Shelly Motion 2 review & Home Assistant integration
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 07. 2024
- Shelly Motion 2 (official Shelly store affiliate) - bit.ly/3Ygd3zN
Shelly Amazon Store - amzn.to/34d88VR
I will show you what is good and what is bad about Shelly Motion 2. As usual I will try to add #Shelly #Motion #2 in Home Assistant and I will create some demo automation.
► MY ARTICLE ABOUT THAT TOPIC - peyanski.com/shelly-motion-2-...
► MY HOME ASSISTANT INSTALLATION METHODS FREE WEBINAR - automatelike.pro/webinar
► DOWNLOAD MY FREE SMART HOME GLOSSARY - automatelike.pro/glossary
► AFFILIATE LINKS
Shelly Motion 2 (official Shelly store) - bit.ly/3Ygd3zN
Shelly Amazon Store - amzn.to/34d88VR
Shelly Official Store (main page) - bit.ly/3BwMMn2
SwitchBot Flash Deals - switchbot.vip/3BwF221
Reolink Flash Deals - shrsl.com/301ih
Aqara Amazon Store - amzn.to/3EpeCSb
Tech that I’m using right now - www.amazon.com/shop/kpeyanski
Get $100 in credit over 60 days for DigitalOcean - m.do.co/c/6dd2caef1f1f
Register for Kajabi from here app.kajabi.com/r/NetydFAg and I will share half of my commission with you (15%)
► CRYPTO AFFILIATE LINKS
Sign up for Crypto.com and we both get $25 USD (Referral code: xn86atnceg) - crypto.com/app/xn86atnceg
Deposit more than $50 in Binance and receive 100 USDT cashback voucher - www.binance.com/en/activity/r...
Binance - One of the biggest Crypto currency exchange - www.binance.com/en/register?r...
► SUPPORT MY WORK
Paypal - www.paypal.me/kpeyanski
Patreon - / kpeyanski
Bitcoin - 1GnUtPEXaeCUVWdJxCfDaKkvcwf247akva
Revolut - revolut.me/kiriltk3x
► TIME TABLE
00:00 Intro
00:16 What is Shelly Motion 2 and is it better than Motion 1?
02:48 Free Home Assistant Webinar
04:24 How to find the Shelly Motion 2 IP?
04:56 Enabling CoAP/COIOT in Shelly Web Interface
05:43 How to add Shelly Motion 2 in Home Assistant?
06:58 Shelly Motion 2 Home Assistant Automation demo
10:09 Near Genius question for You!
10:28 Shelly Motion 2 Cons
11:30 Shelly Motion 2 Pros
11:50 My General Recommendations
► SHELLY MOTION 2 HOME ASSISTANT AUTOMATION FROM THE VIDEO
alias: Shelly Motion 2 detected movement in the dark
description: ''
trigger:
- type: motion
platform: device
device_id: 4e3fc7dcacf59e4e644641469e781f50
entity_id: binary_sensor.shellymotion2_84fd271be41e_motion
domain: binary_sensor
condition:
- condition: numeric_state
entity_id: sensor.shellymotion2_84fd271be41e_luminosity
below: '1000'
action:
- service: input_boolean.turn_on
data: {}
target:
entity_id: input_boolean.dummy_bulb
mode: single
✅ Don't Forget to like 👍 comment ✍ and subscribe to my channel!
► DISCLAIMER
Some of the links above are affiliate links. If you click on these links and purchase an item I will earn a small commission with no additional cost for you. Of course, you don’t have to do so in case you don’t want to support my work! - Jak na to + styl
Great video as usual.
I have one Shelly Dimmer 2 in my setup at the moment.
More Shellys will be added in the future.
The great thing with HA is that you can mix different protocols. I got Zigbee, W-Wave and WiFi in my current setup :)
Exactly, you can use different protocols and brands and treat them equally into useful automations.
This was the hint I needed to integrate the Shelly Motion 2! Thank you very much!
Glad I could help! Check my other videos as well.
Already subscribed.. i have a couple of shelly 1s and they are rock solid. Great videos as always..
Awesome! Thank you for the comment. Best of luck next Wednesday!
Loved your video! I have 3 Shelly devices so far: Shelly 1, which I use activate a garage gate, a Shelly 2.5 for operating a motorised blind and a Shelly EM to measure the power consumption of my house. Working like a charm from minute 1 and all of them integrated in Home Assistant!
Good job! But be careful with the Shelly PM for the whole house consumption metering as it is not designed for that. I think Shelly EM is more appropriate!
@@KPeyanski It was a typo! I do have a Shelly EM 😄
Great review! Thanks for sharing your opinion and keep up the great work!
Thanks, will do!
Thanks in advance for the give away 🥳😘
I have some Shelly 2.5 in use
Haha you are welcome! Thanks for commenting.
Many thanks for the review and chance to win !
You are most welcome. Wish you good luck!
I have gone all in on Shelly! Multiple 1, PM, 2.5 and bulbs. I am monitoring water heating, room temperature, boiler performance, solar PV, power consumption at a device, circuit and whole house level, including EV charging. I and switching many things such as gates, garage door, lighting, fans and EV charger. Am playing with the idea of going to Home Assistant so will check out your other videos. Would be great to add this new motion sensor.
Impressive! And yes imho only Home Assistant is missing in the whole picture ;)
No. I don't have any Shelly devices. Yet... Thanks to you and other creators, I'm learning more about them and will be ordering some soon. Thanks for your videos. I've learned a lot from you.
Awesome! Glad that I'm in any help. Thank you!
Amazing. This new shelly looks just nicer, but still big :). I dont have any shelly devices, but planning to get a few now.
Glad you like it and yes it is bigger than SB or Aqara sensors for example, but compared to Shelly Motion 1 it is much smaller.
Thank you for your videos. My preferred one was the ikea air sensor. I have made three of those.
You are welcome. I like the IKEA air sensor a lot as well :) It is very useful and fun.
Thanks, This one helped me :-), and yes I have a few Shelly in every room :-).
One more great video. Thanks. :). From Shelly I use 2pcs of Shelly EM with 4 sensors for my electricity. Great products. ;)
Good stuff indeed! And many thanks for the good words!
@@KPeyanski We are the ones that we should thank you. For the past 2 years that I got in trouble meaning Home Assistant :) you are one of those 3-4 guys that really helped me a lot. Again thank you for your efforts (cause I know how exhausting it is to make videos) and keep it up. :)
Wow, strong words :) I'm very happy to read your comment and really glad that I could help. See you around.
I have two Shelly Plus 1's that I use. They were early release models and worked with home assistant once I updated the firmware.
Yes, software update and some Home Assistant updates were necessary around the release date of the Shelly Plus, but now everything is bread and butter.
I've been using Shelly Door Window 2 and Shelly H&T for a while and in general they've been great.
Great, do you know that they released Shelly H&T 2 at the same time as they released Motion 2? And it has an eInk display.
Yes I have a number of Shelly 1 relays and Shelly 1 motion sensors. I am pleased the motion 2 Sensor does not appear to have to be manually defined in MQTT but works via the Shelly integration.
Yes, it works flawlessly so far
Being unsatisfied with frequent BLE communication loss between my RaspberryPi Home assistant and Xiaomi temp sensors+ some sonoff relays, I have decided that Shelly is the way to go.smaller form factor and reliable HassIo lan integration made me buy several Shelly1, 1PM, EM to monitor PV and control stuff. On my wish list: TRV and the new temp sensor.
Good choice! Keep up 👍
What i love about shelly motion 2 is quick response! I have several shelly devices and i absolutely love them all! :) shelly plugs for machines, shelly i4 for balcony light, 2.5 for shutters...
Yes, the response is quick and it is the same as Shelly Motion 1. But SM1 doesn't have a T sensor and it is not sold anymore on the official Shelly website.
I have 3 shelly rgbw2 ,using for kitchen under cabinet led lights and one for stairs lighting ,works very well 😊
great, you must have a nice looking kitchen and stairs 👍
I have a bunch of Shelly relays. They are fantastic for letting me reprogram the light switches in my house that are located in areas that don't make sense. And I can get some great automation for my garage lights and outdoor lights without having to buy special bulbs.
Great, it seems that you put your Shelly devices to a good use.
I currently own Shelly 3EM which is a godsent to my Home Assistant. I was looking at expanding my Shelly collection but for now I went with Aquara motion sensor. This Shelly sensor seems quite interesting as I didn't see any sensor that can be recharged using USB-C.
If you already have Aqara don't bother buying Shelly Motion imho.
@@KPeyanski I'd like to have a bit of diversity just to see what is the experience from the other side
Yes I have 3 Shelly 2.5 for my garage cover control and 1 Shelly 1 for a special Light in the kitchen.
Is the motion sensor for outside use also ?
The Shelly CEO said on the product launch event that is for inside use only, but if you cover it with something so no water can reach it - it can be mounted outside!
I do not have Shelley products, so it would be awesome to try one!
OK, wish you success in the giveaway!
Thanks for your videos on the channel. I have 17 Shellies running atm. (plug, EM, Dimmer2, I3, SW-25, 1, L, PM, HT-1, MOS1). My SHMOS-01 is hard to wake up by entering the ip-address in the browser. I hope this is improved in Shelly Motion 2.
I doubt it as they are virtually the same devices in terms of chip, cpu and battery
Yes I have several shellys integrated in Home-Assistenten! Such as Shelly 1, Dimmer and ans blinds Mover. The shelly motion 2 seems to be really impressive i Would integrate This in our staircase with the shelly 1 Switch
Sounds like a plan. Thanks for commenting.
I use Shelly relays all over the place, small and reliable but wifi sensors just suck. Right now I don’t think anything is beating the aqara p1 and fp1 combo … it’s unbelievable we finally got true presence detection and the new p1 is just wow
Thanks for the comment. I'm planning to test & review the p1 & fp1 in the future as well :)
Great video. I have a Shelly one controlling a switch. are you sit within home assistant. it is basically to turn off and on a light during the night and off in the morning.
Thanks, glad you like the video and I think you found a great use of your shelly device
I use 3 pcs shelly 1pm to monitor the energy consumption of air conditioners. They have been working for 2 years and there are no problems with them. Of course they are added to the HA.
Great, knowing your energy consumption is pretty important. Especially, lately!
interesting will be useful also device like this motion sensor/port sensor also for outdoor application, even if i want to monitoring external door motion outside, there is some device for that purpose ? tks
Great video as always. I have no Shelly devices in my smart home yet!
Thanks, I'm trying to be in help. Wish you luck in the giveaway.
@@KPeyanski thanks! Besides a bunch of raspbery pies the only wifi device in my smart home is an ikea sensor, got inspired to do it after your video!
No Shelly devices yet, but my current motion sensors are not verry configurable and I'm definitely looking for a good motion sensor to switch to. Great Video :)
Motion 2 is a good motion sensor for sure. Thanks for commenting.
No Shelly devices, great job on the channel,!
Thank you! Glad you like the channel and good luck with the giveaway!
Great video! I only use zigbee sensors, no WiFi.
Good choice! Glad you like the video!
Do you have any issues using ESP Home on your 10.x.x.x network as I was told the ESPHome server/UI will not work if one does not use a 192.x.x.x or 172.x.x.x home internet IP range. My ESP Home UI fails to see devices with ESP home installed on them.
No issues at all, and I'm hearing this network rule for the first time. It sounds strange though...
what is the cool down time of the sensor? i have cheap IKEA ones in my HA setup and they have a LONG cooldown. Looking for something faster.
minimum is 1 minute, for the max I'm not sure
Yes I have a Shelly EM to measure total energy of my house, a PM1 to control my water boiler, 6 Shelly PM1 to control electric heaters, and a Shelly 2.5 to control my outside lights. All these controlled and monitored from my HA installed in a cloud virtual machine using MQTT, INFLUXDB and GRAFANA
Sounds good. But why your HA is in the Cloud? Are you happy with this setup?
Great video. Thanks. I do have some Shelly devices in my house, but my motion sensors are mostly Aqara Zigbee. This motion sensor looks pretty small though. Interesting.
Hello there, many thanks for commenting here. The SM2 is looking good indeed, but I was thinking another thing when I saw your comment! What if the random HA function pick you as giveaway winner next week? 🤣 People will say that the giveaway is fake! I better remove you from the participants...
Just kidding, wish you success!
@@KPeyanski Haha, I always say to exclude me from giveaways. Let other people enjoy it. I already get so much stuff sent to me. That wouldn't be fair.
OK, I will do as per your request! See you around!
Got a bunch of Shelly plugs for switching kids pc-monitors, controling plant lamps++. Shelly 2.5 behind most light-switches, always on, but to provide input signals for smart bulbs and other things in the house. All connected to a home made controller app through MQTT, and from there exposed to Home Assistant.
Love the different Shelly switches, haven't tried the sensors yet.
Good, but nasty! Are you automatically switching off the PC monitors of the poor kids? 🤣 Just kidding here... What is that home made controller did you made it yourself?
It is indeed automated to turn off when it's time to prepare for bed. Working very well... 😆
It's a series of docker containers communicating through MQTT. So one takes input from the Shelly's and parses single push/double push and hold, or a series of these and sends commands based on the configured events. Others convert the commands into UDP packets for the Wiz-bulbs or pushes setup for Wled segments.
Good, but is it required constant maintenance or it is set and forget?
Quite stable. Have only been running this for a couple of months, so time will show...
Have several Shelly’s, all are 1’s, love the fact that they are dry contact, very helpful for certain things like in my case, when my fireplace hits a certain temperature, it runs my HVAC fan for 10 minutes which circulates the fireplaces warmth through the entire house. I use two on my Autoslide patio door servo, one for dog width, and one for human width. And several for garage door openers, ceiling fan control etc. this sensor you are testing, how fast or slow is it? As soon as I hear IP address and battery operated, I expect delays that usually are too long to be useful.
Thanks for the detailed explanation of the usage of your Shelly devices 👍 Regarding the response time - it is really fast it is under 200ms.
@@KPeyanski wow, even from sleep?
I have two Shelly Uni which I've used to make "dumb" devices smart and a Shelly EM for house power usage monitoring which has helped me scale my new solar and battery system.
Great setup! Did you manage to add your solar & battery system in Home Assistant? Or you are not a HA user?
@@KPeyanski Still waiting for it to be delivered but I've gone for a GivEnergy system specifically as they have released a local interface to mqtt which of course will end up in HomeAssistant.
Sounds good. Enjoy the process!
No, but your videos are really helping me plan and design my future HA!
Glad to hear it! Wish you success!
I use shelly 1L to control light switches. Do you prerefare this shelly motion sensor to the aquara p1
It all depends of what you already have or you plan to have. If you have a Zigbee hub/stick go for the aqara if you have WIFI only go for the Shelly Motion 2.
Yes I have Shelly motion 1, 2 Shelly 4pro, 2 Shelly EM and a lot of other Shelly devices working with my Home assistant.
Looks like you are a Shelly fan. Are you happy with the results?
Yes all the devices work flawlessly through the years, but I'm rather disappointed by the lack of firmware updates for old devices as 4Pro
shelly on home assistant Is it local or cloud?
I still didn't get to the Shellys bit would ask g to start with them. Who knows may I'll have the opertubity soon.
They look very promessing
Wish you luck with the giveaway so you can have your first Shelly device!
Nice vid! i have: shelly1, shelly rgbw and the shelly switch25. I even changed my fibaro switch with a shelly one :D (dont tell them sst :p)
Haha ok I won't!
Yes, I have multiple Shelly 1s, Shelly 1 PM Plus' and a Shelly Motion 1
So you have a Shelly Motion 1 after all? I thought you will never buy it after I saw your previous comment 😂
Yes.I have shelly 1PM.
great 👍
I tried to integrate my Shelly Motion 2 to Home assistant as you described (enable CoIoT, write the IP address of my HA installation with the default 5683 port, then in HA input the IP address of the sensor) but it says ""unable to connect" or something similar (the language is not English). I can connect to the sensor web page and it's working fine. Any idea on how to make it connect to HA?
Now it works. I don't know if it's because I renamed it in the Shelly app to match the name on the device, or because HA was updated to a new version yesterday
Glad you sort it out. I don't know what was the issue...
Does this Shelly Motion 2 work while charging? Can I plug it in and use it while charging?
I believe it is not working, but I'm not 100% sure...
No, I currently don't have any shelly devices, but they are on my wish list
OK, thanks for commenting!
Yes, I have 2 Shelly 1 and 1 Shelly 1 PM Plus
Good, are you happy with the Plus series or the Gen1 are better for you?
I do not have any shelly devices but am looking for a motion sensor. the Shelly would be great.
Thanks for sharing. Yes Shelly Motion is working great.
Don't have any Shelly device, but I'm interested in their smart switches. I have a motion sensor from Sonoff and that one can only be triggered every 2-3 minutes so its not ideal.
Yes, 2-3 minute motion sensor response is far from ideal :) Thanks for sharing this info!
No I don’t have any Shelly devices yet, I have been looking at a number of Shelly devices to replace my older devices.
OK, thanks for sharing.
Yes, I Have 3 shelly 1 relays. 1 for each of my two fireplaces and 1 for the vehicle door of my detached garage.
good, but how your garage is detached? Detached from the house or something other? 🤔
Impossible to connect Shelly Motion and SAhelly Motion 2 to my HA Instance, all other Shelly devices are visible, but No Motion won't be added, I am missing something here, having followed carefully this tutorial!?!?
Make sure that you wake the device before adding it in HA, also make sure that they are in the same network (no vlans and stuff)
I have a shelly1 for my garage door opener, a shelly1pm, and 2 shelly 2.5s. Slowly building out my inventory.
Yes, that is the right way - slowly but surely 😉
I don't have a Shelly device yet 😔, though you make me want to buy one.
Good, check again my next week video and you may be the winner of my Shelly Motion 2 giveaway!
Looks a good device
Yes, the device is good.
I'm not sure if I like to have a device that I need to take down and charge for a while. I do like having a device that can use rechargeable batteries but then I would like to have them ready so I can get the sensor back up and running as soon as possible. But no I do not have a Shelly device in my setup.
Fair point, but I think a quick recharge every year is doable if don't have a lot of such devices, of course! Thanks for the comment!
Ses, 2 shelly 1, of which one with temperature extension. And a Shelly motion 2.
thanks for sharing 👍
I have several shelly devices, bulb, L1s, motion sensors and few days ago ordered 2 temperature sensors. Would be perfect if shelly motion 2 had humidity sensor too.
Maybe Motion 3 will have that as well 😉
I have four Shelly ones in my RV because they can be powered with 12 volts.
I have some of shelly 1, shelly 1PM, and Shelly Dou
Great. Thanks for commenting
I have one Shelly 1L controlling a ceiling fan with no wall switch.
Great, thanks for sharing!
Super video et je suis abonnée a ton Channel :) yes I would like to win and add shelly for my home assistant merci
Super! Best of luck!
Too many, but of course I want more. Old 1PM x 4 as plug extensions, Shelly 1 x 2 as plugs as well, old H&T x 4 around the house, old dimmer1 x 3, Button1 x 3, Duo Bulb x 5 and a 3EM. A few new 1PM Plus and i3 devices are waiting in a box to be installed one rainy weekend.
My one Motion always reads the battery as 0% and Shelly support wouldn’t tell me which pins to check and I couldn’t figure it out. That was fine, but now firmware 2.1.6 won’t let me upgrade firmware because the battery is “low”. These Motions have saved me hours of forgotten lights left on.
That 0% battery reading is nasty, I guess you had a bad luck with it. Hope you manage to sort it out and thanks for commenting!
I do not have a Shelly device, but I would like to have one :)
Great, thanks for commenting!
Using Shelly Plug S to make my washing machine smart.
Very clever. Are you using some Home Assistant automations for that as well or just the Shelly Plug?
@@KPeyanski Home assistant, measures consumption, off, standby or washing and sends a message to the phone when the laundry is done :)
Convert me to Shelly, I could never have enough devices linked to Home Assistant. :-)
haha, so do I
I only have Shelly 3EM unfortunately, but soon I will have and a motion sensor 🤣🤣🤣
Haha with you success next week. Thanks for commenting.
Yes, 3 Shelly Motion 1 sensors
nice, do you have any issues with them?
So far, they are the best sensors I have tried, they react perfectly and have an extremely low delay
currently no shelly device on my setup :(
OK, thanks for sharing.
No, I do not have any Shelly device, but I would like to have them.
OK, thanks for the comment!
Yeah, the shelly motion 1 really had a face only a mother could love. This is definitely better looking.
Hahaha, totally agree! This one was good!
Yes, I Have 3 shelly 1 relays. 2 for light and 1 for a EV charger.
Nice, do you have any issues with them or they are working good?
@@KPeyanski No issue. I have had them for 3+ year. Using them i Home Assistant.
Great to hear. Enjoy!
No Shelley devices YET 😂
oho I think you are aiming for the award of this giveaway. Best of luck!
I don´t have any Shelly device yet...
This video is a chance to get one for free. You have a comment, just sub if you haven't done that already ;)
Yes dimmer 2
Yes, smart Plug US
Good, is it working OK or there are some issues?
@@KPeyanski I have some issues. The first one that I bought never worked with the shelly cloud, and the second one it turns off by itself. I want to give shelly an other opportunity with the Shelly EM
I don't have any Shelly devices yet.
OK. Thanks for sharing!
no i do not have any Shelly devices, yet.
Cool, here is a chance to get one for free ;)
Only zigbee and local please
only local is possible with Shelly, but they are all with WIFI connectivity.
I don't have any Shelly devices.....yet
👍 thanks for commenting.
NO I dont have a shelly motion device because all the companies treat down under as piece of land somewhere in the bottom corner of Earth. No companies think our population is big enough to start a direct company outlet and if some companies are available they would be triple the cost than reset of the world. AUS only hope for tech things on fair price is to depend on aliexpress and wait for an year(sarcasm included) to get a product delivered .
and I mark Like to my own comment well hey as company statics we dont have enough population so I am allowed too :)
That is a shame, but I can't help much here. Anyways wish you success on the giveaway so you can get one SM2 not for triple the price, but for free...
No, not yet.
OK. Thanks for sharing!
No Shelly yet. Maybe that changes soon
Maybe yes, just wait for my next video...
@@KPeyanski Sure, Like Always ;)
No, I do not have any Shelly device.
OK, do you have motion sensors or other sensors from other brands?
@@KPeyanski zigbee Aqara old version with HA
Great choice. Enjoy!
I have two Shelly 1 and Shelly 1 L
Good, check my Shelly 1L & Shelly 1 Plus videos if you are interested.
No I don’t have any shelly devices
OK, thanks for commenting.
No
OK. Thanks for sharing!
No.
👍