Gingerbread Cake Cookie.. Please! Seriously one of my top favorites! Is the icing on Gingerbread the same as most of their cookies? Trying to find a recipe for it as well. Thank you for all that you do karli!!!
So happy you made the video in your house instead of your car like many other reviewers.... but to top it off you discuss recreating these flavors in your kitchen.
Thanks Karli, will go to Crumbl tomorrow... I will request for the Mom's Recipe Oatmeal Cookie. Like everyone else, I love Buttermilk Pancake too, less sweet in my opinion..
I have been doing research for the center of that cookie and Corn syrup is definitely in there! I'll have to give your ratios a go when I do some testing today! Thanks!
Oh man, the Moms Cookie is so good! I didn't try the egg nog, I got the sugar cookie with sprinkles and white chocolate frosting and also tried the gingerbread. Gingerbread was our least favorite. I'm so addicted I totally look forward to seeing what the new flavors are each week!
I bought the eggnog yesterday and I’m a little sad I didn’t like it as much as I thought I would? I tend to like brown sugar, butter, oat profiles.. I wish I hadn’t missed the pancake cookie, haha. Looking forward to trying your recipe.
Love that idea! The dirt cake is actually a chocolate oreo cookie with a chocolate cream cheese frosting, but I think crushed peppermint on top would be a game changer!
Probably! That's what I used for my recipe for Sea Salt Toffee cookies and it workout really well. I actually kind of want to play with the heath bits that you can find in the baking isle though, they are much smaller but I feel like it would spread the toffee love throughout the whole cookie a little better. I think I only got one toffee chunk in my entire cookie and I really liked the toffee! haha
My eggnog cooking came cold. Also, I wanted to love the gingerbread. Mine was not spicy and had barely any flavor. There was SO much frosting that it overwhelmed the whole flavor of the cookie. Wanted to love them both. Bummer :-(
Dang! Maybe my gingerbread and yours should combine and then we'd both love them. haha Mine had too much flavor it seemed. My son actually really liked that one, but he loves fall spicy flavors (which is hilarious because he might be the pickiest kid I know haha). I wonder if my eggnog was warm because it just came out of the oven.. Maybe it's supposed to be chilled! I should look it up. haha
Gingerbread Cake Cookie.. Please! Seriously one of my top favorites! Is the icing on Gingerbread the same as most of their cookies? Trying to find a recipe for it as well. Thank you for all that you do karli!!!
So happy you made the video in your house instead of your car like many other reviewers....
but to top it off you discuss recreating these flavors in your kitchen.
Last weeks buttermilk pancake recipe was amazing.
Would love to try the eggnog
Can you post a recipe for the moms cookie? It was one of my favs this week.
Mom's recipe pleeeease 💜🍪
03:48
My birthday is this month do they give you there choice of a cookie for your birthday
I have made peppermint patties before. It's confectioners sugar, butter, mint extract, vanilla and heavy cream.
Moms cookie and peppermint. ❤️🎄
Great video. Never heard of Crumbl before now. Love your attention to detail.
Thanks Karli, will go to Crumbl tomorrow... I will request for the Mom's Recipe Oatmeal Cookie. Like everyone else, I love Buttermilk Pancake too, less sweet in my opinion..
All of them please! 😉 Yummy!! 😋🥰
1/4 cup butter
1/3 cup corn syrup
1-2 tsp. Peppermint extract
3 cups powdered sugar
I have been doing research for the center of that cookie and Corn syrup is definitely in there! I'll have to give your ratios a go when I do some testing today! Thanks!
I love all these flavors. Has anyone tried freezing cookies? I wish I knew what cookies were coming for Christmas.
Moms cookie and peppermint
Oh man, the Moms Cookie is so good! I didn't try the egg nog, I got the sugar cookie with sprinkles and white chocolate frosting and also tried the gingerbread. Gingerbread was our least favorite. I'm so addicted I totally look forward to seeing what the new flavors are each week!
I bought the eggnog yesterday and I’m a little sad I didn’t like it as much as I thought I would? I tend to like brown sugar, butter, oat profiles.. I wish I hadn’t missed the pancake cookie, haha. Looking forward to trying your recipe.
The eggnog cookie and the peppermint pattie cookie you should make😄
Moms recipe cookie, York cookie and last weeks pancake cookie!!😄
Moms Recipe and Gingerbread 😊
Peppermint cookie
I was hoping Crumbl would make a chocolate cake cookie with a cream cheese and finely chopped candy on top. Maybe even a chocolate cream cheese icing.
Love that idea! The dirt cake is actually a chocolate oreo cookie with a chocolate cream cheese frosting, but I think crushed peppermint on top would be a game changer!
York peppermint patty and moms cookie please
I didn't like the snickerdoodle it was gummy not sweet tasted kind of bitter
mom's recipe and peppermint patty please!
Your daughter handing you a knife to help cut! Awwwww🥺🥺🥺🥺♥️
I can imagine how to make this except for the toffee. What would you use for the toffee, broken heath bars??
Probably! That's what I used for my recipe for Sea Salt Toffee cookies and it workout really well. I actually kind of want to play with the heath bits that you can find in the baking isle though, they are much smaller but I feel like it would spread the toffee love throughout the whole cookie a little better. I think I only got one toffee chunk in my entire cookie and I really liked the toffee! haha
@@CookingwithKarli I look forward to your experiment results. I was unaware that those existed. thank you, happy holidays.
Please make an eggnog copycat!
My eggnog cooking came cold. Also, I wanted to love the gingerbread. Mine was not spicy and had barely any flavor. There was SO much frosting that it overwhelmed the whole flavor of the cookie. Wanted to love them both. Bummer :-(
Dang! Maybe my gingerbread and yours should combine and then we'd both love them. haha Mine had too much flavor it seemed. My son actually really liked that one, but he loves fall spicy flavors (which is hilarious because he might be the pickiest kid I know haha). I wonder if my eggnog was warm because it just came out of the oven.. Maybe it's supposed to be chilled! I should look it up. haha
First one here lmao
You win a virtual cookie!! 🍪