Running Out On a Sick House
Vložit
- čas přidán 28. 08. 2024
- The plaintiff rented an apartment to the defendant, who signed a one-year lease. She says the defendant claimed the apartment caused her health problems, then she disappeared after two months. She’s suing for lost rent. The defendant argues she and her son were sick the entire time they lived in the plaintiff’s apartment.
Case #27056
#PeoplesCourt #RealityTV #Court
If the mold stuff were true, she has to report it to the landlord and wait for them to remedy the situation. Hotel stay, repairs, etc. You can't just bail.
I completely disagree with Judge Milian here. I don't think she's bailing though considering this mold incident, and her personal standing with her husband (I guess that was story?). The landlady knew about her personal situation and that doesn't let someone off the hook on the lease however the mold is not acceptable and no one should have to put up with a declining health issue
I rest my case
@@exlesoes
I completely agree! What would the judge rather that she do live there while going into a state of respiratory failure? And then if she makes it through off of life support having to take all kinds of anti-fungal iv medications via central line insertion and being at home debilitated now picking up social security/disability check versus going to gainful employment come to court and sue? Get real!
@@Lanie-sl9ne yeah the apartment inspection from before she moved in should be called into question too
This was a terrible case
She could have indicated the mold, give the landlord the opportunity to get it fixed, she had no right to just bail out, she could have stayed a week at her husband while a crew fixed the issue, instead she just wanted to move in with her husband.
@@Lanie-sl9neLaws say different.
The defendant is just a big liar, if her son was so allergic, she would have at least one medical record stating breathing problems. She would be more credible if she had gone into another rental place, but going back with her husband rendered her testimony unbelievable...
How
Not necessarily. I visited a friend's place and experienced respiratory problems and had no idea why for several months. Months later I new it had something to do with the environment of the house. I later learned that I was allergic to cat hair. No medical records but it was the cats in the house.
Ralphie and Darryl don’t get it. She a professional victim. The score is 132 to 2
'i'm just glad it's over' - the classic statement of somebody who tried to defend the indefensible
Sometimes accompanied by, “It is what it is.”
I am a housing inspector and I get calls all the time from people looking for something so they can break the lease or not pay rent.
She got sick in December(winter colds), as most of the people on earth do. She was so sick for 2 months, but finally went to the doctor at the end of December?!? Plus, the photos showed rust and soap scum, scratch marks. NONE of them showed mold. The report would have picked up mold that had been cleaned up, so there wasn't any mold to begin with. The Defendant went back to her husband after not being able to pay her rent. She's shameless.
Definitely did look like rust, her husband probably helped her come up with that lie🤦🏾♀️.
Thought the same. A few tiny patches of rust. Nothing to end up ill over.
Plaintiff is lucky she didn't get tetanus because of the masses of terrible rust in dangerous bathroom areas! 😂
She wanted her pictures to be so bombastic, but if they actually were why would you ever move in (Mold doesn’t magically appear that big) and why didn’t you mention it or leave until you got back with your husband?
Just goofy. If her child does have asthma and she lived in a place where she “couldn’t breathe” and was coughing from day 1, wtf is wrong with her lol.
If she were telling the truth she’s still a goofball, but I think she’s just a liar.
It looked like the splash guide came off; ours did & the cruddy stuff was the glue that had held it together.
I wish rent was $650 here in the Bay Area
She was ready to go back home because she made up with her husband but you can't blame it on her house she full of it
What if she was just sick and passed it on.
My house is clean, but sometimes when one person gets a flu.. we all do.
I once was stranded out of state at a family member's home who, unbeknownst to me, had a mold issue. That night, I slept sitting up with my son on my chest because he couldn't breathe due to his asthma. No way there was a mold issue and her asthmatic son was just mildly sick for two months. Where are his doctor's visits?
2 months apart from her husband, they both realize they can't do any better.
So, they reconcile and live happily ever after. Wonderful story isn't it?
😅lol
Disney worthy shooting 💫
Unhappily ever after 😂
@@nasomibelle They will live to tolerate each other until the next crap comes to them!
You made that up
The defendant exaggerated with those pics! Smh
Defendant has the personality of a rock.
The plaintiff seems like a nice lady and the defendant was trying to be slick. Mold or not you just don't bail on someone.💯
She suddenly complains about being sick from the apartment after two months, leaves, but just happens to go back to her husband. I don't know why tennants can't understand that signing a lease is a legal document and that you are under no obligation to honor it if smething better comes along or you reconcile with your ex.
I lease offices for a living and that happens there too. It’s maddening. I always want to ask them, did you actually READ your lease before YOU signed it?
I think you mean you are under obligation (rather than no obligation), but yes, totally agree!
I have asthma and I’m not waiting two months to move! Asthma is serious. However, I would’ve given the landlord a chance to fix the problem and moved out the right way.
So the Defendant broke the lease and the Landord gets stiffed? Thats absolutely crazy. She should've gotten the 3 months, considering it was a 12 Month lease. I feel like the ruling was unfair to the Landlord. BTW, I dont agree with JM about her ruling because she did try to mitigate the damages and a Landlord has a right to find a suitable tenant who qualifies, not just anyone off the street.
I read the title wrong 😅 i saw horse and not house lol 😭😅
Lol there was a case like that though with a sick horse and a scammer.
😂
Your like wait this isn’t about a horse…. Ohhh it’s house🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol😅😅😅 put ur.glasses to n 😅😅😅😂😂😂
I lived in a college apartment that had black mold growing in the basement. We going see it all over the walls and furniture. I started getting extreme headaches that would go away when I’d leave the house. The landlord and health department wouldn’t do anything until I threatened to sue them. Then I got out of my lease and all my money back.
I lived in a basement apartment that flooded twice. My landlord gave a wet vac and bleach. I kept an upper respiratory infection, nose bleeds and I developed chostochronditis. Once I had my son I moved when he was 4mo old.
She should have given the plaintiff all three months rent for breaking the lease
the defendant will never make a good choice...and a very depressing person.
Her poor child. She is an unhappy person and likely to stay that way.
It may be bc of a rocky marriage. She is unhappy in this situation, but we can't judge how she is with her child from this episode.
@@karrifohey7848yes and trust me, a unhappy marriage will make you miserable and depressed.
Plaintiff should have gotten 3 months instead of 2
My own son has allergies in certain environments and not others. It's driving us nuts because we haven't been able to pinpoint exactly what it is yet. However, if I were to sign a lease, it's still my obligation to pay - it's nothing the landlord did wrong. The defendant however, may have made her point better if her friend that was staying with her gave testimony about their own experience.
That's true. Or if she sought medical advice earlier and actually had evidence of mould!
I hope your son's allergies resolve.
@@michelehemlokhexwhite4310 Thank you!
@@missy67 truly, I hope things improve for you and your son ❤
Same here. My 8 yr old has the worst allergies and asthma/bronchitis. We're always giving him breathing treatments at home. If only there was a miracle solution. All in all he's healthy and it could be worse. Wish you guys the Best.🙏🏽
@@mrshappilymarried1 Yep breathing treatments here too! We are going to the beach in a few weeks and usually the ocean air helps his allergies a lot for some reason. Hopefully it will again this year.
The defendant looks like a super annoying person.
My parents had an old Victorian for 42 yrs at the Jersey Shore, built circa 1883. My sister always called it *The House of Mold*. 😆
I discovered after both parents RIP & I had custody of the home as executrix, SHE WAS RIGHT. The place was closed up for about 6 months & afterwards when I looked around, saw green/blue mold on some surfaces. Maybe because of the old plaster/lathe walls??
Sis always said there'd be mold behind all those walls. Anyway, off topic, I know. But mold can lurk in places you can't really see.
Beware of older homes! 😁🏘️
2 months not 3 is BS. Defendant is a sham. She had nothing yet it turned into the Plaintiff’s responsibility to mitigate risk? 2 months in she bailed, come on.
Have a nice weekend everyone. Watching from Australia
You have a nice weekend as well. Watching from America
Thanks and you too
G’day mate!
I was shocked to see the police state in Australia. I always thought the people of Australia were stronger and more independent. So sorry you are living work such a tyrannical gov't. If you liked the lockdowns I don't have anything nice to say.
Wow, you couldn’t just say thank you , you too? 🙄
I had a similar situation in which I had mold and was getting sick inside the apartment, but i felt better once i went outside. Complained to management and wrote a report on their website about it, they finally came to fix it. See she could have won if she told the landlord about the mold issues, and they didnt try to at least fix the problem for her.
Doug was so nice to the defendant wow
On a side note, the plaintiff's daughter is beautiful ❤
The defendant should be ashamed of herself bringing those jerry-rigged pictures to court 😂😅
😂😂😂😂
defendant is a liar and scammer
Marilyn acts like: symptoms don't develop over time and that Americans don't avoid going to the doctor as much as possible due to exorbitant prices. Get real.
$1,300 for 2 months rent in New York City is unbelievably low. A Small 1-bedroom apartment in New York City can easy cost 2000 per month
Didn’t she still get what she was asking for because she kept the security deposit?
I was surprised of this too but I think it's coz you can tell by plaintiff eyes she extremely sad
Water will definitely seep into that "tiny hole" and create mold. Too bad the defendant didn't hire her own expert. This is how poor people constantly get screwed in this country. They don't have the financial means to prove their case.
🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽mold is definitely in the bathroom 🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽
I didn’t realize there were so many people out there that talk over other people. That’s not only rude, but very annoying!
Please don't go in my shower!!! Lol
Bad ruling Plantiff should’ve gotten all three months. I get what Milan is saying about a reasonable amount of time for renting out , BUT if you break a lease early, you are obligated to pay the remainder of the lease. It does not matter if it’s 1 month or 10.
I agree. You should be picky as a landlord.
Where she living at for 650.00 a month? And her husband should kick her out for her comments
She must have thought by taking a close up like that it would look like when they took a close up of a bug it would be like the old "B" type horror movies.ROFLMAO
The defendant is lying, in my opinion
2 months of rent is 1300!? 😮What city is this?! 🤔🤔
Definitely agreed with this decision.
She should have gotten the 3 months rent. She wasn't looking for the perfect person. She was looking for someone to pass a credit check. JM wouldn't rent to someone if they were shady.
I love when the judge screams stop talking over me ! When meanwhile she talks over everybody all the time! Yeah she’s the judge , but out of human decency she shouldn’t be talking over people either. And she loves to ask a question and then in the middle of the persons explanation, she starts cutting them off . Absolutely totally rude judge. Period
She loves hearing herself talk
I've literally thought the same thing. I hate when she says "tell me what happened" but then interrupts the plaintiff before they can even get a sentence about what happened out 🤦🏽♀️.
Facts 😂
Agreed. Don’t ask what happened if you’re not gonna let me tell you.
So why are you here??
9:02 Although the areas in the photos aren’t that big it could be a larger area in the wall behind it. I worked in an ICU where one room smelled really musty, and everyone who entered the room became ill with headaches, upper respiratory problems, and more. Long story short I left because my health became so bad, and wasn’t ill after leaving there. The hospital finally tore out the wall in that room, and it was full of mold, BLACK MOLD!
The defendant wants to always play the victim role and have people feel sorry for her.
So why did the Tennant not clean it off !!!
Is it just me or does anyone else think this woman should clean the shower.
The defendant assumed that it was just a cold that she and her son had and that he was super reacting because of his asthma . She couldn't afford a doctor as she was newly on her own and didn't realize it was environmental until her friend stayed over and reacted the same way. Black mold is serious business. A friend was exposed at work and spent 2 weeks in a coma.
Except that the health department came a week and a half later and found no mold. The only evidence of “mold” the defendant had was a picture of a little rust in the bathtub. No mold. So your scenario obviously wasn’t the case here.
Before she rented it out. Landlord should have fixed the problem. I don't care if it's just the size of a sewing pen.
Psychosomatic allergy, caused by husband deprivation, commonly shared through negative thoughts and words.
The defendant was trying to leave the landlady holding the bag. She left her husband and then later decided for whatever reason to try to make it work again. Those little issues near the gaps in the caulk could very easily have been cleaned, and I doubt they were enough to make her, her son, and her guest sick for months on end.
Defendant said her son has asthma! If the air quality was as bad as all that, he would've been miserable and you'd think she would have a record of taking him to the doctor or something
I think the landlotd should of got everything she was asking for she had proof that she listed it at the exact same discounted rate and was trying to get it rented, also but for the simple fact that the tenant broke her lease early she wouldn't of had to pay a realtor to list the apartment so why would she not be entitled to that 🤦♀️
I thought the same at first. Then I thought, JM would say you would of had to pay realtor to rent it if she lived out the lease. So it’s not an expense plaintiff incurred due to the defendant breaking the lease. 🤷♀️
I'm allergic to mold. Mold grows where I had no idea, even under falling leaves. Where I rented my washer & dryer in basement had mold growing & smell very bad. It got so bad for me to breathe. People ( judges ) and landlords ought to study about mold. I really do not think the woman should pay a cent. Did you hear the plaintiffs daughter answer the judge if she ever seen the apartment? The daughter has never seen the apartment.
Landlady has her deposit too?
I read the thumbnail as " Running Out on A Sick Horse ".
Oh nooooo...sorry.
the defendant has real issues mentally.
No proof but I suspect that there may be domestic violence at home. Even the landlord made reference to her saying she wanted to be safe Often times the men are controlling and he may have coerced or threatened her to return home. She made up the story because she could not tell the truth to the landlord.
A little ZEP mold & mildew would have cleaned that right up
I could do without the Harvey bits of What If.
I could do without ALL of Harvey
the defendant is a liar. 🙄
Great case
the husband played her it seems
After only 2 months the defendant leaves the apartment cause of mold....yet she has no medical records of her issues until mere days before her actual moving out. Come on lady,get ur shit together
Plaintiff's daughter is "classy sexy". She understands that less is more.
Liar liar pants on fire 😆😆😆😆😆😆
None of this makes any sense from the defendant
There is such a thing as mildew that isn’t mold. Clorox cleaners will take that away. I think the plaintiff tried to help her and she just stiffed her.. so wrong…
Defendant played herself
*Warranty of Habitability*
$650 in rent sounds delicious😊 i wouldhave sleptin a hass mat suit
😂😂😂
If the real reason she left was to return to her husband, I can totally understand that… she should have explained it truthfully. And if she and her son were sick for some reason, I’m sorry to hear it. But it doesn’t seem like they were that ill, especially with an asthmatic child, if neither needed medical care until months later. … I hope everyone is doing well today, that all parties are happy and healthy.
Like it's going to eat new york
$650 a month is cheap. In New Zealand they pay that a week for rent and more, even up to $1000 a week and thats not including electricity and water .
This is a very long time ago. The people’s court was done early 2000’s, so….15-20 years ago
Maybe the newly painted walls had mold.😊
No…the city can see these things. There’s no evidence of mold.
Had the defendant gone to the plaintiff and explained that she and her husband reconciled I think she would have let her out of her lease. She seemed to really want to help the defendant out.
No way, that’s still a major hassle and money deficit for the plaintiff. If that were the case, she needed to put her big girl panties on and stay in her lease and then go back to her husband after.
If there was really mold in those small spots, it was easy to clean 😅 peroxide, baking soda and alittle dish soap works great on walls and ceilings. Obviously if there was alot the whole place would have that nasty smell and everyone would be complaining in the apartments. Everyday mold happens and especially in bathrooms with no exhaust fans, but a quick spray and wipe will take care of it. Black mold is another story but you can smell that even before you move it!
She need to be allergic to that no good husband 😂😂
#Preach
Her pictures showing 'mould' were laughable.
If you have asthma and your living around mold you will get extremely sick . One place we were in my mom was constantly sick always in bed
That was fair...
It's so infuriating to me when I see these types of defendants come into court looking so upstanding & so prim & proper only to find that they are wolves in sheep's clothing & are as corrupt as the day is long. The defendant moved out of the apartment to move back in with her husband & apparently is still living with him today. If things were as bad living with her husband as she would have us all believe she would have moved out of his place by now, I'm sure. Anyone listening to this case with some measure of common sense knows exactly what happened here. I'm glad that the judge saw through the defendant's lies & ordered her to pay 2 months' rent to the plaintiff, although I believe that the plaintiff should have received the 3 months. It's next to impossible to rent an apartment during the winter months.
Defendant was pulling at straws with those pictures. She knew she didn't have a case. I think thenbiggest tell on this was she never once messaged or called the landlord within those 2 months besides when she was saying she was leaving.
When she said "she never tried to remedy it" no s*** you never told her.
13:05 That's the name of the game anymore & i feel you. Unfortunately.
Obvious, she wanted to move back home.
Take some allergy pills and chill!
grifters...so miserable...
Lying little vixen
Lol that sounds cute
@@Bebedollie lol some thirsty comments are cray
So..... her child was "sick the entire two months" because of "mold" in the apartment, but it was out of the question for her to return the child to his father she stole him from...... better to risk her child's health than let the father "win".
How did she steal her own child? Y’all are annoying
@@yung1717 "Y'all" isn't a word. Talk about annoying....
@@broeheemed32"y'all" is accepted vernacular in the Oxford Dictionary as a contraction for "You all" and you know it. Don't be silly.
Makes no sense
Get rid of the announcer. So annoying! Are we in a legit courtroom or Jerry Springer?
Looks like Jodi arias
She had no allergies, nor her son, that they caught the flu, since it was wintertime, flu was going around at that time. Lady defendant was a liar cause she decided to go back home to husband and broke the lease, she owes the remaining months. And the photos she took showed no mold.
Bro I've seen that azn girl behind the prosecutor in so many different filmings.
Sounds to me she had a sinus infection and went to her husbands house
Karen
There may have been mold growing BEHIND the wall that is not visible to the naked eye ... there are none so blind as though who will not see...-JM...