I Tested the Top 5 Running Watches | Marathon Prep
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2024
- With a goal to run a marathon in 2023, I need a sports watch that will be the best tool for marathon training. I compared these top 5 running devices: Apple Watch Ultra vs Garmin Forerunner 965 vs COROS Apex 2 Pro vs Samsung Galaxy Watch5 vs iPhone 14 (+ Polar H10 Heart Rate Strap). I decided to test the most popular devices in categories like distance/pacing accuracy, battery life, health features, display & design, price and more!
** Affiliate/Discount Links **
Polar H10 HR Monitor: amzn.to/45ykBS0
Apple Watch Ultra: amzn.to/3zVgmSw
Apple Watch Series 8: amzn.to/3HoMema
Garmin Forerunner 965: www.playbetter.com/products/g...
Garmin 965 on Amazon: amzn.to/3q69iQG
Coros Apex 2 Pro: www.playbetter.com/products/c...
Apex 2 Pro on Amazon: amzn.to/3BXuivB
** Watch More Videos **
I Wore 18 Fitness Trackers... This One's Best!: • I Wore 18 Fitness Trac...
I Wore 22 Sleep Trackers... This One's Best!: • I Wore 22 Sleep Tracke...
My Plan to Run a Sub-5 Minute Mile @ 200 lbs: • My Plan to Run a Sub-5...
** Add Me **
Subscribe // youtube.com/@ShervinShares?su...
Socials // beacons.ai/shervin
Strava // / strava
** Friends **
@TheQuantifiedScientist
@Dcrainmaker
@ColtKirwan
@TejasHullur
#Running #AppleWatch #SportsWatch
** Timecodes **
00:00 - Top 5 Running Watches
00:37 - Sleep Tracking
01:55 - Track Run Test
06:11 - Payments & Apple Pay
06:45 - Battery Update
07:11 - Tall Buildings in Manhatten Run
09:10 - WSH Clear Skies Run Test
12:27 - Treadmill Run Test
13:01 - Strength Training Workout
14:13 - Battery Update #2 & Charging
14:53 - Design & Form Factor
16:14 - Display Brightness
16:35 - Price and Value
17:35 - Extra Features
18:30 - Best Watch for Marathon Training
________________________________________________
** My Fave Products + Discount Codes **
AMAZON // www.amazon.com/shop/shervinsh...
SLEEP // Eight Sleep (Code "SHERVIN"): eight-sleep.ioym.net/shervin
FITNESS // WHOOP Strap ($30 Off): join.whoop.com/shervin
NUTRITION // Levels Health CGM: levels.link/shervin - Jak na to + styl
** Watch More Videos **
I Wore 18 Fitness Trackers... This One's Best!: czcams.com/video/qc094OLDdFM/video.html
I Wore 22 Sleep Trackers... This One's Best!: czcams.com/video/iNoYImNwKO0/video.html
My Plan to Run a Sub-5 Minute Mile @ 200 lbs: czcams.com/video/woqOEmV6wVE/video.html
you're trying so hard to be sponsored by apple
Don't know exactly what it is about this entire channel but something's off. Great ideas for videos and good production values but still something seems phony, secretly sponsored and kind of elitist. Please take a look at different long form reviews on either of these watches and don't base your purchase decision solely on this video, it's quite superficial!
@@Enemy-kl3lx i wish i was secretly sponsored!!! we're burning cash on camera equipment and not making enough money to pay it all back
Apple meň. Amatér
The run accuracy is the main test I wanted to see. Thank you !
Been watching you for awhile. I like how consistent you are and your videos are a lot of fun. Keep grinding Shervin🤙🏼
I had a fenix 5 and now I currently own a Forerunner 965 and its just perfect.
Shervin doing all the tests that we didn’t think we needed - another great video 👏🏽💯
Thank you Suketu!!! Always honored when you comment
As someone becoming more interested and invested in my health I am looking forward to seeing your upcoming videos training for a marathon. I'd love to be able to run one at some point so seeing that process for you would be great! Keep up the awesome videos bro
Drew thank you! What have been the first steps you’ve taken in investing in your health?
I think you have too much time on your hands 👍
Nah that’s crazy props to you😂
@@Mister_flyhon 😂😂
🎉😂
💀💀💀
good one 🤣
Honestly, I can't thank you enough for this video! Thanks man!!!!
thanks dude, i just ran my 2nd half marathon and just signed up for my first full marathon in about a year
on Galaxy Watch 5 when you are in the middle of a workout you can click the mechanical back button to get to the pause workout screen
Good luck with your training! Looking forward to the updates!
Another great video.
For me I've got a Garmin Fenix for my fitness tracking and a Galaxy watch for my general 'smart watch'. Seems to work well.
These videos always make me miss New York. 🗽
Yes I do this too.
Fast becoming one of my favourite CZcams channels! Keep the content coming!
Thank you! Means a lot!! What kinds of videos do you want to see me make next??
@@ShervinSharestesting shoes pls❤
Wow, this video is exactly what i was for looking for ! Nice vid man
I would love to see this video again but with a newer generation of these watches, especially the galaxy watch 6 since they added a lot of things missing on the watch 5 like track run, entering threadmill distance to calibrate, better gps and hr , brighter display etc.
On the Garmin, you need to run a few laps first and then the gps and distance will match the track
Does it automatically detect when you’re at a track?
@@kylemillard7294 no but you can use the hotkey change sport to switch to the run track activity.
@@kylemillard7294probably not quite sure 👍
@@kylemillard7294 there is a track run option which does this mentioned sync after a lap
The new update of garmin includes a database of tracks, removing theoretically the need to calibrate a new track.
Garmin does not detect that you are in a track automatically, you need to select track-mode when starting your activity.
I do a "run" activity home-> track + a "track run" activity for the wo + another "run" activity back home 🤦🏻♂
A lot of room for improvement there still 😅
You can get the GPS to lock on the Samsung before you start an activity. Go to the activity tile, go to run and before you select it it will. Begin getting a lock and heart rate. Status is show at the top.
First Sport watch test that was actually really good. Shitton of work. Thanks.
Great video!
What is your opinion about the Garmin forerunner 45?
Hey Shervin,
Great video as always!
I had a similar issue with the awu. I was doing my first 70.3, I pressed the action button before entering the water. I got 25 mins in before I realised it was still paused, it had also recorded wayy more distance than I had swam. 2.6km instead of 1.9km. A bit disappointing as I wanted to look over the data after the race and see what my pacing was like. I’ve now picked up a 955 and unfortunately won’t be using the awu in a race anymore 👎🏻
4:53 i think you can actually long press the bottom button on the samsung watch when doing a work out to quickly pause it
Thx for the review
Great vid, should of included the full ecosystem/app etc. I have a fenix 7 currently, which is my 3rd Garmin. I have just done a 50km trail ultra and training for my first marathon in sept, so battery life, maps and metrics are key for me. Subbed as love the content!
Music? I need music. I just want to not carry my phone with me. The jumping around in my pocket annoys me.
I have used the Apple Watch ultra for about half a year. I have ran extensively with it, tracked skiing, used it for music, and surfed about 60 days wearing it. I use it for gym workouts etc. I have never had the issues that you had in this video. Glad they fixed the software by the time I started to use it.
Great video!! Thank you!!
It’ll be great if Rob could analyze your HR data. That would give an idea of accuracy on different skin tones and hair.. hope this one’s coming out soon
Samsung has both a track mode and a function to start your workout only after detecting gps location! (These might have both been added after an update a couple months ago so maybe they weren't available at this time.) The track mode is crazy accurate, you can set which lane you are using and it tracks distance flawlessly, like to within a meter of the finish.
I am happy with the FR 965. The big screen, Great battery time, all health/sport metrics, less thickness of the case then the Ultra & Epix.
Love your work Shervin! Great Video! 😊
Thank you Patrick!!
@shervin: What is the name of the app you use it to the gym on the Apple Watch Ultra?
You should try the Samsung GW5 running Strava. I find it much more accurate and easier to control.
Hey Shervin, Great Video. I used both the Garmin and the AW SE. I find the Garmin is slightly ahead with its plans and pacepro etc and use it more for races. I like the AW for training as it my iphone on my wrist and its easier to dip in and out of spotify. Does the AW have anything like Pacepro and also what is the best app for training with apple. There own default app or Nike Run Club which seems to be popular however has its limitations for viewing and editing workouts. Cheers.
You are going to blow up with these kinds of videos - way to go Shervin! What happened to your barefoot shoes though? Did you stop wearing them?
Shervin! Miss you bud. Enjoying all this dope content my man.
Broooooo hope you’re doing well
the problem with wearing 4 watches is that on each wrist, only one of them will be really well positioned, which is one finger above the wrist. You can't compare very well like that. The ideal would be to test 2 at a time. But still, great video!
how did you measure the actual sleep times in the beginning?
The coros does have a touchscreen. Great video though it’s awesome to see these kinds of test!
This is great, thanks!
Weirdly happened to my Apple ultra the last 2 days, the action button didn’t work (both Apple fitness app & the workoutdoors app). It fixed after I restart the watch, another solid video and good luck with your marathon training. Had garmin for years just switch to Apple ultra and done London marathon with my Apple Watch with the workoutdoors app, pretty happy with it. 👌🏼
I have been using the Apple Watch Ultra and Epix 2 for my training I have been using the Runna app and currently am loving it. Currently trying to improve my half marathon time and so far I am seeing results after 6 weeks of training with 6 more to go. It is very difficult to decide which watch to primarily use to train.
Same! 😂
I think of the AWU as just a mini cell phone during my run and is my Stryd device, Garmin is my workout ecosystem because of cycling and the use of training peaks.
I am not going to say that this is the most representative, with the right comparisons, but I do appreciate it nonetheless.
Great video! Some of us are also training for a marathon! We got this 💪
Yes let’s gooooo
When in the gym, you can broadcast the garmin HR via ANT+ so it should work with the treadmill.
I use CZcams playlist with premium and Bluetooth headphones for running.
Is there a way i can do that with one of these watches?
You totally nailed it with the Apple Watch Ultra. They need to have 1 button for start and stop.
They do. You can activate it in the settings on your iPhone. You need to press the corwn and the side button simultaneously
About the music part
If you're using iphone, playing from spotify with airpods, can you control the music thru the apple watch? if yes. then does that also drain battery much?
thanks a ton for doing this, this is really useful information, I think the people were looking at you because they thought probably you were blind because of the black glasses and walking with the wheel
Great video! If you are training Garmin all the way! The data you can get from it blows away anything else. Especially if you pair it with a Garmin chest strap (HRM Pro) or running pod. Apple Watch is great for a smart watch but I didn’t like having to go into 4 different apps to get data.
Yeah I was surprised he didn't mention the mountain of Running metrics that you get on the Garmin to help you run more efficiently.
Nice vid dude!
Dying when I saw you had a HR strap too. I can’t imagine the looks you got?! Haha
Also for thr garmin you are missing the pace pro feature and course creator. These are key.
I watch you tests and find them far better than most out there.
stupid question -you are wearing a watch upper on the hand than normal. will that impact gata gathering?
Garmin is the best for training! The AI Couch is grate the Batterie life is good too .. all the data u get is crazy
What GPS settings did you use on the Garmin for the tests in the city?
Have you tried the Withings’ watches? Scale? BP cuff?
Thanks for a very enjoyable to watch video. Those watches are too expensive for me! My last watch was an old Ironman.
Thanks for watching!
Great Video! Love all the testing you did.
One more thing about GPS accuracy and very tall buildings is that in a more open sky location, generally you can get data from more satellites which can improve accuracy. This is because you can access multiple GPS tracking system standards (GLONASS,Galileo, etc) this improves accuracy(sorry for dorking out, I’m an Electrical Engineer). Battery life is hugely important to me so I went with the COROS BTW…as I hate having to constantly recharge. I like the Apple but having more functionality is taxing on the battery life and they just haven’t gotten there yet.
Thanks for posting this great video! New sub here!! 👍
Hi there, I have a question about Apple Watch. Is there a way to measure rest time while doing intervals on the track with the Apple Watch ultra (using the action button)? I understand that I can set an interval workout with the workout app, but sometimes I just want to freestyle a workout. Right now when I press the lap button within the stopwatch app, it will only show me the total elapsed time. Is there a way to see how much time has passed since I pressed the lap button so I know when to start my next interval?
Can you do a sleep stage study with Garmin with Firstbeat Analytics like fenix latest firmware VA apple ? Pretty please :)
Great video!! Garmin has the daily suggested workout and the Garmin coach for marathons prep.
Would have also liked to see the pixel watch and fitbit sense 2 in this video too..
Yes I’ve had them on and see it. But never actually used it!
Maybe in future videos I’ll include those
@@ShervinShares the daily suggested workout really helped me a lot in my daily training. Of course i have to use the sleep tracking to make it suggest better. It give me training base on training load and my sleep quality.
Coros also has a fitness "coach". Its not quite as good as Garmin but it does have way more options of training plans.
HI, what's the name of workout app for apple watch? thanks
Love the shout out for The Quantified Scientist 👍🏻
He’s great!
Are you running a Watch OS beta? I run 4-6 days a week with the Apple Watch Ultra since it came out and I’ve never once had stop/start issues with the action button.
Hard to imagine a better combination of platforms to test! Much appreciated. Maybe the Ultra button problem is a software issue? Seems to me that lately every Apple product I've touched has been class-leading on hardware, if only they'd have someone else do the software.
Enjoy the work you are doing! Staying real and being empirical is a great angle. My family are all in with Apple, and would love to get your take on the Apple Fitness+.
This is not empirical data. First off he has heavily biased toward Apple products if you've watched any of his videos. He also as a Tennessee to knock anything that has anything to do with competitive companies against Apple. That's why in this video you see him choosing a different category other than smart watches to give that appearance. Further empirical data has a LARGE sample size. In these videos he's only doing one and done's. That's a single sample of each category that's not scientific. I get it this is a simple video to give you a very broad idea but it is not empirical
Would love to see how distance affects data
I run with garmin and my friend runs with apple. Our laps sync up beautifully for the first 8 mi but after that they really start going far apart. I’ll finish with my garmin saying we did 13 miles and hers will say we did 13.52
Would be interested to see how the corps/garmin/ultra perform on a longer run
Thank you!....watching the watch video..Have a great weekend!
haha yes thank you!
Did you already test a Suunto watch? I use them for more than 8 years now an am really happy with it. Since 2 months I use the Suunto Race, fantastic watch!
Streaming music on the AWU is hefty! Started a long run at 79% battery. After 1.45h of running it warned me with 5% left. So streaming music on the AWU better bring your phone for streaming
I would love to see someone out on the street with a measuring wheel to make sure their watch is correct and now i finally did!
Hi, Which app are you using in your Apple Watch for strength training?
What is that strap you use on your arm?
Why did you not use the Galaxy Watch5 Pro? But great video thanks for sharing :)
Amazing test - I have been running with the Ultra A LOT this spring and never seen the freeze? Might be something with the track mode? That isn’t available in Denmark
Are you on beta software? Somethings off with your device. I haven’t even seen it once
Doesnt the apple watch use the GPS metrics from the iphone if it is connected ?
Your video quality is 100%!
Thank you Jess!! What video should I make next?
@@ShervinShares Best gadgets for people just starting their fitness journey
Can anyone tell me why a phone and H10 HR monitor wouldn't get everything done between them without the need for a watch? I am looking at training for a triathlon and want something I can wear but obviously a phone in the water ain't much use and not sure how the HR monitor would work if I left the phone on shore and swam a couple hundred metres away. Any advice/input would be appreciated!
you should also have tested different GPS modes... I know Garmin has 2 or 3 different protocols (or whatever it's called) depending on where you are. Maybe in the States it's different to Europe
Great video!! Loved it! The 4 watches is the only thing I sleep with these days… 😢😢😢 🤣🤣🤣
HAHAH glad I made ya laugh!
@@ShervinShares keep up the great work! Favorite CZcamsr these days!!💪🏻💪🏻
I know it might be a little late for this comment but i believe for the apple watch ultra you need to double press the action button to start the workout. they use it as a "accidental touch protection" feature
I still have my series 7. Ultra too big for me. Probably upgrade to whatever comes out this year. Would like to see what your training plan looks like. I’m just getting into running. Hoping to run a half next year
For running a switch to a garmin 265 would be sweet.
@@vpnconsultI looked at it but I do so much outside of running on my watch so it’s not worth it to me to switch.
Is your Coros Apex Pro 2 a mint green color? I can’t seem to find it online.
What is that thing in your hand which has wheels? I mean what do you use it for? (I'm asking since I have no idea regarding the same, not trying to be rude)
Waiting on the episode to compare Heart Rate Straps and best compatible with Apple
I have been using a Samsung Galaxy Watch 4 for my runs. You can see if the watch has a GPS signal before you start a Workout. On my runs the distance always was nearly spot on.
I use the 5 one and I think it is very accurate I really dont know why it worked so bad on the video. Maybe because he did not put it around his wrist
same even in swims its pretty accurate. no idea why its so bad in this video.
@@fernandobarros7164 The position on the wrist can completely ruin the measurements. Other major problems are if the software is up-to-date and if the Galaxy Watch is being used with a more recent Samsung phone.
I have the Watch 4 and have no problems at all. It's not the most accurate watch in the world but does a decent job.
what about your sub 5 min mile goal? are you still planning to get it?
Amazing comparison, I am very impressed.
My friend, I run a little, I bike r little I sleep like crap.. what device do I want to track my heart rate recovery and sleep?
Can you run a marathon and listen to music with Apple Watch, will the battery last, it would suck to lose your marathon tracking just because you wanted to listen to music and not bring your phone
This channel is very underrated
Hey, bro, I was in doubts about buying iWatch Ultra and just you gave me this impulse to finally take it )) do not betray us - this lovely watch and me ))❤
Hahaha Apple Watch or ☠️ ✊
@UCv9ingiPmqKs6ejZV2Pt6Dw 2 answers from you today (the first one in Strava) - I feel so good 😊
If you use the apple watch Ultra as a comparison, which is a top of the range watch, you need to compare it to the Garmin Fenix ranges as that will be in the similar price range have the full Garmin feature range.
for this kind of comparation it makes no difference. Fenix is more rugged with MIP screen. all the gps, OHR etc. stuff is exactly the same as FR965
very helpful video! thank you
Thank you! What future content do you want to see??
@@ShervinShares love to watch what you do to train for the marathon... thinking about doing one myself but don't know how to prepare
You can long press the back button to pause and unpause the workout on samsung.
Love my Coros
Great video brotha! The Galaxy ranked so low 😂 Pumped to watch your marathon prep journey
🤣 thanks Noah! We’ll have to run or workout together soon!
The Coros Apex Pro has a touch screen. You have to activate it.
Great video. I would have gone with the Apple Watch Ultra. I have it, works flawless every day. Action button is always working for me. When I run on a treadmill I use a Stryd connected to my AW since it got better accuracy 💪🏻⌚️❤️
Good to know Stryd works well! On my Garmin, I can easily adjust the treadmill distance after I complete the run. AW, no ability to change the distance that I’m aware of. I will have to check out Stryd as an option.
You need to use the Samsung longer. Pushing and holding the bottom button on the side of the watch pauses the workout. Also galaxy watch 5 pro would be a better competitor.
Yea I tried that but holding buttons is too challenging esp when you’re out of breath. Samsung didn’t send me the pro so this was the Watch I had to test!
Also, you should have used the classic watch from Samsung. I don't think is a fair comparison when you are using the pro version of the Apple and the 965 om garmin .
I believe the classic fitbit does the trick