@@deathslayer5813 yaa nd u being a famous writer knows everything...bullshit go nd do some usefull work..i kind of don't understand where people like u come from
I am a big fan of Mr. Bhagat and Mr. Hirani. Both have done no less than excellence. I have read the book twice and its my 13th night continuously of watching 3 idiots. I would say, Hirani has just used a framework of the story and i could say, its his story. I was hurt to see my here Mr. Bhagat going public and there was not the same smile on his face as in the books. Please Bhagat, don't change your image.you are a great writter but mr Hirani is the best script writter. you two r BST
No matter what anybody says, part of me says that Chetan acted naively when giving 'adaptation' rights away for this movie. He should have read the contract more carely, esp the part with 'rolling credits'. If such a contract is duly signed and executed by both parties on legal grounds, I don't think even the Writer's Guild would be able to get Mr. Hirani convicted in any civilized nation's legal system.
Chetan doesn't know the difference between a book and a screenplay. If he thinks 3 idiots was his story, let him write the screenplay for a movie and he will know. Raju Hirani has proven himself again and again through his films. Raju Hirani never asked to be awarded a booker prize for his movie. Why does Chetan want the best screenplay award for a film for which he did nothing other than hearing the script after it was written. Chetan was free to write screenplay himself if he was so confident.
@@dileepmuthireddy2462it's not exactly his story he just copied few elements.. Like 3 friends, iit , and suicide issue apart from that nothing is same. Those are just key elements Hirani modified into whole different story Hirani actually made gold out of trash So why the fuck he will get credit?
Read book before movie release and obviously have watched movie.. One can identify difference in storyline and plots... Chetan wanted to Crack a bigger deal which he failed to do at first place.. Anyways loved both versions.. Movie was more inspirational and nostalgic
It seems to me, the entire show was done as a markteting strategy which definitely came from the mastermind's Aamir Khan brains and too was also agreed with Chetan Bhagat in advance.
He should have been given credits among screenplay /writing /story ....such corrupted people. .no one can trust them.. including Aamir Khan ...same they did with Harinder Sikka. .author of raazi movie ..modified it giving it a Pakistani good angle. Nd he was not being given credits ...Meghna Gulzar got all of them ..😠😠👆👆👆
These Bollywood jokers always steal credit of the middle class self made people, they did the same with Sushant. They treat the media and common man as trash, they should know that they are nothing without the middle class people who watch their movies. These are extremely arrogant and selfish people.
@@manishkaushik4595Yeah, but "Adaption" without giving PROPER, ENOUGH and FULL "Credit" is no less than Copying, and to say it blunt it is worse than that, it's stealing the writer's entire life's work and his creative experience and expression and Stabbing him right in the back. But Indians in general and Morons like you won't even think or bother enough on these issues that Plague the Creative fabric of our country. And Mind you a story like 3 Idiots and 5 point someone can never be written in the wildest dreams of Hirani, Amir Khan and someone who hasn't experienced first hand the struggles and extreme pressures of being one in shoe of a Engineering aspirant...
@@test61280that basic trash plot doesnt mean shit when it comes to making movie😂 You gawars don't know shit about movie making😂😂 Apart from that siple plot There is dialgue writing, screenplay writing, script writing, and many more things That basic plot is like a drop ocean
Whatever Hirani said in this video is correct but he is cleverly deviating from the issue at hand. Hirani said the following points in the video: 1.They had bought the rights of the novel.This is true and Bhagat never denied that. 2.He gave him credit in the rolling credits as was promised. The issue is that when the movie's story is around 50% similar to the novel, the book's name and his name should have been at the top of the rolling credits not at the end just like all the movies which are based on a book. 3. He had narrated the entire script to Bhagat. Bhagat never denied that. What he had written in his blog is that " the script was never shown to him ". There is a big difference between narration of the script and the actual script being shown. Apart from this, Hirani and Abhijat Joshi are clearly trying to take the whole credit of the story as Bhagat's name is not mentioned in Story and Screenplay credits shown in the beginning of the film.
Chetan Bhagat is a management graduate. He deliberately created this controversy so that his name gets remembered and we foolish audience start buying his shitty books because we think he was the writer behind the greatest film of all times, 3 idiots. We fell for his marketing gimmick.
I think all fuss is because "Raju and his team trying to take complete credit at the beginning as if it is entirely his own work" Agreement and legal formalities are at its own place, but Raju should have generously said that we used Chetan's book to write the script for this movie, which wouldnt have belittled his achievements as a writer, but now he has to come out and yell to tell the truth and show agreement to the whole world. No doubt Raju and Chetan both are great writer.
hardly people remember the book, but most remember the movie, I read the book when I was in college, then I saw the movie. even after knowing that movie is based on the book, I have a faint memory of the book
thats not the point....the point is that they had made an aggrement to put his name on rolling titles which Bhagat agreed to...and now that this film has become a blockbuster, he is whining
I love raju hirani , but rights were bought for 10 lakh ruppes and movie made 100 crore plus on basis of that story so raji should show some respect and give bhagat some more more as a token of appreciation.
Actually, the thing is that after 3 idiots becoming such a great Blockbuster, Chetan must have felt that what if his name had come in the starting of the movie, so he is speaking senseless things like these......,,,,,,,,,
Book and movie are very different from each other, that is where the problem lies. When an author of a novel sees that the movie made on it does not match his story, he is obviously hurt. There are certain instances from the novel that have been included in the movie, and that's all, and this is what pissed Chetan Bhagat. Actually, the contract between the two parties was itself faulty. It should not have been written there that the movie is based on the novel, but that certain aspects of/in the movie have been taken from the novel, and not the entire novel itself; or that the movie is 'inspired' by the novel, and not 'based on' the novel. Since this did not happen, that's why the controversy arose. As someone who has both read the novel and seen the movie, I was definitely disappointed when I compared both of them. But watching the movie alone, while remembering some scenes from the novel here and there, I was impressed with the movie.
Slumdog Millionaire was a modified adaptation of Vikas Swarup' s Q & A. But when the film received an Award,Danny Boyle called each and every cast and the Novelist Vikas Swarup on the stage to receive the Oscar and also acknowledged him in whole heartedly. This is their culture and what these three idiots(Aamir,Raju,Vidhu Vinod) did is India's Naked and Barbaric Face. I agree that Aamir is one of the Versatile Actors but,I also agree that he is the most credit hungry actor.
i think the story of book was better than the film, i saw the film first then read the book but raju has modified the story beautifully and i think if book plot was to be taken than it could have not been a success
Chetan just didnt understand what rolling credit means. He should have had it put in the contract that he would like a single credit of his name and title of his book just before the movie title appears on screen. Eg: Bram Stokers Dracule , JRR tolkiens Lord of the Rings. Or the way Spielberg did it with Jurrasic Park by putting Michael Crichton name before title appears onscreen.
EVERYONE and i Mean EVERYONE who has read the book and LOVED THE MOVIE...( its touched and shaken my heart ) know what is the truth...they absolutely know what is true n who playing games using the media.. so whatever it is..3 IDIOTS WILL BE LOVED AND CHERISHED FOREVER AND EVER AND EVER......
@narenreddy7: I honestly read the story from bangalore to chennai, when i travelling in train. I got really excited reading it. It is original story happened in the life chetan and his friends. If i were a hirani, i would have displayed cheat bhagat's name in front of movie as like holly wood movies and given due credit to him as per the global standard. We will not emerge as global power, untill if we start comparing the global method/process. This applies to everyone and everywhere.
if i would have been chetan i wouldnt have accepted the contract. yes it would have been nice of director to give credit to mr bhagar in the poster of the film in bold letters but you cant blame him on that part. that is just a mere suggestion
Ya start of the film shows amir khan and all , end shows Rajkumar and all..Atleast after the last scene first name after hirani should had been of Chetan..anyways he got noticed because of noise he made
A good film - must watch category - two commends : Amir should not go to the inside the hospital with his scooter and Parents may agree to whatever their children likes but only after completing the studies - Nandakumar
I dont know what really went wrong and where but when you show the facts, proofs and evidence its much more believeable. Raju's explanation was flawless. With you on all you said Raju!
For a billionaire like Raju Hirani and Vidhu Vinod Chopra,it was easy to buy rights of 5 point someone in some 10-15 Lakhs. But it was difficult for Raju and Vidhu Vinod Chopra to wholeheartedly acknowledge Chetan' s work. As doing so would have taken the camera away from Aamir Khan,who was posing as an idiot. And one more thing,when Aamir can hide his marriage for Carrier,he can left his kids for another girl then this film and rolling credits is very lame issue.
How often we see people who so easily become disgrace .. Chetan Bhagat lost all his credibility as an author by making such tardy allegations .. I think in today's world people are so insecure that they want to cash in at every single opportunity by stopping low to any level ..
He should have been given credits among screenplay /writing /story ....such corrupted people. .no one can trust them.. including Aamir Khan ...same they did with Harinder Sikka. .author of raazi movie ..modified it giving it a Pakistani good angle. Nd he was not being given credits ...Meghna Gulzar got all of them ..😠😠👆👆👆..3 idiots is exactly a copy of Five point someone ..i read novel before watching movie ....these Bollywood people are so corrupt .. 😏😏😏
Aamir khan said in his interview that its your original story .. but i've read the book movie is more than 50% copied as it is, I agree you have worked hard making the movie ..but story credit should be given to him. that's how you make the people fool by giving lollypop ..and legally they cant do anything..
yes u are right,the novel came first and the movie makers have very intelligently kept the storyline different so that no one could question them !! but in reality they have cheated Bhagat,as he never knew that the movie would be such a success earning 200+cr but u pay him 10lacs😠😠 those who have read the novel would know that some of the scenes are directly picked from the novel , even the dialogues are word to word copied!! Even the scenes which are different are somewhat inspired from the novel😠!
Devashish Gupta exactly man.. thought the secen about when Hari got Alok's home to eat..the argument between Alok and his mother....and in the film they three got at Raju's home..and that same argument..they also copied lots of more besides this one..
Devashish Gupta are he bought tge rights, so he had full right to use dialogues from book.and if Chetan Bhagat wanted his name to be at beginning why didn't he say so before signing contract
I read the book Five points..... everything is same in 3 idiots... and not even mentioned credit for author... amit khan is a liar.... #justice for sushant
Mr. Hirani if you bought the book, that doesn't mean you own it. Why isthat the trophies for the story didn't go-to Chetan Bhagat? Now I feel entire Bollywood is a shitty corrupted place.
rajkumar jee, bas lage rahiye, in sab baaton se aapka respect hamare dil me thoda bhi kam nahi hota. aapke jo kaam karne ka anokha andaaz hai wo kabhi badaliyega nahi. best wishes.
once the rights have been bought, you have no right over its adaptation of the film. a film and a book are two different media. and adaptation occurs only when you want to make it the way YOU want to make it. there are many songs which are adapted and made into their own too. i am not talking about stealing , but adapting a particular tune. for which rights a first purchased by the ones who want to remake it. your opinion is not completely truthful. thanks.
@jajnsc : There was no discussion about the chetan asking for more money. He was explaining about the display of the name in the front of the movie..Just forget hirani or chetan and the documents. The story originality is taken from chetan. And generally every movies in the developed world are following like displaying the author's name in front of movies.Then why you follow this crooked method?. this is what am saying indian mentality.
Now i get it, they bought the story from Chetan seems Chetan remained gullible towards Hirani...expecting them to justify the movie but the movie makers betrayed Chetan which shld not have been done as to protect the story they just moulded the story for it bein a commercial success but that's not fair at all I am with Chetan on this!!!
Most possibly this is a PUBLICITY STUNT by the makers of movie and the author. Vidhu Chopra and Raju Hirani even during the launch of PK had fabricated the news of controversy of protests arising due to the religion angle. That was more of a shell company which existed only on print and not in reality
Rolling Credits ...only Not fair...Was Bhagat sleeping while signing the contract ? By the time rolling credits start..only humans present in cinema hall are elders who anyway can not see clearly what is rolling on the screen.
Bhagat became greedy, after the movie became a money spinner. If it had flopped, like his other books 'One night at the call center' made as movie Hello by the Salman Khan siblings, he would have kept his mouth shut.
Normally in hollywood movies the author are shown on the movies when it starts. Why the same method is not followed in 3-idiots. Per chetan, it seems the name is added along with other artists which is bad. I think, we all know indian mentality right?. It is clearly known the quality of current generation of directors and actors. But, the bad part is chetan getting down to their level and speaking is the bad part. It is the fate of India and Indians of not respecting the truth b4 2000 years
Cheat is an MBA from IIM he knew where exactly his name is going to be appeared, apart from that when the book is sold he has no right to claim credit what so ever. its like i buy a t-shirt then i can do whatever i want to do with it. I know how these corporate mba minds are, not that m defending bolywd, but in this case chetan is acting like a mba to make more business for his book and fame
This film is totally a masterpiece 🔥
Now Mr Hirani have to apologise for making a better story than chetan himself
@@deathslayer5813 yaa nd u being a famous writer knows everything...bullshit go nd do some usefull work..i kind of don't understand where people like u come from
Seriously, have you ever read 5 point someone. Novel is 10 time better than this Film
@@naveenparashar764 I have read the novel. No, it is not 10 times better than the film. You have bad taste in novels.
This movie is highly unrealistic. Read the book and understand reality. Don't live in fantasy Bollywood world
@@k.nsingh1160 btw he wasn't that famous in 2009
Who is here after watching only Desi revisit.???
Ur hot
@@chiranjeevsahoo1422 typically indian😌
Lmao me
@@shankar719 😂
Lodoo lodoo lodoo
Its still the best movie in Bollywood history.
Hirani sir.. You are the reason I wanted to become a script writer💗
I am a big fan of Mr. Bhagat and Mr. Hirani.
Both have done no less than excellence.
I have read the book twice and its my 13th night continuously of watching 3 idiots.
I would say, Hirani has just used a framework of the story and i could say, its his story.
I was hurt to see my here Mr. Bhagat going public and there was not the same smile on his face as in the books.
Please Bhagat, don't change your image.you are a great writter but mr Hirani is the best script writter.
you two r BST
No matter what anybody says, part of me says that Chetan acted naively when giving 'adaptation' rights away for this movie. He should have read the contract more carely, esp the part with 'rolling credits'. If such a contract is duly signed and executed by both parties on legal grounds, I don't think even the Writer's Guild would be able to get Mr. Hirani convicted in any civilized nation's legal system.
Are you alive
Are you??? We are concern!
(sigh)He was a gud guy
Chetan doesn't know the difference between a book and a screenplay. If he thinks 3 idiots was his story, let him write the screenplay for a movie and he will know. Raju Hirani has proven himself again and again through his films. Raju Hirani never asked to be awarded a booker prize for his movie. Why does Chetan want the best screenplay award for a film for which he did nothing other than hearing the script after it was written. Chetan was free to write screenplay himself if he was so confident.
Bikram Bab coz he is #chutiya Bhagat...
Chetan was taking about all the awards that the movie got for best story...
Brilliantly explained
Chetan is also screen writer they didnt approach him 😂
@@dileepmuthireddy2462it's not exactly his story he just copied few elements.. Like 3 friends, iit , and suicide issue apart from that nothing is same. Those are just key elements
Hirani modified into whole different story
Hirani actually made gold out of trash
So why the fuck he will get credit?
Read book before movie release and obviously have watched movie..
One can identify difference in storyline and plots...
Chetan wanted to Crack a bigger deal which he failed to do at first place.. Anyways loved both versions.. Movie was more inspirational and nostalgic
It seems to me, the entire show was done as a markteting strategy which definitely came from the mastermind's Aamir Khan brains and too was also agreed with Chetan Bhagat in advance.
Completely agree with you.
He should have been given credits among screenplay /writing /story ....such corrupted people. .no one can trust them.. including Aamir Khan ...same they did with Harinder Sikka. .author of raazi movie ..modified it giving it a Pakistani good angle. Nd he was not being given credits ...Meghna Gulzar got all of them ..😠😠👆👆👆
These Bollywood jokers always steal credit of the middle class self made people, they did the same with Sushant. They treat the media and common man as trash, they should know that they are nothing without the middle class people who watch their movies. These are extremely arrogant and selfish people.
Areee mxxds
Why?? They adopted n adoption n copy is different. He has answered with proofs n agreements. Don't you have brain to understand that??
@@manishkaushik4595Yeah, but "Adaption" without giving PROPER, ENOUGH and FULL "Credit" is no less than Copying, and to say it blunt it is worse than that, it's stealing the writer's entire life's work and his creative experience and expression and Stabbing him right in the back.
But Indians in general and Morons like you won't even think or bother enough on these issues that Plague the Creative fabric of our country.
And Mind you a story like 3 Idiots and 5 point someone can never be written in the wildest dreams of Hirani, Amir Khan and someone who hasn't experienced first hand the struggles and extreme pressures of being one in shoe of a Engineering aspirant...
@@test61280that basic trash plot doesnt mean shit when it comes to making movie😂
You gawars don't know shit about movie making😂😂
Apart from that siple plot There is dialgue writing, screenplay writing, script writing, and many more things
That basic plot is like a drop ocean
Whatever Hirani said in this video is correct but he is cleverly deviating from the issue at hand.
Hirani said the following points in the video:
1.They had bought the rights of the novel.This is true and Bhagat never denied that.
2.He gave him credit in the rolling credits as was promised. The issue is that when the movie's story is around 50% similar to the novel, the book's name and his name should have been at the top of the rolling credits not at the end just like all the movies which are based on a book.
3. He had narrated the entire script to Bhagat. Bhagat never denied that. What he had written in his blog is that " the script was never shown to him ". There is a big difference between narration of the script and the actual script being shown.
Apart from this, Hirani and Abhijat Joshi are clearly trying to take the whole credit of the story as Bhagat's name is not mentioned in Story and Screenplay credits shown in the beginning of the film.
There is huge difference between writing a story and a movie screenplay or script 😂
In contract they have agreed that credit will be given at end then why should they give it at beginning?
Chetan Bhagat is a management graduate. He deliberately created this controversy so that his name gets remembered and we foolish audience start buying his shitty books because we think he was the writer behind the greatest film of all times, 3 idiots. We fell for his marketing gimmick.
U r really a great thinker and fact oriented, I just became ur fan just reading this beautiful comment.
Are di but satya to yahi he na ki 3 idiots ki story chetan sir ki hi thi 🙄
Pyaari behna aapko kuch pataa to hai nahi bus kuch nhi comment me huge jaa rahi ho
Sir can I send would video jisme apane kaha Tha ki ftii me ek ladke jagah pe learn Karn jata dusare. ke naam pe plz plz very argent
I think all fuss is because "Raju and his team trying to take complete credit at the beginning as if it is entirely his own work" Agreement and legal formalities are at its own place, but Raju should have generously said that we used Chetan's book to write the script for this movie, which wouldnt have belittled his achievements as a writer, but now he has to come out and yell to tell the truth and show agreement to the whole world. No doubt Raju and Chetan both are great writer.
Hi
it definitely changed my life
Why this recommend after 9 year 🤔
hardly people remember the book, but most remember the movie, I read the book when I was in college, then I saw the movie. even after knowing that movie is based on the book, I have a faint memory of the book
thats not the point....the point is that they had made an aggrement to put his name on rolling titles which Bhagat agreed to...and now that this film has become a blockbuster, he is whining
They did lol.. Don't believe this joker😂
He just want clout
It's not about agreement... But it's about grace... Do these people don't not have enough grace to give a person his due credit...
Loser
You're a loser and a twat saksam sharam or whatever ur name is.
He is given due credit in the rolling credits
They gave credit to him.. Lol😂
This happens when u comment without doing proper home work😂😂
Mujhe kya, as an audience we just want entertainment not controversy (those who want controversy are fools) and we got it.
The movie is anyway much better than the book
The original author's attitude reminds me of Aesop's fable 'Sour Grapes'
I love raju hirani , but rights were bought for 10 lakh ruppes and movie made 100 crore plus on basis of that story so raji should show some respect and give bhagat some more more as a token of appreciation.
No. What if it becomes flop. With Chetan return money. The film makers are risk taker, they have the rights to get higher profits
It gave Bhagat the popularity worth 100 crores
whatever book shit and movie awesome
If book wouldn't come out 3 idiots wouldn't have been there 😂
True like i thought its the same story when i read the book.. It was so bad
Actually, the thing is that after 3 idiots becoming such a great Blockbuster, Chetan must have felt that what if his name had come in the starting of the movie, so he is speaking senseless things like these......,,,,,,,,,
Book and movie are very different from each other, that is where the problem lies. When an author of a novel sees that the movie made on it does not match his story, he is obviously hurt. There are certain instances from the novel that have been included in the movie, and that's all, and this is what pissed Chetan Bhagat. Actually, the contract between the two parties was itself faulty. It should not have been written there that the movie is based on the novel, but that certain aspects of/in the movie have been taken from the novel, and not the entire novel itself; or that the movie is 'inspired' by the novel, and not 'based on' the novel. Since this did not happen, that's why the controversy arose. As someone who has both read the novel and seen the movie, I was definitely disappointed when I compared both of them. But watching the movie alone, while remembering some scenes from the novel here and there, I was impressed with the movie.
This is the flim which made me strong....
Slumdog Millionaire was a modified adaptation of Vikas Swarup' s Q & A.
But when the film received an Award,Danny Boyle called each and every cast and the Novelist Vikas Swarup on the stage to receive the Oscar and also acknowledged him in whole heartedly.
This is their culture and what these three idiots(Aamir,Raju,Vidhu Vinod) did is India's Naked and Barbaric Face.
I agree that Aamir is one of the Versatile Actors but,I also agree that he is the most credit hungry actor.
i think the story of book was better than the film, i saw the film first then read the book but raju has modified the story beautifully and i think if book plot was to be taken than it could have not been a success
Chetan just didnt understand what rolling credit means. He should have had it put in the contract that he would like a single credit of his name and title of his book just before the movie title appears on screen.
Eg: Bram Stokers Dracule , JRR tolkiens Lord of the Rings. Or the way Spielberg did it with Jurrasic Park by putting Michael Crichton name before title appears onscreen.
0:10 only desi?
loda people
EVERYONE and i Mean EVERYONE who has read the book and LOVED THE MOVIE...( its touched and shaken my heart ) know what is the truth...they absolutely know what is true n who playing games using the media.. so whatever it is..3 IDIOTS WILL BE LOVED AND CHERISHED FOREVER AND EVER AND EVER......
@narenreddy7: I honestly read the story from bangalore to chennai, when i travelling in train. I got really excited reading it. It is original story happened in the life chetan and his friends.
If i were a hirani, i would have displayed cheat bhagat's name in front of movie as like holly wood movies and given due credit to him as per the global standard.
We will not emerge as global power, untill if we start comparing the global method/process. This applies to everyone and everywhere.
if i would have been chetan i wouldnt have accepted the contract. yes it would have been nice of director to give credit to mr bhagar in the poster of the film in bold letters but you cant blame him on that part. that is just a mere suggestion
Ya start of the film shows amir khan and all , end shows Rajkumar and all..Atleast after the last scene first name after hirani should had been of Chetan..anyways he got noticed because of noise he made
It has indeed revolutionarised the Mindset of Millions
I wonder what would happen to Chetan Bhagat if Stanley Kubrick adapted one of his novels 🤣
That would be a fun thing to witness lmao
A good film - must watch category - two commends : Amir should not go to the inside the hospital with his scooter and Parents may agree to whatever their children likes but only after completing the studies - Nandakumar
0:10 😂😂😂
Cake banne se pehle makkhi aate pe nahi baithti hai...jab cake ban jata hai tab baithne ki koshish karti hai...
makkhi = Chetan Bhagat
Anyone from only desi?? Just here to hear him saying lodof instead of lots of 😂😂
endia tatti accent
Waiting for 4idiots or sequel of 3idiot but with the same cast
Sir please go for sequel
Who is watching this hit Movie 🍿🎥 in 2021😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
"Lot of "
Chetan can do a role of chatur
Oh yes lol🤣🤣🤣
Yes his voice and stubbornness is much like chatur.
That Guy is still crying about it, It's unfortunate. Chetan Bhagat is still claiming, even when the movie is so different than his book
Abe jaake book padh le pahle...more than 80% is same...ullu kahin ka...
Bina buddhi ke moorakh....pehle jaake book padh !!!
Usne contract sign kiya hai na bro@@dt9869
IIT iim se padha hai chetan teri terah gadha nhi hai
Content same hi hein..thora sa change hein.. blind hone ki jarurat nahi hein bro
What ever the book is the reality and the movie is same what Bollywood shows..a fantasy which never become a reality.
3 idiots is gem of Indian cinema
5 point someone is nice book but if you ask me, munshi Premchand short stories are more engaging
Sir plzzz 3idiot series ki next movie banaiye
"Lot of......" - Only Desi,2019
Karma exist , you wil face music soon mr Hirani .
He did not do anything wrong
Film is muchhh better than the novel
3:19 we have not Storen stoly 😂 instead of stolen story
YES YES YES
*Dont worry for the future *Follow your heart *Be Honest *Love your God/Family/Friend *Enjoy your life today. #3idiots Thanks.
What about Sonam Wangchuk? Is the bio of Fungsuk Wangru inspired by him or any idea?
I dont know what really went wrong and where but when you show the facts, proofs and evidence its much more believeable.
Raju's explanation was flawless. With you on all you said Raju!
Anyone knew it in 2018?
His name was not shown at the beginning of the film.Looks like thats what has hurt him so much
For a billionaire like Raju Hirani and Vidhu Vinod Chopra,it was easy to buy rights of 5 point someone in some 10-15 Lakhs.
But it was difficult for Raju and Vidhu Vinod Chopra to wholeheartedly acknowledge Chetan' s work.
As doing so would have taken the camera away from Aamir Khan,who was posing as an idiot.
And one more thing,when Aamir can hide his marriage for Carrier,he can left his kids for another girl then this film and rolling credits is very lame issue.
How the fuck did they became billionaires😂 even amir khan is not a billionaire😂
First of all, learn how to pronounce "lot's of"
Mere paas porei kahani tayyar hai aap bas no dedo mai contect kar longa
You look so hurt..don't be you did a amazing job...kudos to your team
If Chetan could write such an amazing book he could have written many more with Raju and become an integral part of Raju’s team and progressed well.
After 3 idiots it's come only pk 😇😊🙂☺
2019?
How often we see people who so easily become disgrace .. Chetan Bhagat lost all his credibility as an author by making such tardy allegations .. I think in today's world people are so insecure that they want to cash in at every single opportunity by stopping low to any level ..
You should have to give him
B͜͡u͜͡t͜͡ ͜͡3͜͡ ͜͡i͜͡d͜͡i͜͡o͜͡t͜͡s͜͡ ͜͡m͜͡o͜͡v͜͡i͜͡e͜͡ ͜͡i͜͡s͜͡ ͜͡e͜͡m͜͡o͜͡t͜͡i͜͡o͜͡n͜͡ ♥️
RK hirani is a honest man and fabulous director he doesn't need to stole some one's story
He is cheap person
He should have been given credits among screenplay /writing /story ....such corrupted people. .no one can trust them.. including Aamir Khan ...same they did with Harinder Sikka. .author of raazi movie ..modified it giving it a Pakistani good angle. Nd he was not being given credits ...Meghna Gulzar got all of them ..😠😠👆👆👆..3 idiots is exactly a copy of Five point someone ..i read novel before watching movie ....these Bollywood people are so corrupt .. 😏😏😏
Ok thanks
Aamir khan said in his interview that its your original story .. but i've read the book movie is more than 50% copied as it is, I agree you have worked hard making the movie ..but story credit should be given to him. that's how you make the people fool by giving lollypop ..and legally they cant do anything..
But u should have given him a credit saying " From Chetan Bhagat - Five Point Someone"
yes u are right,the novel came first and the movie makers have very intelligently kept the storyline different so that no one could question them !!
but in reality they have cheated Bhagat,as he never knew that the movie would be such a success earning 200+cr but u pay him 10lacs😠😠 those who have read the novel would know that some of the scenes are directly picked from the novel , even the dialogues are word to word copied!! Even the scenes which are different are somewhat inspired from the novel😠!
+Ajay Dahiya u r right. Look at Hirani's work throughout and abhijaat joshi's work.
I've read the book and it's only 5% of Chetan's.
Devashish Gupta exactly man.. thought the secen about when Hari got Alok's home to eat..the argument between Alok and his mother....and in the film they three got at Raju's home..and that same argument..they also copied lots of more besides this one..
Watch the video properly man and then talk
Devashish Gupta are he bought tge rights, so he had full right to use dialogues from book.and if Chetan Bhagat wanted his name to be at beginning why didn't he say so before signing contract
I read the book Five points..... everything is same in 3 idiots... and not even mentioned credit for author... amit khan is a liar....
#justice for sushant
He is showing literally agreement of buying book rights still you wanna be blind then nault is of them bro👏🏻
Jaake end credit dekh le 3 idiots ke bhai Sushant ke naam pe bakchodi mat kr
Bevkuf ho kya
Chetan bhagat just wanted to take 💯% credit for the whole film so he made all eligations
Good job raj kumar Hirani ji and Vidhu vinod Chopra ji.
Mr. Hirani if you bought the book, that doesn't mean you own it. Why isthat the trophies for the story didn't go-to Chetan Bhagat? Now I feel entire Bollywood is a shitty corrupted place.
He didn't bought the book helloooo he bought the rights means he can use it and thats what he did.....what wrong he had done
His movie is better
PLEASE UPLOAD THE FULL MOVIE ALREADY!!! YOU SAID YOU WOULD>>> NOW DELIVER!
Only some of the scenes from the book were taken. The book and the movie was completely different, based on what moral they wanted to convey
Who came here after watching 3 idiots review of Only Desi?
Chetan Bhatgat is not an idiot, the one who wrote is the biggest idiot. You should have the mentality to learn something from the film.
this is what happens when a innocent gets trapped ...... rolling and static,,,,,,,, he will say what the hell ???
rajkumar jee, bas lage rahiye, in sab baaton se aapka respect hamare dil me thoda bhi kam nahi hota. aapke jo kaam karne ka anokha andaaz hai wo kabhi badaliyega nahi. best wishes.
watch the movie "Patch Adams" again, and it might sink into you.
Jai Ram Ji Ge.
once the rights have been bought, you have no right over its adaptation of the film. a film and a book are two different media. and adaptation occurs only when you want to make it the way YOU want to make it. there are many songs which are adapted and made into their own too. i am not talking about stealing , but adapting a particular tune. for which rights a first purchased by the ones who want to remake it. your opinion is not completely truthful. thanks.
Who said they have no right to adapt into film?
THE BOOK HAS ITS OWN CHARM >>>
@jajnsc : There was no discussion about the chetan asking for more money. He was explaining about the display of the name in the front of the movie..Just forget hirani or chetan and the documents. The story originality is taken from chetan. And generally every movies in the developed world are following like displaying the author's name in front of movies.Then why you follow this crooked method?. this is what am saying indian mentality.
@prkrules : Well said!
Now i get it, they bought the story from Chetan seems Chetan remained gullible towards Hirani...expecting them to justify the movie but the movie makers betrayed Chetan which shld not have been done as to protect the story they just moulded the story for it bein a commercial success but that's not fair at all I am with Chetan on this!!!
herro handsome his book was crap..if they didn't moulded the story, movie would have flopped
Most possibly this is a PUBLICITY STUNT by the makers of movie and the author. Vidhu Chopra and Raju Hirani even during the launch of PK had fabricated the news of controversy of protests arising due to the religion angle. That was more of a shell company which existed only on print and not in reality
ksneha50 U R RIGHT
chetan is playing politics after all he is from soil of politics delhi
personal view
Chetan Bhagat is such a big hypocrite ..
have u read the book?? I think u are an idiot to comment that ,they have very intelligently cheated Bhagat😠;!!!!!!!!
u r absolutely right. Look at Hirani's work throughout and abhijaat joshi's work.
I've read the book and it's only 5% of Chetan's.
reverend900 exactly... the book is amazing..and the flim also..but the flim got the idea from the book... I do think they cheated bhagat ...
Sneha Ghosh wtf? these kiddos don't know anything about "Agreement" or NDA😑
Rolling Credits ...only Not fair...Was Bhagat sleeping while signing the contract ? By the time rolling credits start..only humans present in cinema hall are elders who anyway can not see clearly what is rolling on the screen.
Raj Kumar Hirani never cheat anyone
Bhagat became greedy, after the movie became a money spinner. If it had flopped, like his other books 'One night at the call center' made as movie Hello by the Salman Khan siblings, he would have kept his mouth shut.
Normally in hollywood movies the author are shown on the movies when it starts. Why the same method is not followed in 3-idiots. Per chetan, it seems the name is added along with other artists which is bad.
I think, we all know indian mentality right?. It is clearly known the quality of current generation of directors and actors. But, the bad part is chetan getting down to their level and speaking is the bad part.
It is the fate of India and Indians of not respecting the truth b4 2000 years
could be a possibility.. but someone of aamir khan's stature will indulge in this kind of gimmicks.
Hi after 12 years
Cheat is an MBA from IIM he knew where exactly his name is going to be appeared, apart from that when the book is sold he has no right to claim credit what so ever. its like i buy a t-shirt then i can do whatever i want to do with it. I know how these corporate mba minds are, not that m defending bolywd, but in this case chetan is acting like a mba to make more business for his book and fame