Top 10 Carlton Players of the Modern Era (1995-2020)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 1. 06. 2020
  • Top 10 Carltons Players of the Modern Era (1995-2020) as voted by MJS Sport.
    All footage belongs to the following:
    afl.com.au
    carltonfc.com.au
  • Sport

Komentáře • 70

  • @warpeace8891
    @warpeace8891 Před rokem +6

    Greg williams is the best player I have ever seen. He should have won four Brownlows and was short, slow, fat, tough as anyone and better than everyone. No player before or since had the awareness of the players around him and the ability to squirt out handballs out of dense packs to put teammates in space and advantage. Supreme skills on both sides and almost never played a bad game whilst being largely injury proof. No other Carlton player comes close. A true coaches dream.
    Gobsmacked to see Judd at two. Umpires pet and spent most of the game running away from contests.

  • @rickytiller31
    @rickytiller31 Před 3 lety +5

    The commentator when Fev nails the goal from the boundary against the crows 🤣🤣

  • @Charles-SG
    @Charles-SG Před 3 lety +39

    Carlton’s biggest mistake: Getting rid of coach Brett Ratton

    • @mattblackmore3252
      @mattblackmore3252 Před 2 lety +11

      Disagree, Ratton dropped the ball the year he got sacked, the biggest mistake we made was bringing in Malthouse, we should’ve brought someone else in

    • @Charles-SG
      @Charles-SG Před 2 lety +1

      @@mattblackmore3252 ok yes that is true

    • @stevepharr1
      @stevepharr1 Před 2 lety

      Agree

    • @duke1724
      @duke1724 Před rokem

      100% agree they played for him
      He got the best out of them fevs best yrs was under ratton

  • @pressurepointmedia
    @pressurepointmedia Před 3 lety +3

    This is brilliant!!! Some outrageously good players in this list!

  • @kenbrand2123
    @kenbrand2123 Před 3 lety +5

    I forgot how good Silvani was.

  • @the_norty_rider
    @the_norty_rider Před 3 lety +8

    Just put in the whole 1995 team

    • @splendidteaching
      @splendidteaching Před 3 lety +1

      Yes. I am a Geelong supporter and was at the '95 GF. Thought at the time this would have to rival any of the great sides of the past. They were a brilliant team

    • @jordandevereux6835
      @jordandevereux6835 Před rokem

      1995 Grand Final side is the best team to have ever taken the field. Narrowly over both Bris 01-03/Ess 2000.
      Show me a better backline than Sexton/Ang/Dean/McKay/SOS!!!
      Midfield of Kouta/Distillate/Brown/Braddles/Ratten/Camporeale 😮
      Sticks and Pearce with Big Earl & Clape in the F50.
      Should have won that GF by 120 points. Took foot completely off gas late and let genuine Geelong spuds like David Mensch and Steven Handley snag a couple sausages when it was all over.

  • @downforanything1265
    @downforanything1265 Před 3 lety +2

    What a great video

  • @rhomahno8878
    @rhomahno8878 Před 18 dny

    Top 6 for mine in no particular order would be due to their impact on the game and changing what you expect from a footballer or position (and not including Judd because he was at WC first). Betts, Fev, Kouta, Cripps, Diesel, SOS.

  • @leewilliamson7119
    @leewilliamson7119 Před 3 lety +3

    the whole 95 side and kade simpson, thats it

  • @kgvexy8894
    @kgvexy8894 Před 3 lety +7

    Why is no one talking about betts?

    • @iz1419
      @iz1419 Před 3 lety

      Bc he ddn’t start in 95 duh

    • @kgvexy8894
      @kgvexy8894 Před 3 lety

      @@iz1419 Did Fev start in 95? No he started in 99.

    • @iz1419
      @iz1419 Před 3 lety

      @@kgvexy8894 I said didn’t

    • @iz1419
      @iz1419 Před 3 lety

      @@kgvexy8894 btw he didn’t start in 99 he started in 2005

    • @harryfletch8081
      @harryfletch8081 Před 2 lety +1

      Betts was great but played his best footy at Crows

  • @THE_crippledman21
    @THE_crippledman21 Před 2 lety +5

    This is great just what about the magical Eddie Betts

    • @Mrcoolguy5913
      @Mrcoolguy5913 Před 2 lety +1

      I think it’s because Eddie didn’t play much for Carlton at his best

    • @theoneweekwonder
      @theoneweekwonder Před 2 lety

      @@Mrcoolguy5913 he played a lot at his best for Carlton, he just wasn't as relied upon as he was in Adelaide

  • @williammcdonald8139
    @williammcdonald8139 Před 2 lety +2

    Kouta no 1

  • @knigggit7672
    @knigggit7672 Před rokem +1

    SOS our GOAT then daylight…

    • @olddarkblues
      @olddarkblues  Před rokem

      Large call

    • @knigggit7672
      @knigggit7672 Před rokem +1

      @@olddarkblues full back of the century, played on and regularly beat the greatest forwards to ever play the game, one of the best marks of all time and could go to full forward and kick a lazy 10 on a regular basis. Our GOAT by the length of the Flemington straight.

  • @azzaprime7257
    @azzaprime7257 Před 3 lety

    They need to show this reel to the current playing group to show them who they are playing for.

  • @blackdogRexy
    @blackdogRexy Před 27 dny

    I demand to know why Ricky Nixon has not made the list.

  • @PetraKann
    @PetraKann Před rokem

    Very sneaky mixing successful quality leaders from 1995 with recent players.
    Even the comparison in ability and performance under pressure is dubious.
    Marketing department behind this one?

  • @darrenjpeters
    @darrenjpeters Před 2 lety +4

    I'm baffled that "Fullback of the Century" Steve Silvagni isn't number 1, and also that Fevola, one of the most mercurial forwards of the last 20 years, is only at number 7. Not a great list.

    • @PetraKann
      @PetraKann Před rokem +1

      Totally agree.
      I would also remove 3 players from this top 10 list all together. The ranking of the remaining 7 is all over the shop.
      Very dubious and sneaky list.
      Whoever complied this list clearly owes everyone in the Southern Hemisphere a written apology

    • @damiano94
      @damiano94 Před rokem

      @@PetraKann why havnt you named which 3 players shouldnt be on here at all and their replacements just curious

  • @the_norty_rider
    @the_norty_rider Před 3 lety +1

    Where's Earl Spalding?

  • @stronzer59
    @stronzer59 Před měsícem

    After the Blues lost the draft picks for 3 years for cheating the salary cap the whole team spirit totally tanked. Looks like Voss is putting the skids on that slide

  • @Ducatirati
    @Ducatirati Před měsícem

    BIG NIC ,JEZZA , WALLS , SWANNY McKAY , SOUTHBY DOULL , PEROVIC , CRANE , GAGS GALLAGHER , ASHMAN , PINELL AUSTIN , RHYS-JONES BRADLEY , HARMES ENGLISH GLASCOTT McCONVILLE , FITZPATRICK, HARRY MADDEN , JIMMY BUCKLEY , JOHNSON , BOUSTOW , HUNTER , GREG WELLS , JONES , MARCOU , ALL PREMIERSHIP CHAMPIONS, BUT ONE IS KING , THAT BE BIG JOHN NICHOLLS, THE MAN WHO CHANGED FOOTBALL , THE MOST INFLUENTIAL PLAYER AT ANY CLUB AT HIS TIME , HE CHANGED THE WAY THE GAME WAS PLAYED , GO BLUES RARARA

  • @clarkclements7204
    @clarkclements7204 Před rokem +1

    10: Kade Simpson
    9: Brett Ratten
    8: Steven Kernahan
    7: Brendan Fevola
    6: Chris Judd
    5: Greg Williams
    4: Craig Bradley
    3: Anthony Koutafides
    2: Patrick Cripps
    1: Stephen Silvagni
    Bonus: Worst player: Cam O'Shea

    • @olddarkblues
      @olddarkblues  Před rokem

      Great list 🙌

    • @clarkclements7204
      @clarkclements7204 Před rokem

      @@olddarkblues of course this updated to 2022, that is why Cripps jumped so many spots.

  • @the_norty_rider
    @the_norty_rider Před 3 lety

    Where's the wheel?

  • @rickyelvis3215
    @rickyelvis3215 Před rokem

    Eddie Betts ?

  • @andrewfletcher590
    @andrewfletcher590 Před 3 lety +3

    Kate Simpson?

  • @JoshHolden-Aka-evani
    @JoshHolden-Aka-evani Před 3 lety +3

    as great as these players were most of their effort were pre 95.

  • @zachlee7945
    @zachlee7945 Před 3 lety +1

    eddie? no?

  • @mattp5843
    @mattp5843 Před 3 lety +1

    Bootsma?

  • @obi-nine1504
    @obi-nine1504 Před 3 lety +2

    Judd easily number 1

    • @darrenjpeters
      @darrenjpeters Před 2 lety

      Plenty of blokes win Brownlows. There's only one Fullback of the Century. How many blokes could have held Plugger to one goal one week, and then played full forward and kicked 10 goals the next week?.

    • @obi-nine1504
      @obi-nine1504 Před 2 lety

      @@darrenjpeters not many, but Judd is number 1 without a doubt

    • @darrenjpeters
      @darrenjpeters Před 2 lety

      @@obi-nine1504 Everybody is entitled to their opinion. Juddy was bloody good, no question, so was Diesel. Steve Silvagni was a freakish talent, if you didn't watch him play every week when he was in his heyday, I'm sure you don't appreciate just how bloody good he was.

    • @obi-nine1504
      @obi-nine1504 Před 2 lety

      @@darrenjpeters mate I do, he was my old mans favourite player, he’s got the best record on the greatest era of FFs. Judd at his peak was light years ahead of everyone, I only have 6 players better than Judd all time.

    • @darrenjpeters
      @darrenjpeters Před 2 lety

      @@obi-nine1504 No question, peak Juddy was pretty much unstoppable, I gotta give you that one, pity the osteitis pubis cruelled him a bit. I don't reckon we got peak Juddy at Carlton, even though he was still a gun.

  • @jeremygreen2198
    @jeremygreen2198 Před rokem

    Judd was an eye fiuer Fevika, a, Drunk n Wukans, a snipe behind play 6jerbahan heard footsteps,!!

  • @scannon4492
    @scannon4492 Před 3 lety

    Just turn down the music a bit... Great video apart from that

  • @robdp8900
    @robdp8900 Před 3 lety

    Fevolaaaaaa

  • @ODN67
    @ODN67 Před 3 lety +2

    Williams was done by 1997 so really can't be 1st in this company.

    • @damiano94
      @damiano94 Před rokem +2

      Hes 95 season alone is enough, 32 disposals 5 goals in a grand final is enough

  • @dionbrown8064
    @dionbrown8064 Před 3 lety +1

    Mark Murphy shouldn't be on this list, should be on the list for most turn overs, put Eddie Betts in, also Silvagni should be 1st.

    • @iz1419
      @iz1419 Před 3 lety

      Btw spelt Marc wrong

    • @darrenjpeters
      @darrenjpeters Před 2 lety

      I'm with you, the fullback of the century was an absolute freak of nature.

  • @fivelion6222
    @fivelion6222 Před 3 lety

    I don’t know how a club can be such a flog for over 20 years. They’ve made some really bad list management decisions. They are still the same flogs as before.

    • @seulb23
      @seulb23 Před 2 lety +2

      16 premierships say otherwise

  • @CastawryFau
    @CastawryFau Před 2 měsíci

    I would put silvagni at 1
    Edit: Yeah na Greg williams number 1 is definite. Old workhorse