchiha-uq3pf do u think it's because of Central gov ? There are some rules and if u violate it u will be punished he published a travel guide book which is business only and u can't do it with a tourist visa also he took part in protest which he was not supposed to do so the consequences are here.
@@CerealKilIer 🤣 It is internal matter indeed , he is on tourist visa and it violates law made by baba saheb amedkar , now u can file case against that law if u want to change it
Protesting and doing business activity is not allowed, if it was Vise versa new zealand govt have also done the same, always respect immigration rules of the country.
Do make a video on how New Zealand government has been ripping of money from Indians and not allowing students and valid work visa holders to return back
How selfish do you have to be to complain about not being allowed to cross boarders in the middle of a global pandemic - especially when the country in question has done so much to contain covid and stop any community spread and the country you're wanting to travel from has the worst numbers in the world.
I Would Simply Advice To Remeber These Things For Future - 1. Don't Participate In Any Kind Of Political Protest Untill You Are A 100% Citizen Of India 2. Follow The Visa Rules Strictly & Get A Bussines Visa If You Wanna Do Bussines In India. 3. Don't Promote Cow Slaughtering Because It Hurts Religious Sentiments Of A Large Group.
@@sahildhanani4282 If you have noticed, he didn't raise voice against Pakistani blasphemy laws or terrorism while in 🇵🇰. Neither did he participate in Political Rallies there. He only raise voice against India and Indians. Why?
Karl, you were blacklisted because you and your wife participated in anti CAA protests, and according to foreign act of India, a foreigner can't participate in protest in India.
You want to know why you are black listed ? Here’s the reason, you were involved in the anti CAA protests, which is in clear violation of the foreigners act of 1946 and 2004, you were in violation of your visa, you can’t be participating in protests on visiting or travel visa, you did this to yourself no one is to blame, you also made a video on it yourself you self incriminated yourself, why don’t you tell the entire story? Being separated from your family isn’t really a good situation and I pity that, but sir you did this to yourself. Even the judiciary won’t be able to help you, you clearly violated the laws and you know it, don’t play the victim now. And also make the video public so that people can see why you were black listed. Your wife has all the right to protest she’s an Indian citizen, you aren’t an Indian citizen. In your video, a times now reporter comes upto you and asks if you’re covering the protest or taking part in it, and I quote you “ taking part in it...... both, taking part and covering it”
For those who are supporting him and abusive Indian government...Plz do some research they are not treating him in an awful way...He had violate many laws that you can't do with tourist visa...So if you don't know both sides don't support anyone without actually knowing the truth...No hate to him, he is not a bad guy but he shouldn't do that. But I do not know why he haven't mention what he had done. He took the rules granted when you visit any country you should follow their rules💜
I've enjoyed a lot of your content, but you need to be careful as a Visa holder. If you violate it you can be deported. I am on Visa in the USA and I'm always careful to not break any rules. All govts have the right to enforce it. I hope you unite with your family. And let this be a lesson for everyone as well.
right! I heard that Rock is on a traveler visa but he did engage in some business activities. This might be minor but you can imagine what will happen if you do the same in the US.
"Before someone is added to the Blacklist they're meant to be given the reason, and time to reply. I wasn’t." These are the words of karl rock, looks like he knows the rules but tried to be more indian than indians.
Went to restricted areas of defence where even Indians not allowed 2Published book without business visa 3participated in CAA-no political activity allowed including journalism without visa 4CAA protest video deleted 5 visted Pakistan through dubai not through india for more than 50days (intelligence alert) 6Participated in election rally Court won't care abt emotions. Countries like USA will deport right after if they see Iran visa. Lol we Indians are still colonized doing same mistake again seeing others with sympathy
Problem is haters have been so brain washed in the last 7 years that they have lost the discrimination power now to know what is right and what is wrong. They just want to stand up against the government even though they end up looking anti national.
I am so sorry that a very nice person like you is banned.. You are a very intelligent and brilliant person. Making great volgs. Promoting India. I have come to love India through your volgs.. I'am a Pakistani. I am so proud you can say j'ai hind... And you are proud to say it.. If Indian government reads this posting please please give Karl his visa to go to India.. He and his wife are a big plus for you and all of us.. With much love to our Indian brothers and sisters... Please understand Karl and his wife's position.. They are great advert for India.... I think we should all write to the Indian government and embassy's in our country's to help Karl... Best wishes to you and your family Karl.. Sending you hugs from all of your viewers from around the world.. Lot's of love. Take care. Never give up or give in Karl..... I hope Mr modi will help you. Get in if he really wants India to go forward then he needs to fix this.. You are not any sort of traitor.. Your promoting harmony and peace and love... Stay safe stay strong... Love is our future peace is our wish.. Brothers in life one and all... Jai hind from Pakistan.
Beware that there’s a lot of miss information in the comments. When it’s safe for me to do so, I’ll tell you why the Govt. came for me (with proof). But right now if I do that, my blacklisting could be extended. Plus we’re in the Delhi Hight Court fighting, so that process must happen first.
✍ Please help us by signing our petition www.change.org/BringBackRock
Ep 2. "Asking the Indian High Commissioner for HELP When My Wife Has COVID 😷" czcams.com/video/x2_iMUn22AE/video.html
For more information, read my blog post blog.karlrock.com/why-i-havent-seen-my-wife-in-269-days-blacklist/
पिछले २६९ दिनों में मैं अपनी पत्नी से क्यों नहीं मिला #ब्लैकलिस्ट blog.karlrock.com/why-i-havent-seen-my-wife-in-269-days-blacklist-hindi/ (Hindi)
Will sign it for you Karl
We are with you karl
Literally indian government to Karl : Nhi chahiye ji
We all are with you karl
We will do it
I'm a Japanese. I'm living in India for past 4 years. I know my limits in india, One can't protests against or favour for govt by having tourist visa.. I think u would have heard about jakob , A German who was studying in IIT Madras had forced to leave india bcoz of his participation in Anti CAA protests. Same goes for U.. Now don't act like a victim. Being a foreigner u should have more concerned about the visa policy of India.
Wishing u would meet ur family ❤️
Yaa bro he is just playing victim card and not showing whole story
Agreed Bro...Watch some of his old videos.He is Fighting with Poor sellers and labeling them as Scammers...this is totally against there self respect what if his son sees that Clickbait
Edit : thanks for you're likes and care
彼と彼の妻は反インドです彼の古いビデオはすべてそう言っています~
There are more problems government should be concerned of. . . . They are busy building ram temple collecting 5000 crores. 😕😕 when people are dying of Covid they are scamming people by blocking all other vaccines and pushing funds to Serum institute .. they wont touch currupted politicians assets , they wont touch currupted government employees assets ,, they wont touch swiss bank list (promised in demonization but never done 🤣) . We the people just believe that some day some miracle will happen like they show in movies some youth taking over country but it wont happen at all. 😕😕
But atleast tell karl the reason
6 years of civil services preperation, yet she didn't stop you from going into the protest.
It's her fault. I think she encouraged him. Karl maybe innocent.
She encouraged him because her father is a congress leader...
Very good point
very good point. it's totally looks like it's her fault under congress' influence
Did he post a video of him going?
he participated in Protest in india. According to law, no foreigners is allowed to participate in any protest in indian territory. Its violation of visa rules.
Though i do hope ban is lifted on him.
so government should tell the reason atleast if they have done so. why silent on the reason. atleast his wife can go to court to see reason is justified or not
Then this should have been in the reason to ban him. And most of all he is husband of Indian National. Even if he is not Indian, Indian government should think it twice and warn him before banning him. He is not shahid afridi or daaud abrahim. He is a gentle person, loves India, trying to make India better. But why is our government behaving like Kim Jon and Hitler? Government should at least behave professional and ethical, unless government had admitted that they lack self-respect and it will continue
MHA Already released a statement . Do check it.
Thats main problem...if anyone do anything against this government will face consequences.
@@jojo-nu9rl you okay.?
1.He went to restricted areas where no one is allowed to visit
2.He participated in anti Caa protest (any person who does not have Indian citizenship is not allowed to protest)
3.He did business activities in India without having citizenship which is illegal too
He broke so many laws what did he expect
Yes, I got one logical comment.....
I was all in support of you Karl, but these questions needs to be asked:
1. Did you participate in Anti CAA protest though knowing you would violate Visa laws as a foreigner?
2. There are rumours you got blacklisted cause you do business, work, earn money on a tourist visa, which is also not allowed?
You should adress these questions asap, else this video will not age well.
Home ministry has replied... Check twitter
Simple thing is he violated the visa norms
Acc to Indian law, no foreigner is allowed to take part in protests.
Similar laws are there in countries like Australia.
Let’s hope this issue gets sorted soon and he gets removed from the blacklist
@@lucky-go4vp
Link?
If karl cannot interfere in indias internal matter then how one can say ab ki baar trump.sarkar....dont.mind
@@mranonymous8333 ❤️du do you even understand the difference between protests and elections ?
I am a foreign in India and I have been living in India from the past 7 years, I never participated in any protest. ..but Karl Rock participated that's why you're blocked 😅😅😅
he knows very well..
@@eodum13 he's acting like a victim
@@denzelheden4256 yeah he think he can broke the law of india what if i broke the law of new Zealand they will kick me out that's the same thing what indian govt did..and he talking about indian culture by eating beef 🤦♂️.. stop making fool people
I had told him about how some of his words sounded like a biased person but he had deleted my comment there. Karma speaks.
@@tirthankarmodak absolutely
You can get a Billion petitioners to sign but the law will not be reversed, unfortunately.
Your wife, as a civil services aspirant, has not read Indian polity.
Karl Rock participated in a political movement in a foreign country, a direct violation of visa norms. He along with his wife participated in the Anti-CAA protests in December 2019. Karl Rock well deserves to be black-listed. I stand with my Government.
And shouldn't be
@@RKS740 no not even court
@@RKS740 dude..but what about his wife n family..they court can do that if required
@@RKS740 and we are humans and we make mistakes that doesn't mean someone's family will be destroyed for that🙏🏻🙏🏻
Good step by Indian government, you violate Indian visa rule.
Don't try to defame and interfere in internal matter of any country.
You can protest here after getting citizenship. Few years ago a Bangladeshi actor got booted from India and got blacklisted because he was participating in political rally. Sorry for you and your wife but Govt need to protect the interests of us.
Sahi bole ap azadi jada he de gaye hai in logo ko 😡😡😡😡
@@vaishalidhawak304 aag laga die poore Delhi me aise log jab sab support kr rhe the un jhadiyion ko .
Itni himmat buland unki aise logo ke karan hi hui thi
@@watchman6825 dude , kuch bhi . Her wife and he went their to show solidarity
Modi govt is nothing but a piece of shit........india need to get modi out from power.....
What kind of "interest" would that be then?
My brother was deported from Australia, because he was driving a taxi while he was on a student visa, it was my brother's fault and not the fault of the Australian government, people need to follow the rules of the land.
But this guy married a local 🙄
@@hss2119 law is law
If the law of the land is to bootlick political leaders then shame on that land.
@@hss2119 That does not make him an Indian Citizen, he was staying in India on a Visa which has certain rules. Educate yourself mate :)
@@Aayushrn25 in normal world when you marry citizen of some country you are getting citizenship trough that marriage, but anyways everybody knows India isn't normal country....
His father in law is in opposition party in government, thats why he is doing protest against CAA... without knowing, that same law is in NZ where he is from.
That's obvious... His father in law is an active participant in FARM LAW PROTEST
Now I understand thanks bro
@Jock Ma but not for a foreigner on tourist visa...!!
@Jock Ma he is here on a tourist visa, in terms it's mentioned that someone on a tourist visa cannot take part in protests or other similar activities.
@Jock Ma 1946 and 2004. At least fpr foreigners who are on TRAVEL visa and not PROTECT visa. I hope it's clear. :)
I am from bhutan, I was surprised to see what Karl was doing on tourist visa with traveling everywhere, running protest, supporting parties, etc etc… a tourist visa has limitations internationally. If it was for bhutan .. this stuffs are instantly not permitted canceling the visa. But I was amazed that’s easy go in India. I think his multiple protocols overlook took off his visa. Besides he is nice guy.
lol. fuck india
@@samir98753
India fucked him instead.
@@samir98753 why are you mad? 🤣
@@BigBrotherTheWatcher1984 - A poor country. lol, you are a supporter of poor and ethnic minor cleaning countries like Endia?
@@samir98753 look at how pathetic u r, calling others poor as if u r the richest person of the world but i guess no one taught u its ur appearance which matters more than "how rich u r", if u "rich" people have no manners and respect for others, then it's better to be poor instead and we can see how well u r representing ur "rich" country which is unfortunately poor in teaching manners and respect.
India just banned you for a year. Imagine if you did the same on a tourist visa in US, UK, Saudi, Qatar, Russia, China, Iran or North Korea etc..
Good benchmarks for comparing India? Eh
@@beefcakeharsh even if it's us you will be detained and you will be forced deported to India
@@beefcakeharsh the common comparison is country rules here.
Its just for a year? I think its for a long time. Then its ok
Rip Karl rock 🤣
A senior retired Supreme Court judge Markandey Katju has to say
“However much one may feel sorry for him because he has been unable to meet his wife for one year, the External Affairs Ministry action cannot be faulted. He broke the law. If one comes on a tourist visa one cannot do business. To do business in India one must obtain a business visa.
Grant of visa is the government’s discretion, not a right ( unlike a passport which is one’s right, as held by the Indian Supreme Court ).”
Agree with this
which business he is doing ?
What is his business?
@@Vishal-nu7iw published a book and also participated in political rallies of Manishas father
@@Vishal-nu7iw in uk or usa even if u visit Iran usa won't allow that he traveled pak through dubai for more 100days
seems like majority of Indians stand by their Govt decision
No, not at all!
@@whytemonkey6969 he said ''majority of Indians'' and yes it is true,
The people who doesn't stand by the government's decision in this case are in the 'minority'.
yes
@@seansb2137 In this case, yes it's true...
I'm sorry for writing that,😅
Yes ...We are....At the end Security of my country only matters.
"Your involvement in a protest in India" violates the Visa Rule as per the information received. Anyway we know how honest and open minded you are. Feel so bad for what happened to you. our support is with you. stay safe and hope you return home soon.
Who is "we"?
its interesting how much he has done for india, and foreignors coming to india and yet they do this. But what do you expect?
why werent the police following that same law for corruption, taking bribes etc?
@@FM-dm8xj what do you think would happen if foreigners randomly started coming to india and taking part in protests and supporting political leaders the situation would become worse .karl is not the only foreigner who can come he is a good man but not everybody is imagine if people from pakistan or another country with which we dont have nice relations come and do something like this it can even lead to riots
According to Indian law No foreigners can participate in Any protest in India but you did it in During CAA protest .Probably this is the sole reason behind your blockage. Otherwise you are a good man and you never show India in a Bad light so we are hoping that govt will lift ban on your entry
Ghanta , why he goes against India , ban is completely justified , waise hi hamari govt boht slow hai ,
This is the only reason
Well that could be the reason, but these are just speculations, it is better to wait for the government's reply.
@Rizz Wizz pata nahi hoga toh bata du action li gaya tha 😂😂. Aur chutiya difference samaj foreigners aa ke protest nahi kar sakte koi bhi country mai.
@Incredible India but we can see your agenda , if you never understand a person when he makes almost 90% video about India and show us amazing places in India and show his love about India in Pakistan you can't accuse someone with fake CZcams account 🙏
It is a law of every country not about india but also of USA Canada UK France Israel.. As a foreigner u can't protest against the govt of any country..
Well actually all the countries you mentioned EXCEPT USA.
Tu khud 10 jagah gutka thukta hoga aur red light tod kar apne aap ko champion samajhne wala law ka gyan de raha hai😂😂😂😂
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 abe sale
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 thats illegal but if you are not part of a country he is a serious criminal ,try to create rift is serious offence and you know what happened after that protest ,how many people died .
@@PeaceOffmate in usa also you can't go extreme,
this might be result of protesting against CAA, foreigners aren't allowed to participate in such protests, even a bangladeshi was sent back due this.
Brother we as an Indian citizen now have no right to protest against the government so why did karl do this and that too on tourist visa?
@@ashutoshsaraswat2138 yes
@@ashutoshsaraswat2138 kuch bhi , kissan kya Mars mai baithe h , itne din se ,??
Yes bro and he also hurted our sentiments on patanjali ad
Made joke of our gaumata
@@ashutoshsaraswat2138 Khalistani bharat ka jhanda nikal k fek diye aur kitna right to protest chahta hai bhai ???
Petition signed. IMHO, after watching a number of your anti-scammer videos, I would have thought that India would be very proud to have an adopted 'son' like you, on their side, in the never-ending fight against corruption and exploitation - against their own people, and against people from other Nations. In fact, they should be rolling out the red carpet for you, and for your brave wife. Good luck and nil desperandum.
You don't understand the situation, do you. Atleast you signed it by yourself
Wer were U when he being a tourist joined campaigns which is against the law
Wer were U when he talks about religion of that country being a Tourist
Wer were U when he makes 8-10 lakh inr/ month on the videos he makes in India
If he loves india so much why can’t he respect the rules
U can’t pull this shit in other countries
They’ll debarr a person for a lifetime
So plz don’t listen to one sided stories & make ur opinions
I think he is digging his own grave by talking all this nonsense online
Basically he is saying how shit Indian govt is for blacklisting him
For doing watever he is doing
Which he knws he can’t do even in his own country !
@@dr.shivanikadam6815 part of the same propaganda machinery instigated by emotional manipulation mate ? Lol.
Me too buddy, this all has happened on purpose with an agenda against Karl mate, and all of the replies you're seeing rn, are mostly triggered after they watched some XYZ creator's vid about Karl.
How can one possibly think of separating a husband and wife, very nasty indeed.
@@dr.shivanikadam6815 You shivani should be withdrawn Your doctor title and thrown into the muds of Assam for being so intolerant!
MHA official: Karl Edward Rice, a New Zealand national, has been restricted from entering India till next year due to violation of terms and conditions of his visa. He was found doing business activities on a tourist visa and also violating other visa conditions
Link? Or imagination on your part?
@@Gappasappa hahah 😂 court ll clear na hehe
He was blacklisted because on December 19,2019, he posted a ground report video wherein he participated in the anti-CAA protests against the ind govt.
Foreign nationals cannot take part in political movements because foreigners who are here in india under tourist visas are not allowed to process against laws passed by the ind parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of foreigners act,1946 and foreigners (amendment) act 2004
Ghante ka link dega bhai ye, itne saal tourist visa pe reh sakta hai koi
Bhai ke dimag me tatti thi or usne yahan nikal di
@@Molly_On_Molly tourist visa pe reh sakta hai, business nahi kar sakta
I have seen his videos ... He participated in anti CAA protest ... That's a violation of Indian laws ...
That's true...Even though I admire him so much, I completely disagree with what he did...It was a law meant to give citizenship to persecuted minorities of Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan...he and his wife had no business to participate in that protest....!!!
That's true bro
Tu khud 10 jagah gutka thukta hoga aur red light tod kar apne aap ko champion samajhne wala law ka gyan de raha hai😂😂.
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@seldom44 CAA will go, it has no constitutional standing, u have amend articles 14 and 21 for it to be valid, which haven't been amended.
The reality is he break law in india as as a foreign person he participated in anti caa protest which volitaes foreign act 2004 thats why he
Has been blacklisted by government
he will delete the comments...tweeter pe gaandh phaadi jaarahi inki
He should be. He shouldn't be involved in such things. You deserve it bro. You should have taken cared of indian laws before getting involved in such protests etc.
@@karanrajtomar9206 Educated ?
@@karanrajtomar9206 😂😂 accha hai inpe bharosa mat karo ye Anti india propaganda chalta hai hamesha
@@vaishalidhawak304 yessss
I’m sorry for what you are going through I was born in Mexico back in 2006 I became a US citizen. Now im struggling for resident applications for my wife I totally understand I personally don’t know you but I feel for what you are going through take care of yourself and your family as much as you can
You were born in 2006 and you're married now? Anyway, thanks for sharing your story.
Lmao what married at 16?
y’all stop. he meant he was born in mexico and later in 2006 became US citizen.
@@pinkaxolotl2446 Read again,he said back in 2006 he became US citizen,he wasn't born in 2006,he became a US citizen in 2006,I guess it's not totally your fault because he didn't use comma to separate the sentences,but still if you use logic you can understand what he meant
Hey mr karl rock, Imagine I An Indian guy goes to New Zealand on a tourist visa and starts business activities which is prohibited by law there also takes part in anti government protests which is also
against the law of New Zealand.
Now government of New Zealand blacklists me on these grounds and I start playing victim card to gain sympathy. Please judge accordingly. 😑
Bruh please shut the fuck up. Guy has been seperated from his wife for nearly a year, he isn't playing the victim card here, he's genuinely distraught. Of course you would have no concept of that given your complete lack of empathy in regards to his plight. He has tried to appeal, and reach out for answers and has been treated with a cold shoulder. I don't know how true it is that he was conducting official business without the proper certificates, but even so, people make mistakes. He is nowhere close to be considered a criminal, and as an Indian myself, I could say he probably loves the country more than most indians I know lmao.
@@shadkunt9387 bhaisahab 2008 ke baad kisika bhi visa approve nahi karte agar vo pakistan jake aya hoto
@@shadkunt9387 your statement is not convincing enough. It might sound good but for a matter of fact he was also a part of the Anti CAA protest so no one gives him the right to do all the things on tourist visa. Kandhe pe bithane ka yeh matlab nahi k koi kaan mein mutne lagega. Sorry if my words sound harsh but this is the reality now a days if the scene stays same no one will value the words and laws of India.
Agreed 👍
@@shadkunt9387 He should've thought of his wife before doing stupid shit. Is it really so difficult to follow the law? The action of the government wasn't even unreasonable. Any other sovereign country would've done the same.
He was found doing business on a tourist visa and has been barred for one year; his visa has been cancelled and in addition to that when it comes to visa norms will newzealand government allow indians to work on tourist visa if yes than I'll get tourist visa . Playing emotional card does not change rule of a country
Logic point👍
True
True said doing business in tourist visa is not allowed . This is the same way how British East India company came in.
morover he and is wife prejudice could be seen in a video where she said this right wing govt has made law on the basis of discrimination in religion if muslims want the citizenship of india than what was the purpose of giving pakistan and bangladesh to them????
What business? What are you talking about
A Pakistani here, family is really important but you need to follow the rules. Its high time tourists start acting like tourists. If you'll start participating in political activities the indian government has every right to ban you.
What you are saying is very wrong. Imagine you are banned from the country you live in, where u have your family. Karl is not a tourist! And he has every damn right to participate in political activities. Im happy I live in germany where this could never happen, because the government isnt working like its the 18th century. I feel bad for karl and hope he can get back to a normal life.
@@lennarts6170 lol FYI he is on tourist visa.. Being on temp visa and if u go against the govt not only India even Germany will ban people.. and I want to tell you one more thing NZ (from where Karl originated ) have stopped migrants on temp visas to come in which caused lots of split families..
🔥🔥
@@lennarts6170 nothing is wrong he said right who are you to speak against anyone's God culture ..who the hell are you. .!! So it's better to kick such person out of the country ..garbage should be dumped outside of the house so we are cleaning ..so before speaking nonsense about India now think 100 times.
India is has become a fascist state to promote hate and violance.
Really sorry to hear of your situation Karl. I have followed your travels through India and I can attest that you truly have contributed to make India a better country by your love and devotion for this place and your wife and family. Hope things clear up to allow you back in India with your family where you belong.
the problem was -he participated in political protest,started bussiness and all that under tourist visa,, which is not allowd and is against the law,,,,so yeah he kinda deserved this 1 year blacklist
It's sad but I'm a Immigrant myself and when you go to other country you have to obey their laws.
Yeah, rule of the land is supreme and should be obeyed.
Yess no country allow foreigner to come and protest against countries internal matter
@@Arvind_Patel23462 Maybe except the US. If you're latino you can come and protest against immigration law without fear of deportation.
@@aloksharma9255 what rule did he break?
@@majidmohd100 why does he have to protest? It's India's matter
With few research on CZcams, I saw a video where you and your wife were part of CAA protest. Most probably that's the reason behind of blacklist.
yes
But his wife is indian citizen. She have right to protest
@@sidhu7753 Who's talking about his wife, idiot?
@@udayvatss just gain your knowledge on constitution.
@@udayvatss 🤦♂️
We should not believe in any emotional message and rather check the facts (Business and anti CAA protest) of him getting blacklisted.
He knows what he has done yet he's like "I dunno why and they not telling me UwU" 🤷♂️
He should've cleared that.
Has any action taken place against politicians like Kapil Mishra that integrate roit in delhi. The answer is no
@@trixway5255 brother they aren't foreigners.. Have some common sense
@@ayusharyan3899 Bro doesn't that made karl an easy target then. I don't think he shouldn't be punished so much, he has help many tourist and showed much respect to this nation
@Book Of Wines amit shah is a mulla? 🙄
I've lived here in Thailand for 35 years as a foreigner married with children. The way to survive visa-wise is to keep your mouth shut, watch what you do, don't piss anyone off and especially don't criticize the royal family or the government. Asian countries' governments HATE vloggers they are considered political dissidents and not wanted because they do not mind their own business.
I really want to go to Thailand. How expensive is it there
India pretends not to be a tin-pot dictatorship. We are the world's largest democracy, and so we are supposed to act like it. However, if you insist on following the path of the authoritarians, then I'd prefer a government like our East Asian neighbours have... at least they have their economies sorted. On the other hand, we are stuck with retarded politics and a retarded economy. Let's not get too comfortable living in the Stone Age?
He did not follow the visa rule.
Most countries have same rule.
What are the rules??
@@vighneshpillai7996 as a tourist u cant go to a protest site and suppourt it
@@vighneshpillai7996 even you cannot do business in Tourist visa..but Karl published book in tourist visa
@@vighneshpillai7996 Foreigners who are here in India under tourist Visas are not allowed to protest against laws passed by the Indian Parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and and Foreigners (Amendment) Act, 2004.
False.
Not a single word on CAA ? Being a foreigner he should have never participated in the agitation.
@@dr.umeshhiwase2063 ohk rice bag
Go n shift to ur dream land paxtan
@@siddharthpandey548 😂😂
@@siddharthpandey548 👍👍👍👍
@@dr.umeshhiwase2063 leave immediately if still here
@@dr.umeshhiwase2063 India is far better to stay than Pakistan, north Korea, Afganistan, Syria and China.
I'm a UK citizen and I've lived in China, Singapore and Qatar and, no matter how I felt about the politics of the country, or about the laws, I would never have been involved in anything political, both out of respect to the nation that was hosting me and because it would be likely I'd be kicked out.
yeah the possibility of get kicked from the country is a good reason not to be involved in such things especially in countries with lack of freedom where you can just be jailed and never come out of prison
David, I totally agree with you dude..if I as an Indian was living in some other nation, I would respect their rules and regulations...and Karl should play a bit safe because he is making videos mainly about IND and PAK ....he wouldn't have involved in any political protests of Pakistan...if he were to do that, he wouldn't have returned alive...but filming that anti CAA protest thing is like living as a guest at someone's place and then poking nose in their internal matters and talking about their fights in public
100%. It's basic common sense.
Im in qatar
@@avantikanarvekar4415 Exactly. I've also travelled a lot to the USA and been asked by Americans on numerous ocassions what my opinion of their president is. I've always replied that I'm just a visitor and it's none of my business.
Please remove the black listing. He is such a good guy and doing so much for us. Government should reconsider his decision.
He even violated article 19 as a forigen national he can't participate in any protest happen in india when he was on tourist visa .
@Uchiha ya article 19
Reporting a protest and being a part of a protest are two different things
Sahi hai ...
All idiots want to protest in USA, UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand. PM goes and says Ab ki Baar Trump ki Sarkar ( interfere internal politics ) but if someone says right thing suckers get upset. I say F^CK YOURSELF !!
He should be banned for whole life he can’t protest on our issues
The actual reason is that he was on a tourist visa in India and parallely he was running his business in India. This is against the state of law.
Which business if i may ask?
@@dreamon1643★ selling his book, on his website.
★protesting against a caa nrc, which later converted into one of the deadliest riots in our country's history
★coming to india on visitors visa, and going to the restricted area of india like POK, and also coming under the surveillance of one of the terrorist intelligence agency 🇵🇰
@@dreamon1643 anything more ? i don't have much time to explain this baby questions, if you want to have a little knowledge use internet thankyou
Giving 60% reservation is also against law .What happened to govt.
Nothing else .
Good decision by the govt. First he isn't a citizen of this country uske baad me chutiye ne protest me part liya vaise toh ye gora apne app ko bhohot bada samajhta hai ye.
Who is after world affairs
But karl you should understand indian laws and respect it
Ask for forgiveness and admit your mistake then I think our court is good enough to allow you back
me
What was his mistake ?
Prashant Dhawan 👍👍
I am, I too belive he should know about law of the land and respect it.
Dude he is not been given a reason , if its his mistake he will admit but I guess he never done something wrong but made videos on wrong things happening here
karl... your story seems incomplete man. You've been in India so long, married to an indian...WHY DID you not applied for your indian citizenship...??
What idiot is dumb enough to let go of new Zealand nationality for lowly Indian passport 😂
India doesn’t allow dual citizenship or something
Its because he participate in anti CAA protest..
according to Indian law foreigners are not allowed to participate in any protest..
Not just in india. Can an indian go to New Zealand on tourist visa and poke into their politics?
It's like this any where in the world.
@Ertugrul Gazi Ertugrul Farji 🤣
@supertramp2.0 Indians with Indian Flags had stormed Capitol Hill as Trump supporters, that was also a so called protest, a violent one. Then if the US Government cancells thier visa, you will say that democracy is in danger and when the Indian government does the same you will justify it! Some Indians are blatant hypocrites.
@@gamingforlife1419 ooooo no you just got this sooo wrong ....see USA itself is liberal about this matter and allows foreigners to protest ..soo basically it not against their laws.
But here in India it is against the law ..now hey you can't disrespect the law of a country.
@@saurabhswarnakar6829 How do you know those are temporary visa holders? They could be permanent resident. Good that this guy is banned. He should never come back to India. We don't need him.
Update: Home ministry have replied by saying that he violated Visa rules by doing business activities on a tourist visa. Suspension stays till next year.
Kiya bhai world affairs
@@dulcedeleche000 mai v
@@dulcedeleche000 dhawan sir
Yes bro, tomorrow he is gonna be called out as terrorist if situation goes more tense...
@@zaeemAtif bro he don't have any right to protest in india ...he isn't indian ..
Sources are saying that he was involved in CAA-,NRC protest so wait for the reply from government before you judge government. As per rules and regulations no foreigner is allowed to protest in India due to security reasons.
Earlier he himself posted a video on CZcams, where karl and his wife are protesting in CAA... Later on he deleted the video...now i get it why he deleted that shit
@Sujatha Shriyan yes bro I personally know them they're from my village.
This explain why I’m not seeing your videos lately. Praying for you brother. Be strong and don’t stop.
New Zealand origin vlogger Karl Rock has been blacklisted by the Government of India for violating multiple visa norms," a ministry official told ANI on this day, "He was found doing business on a tourist visa and has been barred for one year; his visa has been cancelled." He also took part in CAA protest which is against visa norms for a person living on tourist visa.
Reason was he was in political protests
What business he was doing ? Lol that's such bullshit
@@sakshamtyagi9652Delhi police station aa jao waha police bategi kya kiya isne
Illiterate spotted
@@sakshamtyagi9652 yaa indeed I agree, violating Indian laws is such a bullshit reason to ban someone. Like its all ok for foreigners to come to India and violate laws and not expect them to either get banned or arrested. Totally fine !
Brother I feel bad for you but you should have considered this outcome before joining the caa protest. Your visa was to travel India and create content but you decide to protest against the law of a country which you don't even belong to. Overall I hope the government will allow you to be with your family once again.
@@tarun1255 go try to question govt
File a case
See what will become of you clown
@@devastator01ful so government is beyond God now?
A legal marriage can be broken by the government? Ye kaunsa law hai?
Besti to beta India ki hi hogi, bhakti kitni bhi kar lo.
Sometimes I feel we should keep rule aside one who loves India should be allowed a chance ..
And we can't forget he has done many efforts in scam related issue..
I hope u get to return soon brother..
@@voyagerx2133 aisa nahi hota dada rule is rule goro par bharosa kar ke hum bohot badi bhul kar chuke hai ab aur nahi scammers kya hota hai inhone hamse he 45trillion loote tha aur ye kutre hame he scammers kah rahe hai 😡🤬
@@vaishalidhawak304 bro he is from new Zealand not from England.
Despite of being his follower I think that he should be blacklisted from the country...bcuz
Foreigners who are here in India under tourist Visas are not allowed to protest against laws passed by the Indian Parliament. Violating the law can attract provisions of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and Foreigners (Amendment) Act, 2004.
Also, it can attract provisions of Section 121 of the IPC that deals with waging war against the Government of India or abetting the same.
for us the laws of our country matters the most don't they ? if INDIA removes his name from blacklist then the foreign youtubers (mainly the reaction channels, street interviewers who are gaining view by using INDIA's name) they all can come in INDIA and start protesting. So this is the reason why I am totally in favor of INDIAN govt. I am bounded by my country's law and would not tolerate if any other person especially foreigners would try to violate them....
Good bro jai Hind 🇮🇳
I think You came from Prashant sir video...By the way..You are 👍👍
But blacklisting is the right choice? He should be punished for breaking the law but not blacklisted from going home to his wife and family.
@@superboobs890 yeah thats what i was thinking . if it was some random foreign guy we would not have cared but he has a family in india and a indian wife so blacklisitng him would be wrong maybe some other way could have been done
Your wife is hard core politicians daughter right? they are from Haryana, opposition party if not wrong from congress. Saw your 22nd Aug 2019 video participating your in laws political rally. naturally she will take congress's line participating Anti CAA protest, but you should respect Indian constitutional rights & Visa offered to you. She also said bad words for Indian god Lord Krishna in your Andaman visit video. We like you & your videos Karl Rock but keep politics away. You are getting involved & victim of In laws politics.
Had a British Indian friend - born and raised in the UK. Someone in his extended family back in India died and he was obliged to travel to India to deal with the affairs of deceased. He could not understand why he could make no progress. The simplest arrangements went wrong. Mysterious obstructions to everything. Incredible last-minute snags. When he finally talked to the family friends there, everything was explained. He wasn't 'talking' to the right people! And, 'talking' there means paying bribes. Lots of bribes. Nothing in India happens without.
I agree. It's a hellhole
"British Indian"
He's either British or Indian. It's like calling Karl an Indian... nope.
@@PhilipMarcYT Sorry, fella. Being American you know little of the British Empire. Until 1947, the country was officially known as 'British India' the army was known, for example as the 'British Indian Army'. So yes, Yankee friend, you CAN be British Indian.
@@alastairbarkley6572 um no you cant be british indian as you yourself said it was until 1947 .also we dont want british related to any part of india other than trade
Reason for is blacklisting is violation of article 15 of general policy regarding visa matters in Indian law. He participated in anti CAA protest in India which is not allowed for non citizens of India.
So he should not be allowed to protest
@@lemao9239 - He is not even an Indian and is getting political in our Motherland.
As a Pakistani, I'm not signing his petition as that may complicate his case further due to similar reasons. I hope more Indians sign his petition in droves so he gets to go home ASAP.
@@ashishsawant122 and what if a foriegner is supporting caa ,, would'nt he be considered getting political as well ,,, everyone is political whether you support caa or not ,, that does'nt mean that its threatning national security ,,,, many indians participate in protests in usa , european countries they dont face such trials ,, perhaps that is what you call a democracy ,,
What? Article 15 says that the state cannot deny access to public services for anyone in Indian territory.
Where is this law about foreigners not being allowed to lawful public assembl that people are talking about?
Sources in the Ministry of Home Affairs said that the vlogger was found doing business activities on a tourist visa, which is in violation of the terms and conditions of his visa. He has, therefore, been restricted from entering India for a year. His visa has also been cancelled by the government.
What are the business activities you did @Karl vai?
What business please tell me clearly
S he shouldn't be permitted to be india
@sahannadinesh ,
Karl Edward Rice(Karl Rock) in his one of the videos he participated in the Anti-CAA Protest.
According to the Indian Constitution, no foreigner can take part in any Protest in India(Protest against any Domestic Matter of India).
I think it would be the main reason why the Indian Govt Blacklisted him.
Due to this kind of reason many foreigner (a total of 5 foreigner) were Blacklisted/Deported/Asked to leave India.
I do not want to harm anyone's sentiment .
It's what I think " may be " the reason.
@@29subhra working and getting money from utube on a tourist visa you cant do its illegal
My sympathy is with you and your family. You are very good person. But one thing you must remember that anyone is not above law of land. You should avoid involving in protests(you have posted a video of anti CAA protest on your channel what you made private later) or involving any business. There should be some reason for what you have been blacklisted.
Modi is the law?
Its a long History that Anti Nationals also do something which hurt sentiments of masses or violates IPC Laws but then either they apologize for their mistakes or they are granted with bail, thats disgusting. INDIA should set a hard example so that it should not be repeated. Everyone ahould respect the law of land ie INDIA !
⚔ Jay Hind !🇮🇳
@@yasirpk2002 are you crazy?
It's such a shame that you break a country's law and still fight against the government ☹
I guess when you are on visa you can't be in any political movement.
Exactly 👏
and the prime minister of india can go to US and ask people to vote for Trump
@@healthopedia2918 if no law is being broken, then it fine. At the end it is about Law of Land
@Ragesh haan bhai yaad hai tabhi trump k haarne k baad poore india ka naak kata di
@@sparshgupta2931 when he broke the law why they haven't given him the reason even after 8 months ?
BTW 6 years of civil service preparation she should have known its illegal for a foreigner to protest against govt under foreigners act and visa term and conditions . This is what you expect least from an aspirant.
Yup bro
He protested on CAA and he is not an Indian
I know this is so bad that he is unable to met his wife. But on a travel Visa he shouldn't have done that.
Hey, would you mind sharing a link of the law where it mentions this being illegal? I’m from Brazil and I’m trying to find it, but unable to. Would like to learn more. Appreciate the help.
Also, Shivam, if Karl is married to an Indian, I’m sure he doesn’t have a tourist visa, but an entry visa or a business one (in case he receives his earnings through an Indian company). He can apply for OCI after 2 years of marriage. Not sure if this law is only for people under tourist visa or foreigners of all visa categories
@@LeticiaNaIndia he actually has a tourist visa
@@LeticiaNaIndia he is on tourist visa bro
He is not Indian , all we know
Let the community decide. 🙂
How did you make bold letters
-You mean this???-
*Or this?*
@@sincerelyyours2694 just by putting star signs * and * before and after the letter *okay* ?
@@sincerelyyours2694
Type star at start and end of text
Like this
* Text *
But dont leave space in between and it will look like this
*Text*
After all the ordeals Karl refers to India as his home. I love how positive he is about everything.
I know how delusional of him.
@Nitin Singh Negi Exactly, make videos on New Zealand. About the Maoris, the indigenous people of New Zealand. A white privlieged guy has no business maligning a country that has suffered so much under white colonialism and Islamic invasions.
@Nitin Singh Negi Why would he make videos about the scamming in New Zealand? His whole channel was based around India.
@@tashidelek5793 That's the past, white people have close to no privilege anymore.
@@heroinuser.5913 Still its the white leftists who wanted to assuage their guilt who came up with their half baked ideologies that led to this situation which is now spread globally. The leftist aligning themselves with the Jihadists, Antifa BLM extremists and attacking their nations. This is a thought form, an energy that is spreading and will have consequences. Karl, like many believe in those fake narratives spun by leftist msm and hence feel entitled to attack India. After so many decades of impoverishment, India now has a strong leader who works day and night for the upliftment of all Indians and development of India and yet fake news persist and leftists and Islamist are working even harder at their agenda.
It's amazing to see so many comments in support of the Indian government and the rule of law. India I am impressed by your citizenry. I hope this situation can be resolved as I have loved and learnt a lot from Karl.
Exactly ❤️💙❤️💙
We all love Karl but the law of the land is supreme... I hope his name is removed from the blacklist soon.
@@aryan_bhat yes he must apologies instead of criticizing..
He has violated atleast 4-5 laws in India.
Even our 💔 is broken but CAA is a serious issue even we faced internal war like situation and read about vishal jood who is in Australia every country does the same
Why did you involved in anti caa protest without knowing it ?
Haven't you read the terms and condition of visa policy ?
👍👍
it's just a way for gaining sympathy for more followers
@@abhakandpal2948 leave the guy alone, he probably wasn't aware of it, from his channel he seems like a nice dude, he's getting rid of scammers, guiding other tourists/indians just imparting knowledge, he's himself learning hindi and haryanvi out of passion and love for the country, let's not downplay his content as something disingenuous without proof.
@@abhakandpal2948 Teri Kyu jal Rahi hai?
✌️
Hey Karl, I'm sorry you have to go through this. I checked your case. The most possible reason for you getting blacklisted is the participation in a political protest.
According to Indian Law, foreign nationals cannot participate in political activity such as protests against the Indian parliament.
This law has been in existence since 1946.
He knows that, he knew it when he went and protested in the first place. Because he started protesting AFTER the news went viral of 5 foreigners being deported for protesting.
That doesn't matter here... What matters is HUMANITY. You aren't standing up for the country, But this MAN did even though he is not from our nation. He is bold enough to fight these silly issues created by these shit things. According to me the only mistake from his side for telling that the CHAI from india is good rather than in Pakistan. This was the only mistake that happened in the recent. AND I REALLY DONT ACCEPT THIS IS A MISTAKE. HE IS STRAIGHT FORWARD WITH THAT. Except this, He was only showing us the thing that what INDIA ACTUALLY IS.... AND WHAT IS ACTUALLY SAID TO BE. NO MATTER WHAT, HE HAS TO BE SAVED.
@@danoldsouza6088 Law is law
@@danoldsouza6088 Democracy doesn't mean no law
The External Affairs Ministry has said he came to India on a tourist visa but was doing business in India. That is illegal. If u come on a tourist visa u can’t do business in the host country. For that u need a business visa. And also some visa rule violations
My gf also foreigner and I'm living in her country.. Hope u can meet with ur loving family soon
Pp bro❤
Karl: I'm a foreigner but want to protest against Indian govt.
Govt: Nhi chahiye ji! 🤣
Why can't a foreigner protest against India? When Indias were being harassed in Australia few years ago thousands of Aussies came in support and demanded justice for Indians. Do you have to be a German only to criticize the wrong doings of Hitler. I don't think so. Get your brain evolved a bit if you can.
@@sidpanjr Because protest should be made by indians we don't want external influence in our society as it is very dangerous for our country.
@@sidpanjr very true
@@sidpanjr Because allowing foreigners to protest over Indian laws in India can have serious consequences. Imagine Bangladeshis or Pakistanis hijacking protests in India and driving the protest according to their own narrative. Most of the democratic countries have such rules.
@@amitarya5690 thousands of NRIs protested against Trump...no one called them "external influence" because expressing your opinion is not influence and I believe anybody can do that irrespective of citizenship or not.
Ministry of external affairs has mentioned that you were doing business activities on tourist visa.. That's why you've been blacklisted
He didn't receive any notice from EAM. So the blacklist is not valid.
What business clearly state pls
@@29subhra merchandise sale most probably
@@29subhra report and letter is on TOI go and read by yourself
What business activity kindly explain....making videos and creating content never came into the official definition of business activity...
Nowadays situation
Karl rock- I want to come india
Government- Nhi chahiye ji
😂😂
Good Joke....
But not suited in this moment 👎
😂😂
😂😂😂
😑😑😑
@@renjithmathewpsc don't offend,calm down bro
Just saw your 16 December video and now this video. I can't say I can relate to you 100%, yet seeing you, a random CZcamsr out there whose videos I just discovered a couple hours ago, going through such terrible pain. Just breaks my heart. Not a person of religion, I wish you and your wife to be reunited again and live happily ever after from the bottom of my heart. Stay strong, Karl and Merry Christmas!
Don't break your heart , he violated the rules and playing a victim card. You must educate yourself before encouraging such
@@mrnobody9762 - why don't you educate me. What rules did he violate? It's not like that sort of information is ubiquitous. That's like me telling you to educate yourself about the starfishes destroying the coral reefs around the world, which are contributing to global warming.
@@sztypettto brother he had violated many rules
@@vaishnavisharma1503 , I am genuinely interested in knowing what are they. Since you seem to know, what is it?
@@sztypettto With tourist visa, you can't take part in any political matter and he had done this multiple times, he had join in protest too and FOREIGNERS ACT 1964 AND FOREIGNERS AMENDMENT 2004 u can read about this😊
Karl : Let me get back to India..
Indian Government : Nahi Chahiye ji 🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂🤡👍👍👍 ma chod diye bhaiya ji aaptoh
You must not make fun of him
@@tommyshelby9873 Kyun? Aapke mama hai?
he is really in tough situation not a time for jokes
@@anoopmohan7727kyo bhai mama hote toh mazak nahi udate kya....kisi ke pareshani per Hasna jindgi bahut jaldi jawab deti hei.....smaj jao...
Will the New Zealand government allow if an Indian citizen joins the movement with the people of New Zealand on the internal affairs of New Zealand!
Yes. They are not communist
Yup they will allow unlike india lol they r not fasist like our leaders 🤣
Damn true bro ❤️
@@axizz100 ask your government 😂
@@anxiety6230 it's not about fascist brother it's because if we allow foreigners to protest they will overtake the protest and mold it in their own way
Indian: *Working hard to leave india*
Karl: *Working hard to come in India*
🤣bro common..
Same pinch🤣🤣
He working hard to leve her own country
You working hard to defame your country.
@@abhishekshukla579 you working hard to prove his right statement wrong!!
Wow beautiful love story. Hopefully you reunited with her ❤
The act which will give citizenship to persecuted Sikh, Hindu, Cristian,Jain,Parsi minority of paxtan, Bangladesh,Afganistan. Why to protest against that ?
Please learn some English first.
Fuxk english man its not our national language why should he learn?
@@raxxit. You should learn english though
@@osman01003 it's not my mother tongue. So whatever I know it's enough for me.. Anyways thuje padosi ki abba bolne ki thalab hogi,muje Nahin.
@@osman01003 try to be a human first.
Those people who don't know the issue please do some research...And then sign petition 👍🏽👍🏽
What petitiin and what issue?
Help me out.
well if you know then you can explain it here. No offence though. Just curious to know.
@@randomcodes4183 he has flouted visa rules. His long stay in Pakistan didn't help his cause either.
@@randomcodes4183 this guy karl rock is a foreigner for indian soil and he was found protesting against the CAA bill passed by the govt. He uploaded anti caa videos in twitter n social media and as per the indian law foreigners are not allowed to protest or interfere in indian affairs. They are coming to india for tourist purpose so visit have fun and get the fuck out of here... as simple as that.... so does every other country in the world does it. He can go anf make videos in new zealand. But the problem is that he will only get views and content in india. His earning will stop if he is not allowed entry in india. He can make scam videos for the countries across the world, why is he being specific to india? Arent there scams goin on in other countries?
@@randomcodes4183 He went in Anti - CAA protest in 2019 with his wife...but according to Indian Law a foreigner cannot join a protest(riots)...If you live in India married with a Indian girl doesn't mean you are a India citizen...
If we go to any country and violate their visa rules , we will be blacklisted , not only you karl bhai. So you should accept your mistake and hope for the best❤
Curious to know what rules did he violate. Anything concrete on this?
@@DraakMD CZcamsr Karl Rock Visa Violations:
Not Allowed under
X1:
》Taken Part in Anti-CAA Protests
》Made Video & Spread Propaganda
》Hurt Religious Sentiments
X2:
》Published Book 'Indian Survival Guided'
》Visited Restricted Area
》Coverage of Anti-CAA Protests on CZcams
@@DraakMD is ne scammers ki phar di thi tab unko ohati pari hai.
@@DraakMD He started doing business stuff on tourist visa, which is pretty much illegal for almost all the countries in the world.
@@JohnCena-ch3lc what's wrong with taking part with anti CAA protest?
Apart from it religious propaganda? Really 😂?
Literally people in India are taking anything on thier religion and call it propaganda.
Get a life and leave people alone.
I am happy for this guy. He should be banned in Asian countries.
A guy from foreign land, speaks our language, married to an Indian, promotes tourism in india, more Indian than the actual Indians who just wants to leave india is being treated like this ? SHOCKED
Really sad
Look what happens to him is wrong,but he was clearly not promoting any tourism after he got married.
He is a defacto spokesman of his father in law party and communists.
There is term national security stop getting shock
India is only good at shooting itself in it's foot. 😂
@shablan abdhul hameed it's too much fun dude 😜😜
“FOREIGNERS ACT,1964”
And
“FOREIGNERS (Amendment) ACT,2004”
Just don’t blindly listen to anyone
Copy paste
@@ragnarlothbrok2150 HAHA ok i agree
What does these acts state ???
@@rishabhchauhan.03 so you told people not to blindly listen to anyone and then copied a yt comment?
@@Navvye In order to make people like you aware of the norms and laws inspite of blindly supporting and opposing anyone on emotional basis.
Good job india government 👍🏻
Respect the law of the country you are a foreigner not an Indian . Happens to indians all the time in foreign countries never gets highlighted 🙄
Absolutely.
Ekdum sahi reply diya aapne, foreigners expect much more from India but when it comes to the treatment of an Indian in foreign, their misbehave is normal.
Imagine what China would have done!
Ke number reply
Bro tu sahi ho sakta hai lekin...jaroori to nhi ki other countries jo karti hai wo India bhi Kare.... Warna kya farak hai fir India me baki se....
You don't have right to interfere in domestic issue and protests before doing such acts plz read foreigners ACT 1946, and 2004 and you voilted this law India is Very powerful man.
Lol yeah really powerful , blacklist foreigners and arrest Indians for protests.
@@changumangu4660 tujh jaise log ho country me to kaise badhega desh 😭
@@changumangu4660 lol , if foreigners are allowed then bangladeshi migrants will start to protest on freedom of west bengal.
@@abhishektandon8373 Where did I say let foreigners protest but if Indian government is so strong in implementing laws as in original comment then why half of the MPs and high profile scammers not in jail.
If only this much attention they would've given to some public issues.
@@Purana-Pappi Atleast mere jaise logo se desh aage na bhi badhe to pata to chalega ki desh ruka hua hai, Varna aadhi janta ko India superpower 2018 se dikh raha hai .
foreigner are not allowed to participate in protests against the laws of india passed by the government....& he is on tourist visa he is not a citizen of india.....he participated in many protests in india like caa nrc in delhi....
same law is in every country tourist has to behave like a tourist not like a citizen of the country in which he is traveling
Alright. If you think a tourist cannot be part of protests in favor of indian citizens, then why are the right Indian not doing the right thing. Why a tourist has to be the eye-opener for you guys?
@@deepakkaushal7476 nhi chaye ji
@@deepakkaushal7476 Brother, if there is ever a problem in your house, the people of the neighborhood come to settle?
but still government should give the reason to him that you done so so and so thats why blacklisted. atleast his wife can go to court seeking justification
@@chandranshpandey1929 reason diya h Ye tourist visa pr h to koi bhi tourist Indian protest m part nhi le skta ye tourist visa k rules k khilaf h to ab rule toda h to bugatna Pedga rules are rules
Govt should be flexible with rules and see the work he is doing.
Overall he has done more for India than most of the Indians.
There is always a reason behind everything, If my government has done that , i am 100% sure there might be a strong reason behind the decision taken.
He broke the law. A person can not join protest on tourist visa.
Well the reason could be the vlogger is praying to get more significant. This makes great drama and the masses are starving for drama. Getting banned might be the goal of some people. I am not assuming that it is his goal. Its just fascinating to think that it might be. He gets to to start a new chapter and his Pakistan vlogs are interesting. So why was he banned?
your government wants to imprison u lol
@@Majk246 he joined anti CAA protests being tourist. If he would have Indian citizenship then Rock might have been different and he might be chilling in Delhi having samosas but alas law is law
Lol i don't believe that about any government,.. but i think they're right about this one thing
If Karl had participated for any protest in Pakistan 🇵🇰
He might be get into the list of 40k missing Baloch people ..
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Well said bro 🤜🤜🤜🤜🤜🤜
Right
😂😂😂
you can only compare with pakistan..thats your level.
this guy amazes me with so much patriotism towards foreign country... lol
sir you shouldn't had involved in indian domestic issues. because according to Indian laws no foreigners have right to participate in any kind of protest.and your not the only one who has been blocked. and also CAA was very sensitive topic. for participating on same topic 4-5 people's visa are blocked and sent back to their native nation.
you should have behaved as laws suggest. we all hope you will meet your family as early as possible.(we all know for a human family is everything)
but on future follow law's and respect laws.
Leaving aside politics and all
It was a blatant abuse of law and as we know
‘ignorantia juris non-excusat,' or 'ignorance of the law is no excuse,'
This thing was bound to happen.
Let’s hope that this issue gets sorted out quickly and he is able to return to India
Because as it is Pakistan isn’t very safe
I don't understand why CAA has to do with this, by that logic Tarek Fatah, Francois Gautier etc should also be blacklisted for openly taking stands and taking part in a political discourse while being Canadian/French Citizens?? Or is it just that those who oppose the govt will only be subjected to the law? Anyway blacklisting Karl Rock will only affect tourism in India. It's our loss because of this government's pettiness
@@ObitoUchiha-uq3pf do u think it's because of Central gov ? There are some rules and if u violate it u will be punished he published a travel guide book which is business only and u can't do it with a tourist visa also he took part in protest which he was not supposed to do so the consequences are here.
protesting against discrimination is not someone's internal matter. grow up. Human rights is not Domestic issue.
@@CerealKilIer 🤣 It is internal matter indeed , he is on tourist visa and it violates law made by baba saheb amedkar , now u can file case against that law if u want to change it
Protesting and doing business activity is not allowed, if it was Vise versa new zealand govt have also done the same, always respect immigration rules of the country.
Court will decide that.
@@beefcakeharsh you really think the courts will go against the constitution for you weebs?
@@beefcakeharsh librandus we had enough of your.. can't you get it..
@@beefcakeharsh librandus KI Mama kaaa...
@@beefcakeharsh "I'm a liberal. The law of the land doesn't apply to me. Pee poo pee poo." Cope.
Do make a video on how New Zealand government has been ripping of money from Indians and not allowing students and valid work visa holders to return back
Get lost man, Don't know where the New Zealand is 😂
@@unseenvideos9447 the newzealand ! lol
It had demonstrated against CAA, so it became a criminal according to Indian law.
You mean Indian immigrants to NZ right?
How selfish do you have to be to complain about not being allowed to cross boarders in the middle of a global pandemic - especially when the country in question has done so much to contain covid and stop any community spread and the country you're wanting to travel from has the worst numbers in the world.
signed and shared! Best to you and your families Karl.
I Would Simply Advice To Remeber These Things For Future -
1. Don't Participate In Any Kind Of Political Protest Untill You Are A 100% Citizen Of India
2. Follow The Visa Rules Strictly & Get A Bussines Visa If You Wanna Do Bussines In India.
3. Don't Promote Cow Slaughtering Because It Hurts Religious Sentiments Of A Large Group.
Ji shaabji
Respect Indian Law India will take care of u as simple as that
YOUR GOVERNMENT IS CORRUPTED WHAT LAW?
@@flowflow14 its u r perception not fact
@@flowflow14 He broke many law, like doing buisness and protesting on tourist visa
@@flowflow14 the lord the which is made by Babasaheb Ambedkar that foreigners can,t protest in India
U dumb
Finally GOI respoñded saying Karl is blacklisted because he was engaged in business activities while being here on tourist visa!
Political Activities.
You are violating the norms and expect government of india to do nothing???
Why were you engaged in a business activity?? Any answer to this???
@@sahildhanani4282 If you have noticed, he didn't raise voice against Pakistani blasphemy laws or terrorism while in 🇵🇰. Neither did he participate in Political Rallies there. He only raise voice against India and Indians. Why?
He participated anti caa & NRC rally
@@vishalvinayan3375 Maybe this can be one of the points but nothing from GOI about this....
Bhai teri himmat ko maan liye👏
Karl, you were blacklisted because you and your wife participated in anti CAA protests, and according to foreign act of India, a foreigner can't participate in protest in India.
Not only his wife but he himself participated
Guptaji aap apna dimagh kahan phek aaye ??
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 jaha milogay waha laat kahogay
@@cosmicgyan6732 😂👍
@@cosmicgyan6732 👍😂
When UNO reverse card gets used in real life 😂
Nahi chaiye ji
Roflmao
You want to know why you are black listed ? Here’s the reason, you were involved in the anti CAA protests, which is in clear violation of the foreigners act of 1946 and 2004, you were in violation of your visa, you can’t be participating in protests on visiting or travel visa, you did this to yourself no one is to blame, you also made a video on it yourself you self incriminated yourself, why don’t you tell the entire story? Being separated from your family isn’t really a good situation and I pity that, but sir you did this to yourself. Even the judiciary won’t be able to help you, you clearly violated the laws and you know it, don’t play the victim now. And also make the video public so that people can see why you were black listed. Your wife has all the right to protest she’s an Indian citizen, you aren’t an Indian citizen. In your video, a times now reporter comes upto you and asks if you’re covering the protest or taking part in it, and I quote you “ taking part in it...... both, taking part and covering it”
👍👍
Is it?
Exactly!!....at least respect the laws of the country you make cantents on....
FYI he wasn't protesting damn it. He was just spreading awareness. Am talking about the scams
Yeah that's right
For those who are supporting him and abusive Indian government...Plz do some research they are not treating him in an awful way...He had violate many laws that you can't do with tourist visa...So if you don't know both sides don't support anyone without actually knowing the truth...No hate to him, he is not a bad guy but he shouldn't do that. But I do not know why he haven't mention what he had done. He took the rules granted when you visit any country you should follow their rules💜
According to Indian laws a foreigner can't participate in protests. So I support GOI.
Yes I support my government and my constitution
And you are feeling proud on that shame on you.
We need to scrap this law from our constitution
@@ashutoshsaraswat8350 You feeling shameful doesn't matter, nobody is above the law of the land
@@meritoriousgamer apparently their ways have diverged, even this government is not following the constitution. :P
I've enjoyed a lot of your content, but you need to be careful as a Visa holder. If you violate it you can be deported. I am on Visa in the USA and I'm always careful to not break any rules. All govts have the right to enforce it.
I hope you unite with your family.
And let this be a lesson for everyone as well.
right! I heard that Rock is on a traveler visa but he did engage in some business activities. This might be minor but you can imagine what will happen if you do the same in the US.
He was in anti-national protests 😂
@Seymour Dix haan yaar. Dekho bechare ki shakal pewdiepie se bhi milti hai
"Before someone is added to the Blacklist they're meant to be given the reason, and time to reply. I wasn’t." These are the words of karl rock, looks like he knows the rules but tried to be more indian than indians.
@@rokkamvikas i feel ya' hahaha
People who says that they Worship Constitution are also supporting him for breaking the Law
Went to restricted areas of defence where
even Indians not allowed
2Published book without business visa 3participated in CAA-no political activity allowed including journalism without visa 4CAA protest video deleted
5 visted Pakistan through dubai not through india for more than 50days (intelligence alert)
6Participated in election rally
Court won't care abt emotions. Countries like USA will deport right after if they see Iran visa. Lol we Indians are still colonized doing same mistake again seeing others with sympathy
Exactly hypocricy at its worst.
@@chaitanyasaikumarnimmala6392 correct bro
@@chaitanyasaikumarnimmala6392
yes agree
Problem is haters have been so brain washed in the last 7 years that they have lost the discrimination power now to know what is right and what is wrong. They just want to stand up against the government even though they end up looking anti national.
I am so sorry that a very nice person like you is banned.. You are a very intelligent and brilliant person. Making great volgs. Promoting India. I have come to love India through your volgs.. I'am a Pakistani. I am so proud you can say j'ai hind... And you are proud to say it.. If Indian government reads this posting please please give Karl his visa to go to India.. He and his wife are a big plus for you and all of us.. With much love to our Indian brothers and sisters... Please understand Karl and his wife's position.. They are great advert for India.... I think we should all write to the Indian government and embassy's in our country's to help Karl... Best wishes to you and your family Karl.. Sending you hugs from all of your viewers from around the world.. Lot's of love. Take care.
Never give up or give in Karl..... I hope Mr modi will help you. Get in if he really wants India to go forward then he needs to fix this.. You are not any sort of traitor.. Your promoting harmony and peace and love... Stay safe stay strong... Love is our future peace is our wish.. Brothers in life one and all... Jai hind from Pakistan.
One should know about
“FOREIGNERS ACT,1964”
And
“FOREIGNERS (Amendment) ACT,2004”
Just don’t blindly listen to anyone
हा अंधभक्त आईटी सेल😂
जिसके साथ गलत हुआ है वो खुद यहाँ आके बातें बोल रहा है और तू dont blindly listen to anyone की बकचोदी पेल रहा है🤣🤣🤣😂😂
@@anwarcontinue He's not giving full info. His wife mocked Lord Krishna. An Arab nation would've seen riots but India is still humble to only ban him.
@@raya_ashok ye law tere congress ne banya tha
@@anwarcontinue
Toh wo bhi isi ki baat kar raha hai chomu. Usne bola aur tune maan liya galat hua hai.