RUGBY ANALYSIS | How Did Scotland HUMBLE England? (2024 Six Nations)
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 07. 2024
- After lacklustre efforts in Round 1 & 2 of the 2024 Six Nations, Scotland humiliated the England efforts with clinical expertise and a Duhan van der Merwe hat-trick! So, how did Scotland win and how did England crumble? Let's examine the result!
TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 - Introduction & Thanks to Patrons
1:08 - George Furbank’s Try
2:48 - Duhan van der Merwe’s 1st Try
4:39 - George Ford’s Drop Goal
5:50 - Ad Break
5:51 - Half-Time Stats Review
8:34 - Duhan van der Merwe’s 3rd Try
9:40 - Elliot Millar-Mills’ Match-Winning Turnover
10:55 - Immanuel Feyi-Waboso’s Try
11:59 - Full-Time Stats Review
15:04 - Final Thoughts & Conclusion
I must state that in NO way, shape or form am I intending to infringe rights of the copyright holder. Content used is strictly for research/reviewing and analysis purposes to help educate, under the Fair Use Laws.
"Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use."
Support me on Patreon - / theblackjersey6 - Sport
Brilliant performance from Scotland
Epic win for Scotland and fantastic performance from Duhan Van Der Merwe, thank you for covering Max.
Cheers for watching bro 💪
you are like a slower squidge (which I mean as a great compliment) such a good and detailed analysis. thank you so much for this clear explanation of tactical rugby, thumbs up!
Thanks for watching man 😎
We need to get this dude up in the rugby analysis algorithm. Certainly above that fucking melt Squidge.
It's not like this is a new thing. Scotland have been beating England for some time now.
Now only if we had beaten France then we could have set up an interesting final match day
Imagine that though 🔥
@@TheBlackJersey it could still happen but we would need England to do us a massive favour
Good analysis - minor quibble at 2:27 you have Jones labelled as Tuipulotu - actually Lawrence was bashing Sione out of the defensive line at this point - an obstruction similar to the one scotland got pinged for later in the game - the ball was yards behind Lawrence so it hard to pretend he is a decoy
I suspect you’ve got a larger screen than me 😂
The difference between Wales and England, Wales are genuinely building with youth, and Gatlands already told us is plan and not to expect miracles, that England team are still chocked with caps.
Yup, even though Wales are winless so far, at least you can see what they’re trying to do 😅
@@TheBlackJerseyI think when REGAN GRACE is 🔥 with BATH. he'll be a revelation for Wales
Good to see actual footage from the game - I'm sure it makes your job easier. It seems the "fair use" rules for Six Nations is far more sensible than those for the World Cup. It'd be interesting to see how it compares for the Rugby Championship.
I won’t be uploading too much in the Rugby Championship tbh. Won’t even bother watching the Australia games 💀
Quick Question. About the French vs Italy draw (what a game), do you think the last penalty should’ve been taken again? Thanks
I think that when Fin Smith missed the conversion after the try that kind of sealed the game.
Yup, England just don’t know what the heck is going on…
Why is England so bad when they have way more people than Ireland, Scotland and Wales combined....
At this point I’ve got no idea… all I know is that Eddie Jones was right 💯
In fairness they minimum make it to the semi finals in the WC near every time round. More than all those nations combined.
Is fairly clear that is their focus
AND nick players from other countries!
From an irish perspective I think eng struggle as their domestic teams like Leicester, Bath, etc are full of non qualified English players so although they have 9 teams in some positions they have limited depth. In ireland our 4 teams are only allowed 3 non Irish qualified players in our squad so we have no option other than develope players through our academies. It's good for our national team but means our club sides can struggle if they don't have the quality coming through their academies
My bs theory is there are a lot of English players who don't really like the sport. It struck me a couple of years ago when the Italians did their not contesting the ruck gimmick and the English players were baffled, why did Italy choose to unleash this plan away at Twickenham against a strong England team and not at home against a weaker Ireland, Wales or Scotland?
As a frustrated Englander I found your analysis carefully crafted , Spot On The passing of the ball , un-organised positioning , lead to England's demise. !
Don’t blame you for feeling frustrated man 😅
Thanks I will follow you with your excellent insight into rugby union especially with England with interest
Love your vids boyo
Cheers for watching brother 🙏
I wouldn't call it humiliated or use the word "humbled". Scotland have better players and played better. They also have a good coach. They deserved to win.
England have gone backwards at a ridiculous rate… the Premiership was the envy of the world just a decade ago…
Hi , i enjoy your analysis thanks, just wondering about your use of the word 'jackle' is that a thing? Or just a slip if the tongue. Cheers bro.
jackling is the term for the oppostion getting the ball out of the ruck
The “jackal” is the most common method of winning turnovers by a defending team. @yasdniklarf1885 explains how to do it perfectly 💪
I don’t think Eddie jones and Farrell are vindicated. On the contrary they contributed to the staleness and the fear of making mistakes that has plagued England.
The “staleness” has existed since before Farrell was born 💀
@@TheBlackJersey You remember when Farrell started arguing with the officials in the last game he played in an England shirt? They reckoned even back then that Borthwick was getting on his case a bit too much.......and that's basically why he did what he did, it was a personality clash him v. Borthwick. Personally I've NEVER rated Borthwick as a coach, knew he played second row for England once, but his methods have not improved one iota, and if England do not turn up against Ireland in the next game, then I'm sorry but the rot must be stopped, otherwise England start falling down the rankings and any future RWC's become not possible but likely improbable.
Quality vid
The lineout stats are wrong: England lost a lineout on their own throw in the second half.
England have a policy in place that blocks the coach from selecting the best players. They also have a coach in place that doesn’t pick the best of what’s left. It’s no surprise England are way off where they should be.
The more and more England fall down the world rankings, the more and more Eddie Jones is vindicated 💯
Spin spin spin hahah love it
@@TheBlackJersey with his win rate compared to any manager for England i feel like there is no vindication needed.
Excellent analysis. Congratulations to Scotland, they're making a habit of beating England. Putting things in perspective, we should remember that Italy were within a whisker of beating England who are probably only slightly better the Italians. There's a decent chance that the young Welsh team will finish 4th.
Yeah I think Wales can still beat Scotland… but it’ll depend on how certain things go 😅
@@TheBlackJersey Not unless they get a time machine and go back to the first round?
That's not a humiliation. Now losing to France 10-53 last year - that was a propah humiliation
Dull, turgid, formulaic and lacking aggression. Good to see new blood like Feyi-Waboso coming along; hopefully they can brighten up this woefully-dull England.
Yes a good Welsh boy.
England sacking Eddie Jones embodies everything wrong about the RFU 💯
The best winger since Shane Williams helped a lot . A very lot. A lotra lorra tries.
Cool breakdown but did I hear you say Jones is the world's best centre?
Jones is the world’s best 13, Aki is the world’s best 12 🔥🔥🔥
It's true Huw Jones is often overlooked when comparing the world's best 13's. However he has always appeared to be a classy act and a 'big game player.'
Lets give them time .. i (irish) want england on their game .. i want northern hemisphere to dominate rugby over the next 20 years ...ireland finally competitive.. france will be back, wales have zero quit and a really young squad , scotland the best they have been in 2 generations. England need to be pushing to top 3 in the world at all times.
England is top 3… bronze in the World Cup!
@TheDdvd1 finally a positive comment on this channel! You're right, I'm loving how good Scotland are at the moment, it's great for the 6 nations. Wales building for future. Italy are looking respectable. Look forward to Ireland Scotland. I'm hoping England put up a stubborn effort at home at Twickenham against you guys!
@@thomasskywalker8893 Would you settle for bronze every time? This must be the Borthwick syndrome.........................................
Very good as usual, Max, thank you for providing the details around space which are hard to pick up in real time and with camera angles that seem to provide emotional rather than tactical information.
Whilst I thought it was accurate for Borthwick to point out the disparity of experience in the two teams, it is somewhat disingenuous as this is a matter of choice for the head coach, and it came very close to biggest "no, no" in rugby, which is making excuses after a defeat. I am perhaps being a touch harsh, as he talks in such a monotonous voice that he must hold to truth and decency to gain respect, he has no sense of fun: if a pragmatist is making excuses it feels closer to lying, than someone happy to discuss nuance within a bigger picture.
I think that you are a wee bit harsh on Russell for the first try, as the positioning of the Scottish scrum half was awry.
Scotland's loss against France has somewhat spoilt a potential "final" against Ireland, which Ireland would cruise, but it would have been fun.
Scotland's problem, as ever, is a lack of depth in the tight forwards, particularly the front row, and we don't appear to have much talent bubbling under the surface. I have enjoyed the progression of this team, and whilst they haven't made a serious dent in tournaments, they have provided so many great moments that I am grateful.
Yeah I do agree that Scotland needs younger props 😅
For me it was a tale of mysterious unforced errors that killed England’s momentum. Scotland could handle the ball so it wasn’t the conditions. England did show a formidable rush defence in the first 10 minutes and scored from a proper phase play, not just a lucky interception. I hate to say it but I think England choked.
England have not won the calcata cup for close to 8 years?
I’m English but that is the worst performance I have seen in a long time from England
Cue the trolls commenting “OwEn FaRrElL sTiLl BaD” 💀
@@TheBlackJersey Sorry, Max, I think that Borthwick and Farrell have had a few close encounters of the not-so-very nice kind. Which goes a long way to explaining why he was so hacked off with the officials in his last ever performance in an England shirt.
We didn't "humble" England, we beat them in a game of rugby. Get a grip!
I thought promising for England.
Handling errors and rushed passes can be fixed.
England on an improvement path ehich was nit the case over last few years
You were going OK till you said Jones was the best centre in the world
Scotland have had a settled team for atleast 4 years. Englands midfield have had 2 sessions and it showed. England also on 3rd ond 4th choice 9 & 10. Also england looseing players in france, farrell , willis & marchant probably make any teams 23.
Farrell wouldn't get a game for Scotland because he's a cry-baby tosspot.
@@stanleybuchan4610harsh but true
@@stanleybuchan4610harsh but true
@@stanleybuchan4610one look at his social media would tell you he’s not a fan of the “celebrity” life…
Considering where England were last year, I wouldnt consider this a humiliation. Scotland are the 2nd best team in this tournament, and were at home.
Call me a pessimist, I kinda get the feeling England haven’t improved since last year 😅
England have beaten Wales and Italy by less than last year and lost to Scotland by more organised last year. This game being at Murrayfield is the only saving grace really.
@@TheBlackJersey OK Max. You are a pessimist. I do agree with you though, if that's "improvement", well then, what's deterioration?
As a nation they have an identity issue as some say they are english whilst others say they are British
Maybe?
You can be British from either 4 countries that make up the UK
Complete tosh. We are all British no matter what country we in. Only outsiders that know nowt come up with crap like that. We just having a bad spell as all teams do. Not to say there's not fundamental issues with English rugby.
Britain is England and Wales, hence British.
Scotland joined to Britain by landmass makes it Great Britain meaning Scotland makes it great😁
Northern Ireland being classed as British isn't really a thing due to them not actually being part of the landmass plus when you speak of the UK which Northern Ireland is part of, it states, United kingdoms of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. And Northern Ireland, not U.K of the British lands.
As for the English identity crisis, there is a few things to back that up.
England, uses British anthem, not an individual National anthem.
As a whole, England is ruled by the UK PM, no Devolved representation at National level like a first ministers etc.
England has no national Parliament, it is under the authority of the UK.
England needs a little self respect before it will find its identity on the world stage and then in sports.
All in all though, English rugby fans are quite nice and behave better than their brothers and sisters at football games so there is hope.
Bless. English speaking English people in England are English, cultural confusion is for the conquered celts.
Van De Merwe and Russell are tearing England apart..😂😂😂
When you consider that all three VDM tries were scored from England mistakes, and the phenomenal kicking ability of Finn Russell...........well you could say that Scotland beat England with only two players. Which only leads me in one direction. BORTHWICK. I've played the game myself, at full-back, and if you give a winger the chance to run directly for the 22 then he'll take it. As England did. If they play like this against Ireland, well quite frankly, I'd rather NOT watch the game!! The rot MUST be stopped before it really sets in, otherwise England start dropping down the world rankings and any future RWC's become a matter of conjecture.
The rot in English rugby began long before Martin Johnson took charge in 2008… aside from the endless trophies under Eddie Jones, England has been in a slow slide into being a tier two nation ever since well before 2008…
It’s a familiar story we’ve seen before with Australia…
I think that really diminishes how well Tuipolotu and Jones were able to open up gaps or react in defense on turn over ball to let DVDM do his thing.
@@vadersjester OK. Give you that one. It's this coming Saturday at so-called "fortress" Twickenham that gives me the butterflies.
@@lesskeels3417 I know what you mean, Ireland are a hell of a team this year but there is always the England at home factor that means the game could go either way if England get themselves up for it and bounce back.
@@vadersjester Sorry, vadersjester, this one's already giving me the crinklies, crikey am I glad I'm not playing in it!! Borthwick is HARDLY an inspirational coach, he couldn't get the team all fired up and ready to play their guts out. Look at him sometimes in the box or the dugout. It's as if he just doesn't give a monk's. That plays right into the opposition's hands, they see or know that..........well, expect a THRASHING. Nothing you or I could do to stop it. Unless the RFU dismiss him. Or he gives his notice to them.
Its truly a wonder to see how quickly england went from pool D elite to struggling against scotland...surely thats just coincidental 🤔
Oh no definitely no coincidences there 😂
England still building, maybe we'll win next year. I hope England can pull something out against Ireland and give the tournament some excitement, would love to see Scotland win the whole thing.
Other than England building slower and worse than British Leyland…this is an excellent point - if England were to beat Ireland, that’d be great from a Scotland perspective (ignoring the fact that Scotland just can’t beat Ireland…). However, let’s not ignore the fact that England could then win it if they were to beat France!!!
England will never win anything under Borthwick. Take a look at his record, hardly enthralling is it?
Finn Russell's game management was excellent this week. Doesn't fit the narrative so predictably absent from the analysis
I didn’t want to waste my time stating the obvious that Scotland mostly play off 9…
Van De Merwe that great Scottish import .... Did he have a great great Aunty that once watched Braveheart , Thereby ensuring qualification or something 🤣
England second try scored by a Welshman. You aren’t all Anglo Saxons are you? No talent and fans that are poor losers.
You say that… yet Roots is only half-English and Underhill was born in the USA 💀
All hail Biltong Bravebok-McMerwe-Haggis
Why shouldnt Scotland beat England ?
England has 10 times the number of Rugby Union Players than Scotland even more regards Ireland and Wales. England should be winning much more.
It’s still 15 on 15…
@@paulwilson2651 Perfectly valid point. Then ask yourself WHY THEY AREN'T. The RFU would be one culprit. Coaches with antiquated methods eg. Borthwick, would be another.
England vs Scotland 7 years of pain for England only 1 victory for England Vs Scotland in 7 years 😂😂😂😂😂
And they’re still blaming Eddie 💀
Just so! but when it comes to the more important world cup, they do much better than the other UK teams.
Not really, other than the fixed draw last year they did just as well as Wales for like 10 years.
Your 1896 comment is not correct! I remember watching Scotland beating England four times in a row 1970-72, captained by Peter Brown.
One of those games was a centenary special, not a Calcutta Cup
@AJ-hu9ns That's correct, but doesn't negate the accuracy of my comment...
@@AJ-hu9ns you mean if England wins " special " games, they don't add that to their tallies and overall stats?
The comment in the video was that this is the first time Scotland have won four Calcutta Cups in a row since 1896. That is correct. @bobsimpson4298 commented that Scotland beat England four times in a row in the early 70s. That is also correct. One of the matches was not a Calcutta Cup, so both things can be true.
@@bobsimpson4298yes it does because he said Calcutta cup......
Yeah we gubbed them lol.
'We'. Lol.
@@clemfandango619yeah we did. What’s your problem with that lol 😁
Mean vid g up the Irish hope we smash EngLLLLand lol that 4 L’s for every Scotland one suck on that most boring 6N team shot for exposing them bro
Chill dude 😂
Schoolboy errors, schoolboy rugby from England.
Yup, they should have won the game by a healthy margin based on their set-piece… but then those happened…
Please, don't insult grass-roots rugby!! We all had to start somewhere!! The trick is in improving your game, getting better. Under Borthwick England hve retrogressed, not improved.
England's handling was very poor. As a result I could not see England winning.
Yup, very unusual to see them deal with the rain badly considering their national weather 😅
England will never win anything under Borthwick, sorry, not playing crap rugby like that.
They should never have got rid of Eddie Jones. When Japan smack the English side at the next World Cup then you’ll see.
Hahah you’re utterly clueless. Tell me how EJ did at the RWC?
@@Daniboi971anyone that’s paid attention to Australia in the last two decades knows they were lucky not to exit the pool stage in 2019. Rugby Australia is a joke and I’ve predicting this mess for a decade.
Eddie Jones gave it a go and attempted to see what he could do with the mess, by turning to the next generation. He obviously resigned because Bell and Donaldson are the only Wallabies who are good enough to play test rugby 💀
@@Daniboi971 I think the 6 nations should put their respective coaches names into a hat at the beginning of the season and the captains pull them out to select their coach for the next series. Imagine the creativity.
Blah blah blah more absurd predictions and wishful thinking from haters
Humiliation is a bit strong. They weren't that bad.
Nah g it a fact
I’d definitely feel a bit humiliated if I was one of the English players 😅
@RugbyWithMax scotland are a strong team. It's no shame to lose to them I think
Yes they were
I was there. They weren’t great. Scotland weren’t brilliant at points either, but we capitalised on mistakes for more efficiently from both sides.
I don't think you need to be a genius to beat England. They play predictable, slow rugby.
Yeah man, England have gone backwards a fair bit and I feel really bad for Steward in particular… he’s the one guy in that backline (of those available for selection) who you could say is world class, yet they dropped him for the game 💀
England got beat get over it
Jmo, but I preferred your channel when you just analyzed the game and weren't doing the screen meme stuff and jokes ala Squidge, that gets on my nerves and is why I stopped watching him after a while. Of course, other people may like it.
But van der Merwe is SOUTH AFRICAN ❤🇿🇦 and it took a SA to help Scotland to win......isn't he born from country that was sooooooo hated in the WC 🤔
He wasn’t born in England
Scotland made him the player he is and gave him a chance. Not South Africa - he is rightfully Scottish
England had non English players playing but English hypocrisy knows no bounds.
@@andrewmaclugash1592 you funny, thanks for giggle......he was a damn good player when he played for the Bulls and under 21 Springboks but he enjured his hip.....regrettably our talent is so incredibly deep that even the best struggles to play for the Boks and isn't that a blessing for all the other nations.....you get our best
Nor me . Thought the Boks were great@@whenisasnakeatail4933
THE BOKS PLAYED THE PISS OUT OF ENGLAND LAST YEAR. THEYVE NEVER RECOVERED
You mean when they won by 1 point?
Bro they won by a point. Clearly didn’t watch the game if you thought SA were thrashing them
@@Uncaringrain AAGGHH . . . . THE LITTLE TEAMS OF THE SIX NATIONS. HA HA
@@mrsusan5672 THEY WON THE WORLD CUP. NOT THE WOKE CUP. HA HA
@@valsables5299 From an English perspective holding Israel accountable for their actions is pretty woke. Not saying I agree with them, just saying it's typically a term used by c*nts who aren't allowed to describe things they hate as being gay anymore.
One team attacked, the other stood back and waited for mistakes. Without the SA winger what do Scotland offer…….very little.
Cry me a river.
They obviously give you a very good chance to get rid of all your salt.
Every country does it. Jealousy is' not becoming. New Zealand, Australia over there years have players that qualify thru family or residency, who were born in Samoa, Fiji or Tonga. Not to mention the other teams that make up the 6 nations.
Second English try by Welshman. Injured 10 from Philippines, replacement. 10 Scottish. Qualified , the list goes on. 10 x the population of your true Anglo Saxons and -10 times the talent. Cry baby
Without all the non English in the English team you'd be even worse. Just goes to show money can't buy everything.
Awful England selection against the Anglo Bok Scotch.
Bitter or what you're forgetting the non English players in England's team. Mind Scots are used to English hypocrisy!
@@paulwilson2651 when did England have eleven foreign born players in their team?
@@clemfandango619 Obviously English isn't your first language. Where did I say Eleven? I was pointing out to you hypocrites that England has non native players too including a Welsh man and a Scot. All part of the Celtic brotherhood to shaft you lot and Bhoy it works!
@@clemfandango619 sadly you’re too myopic to realise that there’s millions of your so called English who’ve got ancestry from other nations. Of you don’t like residency rules for qualification then agitate to change them but say goodbye to your NZ born players. If the English Premiership clubs were actually interested in the welfare of the national team, they wouldn’t have teams stuffed full of non-eligible players (we see you Bristol!!!). Perhaps you think the days of 10 man rugby were the days of heaven…
@@mikeharper3459 no pally, I'm talking about players born, raised and trained outside of Scotland. They're either of partial Scottish descent, or don't have any Scottish ancestry at all. Were England playing ten man rugby when they beat Scotland 61 -21?
How many of the Scottish players are - er Scottish?
And England also. Some England teams look half African/pacific..
What is the point in having national teams if half or more of the players are foreign?
They might as well just call the teams The English Barbarians, the Scottish Barbarians and so on…?
lots of scottish players are english, but there are no africans playing for england.
I assume you just can't distinguish between race and nationality?
@@InvestStrategyWire there are more kiwis playing for pacific island sides than pacific islanders playing for new zealand
@@newchannelname3395 Not sure about that one, but a lot of those sides, eg. Samoa, have their own versions of the "haka", the New Zealand Maori war dance.They might not fancy doing the NZ version, instead of their own, however intimidating it might be!!
@@lesskeels3417 what are you on about
Or we could just not be racist?
Lol how were England humbled? Don't try and make it out to be something it wasn't fool.
He addressed this, genius.
Ooo touchy
South African is not Scottish.
But Duhan is and he made the difference.....we are everywhere what a knife stabbing thing to witness 😂
Welsh is not English
And Samoan and New Zealand isn't English but you picked them. Get over the fact that Scotland are better than England right now and have been for awhile.
@@Topaz2008 Four in a row Hello Four in a row!
Scotland got help from apartheid South Africa
Apartheid South Africa was abolished in 1991 💀
The Grannie rule.
Dae ye want some mere England!
.......not jealous then?
It's actually post Apartheid South Africa, pretty sure they would be playing for the Springboks otherwise....
CLICK BAIT
SLIMY CLICK BAIT