I still ended up making this concept after my previous 10 minutes thing (which was originally supposed to be this) after stumbling across some new stuff like 1:39! I tried to use as diverse but still impressive clips as possible... but it was hard cause yk.
@@tonybs03 lol I’m talking about it sounds like it’s a comfortable spot in her range Her tone sounds similar to studio in ways it doesn’t in other songs But doesn’t mean that exact performance didn’t have some pitch concerns
I just realized that Mariah's best vocals are when her eyes are closed. 3:19 in Hero, 3:43 in Miss You Most, 5:15 My All etc. Also her vibrato has greatly improved in consistency.
Sometimes I feel like when she close her eyes she imagines being by herself which cause her to do better because she once said herself that she is more comfortable in the studio when live she is nervous
Also she already know the older she gets the more fragile her voice so her confidence is also a big part to play but most of the time she could definitely hit high notes but her confidence gets in the way and she rely on play back or not singing it at all
I agree there is definitely something special about her mind when she sings. Maybe part of the reason she's bad at lipping is because she's not an actor at heart, but I also think that singing is such a personal, almost spiritual thing to her that its hard to act that experience out so to speak
1:40 ummmm incredibly disappointed in the lambily that this wasn’t talked about sooner…. Thank you for showing us how good this year has been more Mariah’s voice, I’m really looking forward to what she has in store for us!!
I hope she gets back to at least her 2023 Christmas levels of live singing...which were FAR below what she had prior, but at least there were like 2 songs that were mostly live (Hero and HTHAS). C'mon Mimi, give us SOMETHING.
Yes Hero makes me especially sad, because she was always willing to sing it, and it is a forgiving song, so she's not required to hit the Eb5s (in my opinion). Hero has always been where she feels connected to her fans the most- so lipping it makes us lose some of that emotion.
@@outsideskippy1997 I was actually so sad when she started lipping the ending of Hero last year😭 like the bridge ok fine cause she struggled with it so much in 2022. But like the ending is the most emotional part with the best adlibs and actually it's probably the easiest part of the song too...
Give her some more time. She hasn't been the same since late 2023. It's like she doesn't wanna be out performing anymore, it feels like a lot like an obligation at this point. Hopefully she'll get her 2019-2022 energy back soon
She has more than 10 minutes though, in the past 12 months she has sang live for hours. This is just condensed segments from actual live performances. She only stuck to pre recordings for most of the show now for Vegas. Y'all act like she hasn't sang her ass off for 34 years, too. 😂
@@Filotus pls stop assuming I don’t take account of her long career😭. All I’m saying is it’s sad how more common lip syncing is becoming even if it’s more then 10 mins, I’ll always love Mariah no matter what anyways
Mariah doesn't have to prove anything to anyone. No one in the entire Earth can do what she has done over 30 years! That's something outstanding and a jawbreaker.
@@Supchargedwhen you’ve literally sang your voice to the extreme for the 1st 10 years of your career and done things most vocalists could only dream of doing, what else do you expect. She’s cemented in history as a legend.
Ive noticed something everytime mariah has talked about the residency shes said it was something completely unexpected and that she wasnt even planning to do it but she finally decided to (almost like saying she didnt want to do it). If i recall correctly shes independent now, and i also saw someone on twitter saying that this vegas show are just to get some money for the promotion of mc16 since shes independent now... Idk maybe it makes sense she wouldnt waste her voice in something she didnt plan to do and something she doesnt like but ultimately has to do. Either saving her voice for recording mc16 album or mc16 tour or both
@@superbored4576 omg i think youtube deleted my comment but yes, im pretty sure she is. since 2021 i think. all her recent projects have been collabs with other artists so if you check the credits, that artists label will appear in them. but for example, if you scroll down on spotify in wbt 2021 late night valentine mix, you can see something like "MARIAH 2021" which means its an independent release and she owns the masters of it.
Do you really think with the amount of money she has that she would need to do a Vegas residency in order to fund an album or album promotion? She could fund it on All I Want 4 Xmas money alone. Whenever she releases a new album I highly doubt she’ll bother with much promotion or music videos cos she just doesn’t seem that invested anymore. I would love a new album with new vocals but I also would just like her to be happy and raise her kids if that’s what she wants to do and stop tarnishing her amazing legacy with these shows that are fully lipped. It’s becoming more and more difficult to defend her at this point
I never released the attempts she actually went for in early 2023. Maybe early-mid 2023 was overhated bc she went for the same attempts as 2024 but actually sounded wayy less hoarse. Also the christmas 2023 shows sound so good now relistening to it!
yeah her voice was definitely better than Dec 2022 in early-mid 2023, but it was just really inconsistent. Like if you only look at the good attempts then she had actually had the same level of belt attempts (C#5s and D5s) as current Mariah
I will be honest, and say even though I truly appreciate Mariah going up on stage and still performing however this way of performing isn’t sustainable. This makes me feel like we took Cautionriah for granted considering she still got up on stage and sang live.
@@Believe.H It makes me kind of nervous that Mariah is lipping so much atm because based on past trends her voice never stays in such great condition for long. So even if she does sing live more in the future her voice might not be in as good shape then as it is now😔
It’s really really sad but I do feel like Mariah has pushed herself for years despite her compromised vocal state it’s actually a wonder she waited this long to lip shows as much as she is now, I think any other artist in her position wouldn’t have waited that long, but if anything it shows her life long commitment to her craft and singing live. Whereas before she used to control her voice, her voice now controls her depending on her vocal state. In the last 5 years especially her inconsistency has become the very thing that hinders her from performing live. It’s not the necessarily that she can’t hit the notes because she obviously can if she’s recording the studio tracks to lip to, it’s that she can’t hit them consistently anymore. She might have a day where she wakes up and her voice is in a really good condition and be able to perform large parts of the shows live, however she can’t risk singing live for 30 shows if she only has a couple shows where she is in good vocal health, it becomes a question of whether its worth the gamble. Whereas she used to take that gamble and was able to push through shows where she wasn’t in the best vocal state, she doesn’t anymore simply I guess because her voice didn’t bounce back after quarantine the way she probably wanted it to. Unless she takes some very serious decisions about her voice in terms of surgery etc which we all know she would have done by now if she was going to unfortunately this isn’t going to get better. I hate how we used to take her previous vocal state for granted and compare it to the 90s which quite frankly is a completely different singer from what we saw for the 2010s. Love her with all my heart I hope I’m proved wrong
I genuinely hope she isnt recording. Yes new music would be great. But she needs to heal her voice and get help immediately. 2024 is the Merry Christmas 30th Anniversary and I believe she must have something even bigger in the works. She cannot go on stage a mess. 30 years of AIWFCIY. She needs to get it together.
I just wonder how her sound has become this constricted in a way, like something is holding her back from really hitting the right notes, or even sing live in the first place. She just doesn t seem to let her voice be free, maybe it s because she lost a lot of her confidence……who knows
This is a revelation. I think it's one thing to listen to her current live singing layered in between pre-recorded vocals, where the halo of "good vocals" can outshine the not-so-good live vocals. But to hear all of the live bits together just underscores the fact that she really and truly has lost it. I hate to say that, especially since it looks like she is concentrating very hard on delivering good vocals. I think we can be forgiving if she cannot belt out notes with ease like she did in her youth. But she is often flat/off pitch and her belting voice has taken on a harsh, metallic edge that is just not pleasant to hear. Things have gotten so bad, yet, she feels the need to put on this false public facade that she is still the same powerhouse vocalist of her youth. I wish she could carry on forever, but at some point she has to stop before she tarnishes her legacy even further. Or maybe the best thing would be for her to disappear for a while, raise the kids, travel, live a normal civilian life, and then come back to the world as a completely different/wiser artist who is no longer bogged down by the baggage of her former capabilities.
I mean, in my opinion she hasn't completely lost it- I could see those issues in 2018-2022- but her voice has improved since then. Sure, you could argue that these vocals aren't very good, but they are certainly not Mimi's worst. And the lambily absolutely has lowered our standards for Mariahs voice- but that's how we celebrate improvement from 2022. Frankly Mariah in the 2010s had frequent pitch issues- so 2023/2024 is only marginally worse than that. But I do agree that it might serve Mariah well to take some time off, especially since it doesn't seem like she has the desire to perform currently.
I still ended up making this concept after my previous 10 minutes thing (which was originally supposed to be this) after stumbling across some new stuff like 1:39! I tried to use as diverse but still impressive clips as possible... but it was hard cause yk.
I'm mad the piano rehersals she posted were probably the day she was recording the new tracks ☠
I know💀 especially the It's Like That clip. The Circles one looks like she's actually on the stage so maybe not
@@VMariah agree
queen of clickbaiting
@@vicktheengine5304exactly … cheater she is nowadays
@@coltonisalambbro I never thought about that, but yeah she must have been recording for quite awhile
The beginning of we belong together is perfect for her current voice
It sounded very pitchy or is it just me haha
@@tonybs03 lol I’m talking about it sounds like it’s a comfortable spot in her range
Her tone sounds similar to studio in ways it doesn’t in other songs
But doesn’t mean that exact performance didn’t have some pitch concerns
@@tonybs03I think the endings of the phrases are different than studio
But it’s not that pitchy
I just realized that Mariah's best vocals are when her eyes are closed. 3:19 in Hero, 3:43 in Miss You Most, 5:15 My All etc. Also her vibrato has greatly improved in consistency.
Sometimes I feel like when she close her eyes she imagines being by herself which cause her to do better because she once said herself that she is more comfortable in the studio when live she is nervous
Also she already know the older she gets the more fragile her voice so her confidence is also a big part to play but most of the time she could definitely hit high notes but her confidence gets in the way and she rely on play back or not singing it at all
I agree there is definitely something special about her mind when she sings. Maybe part of the reason she's bad at lipping is because she's not an actor at heart, but I also think that singing is such a personal, almost spiritual thing to her that its hard to act that experience out so to speak
It's so crazy how 2023 was the last time she basically sang live and also the last time she attempted a lot of notes she skipped in Caution era
Looking at you "You make ME feel"
What about Abu Dhabi earlier this year?
@@alejandrogonzalezakamintyt2242 abu dabhi counts mainly as an extra show from MCTA, considering how close the dates were
8:14 the way she’s having sm fun singing live like girl please give us more of this istg
0:00-0:15 Mariah's brand new FULLY LIVE Emotions arrangement for 2034😍 (only slightly shortened)
YOU ...got me feeli I'm in love... I'm alive... you make ME feel so- oh ohh oh yeyeah you got me feeling hiGRAHH
“Slightly shortened” 😍
manifestin Emotions interlude
1:08 this note change tickles all the right spots in my brain
She sounds borderline like a man
0:41 okay but the “go” ate
I love the lower Adlibs
She’s playing with her lower registers instead of modulation to infinity
5:37
1:40 ummmm incredibly disappointed in the lambily that this wasn’t talked about sooner…. Thank you for showing us how good this year has been more Mariah’s voice, I’m really looking forward to what she has in store for us!!
0:52 wait cause this intro is so good omg 😭
No fr her voice there sounds equally to almost good to her old christmas album 😍
Having to do this is sad 😭
I hope she gets back to at least her 2023 Christmas levels of live singing...which were FAR below what she had prior, but at least there were like 2 songs that were mostly live (Hero and HTHAS). C'mon Mimi, give us SOMETHING.
Yes Hero makes me especially sad, because she was always willing to sing it, and it is a forgiving song, so she's not required to hit the Eb5s (in my opinion). Hero has always been where she feels connected to her fans the most- so lipping it makes us lose some of that emotion.
@@outsideskippy1997 I was actually so sad when she started lipping the ending of Hero last year😭 like the bridge ok fine cause she struggled with it so much in 2022. But like the ending is the most emotional part with the best adlibs and actually it's probably the easiest part of the song too...
@@VMariahyes discovering that the hero endings were all the same was sooo sad
Don't forget Emotions, Make It Happen and Fly Like a Bird
Give her some more time. She hasn't been the same since late 2023. It's like she doesn't wanna be out performing anymore, it feels like a lot like an obligation at this point. Hopefully she'll get her 2019-2022 energy back soon
7:43 best part of her voice omg 😍
9:08 omg it’s giving charmbraceletttt
I should lower my expectations but I feel like she's on the verge of attempting at least one Eb5 in IBT
well it's gotta be IBT if anything cause that's the only song she actually removed playback from in Aruba. Maybe it's a sign🙏😭
why is it about the note ? Why not crisp vocals with fluidity, vibrato, legato?
@@odumosuolusegun2781 we don’t have either
It’s sad how many hours of so many shows live vocal wise are put into 10 minutes 😢
“Live” shows
She has more than 10 minutes though, in the past 12 months she has sang live for hours. This is just condensed segments from actual live performances. She only stuck to pre recordings for most of the show now for Vegas. Y'all act like she hasn't sang her ass off for 34 years, too. 😂
@@Filotus pls stop assuming I don’t take account of her long career😭. All I’m saying is it’s sad how more common lip syncing is becoming even if it’s more then 10 mins, I’ll always love Mariah no matter what anyways
@@trent0292I’ll always love her too but not gonna lie the 98% lip syncing is really depressing
@@Filotus delusion. shes lipping everything
0:49 the best attempt I fear
Better than the ones she uses on her videos 😮
1:45 the slayage
Vegas actually makes me so sad bc her vocal condition had gotten sm better end of 2023- early 2024 compared to 22/23
7:03 she sounds so rested and good tho omg
8:55 Definitely top 1 whistle/falsetto moment of 2024! Makes me feel like I'm floating on the clouds
2023 carrying this video😭 never thought I'd ever be saying that💀🙏
0:49 it's tiiiiiiimme
Mariah doesn't have to prove anything to anyone. No one in the entire Earth can do what she has done over 30 years! That's something outstanding and a jawbreaker.
I mean, at this point “she doesn’t have anything to prove” has been said for longer she had been performing all live 🤷♀️
@@Supchargedwhen you’ve literally sang your voice to the extreme for the 1st 10 years of your career and done things most vocalists could only dream of doing, what else do you expect. She’s cemented in history as a legend.
1:39 omg I never noticed this one!?
Ikr it's such a good find😍 I found out about it yesterday. Philly and MSG night 1>>
@@VMariah We kinda judged those “Fully lipped and uninteresting” vocally song way to early that we missed their rare good live vocal moment 😭
0:09 audience member having the best attempt😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Her tone, vibrato and resonance❤
Something must have happened in 2023. At first, she just sang less live on the Christmas tour. Finally, she barely sang live after Abu Dhabi😭
Ive noticed something everytime mariah has talked about the residency shes said it was something completely unexpected and that she wasnt even planning to do it but she finally decided to (almost like saying she didnt want to do it). If i recall correctly shes independent now, and i also saw someone on twitter saying that this vegas show are just to get some money for the promotion of mc16 since shes independent now... Idk maybe it makes sense she wouldnt waste her voice in something she didnt plan to do and something she doesnt like but ultimately has to do. Either saving her voice for recording mc16 album or mc16 tour or both
wait, so she's actually not under any record label right now?
@@superbored4576 omg i think youtube deleted my comment but yes, im pretty sure she is. since 2021 i think. all her recent projects have been collabs with other artists so if you check the credits, that artists label will appear in them. but for example, if you scroll down on spotify in wbt 2021 late night valentine mix, you can see something like "MARIAH 2021" which means its an independent release and she owns the masters of it.
Do you really think with the amount of money she has that she would need to do a Vegas residency in order to fund an album or album promotion? She could fund it on All I Want 4 Xmas money alone. Whenever she releases a new album I highly doubt she’ll bother with much promotion or music videos cos she just doesn’t seem that invested anymore. I would love a new album with new vocals but I also would just like her to be happy and raise her kids if that’s what she wants to do and stop tarnishing her amazing legacy with these shows that are fully lipped. It’s becoming more and more difficult to defend her at this point
0:49 to 1:38 it's magical
I never released the attempts she actually went for in early 2023. Maybe early-mid 2023 was overhated bc she went for the same attempts as 2024 but actually sounded wayy less hoarse. Also the christmas 2023 shows sound so good now relistening to it!
yeah her voice was definitely better than Dec 2022 in early-mid 2023, but it was just really inconsistent. Like if you only look at the good attempts then she had actually had the same level of belt attempts (C#5s and D5s) as current Mariah
@@VMariahtrue. Also current Mariah has vocally been the best since 2020 and tonally since 2018
This is wonderful LIVE vocals she sounds good too
I will be honest, and say even though I truly appreciate Mariah going up on stage and still performing however this way of performing isn’t sustainable. This makes me feel like we took Cautionriah for granted considering she still got up on stage and sang live.
With each era I see im like damn the prior era was underrated, I actually loveeeeee cautionriah
@@Believe.H It makes me kind of nervous that Mariah is lipping so much atm because based on past trends her voice never stays in such great condition for long. So even if she does sing live more in the future her voice might not be in as good shape then as it is now😔
@@VMariah honestly if she did a thing where she prerecords every performance the day before the performance and then lip it that would slay
@@Believe.H that would be so slay but probably too much variation for her/the band to remember when lipping😭
TONE
her singing miss you most makes me wanna cry every time i see it lmao
Thank you so much for creating this lovely video, Mariah is the greatest!
coltonlamb key 😍7:24
It’s really really sad but I do feel like Mariah has pushed herself for years despite her compromised vocal state it’s actually a wonder she waited this long to lip shows as much as she is now, I think any other artist in her position wouldn’t have waited that long, but if anything it shows her life long commitment to her craft and singing live. Whereas before she used to control her voice, her voice now controls her depending on her vocal state. In the last 5 years especially her inconsistency has become the very thing that hinders her from performing live. It’s not the necessarily that she can’t hit the notes because she obviously can if she’s recording the studio tracks to lip to, it’s that she can’t hit them consistently anymore. She might have a day where she wakes up and her voice is in a really good condition and be able to perform large parts of the shows live, however she can’t risk singing live for 30 shows if she only has a couple shows where she is in good vocal health, it becomes a question of whether its worth the gamble. Whereas she used to take that gamble and was able to push through shows where she wasn’t in the best vocal state, she doesn’t anymore simply I guess because her voice didn’t bounce back after quarantine the way she probably wanted it to. Unless she takes some very serious decisions about her voice in terms of surgery etc which we all know she would have done by now if she was going to unfortunately this isn’t going to get better. I hate how we used to take her previous vocal state for granted and compare it to the 90s which quite frankly is a completely different singer from what we saw for the 2010s. Love her with all my heart I hope I’m proved wrong
also circles vegas rehearsal
Best moments is with Trey. Improviah!
Her voice totally change 😢
now imagine if she used the 2022 lipping format with this vocal condition 😍
Hero and we belong together!
Love it
Thank you❤
loved this - can you done using any recent vegas moments?
The Queen of dubbed vocal recordings presented as authenthic to unsuspecting fans like this one
come on now this is the ONE time you can't say that this year💀
@@VMariah he's a britney fan.
I genuinely hope she isnt recording. Yes new music would be great. But she needs to heal her voice and get help immediately. 2024 is the Merry Christmas 30th Anniversary and I believe she must have something even bigger in the works. She cannot go on stage a mess. 30 years of AIWFCIY. She needs to get it together.
Waiting for new arrangements for new songs:)
1:39 What note did she hit here?
she hit two C5s in the phrase! the second one is barely audible but the first one is pretty good
@@VMariah thanks
You can use a guitar tuner app as well
not the instagram clips 😭
is 0:38 the actual audio from that video? why is it so clean
wait... I got it from another video but maybe whoever uploaded it dubbed it over?
@@VMariah maybe it's a small venue and the camera is close to the speakers
@@coltonisalamb yeah I think that's probably it
I just wonder how her sound has become this constricted in a way, like something is holding her back from really hitting the right notes, or even sing live in the first place. She just doesn t seem to let her voice be free, maybe it s because she lost a lot of her confidence……who knows
she is always and forever Queen of Divas in the world ❤❤❤.. beyond here and on to eternity. Mariah Mariah Mariah.. Infinity Mariah Carey❤❤
This is a revelation. I think it's one thing to listen to her current live singing layered in between pre-recorded vocals, where the halo of "good vocals" can outshine the not-so-good live vocals. But to hear all of the live bits together just underscores the fact that she really and truly has lost it. I hate to say that, especially since it looks like she is concentrating very hard on delivering good vocals. I think we can be forgiving if she cannot belt out notes with ease like she did in her youth. But she is often flat/off pitch and her belting voice has taken on a harsh, metallic edge that is just not pleasant to hear. Things have gotten so bad, yet, she feels the need to put on this false public facade that she is still the same powerhouse vocalist of her youth. I wish she could carry on forever, but at some point she has to stop before she tarnishes her legacy even further. Or maybe the best thing would be for her to disappear for a while, raise the kids, travel, live a normal civilian life, and then come back to the world as a completely different/wiser artist who is no longer bogged down by the baggage of her former capabilities.
I mean, in my opinion she hasn't completely lost it- I could see those issues in 2018-2022- but her voice has improved since then. Sure, you could argue that these vocals aren't very good, but they are certainly not Mimi's worst. And the lambily absolutely has lowered our standards for Mariahs voice- but that's how we celebrate improvement from 2022. Frankly Mariah in the 2010s had frequent pitch issues- so 2023/2024 is only marginally worse than that. But I do agree that it might serve Mariah well to take some time off, especially since it doesn't seem like she has the desire to perform currently.
Not you making round figure ...10:00
The fact that it had to be titled pure live vocals, says it all.
We got 10 minutes😂
The fact that this video is ONLY 10 minutes out of an entire year is very depressing 😢
Show for 1:50 ? And 1:55 ? Please
The first is the philadelphia show (12/13/2023), and the second is the first new york show (12/9/2023).
i just know at least 5 mins of this is lipped too
@@nh2201 changed your profile pic? Almost didn’t recognize you there
oh that’s not….
Girl i knida dont like this vid..love your effort tho...but make a one complete song of recent vocals of mimi❤❤❤