Deodorant vs Antiperspirant - Which one Works?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 1. 07. 2024
  • Deodorant or Antiperspirant? They're very different but most us don't really know why. In one way, this is understandable - both deodorant and antiperspirant will stop armpit odor. But only antiperspirants will stop sweat.
    For one week, I wore deodorant on one armpit and antiperspirant on the other to put their differences to the test.
    Check Out Carpe: mycarpe.com/
    Video breakdown:
    Intro: 0:00
    The Science Behind Armpit Sweating: 0:42
    How Deodorants Work: 1:37
    How Antiperspirants Work: 2:30
    The Experiment: 3:03
    The Results: 3:21
    Conclusion: 4:45
  • Jak na to + styl

Komentáře • 59

  • @alkaholic4848
    @alkaholic4848 Před měsícem +7

    Underrated, this deserves a lot more views.

  • @romancastro4556
    @romancastro4556 Před 2 lety +9

    Very informative thank you man

  • @bluaurax
    @bluaurax Před 10 měsíci +4

    Incredible video!

  • @yourube2210
    @yourube2210 Před 8 měsíci +10

    Someone that actually tested it 😘😘😘😌

  • @joshuaja3g3r
    @joshuaja3g3r Před rokem +15

    Very underrated Chanel bro props for giving good advices, i used nivea men antiperspirant for weeks but it didn't really work for me especially cause I'm a heavy sweater and i see people saying antiperspirant doesn't really block bad smell so I'm back on using deodorant again at day and antiperspirant at night and it works better

    • @user-gc1gi8fp2x
      @user-gc1gi8fp2x Před rokem +3

      It really depends on the brand try old spice it worked wonders for me i used axe and nivea before and my underarms still sweat and smelled bad but when i used old spice it stoped and smelled good

    • @joshuaja3g3r
      @joshuaja3g3r Před rokem +2

      @@user-gc1gi8fp2x what type of old spice are you using bro# is it antiperspirant or deodorant? is it spray or roll on? and do use use it day and night?

    • @thest1llwater
      @thest1llwater Před 4 měsíci

      ​@@user-gc1gi8fp2x old spice deo/antiperspirant?

  • @jaroslavkandrac8870
    @jaroslavkandrac8870 Před rokem +29

    I use them both at the same time! First I apply
    antiperspirant and then over it deodorant, for better smell. After that, never had a problem with bad smell or excessive sweating.

    • @Andrei-yb3vy
      @Andrei-yb3vy Před 8 měsíci

      Is it safe to use it on the same time?

    • @funkymonkeyjr
      @funkymonkeyjr Před 6 měsíci

      @@Andrei-yb3vyno the combination may cause a small nuclear fission reaction to start in your armpits pls do not attempt it it is extremely dangerous

    • @abdulsalamdeiri4221
      @abdulsalamdeiri4221 Před 4 měsíci +2

      @@Andrei-yb3vy im pretty sure its safe, but for the best results put deodorant 2 or 3 hours on after anti perspirant

  • @bullymaguire793
    @bullymaguire793 Před 9 měsíci +4

    I should try this in my office too. I just hope i don't get trashed

  • @siratulmustakim3076
    @siratulmustakim3076 Před rokem +4

    I use lavillin cream deodorant it keeps me odor free for 7+ days in a row and it doesn't wash off with swimming and showering unless you scrub it off.

  • @Evadewtf
    @Evadewtf Před 10 měsíci +2

    What if you just started getting sweat stains any way that it could be because of deodorant and shampoo

  • @siritachi1137
    @siritachi1137 Před 2 lety +2

    Lol So helpful, thank you :)

  • @chalolozano8675
    @chalolozano8675 Před 2 měsíci +4

    I will always use antiperspirant. Thank you for the advice

    • @ConFirm-hz2ot
      @ConFirm-hz2ot Před měsícem

      It wasn’t easy living with bullying, embarrassment, not able to socialize was indeed a real struggle. I cured my chronic Tmau/body odor smell & Hyperhidrosis(hands,feets) at DR.UWENBOHERBALHOME youtube channel I came across on YT..🎉🎉🎉🎉

  • @dwight6502
    @dwight6502 Před rokem +9

    I am also a very sweaty guy. I use Rexona Antibacterial + Anti Perspirant for both my Arm pits and Feets! It's really effective for me. I live in the Philippines where most of the time it's always too hot here lol.

  • @alkaholic4848
    @alkaholic4848 Před měsícem

    Decades ago i switched from deodorant to antiperspirant and never looked back because it was so much better. Or so i recall, but it was so long ago now i was questioning my memory and the judgement of a very immature much younger version of me (without the luxury of researching things on the net), so i decided it was worth looking into it again. After watching this video, it looks like i made the right call and am going to stick to it.

  • @Jo3W3st
    @Jo3W3st Před měsícem

    My left arm pit doesn't smell at all even after 5 days without a wash. My right arm pit after 2 days if I miss a shower will slowly start to sweat and then after the third day start to smell but not horrible that doesn't happen till after the 5th or 6th day. I work from home and live by myself.

  • @UniquelyCritical
    @UniquelyCritical Před 29 dny

    What about the yellow armpit stains in white shirts? Is it true that deodorants don't cause that?

  • @HamBone86
    @HamBone86 Před 6 měsíci

    Hey, Durham NC! This is where I live! (Also born here)

  • @bobmarley8982
    @bobmarley8982 Před 2 lety +19

    subbed. Mate, use your CZcams tags properly so your videos can reach a wide audience.

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před 2 lety +3

      Thanks, Bob! What specifically can we do to make our tags better?

  • @jacoblowe387
    @jacoblowe387 Před 16 dny

    i mean i dont know if i should use both

  • @duesa2203
    @duesa2203 Před rokem +2

    So I just stopped kinda using my dove antiperspirant and switched to the dove 0% aluminum and I don’t seem to be sweating a lot with it on plus my arm pits smell good even with a little sweat. Now is it that they both are working together since I’ve used it so much it’s at maximum potential my body has just stopped making bad odors and using gel deodorant just makes me smell good/decent now?

  • @supermind14delicate
    @supermind14delicate Před rokem +3

    Thank you so much , i have sweaty patches iused antiperspirant it works but sometimes it doesnt can you tell how many times you put in a week and how long does it take until it works?

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před rokem

      Generally daily use is best - and applying before bed is key. So for maximum results, I'd suggest applying before bed and again in the morning. With any antiperspirant, results should get better and better for about 4 weeks. Whatever sweat reduction you're seeing after 4 weeks of use is what you can usually expect from that point on.

    • @imaguglielmo
      @imaguglielmo Před rokem

      @@MyCarpe Even put on at night if you shower in morning?

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před rokem +2

      @@imaguglielmo Yes - you can re-apply for scent after your shower, but the sweat plugs are deep enough in your sweat glands that most showering won't remove them

    • @nyaraur7623
      @nyaraur7623 Před rokem

      @@MyCarpe does soap wash it off? how do i wash it off or how does it get removed?

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před rokem +2

      @@nyaraur7623 Soap will remove the gunk that antiperspirant or deodorant leaves on the surface of your skin, but it won't remove the antiperspirant plugs from deep in the sweat glands. These will instead decay naturally over time; so even if you scrub your armpits with soap, antiperspirant effects will linger for some time after regular antiperspirant use.

  • @PsychoMantisss
    @PsychoMantisss Před 5 měsíci +1

    Women's deodorant without anti-perspirant is extremely difficult to find. I've only found one brand that even sells it, which is Dove. I tend not to sweat under my arms, and if I do it's mostly just maybe slightly sticky. I've never really had pit stains or anything like that, so I don't even bother with anti-perspirant. It just runs my bras anyway.

    • @ConFirm-hz2ot
      @ConFirm-hz2ot Před měsícem

      It wasn’t easy living with bullying, embarrassment, not able to socialize was indeed a real struggle. I cured my chronic Tmau/body odor smell & Hyperhidrosis(hands,feets) at DR.UWENBOHERBALHOME youtube channel I came across on YT..🎉🎉🎉🎉

    • @sayed_9730
      @sayed_9730 Před 9 dny

      yeah i think women do not sweat too much like we men do so i dont think u need antiperspirant

  • @redrocker1582
    @redrocker1582 Před rokem +4

    Wouldn't it be the best to use antiperspirant before bed and deodorant in the morning?

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před rokem +3

      This absolutely works. For antiperspirant, the evening application is the important one - in the morning, if you're just applying deodorant (to help with the scent), that's perfectly fine.

  • @UniquelyCritical
    @UniquelyCritical Před 29 dny

    Does the deodorant you used use all four methods to remove the odor, one or some other combination?
    This experiment feels like margarine vs. butter. There are so many different kinds of margarine that it's hard to make a generalized statement.

    • @GDRobbye
      @GDRobbye Před dnem

      Not really. I've used deodorant and antiperspirant from the same brand (Old Spice) and antiperspirant definitely works much better. With deodorant, by the end of the day, my armpit would be a bit smelly and by the next day it would definitely lose its efficacy; while with antiperspirant, even if I still sweat a bit (although much less compared to deodorant) it would smell good throughout the next day as well without having to reapply.
      So, if you want to be fresh for a longer period of time, use antiperspirants; they "block" sweat and also neutralize the odor.

  • @fahmidatisha3507
    @fahmidatisha3507 Před rokem +2

    Is that for only man or woman can use it as well

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před rokem +1

      Carpe is gender neutral - our products are for men and women both!

  • @spokenone1321
    @spokenone1321 Před rokem +1

    Nice Place

  • @shawn292380
    @shawn292380 Před 10 měsíci +16

    Antiperspirant at night and deodorant in day

    • @mrahshanullah8031
      @mrahshanullah8031 Před 2 měsíci +6

      why night?

    • @ConFirm-hz2ot
      @ConFirm-hz2ot Před měsícem

      It wasn’t easy living with bullying, embarrassment, not able to socialize was indeed a real struggle. I cured my chronic Tmau/body odor smell & Hyperhidrosis(hands,feets) at DR.UWENBOHERBALHOME youtube channel I came across on YT..🎉🎉🎉🎉

    • @ShawnPeter-wi8wt
      @ShawnPeter-wi8wt Před měsícem

      ​@@mrahshanullah8031coz it's the right way

    • @PlayStationClassic..
      @PlayStationClassic.. Před 16 dny +1

      @@mrahshanullah8031because it gives it more time to get to the sweat glands and then in the morning you won’t sweat as much

    • @Fireflygirl-pz4yw
      @Fireflygirl-pz4yw Před 8 dny +1

      ​@mrahshanullah8031 You sweat less at night which allows the antiperspirant to get closer to your sweat glands and stop sweating

  • @amapparatistkwabena
    @amapparatistkwabena Před 11 měsíci +3

    Is it possible that this guy doesn’t know about the potential harm of the long-term use of aluminum salts?

    • @MyCarpe
      @MyCarpe  Před 11 měsíci +4

      Check out our video about that! A LOT of research has been done on this in the past ten years and the results are good.

  • @PlaywithDaisy
    @PlaywithDaisy Před 11 měsíci +1

    Anti makes me stink soooo bad

  • @Nidhoggrr
    @Nidhoggrr Před 5 měsíci

    Other thing you can do is shave your armpits and get rid of the bacteria breeding forest that is armpit hair.

  • @tony997
    @tony997 Před rokem +1

    Is armpit hair needed for antispirant or deodorant?

    • @thetissuebandit5815
      @thetissuebandit5815 Před 11 měsíci +7

      Armpit hair would end up making BO worse as sweat and bacteria are more likely to get caught up in the hair.

    • @user-xh3wn8xw6m
      @user-xh3wn8xw6m Před 11 měsíci +5

      ​@@thetissuebandit5815лучше сбрить станком и все