Nous sommes ici sur les plus hauts sommets de la musique !! Et c'est impressionnant de rigueur, de précision, de souci du moindre détail... Il n'a pas gagné ce 18e concours Chopin par hasard !! Une préparation longue et minutieuse, avec un autre lauréat du concours. Une "conversation" entre deux magnifiques musiciens. Mais quelle conversation !... C'est un grand bonheur.
The hard work in communicating so much that is beyond words … Bruce’s patience to catch the gems in different levels of glittering and dying off …even the sad reflective nostalgia of nothing, of petering out after the most stupendous storms of human emotions and states that Chopin’s genius IS able to capture for us… is a great example of learning attitude…recognising, despite everything, Dang Thai Son’s Eurasian background has helped him internalise the more unusual deep, almost numbed reflective states in the turmoil of Chopin’s short but intensely lived …’almost aristocratic ‘ life.
Importante video que nos muestra la búsqueda de precisión de Mr Bruce Liu en su arte. Es un "gran pianista" que nos brida lo mejor con dedicación y exactitud. Lo admiramos! Es ejemplar.🇦🇷❤️
We agree with Mr. Dang Thai Son in many things:-) When I first listened to Bruce's production in this video, I already had a few words of critique (if one should even attempt at this in his case of course - but I guess in July this ballade was not yet fully expressed, as simple as that) , and I'm glad to hear the same impressions and words of wisdom from one of the best chopinists in the world!
Oberlin College & Conservatory is the main source of this video and there are other workshops of Bruce with different teachers and he played different pieces with them. Dang Thai Son also has different workshops too. Please go to the source to support them and give thumbs up them too👍
Prof Dang's French is better than his English, albeit with a Vietnamese accent. He finds it more natural too. French is also Bruce's first language, although he also speaks Chinese like a native. Interestingly, he speaks standard French, not a trace of Quebecois.
@@JaseBach Totally agree with you., I think they speak "Français Québécois" daily. It’s also interesting for Chopin spoke “Français Parisien “. That’s why I think Liu and his pro Dang (Dang’s mom can speak French too) played so amazing and so naturally in Chopin’s musical phrasing.
i can not take it HERE, but the piano singing Chopin vision mmmm:) the vision share the future surely more light from that scary thing THE PIANO; black n' white piece of wood
extremely talented pianist, but it's kind of broken that the literal teacher of two prize winners in this year's competition was also allowed to be on the jury...
It's quite common in the Chopin competition where the world's most renowned Chopin-specialists and former Chopin-competition winners are invited to the jury. The rules are carefully executed to avoid any bias, and the jurors don't score their own students. Of course some jury member could have so much authority on the other jury members that they would not dare to give low scores to his/her student, but I seriously doubt if that would happen in a large scale anyway.
Jurors are not allowed to give scores to their student during the competition. There were other finalists that also have jurors as their teachers as well.
@@jondoe9596 It is inevitable. Otherwise the only people allowed to judge would be high school piano teachers. Almost every talented pianist teacher has talented students in this competition.
I don't agree with you at all！There's a great gap between Bruce and the 2nd prize winner, in terms of artistic taste and techniques, also the charisma of performance. Bruce is absolutely outstanding and far better than the one you mentioned！！
Mr. Son's pronunciation is not well articulated making it difficult to understand ... perhaps it is much better to use the piano to demonstrate directly ... let the music speak ...
I read somewhere that Thai Son gave a low score to Sorita. I hope it isn't true, and I surely hope it wasn't because he wanted his student to get 1st prize.
@Mazzel Tov yap Thai Son should never won a chopin competition.. Pogorelich was a true winer in 1980 and that sad Martha Argerich but ok.. i think that Sorita or Alexander Gadjiev should won but ok.. who am i to tell that...
@@haulecong6208 oh yes and he also can’t talk to other juror during the competition? Are you really that naive? They couldn’t even release final results this time - it is obvious what is going on
I saw Dang Thai Son in the mid 90's and he played f minor Ballade and Ravel Le Valse he was brilliant. Most impressive.
Nous sommes ici sur les plus hauts sommets de la musique !! Et c'est impressionnant de rigueur, de précision, de souci du moindre détail... Il n'a pas gagné ce 18e concours Chopin par hasard !! Une préparation longue et minutieuse, avec un autre lauréat du concours. Une "conversation" entre deux magnifiques musiciens. Mais quelle conversation !... C'est un grand bonheur.
Bruce wygrał, bo jest najlepszy!
A world class piano lesson between two world class pianists
I really hope that Dang Thai Son and Bruce Xiayu Liu will give a concert together in 2023 in Paris(TCE) it will be a precious moment
and they are!!!
SUPER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! piękna współpraca Dang Thai Son z Bruce Liu!!!!!!!..............
Bruce wygrał, bo jest najlepszy!
Thank you for sharing! Learn much from Mr. Dang! Love Bruce Liu forever! Hope Bruce Liu have a bright future!
The hard work in communicating so much that is beyond words … Bruce’s patience to catch the gems in different levels of glittering and dying off …even the sad reflective nostalgia of nothing, of petering out after the most stupendous storms of human emotions and states that Chopin’s genius IS able to capture for us… is a great example of learning attitude…recognising, despite everything, Dang Thai Son’s Eurasian background has helped him internalise the more unusual deep, almost numbed reflective states in the turmoil of Chopin’s short but intensely lived …’almost aristocratic ‘ life.
This is wonderful to see. Thanks.
Super ❤❤❤Thank you so much !!!
thanks so miuch for sharing this ! really good and appreciated to see 2 of them togehtr
Importante video que nos muestra la búsqueda de precisión de Mr Bruce Liu en su arte. Es un "gran pianista" que nos brida lo mejor con dedicación y exactitud.
Lo admiramos! Es ejemplar.🇦🇷❤️
I think that Dang Thai Son is the best Chopin player. No wonder Liu was the first prize winner of the most recent Chopin competition.
He has a good teacher. Congrats on the victory!
Liu氏の深い音色の意味をほんの少し理解できたように思います。神ともにありますように。いつもステキな音色を有難うございます。
Dang Thai Son is the top pianist who is the best interpreter of Chopin.
We agree with Mr. Dang Thai Son in many things:-) When I first listened to Bruce's production in this video, I already had a few words of critique (if one should even attempt at this in his case of course - but I guess in July this ballade was not yet fully expressed, as simple as that) , and I'm glad to hear the same impressions and words of wisdom from one of the best chopinists in the world!
SHUT UP!!!
Amazing!
I heard in The last chord in coda - cerebral stroke. And extinction of life on the last line.
Thank you for posting, so many interesting ideas!
It is not easy to teach in a language that is not your native language.Especially to educate him to win the Chopin Championship.👏👏👏
As long as they can speak English there’s no problem.
Wdym, he is Canadian
@@jhNic still not his first language
He’s Vietnamese
Both are speaking French English and Chinese and Vietnamese
This is amazing
Thương hai thày trò 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
音色は変わりませんね。４０年前のショパン国際ピアノコンクール優勝🏆の時と同じブルリアントで美しい深い音色。
彼の場合、素晴らしい最高級のピアニストであり、またブルースを生み出した最高の指導者にもなりました。
As expected from Maestro Dang Thai Son, very valuable lesson.
Grateful for listening till the end.
Thank you for sharing the video. 👍
ピアニストのレッスンを見ることはほとんど無いと思うので、これは貴重な映像だ。
二人の師弟関係も素敵だ。
So lucky to have such fantastic teacher
Bravissimo!!!
What a teacher to have.
Worth its weight in gold for those studying the second Ballade!
Nice to know that someone who is double jointed won the Chopin competition ☺
Wat rlly ?
I'm double jointed in one thumb and a couple fingers and it used to mess me up so hard
Please explain what is “double jointed”? Thanks in advance 🙏
Belíssima interpretação
This is Chopin Ballade 2 by the way in case anyone wonders...
That's hard work.
Bruce said in an interview that he only practices 3-4 hours a day.
That’s not a lot considering his Repertoire .
He’s a genius!
En qué año fue la 17a competencia Chopin? Recién pude realizar de ver una competencia después de muchos años .Soy de Montevideo Uruguay
Fue en 2015. El vencedor fue Seong Jin Cho
Oberlin College & Conservatory is the main source of this video and there are other workshops of Bruce with different teachers and he played different pieces with them. Dang Thai Son also has different workshops too. Please go to the source to support them and give thumbs up them too👍
That's my alma mater.. Oberlin Conservatory.. so I take it, Dang Thai Son is on faculty.
👋 Enjoy your detailed tutorials. Fun to see you here too!
@@peterCheater Thanks, Peter! Shirley K
Mine too!
What is the source of this video ?
Oberlin Conservatory. The original video czcams.com/video/9filpN0azfc/video.html
❣️❣️❣️🌏
Two gods
⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘⚘
鞋子是特步飞一样的感觉吗
😅😂
seems like Dang Thai Son might teach to sit at the edge of the bench
I thought they would be speaking French together given both are from Montreal
C’est vrai, mais pourquoi pas
Ça sera interessant à voir. Je peux pratiquer mon français.
@@pianosbloxworld4460 Apprends le Français avec le prof de piano ? 🤔⁉️Ça c’est pas une bonne idée.
Prof Dang's French is better than his English, albeit with a Vietnamese accent. He finds it more natural too. French is also Bruce's first language, although he also speaks Chinese like a native. Interestingly, he speaks standard French, not a trace of Quebecois.
@@JaseBach Totally agree with you., I think they speak "Français Québécois" daily. It’s also interesting for Chopin spoke “Français Parisien “. That’s why I think Liu and his pro Dang (Dang’s mom can speak French too) played so amazing and so naturally in Chopin’s musical phrasing.
すげー
Pongan traducción al español POR FAVAUR!!!!!!
What is name piece introducción? Plz
First 00:01 piano and Trumpet sound
It's the opening of Brahms Piano Concerto no. 2
44:40 coda
Omg, how can you learn from him? it's impossible.
What means
i can not take it HERE, but the piano singing Chopin vision mmmm:)
the vision share the future surely more light from that scary thing THE PIANO; black n' white piece of wood
Ur comment makes no sense.
Dang Thai Son sounds like BukLau from Ownage Pranks!
extremely talented pianist, but it's kind of broken that the literal teacher of two prize winners in this year's competition was also allowed to be on the jury...
It's quite common in the Chopin competition where the world's most renowned Chopin-specialists and former Chopin-competition winners are invited to the jury. The rules are carefully executed to avoid any bias, and the jurors don't score their own students. Of course some jury member could have so much authority on the other jury members that they would not dare to give low scores to his/her student, but I seriously doubt if that would happen in a large scale anyway.
Jurors are not allowed to give scores to their student during the competition. There were other finalists that also have jurors as their teachers as well.
@@jondoe9596 It is inevitable. Otherwise the only people allowed to judge would be high school piano teachers. Almost every talented pianist teacher has talented students in this competition.
저격인가ㅋㅋㅋ
Your piano playing are really chit ,lourd
Chopin institute said Bruce received the highest score in the history of the competition.
And 2021 has the deepest field in history.
私の中では第18回ショパン国際ピアノコンクールの優勝者は別の人(2位の人)だと思っています！コンクールだから仕方ないですね。
I don't agree with you at all！There's a great gap between Bruce and the 2nd prize winner, in terms of artistic taste and techniques, also the charisma of performance. Bruce is absolutely outstanding and far better than the one you mentioned！！
反田さんのコンチェルトの動画視聴数の高さが、多くの人の心を魅了していることの証拠ですね。ブルースさんも素晴らしいですが。技術は別としても、芸術性やカリスマ性というのは人によって感じ方が違うと思いますので。私は反田さんにカリスマ性を感じます。
@@babycho9 これだけ豊富な音色でピアノを歌わせることができるのは、演奏者の耳と技術に他なりません！反田さんのファイナルのコンチェルトは特に圧巻でした！私の個人的感想ですが、アルゲリッチさんが審査員にいたらまた違った順位になっていたように思います。
虚しいね。。。もう哀れにしか思えない。しつこさはだけはよく伝わってるよ。
Mr. Son's pronunciation is not well articulated making it difficult to understand ... perhaps it is much better to use the piano to demonstrate directly ... let the music speak ...
I read somewhere that Thai Son gave a low score to Sorita. I hope it isn't true, and I surely hope it wasn't because he wanted his student to get 1st prize.
@Mazzel Tov yap Thai Son should never won a chopin competition.. Pogorelich was a true winer in 1980 and that sad Martha Argerich but ok.. i think that Sorita or Alexander Gadjiev should won but ok.. who am i to tell that...
I thought Chopin competition haven't published the score yet?
@@brainlin1669 Its been over for like a week bruv
@@skrz8 wait they already published the score? where can I see them
@@brainlin1669 That's why I said "read somewhere"
Jury member student wins yet another competition, nothing new here
Jury can't give score to his own student. He also didn't give lower score to other competitors than other jury so your point isn't right.
@@haulecong6208 oh yes and he also can’t talk to other juror during the competition? Are you really that naive? They couldn’t even release final results this time - it is obvious what is going on
PLEASE PLEASE take the mask off !!!!
😡
Typical case of a pupil who does not surpass the teacher
Hmmm, Bruce is only 25 years old. He can develop further in the next few decades.
You both are vaccinated . Why are you wearing masks ? Stop the hysteria . You are two incredible artists . Apply science to you behavior.
They apply the law of the land
@@joannakosicka4307 lmao
They’re educated, unlike you…
no1 gives a fuck its their choice
44:23 coda