Why it Feels Suffocating? | Composer REACTS to DARK SOULS 3 OST

SdĂ­let
VloĆŸit
  • čas pƙidĂĄn 28. 07. 2024
  • đŸ”» SUPPORT
    Patreon bit.ly/38Clzjo
    Ko-Fi (Tips) bit.ly/3aGzTbM
    Teespring (Merch) bit.ly/3b423wa
    đŸ”» TIMESTAMPS
    Intro 0:00
    Reaction 3:32
    Breakdown: The Wall of Sound 10:51
    Section I 12:39
    Transitions and Space Created? 15:12
    The Wailing!!! 19:52
    The Schrodinger Cat Ending Scenario 22:39
    đŸ”» SOCIAL MEDIA
    Instagram: bit.ly/3mNBzV5
    Twitter: bit.ly/38AuXUK
    đŸ”» CONTACT
    voidbornes@gmail.com
    #DarkSoulsIII #SlaveKnightGael #Reaction
  • Hudba

Komentáƙe • 1,8K

  • @TheBoxGhost_tm
    @TheBoxGhost_tm Pƙed 3 lety +6069

    No, he wasn't the final boss of the game.
    He was the final boss of the *series* .

    • @ottodavis-octane3839
      @ottodavis-octane3839 Pƙed 3 lety +252

      If you have taken down Darkeater Midir before Gael

    • @azzolith
      @azzolith Pƙed 3 lety +350

      @@ottodavis-octane3839 I always leave Midir till last, sorta goes from the beginning of the story, fighting a dragon, in the darkest depths

    • @yandere8418
      @yandere8418 Pƙed 3 lety +371

      The final boss of the series, you fight the Dark Soul that’s within gaels body, a fitting ending.

    • @noquad824
      @noquad824 Pƙed 3 lety +126

      @@yandere8418 I think so too, but Midir ate a lot of the dark soul too. Which makes both the perfect last 2 bosses. I usually blitz Halflight, then going midir, and finish with gael

    • @Ayniishu
      @Ayniishu Pƙed 3 lety +5

      GG

  • @madbrosheo1514
    @madbrosheo1514 Pƙed 3 lety +2136

    When phase 2 hits.
    Gael: “Call an ambulance...! But not for me!”

  • @williebell1956
    @williebell1956 Pƙed 3 lety +7362

    a comment that explains this fight perfectly: "two nobodies, in the middle of nowhere, fighting over nothing, with no one to witness it."

    • @Whitebreadmm
      @Whitebreadmm Pƙed 3 lety +296

      Perfect

    • @namelessking9399
      @namelessking9399 Pƙed 3 lety +296

      not over nothing though

    • @nefarious8278
      @nefarious8278 Pƙed 3 lety +601

      @@namelessking9399 it really is once Gael realise that he becomes the embodiment of some of the Dark soul at which point in phase 2 he becomes hollow as he has completed his objective

    • @NamelessKing1597
      @NamelessKing1597 Pƙed 3 lety +283

      @@namelessking9399 Technically it's to create a new world but it's still a good quote.

    • @sirparadigm2241
      @sirparadigm2241 Pƙed 3 lety +688

      Technically there is that one Ringed Knight in the arena to bear witness. I call him Steve.

  • @misterturkturkle
    @misterturkturkle Pƙed 3 lety +2590

    For hype context...
    This is the song that plays in the final battle.
    Like literally the last fight at the end of time. All other combatants have faded and turned to ash. And you battle in a valley made of their scattered ash.
    You, a failure, ressurected to try and save the world again when many who succeded refused to do it again. Gael, a slave, cursed and belittled. But hes outlived his masters.... hes collected all the parts of the "dark soul" one of four borne of the first flame.... all... but the bit you hold.
    He literally holds all the power in the world... except that which you bring with you.
    There is literally nothing left in the entire world... but you ... and Gael. And no matter the outcome of your battle... the Dark Soul will be made whole again..

    • @misterturkturkle
      @misterturkturkle Pƙed 3 lety +82

      @@minecraftmaster12245 it could be- its not explained. But i see it more as a mix of ash and everything being so old its crumbled to dust

    • @HowlingDoom
      @HowlingDoom Pƙed 3 lety +38

      @@minecraftmaster12245 There isn't any ash in Gaels arena just sand. Soul of Cinder might have ash in the arena just due to the fact thats where you do link the fire.

    • @HowlingDoom
      @HowlingDoom Pƙed 3 lety +74

      Also don't forget that Gael in the end was doing this for the painter, in fact its kinda implied he wants you to help him complete the dark soul and give it to painter.

    • @Vinnini
      @Vinnini Pƙed 3 lety +157

      @@HowlingDoom Yeah it's heavily implied, through his item descriptions and the fact he leaves you messages showing how to get to him in the Dreg Heap, that he knew the Dark Soul would drive him mad. He was leading you there so you could kill him and finish the job.

    • @TheViralInfekT
      @TheViralInfekT Pƙed 3 lety +14

      Very well put. And it seems the song does convey it beautifully.

  • @yuuyakizami2133
    @yuuyakizami2133 Pƙed 3 lety +528

    Fighting over a can of paint in the middle of nowhere has never been so intense as this fight

    • @radcut7404
      @radcut7404 Pƙed 3 lety +54

      I hate how accurate your summary of the fight is Lmao

    • @Zoinkoman135
      @Zoinkoman135 Pƙed 2 lety +31

      Lmfao you’re right tho “that thing
 your paint
 hand it over
”

    • @hyper_channel
      @hyper_channel Pƙed 2 lety +27

      My uncle went to buy paint and never came back

    • @cn4090
      @cn4090 Pƙed 2 lety +8

      @@hyper_channel Perhaps he is still searching for that paint.

    • @HaggisDruid
      @HaggisDruid Pƙed 2 lety +2

      @@cn4090 Until the end of time, until the end of everything.

  • @edbarbieri9106
    @edbarbieri9106 Pƙed 3 lety +1125

    Man..flashbacks when Gael jumps to strike you while also shooting bolts from his machine-gun crossbow lmao.

    • @antoniovitkovszki948
      @antoniovitkovszki948 Pƙed 3 lety +9

      Nightmare

    • @Monavatarestcool1
      @Monavatarestcool1 Pƙed 3 lety +80

      With lightning falling here and there

    • @nirmiak9906
      @nirmiak9906 Pƙed 3 lety +65

      it's one of my favorite combos at least visually

    • @jhonny1416
      @jhonny1416 Pƙed 3 lety +13

      It's just a fancy move, but it's too good.

    • @groundbreaker91
      @groundbreaker91 Pƙed 3 lety +34

      One of the best Gael moments I experienced was having him do his leaping attack with lightning striking dramatically behind him. So freaking epic.

  • @lamarose3613
    @lamarose3613 Pƙed 3 lety +1028

    You’re now my favorite bald man

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +310

      Bald is the new sexy 😆

    • @totem311
      @totem311 Pƙed 3 lety +18

      @@AtlasBenighted trueeeee

    • @bot_matrix
      @bot_matrix Pƙed 3 lety +13

      Cries in Bruce Willis*

    • @zmertzi
      @zmertzi Pƙed 3 lety +4

      bruhh this made me laugh in a very quiet night, well done

    • @johnnysins9054
      @johnnysins9054 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      What about me

  • @repcraptv3320
    @repcraptv3320 Pƙed 3 lety +501

    Didn't know Hitman hears to boss music.

  • @HarumiYu
    @HarumiYu Pƙed 3 lety +3897

    Everytime I hear Dark Souls or Bloodborne OST I'm like "Wait, was THIS playing while I was fighting?".

    • @ryanmazalli2198
      @ryanmazalli2198 Pƙed 3 lety +409

      The right way of playing this series is turning the music and tv to the max.

    • @Fobrat
      @Fobrat Pƙed 3 lety +243

      Dude me too, I get too stressed during the fight.

    • @WeskerTechnology
      @WeskerTechnology Pƙed 3 lety +9

      ikr

    • @blue_caduceus592
      @blue_caduceus592 Pƙed 3 lety +272

      Doesn't feel quite complete without the clash of steel, footsteps, and cries of pain.

    • @carlosjf504
      @carlosjf504 Pƙed 3 lety +122

      @@blue_caduceus592 Don't forget the "YOU DIED" jingle we are all too familiar with.

  • @wormy8559
    @wormy8559 Pƙed 3 lety +1842

    "The female choir is sound like hopeless"
    Well indeed, Ringed City DLC is end of the world and the last of everything.
    Demon Prince, Last of the Demons
    Darkeater Midir, Last of the Dragon
    Filianore, Last of the Gods
    Shira, Last servant of the gods
    Patches, Last NPC that stay sane
    Halflight, Last guardian of the gods
    And Gael, Last Human
    Soul of Cinder is the Final Boss of the game, but Gael is the Final Boss of the trilogy

    • @Valsorayu
      @Valsorayu Pƙed 3 lety +164

      And you, the final Undead.

    • @jhonny1416
      @jhonny1416 Pƙed 3 lety +91

      And the last ring knight

    • @luoxis
      @luoxis Pƙed 3 lety +85

      @@jhonny1416 Steve

    • @edwardlhesta7258
      @edwardlhesta7258 Pƙed 3 lety +74

      And The last of the Pygmies

    • @enclavesoldierusa
      @enclavesoldierusa Pƙed 3 lety +58

      @@jhonny1416 everybody forgets him, always called him Steven

  • @thomaspereira1545
    @thomaspereira1545 Pƙed 3 lety +1147

    It isn't overhyped. Just listening to it isn't the same as having it in background while fighting the man who by himself survived until the end of the world, fighting for a new one. Sacrificing himself so others can live away from the mistakes the gods made. It's the whole package that makes this song more than amazing.

    • @joshuagleeson4776
      @joshuagleeson4776 Pƙed 3 lety +109

      This is true. I never become attatched to music without experiencing it in full context. I can enjoy it, and appreciate it, but experiencing it properly first adds so much.

    • @orochinagis
      @orochinagis Pƙed 3 lety +8

      Actually he is a slave doing his mistress orders to find some pigment, he couldn't get the pigment early because the Ashen One took down most if the lords before him

    • @biggierocc1935
      @biggierocc1935 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      I learned that myself listening to music made before it's respective boss was finished, as well as music to fill a slot previously held by a placeholder

    • @cranx1668
      @cranx1668 Pƙed 3 lety +2

      Two nobodys fighting in the wasteland their kings and gods mistakes created, it's sincerely an amazing closure and especially when you have the music slightly higher than the sfx when fighting the boss

    • @johntimothyvalenzuela8146
      @johntimothyvalenzuela8146 Pƙed 3 lety +4

      especially when you get to 2nd phase and gael is flying all over the place among lightning strikes, with the music in the background, that was the most fcking epic scene in the whole series.

  • @lucashurpia7474
    @lucashurpia7474 Pƙed 3 lety +285

    Its really interesting how much and how accurate he was able to especulate about aspects of the lore just by hearing this song. For us, Dark Souls Nerds, the implications are obvious ...but to see someone with no atachments to the series get so much right is really something! It shows how storytelling can be much more than just pictures and words, Great video!

  • @youtubewanderer3347
    @youtubewanderer3347 Pƙed 3 lety +1607

    I have a friend named Gael, and yes, i don't miss a chance to make jokes on his name

    • @draw2death421
      @draw2death421 Pƙed 3 lety +73

      Is he a Gael old Man?

    • @soldier8507
      @soldier8507 Pƙed 3 lety +374

      When u are older:
      "Hey Gael, where is your sword"
      Gael: "hand it over, that thing, your unfunny joke, for my final peace"

    • @majeszczak
      @majeszczak Pƙed 3 lety +70

      Cut his arm and ask Is this the blood? The Blood of the dark soul?

    • @majeszczak
      @majeszczak Pƙed 3 lety +30

      Worst case scenario would be if after you cut him he asked you first

    • @bungiecrimes7247
      @bungiecrimes7247 Pƙed 3 lety +33

      Hope he isn't black

  • @zompabaspleen
    @zompabaspleen Pƙed 3 lety +974

    T H I S P L E A S E S M E G R E A T L Y

    • @bluehood2077
      @bluehood2077 Pƙed 3 lety +9

      Where is the Il vento d’oro reaction?

    • @zompabaspleen
      @zompabaspleen Pƙed 3 lety +4

      Idk, that’s actually a really good one to recommend

  • @Enigma1990ad
    @Enigma1990ad Pƙed 3 lety +731

    Wait did you fight Gael? Your points on desperation, hopeless and everything being over were spot on.

    • @nyizaw8335
      @nyizaw8335 Pƙed 2 lety +17

      We are all hoping that he would fight Gael Someday.... :D That would be a perfect end to the series.

    • @hairypencilman8890
      @hairypencilman8890 Pƙed 2 lety +9

      that’s just how fitting the track is

    • @HaggisDruid
      @HaggisDruid Pƙed 2 lety +7

      Also I mean, going off name alone "slave knight" doesn't sound like Gael is having a good time haha

    • @DivineBanana
      @DivineBanana Pƙed 2 lety +1

      He hasn't played DS3 yet but it's the next game on his list. Can't wait for him to see the abyss watchers

    • @Stroimex
      @Stroimex Pƙed rokem +1

      Music is but a language, that's all

  • @enriquepelenato4956
    @enriquepelenato4956 Pƙed 3 lety +148

    He described the fight with Gael with 100% accuracy without even playing the game. FUCKING INCREDIBLE. Even his "wailing of failures" perfectly describes the failure of upheaval of civilization in Dark Souls, the end of everything and Gael's mission to deliver the blood to his niece so she can create a new world and start again. Honestly at awe at his analysis. He understands music inside and out, and also shows how great Yuka Kitamura was at trying to translate what Miyazaki was going for in music.

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +17

      Thank you so much 😄 join my Discord, link is my channel homepage đŸ‘đŸ»

    • @enriquepelenato4956
      @enriquepelenato4956 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@AtlasBenighted will do! thank you for providing great content my dude! you're a legend

  • @agentcd7806
    @agentcd7806 Pƙed 3 lety +160

    Trust me, It sounds and feels x100 times more epic when you are fighting him

  • @sverker7826
    @sverker7826 Pƙed 3 lety +247

    Oh, it is an OST for a boss battle, or rather, for THE last boss battle in the last Dark Souls 3 DLC. It is a battle at the end of the world and it is a climax of the series. The context of that boss battle is part of the reason people love this track so much.

    • @lilflax0396
      @lilflax0396 Pƙed 3 lety +9

      It took me over 20 attempts to beat him but god I loved every second of fighting him

    • @ToxicSoul03
      @ToxicSoul03 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      @@lilflax0396 yeah Gael was great, I’d drag out the fight just to hear the music.

    • @lilflax0396
      @lilflax0396 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@ToxicSoul03 I didn't have to drag out the fight. Even on my winning attempt it was still extremely long.

    • @ToxicSoul03
      @ToxicSoul03 Pƙed 3 lety +2

      @@lilflax0396his HP pool is whack

    • @ascended313
      @ascended313 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@ToxicSoul03 yeah the only one who has more HP than him is Midir(and demon prince if you are willing to count all forms)

  • @nagato1549
    @nagato1549 Pƙed 3 lety +190

    “Hand it over. That thing, your dark soul”

    • @metalwolf717
      @metalwolf717 Pƙed 3 lety +28

      "...for my lady's painting..."

    • @executioner_ecgbert884
      @executioner_ecgbert884 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      I got goosebumps just from reading it lol

    • @areallybadgamer3042
      @areallybadgamer3042 Pƙed 3 lety +2

      Imagine he tries to get up and just falls because he's too old and he ultimately has to fight you in a wheelchair.

    • @Strap89
      @Strap89 Pƙed 3 lety

      me: " yametee ojiisan!"

    • @tkyan4284
      @tkyan4284 Pƙed 2 lety

      No worries grandpa, I will take your lady

  • @MaNiHaGaming
    @MaNiHaGaming Pƙed 3 lety +112

    This guy interpreted the exact placement of this song in the game and a ton of actual game elements too just by interpreting the music. Not sure which is better, his ability to read that from the music, or the original composers for being able to convey that so well to a listener who hasn’t even played dark souls.

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +32

      Credit to the composer of course! 😄

    • @Zoinkoman135
      @Zoinkoman135 Pƙed 2 lety +5

      I thinks it’s probs a mixture of both, real recognized real after all!

  • @facundogarcia1862
    @facundogarcia1862 Pƙed 3 lety +1397

    React to Gherman OST from bloodborne

    • @arthuralves953
      @arthuralves953 Pƙed 3 lety +19

      I think heÂŽs ignoring it

    • @thewretch4081
      @thewretch4081 Pƙed 3 lety +28

      He's gonna do it one day

    • @schnozgaming989
      @schnozgaming989 Pƙed 3 lety +3

      Point up

    • @mexicanzoidburg8072
      @mexicanzoidburg8072 Pƙed 3 lety +53

      He's DEFINITELY going to do Gherman eventually. I'm pretty sure he just doesn't want to burn out on dark souls/bloodborne content.

    • @ryana1713
      @ryana1713 Pƙed 3 lety +21

      Maybe try asking nicely? Instead of demanding

  • @cinnabonbons
    @cinnabonbons Pƙed 3 lety +634

    we did it, kids 😂
    LOTHRIC & LORIAN NEXT PLEASE

  • @Psychosurgeonpls
    @Psychosurgeonpls Pƙed 3 lety +226

    "he becomes more of a threat"
    *_The Understatement of the century_*

    • @abcrx32j
      @abcrx32j Pƙed 3 lety +18

      Last boss in Bloodborne DLC second phase: Evolves and goes berserk.
      Last boss in Dark Souls in his 10th phase: Starts trying

    • @popkhorne5372
      @popkhorne5372 Pƙed 2 lety +2

      @@abcrx32j a bit like ludwig in bloodborne.

    • @destrorso2505
      @destrorso2505 Pƙed 2 lety +1

      @@popkhorne5372 you were at my side, all along...

  • @SwagatoChatterjee1
    @SwagatoChatterjee1 Pƙed 3 lety +96

    Does he know how accurate his analysis is in regards to the lore and game play of this fight. 😂

  • @actuallyjohnwick1933
    @actuallyjohnwick1933 Pƙed 3 lety +230

    Just finished the whole video, you read this track like a book atlas, Very impressive.

  • @queenvictoriann
    @queenvictoriann Pƙed 3 lety +628

    The solo female voice is actually her singing....Yuka Kitamura. She also played those fast violins in the song. Such a cool fact, honestly. That’s the type of composer I’d wanna be.
    You’re totally right about it having this heart-wrenching and lamenting quality to it and it does fit so perfectly with the Dark Souls world. Thanks for reacting!
    Here’s another vote for Gerhman’s theme. đŸȘ„

    • @Heretogasunu
      @Heretogasunu Pƙed 3 lety +15

      Pontiff Sulyvahn

    • @nefarious8278
      @nefarious8278 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      @@Heretogasunu pontiff along side of the abyss watchers are the coolest Characters in DS

    • @eliasbonafe9236
      @eliasbonafe9236 Pƙed 3 lety +4

      weren't ds3 songs made by computers?

    • @queenvictoriann
      @queenvictoriann Pƙed 3 lety +23

      @@eliasbonafe9236 They were a mix of VST instruments and live instruments. Particularly Kitamura’s songs. She sang in a ton of songs and played the violin throughout the majority of them. She also played cello and piano in some.
      The choir, percussion, bells, and string ensembles backing it all up were VSTs. (Recorded samples of live instruments)
      So, basically it’s a blend. Slave Knight Gael is a good example of this because you can clearly hear Kitamura’s voice and her layers of violin playing along with the darker male choir VSTs. It’s pretty cool.

    • @eliasbonafe9236
      @eliasbonafe9236 Pƙed 3 lety +4

      @@queenvictoriann thank you so much! Do you also know if ds3 songs has any kind of lyrics within them? Maybe just some of them

  • @Leonshearth
    @Leonshearth Pƙed 3 lety +529

    I've to admit: you were right about the overhype of Gael's soundtrack.
    I mean, it's an awesome song, but the love of Dark Souls fan for this track comes from the "overall" boss fight.
    Gael, has you deducted, has 3 phases, and the visual presentation of each of one is important: first phase Gael fights animalistic, has little reason left, like a monster. Second phase, with that crescendo of sounds, Gael reagains his sanity and purpose to fight, third phase he's struggling to contain the Dark Soul while still fighting you.
    And the second and third phase, man... The visuals matches the soundtrack perfectly: just imagine fight a monstrous giant with a big and broken sword, in a deserted and crumbling city, with him attacking relentlessly, while a storm of lighting strikes all the battlefield.
    That's the only way for me to fully experience this track.

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +202

      I think the track by itself does not translate to the hype, but I will probably get it when I play the game

    • @Leonshearth
      @Leonshearth Pƙed 3 lety +44

      @@AtlasBenighted I'm sure of that, from an epicness point of view is probably the best boss fight in the series.
      All boss themes in Dark Souls are great, but viewed in their specific contest I think, as they're, like you said, supporting role in storytelling.
      Same goes for me with Metal Gear Rising: lot of awesome tracks, that paired with their boss fights are truly good.

    • @CrimsonRayne
      @CrimsonRayne Pƙed 3 lety +19

      And gael exploding with all the souls hes collected over centuries, homing in to take your life

    • @ChipSouls
      @ChipSouls Pƙed 3 lety +17

      @@AtlasBenighted if you record gameplay or even stream yourself playing Dark Souls 3 a lot of us will come watch you play.

    • @kevinbeck8836
      @kevinbeck8836 Pƙed 3 lety +17

      One problem here, Gael doesn't regain his sanity. Starting in phase 2, he's gone hollow. Weapons such as the hollowslayer do bonus damage only beginning in this stage

  • @White-Silent
    @White-Silent Pƙed 3 lety +377

    Ok... Now, Slave Knight Gael can rest in peace.
    Guys, don't tell him to do Gherman, i think he knows.
    When the time will be coming, the first hunter will joins the void. ^^

    • @joshuagross3151
      @joshuagross3151 Pƙed 3 lety +7

      So long as he hears some of the Great Ones afterward. Gotta love those angelic chorals. The One Reborn, Living Failures, Ebrietas -- they hit you different from the hunters and the beasts. And then there's Logarius and he's just an enigma of his own.

    • @calamar8199
      @calamar8199 Pƙed 3 lety +3

      i hope he doesn't thing gehrman is like the other dark souls tracks where it's just an orchestral mess and we hype it because it sounds cool
      gehrman is like a simple painting, whereas gael is an impressive one
      of course, gael has more details, but that let's it slide away with little mistakes that often go unoticed
      gehrman however, is a simple form, but it is perfect, and one wrong stroke can ruin the entire thing

    • @White-Silent
      @White-Silent Pƙed 3 lety

      @@calamar8199 It’ll be fine, don’t worry. Even if the song does get bigger when playing the game, it will not be able to miss the fact that it is masterful.
      And even if in the end he didn’t find it so well for one reason or another and well it will only be his opinion.
      We don’t have to idolize him to the point of thinking that he has the holy word. He’s just someone who makes videos on video games ost. He has the right to have a different opinion from ours.
      And even if it may seem disappointing to us coming from someone we like, we must know how to accept everyone’s opinion.
      But I repeat, everything will be fine. ^^

    • @waltuh11121
      @waltuh11121 Pƙed 3 lety +2

      Soon, Gehrman will join the hunt...

    • @matheusmarquesjesuino3323
      @matheusmarquesjesuino3323 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@joshuagross3151 the logariu's theme Is the same theme of Queen Yharnam..the named song is "The vileblood Queen" that reforces the Idea of Pthumeru bloodline descendence in vileblood Queen Annelise , there Logarius was hiding for world not seen her, that the propose of the fight with him.

  • @gustavocarvalho8082
    @gustavocarvalho8082 Pƙed 3 lety +39

    Oh man when u first see Gael exploding with the song it really changes your life.

  • @Marcus-lg4pg
    @Marcus-lg4pg Pƙed 3 lety +81

    Slave knight Gael is especially personal to me and prob to a lot of other soul fans. Lore wise, Gael embodies the raw emotion of humanity struggling against their own fate, and thus in the middle of nowhere at the end of the world, you fight him for the dark soul. This theme gives me all sorts of feelings when listening to it, especially since it’s the last boss of the souls series. But I love it nonetheless :)

    • @marleyjr00
      @marleyjr00 Pƙed 3 lety +3

      For me Gale was the last boss. Two of history's ultimate loosers, a slave knight and one who tried and failed to link the fire, fighting at the edge of the world and the end of time for the dark soul itself. This was the apocalypse for the setting.

  • @aymeraldds9126
    @aymeraldds9126 Pƙed 3 lety +15

    that female voice is sang by Yuka Kitamura the composer herself and it always struck and gave me chills on the third phase

  • @ragenaros4475
    @ragenaros4475 Pƙed 3 lety +28

    3:32 FIRST PHASE, 5:30 SECOND PHASE !!! 7:35 THIRD PHASE ! Best Song, best boss in gaming history for me!

  • @sheep6008
    @sheep6008 Pƙed 3 lety +14

    LMAOOOO that tease with the. “It was uh.....it was...you know?........it was AWESOME!”

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +5

      😆 😆

    • @sheep6008
      @sheep6008 Pƙed 3 lety +3

      @@AtlasBenighted I was shocked when you started speaking that way, genuinely thinking. “Damn I thought the soundtrack was pretty good, what made him so displeased?” But then you switched it up right after and genuinely made me laugh. Anyways just wanted to say that your videos are fun as hell to watch and it is super interesting how you break down the different sections of the songs. Keep up the great work!

  • @johnkingsize
    @johnkingsize Pƙed 2 lety +3

    This is not a simple boss battle; this was saying farewell to a friend reaching the end of his path, and carrying his task to completion when he couldn't do it himself.
    This is a pair of warriors bonded over the same quest and absolute dedication, perfectly matching each other in a physical confrontation so that the one who failed could bestow the dark soul to the one who could yet succeed, who could, in turn, allow his friend to finally rest, having his mantle carried after his fall. And whether you succeed or fail in this fight, you feel a loss. There is no right outcome, only one when you at least leave with what you came for, at a price.
    You do not fight Gael because you want his destruction, but because you owe him a proper end after he lost his track, as a partner. You do not fight fueled with destruction, hatred or even disdain, although he has indeed fallen. Instead, you do your best to best him as a token of respect as well as to prove yourself perseverent enough to not succumb to the same peril that made him fail.
    These are two friends crossing steel at the very edge of time and space so that one can redeem the other, and the world itself, allowing the cycle of creation to start again, untainted.
    The actual world is unsalvageable, cursed by Gwyn's folly and cowardice to repeat itself, in utter defiance to the very urge to create, each time a shadow of its previous iteration until there is nobody to walk it. But the painted world can be made anew so that a new, different home can exist for those lost souls who maybe seek one.
    The ultimate encounter with Slave-Knight Gael is perhaps the deepest and most intimate scene I've lived in a video game and is certain evidence that a final adversary can not be an antagonist. If there is an antagonist in this fight, it is most likely the Dark Soul that took possession of Gael, and not the knight himself. Yet, the Soul has to be conquered and so Gael must be defeated. Such was his purpose since the beginning and it is likely that he knew it all along, hence why he recruited you in the first place and guided you on every step so that this final meeting could take place. So that Gael could retrieve the Dark Soul, be consumed by it and become its vessel so that you could then arrive, conquer it by proving your might, will and dedication and leave uncorrupted.
    Or so at least is how I interpret it.

  • @brent4151
    @brent4151 Pƙed 3 lety +40

    I think this track was hyped so much because of the context to the boss fight. As a stand-alone piece it’s still amazing, but if you incorporate the atmosphere and lore of the fight it’s becomes one of the best.

  • @Velshin1986
    @Velshin1986 Pƙed 3 lety +84

    One of the best if not the best Dark Souls theme ever. The song itself is like telling you "Farewell this is the conclusion of this awesome series"

  • @CantTreadOnMe
    @CantTreadOnMe Pƙed 3 lety +23

    Does abybodu else get goosebumbs and extremely emotional when hearing any ost from Souls and Bloodborne? Man this runs deep for me.

  • @freddydurbin6778
    @freddydurbin6778 Pƙed 3 lety +85

    GERHMAN OST PLS ITS SO GORGEOUS

  • @raul_8985
    @raul_8985 Pƙed 3 lety +29

    And if you put together the sounds of weapons, the noise of combat, the screams of Gael and the sound of swords, thunder and all ... it is impressive.

  • @probot6172
    @probot6172 Pƙed 3 lety +11

    That feeling when the phase two music hits and he is menacingly walking towards you is unmatched

  • @KevinGarcia-sy4rr
    @KevinGarcia-sy4rr Pƙed 3 lety +64

    Demon's Souls Ost- Maiden Astraea's theme. The original (Playstation 3) AND the remake version (Playstation 5). It'd be cool to see a comparison video where you do both tracks in 1 video. Also the Flamelurker Theme for Demon's Souls original, and remake is AMAZING too!

  • @ndxw
    @ndxw Pƙed 3 lety +10

    It was actually incredible watching you extract so much from just the music. Everything you said about it being the final boss in the game, the different sections corresponding to different phases of the fight, the feeling of hopelessness and clawing at life, everything was spot on.

  • @DudemitnemHut
    @DudemitnemHut Pƙed 3 lety +15

    Subtitles: *laughs*
    Subtitles: "No need to thank me"

  • @jaceholmio6200
    @jaceholmio6200 Pƙed 3 lety +266

    I can see why you think it was a little too hyped. It's not some masterpiece that is perfect in every way. It's kinda hard to get the same experience just listening as you would if you played the game and have some context. It really helps to actually see Gael and the surroundings and to know the lore behind it all. I'm sure reading most of the comments helped with that.

    • @joshuagleeson4776
      @joshuagleeson4776 Pƙed 3 lety +46

      It is a masterpiece that is perfect in every way. Maybe not as a standalone musical piece, but as the boss theme for Gael, absolutely.

    • @KeggleStomp_Pogrompa
      @KeggleStomp_Pogrompa Pƙed 3 lety +23

      It was over-hyped because we don’t know shit about music

    • @luoxis
      @luoxis Pƙed 3 lety +6

      @@KeggleStomp_Pogrompa that's the biggest problem in this comment section

    • @OljeiKhan
      @OljeiKhan Pƙed 3 lety +17

      @@KeggleStomp_Pogrompa but it is a masterpiece musically , the layers that call and respond to each other , the half step key change during the last part , the rythym , the female and male vocals that also call and respond...
      It all works together. Anyone who knows jack shit about music will most likely confirm this.

    • @danielantony1882
      @danielantony1882 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@luoxis Eeey.

  • @dillzkillz891
    @dillzkillz891 Pƙed 3 lety +73

    I can’t believe I’m not seeing more sister friede requests . Mind blowing

    • @ronbaevsky4639
      @ronbaevsky4639 Pƙed 3 lety +4

      Facts

    • @armaani11
      @armaani11 Pƙed 3 lety +4

      FAK YEAH! Sister friede and lady maria deserve some attention.

    • @Matthias_F.
      @Matthias_F. Pƙed 3 lety +3

      Return from whence thou cams't Ashen One..... Gives me PTSD that line. 😅

    • @oatmeal8673
      @oatmeal8673 Pƙed 3 lety

      Overrated theme

    • @mellamojeff458
      @mellamojeff458 Pƙed 2 lety

      because of all the ptsd we had when we saw she had a 4th form

  • @blazouille2453
    @blazouille2453 Pƙed 3 lety +76

    I don't know if i prefer Gael's actual theme, or the "transitory lands" version, both are so great.

    • @N8Bakka
      @N8Bakka Pƙed 3 lety +12

      The official track name is “For the Dark Soul”

    • @blazouille2453
      @blazouille2453 Pƙed 3 lety +6

      @@N8Bakka Do you know why is it nicknamed transitory lands?

    • @N8Bakka
      @N8Bakka Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@blazouille2453 No I don’t

    • @wezerd
      @wezerd Pƙed 3 lety +15

      The narrater called Lothric the transitory lands of the Lords of Cinder and as the arena is set thousands of years in the future it could mean that youre in Lothric but everything is ashes

    • @N8Bakka
      @N8Bakka Pƙed 3 lety +7

      @@wezerd Transitory Lands refers to the lands once ruled by each lord of cinder, not just Lothric. That’s definitely a good guess though.

  • @manuelciancarella7152
    @manuelciancarella7152 Pƙed 3 lety +20

    Gehrman is wildly considered to be at least in the top 5 OST in any Soulsborne game you might want to check It out is extremely unique

  • @Divinemakyr
    @Divinemakyr Pƙed 3 lety +17

    I literally watched every second of this 25-minute video. Damn dude.

  • @zaynekauffeld2073
    @zaynekauffeld2073 Pƙed 3 lety +17

    HE DID IT, HE FUCKING DID IT

  • @cirac800
    @cirac800 Pƙed 3 lety +10

    You described the boss fight in a single word: *PAIN*

  • @cushdaddy24
    @cushdaddy24 Pƙed 3 lety +35

    Watching Gael jump over you while shooting his crossbow with lightning crashing down and dark magic everywhere as the high vocals hit is just something else

  • @austingaw5851
    @austingaw5851 Pƙed 3 lety +46

    This song degrades into complete chaos in the third phase and that is perfect. I cried when I beat this boss man, the final fight in the entire series. At the start of the fight you are just defending yourself from Gael who recognizes you but once the dark blood drips out of Gael and he realizes that he has finally found what his mistress needed to make a world separate from the slowly dying one he resides in, a fresh start, he goes hollow (he basically becomes a pseudo zombie) and your character now has to finish off the now hollow Gael to claim the dark blood, bring it to Gael's "niece", and give humanity another chance. A beautiful and hopeful end to the series. He killed me about 20 times until I finally beat him, so worth it.

  • @UprisingGrand
    @UprisingGrand Pƙed 3 lety +5

    I’m glad that you found the time to react to Gael’s theme. Keep up the awesome reactions dude!

  • @serevine9730
    @serevine9730 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    2:47 "Everyone who can't take the plunge..."
    I see what you did there

  • @Turboman_64
    @Turboman_64 Pƙed 2 lety +11

    The reason why people praise this song so much has to do with the depth and much more so the meaning. If you one day arrive in Dark Souls 3 at this point and you have read the lore pieces along the way and understand Slave Knight Gael and you have him standing in front of you with this song kicking in you will shake from the goosebumps and simultaniously wanna cry.
    The amount of feelings that this boss fight awakens is unreal.... and that is coming from me, an emotionless brick....
    As a verry popular comment, wich can also be found in this here comment section states: "Two nobodies, in the middle of nowhere, fighting over nothing, with no one to witness it."
    Yes the comment is oversimplyfied and theres much more to it than nobodies fighting over nothing, but essentually the main thing about the entire scenery is the sense of hopelesness and despair.
    From the verry first moment you woke up in the cell in the undead asylum you persevered and fought your way through against all odds only to end up here.... and when you see it you will understand. I wont spoil no more.

  • @masondobbins8069
    @masondobbins8069 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    Great video! I really liked how you derived emotions and gameplay mechanics from the music alone.

  • @mLIIIIGHT
    @mLIIIIGHT Pƙed 3 lety +23

    Six last minutes of Hell before Heaven.

  • @rangedweevil6150
    @rangedweevil6150 Pƙed 3 lety +48

    Oh my god I've never clicked a notification so fast

  • @khajiitimanus7432
    @khajiitimanus7432 Pƙed 3 lety +22

    5:20 That false ending was hilarious - I could see that you were practically thinking, 'Oh... is that _all?'_
    And then, it just booms into action.

  • @thehollowedone5459
    @thehollowedone5459 Pƙed 3 lety +7

    That wailing is because of this in my opinion:
    Gael is the greatest hero among the humans. He went to the deepest part of hell and sacrificed everything to make a new world in which humans can finally be free from the gods, but no one will ever remember his name since no one was there to notice...

  • @jakelee8789
    @jakelee8789 Pƙed 3 lety +8

    I would also say that the weapons clashing and striking during the battle adds to the sound too, I felt it was missing some percussion in sections, but it is a battle taking place. Combined with the sound of combat it is intense for sure.

  • @LifeSpirited
    @LifeSpirited Pƙed 3 lety +3

    This is what I was waiting for and you delivered it perfectly!!! Its always that ramp up that made me fall for this song so greatly. Cant wait to see how well Gerhmans theme will do next ^^

  • @Melchiorblade7
    @Melchiorblade7 Pƙed 3 lety +14

    Great reaction! I agree completely with the wall-of-sound insight. It gives you little room to breathe or 'hide' so to speak (in a good way for the context). My favorite track in DS3 would have to be Nameless King. It's got this incredible storm motif similar to the famous storm movement from Rossini's William Tell Overture. It's ridiculous.

  • @Ivel94
    @Ivel94 Pƙed 3 lety +8

    One of the best tracks on the series. I also recommend “Father Ariandel and Sister Friede” theme. It has everything imo.

  • @thezimister1282
    @thezimister1282 Pƙed 3 lety +5

    I had no idea that one could basically understand the lore in dark souls 3 from just the last song. When he said that it could loop blew my mind since that is what dark souls 3 is about. You are trying to end the loop for good but it may just keep looping in an endless cycle.

  • @kartman8880
    @kartman8880 Pƙed 3 lety +35

    Hi Atlas. U can even watch the actual battle with the boss. Just type in "Slave knight Gael boss fight". U will soon understand how music is related to the boss, his movements, his design and the arena's design. Thank u for your efforts.

  • @Jboyk918
    @Jboyk918 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Love the detailed breakdown and analysis of each section individually. Also spot on for guessing the overarching theme for the music.

  • @BunnyCookiie
    @BunnyCookiie Pƙed 2 lety +1

    the music of each boss in this game is its own whole experience!
    so glad to see you feel the songs and read out the situations, only by listening to the music.

  • @diegoslopez1
    @diegoslopez1 Pƙed 3 lety +13

    Yuka Kitamura is just genius, she's responsible for all the best OST of Dark Souls II, Bloodborne and Dark Souls 3, Gael's soundtrack is truly a masterpiece... She's unbalanced compared to the others composers at From Software

  • @esgown4184
    @esgown4184 Pƙed 3 lety +16

    Geal starts of as an elderly Mpc who's only reason to live after the end of the world's was to get his grand daughter some paint. He himself is powerless and requires your characters help. Skip to the end of the games final dlc, where the word has turned to ashes, the gods of old are all dead, nothing remains, except your character and a red hood, a lowly Slave..
    (Basically he is a nobody who fought till the end of time dying to all the powerfull enemies of the ringed city, each time he died, he returned like your player, each life he lost, he sacrificed everything, including his sanity. Just to fulfil his grand daughters wish (even though she may already be dead by this point).
    BTW I imagen the female voice to be that of his grand daughter...

  • @DrippyGatsu
    @DrippyGatsu Pƙed 2 lety +2

    "Is this... The blood.. of the Dark Soul?"
    -Gael

  • @KaitN9
    @KaitN9 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    This video just jumped out of nowhere on my thread so I have it a look. I am very impressed by your deductions, you got the fight progress on point by just listening to the music for it.

  • @elefantemortal3704
    @elefantemortal3704 Pƙed 3 lety +20

    Just a small glimpse of Gael lore: he once was a knight in an army, an army of undead knights that where in the front line, just to clear the path and get the enemy tired, as they would never die. Then, he would search for something else to serve, as he knew that he wasnt a champion or anything like that. Then, he goes on search for the Blood of the Dark Soul, that his lady would need to paint a new world for mankind. When he finally founds it, its literally the end of the world, and you, the Ashen One and Gael, are the last two living things. And you two fight for the Blood of the Dark Soul, because Gael has gonne hollow beyong imagination, and basically becomes the darkness it self.
    Yeah, my english aint perfect but hope everyone likes reading it :)

  • @snowdrifter6187
    @snowdrifter6187 Pƙed 3 lety +3

    Gael and gwyns music fall into the category of "Its calming to start, picks up as they grow more desperate" song tells a story behind a story.

  • @glasslicker2829
    @glasslicker2829 Pƙed 3 lety

    Yesss!! You finally reacted to it!

  • @noodleborn8586
    @noodleborn8586 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    I love how you can just tell so much about Gael and the bossfight just from the music

  • @needo6295
    @needo6295 Pƙed 3 lety +3

    you are spot on with the analyses, this boss is basically always after you, after the first time you die to him he literally runs at you on all fours as soon as you walk into the area
    incredible how much info youre able to get from just the music, shows how great dark souls music is

  • @atikunchaisuekun2378
    @atikunchaisuekun2378 Pƙed 3 lety +4

    Everytime I fight gael I always turn up volume.
    The fight feels tense as hell and I LOVE it every moments.

  • @Semtexican76
    @Semtexican76 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    First time seeing your channel but I love dark souls and would love to see more videos like this where you dissect video game music and show what its trying so say, subscription from me

  • @ArtemisiaDS3
    @ArtemisiaDS3 Pƙed 3 lety +37

    Yessss been waiting for this! You know what you should totally do? Since you've reacted to so many OST from Dark souls 3, you should play it yourself to experience it and record it for youtube! The significance of this boss battle can definitely be felt in the music. Soul of cinder was the final boss of the game, but Gael was the final boss of the entire series. The one boss to end it all. The one boss to survive the end of the entire world.

    • @lubko981
      @lubko981 Pƙed 3 lety +5

      As much as I'd like to see him play the game I think it's highly unlikely since this is not a gaming channel

    • @ArtemisiaDS3
      @ArtemisiaDS3 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@lubko981 He could open a gaming channel. I'm sure it will bring him in a ton of views too! I just want him to experience the ost in real time so he can see what hes listened to.

  • @DanCoutoS
    @DanCoutoS Pƙed 3 lety +12

    Curious fact, the developers from "From Software" use the boss fight songs as a metronome on combat, so you as a player know when to evade/block the incoming attack.
    One of the hardest bosses on Dark souls 3, the Dancer of the Boreal valley, have a theme with odd compass, 2/3 if i remember right

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +3

      No waaay 😼

    • @daybreak2127
      @daybreak2127 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      3/4, but you're close. Every boss in the game except the Dancer is 4/4 or an equivalent.

  • @pedropau288
    @pedropau288 Pƙed 3 lety +4

    Regardless of how many times I died I always did a slow walk towards Gael as the music starts to ramp.

  • @justanothergamer7918
    @justanothergamer7918 Pƙed 3 lety

    I’m glad this was recommended. This is definitely a very strong track and is such a gorgeous piece.

  • @Tvanon
    @Tvanon Pƙed 3 lety +3

    Thanks for the breakdown. This song is my favorite in any game ever.
    You got everything right about what happen in the game when the song is played. Amazing.

  • @alixh.181
    @alixh.181 Pƙed 3 lety +72

    I will say Gael’s ost is kinda overrated cause while it is great just listening to it by itself doesn’t do justice to how epic it sounds in the actual fight

  • @KupriyanovKirill
    @KupriyanovKirill Pƙed 3 lety +6

    21:27 I really like how you read the meaning of the female line and perfectly translate that into game lore..

  • @adib2219
    @adib2219 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Love your energy!

  • @Therealrhyno
    @Therealrhyno Pƙed 3 lety +2

    I will watch every Dark Souls 3 OST video you make from start to finish.

  • @Gatx104
    @Gatx104 Pƙed 2 lety +3

    I'm surprised not many are mentioning Sister Friede and Father Ariandel's theme. The dual boss theme just seem to fit both their personality and disposition and the fact that there's two different themes of soft and deceptively alluring to tension inducing and intimidating just clashing with each other but still somehow remain in rhythmic harmony its almost like a controlled chaos.

  • @HarduntheRanger
    @HarduntheRanger Pƙed 3 lety +3

    The voice is absolutely the best part of this track, it's a single part counterpointing the entire mad rush. When it pauses for breath and that voice comes to the fore, it's amazing

  • @newleader5982
    @newleader5982 Pƙed 2 lety +1

    It's incredibly beautiful orchestra. Great music review brother.

  • @Robahomusic
    @Robahomusic Pƙed 3 lety +1

    You can't imagine the feeling facing Gael while this plays in the background.

    • @AtlasBenighted
      @AtlasBenighted  Pƙed 3 lety +1

      You're right, I can't

    • @Robahomusic
      @Robahomusic Pƙed 3 lety

      @@AtlasBenighted Thanks for breaking down songs near and dear to my heart.
      My own suggestions:
      Demon's Souls:
      Tower Knight Theme
      Maiden Astraea
      Sekiro:
      Corrupted Monk
      Owl (Father)
      Hollow Knight has great tracks, Hornet (Godmaster) comes to mind. For Final Fantasy Bhunivelze, God of Light. A chaotic track.

  • @hauvrichunter2488
    @hauvrichunter2488 Pƙed 3 lety +3

    The swimming analogy you used fits it perfectly. During first phase Gael's fighting style is more lazy and animalistic and you have plenty of time to heal and regain stamina but during second and third phase he becomes a nightmare to deal with that leaves you with little or no time to heal and kills you in 2 or 3 hits.

  • @waltuh11121
    @waltuh11121 Pƙed 3 lety +4

    Great video! An underrated theme of the series would be"Champion's gravetender" it is underrated as hell. Other would be "Iron Golem" or "Dragonslayer armour"

  • @Dravianpn02
    @Dravianpn02 Pƙed 3 lety

    The fact that you read the comments and take them seriously is a great thing. Thank you.

  • @gray8885
    @gray8885 Pƙed 3 lety

    You are an awesome guy man keep up the great videos!!

  • @mirko241
    @mirko241 Pƙed 3 lety +6

    Randomly recommended this, excellent analysis in my opinion. Just a wish/tip going forward, look at the character/area/context where a track is played as that plays a major part in games, movies and series compared to "normal" music

  • @daaaanteeeee5389
    @daaaanteeeee5389 Pƙed 3 lety +50

    The transitions were a bit janky because the actual version is 9 minutes long and each phase is around 3 minutes long. In that version the transitions are much more fluid.
    I think the reason people hype this song up is the boss behind it. Gael is by far the best boss in ds3 for most people, and the song is one of the main attractions alongside the fight and lore.
    Gael was once a hollow slave knight pushed forward as fodder by lothric. He was drawn into the painting of Ariendel and decided to serve the young painter who lived there. Gael needed to retrieve the dark soul as a pigment for the painting, but when he reached the ringed city, he found the pygmy lords dead. In desperation, he started drinking their dried blood in a hopeless attempt to steal the dark soul for himself. The ashen one finds him in this moment, and they fight over the dark soul. 2 nobodies, fighting for a future that doesn't exist, in the middle of nowhere with nobody to benefit. Perfection.
    Sorry for the long comment, but I felt I had to articulate the lore in all its glory.

    • @fumeknightofshovelry3901
      @fumeknightofshovelry3901 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      I'm pretty sure Gael predates Lothric?

    • @daaaanteeeee5389
      @daaaanteeeee5389 Pƙed 3 lety

      @@fumeknightofshovelry3901 maybe he does? I just saw the lore that way

    • @luciano1240
      @luciano1240 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      This song is the actual version, the 9 minutes version repeats some parts

    • @daaaanteeeee5389
      @daaaanteeeee5389 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@luciano1240 these transitions don't happen when you're fighting him though, so the 9 minute version is certainly more accurate

    • @youtubewanderer3347
      @youtubewanderer3347 Pƙed 3 lety +1

      @@daaaanteeeee5389 he didn't just find the pygmy lords, he lived for thousands of years slaying everything to get every single piece of humanity untill the end of time, where you kill him to get the Dark soul

  • @carmine2757
    @carmine2757 Pƙed 3 lety +2

    I’ve never sat down and listened to Gael’s theme. Now that I have, I can safely say it is one of my favorite tracks.

  • @-AD-Astra-0
    @-AD-Astra-0 Pƙed 3 lety +1

    Honestly, Gael's fight and theme one of my favorite. You did awesome react and review. Keep it up!