Should Derrick Rose be in the Hall of Fame? | The Jump
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 09. 2019
- Rachel Nichols, Ramona Shelburne and Amin Elhassan react to Derrick Rose's interview on The Stephen A. Smith Show, and debate whether the former NBA MVP with the Chicago Bulls should be in the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame.
#TheJump #NBA #Sports
✔ Subscribe to ESPN+ plus.espn.com/
✔ Get the ESPN App: www.espn.com/espn/apps/espn
✔ Subscribe to ESPN on CZcams: es.pn/SUBSCRIBEtoCZcams
✔ Subscribe to ESPN FC on CZcams: bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoESPNFC
✔ Subscribe to NBA on ESPN on CZcams: bit.ly/SUBSCRIBEtoNBAonESPN
✔ Watch ESPN on CZcams TV: es.pn/CZcamsTV
Exclusive interviews with Rachel Nichols urlzs.com/jNURe
Stephen A. Smith on ESPN urlzs.com/W19Tz
ESPN on Social Media:
► Follow on Twitter: / espn
► Like on Facebook: / espn
► Follow on Instagram: fespn
Visit ESPN on CZcams to get up-to-the-minute sports news coverage, scores, highlights and commentary for NFL, NHL, MLB, NBA, College Football, NCAA Basketball, soccer and more.
More on ESPN.com: www.espn.com - Sport
The Chicago HOF for sure, D. Rose’s jersey needs to be in the rafters at the United Center. 🌹
same with gilmore and rodman
Yea true
Jahod Davis true, but Dwight no discussion should be there.
Jahod Davis do you know how good Dwight was for a decent amount of time?
Gary Nutt youngest mvp ever, definitely in the Hall of game
Even if he doesn’t make it, I’ll always be a d rose 🌹 fan. For life
Senpai facts❤️🌹
Absolutely yes
💯
NBA Most Valuable Player
3× NBA All-Star
All-NBA First Team
NBA Rookie of the Year
NBA All-Rookie First Team
2x Gold medalist
Yes indeed
Don't forget the NBA ROOKIE PLAYOFFS SCORING RECORD.
Plus 2-time Illinois high school state champion and Mr. Basketball, plus he lead Memphis to NCAA championship game. It's the Basketball HOF, not the NBA HOF, so all bball achievements are considered
@@Ryan-fg7sd that Memphis team/season doesnt exist anymore.. Rose messed up that season by paying someone to take his SAT for him
He's pretty much a IRL Chris Smoove, set all these records within two years, then disappear.
Shouldn’t have won mvp
Close your eyes, imagine you've hit the top in your profession, got an injury, and does not have a job for a couple years. And then GOT UP AND WORK your way back. If that's not HOF then I dont know what is.
Work your way back... That's his job. You're putting him in the hof for doing his job? We see injurys all the time he came back to what? A six man? That's not working yourself back up.
Facts
How am I supposed to read your comment when you’re telling me to close my eyes
then shaun livingston is a hall of famer. Rose isn’t a HOF
@@measelcatches3202 drose has awards though I keep seeing you but you won’t bring up his accolades you’re just hating
If Grant Hill can get in then I believe Derrick Rose should get in
Mike Alford t h a n k y o u
Derrick Rose*
Its not Derek like Derek Fisher
As it stands Hill has done more in his career than Rose, especially with his time at Duke which is also considered. It's unfortunate Rose had as many injuries as he has, but potential or what could've been shouldn't be why he gets in
Grant Hill got in mainly because of his contribution to basketball. You can get in like that also.
STILL never heard an apology from Rachel after dragging him through the mud... Brought up nothing but ALLEGATIONS after his 50 pt game SMH
Vante I agree
What allegations
@@jamesedington3153 rape allegations even though he was proven innocent
You’re 100% DROSE FAN. I’ve been some type of way about her every since then!
@@39830000 fax fax
D.Rose is more than an NBA HOF! He is a true inspiration of our generation we can never forget like some of the others included in the actual list.
Poo will always be a HOF to us in Englewood. 073 079 B.O.S 7414
Fuddyduddie1 You Wuga World?
RIPKEE4 we Jojo gang
123 O.N.E. 1-2BUKL MY SHU 456 Gang
Frez28 yare yare daze
pooh
If Tracy Mcgrady made it and Yao plus they never won MVP, how D Rose ain't going to make it?? Smh
He said it 6-7 good/great seasons
Tracy was way better than d rose
Argenis Peña MVP doesn’t automatically make u HOF if u were only elite for 2 seasons that doesn’t make sense
Tracy was a animal! 6’8 6’9 wit a jumpa, D# and hard to contain man he deserved it.
Tmac never got out first round
If Tracy McGrady made it, D Rose should easily make it.
Same thing I thought. Similar level of talent, both ruined by injuries, they both deserve it but Rose just accomplished more than Tmac
Very sorry indeed grant Hill and penny hardaway too so many talents wasted by injury
T Mac got in off of seven all star teams that an automatic in
Definitely, though T-Mac being in can justify way too many people getting in the HOF ahah
Nah mcgrady was better n his prime...7x all star 2 scoring titles....pretty much unguardable...
Im someone that made it out the south side of chicago.. I went to high school in Englewood.. He was def our hometown hero in our eyes & deserves to go in the basketball hall of fame..
TMac and Yao Ming made it. Derrick Rose should def make it.
Facts
tmac has 2 scoring titles during the Kobe VC AI era. Yao ming is against Shaq center era with 20/10 stats for 10 years, Yao dominated Dwight Howard every time they met. he has well deserved the HOF. plus global influence. D rose probably in HOF of Chicago only, he is not even on Steve Francis level. avg 18 ppg and some dunk highlights make him a HOF? yall Internet kids are dreaming nowadays. LOL
Tmac and Yao had longevity in their prime. Rose only had 1 year
I disagree homie
CTO Information drose have a mvp asshole
Youngest MVP in the NBA.. of course. If it wasn't for his injuries he would of been the most explosive PG of all time.
Alberto L for real
but did u check his stats? Wikipedia it.. he had 3 seasons where he averaged 20-25.. the rest were 15 and such. .. 3 seasons imo is not hof material unless it was a cultural impact of some sort.. yea he would of easily made it if he wasn't injured but you could easily say the same for 100 other guys.. winning mvp young was his only merit .. doesn't mean he was good enough regardless of how u think he was going to do preinjury... hof should not be for casuals
Goat pg. **
@@TheAnonapersons stfu
@@jordanrodriguez6412 *corrections 2 and a half seasons*
Derrick Rose is a hall of Famer to me. MVP, ROTY made the Conference Finals. I believe he is
Edit: 1k likes? I guess you guys agree with me!!! ❤
Jamario Stevens Fax
Everyone makes the basketball hall of fame. At this point it devalues the the weight of being a hall if famer
He techinically made the finals
@The Truth a lot of players who didn't do enough made the hall of fame
Please tell me your serious...
he’s the youngest mvp ever why is this even a question
@Joseph S your actually high
@@maliszn9293 no he should be in the HOF
So? He only had 1 good season and was hurt the rest of his career
He had a few good seasons but overall his career is not hof worthy because for the past 8 years he has not gotten a single accomplishment. As much as I love D Rose the hof is pretty strict and he doesnt have a good enough career
@Awakened Khi did you just say d rose is first ballot hof, that is delusional his accomplishments are 1 mvp and 3 all star games but thats its. He had good years and 7 bad, and hes made somewhat of a comeback but not enough to even make an all star game.
Idc what nobody say & I'm not even from the Chi but dude a legend for life what he overcame on & off the court is proof enough 💯
1.They should NOT forget and leave out "YOUNGEST" every time they say he's been an MVP.
2.His career is not over. He's several months younger than Steph Curry and you can't be making any definite conclusions YET.
He's not putting up any elite level play though. He might not even be starting the season
If Rose makes another all star team and wins 6MOTY or plays a key role on a championship team I think he cements his case.
Vililol don’t matter he’s not a HOF player
@globalicon2012 Who did he quit on? You think sitting out for a year to recover because his dumbass coach kept running players into the ground is quitting?
Curry’s guaranteed mvp
I feel like it's different when you get it out the mud.
Haha
???
What that has to do with playing basketball
Carlos Anziani you not the sharpest knife in the draw
@@carlosanziani5677 everything 😡
What still blows my mind is, we never saw “prime rose.”
He never reached prime rose. He was what? 21 or 22 when he won?
This man deserve the HOF, no questions asked.
Nah even tho i love drose but there're requirement for you to get in cuz you cant just be good for like 3 seasons then bad for the rest of them
Just_Nodh well he hasn’t been bad. He’s been a 18+ ppg scorer coming off the bench the past two seasons. He was a solid player on the knicks and his last bulls season. He’s never been bad. His prime was great, he led the bulls to an amazing record at just 22. He averaged 25 and 7. He won mvp over lebron. He’s still a 3x all star. He deserves the hall of fame, in his short prime he did more than 99% of nba players
@@just_nodh864 he's still a very decent pg and if he can win a chip he's a no question
@@just_nodh864 so how yao hof and grant hall
@@andyabreu5627 3x all star isn’t hall of fame level. That’s hall of very good.
Their takes just make no sense to me.
Derrick Rose leads Memphis to a record setting 38-2 record as a FRESHMAN... also named Wooden award finalist... “Oh but he doesn’t have the college aspect of the game to get in”
Derrick Rose part of the 2010 World
Championship Team-Won Gold. Also part of 2014 World Cup Team-Won Gold. “He doesn’t have the international play on his side when it comes to voting..”
People who say he’s not deserving are just hating at this point.
College won't count because of the sat scandal he was in. I think all records he got at Memphis don't officially count.
I still say he should get in.
NCAA is not the NBA... If that counted; Ralph Sampson, Danny Manning, Ferry, & the late Wayman Tisdale would all be NBA Hall of Famers! BTW they all had less then stellar NBA careers...
Michael Jones it’s the basketball hof not nba hof... it does count. what are you trying to say here?
@@robertguerrero2243 the question does say "Hall of Fame" you are right on this.. Since you want to be technical with me, I don't think Derrick Rose should be in National Collegiate Hall in Kansas City, MO. since he only played 1 yr of college basketball or the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame (NBA) due to lack of superior statistics due to multiple injuries in his career. The players I mentioned before were all collegiate Hall of Famers, but the consensus is referring to the NBA (Naismith Memorial) Hall of Fame.. Does this answer your question?
YOUNGEST MVP. that's all he needs to get in the Hall of Fame. Tf they talkin bout.
The hate is real.....
Yeah no
Was thinking the same thing
He has the least impressive mvp of this decade..
@@alexanderjackson8389 2015 Steph
Most people would rather have Rose career than Chris Webber’s 🤷🏽♂️
Cdiddly Son what does voice have to do with the way they played? One of the dumbest comments I’ve seen in a minute.
zinedineyzidane thank you
Not to mention rose dumb as a brick
zinedineyzidane came to the final conclusion people are idiots who only care about appearance to make their judgments
Yall know C webb aint in there right?
Y’all are wrong he’s most definitely a Hof
no he isn’t. You’re just blinded by your nostalgia. He had 2 good seasons. That’s not HoF you idiots
@@measelcatches3202 3 time all star, MVP, Rookie Point Record Holder, 2 time Gold Medalist, Priceless Leader, multiple all 1st teams. Multiple HOF nobodies in the 70’s made it with almost no accomplishments. You are stupid if you think Derrick Rose is not a HOG player.
D wade and lebron. Had to guard this man when he was on. 🔥🔥🔥 mvp. . hof forsure.
He said “not “in everyone eyes but to the ppl he grew up with...taking out words to change
True
He is an MVP and he was rookie of the year. It shouldn't be a problem for him, and I won't be surprised if the bulls retire Rose's number.
2 gold medals also
Retire his number for doing what ?
Winning roty is basically irrelevant if talking about the hof
Geo Rockmann HE WON MVP HIS ROOKIE YEAR!!!! That’s unheard of 🤦🏾♂️
@@nolimitfrank no he didn't. Stop making up lies and do some simple research
Regardless if he makes it in or not, I'll always have his bulls jersey on my wall. He is my favorite player of all time
anyone remember how a year or two ago she was practically lobbying for tracy mcgrady to get in but now says derrick rose shouldnt lol
If Grant Hill and TMac get in, Derrick Rose should definitely get in. MVP, ROTY come on
Grant hill cause of college and yes mcgrady was good but never got out of the 2nd round rose won mvp and got to easter conference finals dont disrepect drose either he was a beast in his mvp season and is still a great role player as all 3 of them were later in there careers
@@leogonzalez6751 Prime T-Mac was crazy, even Kobe said T-Mac would be one of the greatest if not due to his injuries and he still managed to drop crazy numbers, advancing in the post season is a team accomplishment, the Bulls were stacked, if prime T-Mac was there they might have reached the finals
Vlade just got in
Rose is the Youngest MVP in NBA HISTORY!
* And still playing
The mission of the Basketball Hall of Fame is to preserve Basketball HISTORY!
Hence, Rose was a lock for the Hall of Fame, the day he won MVP, especially the Youngest MVP in HISTORY!
These SCRUBS are just exposing themselves as low basketball IQ SCRUBS!
@Jack park Rose won MVP at age 22. Imagine if he didnt get injured. He averaged 25 and 8 assists in his mvp yr, couldve avgd 30 and 10 by the time he got to his prime like Harden.
I don't even know why they ask this dude about drose you can tell he doesn't like him 😂🤦🏾♂️
Dude is weak sauce..
globalicon2012 he’s a basketball player what’s their to not like he’s making millions? 🤣
Jason Jamieson you can't never call any ball Player weak that puts a certain amount time and Go hard in the gym like he does. If he did'nt do that then Yeah he's weak
@@anthonyking3072 I'm not talking about D. Rose bro!
@globalicon2012 Derrick Rose is neither a crybaby or a quitter..
1 billion percent!!!!! But they don’t deserve him 🌹❤️❤️❤️
Dhanuja Boyagoda shaddup
Jo Ga no you shut up
Below Freezing no YOU shut up
Whoever says no, go win MVP, tear your achilles and ACL, contemplate about quiting, average 18 on a Wolves with a young Wiggins and KAT, and drop 50 on someones head
80 overall on NBA 2K20 after averaging 18 points of the bench last season? What does he have to do
He avg almost 19 ppg
18 ppg actually
Pulp isn’t that a perfect rating? He scores off the bench , what is he a 88?
-Z3us - 82/83
BoyIfYouDon't Leaks at the most , but all he rlly did was sclre
If Vlade Divac could make it b4 Chris Webber, then D Rose could defly make it
On GD
Yea vlade divac is trash
Seth Stelzer he was ok
As the youngest MVP he should. His layups are some of the most athletic I've seen and they're beautiful.
so he should be in the mvp cos of layups?
@@measelcatches3202 he is a mvp
Simple question simple answer. YES HE DOES!!!
D-rose is a HOF it took Lebron in Cleveland to guard him in the playoffs come on now 😩🔥🔥🔥🎖🏆🏅
Randy 25 no
You do remember that lebron was robbed that year of the MVP? Lebron wanted to prove a point and shut that man down in the playoffs.
Sa-eed Siraj his point is that Drose shouldn’t have won that MVP that year
Jules AA The last time he did so. Hasn’t played defense since.
@@skywalker2676 a simple no is childish son
He took on the 3 headed monster Heat on his own. Blew his knee out being a one man team and he’s not a hall of fame?
Art B no he isn’t lol he took them on and lost. Won only 1 mvp. Yeah he was young but doesn’t really matter. Take emotion out of it buddy he has not had a HOF career
That Chicago team was not a one man team.. all star Luol Deng, all star Joakim Noah, and all star Carlos Boozer.. you’re tweaking
@@geraldbuncum3861 without drose we were bottom 10 in all offensive categories
MadManFN without Derrick Rose the bulls made it to the second round of the playoffs.. twice
Gerald Buncum tweaking ? Come on bruh Boozer? Really I’ll give you Deng other then that what other offense did the bulls have
Vlade Divac just got into the HoF. Ahead of C Webb. If Vlade gets in, how does D Rose not?
Vlade Divac was sick bro and stated playing before c webb lol .......... you prob just too young. you cant compare the two, but all should be in.
RBG RBG Divac is in for his international accomplishments and his contributions he’s made towards making the NBA global. It’s the Basketball HOF not NBA HOF.
Webber isn’t in (yet) because of the Michigan scandal that basically wiped his entire college career.
@@lacydoe Vlade Divac is hot garbage only thing he will be remembered for is being traded for Kobe 😂
TheNextgenballer ....... man I can’t stand Stans, don’t know anything about basketball and only knows the top players. It’s too sad.
Lacy Coleman what did vlade do in the NBA that qualifies for the HOF? He’s a career 11 and 8, no all star selections, no all nba teams beside the rookie team in 90. No dpoy awards, 6th man and he played at a time when the center position was very important and got worked by all of them. So unless u watched him play in Yugoslavia u sound dumb
He's a Hall of Famer no matter what ill still put my money on rose anytime 💯
D rose was the youngest mvp winner won roty and made the conference finals that's a hall of famer
what low standards the nba has. sure everyone should be in the HoF i guess
In the NBA, everyone gets to be in the HOF. Sounds a lot like the “everyone gets a trophy” people,
@boochtron Winning NBA MVP makes you a HOF dumbass. “LoW sTaNdArDs”, being the youngest MVP in NBA HISTORY
@globalicon2012 quitter? He was injured alot cause he went hard asf
@globalicon2012 you say that like a man that's never played basketball in their lives. What were you saying when KD was diagnosed with a torn achilles? That he shouldn't have played? Shame on you.
Vlade freaking divac made it HOF.....why not derrick rose ?
Vlade made it for contributions outside of what he did on the court.
Vlade is one of many international players who helped popularize the sport on an international level, especially in his home country, Serbia. Plus, Vlade was a great player in the Euroleague before he came to the NBA.
Other than win MVP, what has Rose done to warrant a HOF selection?
EyeLoveTheStars youngest mvp?
EyeLoveTheStars and has vlade won an mvp?
Vlade Divacs greatest contribution to basketball was getting traded for Kobe
I seen this man back in 2011 in a playoff game. Chicago vs Cavaliers
The man literally flew over everyone
I was going back in forth about this but I think he should. Especially the way he bounced back from everything he endured injury wise throughout his career and came back and balled out the way he did with the wolves, scoring 50 points, being a consistent contributor night in and night out, and never giving up.. to me that’s the epitome of someone that deserves to be in the hall of fame. And then being the youngest mvp of all time, several all star appearances BEFORE the age of what, 24, 25? An all NBA team.. that speaks for itself.
WEST ENGLEWOOD'S FINEST! THESE PEOPLE WILL NEVER KNOW HOW SPECIAL YOU HAVE TO BE TO MAKE IT OUT THAT PLACE!
Eric Clapmen man these people don’t even know
Facts bro
@Jack park there have been more players that are at roses level who have got in so yeah L
Jack park the ignorance is insane
So the youngest mvp of all time and the fact that’s he still showing flashes of that even after losing his knees and he’s not a hall of fame candidate?🤔😪
Exactly💯💯💯
@Nahbro Bro Where in the NBA bylaws does it say "you can't make the Hall of Fame off of 1 MVP season alone?"
Stop making Bullshyt up!
Rose's resume is already more impressive than Bill Walton's, Grant Hill & Tracy McGrady.
Rose is a surefire Hall of Famer, the only partly legit question scrubs can ask is will he be a first ballot HOF TEN YEARS FROM NOW when he's retired and eligible?
@1-800-Wavy 18ppg career average & that includes being wasted/misused out of position for 3 straight seasons.
Rose is ALREADY a lock for the Hall of Fame and the next few years is just icing on the cake.
Maison Frymier that's what I said bro they crazy he is a hof
He was one of the greatest in the league for 2-3 years and despite injuries is still putting up good numbers and more importantly people love him almost on the level that people love AI.
He deserves to be in the HoF one day. He was the most explosive point guard the NBA has ever seen. Youngest MVP ever, multi time all star, gold medalist, roty, carried the bulls through the playoffs and despite his many injuries still came back and put up good numbers.
The basketball HOF is a joke anyway, who TF cares
It is a joke
You stole that pic from Wilburgur.
In the nfl you can get in the hall of fame with stats and long jeporday with characteristics. Nba it's all about stats but you need long jeopardy of dominance. He was robbed for his prime because of injuries. The nba gods probably wont let him and but as a fan he deserves because of his talent. You can tell by an athlete who has the it factor and he had it
Not more of a joke then the baseball hall of fame tho.
@@boomboominroom The WWE Hall of Fame would like a word
Personally no. But there are so many mediocre players already in the hall of fame that he has to make it.
Mo Pie thats kinda the whole reason he said Personally.... ya know.... bc its HIS opinion... just like you had yours
im a rose fan since '10. its been a decade. still hes my favorite player of all time. he deserves to be a HOF
I’m 24 years old, and from Chicago. Derrick Rose is a hall of famer in my mind and a legend in this city forever
YOUNGEST MVP of all time.. put some respect on his name
Lol youngest mvp now go ahead and tell me what he did after winning mvp at 22 years..Absolutely nothing of all star caliber play. Might as well consider Jeremy Lin for the hall of fame then if you think Rose a sure shock hall of famer lol
Grant Hill gets in, so does Derrick Rose.
Jason Derrick rose was the youngest player to win MVP, and ROTY did grant hill achieve those ?
Dammit you took my point., Andrew. Not deleting now.
@@kiddox4015 Grant had co-rookie of the year with Jason Kidd. Grant Hill was also one of the top small forwards in the 90s alongside Scottie Pippen. 7x all-star and 5 all-nba teams. If D-Rose has a couple more solid seasons he'll be a hall of famer. As of right now, he is not.
*Drops mic*
@@kiddox4015 the only thing rose has over hill is the MVP title
who's this guy saying DRose just doesn't have enough for him to in the HOF? Did he do his research?
Not just MVP. He’s the Youngest MVP!!
WHY ARE WE EVEN TALKING ABOUT THIS. YES
Your standards are very low.
The HOF should be a big deal. When you allow D-Rose through on pity points, along with some of the other names in there already, it dilutes the purpose of any HOF.
solcreate Youngest League MVP, multiple all-star and all-NBA appearances, Rookie playoff scoring leader, two high school state championships, and an NCAA Finals appearance should be a big deal.
THANK YOU IM YELLING AS WELL
@Jack park He was MVP, every MVP deserves to be in the hall of fame
Jack park if you say no you stupid. D rose deserves it. Without him most people who like basketball wouldn’t like basketball.
Absolutely!! He was on the road to becoming the best PG ever! Until injury. Battled through injury and still play in the NBA!
Growing in the 100s in chicago I hear about him when I was in fourth grade(when he was in sixth Grade) going to Beasley. I have seen him play at Siemon as I went to a rival school and he put up points easily...to Chicago, he is an MVP and always our MVP.
It's the BASKETBALL HOF, not NBA HOF. 2-time Illinois High school state champion and Mr. Basketball, lead Memphis to championship game (technically wiped out because of ineligibility), NBA Rookie of the Year, YOUNGEST MVP in history at age 22, lead Bulls to best regular season record in NBA in back-to-back seasons (no allstar teammates besides Deng in 2012). Don't forget that he's a cultural icon in Chicago and Asia. The stuff he accomplished in his prime (2009-2012) is more than what guys like CP3 or Melo have accomplished in their NBA careers technically. Sometimes quality > quantity
Definite hall of Famer. He was a state legend on the high school level. Had a college season. Had a great NBA career until injuries. Youngest to ever win MVP in the NBA. That's a basketball hall of famer. Dominated every level of basketball he's played on
Preach!
Yes.. Simple he got an mvp. He lead the bulls to multiple playoff runs.He inspired me especially since I live in Chicago to play. He played through injuries leading the bulls mentally.
I'm sorry, mvp of the nba should make the basketball hall of fame a sure thing
Because basketball hof is easy to get into but boi didn’t do much in his nba career
joseph Henry man your wrong
LimaBean Lowry He only had like 3 good seasons
LimaBean Lowry how much of an impact to the NBA and the teams he’s played for has he made post injuries?
@@user-jc2ng2xd9n Kobe said he was few of the young players he respected lebron calls him a hero steph calls him a legend anyone in the league calls him hof worthy and has one of the most impressive and inspiring stories so yeah he had a great impact
If you are an MVP you are a hall of famer no question
Youngest mvp of all time and still goin strong hes a Hall of Famer
If he was going strong like being a top 20 player in the game then yeah but he's not
If Yao and T-mac made it then D-Rose should be HOF!
Dumb comparison
Tyrone Grant dumb face
Yao is in there because of "international impact". Basically, he's Chinese and the NBA wants to capitalize on that market, so they let him in to increase the popularity of the game over there. Derrick Rose is not an international player, so you cannot compare the two.
T-Mac made it because of his longevity. T-Mac sustained a high level of offensive output for several seasons before he got injured. His numbers are significantly more impressive than D-Rose's though he did not experience as much playoff success. Hall of Fame induction is more predicated on numbers than, non-championship playoff success.
D-Rose is more comparable to Penny Hardaway, who was a great player, but is not in the Hall of fame due to lack of longevity. They have similar numbers and similar playoff success. D-Rose's only viable argument is that he won an MVP award.
I personally think he deserves to get in based off of his talent alone. I think he would be a top 5 player today and top 20 all time had he never gotten injured.
Top 20 all time is an insult. He'd be the best pg of all time and top 5player no question
James Taylor Yao and T-Mac despite their injuries they managed to have 7-8 great seasons playing at an All Star level. Yao is an 8x All Star, T-Mac is a 7x All Star. D-Rose is what...3x All Star??
Put my boi in man I wish hed get one ring before he retires. Been of fan of rose since he came outta Memphis. I tore my acl and it fluffed me up mentally I didn't play a lick of high school football. This man came back relentless time after time giving all he had cant nobody question his heart
Amin nailed it when he said he's a first ballot hall of famer in life, whether or not he makes it into the basketball hall of fame, he will always be looked upto, especially when we are down in our life and look for some inspiration
Yea Derrick rose is a HOF maybe 3rd or 4th ballot.
Ikr
1st ballot
@@allen62 is CP3 an MVP?
@@TheIcemanthomas Delusional rose stans smh
CPGoat #3 FACTS
He should make it. Obviously his career path and postseason success wasn’t ideal but he’s got the accolades
Like wat
The only relevant accolade he has is mvp
Without a doubt hall of famer. Dude had one of The worst injuries and came back playing like a 6th man of the year, could even start if u say he shouldn’t u a hater and don’t like basketball🤷🏾♂️
Rose will always be Chi-town royalty. If the NBA is too stuck up to put him in HOF, then he is too good for it 💪🏽
Well the best bull ever (Brian scalabrine) isn’t even in the HOF so I wouldn’t be surprised if rose gets snubbed 🤷🏼♂️
Good point
But the 2nd best in MJ is in the HoF
D Rose was not even better than Scottie Pippen how is he the best to play with the Bulls
@@winstonsmith8867 😐 cant tell if you slow or you trollin but either way it aint funny.
Tf they acting like D-Rose not better than maybe half of the players in the HOF
One thing to be good and one thing to accomplish things for years straight
hes not lol
@Nahbro Bro Drazen Petrovic,Bill Walton,Frank Ramsey,Arvydas Sabonis, and Bill Bradley they didn't have a hall of fame career yet they made the hof....
D Rose would be a healthier player if Tom didn’t wear him down every game. Luol Deng too
Bernard King had a similar career. Got taken out with an ACL injury, at a time when no one ever came back from that injury. Then he came back and put in some more work and made it to the HOF. D. Rose will definitely make it into the HOF.
0:08
ESPN fake news
He says " I'm a hall of famer, maybe NOT IN EVERYONES EYES."
ESPN with the nice edit
How is that an edit? It's in the chyron lol
Thank god someone else noticed that. ESPN do better.
Ricardo Aguinaga 😂
Stay woke 👀💯
We see that '...'
To be analyst on TV there dumb Derrick rose is 3xtime all start rookie of the year and the youngest player every to win the mvp award he is a hall of Famer foh
Imagine using the wrong their and calling someone dumb
Two great seasons does not get you in. No way
JAMES C facts that’s disrespectful to people who have been elite for 6+ years
TheHomieHiro it's safe to say Rose has been Elite for 5 years and counting
Anthony King hate to say it but only getting 3 Allstar appearances isn’t elite that’s something a Jeff Teague could do let’s put him in the HOF to then since we know if he starts on a team in the east he could make the Allstar team sometimes
Yeah. He was the youngest MVP in NBA HISTORY. I feel like when u make a solo milestone. YOU HAVE to be in. Same thing wit Devin Hester.
Troy God Devin Hester in The HOF is a big reach
Jabrony Lin how??? He has the record for the most return touchdowns in NFL history.
1000% not many players can go through what he has, could have been one of the goats in current time, but the fact he’s still here balling he deserves it
Drose is a HoF... if he didn’t get injured, he could’ve been one of the best players to play the game. he’s a HoF
Jake Miller but he did and so there are 3 great seasons to justify HOF status....no way that’s enough
Jhonathan Alarcon don’t forget about international tournaments along with his college season
Keep grinding
Thank you!
Dude, absolutely. We all know how good this man was. Only one thing stopped him. Youngest MVP in league history. He was that good and on that trajectory THAT early.
Youngest MVP in the NBA and was a major part of breaking an NCAA single season wins record (basketball hall of fame not NBA)
Olympic champion
Definitely hall of fame
I'm suprised Rachel Nichols didn't find away to bring up roses trial
She should have been fired for bringing that up on the day after he scored 50. Tried bringing a black man down while everyone was praising him smh
@Berlin Gray Go back and watch that clip again. It was brought up as a hardship he faced. Y’all are just sensitive.
@@jrthegoatsmith712 Naw she was insinuating that everybody was brushing over the fact that he just got out a rape case because he scored 50 the previous night. A case in which he was not found liable or guilty of before the season even started. It was petty and tasteless and she just couldn't let him have his moment to shine.
He’s a hall of famer no doubt! Quit Trippin’
derrick rose needs to add one more thing to the legacy. it can be anything it just has to be impactful in terms of winning. like an amazing playoff run and performance with the pistons
WITHOUT A DOUBT.
of course I would want rose to make it but like other people are saying getting into the hall-of fame requires you to have a great career not to just win a ring or one mvp.
like T-mac said anyone can win a ring looks at all the bums on the warriors that have rings because of Steph durant klay draymand but not everyone can make it to the hall of fame to make it I would say you have to at-least have 5 great years in your career you don't have to be great in you whole career but minimum at least five yers.
Bro he trippin, Rose is definitely a hall of famer.
not at all
He better be in, and I hope his jersey is in the rafters in Chicago. Period.
S.N- this is one of the best DRose comment threads I’ve seen in a while
He should get in.. that Gale Sayers comparison was spot on
He's definitely a HOF, the guy has been through a lot but bounced back
Grant hill is in 😂
They’re off that dog food
I'm not gonna say anything since I was never a D Rose fan in a sense where he's my fav player or watched him
I know of him seen him play and I have looked him up a bit for the last few months I can't say since I don't know all of his achievements but. With all that I know right now I think he should I mean guy has heart a lot of heart for the game and despite the Injuries i feel hes gettibf back to where he was before but I'll have to see this coming up season.
It’s great how everyone in the comments is a D 🌹 fan I’m no different at this point I don’t have a favorite team I reap rose going from Chicago to New York to Cleveland to Minnesota now to Detroit I wouldn’t be a interested in the nba if wasn’t for 🌹 so he most definitely deserves to be a HOF if not he is in my heart
He's arguably the most loved player of this generation, I am yet to meet a D. Rose hater. If Dwight Howard is a HoF'er then D. Rose should be too imo.
Dwight shouldn't make the HOF unless he returns to 2009 form and performs that way for another half-decade.
D-Rose should only make the HOF if he can return to a star presence for something like 5 years from this point on.
Fat chance. Luckily the HOF is a joke right now, so they may make it anyway.
@Michael Hart Howard had essentially a five-year prime, when considering offense and defense.
When his back started to rob him of his athleticism, he dropped off fast.
He always lacked any notable post-game offensively, and his prime didn't last long enough to justify a hall nod. If we pretend that the Hall of Fame isn't largely a joke in it's easy selection process.
The idea that what I'm saying is outlandish is asinine on your part.
5,6,7, years of dominant MVP production????
alot of current HOFs dont even have that
That's nowhere in the NBA bylaws. Amin is low basketball IQ + be making shyt up.
That's why he's never been invited back into a Front office
@dwade
i didnt say he did, the guy said that you need 5-7 years of MVP type of dominance to be in the HOF, and i said thats not true, because plenty of players dont have that, and ARE in the HOF
@dwade Never said that he did have 7 years of dominance, you clearly dont know what im talking about.
@dwade if you actually watched the video, you would know what im talking about. i was clearly refrencing what Amin said at 2:10
people who compares tmac with drose have no idea what kind of a beast tmac was in his prime. pure skills, that guy was a monster.
Simply put, yes.