@@SYNAGATES did you know that Harvard has done a study recently on how spanking a child activates the same part of the brain that sexual assault activates?.
split is definitely harmful, but tbh i would trust anyone in my system around him as a therapist it's,,, some of this seems wrong? actually, a lot of this seems wrong -dark
To "alternate personalities that often" is possible, especially if the therapist is inexperienced and communication between alters starts. For this not to get out of control, causing confusion and fear, it's a must for therapists to have some idea of what can happen (hearing voices), if this is not something the alters experienced before.
So true. Despite having very hard multiple choice tests he was still my favorite Prof at McMaster because he was always excited to talk about psychology.
@@elpsykoongro5379 meh, "normal" humans can learn martial arts, parkour, ballet and take enhancement drugs to become "roid rage monsters". So its not far out there really, not to mention millions of soldiers become bulletproof just by putting on body armor. Sooo, the real question is: who would win in a fight, " The beast" or "captain america"?
Finally Some Systems Speaking In This Comment Section Speaking About How Wrong This Movie Is, Also, This Guy Clearly Doesn't Know D.I.D. At All. After A Decade Of Training Our System Is Fully Communicable.
Dude for real like. Hypnosis? Really? I mean maybe some would try but we're so full of paranoid protectors that it's hard enough doing the emdr thing. (Literally had to google that, wasn't there in any of our sessions) They should probably talk to a therapist/psychologist/whatever who has actually treated a system. Or talk to a system. Or anyone but this Bootleg Santa Claus. -JD
@@mikatu everyone wants to have an interesting personality, like a movie star...so the more "roles/alters" you have = the cooler you are, like an inverse highlander complex or sometin.
@@twinstarssystem2857 it may be “shit” on the whole representation aspect- but from an acting stand point it’s absolutely incredible- the actor plays the rolls extremely well- and it is a very good movie because of that- everyone with a DID system is different and there HAS been cases documented similar to that of the system in the movie- however that’s only part of 2% of people affected with the disorder so it’s EXTREMELY rare but it CAN happen nonetheless- unfortunately since this is one of the only movies people will watch and see DID it ends up creating a massive stigma around it since a lot of people will not do their research on the actual disorder itself :// hence why this movie is unfortunately very problematic- if there were way more movies with GOOD representation then this movie would not have as big of a negative impact as it does. Either way if someone is going to watch this movie I recommend they do research on the actual disorder first- and do not group everyone in to one category since nearly every system is different- to sum up my comment it’s a good movie but it sends the wrong message
@@xavirat1117 assuming a correct understanding, it seems to be, neuropsych speaking, a stricter adherence of basic physiochemical "emotions" or "feelings" creating or malwiring into or forth, a "new" person or thought matrix. Which doesn't really make any sense in of itself as it assumes that any & all clusters or systems of a "self" can definitively exist at all, even tho humans have used the IDEA of personage throughout civilizations various histories. To actually prove anyone personality as a physical reality OUTSIDE of the subject, or observers own mere perceptions/contemplation, is as mentioned, technically impossible. Point was, even the most basic premise of the movie is flawed. But then again, so are most movies. Also also, john Cusack did a movie sorta like it called "Identity" I think
@@straygameplaywalkthroughps6480 there are many instances where psychological disorders cause the body itself to begin doing things, for example if my brother tells himself he’s going to have a seizure enough he will indeed have a seizure. Same could go with did, you believe something enough in your head your body could start physically doing it. So it’s not entirely possible, it can also be said the same for munchausen those people can make themselves believe they are genuinely ill to the point their body itself starts to show symptoms.
@@xavirat1117 That is unlikely as true as most think (placebo /nocebo effects). As it would seem to be less the form of thoughts, and more the genre, ie, happy v sad v mad thoughts. Which equates to feeling production (hormones). So, if you think about fighting (or any distress/ustress adversarial encounter), the fight hormones get released. Same for happy/sad. Meaning, it would seem to be less the "magic power of will/thots" and more basic hormonal stress response cascades. Specifically, it is not the act of thinking you have a disease and then getting it, it is more the act of stressing (nerves/thinking/synaptic chemical production/transmission) that makes one "sick" from being stressed out, symptoms of which can mimic most other diseases, as most diseases have similar, vague symptoms. Like inflammation, can be a symptom of many things. Also, many things causes inflammation. Including the bodies reaction to mental good/bad stress situations. This is logical and doesn't imply magick spirit will/belief, because, after all, even the most physical basic reality of "OMG a bear/tiger is attacking me" , requires the brains reactive ability to process such information, and things like pain/pleasure, nutrients & injuries ARE INFORMATION the brain has to process in order for the body to function as a byproduct of its own existence! Same effect, misunderstood causation. As for some reason, both religion & science like to play fast & loose with their "ownership" of various definitions, like how seeing a therapist doctor, & priest (or monk etc) can result in the same advice given in multiple formats, for instance all would probably say: "Yeah, maybe stop smoking to feel better?" But have different rationals as to why.
Not just sexual abuse, it's any extreme trauma, including witnessing. Please get that straight
You a doctor ?
@@kush1726 They are right it is not Just Sexual Abuse
@@kush1726 check Dissociadid and educate yourself.
No, it is mainly sexual! Some other severe trauma may cause it but it is very rare. Witnessing for sure it is not.
@@SYNAGATES did you know that Harvard has done a study recently on how spanking a child activates the same part of the brain that sexual assault activates?.
split is definitely harmful, but tbh i would trust anyone in my system around him as a therapist it's,,, some of this seems wrong?
actually, a lot of this seems wrong
-dark
Split: 23 personalities, the 24th is about to be released
Us: Rookie numbers.
A shit
Now I understand why there is a pronoun for they them
To "alternate personalities that often" is possible, especially if the therapist is inexperienced and communication between alters starts. For this not to get out of control, causing confusion and fear, it's a must for therapists to have some idea of what can happen (hearing voices), if this is not something the alters experienced before.
To be able to call certain alters when be great but with me I haven't mastered that. I cannot control my switching...not one bit.
I can ask them but they dont listen
Dr. Day is awesome. Always down to just chat in his office about anything
So true. Despite having very hard multiple choice tests he was still my favorite Prof at McMaster because he was always excited to talk about psychology.
You forgot to ask if it's possible for an alter to transform into an ultra powerful monster.
Definitely not to the extent of being inmune to bullets but I think it can give an increase of strength
I hope you know this movie is supernatural 😭
It's a superhero movie
@@elpsykoongro5379 meh, "normal" humans can learn martial arts, parkour, ballet and take enhancement drugs to become "roid rage monsters".
So its not far out there really, not to mention millions of soldiers become bulletproof just by putting on body armor.
Sooo, the real question is:
who would win in a fight, " The beast" or "captain america"?
Finally Some Systems Speaking In This Comment Section Speaking About How Wrong This Movie Is, Also, This Guy Clearly Doesn't Know D.I.D. At All. After A Decade Of Training Our System Is Fully Communicable.
Dude for real like. Hypnosis? Really? I mean maybe some would try but we're so full of paranoid protectors that it's hard enough doing the emdr thing. (Literally had to google that, wasn't there in any of our sessions)
They should probably talk to a therapist/psychologist/whatever who has actually treated a system. Or talk to a system. Or anyone but this Bootleg Santa Claus. -JD
@@Abitscrewycreations human watches movie = thinks movie is about them or that they too can leap buildings in a single bound ;-)
How rare is this condition ?
The condition for real is rare, but nowaday seems to be trendy to have it, so everybody has it.
Less than 200,000 people diagnosed in a year, so pretty rare
@@mikatu
Some maybe attracted to the idea of kaneki ken
(An anime character that has a form of did)
@@mikatu everyone wants to have an interesting personality, like a movie star...so the more "roles/alters" you have = the cooler you are, like an inverse highlander complex or sometin.
Brb gonna go watch split again
split is shit would not recommend
@@twinstarssystem2857 it may be “shit” on the whole representation aspect- but from an acting stand point it’s absolutely incredible- the actor plays the rolls extremely well- and it is a very good movie because of that- everyone with a DID system is different and there HAS been cases documented similar to that of the system in the movie- however that’s only part of 2% of people affected with the disorder so it’s EXTREMELY rare but it CAN happen nonetheless- unfortunately since this is one of the only movies people will watch and see DID it ends up creating a massive stigma around it since a lot of people will not do their research on the actual disorder itself :// hence why this movie is unfortunately very problematic- if there were way more movies with GOOD representation then this movie would not have as big of a negative impact as it does. Either way if someone is going to watch this movie I recommend they do research on the actual disorder first- and do not group everyone in to one category since nearly every system is different- to sum up my comment it’s a good movie but it sends the wrong message
@@xavirat1117 assuming a correct understanding, it seems to be, neuropsych speaking, a stricter adherence of basic physiochemical "emotions" or "feelings" creating or malwiring into or forth, a "new" person or thought matrix.
Which doesn't really make any sense in of itself as it assumes that any & all clusters or systems of a "self" can definitively exist at all, even tho humans have used the IDEA of personage throughout civilizations various histories.
To actually prove anyone personality as a physical reality OUTSIDE of the subject, or observers own mere perceptions/contemplation, is as mentioned, technically impossible.
Point was, even the most basic premise of the movie is flawed. But then again, so are most movies.
Also also, john Cusack did a movie sorta like it called "Identity" I think
@@straygameplaywalkthroughps6480 there are many instances where psychological disorders cause the body itself to begin doing things, for example if my brother tells himself he’s going to have a seizure enough he will indeed have a seizure.
Same could go with did, you believe something enough in your head your body could start physically doing it. So it’s not entirely possible, it can also be said the same for munchausen those people can make themselves believe they are genuinely ill to the point their body itself starts to show symptoms.
@@xavirat1117 That is unlikely as true as most think (placebo /nocebo effects).
As it would seem to be less the form of thoughts, and more the genre, ie, happy v sad v mad thoughts.
Which equates to feeling production (hormones).
So, if you think about fighting (or any distress/ustress adversarial encounter), the fight hormones get released.
Same for happy/sad. Meaning, it would seem to be less the "magic power of will/thots" and more basic hormonal stress response cascades.
Specifically, it is not the act of thinking you have a disease and then getting it, it is more the act of stressing (nerves/thinking/synaptic chemical production/transmission) that makes one "sick" from being stressed out, symptoms of which can mimic most other diseases, as most diseases have similar, vague symptoms.
Like inflammation, can be a symptom of many things. Also, many things causes inflammation. Including the bodies reaction to mental good/bad stress situations.
This is logical and doesn't imply magick spirit will/belief, because, after all, even the most physical basic reality of "OMG a bear/tiger is attacking me" , requires the brains reactive ability to process such information, and things like pain/pleasure, nutrients & injuries ARE INFORMATION the brain has to process in order for the body to function as a byproduct of its own existence!
Same effect, misunderstood causation. As for some reason, both religion & science like to play fast & loose with their "ownership" of various definitions, like how seeing a therapist doctor, & priest (or monk etc) can result in the same advice given in multiple formats, for instance all would probably say:
"Yeah, maybe stop smoking to feel better?"
But have different rationals as to why.