Who Is The Best QB In College Football: Shedeur Sanders Vs. Carson Beck Film Breakdown!
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 05. 2024
- Everyone has been talking of the recent emergence of Carson Beck as the #1 Ranked QB in College football OVER Shedeur Sanders. In This live we will breakdown Full game film of BOTH QB's so you can decide who is the superior Quarterback! Make sure to be in the chat for this one!
/ buffedinprime - Sport
lol T Cal just put all the UGA fans to bed with this argument 😂😂😂
lol they went SILENT
@@BuffedInPrimeand immediately left the chat lol
Put beck behind shedeur oline last year and 90% of his passes are check downs
@@kianclinch3315make that 98% 😂
@@thehfamily_ 😂
I think when you look at the numbers, Colorado’s QB put up last year with the office. He had no way anyone can say he’s a secondary quarterback this year. All the pieces are going to come together is going to be Cinderella all the way.
🎶"Hello who's nxt? Sumn Sumn Sumn do your words match your video?" I can't get enough of that intro 🔥🔥🔥
It’s obvious Colorado was sabotaged from with last year. Their 3-0 start was no fluke. Too many want to see Coach Prime fail, for multiple reasons.
Oh, so how was it sabotage? Those other teams flew in better players? 😂
Those scouting reports on shedeur were accurate when he was a freshman at jsu! I watched him get better and more comfortable every year. People that really know what quarterbacking looks like has him as the first qb off the board.
I saw his games at Jackson state. I knew then he was good. But now, no doubt he is the best quarterback in college football.
First time I heard T-CAL breakdown some film I said to myself he won't be doing this long before someone snatches him up and puts him on their staff if they are smart. Bravo young Man!
🫡!! Appreciate you fam!
@@BuffedInPrime All day everyday. You made an open and shut case. I'm proud of you
This man CT said “ You have officially entered supervillain status!”😂
Dunno whats going on but I can't see my previous posts...anyhow, while Beck is in the SEC and had really good stats to that point, Sheduer played against 5 top 25 ranked teams with the worst O-lins in fbs. Once again, put Sheduer behind UGA's line from last year and they win the NC and he wins the Heisman .
That’s a weird assumption seeing how if you think Sheduer is a big upgrade over Carson then Georgia would’ve been so much better to the point where Sheduer wouldn’t be throwing late in games to have the numbers to win the heisman. Big difference how plays are called when you’re up by 20 late in a game oppose to being in a shootout. There’s a reason Carson had less pass attempts despite playing 3 more games.
@antw9770 the amount of throws was due to no o line... thus no running game.
@@ahouston3202that was a part too yeah. So if he’s on a better team with a better o line that’s gonna run the ball more where are these extra passing yards to win the heisman coming from? Not to mention if shedeur going to Georgia makes them this dominant team will he even be in games in 4th quarters? You gotta take all this into account.
@@antw9770Bruh…what you just said defies reality. Especially after watching film breakdown of an SEC quarterback throw check down’s on over 95% of his passes. Film doesn’t lie…but you will try to convince not to believe our lying eyes. 🤣🤣
@@CBW10 defies reality of what? Despite depth of throws Georgia still had an efficient passing offense that was a top 10 passing offense in the country. There’s only so many yards to be gained in a game when you’re balancing a run game with a pass game. So again explain to me where all these extra yards will be coming from if Sheduer is in the game when Georgia would be playing with a lead running the ball and killing the clock? My whole point is no matter who is the quarterback the offensive game plan isn’t changing. Georgia isn’t all of a sudden gonna be airing it out up 20 in a fourth quarter. There was very few games Beck was even throwing in the 4th. If shedeur is the QB does Georgia run the ball less? Are they in tighter games so he needs to throw more? Y’all keep bringing up “if Sheduer played for Georgia” like y’all weren’t the fan base screaming “we coming and we got Louie” all offseason. Don’t worry cause according to Colorado fans those G5 linemen y’all brought in the portal and a true freshman is all Deion needed and shedeur will be throwing to the supposed best player in the country so no excuses this year.
Beck is ok but he’s sometimes slow to react and doesn’t have the arm strength to throw his receivers open. Lucky for him he has elite skill players.
As for Shedeur, I’m very familiar with the Lewis offense. It’s a version of the Run and Shoot, which I learned from John Jenkins back in the 90’s and ran for about 15 years. I don’t know how many times I watched CU run Hook, Hook Special, Divide and X Choice incorrectly. The Sprint passes were Hook Spc and the OL was not running the correct sets. In the drop back varieties, the stop routes should’ve turned into quick ins and they didn’t. The Hook (which is a corner by #2 or #3 in Spc) turned into a PoCo and the WR was running straight into the Safety and not breaking either in or out.
I say this to say that Sanders was right about all the issues with the option routes. He was not holding the ball too long. He was not slow to read. His OL was struggling and his WR’s weren’t breaking into the correct options. The USC game featured those 4 passes over and over, and basically Antonio once and Omarion on his big plays, were the only ones running the routes right. That was a pattern throughout the season.
As for the evaluations near the end, those guys have Madden educations. I’m talking the video game and not the legend himself. They clearly know nothing about actual football and they no even less about film study. If stats are all that matter, then Revis was a lousy CB and Matt Stafford must have like 5 Super Bowl wins. The Pros study film, not stats. Bloggers and Gamers study stats.
Sanders is clearly better than Beck in accuracy and arm strength and this year we’ll see his true decision making skills in action under Shurmur. I guarantee you that.
Beck has the arm strength. Accuracy is what he lacks (at least last year)
@@thehfamily_ I’m going to humbly disagree. Arm strength is not measured by throwing the ball 70 yards downfield. It’s measured by getting the ball to the window on time. A QB can be accurate within the short to intermediate range, but when he throws behind and high to his receivers in the upper range of the intermediate area and beyond, that’s a lack of arm strength.
I know that may sound silly and just sounds a lot like accuracy, but in the upper levels, there’s a difference between knowing where the windows are (accuracy) and being able to hit them (arm strength). I hope that makes sense.
Elite skill players? He had a great TE and a solid slot receiver. His WR2 is a projected 7th round pick and his WR3 went undrafted. Both his RB’s went undrafted. Y’all don’t even know the team just be saying stuff. This year he doesn’t have a single skill player that’s projected higher than a 4th round pick so when he puts up similar numbers again what will the excuse be?
@@antw9770 well with all due respect, since you have clearly articulated the ultimate gloom and doom scenario for GA, please explain how Beck will put up similar numbers with no skill help if you don’t mind.
By the way, how did Beck compare to Sanders since Sanders had no OL, no run game, no drafted skill players, etc? Using your criteria of course. Thanks and have a nice day.
@@jasonlewis5350 Because it doesn’t take “elite” skill weapons to put up those numbers. They’re a solid offensive group but this isn’t 2019 Alabama with a 1st round RB and 4 1st round receivers. I’m just correcting the false narrative that Georgia in 2023 had this unbelievable elite offensive unit. I’ve seen Sanders family fans say this over and over yet it isn’t true. I don’t blame them though because I know they didn’t really watch Georgia or know the team. They know the name Bowers from the draft and that’s it. They just assume Georgia being a top ranked team had loaded weapons but it isn’t true. The only other offensive skill player drafted was a slot receiver Ladd McConkey. The “elite” RB duo that I saw Sanders fans saying Beck had went undrafted. His WR2 who will be the WR1 this year is projected as a 7th rounder going into the year and maybe could go up to 4th round with a good year but isn’t seen as an elite prospect. And his WR3 from last year went undrafted. So Beck with a great TE (missed 5 games) solid slot receiver (missed 4 games) and a bunch of other undrafted skill guys put up almost 4,000 yards with a 4-1 TD to interception ratio. I’m not saying he’s a superstar but y’all acting like he’s a bum getting carried by a team full of future NFL stars is just disingenuous.
To me this is a ridiculous question. Not only is number two the number one. There's a distance between the next competitive quarterback with the same level of stats. So in my opinion there is no number 23, 4 or maybe even five. That's how much better number two is from this other quarterback. Number. Two was the best quarterback last season. If you don't understand what I'm saying, just ask TCU, Nebraska, Colorado State, UCLA, and virtually every other team at that played. There's only two other quarterbacks that racked up the amount of yardage he threw for. Only a handful of quarterbacks that threw more touchdowns and none of them did it unprotected like he did. There's no other quarterback even close last year or this year. He is the most pro-ready quarterback in the longest time and probably the best quarterback ever for Colorado
Thank you guys for the authenticity of this channel! TCal I like your stance on dealing with haters! May you and CTDAFan experience much success🙏👍🎊🎈
Yeah, y’all done came up big… congrats
I live in the Atlanta, Beck had 2 great TEs! Actually 3 ! One was a 6’5 bro that was in the draft the 3rd replacement Bower when Bower had mid season ankle surgery !
Yo! This what we all need! Carson stayed in school maybe he thought Shedeur is a push over!
Lol damn 3 hours i missed the live but havent watched..can already tell this gone be lit😂
Great breakdown! Best 1 you guys have shared because people assume these QB‘s at top tier programs are better than the films indicates!
I saw the headline. Being from Georgia, I've watched UGA football. I was at the Mizzou game. I didn't know anyone thought Carson Beck was "that guy". lol. I do believe NY would take him over Sanders. That Daniel Jones pick was a head-scratcher for me at the time.
After analyzing these sets, it seems that the option style offense wasn't suitable for the WRs and it was evident that to run that last yr #2 needed a cleaner pocket more consistently since the read takes a fraction longer to develop. Having a more Pro offense this yr will highly benefit SS's progression and speed he gets the ball out
“I told you to leave Carson Beck alone they done took out the whole power in the neighborhood.” 😂😂 #CarsonBeckdown
Missed the live 🙁Great podcast as usual. #2Legendary all day💪🏾💪🏾every day!! #SKOBUFFS
Not uncle Tcal taking the belt off 😂 😂😂
Has to be done 😂
Watching this video I’m wondering what is beck good at besides checking down
awesome my brothers
You can’t throw for 3200 yds throwing short passes like the NFL scout said of Shedeur !
Guys remember Shedeur was taking a few too many sacks by the time they played SC because the Oline was failing. That’s why he began to scramble!
T CAL PUT THEM HATERS TO BED!!! ( WAY TO GO GUYS) I LOVE IT❤❤💯💯💯💯♥️♥️💯💯💯💯
YOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! man though I am from GA... I am all for giving credit ... QB1 Sanders is killing the game... I'm glad folks are dismissive ... the punch that knocks you out is always the one you dont see
No comment fam gunning everybody
That throw is a clinic for those that are generational talent shedeur is himmmmm
Great breakdown….If I were Shedeur,I would hire you as my personal QB filmbreakerdowner👈🏾
Shedeur glazers
what did Dave Chappelle say about Twitter it's not a real place
T Cal, I don't beleive you when you say you will not be a coach one day! Lol.... QB1 that wears #2 is him, and the "hate trolls" just got dog walked.
He tore #1s acl with that tackle
My man T cal is surgical w this sh$@ tho!!! Spitting str8 facts 💯
🫡 all facts no-fiction! Appreciate ya!
Comment just for the algorithm, 1 love.
I’m with T-Cal , I hope the the scouts under estimate Shedeur so he can fall the the Raiders! I’ve been hoping that since he transferred ! I’ve been watching him since JSU and Travis since HS here in the ATL!
Shedeur came into the season with 896 pass attempts under his belt, Beck came into the season with 58. It'll be interesting to see how Beck plays with a full season of experience under his belt. I'm excited to watch both of these guys this fall.
GameChanger vs GameManager #UpTheSko
4-8 game changer🤔vs 12-1 game manager #GoDawgs
Have mercy on em kiddo
Let my boy cook. He performing a stew chicken dinner right now
CHOP EM UP TCAL!
🫡 🫡🫡🫡
What does check down mean?
A checkdown pass is when the quarterback attempts to complete a short, accurate pass, typically to a running back or tight end, as a last option when the primary receivers are covered. In Becks case, he never looked at any other receiver, he mostly looked for the easy short pass.
Dawgs OL is Elite! Even with the self proclaimed CU OL it’s still mid! 👀
If you enjoyed this video, don't keep it to yourself! Hit that like button, subscribe to join the Buffed in Prime community, and share with your friends to spread the love!"
This isn’t even an argument. Shadeur isn’t even NFL caliber.
Great breakdown. However could be really really condensed. T-Cal got ADD too much and unfocused on the point of this video. CT’s humor gets old fast.
Now ask us if we care about your opinion. I have the answer ready 😊
@@BuffedInPrime If you truly didn’t care you would never have taken the time to reply. I’m just providing feedback to take your show to the next level. You have a solid foundation.
This helps the algorithmic lol truly couldn’t care less. Don’t care about your input, don’t care how you feel about our foundation
Carson Beck could not beat out a walk on Stetson Bennett. Bennett was lucky not to be an undrafted free agent. He is now no longer in the league. Georgia least talented players have been the quarterbacks. Beck might not even be a top 10 quarterback. All he has to do is not derail the freight train called Georgia.
You're misinformed, you put it on full display with this conmment.
I agree Carson Beck not better than Sanders at all saw him play in person and I support Colorado hoping they do great this year. Don’t disrespect Bennett idc about the nfl with him he was a great college football player, a 2 time ncaa champion and I was at a lot those games in person he was the best offensive player Georgia had on the field trust me he had a lot talent 🐶
@@deewill2131 Dude said Bennett is "no longer in the league". LOL, he has no idea what he's talking about.
Same thing could be said for Stroud, Bryce Young, Ewers, Dart, McCarthy and every other QB fortunate enough to play with Uber talented rosters
3 int lol a bunch of deep pass plus college football calls sacks a rush
Carson led UGA to a 13-1, 8-0 in the SEC! Sheduer lead CU to a 4-8 record and 1-8 in the PAC-12🤫Carson threw for 3,914 yards after splitting touches with his RB’s vs Sheduer throwing for 3,320 yards passing the rock 85% of the time w/his RB’s getting little to no burn to help his OL🤔
What was georgias record before he became a starter? Il tell you 15-0. What was Colorados record before sheduer 1-11. So tell me where exactly did each player lead their team
@@bloading15Colorado is an entirely new team compared to the one that went 1-11
I’m no Rico Knows Fan but he was right about y’all 👀 😂
And you a sucka just like him 😂 and you’re subscribed to us. You a Fan you a fan you a fan!!
@@BuffedInPrime ...Freaky A** ni88a he a 69 god.... lol
Would’ve love to see the breakdown from a neutral standpoint. It’s clear who the channel favors.
Who did the film favor?
@@BuffedInPrime The channel favors Shedeur obviously. It’s not like you were going to put clips up of someone outshining him. I get that. I love the film breakdowns on this channel tho. Would be cool to see breakdowns on other teams and/or star players as well.
@@carlosroberson6659 still didn’t answer my questions. I didn’t delete any unfavorable throws or clips. What does the FILM 🎥 favor?
@@BuffedInPrime It favors Shedeur. There is so much film that could make either player look good or bad. Would be cool to see you break down film without a dog in the fight.
The film itself dnt make any decisions for either Qb…u couldn’t have watched this film fr because t-cal gave beck plenty props when he deserved them and acknowledged when #2 could have made a better decision,placed balls better or if a sack was his fault..this isn’t A.I.
This video would’ve been even better if you would’ve had a former QB or QB Coach breaking it down with you.
Naw, just us. We not bringing nobody on lol
@@BuffedInPrime Getting someone’s prospective who actually played or coached the position has some value for videos like this
We’re a two man team lol that’s us, as a DB I studied QBs week in and week out, I know what to look for and I played QB in HS. But appreciate the input
All the haters we sold out woohoo and we will go undefeated and dominate you will not be able to say a dam word or shitttttttt period!
Shedeur completion percent has never been 63%
Ur right it’s been higher
You do know you can easily google that he was 69.3% last yr instead of lookin like a clown
He has never had a completion rate that low is true. He completed 69% of his passes is also true.
Hilarious 😂😂😂😂😭 if Shedeur played anything close to SEC defenses he’d never be able to walk again what a clown show
Must be why Georgia scheduled so many cupcake teams with weak defenses, trying to duck the smoke. Hilarious 😂😂😂
@@kingcourtney6982 you don’t know what you’re talking about and it’s cool cause you know you don’t know what you’re talking about 😂😂
Please stop…Colorado was 4-8. He’s only getting any attention because of his Dad. He’s not even top 25 in the Country.
This is so stupid. Is college football a team sport or an individual sport. Georgia only lost 1 game last year. While Colorado lost 8. Smh
Comparing 2 individual players is individual. Not team related 🤡
@@BuffedInPrime if you were a real college football analyst, It would be different. But, you are only a bias fan boy of shedeur. That’s the only reason why you were doing the comparison. Did you point out the Colorado was a pass first team and Georgia had more of a balance offense.
@@kongkinglive2.0reloaded96 went further playing ball than you 😂 🤡 watch the video and you’ll see. You don’t know anything about football
@@BuffedInPrime 😂 that’s funny. I don’t know anything about football. But you are the one who is trying to compare a winner against a loser. 😂
@@kongkinglive2.0reloaded96 proving my point with every message 😂 but you’re right, that’s why Stetson Bennet was a 1st round pick and has been balling in the NFL
UGA playing cupcakes? Half of Colorado's 2023 conference was cupcakes.
colorado played more ranked teams
We found the troll in the chat. 😂😂😂