Overconfidence or Modi succession fight twist- Why Nadda is wrong about BJP not needing RSS any more
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 05. 2024
- #rss #modi #bjp
JP Nadda snubbing RSS has come as a surprise but there is a larger story behind it, ThePrint's Political Editor DK Singh analyses in this episode of #PoliticallyCorrect
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our CZcams Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
BJP can do without RSS is debatable however the party can certainly do without Nadda
💀💀💀💀
@@robsr Hey Friend, Nadda is a well fed, fat animal not just bones
The words are from Modi, not Nadda! RSS knows that Modi will take over even RSS if he wins again!
😂😂😂
What now 😂😂😂
Political Parties and personalities come and go. The organization, ideology, and discipline will be forever.
Aisa mat socho ham hindu hai isliye bach jaengeAur laga ki tum jaise youth hi desh ka Bhavivysaya aur ye politics kitna brainwashed rakh rahi hai ham youth koAaj muslaman maar kha raha kal kisaan kha raha tha ek din jab sawal poochona choge to ham bhi kahenegeAur phir tumhe lagega bahut der ho gayiYe neta log politics ko isliye hi aisa rakhte hai taaki ham jaise youths inki taraf na dekheHam reels ke comment kattar hindu likhne mein busy rahenge aur ye log desh ka bantadhar karne mein lage rahenge❤
THE ANTI-NATIONAL ACTIVITIES OF RSS IS WELL DOCUMENTED IN HISTORY. RSS was founded in 1925, by 1947, it had been 22 years since the creation of RSS & RSS had its organisation all over the country. RSS despatched a circular to it's branches NOT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE QUIT INDIA MOVEMENT & SUPPORT THE BRITISH AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. RSS ALLY HINDU MAHASABHA FORMED GOVERNMENTS WITH THE MUSLIM LEAGUE IN SINDH & BENGAL IN 1937. RSS ALSO DISTRIBUTED SWEETS WHEN GANDHI WAS KILLED.
Modi has unironically been a disaster for India's political organization at the state level. All local politicians don't even bother doing anything on the ground because they know they'll keep winning elections using Modi's name. Used to be that local state level leaders would at least try to whitewash things - build roads, beautify the city - before elections. Now they don't bother because of Modi's popularity
Predict disaster for BJP once Modi is gone. The state level leaders are grossly incompetent and unpopular
"DISCIPLINE"🤣🤣
Statement made by nadda and rajnath are cunning in nature. That's how RSS and BJP deceives 😂
If rss dont do groundwork,bjp will drop back to single digit in lok sabha....
What can I say to counter your ignorance on the ideology and organizational structure of the BJP and RSS-the BJP being the political branch of the RSS, that both organizations have distinct duties and functions and won't interfere with one another's operations until absolutely necessary? This is the primary distinction between you and an RSS pracharak: one considers strategy and reasoning, the other considers?
@@AK-yw9qs I guess uou haven't seen rss people going door to door asking for votes
Very True Sir
🙏
What underground suwarss do is these bra man of rss send there bra women's for survey at nights because it's a underground work and success mantra of bra man to become mla mp minister sending wifes to lalu mulayam akhilesh mayavati and also akbar khilji aurangjeb to earn in there kingdom. Each and everyone vote to modi not suwarss of bra man women's half pant sons aged 60 or above.
Well they did bad
hahaha today it got clear who need who 😂😂😂😂
Looks like Nadda signed his own downfall.
He's on his way out anyway. His term will end in a few months. But he is right. People don't care as much about party, they care about the name and face of Modi. It is not BJP sarkar . It is always "Modi sarkar", or "Modi hai toh mumkin hai"... Recall 2009 when BJP led by Advani used to have ads saying vote for NDA.. you will now never see the words "NDA" in any political ad for votes, it's always vote for Modi... Modi will do this and that, not party.
People in our country are used to this hero worship for millennia and it has led to their downfall and exploitation time and time again by various forces : starting from indo Greek to Persian and central Asian sultanate to European colonialists and now their very own political and ultra rich class back home. And the shameful thing is we still haven't learnt our lessons (or perhaps learnt the wrong ones). This is to such a degree that we the people are debating whose "faayda" it will be among RSS and BJP in this democratic process and we do it so non chalantly that in fact we ignore the fact that the system is supposed to work for "janata ka faayda".
So yes, Nadda is right.
@@rosieroti4063 interesting view.
Bjp and rss can't even be separated. He should be ashamed for such a statement.
He will be thrown out in next few days
Of course they dont need RSS, now they directly recruit from opposition party
😀😀😀😀
This overconfidence made a loss in 2004, when RSS did not helped in election....What was the result we everybody know
Not suwarss it was vhp ashok singhal and at time of atal, he 52 not able to win in up bihar south india no sitting cm were of bhojoppo. That man was also coward as he was not able to built ram temple for which he was made pm by hindus. He have fear of muslims as if try to built mandir then what if again killing started by muslims how to save each other. He never talked about mandir after winning election he was two sided or dogla. That's why he lost as that time there was a saying that bjp is party of sadhus and they vote but that all sadhus were part of vhp not suwarss
Kal bhi overconfidence tha isliye majority nhi mili
This is arrogance from the part of BJP and Modi if they really sideline sangh. I already see no difference between Congress and BJP. Sangh ensures good disciplined and honest party functionaries and. BJP must make use of it instead of importing corrupt elements into the party.
DK should know that such statements are made to silence those who keep complaining that BJP is run by RSS. The inside truth remains that BJP is simply the political wing of RSS because the core ideology comes from there.
What core idealogy corruption looting feudalism superstition backwardness ???
@@Fubea_sales prince is the most honest person who doesn't have any responsibility but aspires to be pm by just working for a few hours 😅
JP nadda ki wajah se Sant Samaj aur Sangh/RSS samaj ne U.P me full support nhi kiya
Jb inhone ye bol diya tha ki Sangh k bina bhi hum full majority le skte hain
Aur Ayodhya me Sant samaj ko Ijjat na deke Modiji Celebrity form leke red carpet bicha k vote ki Politics kr di
Usse sare Sant Mahatma log naraj hue aur BJP ko Mirror dikha diya
Shi tarike se Modiji ko Piche rhna chaiye tha Ayodhya mandir k time pe aur Sant Mahatma logo ko aage rkh k bs sabka Ashirwad lena chaiye tha.. tb inko na keval Ayodhya ka Ashirwad lekin Ram ka Ashirwad bhi milta.
Ab isko leke bura na manna bhai log
Me bht neautral Geopolitics ka student hu
Mujhe pta h India me aur especially north mein
Sant samaj aur RSS jo ghr ghr jake logo ko family bna k influence krte rhe h vote krne ko
Wo is br nhi hua
Agr aap U.P se h to apko farq dikha hoga ki kitna apko contact kiya gyaa personally RSS ki taraf se.
Answer apko khud mil jayega
BJP leader jo bde h 4-6 unko ghamand apna todna pdega aur ego khtm krk wapas se logo se jud jaye
Power ka nashe me inhone apne bado tk ko respect nhi kiya
To bhagwan Ram tak inse naraj ho gye aur Ayodhya se bhi inko haara diya..
Sirf face value bchi rhe aur Congresss na aa jaye power mein utna hee sant samaj aur RSS se support mila h ki ventilator pe govt. Bjp ki khdi ho sake
Jai Hind 🙏
Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
RSS is the root of BJP
Without it there is no spine in BJP.
Politically I'm a BJP supporter but only because BJP's ideological base is RSS. Without the ideology, patriotism and discipline of RSS, lakhs of people like me will never think of supporting BJP.
BJP with RSS creates Gadakari, Parrikar, Advani, Bajpai, Modi....... BJP without RSS creates Manoj Tiwari, Giriraj Singh, Vasundhara Raje, Brijbhushan....
Aisa mat socho ham hindu hai isliye bach jaengeAur laga ki tum jaise youth hi desh ka Bhavivysaya aur ye politics kitna brainwashed rakh rahi hai ham youth koAaj muslaman maar kha raha kal kisaan kha raha tha ek din jab sawal poochona choge to ham bhi kahenegeAur phir tumhe lagega bahut der ho gayiYe neta log politics ko isliye hi aisa rakhte hai taaki ham jaise youths inki taraf na dekheHam reels ke comment kattar hindu likhne mein busy rahenge aur ye log desh ka bantadhar karne mein lage rahenge❤
Brijbhushan is not even remotely BJP, imported from SP
THE ANTI-NATIONAL ACTIVITIES OF RSS IS WELL DOCUMENTED IN HISTORY. RSS was founded in 1925, by 1947, it had been 22 years since the creation of RSS & RSS had its organisation all over the country. RSS despatched a circular to it's branches NOT TO PARTICIPATE IN THE QUIT INDIA MOVEMENT & SUPPORT THE BRITISH AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. RSS ALLY HINDU MAHASABHA FORMED GOVERNMENTS WITH THE MUSLIM LEAGUE IN SINDH & BENGAL IN 1937. RSS ALSO DISTRIBUTED SWEETS WHEN GANDHI WAS KILLED.
@@vinodmenon3591BRIJBHUSHAN IS THE CLOSEST AIDE OF AMIT SHAH IN UP. THAT'S HIS SEXUAL MOLESTATION IS GOING UNNOTICED.
Patritoism of rss😂😂😂, dont make me laugh
Underminig RSS is like child saying to his mother that I am grown up now,you are no more required. BJP must apologize before further demage, no person or BJP can be stronger than RSS. We know BJP through RSS only.
These are Arrogant words, driven by political power in 10yrs. These need to be taught a lesson, who is the actual baap. Without ideology of RSS and it's cadre BJP woul have collapsed after the 1984 debacle of 2 seats. The top brass of BJP is thinking that they can beat the opposiyion without the Sangh.
what about the words spoken in 2014? Those words were not arrogant then, spoken just after gaining power 10 years ago?
In today's age of rapid spread of information, the RSS has lost a lot of its significance for the BJP. Plus the sangh doesn't have a lot to complain about, Modi govt has very openly endorsed Sangh idealogical core albeit in a veiled manner making it seem BJPs.
Absolutely true Sir.
Modi 2014 was RSS choice.
They will illuminate rss after election mark my words
Let them be arrogant don't worry you bra women's son just look after the harmfull killing of your bra man in kashmir as well as vadh in bheema koregaon. Your atalwa was in combination with vp singh in 1992 but was not able to save bra women and bra men and they ran without bra from kashmir even though dada padduram didn't came or has been killed in bheema koregaon as said by mahars of maharashtra. Your dada padduram is so arrogant yaar.
The desperation of the Modi-Shah duo to induct people from the opposition! You are right🎯 The RSS-BJP workers have no love lost for "outsiders." Nadda is out of touch with realities like his boss. Has shot his mouth off at an inappropriate time.
Mr Nanda You are not enough matured
Neglect rss , if rss can make it happens in 2014 and 2019 they can make down also
Politics is always dirty
Please remember this
बस इसी बयान से पता चल गया कि भाजपा क्यों हारी.
Rss guides BJPs ideology even when new migrants from other parties join
Now the RSS shows the power who is the Boss
Hnn bhai aap khud kitna sankhsam h pta chal gaya aaj
RSS or BJP worker has no Ego. That is the Primary Purpose of RSS. Ego is nipped in the Bud in every RSS Cadre. Don't you know this basic charector
Some buds seem to have escaped the nip
Nadda's statement quells the criticism on how BJP is run by the RSS. Of course BJP's ideology is intertwined with the ideology of the RSS and that's how it'll always remain.
It is like pushing the ladder away after climbing the roof,.
Not a good statement..
Something like discarding the parents after you have grown big.😡😡
Dk singh telling jp nadda whats is wrong and right. What days have come
This organisation is must for conservative people of the nation
Aisa mat socho ham hindu hai isliye bach jaengeAur laga ki tum jaise youth hi desh ka Bhavivysaya aur ye politics kitna brainwashed rakh rahi hai ham youth koAaj muslaman maar kha raha kal kisaan kha raha tha ek din jab sawal poochona choge to ham bhi kahenegeAur phir tumhe lagega bahut der ho gayiYe neta log politics ko isliye hi aisa rakhte hai taaki ham jaise youths inki taraf na dekheHam reels ke comment kattar hindu likhne mein busy rahenge aur ye log desh ka bantadhar karne mein lage rahenge❤
brain washing means conviencing with fake and false data,
Awareness means conviencing with fact and true data,
The person who talks in edited video sitting at home is called brain washing,
The person who talks face to face in front of you is called awareness
@@Devmew000 Nope, brainwashing can be done face to face too. When you are online you can have other sources to fact check them, but many times this luxury couldn't be afforded if you are talking physically
Nadda ji is right and it was supposed to happen by design. Just observe the amount of donations bjp has. this is a big money and now bjp runs a massive office in each district of india at least in hindi belt. they have paid staff in all those offices. who needs rss if they already have this kind of network. They also don’t like unnecessary interference of rss in day to day working of government
And u have seen the downfall now...
Let's hope the country proves to be wiser than expected...
R u trying to cause a fight between BJP and RSS workers??
U don’t understand what nanda said.
BJP do not need RSS support.
* BJP is stability
Excellent political journalism,son on the shoulder of father looks higher but it the shoulder of father so Nadda seems foolish ,arrogant and self destructive.
Also in maharashtra same things happens dill khatta ho gaya
If BJP has an internal system of accountability then Nadda should resign or atleast have the moral responsibility to do so because he is directly responsible for the poor performance of BJP in UP and recommended all wrong candidates instead of what Yogiji and recommended 😡
जिस डाली पर बैठे हैं उसी को काटते हुए नड्डा जी
Aisa mat socho ham hindu hai isliye bach jaengeAur laga ki tum jaise youth hi desh ka Bhavivysaya aur ye politics kitna brainwashed rakh rahi hai ham youth koAaj muslaman maar kha raha kal kisaan kha raha tha ek din jab sawal poochona choge to ham bhi kahenegeAur phir tumhe lagega bahut der ho gayiYe neta log politics ko isliye hi aisa rakhte hai taaki ham jaise youths inki taraf na dekheHam reels ke comment kattar hindu likhne mein busy rahenge aur ye log desh ka bantadhar karne mein lage rahenge❤
he is not, that is why he is Nadda and you are not!, he is laying ground for future!
BJP maybe political extension of RSS. (even though RSS refuses it) but their functions are different, and it mayn't match with each other,
BJP and RSS knows this very well and they have commonsense not to interfere with each other, other than in crucial maters. I do think you do lack that
BJP would fail miserably, if they have this stance on RSS..
If Nadda actually said this, then he can say goodbye to his glittering career 😅.
HE IS TALKING LIKE SON WHO IS IGNORING FATHER LIKE SON OF WHO LEFT MOTHER AT AIRPORT.
I am an RSS swayamsevak and a BJP booth president from Kerala. Sangh always wanted its frontal organisations to grow by themselves and become 'atmanirbhar'. So what Naddaji has told is correct. His words do not indicate any wedge between BJP and RSS. After all Modiji is still a Sangh pracharak.
No. Modi has left RSS a long time back. When was the last time you saw him wearing RSS shorts, or giving an RSS salute? Just like BJP eating out the local parties they align with, they will eat RSS out of existence.
We trust you
@@sibimanjale He need not always have to wear uniform to prove that he is a swayamsevak. Whatever he has done in office is in accordance with the policies of Sangh.
Da sangi
@@DhhbnShorts poda sudapi commi. Niyokke ini karanjukondu irikkukaye ulloo
Very insightful
Bjp will be reduced to below 100 believe me if at all rss decide to take away support. Trust me u don’t know the power of rss
What was Modi's stature before he came in limelight? Don't worry. RSS will bring someone equally capable.
Appreciate the controlled and precise narration
The Print and Guptaji should also go back to rss for better strategy!
BJP's Sambit Patra says even God worships Mudi. 😂
Good analysis and reporting !!
Thank you dksingh sir for the valuable video.
Hi Prakash,
Glad you liked it. Thank you for watching!
Great Analysis 👍 DK
RSS knows that Modi will take over even RSS if he wins again!
What Nadda said is true. In 2004 Rss to bjp worker ratio was 1:1.5
Today this ratio is 1:30 (for every RSS workers, there are 30 bjp workers.
They should have banned them
60% of BJP Telangana MP candidates are turncoats from BRS
Thank you Sir for the wonderful video.🙏
Thank you 🙏
Thank you Mr Singh. As a subscriber, I like to listen to your sharp, insightful analysis. It is therefore with great respect that I would like to make some observations: 1-Please continue to give translations in english of the quotes in Hindi or another language; it is most helpful. 2-Would you please speak at a slower pace? On occasions (in the course of the video) I found it difficult to follow your presentation and 3-sporadically the audio became less audible, perhaps due to the positioning of the microphones? Many Thanks.
Thanks a lot for your feedback. Your observations are valid. We will work on these issues.
It's the RSS who need BJP all the time, be it roti, clothing and even feeding their families. RSS would extinct without BJP.
Rss has existed even before independence..BJP was formed in 1980 only
BJP is RSS's prodigal child @@yourstruly1234
Poor people doesn't understand with Naddha's speech now opposition say that RSS behind bjp is totally snubbed.
3 costly mistakes - party president, Finance minister and minister of women & child welfare
With the elections nearing their conclusion, Nadda has made a bold statement. Despite facing challenges in securing his own seat, he has asserted his independence by stating that he does not require the support of the RSS.
RSS has to create BJP2 so it will be always BJP1 vs BJP2.
Interesting
Take out RSS ideology and BJP is just another Congress. So even BJP organisation maybe strong, they need RSS for ever
Unlike most discussions/analysis, which are usually mostly a waste of time, having really nothing to say, DK's stories are usually unmissable. Thanks !
Thank you so much
IF OTHER PARTY DID NOT IGNORE HINDU, RSS DID NOT SUPPORT BJP.
Corruption galore, over confidence leads to death 👎👎👎
That's what RSS expects from all frontal organisation
Your language for india or for word earth 🌎
Dictator and his gangster will be gone soon.
Very natural
Every son needs support of father in Initial phase,
As he growes the support needed is less,
Son may ask for guidance if he feels like doing so,
Father may give advice without asking as all fathers do.
RSS provides behaviour bjp provides power
reminds me of "Punar Mushika Bhava" story
This shows that politics without principle is bound to falter sooner or later, be it left wing or right wing ideology.
Let the ECI give notice to JP Nada for RSS comment😂😂😂
It was a simple statement, people are over analysing😂😂
Though it should be avoided.
Now those who dont know rss will say that this is arrogance.. but rss is behind brain of bjp.. these statements are for those who criticize bjp for rss backing.. its just for elections but reality is rss will always be there for bjp... N bjp will always be there for rss.
If BJP distances itself from RSS, it is their downfall.
RSS can create a new political wing and can back it up to power in due course
Rss is the core of bjp just like gandhis are tge core of congress
The issue with the opposition, as perceived by the BJP, is that they fail to grasp the strategic positioning currently underway. The BJP aims to demonstrate their independence from the RSS by appealing to a specific community and distancing themselves from religious-based ideologies. This tactic is likely well understood by most RSS members.
Its just to dilute opposition, bjp doesn't function without Rss , its impossible to separate them , rss idiology is the base of bjp
Now they became RSS fan?
baap ki jarurat nahi h betey ko 😢
This be tested also in महाराष्ट्र
He should not forget it's root or this big tree will fall sooner
*Nadda is just trying to answer the critic otherwise he also knew BJP ke is just a political wing of RSS*
divide and rule is the policy of the west and print is trying to do the same; but it will never work with bjp/rss ; as most of them are product of the same
Divide and rule isn’t merely a policy belonging to the English. Modi/BJP/RSS all have the same principle. Divide Hindus and Muslims and increase communal tensions in order to maintain power.
@@fawaaza.7743 hindus know the true intention of muslims in kashmir, kerala and wb. muslim tends to become ruthless once they are majority ; there exist no minority in pak and bangla
@@fawaaza.7743bjp is uniting hindus and muslims since 2014 70 percent hindus are voting to bjp and 70 percent muslims voting to congress 😂cry talwar ko dek salvar kho liya😂
No party Cando without the cader.
Too much is being made
Tell tale signs of pending BJP's decline
Arrogance speaks
RSS can able to produce another Party like BJP.
JP nadda ki wajah se Sant Samaj aur Sangh/RSS samaj ne U.P me full support nhi kiya
Jb inhone ye bol diya tha ki Sangh k bina bhi hum full majority le skte hain
Aur Ayodhya me Sant samaj ko Ijjat na deke Modiji Celebrity form leke red carpet bicha k vote ki Politics kr di
Usse sare Sant Mahatma log naraj hue aur BJP ko Mirror dikha diya
Shi tarike se Modiji ko Piche rhna chaiye tha Ayodhya mandir k time pe aur Sant Mahatma logo ko aage rkh k bs sabka Ashirwad lena chaiye tha.. tb inko na keval Ayodhya ka Ashirwad lekin Ram ka Ashirwad bhi milta.
Ab isko leke bura na manna bhai log
Me bht neautral Geopolitics ka student hu
Mujhe pta h India me aur especially north mein
Sant samaj aur RSS jo ghr ghr jake logo ko family bna k influence krte rhe h vote krne ko
Wo is br nhi hua
Agr aap U.P se h to apko farq dikha hoga ki kitna apko contact kiya gyaa personally RSS ki taraf se.
Answer apko khud mil jayega
BJP leader jo bde h 4-6 unko ghamand apna todna pdega aur ego khtm krk wapas se logo se jud jaye
Power ka nashe me inhone apne bado tk ko respect nhi kiya
To bhagwan Ram tak inse naraj ho gye aur Ayodhya se bhi inko haara diya..
Sirf face value bchi rhe aur Congresss na aa jaye power mein utna hee sant samaj aur RSS se support mila h ki ventilator pe govt. Bjp ki khdi ho sake
Jai Hind 🙏
Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
DK Singh is trying to hard to create divide between BJP-RSS with his exaggerated understanding and presentation !RSS and BJP are always like Ram-Lakshman ❤
We thought so, but now BJP is showing middle finger to RSS.
You are the type of people we need in this country
@@sibimanjale no no RSS and bjp are inseparable man !
There is nothing too deeply wrong with what Nadda says, but it is a fact that RSS brings discipline, ideology, well trained and organized cadre and much more to the table. This benefits BJP. Don't forget, Nidi himself is from the RSS.
Without RSS,BJP will be nowhere.Modijee,plz remove him' else nadda will be Rahul ghandy for BJP
Ab " Misprint " Knows more. About BJP than BJP. 😂
Congress can never repay..the suffering of millions ..without basic amenities like pipe water, electricity, cooking gas, toilets for over half a century
One gets a feeling that DK has made an effort to show that differences exist between RSS and the BJP. Nothing could be farther from the truth. It is inherent nature of the Print to adopt anti BJP narrative.
He has wonderfully analysed. U r illiterate to understand his point
Theory and practical has difference, practical need experiment, experiment need money and time and sacrifice. therory need just knowledge and faith and a guru there is no need of money or risk . This is the difference between RSS and BJP . Social experiments are dangerous dont meddle with nature .
#BJP's succession is #hindus' problem ? public can make anyone PM.
#PoliticallyCorrect #rss #modi
Clearly visible and it looks like, All these people from one side have "Lost their Tounge and Utter All Nonsense Words" right drom the lowest level person to the Top Person of that side. So all these people missing tounghe and Do Not Know How to Speak Well. So, they All are blabbering something.
Koi context toh dedia karo DK
Very arrogant, unwanted, un called fir statement. 😡😡
You are telling that Nadda is wrong and Modi is right.
But I think Nadda is doing his duty and he is trying to divert anti Modi sentiment of UP people into anti RSS feeling. It is similar to putting forth Nadda photo when BJP loses an election relegating Modi photo to backside.
BJP fools people like this.
B.J.P. ho gayi hai ghamandi !
Modi ho gaya hai.... Amit saha ko PM nahi bana ke Yogi ko banana hai
If BJP avoid RSS then many dalith will support BJP💪
Because of RSS daliths are not supporting BJP