Nature of India's Independence l क्या 1947 के बाद भी ब्रिटेन के राजा का भारत पर शासन था?
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 12. 2021
- #UPSC #IndianIndependenceAct #BritishKing #CurrentAffairs2022 #MahipalSir
UPSC CSE Learner's Form: forms.gle/4jJ4736FMdY2B9fu5
In this lecture, Mahipal Singh Rathore talks about the Nature of India's Independence l क्या 1947 के बाद भी ब्रिटेन के राजा का भारत पर शासन था?
👉🏼 Enroll Now: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/85c...
Unacademy Combat every Sunday at 11:00 AM.
👉🏼 Course on Post Independence History of India: unacademy.com/course/comprehe...
👉🏼History MCQs Series with Dr. Mahipal Singh Rathore: www.unacademy.com/a/History-M...
👉🏼 Comprehensive Course on Class XI NCERT Polity unacademy.com/course/comprehe...
👉🏼Top 20 Special Classes: bit.ly/PathFinder_
👉🏼 Dr. Mahipal Rathore’s Unacademy Profile Link
SignUp Here: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/221...
Welcome to Path Finder Channel, your one-stop solution for all UPSC CSE Exams. India’s Top Educators will be teaching you daily on this channel. We will cover the entire syllabus, strategy, updates, and notifications which will help you to crack the UPSC exams.
During the live session, our Educators will be sharing a lot of Tips and Tricks to crack the exam. UPSC aspirants who are preparing for their Exams will be benefited from this channel. Unacademy platform has the Best Educators from all over the country, who take live classes every day.
Dr. Mahipal Singh Rathore and more top educators are teaching live on Unacademy.
Use Special Code “MAHIPAL” to get 10% discount on your Unacademy Subscription.
👉🏼 Goal Subscription Page: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/728...
👉🏼 Goal Upcoming Class Page: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/fea...
👉🏼 Link for Loan Process: pluslearner.typeform.com/to/K...
👉🏼 Feedback Link: unacademystudios.typeform.com...
📝 Full Modern India Playlist Link: • Modern Indian History ...
📝 Full Current Affairs Playlist: • Most Popular Current A...
Do Subscribe and be a part of the community for more such lessons here:
👉🏼Join our Telegram Channel: t.me/pathfinder_upsc
👉🏼 Subscribe to our channel: / @pathfinderias
👉🏼 Bugs Bounty Program Submission Form: form.typeform.com/to/eGFuarQH...
Download the Unacademy Learning App here:
iOS: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/173...
Android: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/855...
Unacademy Learner App Benefits:
1. Learn from your favourite Educator
2. Dedicated DOUBT sessions
3. One Subscription, Unlimited Access
4. Real-time interaction with Educators
5. You can ask doubts in live class
6. Limited students
7. Download the videos & watch offline
Get the UPSC-CSE GS Iconic Advantage:
1. Personal Coach
2. Study Planner & Bi-weekly Reviews
3. Dedicated Doubt Clearing Space
4. Personalized Test Analysis
5. Study Booster Sessions
6. Preparatory Study Material
7. All the Unacademy Subscription Benefits
#MahipalSir #UPSC #PathFinder #IAS
To avail LIVE classes of Dr. Mahipal Rathore and other top educators, click here - unacademy.com/combo/upsc-cse-gs-upsc-cse-optional/NTYDC/subscribe?referral_code=mahipal
26 Jan 1950 True independence, as we had our own constitution into effect...
@@pratyaymustafi Ashoka chakr bhi hai national flag me iska kya matlab hai ki
Yahan Mauryan empire ka rule hai?
@@RbRaza007 .. Aisa bakchodi maat kaar .. aj vi nevi ka flag has cross .. what do you think why it has .. we are not Christan mejorty country so why it still has cross on it's flag ..
@@pratyaymustafi to isse ye sabit hota ki India abhi bhi colony hai?
Pakistan me bhi British India Penal code use hota hai aaj bhi
Tumhare naam se to tum Indonesian lag rahe ho
@@pratyaymustafi Caste ke naam par naye regiment nahi banaye jate hain ab,
Aur un Regiment me ek community ke army nahi hote hain sirf naam chalan me hai
Halanki mera manna hai ki naam change kiya jana behter hoga lekin jin community ke naam par regiment bani hai be virodh karenge aur election me nuksan hoga isliye koi karna nahi chahta
True Independence lies in thoughts.
Forever grateful to Mahipal sir 🙏
With all due respect sir there is huge difference between independence and transfer of power..... 🙏🙏🙏
@MULLO KAA YAMRAJ XI JINPING, XINJIANG =NARK(HELL) tumko to museum mein rehna chahiye, tum per to PhD ka theses ho jayega
Could you pls explain in detail?
@@sahilbhalla_01 watch abhijeet chavda sir video or sanjay dixit sir video
@MULLO KAA YAMRAJ XI JINPING, XINJIANG =NARK(HELL) secularism is a western concept?
Chacha Hindustan (the land) aur Hinduon (the people who reside here) se zyada secular koyi desh nahi hai dharti par
@@Ikillwish abey wo dono chodu abhijit aur sanjay, unko jhaant koi puchta nahi.....faltu ka historian bnke baithe hai. Ancient history hi pata hai abhijit ko bas. Modern history mei dono bekaar hai 😂😂😂
If neta ji was the 1st PM then imagine india
nehru ne achha kia ..........
but agar neta ji hote to aur achha karte
if Bhagat Singh
Then what would be Condition of Religious fundamentalists ?
He Himself recognised only two Leaders Nehru & Bose
@@arbaz6673 Nehru only created blunder in critical situations
Netaji died in 1945 before independence
@@nitishnayak1005 Whatsappiyo ke liye
Certainly British gave us option to do whatever , but willingly decided to continue with most British codes ,As to justify non democratic appointment of Nehru as PM ( despite Patel’s election by all 13 provinces as PM) Gandhi told that Nehru is only Angrez among us .
Autocracy in Congress ( by rejecting popular mandate in party)was started by our very own Gandhi from Bose as congress president to Patel as first PM.
Patel was not even alive to become PM. Watsapp gyaan mat laga gadhe.
Lodu chand patel died in december 1950 .
it means he lived 3.5 years after independence .
@@preetamyadav7952 search when first general elections were held in India and when sardar Patel died. Then you will understand comment above you
@@Ph-xj9lb ok loduchand .
still gandhi is not above constitution
Just imagine Netaji as first PM ❤️
Chicha nahi maanenge 😂
@@vajahat4912 no , Netaji was inspired by Swami Vivekananda .
@@oniichann-gaming Neta ji Had Nazi Germany and Japan , Axis Powers on his side
This Would Have Made us Soviet so we would have not became a part of Cold War
Now imagine Bal Narendra as 1st PM.😜
Respected sir ,
You are my single biggest source of knowledge till date... Thank you for lightning my dark mind with sparkles of knowledge.... I am indebted with whatever I have got from you till my death.... May 2022 bring even greater popularity and property to you than 2021.
With Regards,
One of your million fans
Are rulayega kya pagle 😂😂😂😂
Ghanta 🤣
Naye-naye gyani kuch zada hi bhavuk ho jate hai.
Yes sir... We are highly obliged to you
We are Mahipalians - Follower of Mahipal sir
Yes Mahipal sir is underrated 🔥
India azaad hua hai.... Par "Bharat" aaj bhi maansik taur pe gulaam hai..... We have to accept the history and live in our presents and continue work for better future
Few questions
1) do England's emperor (king or queen) not need any document to travel India?
2) why India is still a member of commonwealth ?
Only countries having allegiance to the Emperor of England are part of it.
3) There is a huge need to change the current Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC), which is hugely racist and largely inspired by the laws in the British era.
Why the government even didn't think about changing it.
1 ans- king or queen of england is head of state of UK and yes they don't require visa to come to india or any other nation!
Even the president of india don't need any visa or documents to go to UK or any other recognised country!
It is same for most head states of world!!
Hope you got the ans ; )
Ans 2) India can withdraw. It's india own choice to be in common wealth country or not.
Ans 3) for fast making laws we have copied from from many countries but our laws are largely influenced by british laws because our system base was made as britain system
1947-1950 George 5 was King of india Nehru Congress took oath in the name of George 5 how can u call them independent
Independence and dominion and transfer of power r
different thing
But Academic and Political Prostitution are worst form of Prostitution...
Sir it doesn't matter what you say
It is proven fact that
Independence is always taken by force
And Indian independence was just a power transfer from one set of crooks to another set of Crooks
Dominion = अधिराज्य
How is this equal to independence (repeatedly claimed by Sir) as far as legal terminology is concerned?
Also, why even today the Indian Navy flag has Christian cross, imposed by the British?
Why our secret agencies like IB reported to British till 1965?
Why in airlines, we still call our region as "Viceroy Territory"?
I don't think these are the signs of true independence as long as minds of the people are colonized!
We are not bounded with all these things. we can change whenever we want there will be no role of britishers in it at all. Therefore we are independent and sovereign
@@AbhinavKumar-nj2ef Sorry to say, but that's exactly the difference between the independence & the transfer of power. 🙏
Here comes WhatsApp guru.
You are spitting facts , We need to discuss this more .
@@govindaaggarwal103 Don't be sorry please elaborate the difference between independence and power of all the work done by indian government without external interference.
You can't coz that's what independence is.
Moral of story is Gandhiji or Congress did not snatched Indian Independence from British rather it was an Act of British Parliament that transfered the legitimate power to rule India from British to Congress
Algeria aur vietnam ki tarah ladai lade the
big slap to the Bollywood's celebrities'
Well imagine netaji ka BHARAT❤️🇮🇳❤️
Respect your courage. Stand for the dignity of the nation 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
What we got in 1947 is long lease given to Mr. J. Nehru.
Only 2014 we got true Independence.
JAI HIND
Sir we need to remove few symbols in our country which represents British Imperialism, for eg St George cross in flag of the Indian Navy
Agree With You
Why flag only& not army or navy?
@Ashwin yes they looted our property but what's the point behind using St George cross in our navy Flag
till 1958 indian navy did not have an indian chief ... on paper we got independence ... but in reality it was the transfer of power from one set of crooks to another set of crooks apointed by the first... we got independence on british terms on dates decided by them and by the methods they chose ..i dont understand what kind of independence was that.. as bhagat singh righlty said congress ko azadi se koi mtlb nnhi unhe bas satta chaiye... gore sahab jayenge to burhe(brown) sahab raj krenge.. that is what we saw dueing the nehru gandhi dynasty ... P V narshimha rao was one of the best pm who broke those dynasty by remaining in congress ..
socho zara hum sab 75 saal se fake cheeso sach maan k chal rehe the sirf kehene k liye independent the likin nehi the or jab tak Congress ne raj kiya tab tak hum azad nehi the kangna sehi bolti hai azadi 2014 mai mili hai she is right
mujhe kagna ki baat mai kuch galat nehi lagti Muslim ki tustikaran hua or hinduo ko dabaiya geya
@@debalinamukherjee7197 actually yes... i partially agree with kangana... but 2014 me bhi hame azadi mile nhi... na aaj bhi ham azad hai.. 2014 me ek step aacha tha decolonisation ke trf
101% true 👍👍 you're absolutely right 🙏🙏
Desh chunotiyo se jyda kangana aur unke jese chutiyo se preshan h itni information ka kya akal h. Sahi bat bhakto k liye Kala akshar Bhains barabar
1947 India got dominion status with transfer of power to chicha nehru . The king of England gave up his power over India on June 1948. All though technically India gained ominion status through an act of Parliament 'indian independence act' which to this day is not reapled in British parliament
😂😂😂 Shukla ji I think your india is not independent but mine is independent.
@@shreyanshumishra225 Kya mtlb ?? . Read indian independence act 1947 before getting fooled by this lecture
@@HimanshuShukla7987 preamble padh lo india ka
@@shreyanshumishra225 kya padhna hai secular socialist 42nd amendment
tu kuchh mat pad soja
ThankQ
Sir ne on paper wale baato ko acche se samjha diya but what about on ground reality, aaj tak humare kuch logo ki Britishers ke prati slave mentality nahi gayi hai, aur humare pyare CHICHA se accha example to koi aur ho hi nahi sakta
Gadhe hi rehna hai tere ko puri life likh le 😂😂😂😂
@@singhparihar8530 likh liya
@@singhparihar8530 likh Lia ja GOBHI KHUDA 😂apne Britishers papa log ko defend karne aa gaya slave 😂
For better understanding one must have a searching look at Art. 395 of the Constitution of India, wherein the constituent assembly expressly repealed Independence of India act and other ancillary British legislations.
Will always be grateful to you sir for sharing your knowledge..
1950 m hi hum sach m aazad hue
Yoooo
सवाल वो नही था के भारत 1947 में आजाद हुआ था के नही सवाल ये था के भारत को क्या सिर्फ एक ने ही स्वतंत्रता दियाई थी जो 74 सालो से भारत में एक ही आदमी की माला जापी जाति है एक ही आदमी की फोटो नोटो पे छपी जाती है ।
Tera photo chaple
Sahe kaha . Lakin in logo ko to video banane se matlab hai
to kya sab logo ki photo chhap de note pe
@@arbaz6673abe bkawaas karne se pehle ykuska matlab to samajh le.
Needed this was needed a video on True Independence in 1947 thankyou so much sir 🙏
Perfectly explained sir🙏
Fantastic Session Sir 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Rahul
Thankyou dear sir
thank you sir great lecture
Watch the recent episode on Jaipur dialogues channel. They have even covered the contribution of Neta ji Subhash chandra bose in the freedom struggle. With facts they have proven it was Neta ji Subhash chandra bose and his INA which Britishers FEARED not this fake Mahatma (title given by brits).
Biggest lie - bina khadag bina dhaal sabarmati ke shant tune kar diya kamal.
Jaa ke padh Britishers ne Gandhi ji ke baare mei kya bola tha. Netaji khud Gandhi ki sabse zyada respect karte the. Unko baapu Netaji ne hi title diya tha.
@@kushsharma3842 to?Bola to britishers ne bhi tha ki gandhi ki contribution nil thi unke desh chorne ke picche.main bhi starting main DR.swamy ji ko like karta tha, lekin ab nahi karta.. ,, ,, to kehna kya chahte ho? pehle mujhe soan papdi bahut acchi lagti thi, ab nahi lagti , ek bar jo accha lag gaya to kya jeevan bhar accha lage ye jaroori hai?
@@kushsharma3842 gandhi wahi naa jo celibacy test karne ke liye nude hokar bacchio ke saath sota tha? ya phir wo jo dharne par baith gaya tha ek road ke liye jo bharat ke beech say hokar jaati from pakistan to bangladesh? yaa wo jisne hinduo ka ethical cleansing karayi in the name of KHILAFAT movement? ya phir wo jo Nehru ko jabardasti PM banwa diya? Jaipur dialogues channel subscribe karo for gyaan. unko challenge karo agar wo galat bol rahe hai, phir live debate par aao unke saath apni baat prove karne ke liye.
@@N--D1 tu ab Dr. Swamy ko like nahi karta na??? 😂😂😂 Hence Proved. Sab samajh gaya main reason. Tu andh bhakt hai bacche. Tu toh muh hi mat lag
@@N--D1 ISE HI KEHTE HAIN WATSAPP GYAAN. Isliye toh Prime Minister sar jhukate hain Gandhi ke samne.😂. Aur rahi baat Jaipur dialogue channel ki toh ab sun ...usko kaun fund karta hai aur kyu fund karta hai main achhi tareh jaanta hun. YOU FOLLOW A PROPAGANDA CHANNEL THATS WHY THIS IS HAPPENING WITH YOU.
Thank you sir 😀.
Love from West Bengal sir .
Why this love
নমস্কার 🙏🏻
কোন জেলা??
@@VikashKumar-xg1xq sob jaigai ek ta bis mal thake.... Jemon ei bekti.... 😂
@@carbangla Howrah... Apni??
Nice lecture... thanks for this topic and happy New year 2022...
Eagerly waiting
Huge respect for you sir ...
Shaandaar knowledge
Thanking you Sir for starting Medieval India Series...
It comes under modern history dude!
The current indipendent debate is more of a notional, conveying the freedom of mind set and ethos of India rather than the change of governing people from Britishers to Indians in 1947. Issue is the hang over of the British mind set took too long to crack.
Well said
True colonial mentality, Colonial propaganda and narrative in media academia and bureaucracy is very strong..
Jabardast Video
Great!!
For more detail ...watch Great Rajiv Bhai Lectures
Thanks sir for providing this important information
Thanku sir
Badhiya Laga Sir Thank you
Thank u sir
Awesome explanation sir
Great lecture sir
Great lecture Sir👍👍👌👌👌
Great video !
Thanks sir
Aplog sab samajhdar ho.. ye line ❤️
Thanks u sir... Love ❤❤❤
Could you talk about army/navy/Air Force chief from 1947 to 1960
Mr Mahipal you left question open ended , was India got independence in 1947 and if it has its navy /air chiefs (Indian) ???
बेस्ट 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏👌👌👌👌👌
Very helpful last session of history
Sir you didn't mention regarding army navy and Airforce
Great lecture thank you sir sab Cristal clear ho gaya 🙏👍
thankyou so much sir for L1- L57 lecture series 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏💖
Thank you sir...
You explanation are so lucid that it cleared all my doubt's.
Thank you for this video.
Thank you sir ❤❤❤❤
Thank you Sir.
Why we're still part of commonwealth, what are the advantages and disadvantages?
Commonwealth gives us a voice without fear of west since US and Russia isn't part of Commonwealth.
multilateral forum hai , UN , WTO ki tarah
@@MayankSinghX1 really?? Dude, British royal family is the main host of common wealth game 😂😂
@@JITAPERTURE toh
@@MayankSinghX1 bro jo country angrejo ki gulam thi vo hi common wealth games me hissa le sakte hain.
Ok but can plz answer below questions
Who was Air chief marshal till 1954?
Who was Chief of Naval staff till 1957?
Why Neheru asking for permission to Queen before become PM, if we really get the Independence bina Khadag bina dhal then no permission needed.
Why there is need of Domain status for independent contry? There no such thing called pertial pregnancy?
Netaji and Neheru both were against of Domain status.. But why suddenly Neheru changed his mind?
Why there was SLO post in IB department long after 1947?
jab na samajhne ka man bana rakha h to samajh me kaha se aayega
@@arbaz6673 jab jawab nhi hota tum jaise yhi kehte h
Kyuki pehla election 1951 me hua
@@prashantbhardwaj4765 book padh lo...spoon feeding nhi ho skti har jaghan...
One more question
If we snatched the freedom from British then why we let British decide what should be our boundaries are? So many answere less questions... But good time is changing.. Things are coming in main stream now. No more ultra leftist propaganda will dominate our sense of history.
JUST Imagine Sardar Patel as 1st P.M of India
Sardar patel died in 1950
1st election held in 1951
Aur Election aur Constitution Independent Country me Hote hai aur bante hai. Jab hum Independent he nahi the toh Election aur Constitution ka koi sense nahi hai. Kyuki jiska kabja desh par hak unki he party election jeetenge, unka he aadmi PM banega aur constitution aur law me wahi hoga jo wo chaahenge. Aur wahi hua Nehru pm bana bina vote ke aur constitution, Party aur laws britishers ke.
Thanks for making such a informative video for us
Radhe Radhe
Very interesting
As I understood, Sir they said it hypothetically, and you are discussing it literally.
@Ashwin definately I agree on your point👍
Thank you so much Sir....
Good information..
Thank you sir for the information.
Best video, it cleared all doubts
Mast❤❤
Awesome sir
Perfect
Though everything was clear, I enjoyed this lecture
Thanks sir...🙏
उत्तर प्रदेश से भी जितने क्षेत्रफल का एक देश भारत पर दो सौ साल राज कर गया। ये तभी हो सकता है जब इंसान पहले से ही मानसिक रूप से गुलाम हो। जो इंसान अपनी जिंदगी के फैसले लेने से घबराता है उसको कोई भी आसानी से गुलाम बना सकता है।
Agree with you.
Great 🙏🙏
बहुत शुक्रिया sir iss info ko hme btane hmse share krne k lye..it was really very interesting and helpful
Chief of airforce was British after 1950
Chief of naval was British after 1950
Slo was tll 1966
Are bhai hamara pass itna use time mein kuch nehi taha Kia bolo yarr 😂😂😂😂 thoda dimag lago
@@smokepubg4667 hindi dhang se likh kya likha sar ke upar se bounce kar gya 🤯
@@brownsugar3544 😂😂😂😂😂
Sir don't you think "independent" and "dominion" both words are contradictory in nature, how can they be used together in a sentence for a single noun?
Very informative video sir
Some facts on "True independence " in 1947.
If India got independence in 1947 then why our :
1.Indian Air Force chief was a british Gerald Ernest Gibbs till 1954.
2.Indian Navy chief was a british Sir Stephen Hope Carlill till 1958
3.Indian Army chief was a british Sir Francis Robert Roy Bucher till 1949.
From the above facts the question that arises is that if India got true independence in 15 th of August 1947,then why the three wings of Indian military were controlled by people of British origin even after "independence"??.
P.S : source is Wikipedia (not whatsapp university).
Don't put labels of political parties on me .I have put my question based on facts not propaganda.
Indian military ke head se independece ka kya lena dena bhaai .........
jo the unhi ko continue rakha jab tak retire ni hue wo
isme kya itna bawal macha rakha h
@@arbaz6673 LOL. Agari aisa hai toh phir PM Mountbatten ko banana chahiye tha jab tak wo retire nahi hote.
Thoda dimaag laga liya karo.
ek cheex hoti hai kitab , usko kabhi kabhi padh lena chaheye
पंचरपुत्र विस्फोटवाले
@@TheLohit007 head of the state aur head of the government me difference hota hai
Super video 👌
Those who think India gain independence through Gandhi.. should read a book "Gandhi or Bose - who got India's independence" by Maj Gen. GD Bakshi ...all the proofs and records of British were given in it
Sir, please make a video on why Nepal and Sri Lanka is not part of India.
Ap best teacher ho sir 🙏🙏🙏
I will share it to Kangna Ranaut and JNU Azadi gang 🤣
India is independent not because of Gandhi or nehru it because British gave them
Happy new year 2022 in advance sir🙏
You must have mentioned very important Article 395 of the Constitution of India as a last point which says,"The Indian Independence Act, 1947 and the Government of India Act, 1935, TOGETHER WITH ALL ENACTMENTS amending or supplementing the latter Act, but NOT including the Abolition of Privy Council of Jurisdiction Act, 1949 are hereby Repealed."
After we became Republic.
Manipal Sir.... Thank You so much for giving such a imp fact for all against faulty arguments which is spreading now a day.... 👍👍👍 Thanks
What a Great Knowledge Sharing Sir.
Sir Ek Video Common Wealth ke membership ke karan kya Benifit hai , video बनाए.
I have just watched the last lecture of history series.... And request to everyone to watch the same to remove all the doubt against the truth... And break tha unholy propaganda.
Haha if England feared to give independence then how they dictated to partition??
@@politicallyapolitical7441 dictate!!! first read the course of history from 1940 to independence... U can understand... If u want to understand.
2047 ky pahle pahle hame common wealth se bahar ho jana chahiye
Any Benefit?
At 1X, u sound great, At 2X u sound fabulous.
Highly colonised educator.
Share karo iss video ko sabko knowledge milni chahiye iss topic ki