We need a public apology ASAP, imagine Essa’s daughter coming across this video. Just deep it subhanallah, we need him to remove this video ASAP. I feel your frustration brother Ali.
If that's the case we need a public apology for Ali Dawah, because Shamsi said "there is something going down online between this atheist AND the gentleman, this guy Muhammad Hijab" He was referring to Brother Hijab as the gentleman. I'm no defender of Shamsi, but if you gonna go demanding public apologies for backbiting from him, then maybe you should stop with the double standards and demand Ali Dawah for slander....
@@Tameeeeeem exactly!! It was so clear that he said "and gentlemen"... Not "atheist gentlemen". It's really appalling what this ummah has come to. It's like we are finding pleasure in dissing people and fueling hate. Yes the brother should have not mentioned anything at this time, but to go as far as saying he was speaking I'll of the dead is beyond me.
@@maggyhamada2560 what people don't seem to understand is that Ali Dawah does not speak or behave in real life like he does in his videos, because I've come across him a few times in person and the only vibe I got was this "rude boy" one, however that's my opinion, people can choose to ignore it or whatever. The point being, it's an internet/CZcams persona used to gain more popularity among the masses,(again, over emphasis he does not talk like this or even do all these hand gestures in real life, this is an over exaggeration on his part). we know so many successful ( in terms of monetary success) CZcamsrs whose online personas are nowhere near their actual persona, everything is hightened, exaggerated, all for show, making it more "entertaining" in order to gain more views/likes. In the end of the day, Allahualem, people can believe what they want, but he is over exaggerating, and is slandering, knowingly or unknowingly, and should be careful posting videos doing so, where thousands of people it seems blindly follow and back him, and he'll be the one responsible for hate delivered to another person, let alone another Muslim...
Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.” If he happens to attend a gathering and his Muslim brother is being mentioned with sin or being degraded, then he defends him as he would defend his own honour, because his brother’s honour is like his own. Sālih ibn Fawzān al-Fawzān
Haven't watched the video yet. But let me just say that talking bad about a muslim who died is against the deeds of salaf of the ummah let alone the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). You can't just call yourself 'salafi' and do that.
@@muftidavidwoodthetimetrave2592 You guys are thinking that Shamsi did something wrong. He corrected his mistake just like how Imam Shafi did with Imam Malik
@@SaifulIslam-uu9xz let's put it like this: A root of a following path in islam. To many this path may come over as extremist and controvers. I'm not here to judge, I'm just telling you how it appears to outstanding people. In quotes like "was he a salafi?" People show there disbelieve to other roots of following in Islam
“Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects, you O Prophet, are not associated with them in anything. Their affair is left only to Allah and He will inform them about what they used to do.” (Al-An’ām: 159)
Christianity also has sects Catholics Protestant orthodox evangelicals any other religion which has a sect ? Muslims seem more disunited over sectarian issues than any other religion and this is just making them more weaker and making there opponents stronger
You guys need to listen to what shamz said ... and not be encouraged by what Ali is doing which is catching your emotions in mid air and Turning you all against shamzi
Haven't watched the video yet. But let me just say that talking bad about a muslim who died is against the deeds of salaf of the ummah let alone the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). You can't just call yourself 'salafi' and do that.
@@lewis8332 bruh in other videos you were saying Christian stop spreading lies I know you are Christian that's why you are supporting nabeel Qureshi I lost one
Abu Hurairah (RAA) narrated, ‘The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) asked, “Do you know what backbiting is?” They replied, `Allah and His Messenger (ﷺ) know best.’ He said, “It is saying something about your brother which he dislikes.” Someone asked, *‘Supposing that what I said about my brother was true?’ and the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “If what you say about him is true you have backbitten him and if it is not true you have slandered him.”* Related by Muslim.
Let the brother be, he's dead. His sins, or wrongdoings are between him and his Creator now. I don't understand why everyone is attacking a humble servant of God? It makes no sense.
Zi I have never heard the salaf talking negatively about dead Muslim at a funeral. We all have differences in fiqh so why does Shamsi think he has the god given right to force his understanding to others like Essa who had a different opinion? What Shamsi done is haram as it fits with what the Prophet said about not speaking Ill of the dead. So anyone in Shamsi’s little congregation that steps out of line and has a valid but opposing view should now realise that when you die, you’ll be dishonoured and spoken about as if you were less of a Muslim than them
I personally knew Isa and I can definitely tell you he was one of the most beautiful brother you could come to meet. He was Salafi in the sense that he did follow the prophet and the sahaba and he would be the first to admit that
M43k GAMING which the salaf did so we can call ourselves salafi. The prophet saw said we are ahlus sunnah Wal jamaah i.e a Sunni. Sunni=salafi but I don't mean these dirty cult members.
Caster Gil of course it's enough to be called Muslim but there's nothing wrong with being called salafi as the salaf followed the Qur'an and sunnah better than all of us so don't bash people for calling themselves salafi.
Imagine, Reading "Quran" and understanding each and every single letter with deep meaning. May ALLAH grant us such a wonderful knowledge of Quran. Ameen sum'ameen! 😇
@@Xbox76751 Thats not the point bro. Everything isnt binary, black and white. No respect from Shamsi here... isnt really sincere. Why wasnt these vids done before? or after a little while?? You're so simple minded. Didnt you watch this vid, had some good points. The greater picture will be that Shamsi is coming across as the bad one therefore it does more harm. Use your logic mate. No respect for his wife?? His daughter?? Bro be smarter. Theres ways you do stuff and Shamsi couldve done it better. Thats the point.
Aisha reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Do not abuse the dead, for they have reached what they put forward.” In another narration, the Prophet said, “When your companion dies, leave him alone without speaking badly about him.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 1329
Assalamu Alykom, Let's start with this hadith " Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 1931". Shamsi has publicly spoken about brother Essa and if anyone is going to reply to his claims then it should in public too. However, if Shami kept his opinion to himself or among his peers then there is no reason to reply to him in public but I'd rather give him a call and talk to him. I hope you understand!! I do not know brother Ali, brother Shami or brother Essa personally. But I am here to defend brother Essa in particular and his family who might to listen to their son who is deceased is being slandered. Subhannalh. To Shamsi, 1) I just want to tell you that speaking/ slandering about a deceased brother who also contributed to dawa and subhanAllah Allah passed away in away that me and you wished to be in his position. May be you don't (only Allah know our intentions) but trust me wallahi I wish to be in his position . 2) His respected family will be listening to what you are saying, subhanAllah. You shouldn't speak about this at this difficult time for his loved ones sake at least (Only two days since Janazah, subhannAllah). Wisdom is rizq and I ask Allah to bless me and you, some of the wisdom that Allah blessed brother Essa with. 3) Shamsi not only salafies will enter paradise. We all have mistake and you made a plunder already but you know what we all make mistakes. To brother Ali Dawa, only Allah knows what's in your heart but I respect you for defending brother Essa in public because he was slandered in public. Again, I never been to speaking corner or participated in any debate and I don't know most of the brothers there but I know for sure who I will be avoiding to learn from. Let's try to give dawa without affecting dawa it's self. May Allah (swt) grant our brother Essa highest station in paradise. Amiin
The salaf did not label and call themselves salafi. We all hope that in our strive to follow the Qur'an and Sunnah that we are on the path of the salaf and Allah keeps us on this path until we die. Ameen
I pray to God that he guides us on the straight path, as he tells us to pray in the Quran. This is what your prayer should be!!! Always ask God to guide you on the straight path itself, not the path of any other person. Not your parents, not your teachers, not anyone else. I love my parents, I love my teachers, but at the end, we are all human. Do you think the Salaf prayed for God to guide them onto their own path?
@@mrqas2000 they remind me of the Christians going around saying they are "saved". Wallah, I am muslim, thats it. Inshallah, I follow Islam as our beloved brought it, that's it. Simple as that. I follow Allah and His messengers, period. I am Muslim with no prefixes or suffixes
I saw his video. What did he do other than give him dua? He explained in the nicest way possible some of his mistakes and clarified them, because people will still watch the old videos. What's wrong with that? Can't you guys have a mind of your own instead of blindly following Ali's slander
@@CaSama He didnt do it when he was alive, but only cared after he dies and can not deffend his postion. Now when his followers remember brother Esa, they won't think may Allah increase him in rank, or may Allah be pleased with him, they will look at him as a misguided and will look at his legacy negatively. What mighty evil did the brother do that required a video explanation about him while he is dead?
@@ammarahmad5757 I don't think he made him look evil at all. He said a lot of Duas and spoke very nicely of him and made it clear he just wanted to clarify some of the mistakes he made in his dawah. Do you think it's right Ali and hijab selectively cut out parts to make it seem like he was back biting?
@@CaSama How did Ali cut out parts? He showed the beginning of the video entirely. What was he supposed to show the entire 20 minutes of it? Again, why wait until he is dead, and can not respond. I do not care how euphemistic he sounds, anyone would sound that respectful when the guy is dead besides Abu lahab. Even non muslims payed their absolute and unconditional respects to him. From his perspective brother Esa was misguided before too right. If he was so much worried about the truth, he would have done it when he was alive.
@@CaSama Also, Why wait until now? why not when he was alive? If he is so much on the haqq why not refute Abu layth? Why was he getting chummy with Raj and talking about Ali's behavious? Why did he even allow it coming from a known islamaphobe who misrepresents and is foul with the muslims all the time? He can be as euphemistic as he wants but it doesnt take away from him being egotistical. What Ijaza does he have to be speaking about, making takfir about, and calling brothers misguided? He is a laymen as well as Ali yet you blame Ali and dont recognize that he is a convert of only 5 years, and you hammer him and call him misguided becuase from your perspective he has a lack of knowledge! What kind of "speak the haqq" is this where you refute so many muslims, yet you won't even refute his leader for praising Obama. Or you wont refute the clear and open devaint Abu layth. What crime or act of kuffar, or innovation did Ali, Hijab, or brother Esa did to be made videos about them. How can you let minor differences in fiqh and aqqeeda drive a wedge between the muslims? Nobody is saying we should align oursleves with the shia or with the non muslims, but at this rate, there isnt going to be an ummah left to unite with your logic. There is only going to be a couple of people in a room who are "on the haqq".
This is seriously disgusting- the nerve to insult and bash a dead man who can’t defend his action he clearly see himself above others- let the creator judge the actions and take action.
MKIS he said it to his face and said that in the video so either you just took what brother Ali said ignorantly and ran with it or you haven’t listened to the whole video shamsi put out either way as a Muslim don’t listen to one side of the story ever look at both sides and weigh it up, also I’m not a fan of either of them but as an outsider looking in the brother called shamsi said absolutely nothing wrong. Don’t respond emotionally and let go of any hatred you have you’re a Muslim and muslims are a careful and level headed people. If he lied against him you would have a point, but that’s not the case so fear Allah.
Subhanallah I don't get why they're talking about brother Eesa when he has passed. Be quiet. Keep your comments to yourself. It's over. Here's not here top send himself. May Allah have mercy on this brother and his family granted patience
Its only Shamsi, br Ali is a family freind of br essa and the father called him first. Br ali arranged the funeral so no, Ali can if he wants. Not that Shamsisi tho
Salam alaikum guys, Allah swt says in the Quran 41:34 "good and evil isn't the same, so repel evil with which is good". So instead insulting this misguided cult member, instead praise Brother Essa in comments and social media. Essa was a man of the Sunnah of the Prophet pbuh, he had amazing character and was so kind and good to everyone. Also support his causes for him and his family. www.launchgood.com/essafamily www.justgiving.com/lifevillage anyone who mentions this guys name will be blocked.
Walaykum Salam akhi, I understand your emotions but please don't make it sound like you're basing walaa and baraa around other than Allah and his messenger 16:14
I think its important to know that br Ali was called by br essa dad after his passing, br Ali arranged the funeral w launch good etc. If anything Br Ali was a brother to him so dont comment stupid stuff like "none of you should be talking about him", only S$#% (and no thats not a swear word its his name والعياذ بالله) is to blame here.
Wallahi uqthum billah i loved & respected brother Shamsi big time. Having seen this video & heard the disgusting words he uttered against Eesa, wallahi i've lost full respect for him. Shame on him & on those who believe what he believes & that agree upon his words. May Allah guide them & guide us all. May Allah swt grant us ALL the highest rank in Jannah tul firdous as well as brother Eesa as well as his family & loved ones without reckoning Ameen. What a lovely brother wallahi ! Salute to you for this & defending his honour Akhi Ali ! Allah bless u immensely. Pure & the best of company ! If brother Eesa was alive surely he'd have given you the biggest hug whilst tears fall from his eyes
@@abdulrahmanalenezi6068 My beloved brother. When one can't show condolences & support towards a dear muslim brother who's just passed away but instead pulls out his mistakes & disagreements with him that's real sad. Whatever he believed or passed away upon is between him & Allah. We should make dua'a for the beautiful brother, speak of his true beautiful character & akhlaq, pray for him & show love and support towards his family & loved ones during this such saddening time. Like brother Ali said.. I'd have made Dua'a for you Shamsi if u had passed away & prayed for nothing but good for you and by Allah that's the way of our beloved ﷺ who even stood up for a Jew at his uneral سبحان الله
“Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects, you O Prophet, are not associated with them in anything. Their affair is left only to Allah and He will inform them about what they used to do.” (Al-An’ām: 159) Salafi this Salafi that.....SubhanAllah, the brother is not dead for a day and his character is being questioned by hyenas smh! Allah mustayn, i used to respect brother shamsi but not after this May Allah s.w.t forgive brother Esa, have mercy upon him, widen his grave and grant him entry into Jannatul Firdous. Ameen ya rabb
Brother Essa’s death tells us all about the person he was. He passed away in the last 10 days of Ramadan, and the cause was covid. So he was a shaheed who passed away in Ramadan. If it was in the day time he was probably fasting as well. Subhanallah What a way to leave this world. It is a hadith of our beloved prophet (S.A.W) that a person will die the way he lived. And he will be resurrected the way he died. Brother essa إن شاء الله will be amongst the special friends of Allah and إن شاء الله he will not be questioned on the day of judgement آمين
Why did he feel it was necessary to mention this after he had passed if it was so important surely he would have said something when he was alive this is poor and low of s*****.
This needs to stop. A Muslim is a Muslim. Salafi, hanafi, Shafiiee, Malakee, whatever school of thought you follow, you are a MUSLIM just as Allah calls you. Stop creating divisions.
Thank you. Someone finally said it like it is. If only we could all think like this instead of dissecting each other's school of thoughts and who the 'rightly guided' is. May Allah guide us all and keep us on the path of MUHAMMAD peace be upon him. Ameen.
It's ridiculous, even Surah Jinn verse 11 fits perfectly "There are among us some that are righteous, and some the contrary; we are groups having different ways (religious sects)." I came across this verse yesterday and look at such a perfect example of this verse, it's hard for Muslims like us who are trying to learn about Islam, then you have the risk of getting involved with the whole sectarian bullshit and this whole group of people who keep dividing the Muslims.
I saw a video of Shamsi telling other Muslims about Mufti Menk, Zakir Naik, Nouman Ali that they are not this that and they are this that. That day he lost my respect.
What of all he said is wrong? Shamshi always says, if you are looking for answers follow the sources. Those you mentiond are not sources. That's all he said. They are not sheikhs. He said nothing else.
So do you respect someone who slanders?..... because it's clear Sh**si said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman. So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Sh**si says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no?
This hurts my soul at the deepest level. I'll write more on this topic later - but mashallah I'm very proud of you for making this video and getting your thoughts out, brother. May Allah grant Eesa happiness and barakat in the next life. May Allah grant his family strength, good health, safety, and success. Ameen. Allah Yerhamo
Does it also hurt your soul to the deepest level when one brother slanders another?.. because it's clear Sh**si said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman. So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Sh**si says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no? Yes I say, Sh**si because Ali Dawah apparently wants to block anyone who mentions him by name on the comments....I wonder why 🤔
Sorry Ali,, but Atfer i watched lot of videos for both of you, Shamsi is on the right path. This is deen not a game, you cant speak without knowledge, if you make mistakes someone have to correct you . U know how many time he said in the video May Allah forgive him, So because he said gentleman he is on his side, cmoon man yo can do better than that
I don't understand Shamsis logic? Everyone will have made mistakes in this dunya? But why make a video about it talking about a man's mistakes after he is no longer with us? What's the logic?
SAA and didn’t Allah say in 6:159; “Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do.”?
SAA so what happens to the many sufis who have passed away in Makkah and medina in the holy mosques in sujood while in prayer and their janaza is read in the holy masjids by millions especially in the time of hajj or Ramadhan??? Are they going to hell according to you???
Seems after the Prophet dies people manipulated the Koran for a power grab. These sects bullshit is worse then Hindu caste system or Nazi Race blocks. Grow up all off you
blad90 well then they must be pious to die in that state or maybe it’s just Allah swt’s mercy on them, so this so called saved sect lot need to relax and stop with the arrogance like how iblees had
First of all rest in peace to issa and my heart goes out to his family, from my observations at the park the way issa delt with issues inside and outside the community was second to none, the dawha that he gave to non muslims will be a big loss to the community as he was such a gentleman, he was polite kind and gentle in his approach no matter how heated it got in debates the world is gona miss you😔
Funny how in all his videos he has so many books to make himself look pious. May Allah swt grant Eesa the highest rank in Jannah Aameen🤲🏻 I pray we all have friends who protect our name after we return to Allah🙏🏼 aameen.
@@Samina_787 I'm not defending him, but in the second part it's clear he said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman. So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Shamsee says
I've defended Shamsi in the past even though he doesn't require any of us to do so. However to call people out for being ignorant or uneducated upon having just lost their life is insensitive to say the least.That being said, let's see if pride takes precedence over humbly admitting ones mistake with a sincere apology at least to his family.
no way i didn’t think it was him i saw the thumbnail and i was like nah it can’t be him to be backbiting i literally was just watching his videos of him disapproving shias , converting people etc 😳
when Muhammed hijab said that ibn Taymiyyah (who is dead) that he made mistakes why does nobody make a video about that the answer is because they are on a witch hunt for the Salafis . what did Shamsi say that was wrong except he will not promotes some of the things that brother Essa said.
He didn’t make an entire video out of the blue to talk about ibn taymiyyah did he? Was brother esa a scholar who had influence around the world? Who had books that were accessible? So then what’s the point in talking about Esa’s mistakes after he died? That’s like talking about some random Muslim guy 1000 years ago that’s not known.
Assalamu alikum brother thank you always for reminding these advices during ramadan. I was outraged what that brother was doing but thank you for posting the video and reminded me about the adab of our Rasool Sallalahu Alaihi Wasalam or else I would have regretted during this ramadan and the day of judgement by giving my good deeds to that person. Jazak Allah Khair. Maasalam. Love you for the sake of Allah from Bahrain.
" Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 1931".
brother Ali, I think you heard wrong in the last part, brother Shamsi said " An athiest and a gentleman, or a guy, Muhammed Hijab" he didn't call the Athiest a gentleman, rather he was calling brother Hijab a gentleman.
who are they to talk about him like this , whatever he is , is between him and his creator no one has the right to say anything about him, astaghfirullah ,may Allah swt Grant our brother the highest place in janah and grant his family sabr ameen. guys remember brother essa in your prayer.
The funny thing is Shamsi is unqualified and ran away from Br essa رحمه الله when questioned about this. Just another case of triple S guys... Saved sect syndrome For a unique case of Quadruple S just add S at the end Edit: cant say his name fear of being blocked by br Ali 😁
Nah nah...there are many "salafis" but not alot that actually follow the aqidah and the characteristics....we don't call ourselves salafis... were ahle hadith and Ahlus Sunnah...these so called people who act like salafis and bring us down with arrogance are no better then any other sect.
Muhammedibnyaseen they are praised by the scholars of ahul sunnah this dude haven’t even studied the books of the salaf. May Allah bless spubs I never met these brothers but they call to Islam the the salaf was upon. It’s so clear!
Mashallah Ali Dawah Enjoin Good and Forbid Evil. Your definitely standing the truth but your right someone is dead already just leave him alone is best
I only knew brother Ésa for a few days. And Alhamdulilah he was shining from Noor and was always smiling. O Allah please widen Ésa’s grave and enter him in to your paradise. Amëën
After many years I looked you up on CZcams. But have been saddened to learn the infighting which has been going on for the past year or so between you and other brothers. And it breaks my heart to see that none of the brothers are holding back their emotions. @alidawah it is important to be tolerant and forgive if other brothers are misguided or doing things wrongly. This whole fighting between brothers shows our disunity in a country where its outmost required. Salam.
He died in Ramadan, he has achieved a status of someone higher than a martyr, he's passing away in Ramadan has a status higher than a shaheed. Also, he passed away in Ramadan, that's enough said. Hadith No: 3925 Narrated/Authority of Talhah bin Ubaidullah Listed in: The Chapters on the Interpretation of Dreams that two men from Bali came to the Messenger of Allah (saw). They had become Muslim together, but one of them used to strive harder than the other. The one who used to strive harder went out to fight and was martyred. The other one stayed for a year longer, then he passed away. Talhah said: "I saw in a dream that I was at the gate of Paradise and I saw them (those two men). Someone came out of Paradise and admitted the one who had died last, then he came out and admitted the one who had been martyred. Then he came back to me and said: 'Go back, for your time has not yet come.'" The next morning, Talhah told the people of that and they were amazed. News of that reached the Messenger of Allah (saw) and they told him the story. He said: "Why are you so amazed at that?" They said: "O Messenger of Allah, the first one was the one who strove harder, then he was martyred, but the other one was admitted to Paradise before him. The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: "Did he not stay behind for a year?" They said: "Yes." He said: "And did not Ramadan come and he fasted, and he offered such and such prayers during that year?" They said: "Yes." The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: "The difference between them is greater than the difference between heaven and earth."
That is not the case. Rather what this means is that the gates of Paradise are opened to encourage people to strive hard, so that they can enter it, and that the gates of Hell are closed, so as to encourage the believers to refrain from sin, so that they will not go through these gates. That does not mean that the one who dies in Ramadan will enter Paradise without being brought to account; rather those who will enter Paradise without being brought to account are those whom the Messenger (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) described when he said: “They are the ones who do not ask others to perform ruqyah for them, or believe in omens, or use cautery, and they put their trust in their Lord”, in addition to their doing the righteous deeds that are enjoined upon them. End quote. Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saalih al-‘Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him).
The man died. He never harmed anyone he invented people to islam and after he dies you're like "some of the mistakes he made are...". Come on man you know the Prophet pbuh would NEVER condone such behaviour.
I’m actually in shock, I did not realise shamsi was this way. This was so wrong on so many levels. Justice will prevail. May Allah have mercy and peace be upon brother Essa. Allah’humma Ameen.
Ali I think you need to address the issue of salafism and how they made a cult about misinterpretating the way of the people of the salaf. The people of the salaf are not the issue it's this cult that's the issue.
Essa bro was a really beautiful soul, whenever I saw him in PARK, I was feeling a great soul and pious person. I really miss him. May Allah increase his reward. I think Mr. SH***i, we love you please don't do this to Bro Essa. (Sh***i) you have decreased yourself. I am sorry for your attitude. It is a kind of arrogance.
Always wondered why I liked both their dawah and why they were never together because united they would have been stronger! Thanks for this Ali I really appreciate this clarification!! A*
@Denzo Dridz sorry but no I will not watch Shamsa video. He decided to do a video when brother ESA didn't even spend 1 night in his grave and on the 27th of Ramadan. To me that is a disgusting act.
@@OMAR-if9kb Calling someone a deceiver that means you got a pass to jannah khalas no more questioning to you after you dead straight jannah make istegfar my brother ask for repentance.
Salaam Brothers, you're all doing a wonderful job for Islam around the world please try to unite with all the wisdom you have. Don't fight each other . If someone among you is not having the right behaviour try to advise or just ignore him . For those of us who are following you we would like to see working together.
I just don't get it. We sunnis follow the Prophet and the Companions anyway so what's all the fuss about being a salafi?? These people are taking these things too seriously, just be laid back and enjoy yourself.
Ma Sha Allah, brother Eesa is getting rewards even after he died. Imagine the amount of muslims the other brother called to Islam, the Qur'an he read and all the prayers he prayed, all his fast will In Sha Allah go to Brother Eesa on the Day of Judgement.
He mention a whole lot of nothing in his so call clarifying his mistakes. It seems like a whole lot of backbiting to me which make me question there sincerity why did this person wait until eesa is dead to ask this person for a so call clarification of a dead man? And all he had to say was we advice him he had many mistakes. Why choose not to address it when the man is alive? It is jealousy due to believers and non Muslims praising him and speaking if his good character
Jazak Allaah Khair Zi you spoke the Haqq there's a difference between Shamsi speaking with ILM and the emotional baseless negative responded he's getting may Allaah guide the Muslims akhi perhaps you should change your pic of the statue
Zi I think you and the people you follow are hizbis it’s clear and as the morning ☀️. The scholars have clearly refuted the individuals you look up to in your hizb why you don’t abandon them And stick to the haqq and not men? Because in your heart it is a disease. If the livestream wasn’t about him the brother shouldn’t have been mention at all. Besides, no one said the lecture was all about him but a segment of it was about him
No one knows when will a person die. and it is too late to address a living individual public mistake when the person has died already, death will always be unexpected. How could someone wait for a person to die just to point out their mistake? That sounds absurd because the waiting person could be the one dying before the other one too by an unexpected possibility. If there is a public mistake of a Muslim person that he or she has not clarified before they died, then someone has to do the job for them so the people will not unknowingly follow the mistaken advice. People following the advice of a deceased brother can affect the deceased deeds. Just like how a Muslim person who built the mosque but then died, for every person that goes to the mosque, prays in the mosque, performs the Ramadan, and reads Quran in the Mosque which the deceased person has built. Indeed that will be his ongoing charity even if he has died. Passing of the deceased's correct Islamic knowledge is also an ongoing charity.
Shin Sekai Animationz they still didn’t clarify what mistakes he made.secondly does those mistake required to be mention in public and refuted openly? Brother how conveniently people want to ask and inquire about someone when they was dead. Yiu gonna have mistakes when you die does that give someone the right to talk about you ?
Brothers and sisters , we are fasting. if you have watched this video dont carry on back biting after and write bad comments about either Ali or Shamsi or anyone else. Let's not let our fasting go to waste (advice to myself first). If your really concerned make dua for everyone. May Allah guide us all. aameen.
I have never seen brother essa real life but in videos at speakers corner and I have never seen him get angry and all his videos he is always smiling, May Allah swt grant him jannatul ferdous
Ali dawah, this is my request that show the video first then talk.. I couldn't get what he is speaking in that video as you simultaneously interrupting😒 either you speak or show us the video..don't do both at the same time. Uf
it's clear Shamsi said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman. So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Shamsi says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no?
I didn't know the brother personally but from a few videos i saw of him in the park he was well mannered guy.May Allah 4give us of our short comings & grant him jannat firdous & may Allah give his wife & daughter good in this life & the hereafter. Ameen.what a beautiful soul he was.
We need a public apology ASAP, imagine Essa’s daughter coming across this video. Just deep it subhanallah, we need him to remove this video ASAP. I feel your frustration brother Ali.
Who's we? This isn't ANYTHING to do with you at least say his family..
Etc etc
If that's the case we need a public apology for Ali Dawah, because Shamsi said
"there is something going down online between this atheist AND the gentleman, this guy Muhammad Hijab"
He was referring to Brother Hijab as the gentleman.
I'm no defender of Shamsi, but if you gonna go demanding public apologies for backbiting from him, then maybe you should stop with the double standards and demand Ali Dawah for slander....
@@Tameeeeeem exactly!! It was so clear that he said "and gentlemen"... Not "atheist gentlemen".
It's really appalling what this ummah has come to. It's like we are finding pleasure in dissing people and fueling hate.
Yes the brother should have not mentioned anything at this time, but to go as far as saying he was speaking I'll of the dead is beyond me.
@@maggyhamada2560 what people don't seem to understand is that Ali Dawah does not speak or behave in real life like he does in his videos, because I've come across him a few times in person and the only vibe I got was this "rude boy" one, however that's my opinion, people can choose to ignore it or whatever.
The point being, it's an internet/CZcams persona used to gain more popularity among the masses,(again, over emphasis he does not talk like this or even do all these hand gestures in real life, this is an over exaggeration on his part).
we know so many successful ( in terms of monetary success) CZcamsrs whose online personas are nowhere near their actual persona, everything is hightened, exaggerated, all for show, making it more "entertaining" in order to gain more views/likes.
In the end of the day, Allahualem, people can believe what they want, but he is over exaggerating, and is slandering, knowingly or unknowingly, and should be careful posting videos doing so, where thousands of people it seems blindly follow and back him, and he'll be the one responsible for hate delivered to another person, let alone another Muslim...
czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
Rest in peace brother Eesa. May Allah grant him jannah ameen
Ameen 🤲
Deen Mia ameen
Ameen
Deen Mia Ameen
Ameen
Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.”
If he happens to attend a gathering and his Muslim brother is being mentioned with sin or being degraded, then he defends him as he would defend his own honour, because his brother’s honour is like his own.
Sālih ibn Fawzān al-Fawzān
Very beautiful wow
Haven't watched the video yet. But let me just say that talking bad about a muslim who died is against the deeds of salaf of the ummah let alone the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). You can't just call yourself 'salafi' and do that.
brother shamsi knows better than you
so don't teach him islamic knowledge
@@arshadmalik4619 wow. Everyone has knowledge that the next person doesn't know. That is the definition of arrogance.
@@muftidavidwoodthetimetrave2592 You guys are thinking that Shamsi did something wrong. He corrected his mistake just like how Imam Shafi did with Imam Malik
Was he a salalfi? For goodness sake , the brother has passed away, it doesn't matter what he was , he was a Muslim brother of the deen!.
What’s a salalfi?
Nvm I think I know it’s a “sect”
@@SaifulIslam-uu9xz If you don't know, don't assume. Read up on it, it's better for you.
@@SaifulIslam-uu9xz let's put it like this: A root of a following path in islam. To many this path may come over as extremist and controvers. I'm not here to judge, I'm just telling you how it appears to outstanding people. In quotes like "was he a salafi?" People show there disbelieve to other roots of following in Islam
Kamal Hussain yeah I know hence the I think
“Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects, you O Prophet, are not associated with them in anything. Their affair is left only to Allah and He will inform them about what they used to do.” (Al-An’ām: 159)
Christianity also has sects Catholics Protestant orthodox evangelicals any other religion which has a sect ? Muslims seem more disunited over sectarian issues than any other religion and this is just making them more weaker and making there opponents stronger
Astagfirallah, our brother Essa should be honoured much better than this
Allah will honour him, thats the best of honours. Keep him in your duas
You guys need to listen to what shamz said ... and not be encouraged by what Ali is doing which is catching your emotions in mid air and Turning you all against shamzi
Essa had such a good character and I aspire to be like him and posses some of those characteristics. How can someone do this !
Haven't watched the video yet. But let me just say that talking bad about a muslim who died is against the deeds of salaf of the ummah let alone the prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him). You can't just call yourself 'salafi' and do that.
@Raheeb Mahmood. He is a brother who used to give dawah. But he is no longer alive.
@Raheeb Mahmood. Wright "esa speakers corner" u will find him on CZcams..
@@cowdyimammurrahtabari973 I got worried there for a minute brother, thought u were talking about me😂, but ye i agrre with you
Instead of listening Ali Drama talking gibberish and making up lies, go and watch this video:
czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
I am seriously shocked, refuting a person who has passed away.
@@lewis8332 bruh in other videos you were saying Christian stop spreading lies I know you are Christian that's why you are supporting nabeel Qureshi I lost one
We talk a lot about dead people but I can see from your perspective from how recent it is
@@lewis8332 but nabeel was a lier. And deceived a lot of people. If you're Muslim, how can you be protecting nabeel? The guy lied against Islam
@@lewis8332 your a typical Christian trying to deceive people. Good luck with that
FakeChaosX Damn😂😂 last time you said you were a christian, mashaallah did you revert to islam?
Abu Hurairah (RAA) narrated, ‘The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) asked, “Do you know what backbiting is?” They replied, `Allah and His Messenger (ﷺ) know best.’ He said, “It is saying
something about your brother which he dislikes.” Someone asked, *‘Supposing that what I said about my brother was true?’ and the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: “If what you say about him is true you have backbitten him and if it is not true you have slandered him.”* Related by Muslim.
U. 2B Was Shamsi backbiting?
Shamsi said he agrees but he says there are exceptions for example, in the case of someone misguiding the mumin, is that form of back biting haram?
In short, backbiting (truth or lie) will give you no good. Subhanallah.
definitely disagree. When a man dies,and doesent know what happened it is still backbiting, whether in public or not.
Let the brother be, he's dead. His sins, or wrongdoings are between him and his Creator now. I don't understand why everyone is attacking a humble servant of God? It makes no sense.
Zi he didn’t do that I disagree he was mainly backbiting
@@aq4356 smh.
Zi I have never heard the salaf talking negatively about dead Muslim at a funeral. We all have differences in fiqh so why does Shamsi think he has the god given right to force his understanding to others like Essa who had a different opinion? What Shamsi done is haram as it fits with what the Prophet said about not speaking Ill of the dead. So anyone in Shamsi’s little congregation that steps out of line and has a valid but opposing view should now realise that when you die, you’ll be dishonoured and spoken about as if you were less of a Muslim than them
because you forget that sins can still add up when you die , same as Hasanat... so we muslims should help each other in every kind of way
I personally knew Isa and I can definitely tell you he was one of the most beautiful brother you could come to meet. He was Salafi in the sense that he did follow the prophet and the sahaba and he would be the first to admit that
We're just Muslim. Why is everyone putting people into categories, does nothing but cause a divide amongst the Ummah!
@M43k GAMING literally means someone that follow the way of the salaf (the salaf are the first generations of Islam. Sahabi and tabi'.)
M43k GAMING which the salaf did so we can call ourselves salafi. The prophet saw said we are ahlus sunnah Wal jamaah i.e a Sunni. Sunni=salafi but I don't mean these dirty cult members.
AB ALLAH calls us “MUSLIMS”!!
Caster Gil of course it's enough to be called Muslim but there's nothing wrong with being called salafi as the salaf followed the Qur'an and sunnah better than all of us so don't bash people for calling themselves salafi.
Imagine, Reading "Quran" and understanding each and every single letter with deep meaning. May ALLAH grant us such a wonderful knowledge of Quran. Ameen sum'ameen! 😇
Ameen ya rabb
Ameen 🤲
Ameen!!!
Ameen, but we did to get that?
Do the reasons, study 📖.
Shamshi is knowledgeable but sometimes you get that "ego" that you know everything.. i love brother Ali and Shamshi both ❤
This made me cry. Why would someone talk about the deceased in such a manner. Ali Dawah, JazakAllah bro.
Sophie's Health and Well-being czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
May Allah give brother essa family sabr
Imagine seeing people speak wrongly about the deceased who's so close to you
Ameen
@Ltown AK beat him twice
Dont need to whoop him again
I used to respect shamsi so much. May Allah have mercy on our brother Eesa. May Allah grant eesa jannahtul firdous.
Wtf are you on about did he say anything wrong about him you clown go to sleep man
@@Xbox76751 wait what did shamsi do wrong?
he's correcting his mistakes
@@Xbox76751 Why are you cursing though?
@@Xbox76751 Thats not the point bro. Everything isnt binary, black and white. No respect from Shamsi here... isnt really sincere. Why wasnt these vids done before? or after a little while?? You're so simple minded. Didnt you watch this vid, had some good points. The greater picture will be that Shamsi is coming across as the bad one therefore it does more harm. Use your logic mate. No respect for his wife?? His daughter?? Bro be smarter. Theres ways you do stuff and Shamsi couldve done it better. Thats the point.
Nadim Ahmed same 😩
Aisha reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Do not abuse the dead, for they have reached what they put forward.”
In another narration, the Prophet said, “When your companion dies, leave him alone without speaking badly about him.”
Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 1329
Assalamu Alykom,
Let's start with this hadith " Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 1931".
Shamsi has publicly spoken about brother Essa and if anyone is going to reply to his claims then it should in public too. However, if Shami kept his opinion to himself or among his peers then there is no reason to reply to him in public but I'd rather give him a call and talk to him. I hope you understand!!
I do not know brother Ali, brother Shami or brother Essa personally. But I am here to defend brother Essa in particular and his family who might to listen to their son who is deceased is being slandered. Subhannalh.
To Shamsi, 1) I just want to tell you that speaking/ slandering about a deceased brother who also contributed to dawa and subhanAllah Allah passed away in away that me and you wished to be in his position. May be you don't (only Allah know our intentions) but trust me wallahi I wish to be in his position .
2) His respected family will be listening to what you are saying, subhanAllah. You shouldn't speak about this at this difficult time for his loved ones sake at least (Only two days since Janazah, subhannAllah). Wisdom is rizq and I ask Allah to bless me and you, some of the wisdom that Allah blessed brother Essa with.
3) Shamsi not only salafies will enter paradise. We all have mistake and you made a plunder already but you know what we all make mistakes.
To brother Ali Dawa, only Allah knows what's in your heart but I respect you for defending brother Essa in public because he was slandered in public.
Again, I never been to speaking corner or participated in any debate and I don't know most of the brothers there but I know for sure who I will be avoiding to learn from.
Let's try to give dawa without affecting dawa it's self.
May Allah (swt) grant our brother Essa highest station in paradise. Amiin
Wa alaikum musalaam
I love that; let's give dawah without trying to affect the dawah!!
Amin
Beautiful response. Ta barak llah.Allahumma barik
nice comment masha allah. ramadak mubaram
Does anyone know to which maddhab do Ali and the whole Dawah Team ?
The salaf did not label and call themselves salafi. We all hope that in our strive to follow the Qur'an and Sunnah that we are on the path of the salaf and Allah keeps us on this path until we die. Ameen
Neither did Allah or the Prophet (ﷺ) told us to divide ourselves into sects and label ourselves! Rather they warned us against doing so.
Suha Iqbal these so called “saved sect” lot are fitna among the ummah horrible people
I pray to God that he guides us on the straight path, as he tells us to pray in the Quran. This is what your prayer should be!!!
Always ask God to guide you on the straight path itself, not the path of any other person. Not your parents, not your teachers, not anyone else. I love my parents, I love my teachers, but at the end, we are all human.
Do you think the Salaf prayed for God to guide them onto their own path?
@@mrqas2000 they remind me of the Christians going around saying they are "saved".
Wallah, I am muslim, thats it. Inshallah, I follow Islam as our beloved brought it, that's it. Simple as that. I follow Allah and His messengers, period.
I am Muslim with no prefixes or suffixes
May Allah keep us on the path of MUHAMMAD peace be upon him until the day we die and even after that. Ameen 💪
Can’t even leave a dead man alone🤦🏽♂️
I saw his video. What did he do other than give him dua? He explained in the nicest way possible some of his mistakes and clarified them, because people will still watch the old videos. What's wrong with that? Can't you guys have a mind of your own instead of blindly following Ali's slander
@@CaSama He didnt do it when he was alive, but only cared after he dies and can not deffend his postion. Now when his followers remember brother Esa, they won't think may Allah increase him in rank, or may Allah be pleased with him, they will look at him as a misguided and will look at his legacy negatively. What mighty evil did the brother do that required a video explanation about him while he is dead?
@@ammarahmad5757 I don't think he made him look evil at all. He said a lot of Duas and spoke very nicely of him and made it clear he just wanted to clarify some of the mistakes he made in his dawah. Do you think it's right Ali and hijab selectively cut out parts to make it seem like he was back biting?
@@CaSama How did Ali cut out parts? He showed the beginning of the video entirely. What was he supposed to show the entire 20 minutes of it? Again, why wait until he is dead, and can not respond. I do not care how euphemistic he sounds, anyone would sound that respectful when the guy is dead besides Abu lahab. Even non muslims payed their absolute and unconditional respects to him. From his perspective brother Esa was misguided before too right. If he was so much worried about the truth, he would have done it when he was alive.
@@CaSama Also, Why wait until now? why not when he was alive? If he is so much on the haqq why not refute Abu layth? Why was he getting chummy with Raj and talking about Ali's behavious? Why did he even allow it coming from a known islamaphobe who misrepresents and is foul with the muslims all the time? He can be as euphemistic as he wants but it doesnt take away from him being egotistical. What Ijaza does he have to be speaking about, making takfir about, and calling brothers misguided? He is a laymen as well as Ali yet you blame Ali and dont recognize that he is a convert of only 5 years, and you hammer him and call him misguided becuase from your perspective he has a lack of knowledge! What kind of "speak the haqq" is this where you refute so many muslims, yet you won't even refute his leader for praising Obama. Or you wont refute the clear and open devaint Abu layth. What crime or act of kuffar, or innovation did Ali, Hijab, or brother Esa did to be made videos about them. How can you let minor differences in fiqh and aqqeeda drive a wedge between the muslims? Nobody is saying we should align oursleves with the shia or with the non muslims, but at this rate, there isnt going to be an ummah left to unite with your logic. There is only going to be a couple of people in a room who are "on the haqq".
This is seriously disgusting- the nerve to insult and bash a dead man who can’t defend his action he clearly see himself above others- let the creator judge the actions and take action.
Where did he insult him, may Allah have mercy on him, and mentioned that he had faults, which btw we all have faults please stay level headed.
Don't be emotional. If he was misguided and has group of people followed him, they have to know the truth wither he is dead or alive
MKIS he said it to his face and said that in the video so either you just took what brother Ali said ignorantly and ran with it or you haven’t listened to the whole video shamsi put out either way as a Muslim don’t listen to one side of the story ever look at both sides and weigh it up, also I’m not a fan of either of them but as an outsider looking in the brother called shamsi said absolutely nothing wrong. Don’t respond emotionally and let go of any hatred you have you’re a Muslim and muslims are a careful and level headed people. If he lied against him you would have a point, but that’s not the case so fear Allah.
Instead of listening Ali Drama talking gibberish and making up lies, go and watch this video:
czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
Subhanallah I don't get why they're talking about brother Eesa when he has passed. Be quiet. Keep your comments to yourself. It's over. Here's not here top send himself. May Allah have mercy on this brother and his family granted patience
Ameen
Its only Shamsi, br Ali is a family freind of br essa and the father called him first.
Br ali arranged the funeral so no, Ali can if he wants.
Not that Shamsisi tho
Salam alaikum guys, Allah swt says in the Quran 41:34 "good and evil isn't the same, so repel evil with which is good". So instead insulting this misguided cult member, instead praise Brother Essa in comments and social media. Essa was a man of the Sunnah of the Prophet pbuh, he had amazing character and was so kind and good to everyone.
Also support his causes for him and his family.
www.launchgood.com/essafamily
www.justgiving.com/lifevillage
anyone who mentions this guys name will be blocked.
Your brother in deen can you explain the story bro idk what happened
Walaykum Salam akhi, I understand your emotions but please don't make it sound like you're basing walaa and baraa around other than Allah and his messenger 16:14
@Michelle S its exactly what this guys doing tho
I think its important to know that br Ali was called by br essa dad after his passing, br Ali arranged the funeral w launch good etc.
If anything Br Ali was a brother to him so dont comment stupid stuff like "none of you should be talking about him", only S$#% (and no thats not a swear word its his name والعياذ بالله) is to blame here.
@Michelle S I agree with this. Please. To be honest please just take down the video. It's not appropriate
Wallahi uqthum billah i loved & respected brother Shamsi big time. Having seen this video & heard the disgusting words he uttered against Eesa, wallahi i've lost full respect for him. Shame on him & on those who believe what he believes & that agree upon his words. May Allah guide them & guide us all. May Allah swt grant us ALL the highest rank in Jannah tul firdous as well as brother Eesa as well as his family & loved ones without reckoning Ameen. What a lovely brother wallahi ! Salute to you for this & defending his honour Akhi Ali ! Allah bless u immensely. Pure & the best of company ! If brother Eesa was alive surely he'd have given you the biggest hug whilst tears fall from his eyes
I couldn't have put it any better
Shamsi only said it because Essa said that it was allowed to listen to music in Islam
Don’t make up your mind on his perspective alone watch the video without a commentary delaying it for unnecessary reasons
@@abdulrahmanalenezi6068 My beloved brother. When one can't show condolences & support towards a dear muslim brother who's just passed away but instead pulls out his mistakes & disagreements with him that's real sad. Whatever he believed or passed away upon is between him & Allah. We should make dua'a for the beautiful brother, speak of his true beautiful character & akhlaq, pray for him & show love and support towards his family & loved ones during this such saddening time. Like brother Ali said.. I'd have made Dua'a for you Shamsi if u had passed away & prayed for nothing but good for you and by Allah that's the way of our beloved ﷺ who even stood up for a Jew at his uneral سبحان الله
@@abdulrahmanalenezi6068 what is videos title? cause I looked and couldn't find it.
The fact that Shamsi had to wait for brother Essa's death to make a expose video ,says Volume of his character.
Please listen to all what Shamsi said. @Alidawah is cutting and pasting and taking things out of context
@@smh6234 what did shamsi say then? "Oh it was jus a joke" he wasnt with their shitty cult which is why he callin him misguided
I have no more respect for that dude, May Allah grant Esa highest rank in jannah
Please brother watch Shamsi's reply. May Allah continue to strengthen him. And may Allah guide Ali to repent.
Why are we Muslims always fighting Akhi? Its sad that we are arguing over a brother that has passed away. May Allah have mercy on him.
Simply because groups or individuals have hijacked the religion to there own.
And if you don't fit then your a outcast.
Sad but true
I feel you brother this issue hurts me and worst it hurts the entire ummah.. may Allah guide us all
May Allah protect us from major sin of gheebah
“Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects, you O Prophet, are not associated with them in anything. Their affair is left only to Allah and He will inform them about what they used to do.” (Al-An’ām: 159)
Salafi this Salafi that.....SubhanAllah, the brother is not dead for a day and his character is being questioned by hyenas smh! Allah mustayn, i used to respect brother shamsi but not after this
May Allah s.w.t forgive brother Esa, have mercy upon him, widen his grave and grant him entry into Jannatul Firdous. Ameen ya rabb
Thank you so muchhhh!!!
it's also about sunni and chiite
I know subhanallah there was something so distateful about the video make dua and move on
Ameen
Jazakallah kheir brother for reminding us we are no salaf neither was the messenger alhamdulilah
Praying fajr in the garden. Subhanallah may Allah swt bestow nothing but blessings upon him.
Brother Essa’s death tells us all about the person he was. He passed away in the last 10 days of Ramadan, and the cause was covid. So he was a shaheed who passed away in Ramadan. If it was in the day time he was probably fasting as well. Subhanallah What a way to leave this world. It is a hadith of our beloved prophet (S.A.W) that a person will die the way he lived. And he will be resurrected the way he died. Brother essa إن شاء الله will be amongst the special friends of Allah and إن شاء الله he will not be questioned on the day of judgement
آمين
Why did he feel it was necessary to mention this after he had passed if it was so important surely he would have said something when he was alive this is poor and low of s*****.
This needs to stop. A Muslim is a Muslim. Salafi, hanafi, Shafiiee, Malakee, whatever school of thought you follow, you are a MUSLIM just as Allah calls you. Stop creating divisions.
Thank you. Someone finally said it like it is. If only we could all think like this instead of dissecting each other's school of thoughts and who the 'rightly guided' is. May Allah guide us all and keep us on the path of MUHAMMAD peace be upon him. Ameen.
Bruv Im Muslim and kurd, fam ive been watching you for so long mann, keep do watch you do brother
"Truth will prevail and falsehood will perish” may Allah strengthen our hearts ❤️ and may Allah guide us all inshallah
It's ridiculous, even Surah Jinn verse 11 fits perfectly
"There are among us some that are righteous, and some the contrary; we are groups having different ways (religious sects)."
I came across this verse yesterday and look at such a perfect example of this verse, it's hard for Muslims like us who are trying to learn about Islam, then you have the risk of getting involved with the whole sectarian bullshit and this whole group of people who keep dividing the Muslims.
As far as I understood The way of the salaf describes following Quran and the sunnah of the prophet saw. the sahaba and the following Generation
@@Baba-ul9vo yes... But this guy isn't a salaf...he is one of those who wants to ruin our name by speaking out of arrogance and putting us down.
The prophet Mohamed pbuh spoke of these things to happen brother it’s actually Ali & Co who go against Quran and sunnah that cause more sectarianism.
I have actually lost all respect for shamsi🤦♂️ . he speaks after a brother passes away which shows his arrogance
Don't use S*****'s name. Ali Dawah said not to.
oh shoot i can't believe that's shamsi whaaaat?! are u fr?
Dont say dat bro take good news from him and left the bad things
U can see his face on the thumbnail...
WATCH HOW SHAMSI EDUCATED THIS MAN AND HIJAB ON ISLAM. THIS MAN SHOUTING HERE CAN'T REACH SHAMSI
I saw a video of Shamsi telling other Muslims about Mufti Menk, Zakir Naik, Nouman Ali that they are not this that and they are this that. That day he lost my respect.
Yess bro...me too....from that day....i know it was something wrong with shamsi....
They are not scholars they are just people who talk why are you so shy from your religion
What of all he said is wrong? Shamshi always says, if you are looking for answers follow the sources. Those you mentiond are not sources. That's all he said. They are not sheikhs. He said nothing else.
So do you respect someone who slanders?..... because it's clear Sh**si said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman.
So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Sh**si says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no?
Jahidul Islam czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
This hurts my soul at the deepest level. I'll write more on this topic later - but mashallah I'm very proud of you for making this video and getting your thoughts out, brother. May Allah grant Eesa happiness and barakat in the next life. May Allah grant his family strength, good health, safety, and success. Ameen. Allah Yerhamo
Does it also hurt your soul to the deepest level when one brother slanders another?.. because it's clear Sh**si said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman.
So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Sh**si says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no?
Yes I say, Sh**si because Ali Dawah apparently wants to block anyone who mentions him by name on the comments....I wonder why 🤔
Sorry Ali,, but Atfer i watched lot of videos for both of you, Shamsi is on the right path. This is deen not a game, you cant speak without knowledge, if you make mistakes someone have to correct you . U know how many time he said in the video May Allah forgive him, So because he said gentleman he is on his side, cmoon man yo can do better than that
tiger lily he said he advised him, just missed the days when they all together, may Allah bless them all in their mission
I don't understand Shamsis logic? Everyone will have made mistakes in this dunya? But why make a video about it talking about a man's mistakes after he is no longer with us? What's the logic?
Cut out his name. 🙁
It is not because of his mistakes, but because he was misguiding others with his mistakes.
I don’t know how people like shamsi thinking..what if esa’s wife and family saw the video what they will feel?
Shamsi is salafi that’s the problem
Instead of listening Ali Drama talking gibberish and making up lies, go and watch this video:
czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
Instead if asking if he was a Salafi...how about asking if he was a good human being. By all accounts he was. Only God can judge you.
SAA and didn’t Allah say in 6:159;
“Indeed, those who have divided their religion and become sects - you, [O Muhammad], are not [associated] with them in anything. Their affair is only [left] to Allah ; then He will inform them about what they used to do.”?
SAA so what happens to the many sufis who have passed away in Makkah and medina in the holy mosques in sujood while in prayer and their janaza is read in the holy masjids by millions especially in the time of hajj or Ramadhan??? Are they going to hell according to you???
Yes but you misunderstanding that hadith do a proper research on it please
Seems after the Prophet dies people manipulated the Koran for a power grab. These sects bullshit is worse then Hindu caste system or Nazi Race blocks. Grow up all off you
blad90 well then they must be pious to die in that state or maybe it’s just Allah swt’s mercy on them, so this so called saved sect lot need to relax and stop with the arrogance like how iblees had
SubhanAllah i could feel the anger from Ali. Never seen him like this.
First of all rest in peace to issa and my heart goes out to his family, from my observations at the park the way issa delt with issues inside and outside the community was second to none, the dawha that he gave to non muslims will be a big loss to the community as he was such a gentleman, he was polite kind and gentle in his approach no matter how heated it got in debates the world is gona miss you😔
Big up Ali Dawah for this one, may Allah have mercy on Eesa forever!
'You would have thrown all of us in the fire' that bit got me laughing hard.
It’s true though ... have you seen how sectarian these guys are... it’s either their way or no way
Funny how in all his videos he has so many books to make himself look pious. May Allah swt grant Eesa the highest rank in Jannah Aameen🤲🏻 I pray we all have friends who protect our name after we return to Allah🙏🏼 aameen.
At least he studies them. He has more knowledge then Ali and thats a fact.
@@makeithappenbourriht963 your proof please for shamsi studied this books?
makeithappen bourriht he has more knowledge but yet so arrogant. I’ve seen his videos in the past all he does is put others down
@@Samina_787 I'm not defending him, but in the second part it's clear he said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman.
So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Shamsee says
I've defended Shamsi in the past even though he doesn't require any of us to do so. However to call people out for being ignorant or uneducated upon having just lost their life is insensitive to say the least.That being said, let's see if pride takes precedence over humbly admitting ones mistake with a sincere apology at least to his family.
Don't use S*****'s name. Ali Dawah said not to.
no way i didn’t think it was him i saw the thumbnail and i was like nah it can’t be him to be backbiting i literally was just watching his videos of him disapproving shias , converting people etc 😳
@@osmxnn3311 Regardless, some Shias are messed up.
The Ottoman Empire no comment may Allah guide them and us all
Did you see Shamsi’s clarification video?
Im so sad that i will never have the same feelings and respect towards shmai anymore . May Allah grant brother Isa jannatol firdows .amen
when Muhammed hijab said that ibn Taymiyyah (who is dead) that he made mistakes why does nobody make a video about that the answer is because they are on a witch hunt for the Salafis . what did Shamsi say that was wrong except he will not promotes some of the things that brother Essa said.
He didn’t make an entire video out of the blue to talk about ibn taymiyyah did he? Was brother esa a scholar who had influence around the world? Who had books that were accessible? So then what’s the point in talking about Esa’s mistakes after he died? That’s like talking about some random Muslim guy 1000 years ago that’s not known.
Shamsi I would never thought you was like that bro. What is wrong with you cuz u need to fix up
hes probably sick
Zohair S. His picture is in thumbnail of the video lol
Red Sufyan yeah lol they act like he is some god or something
makeithappen bourriht can you send the video? What’s the title
Assalamu alikum brother thank you always for reminding these advices during ramadan.
I was outraged what that brother was doing but thank you for posting the video and reminded me about the adab of our Rasool Sallalahu Alaihi Wasalam or else I would have regretted during this ramadan and the day of judgement by giving my good deeds to that person.
Jazak Allah Khair. Maasalam.
Love you for the sake of Allah from Bahrain.
Let these people backbite. This is more ajr for Esa. May Allah az have mercy upon him Ameen.
" Abu Darda reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever defends the reputation of his brother, Allah will defend his face from the Hellfire on the Day of Resurrection.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 1931".
@@aq4356 what's this vid
It's incredible that they want to backstab a brother on a possible laylatul qadr
Ameen
@Ayan D A the irony. But at least shamsi still alive and can defend himself
Brother isa was a amazing guy, may Allah forgive all people who have died and grant them jannah
brother Ali, I think you heard wrong in the last part, brother Shamsi said " An athiest and a gentleman, or a guy, Muhammed Hijab" he didn't call the Athiest a gentleman, rather he was calling brother Hijab a gentleman.
I watched it carefully. He said the atheist-an-gentleman and Mohammad Hijab.
Wallahi my heart weeps from this... la hawla wala quwa illa billah.. Ya Allah have mercy on brother Essa and grant him the highest level of jannah.
who are they to talk about him like this , whatever he is , is between him and his creator no one has the right to say anything about him, astaghfirullah ,may Allah swt Grant our brother the highest place in janah and grant his family sabr ameen. guys remember brother essa in your prayer.
The funny thing is Shamsi is unqualified and ran away from Br essa رحمه الله when questioned about this.
Just another case of triple S guys...
Saved sect syndrome
For a unique case of Quadruple S just add
S at the end
Edit: cant say his name fear of being blocked by br Ali 😁
@@zohairs.5038 lol will do thx
@Alex Gemi 😂
These cults exist in all firqas, unfortunately the cults within Salafism are some of the worst. Disgusting.
Nah nah...there are many "salafis" but not alot that actually follow the aqidah and the characteristics....we don't call ourselves salafis... were ahle hadith and Ahlus Sunnah...these so called people who act like salafis and bring us down with arrogance are no better then any other sect.
Muhammedibnyaseen they are praised by the scholars of ahul sunnah this dude haven’t even studied the books of the salaf. May Allah bless spubs I never met these brothers but they call to Islam the the salaf was upon. It’s so clear!
I think you need actually study brother than you can see whoes closer to the early Muslims and what they believed.
May Allah grant Essa the highest place in Jannah💕
Thanks for the content it's a big help for us specifically for a non arabic
Mashallah Ali Dawah Enjoin Good and Forbid Evil. Your definitely standing the truth but your right someone is dead already just leave him alone is best
Ali Dawah, you are the only guy I can trust in Islam thank you❤️
I only knew brother Ésa for a few days. And Alhamdulilah he was shining from Noor and was always smiling. O Allah please widen Ésa’s grave and enter him in to your paradise. Amëën
After many years I looked you up on CZcams. But have been saddened to learn the infighting which has been going on for the past year or so between you and other brothers. And it breaks my heart to see that none of the brothers are holding back their emotions. @alidawah it is important to be tolerant and forgive if other brothers are misguided or doing things wrongly. This whole fighting between brothers shows our disunity in a country where its outmost required. Salam.
May Allah have mercy on our beloved brother Eesa.
May Allah reward him Jannatul firdaus and I know you Ali dawah Mashallah you and Mohammed Hijab are doing so good no one is perfect expect Allah
May you blessed brother Ali Dawah. May you find healing from this great loss
He died in Ramadan, he has achieved a status of someone higher than a martyr, he's passing away in Ramadan has a status higher than a shaheed.
Also, he passed away in Ramadan, that's enough said.
Hadith No: 3925
Narrated/Authority of Talhah bin Ubaidullah
Listed in: The Chapters on the Interpretation of Dreams
that two men from Bali came to the Messenger of Allah (saw). They had become Muslim together, but one of them used to strive harder than the other. The one who used to strive harder went out to fight and was martyred. The other one stayed for a year longer, then he passed away. Talhah said: "I saw in a dream that I was at the gate of Paradise and I saw them (those two men). Someone came out of Paradise and admitted the one who had died last, then he came out and admitted the one who had been martyred. Then he came back to me and said: 'Go back, for your time has not yet come.'" The next morning, Talhah told the people of that and they were amazed. News of that reached the Messenger of Allah (saw) and they told him the story. He said: "Why are you so amazed at that?" They said: "O Messenger of Allah, the first one was the one who strove harder, then he was martyred, but the other one was admitted to Paradise before him. The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: "Did he not stay behind for a year?" They said: "Yes." He said: "And did not Ramadan come and he fasted, and he offered such and such prayers during that year?" They said: "Yes." The Messenger of Allah (saw) said: "The difference between them is greater than the difference between heaven and earth."
Where is the evidence that if you pass away in the month of Ramadan you achieve a higher status than a martyr?
I was gonna ask the proof for tht aswell just trying to learn not cause arguments
Proof ???
That is not the case. Rather what this means is that the gates of Paradise are opened to encourage people to strive hard, so that they can enter it, and that the gates of Hell are closed, so as to encourage the believers to refrain from sin, so that they will not go through these gates. That does not mean that the one who dies in Ramadan will enter Paradise without being brought to account; rather those who will enter Paradise without being brought to account are those whom the Messenger (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) described when he said: “They are the ones who do not ask others to perform ruqyah for them, or believe in omens, or use cautery, and they put their trust in their Lord”, in addition to their doing the righteous deeds that are enjoined upon them. End quote.
Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saalih al-‘Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him).
Higher then martyr?
The man died. He never harmed anyone he invented people to islam and after he dies you're like "some of the mistakes he made are...". Come on man you know the Prophet pbuh would NEVER condone such behaviour.
I’m actually in shock, I did not realise shamsi was this way. This was so wrong on so many levels. Justice will prevail. May Allah have mercy and peace be upon brother Essa. Allah’humma Ameen.
Same
I am shook to the core. I don't what to say. But, may Allah bless brother Essa and grant him the highest place in Jannah.
Salaamuailkum everyone,I didn’t even know brother Isa....but MashaAllah he had very good way off spreading Islam.Allah bless him Jannah firdos.🤲
Ali I think you need to address the issue of salafism and how they made a cult about misinterpretating the way of the people of the salaf. The people of the salaf are not the issue it's this cult that's the issue.
True
I'm salafi
ItsFareed Do you agree with what’s being said in this video?
@ You people are the worst of people, Salafis do not say they are the only sect that is saved, they follow the Qur'an and Sunnah, that's all.
Madkhalis ≠ Salafi
True Salafis do not call them salafis, they follow the Qur'an and the Sunnah and ahadith.
Essa bro was a really beautiful soul, whenever I saw him in PARK, I was feeling a great soul and pious person. I really miss him. May Allah increase his reward. I think Mr. SH***i, we love you please don't do this to Bro Essa. (Sh***i) you have decreased yourself. I am sorry for your attitude. It is a kind of arrogance.
czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
I loved every video of brother Esa. I will carry on watching them Inshallah. May Allah grant him the highest rank in jannah. Ameen
Ameen ya rabbalaalamin
Always wondered why I liked both their dawah and why they were never together because united they would have been stronger! Thanks for this Ali I really appreciate this clarification!! A*
Shamsa is honestly a veil person for this
I have lost all respects for him now.
@@samboy1406 me too
@Denzo Dridz Can you link me to the other video, cannot find it on his channel.
@@samboy1406 i used to like so much. Now i don't
@Denzo Dridz sorry but no I will not watch Shamsa video. He decided to do a video when brother ESA didn't even spend 1 night in his grave and on the 27th of Ramadan. To me that is a disgusting act.
Who is he to judge who is he what we don't know is human heart #subhanallah
Jazakallahu Khairan, for the working your doing may Allah increase you in knowledge
Assalamu 1alaikum. I had got love for Easa right immediately when I saw him on the video. I just saw him and loved him immediately
Shamsi always think he is right and others wrong..bro hajji made series of video to refute him.
Brother Ali May Allah (S.W.T) give you Ajr for everything Ameen!
Dusre taraf ki kahani kya hai maloom bhi aapku?
Ali dawah is a pure deceiver
@@OMAR-if9kb Calling someone a deceiver that means you got a pass to jannah khalas no more questioning to you after you dead straight jannah make istegfar my brother ask for repentance.
Salaam Brothers, you're all doing a wonderful job for Islam around the world please try to unite with all the wisdom you have. Don't fight each other . If someone among you is not having the right behaviour try to advise or just ignore him . For those of us who are following you we would like to see working together.
Akhi, let's forgive others so that May Allah Almighty forgive us
Exactly 😭😭😭
I just don't get it. We sunnis follow the Prophet and the Companions anyway so what's all the fuss about being a salafi??
These people are taking these things too seriously, just be laid back and enjoy yourself.
Humble yourself yaa Shamsi! Humble yourself!
TheUnknown czcams.com/video/gdvA9_QIUI4/video.html
Ma Sha Allah, brother Eesa is getting rewards even after he died. Imagine the amount of muslims the other brother called to Islam, the Qur'an he read and all the prayers he prayed, all his fast will In Sha Allah go to Brother Eesa on the Day of Judgement.
Wow I actually looked up to shamsi so much, this has broke my heart, may Allah guide us all ☹️
He mention a whole lot of nothing in his so call clarifying his mistakes. It seems like a whole lot of backbiting to me which make me question there sincerity why did this person wait until eesa is dead to ask this person for a so call clarification of a dead man? And all he had to say was we advice him he had many mistakes. Why choose not to address it when the man is alive? It is jealousy due to believers and non Muslims praising him and speaking if his good character
Jazak Allaah Khair Zi you spoke the Haqq there's a difference between Shamsi speaking with ILM and the emotional baseless negative responded he's getting may Allaah guide the Muslims akhi perhaps you should change your pic of the statue
Zi I think you and the people you follow are hizbis it’s clear and as the morning ☀️. The scholars have clearly refuted the individuals you look up to in your hizb why you don’t abandon them And stick to the haqq and not men? Because in your heart it is a disease. If the livestream wasn’t about him the brother shouldn’t have been mention at all. Besides, no one said the lecture was all about him but a segment of it was about him
Striver Goal show me one thing he mention from knowledge base.
No one knows when will a person die. and it is too late to address a living individual public mistake when the person has died already, death will always be unexpected. How could someone wait for a person to die just to point out their mistake? That sounds absurd because the waiting person could be the one dying before the other one too by an unexpected possibility. If there is a public mistake of a Muslim person that he or she has not clarified before they died, then someone has to do the job for them so the people will not unknowingly follow the mistaken advice. People following the advice of a deceased brother can affect the deceased deeds. Just like how a Muslim person who built the mosque but then died, for every person that goes to the mosque, prays in the mosque, performs the Ramadan, and reads Quran in the Mosque which the deceased person has built. Indeed that will be his ongoing charity even if he has died. Passing of the deceased's correct Islamic knowledge is also an ongoing charity.
Shin Sekai Animationz they still didn’t clarify what mistakes he made.secondly does those mistake required to be mention in public and refuted openly? Brother how conveniently people want to ask and inquire about someone when they was dead. Yiu gonna have mistakes when you die does that give someone the right to talk about you ?
Brothers and sisters , we are fasting. if you have watched this video dont carry on back biting after and write bad comments about either Ali or Shamsi or anyone else. Let's not let our fasting go to waste (advice to myself first). If your really concerned make dua for everyone. May Allah guide us all. aameen.
I didnt know about brother eesa before this. I will go and watch his videos now inshallah
I have never seen brother essa real life but in videos at speakers corner and I have never seen him get angry and all his videos he is always smiling, May Allah swt grant him jannatul ferdous
on behaf of all moroccans shamsi has been kicked out, this man is a toxic man and we hate him wallah, god bless essa and may he rest in peace
14:57 i gotta few names for him but I'm fasting 😌
🤦🏽♂️
Khara
May Allah grant brother Esa jannah nd his family sabr jameel alahuma ameen 🇦🇫🇦🇫🇦🇫
May Allah protect and preserve us all ameen summa ameen
Ameen
@@predestinedbyGod not relevant but okay
Ali dawah, this is my request that show the video first then talk.. I couldn't get what he is speaking in that video as you simultaneously interrupting😒 either you speak or show us the video..don't do both at the same time. Uf
it's clear Shamsi said "there is something going on online, between this atheist AND a gentleman" to which he further elaborates who the gentleman is "this guy, Muhammad Hijab" ...... anyone who speaks even basic level English can see he was referring to Hijab as the gentleman.
So why is Ali Dawah missing out words intentionally, when he says "look what he says, this Atheist... gentleman.."....clear manipulation of what Shamsi says.... during Ramadan too, bit of a hypocrite no?
May Allah grant him jannah🙏🙏...as for the guy may Allah disgrace him😒🙄 Amin ya rabbul izzah
I didn't know the brother personally but from a few videos i saw of him in the park he was well mannered guy.May Allah 4give us of our short comings & grant him jannat firdous & may Allah give his wife & daughter good in this life & the hereafter. Ameen.what a beautiful soul he was.
Mate you need to relax. Please stop taking what Shams ud Deen said out of context. Please stop maligning him.