Some very pleasant sounds and absolutely extraodinary technique, but if ever the criticism of everything sounding the same within a genre could be applied...this is it
I think this stuff sounds super pleasant as a style to jam in for a few minutes, but not as a whole ass genre. I could never listen to an entire album of just that
i dont care what other peole say, i love these players and they deserve all the success they have. Ichika Nito is my favorite, far from the best but his tone and creativity are fantastic.
I think that Tim Henson does it pretty well. A lot of the Polyphia songs stick with me. A couple from Ichika too. But in a lot of cases it can feel like there's too much going on for me to really connect with it. I love the music, but I love it in a very different way to the other music I listen to
@@zmlhezmlhe4843 Its mostly major in tonality and its too "pretty". The harmonies here are totally cliche and its mainly technique driven. Have these guys heard of dissonance?
Bro, seem you're irritated by my comment, how old are you, 11/12?!? What do "pentatonic shredders" have to do with it: don't you know anything else? ? There is an infinity of other music and there are countless other players to be heard out here, who are far more versatile and exceptionally virtuosic, more than these niche shredders. Listen, look around, grow a little, broaden your mind if you can: don't stay limited.
when I hear or read those old farts (I'm only 70) saying that young generations have nothing to say or to give I remember why I don't have many friends
Iâm sorry, but this just doesnât sound musical to me at all. It sounds like someone asked an AI to write a song on guitar. Iâve heard Atari 2600 soundtracks that were more musical than this stuffâŠthen again, I also think Shawn Lane is the pinnacle of the art of electric guitar and plenty of people think Kieth Richards or Slash are the âbestâ. Thereâs no accounting for taste⊠So while this style doesnât stir my puddinâ I AM happy to know that itâs out there and that the people playing and listening have something that they love and can kinda think of as âtheirsâ like I do with guys like Lane and Lenny Breau.
All very clever but a bit boring after about 30 seconds. The last guy was quite impressive but I could only listen to him for a short while. It's still good to see people pushing the boundaries of the guitar though. Keep it up fellas đ
I absolutely admire the techniques and virtuosity these guitarists display but... Much of it sounds the same. In short: brilliant guitarists, boring to listen to.
Not sure why you guys called "math rock". I would have titled top 5 guitarist that use unconventional or hybrid techniques. Also I totally disagree with some posters who said this wasn't music or just music for the sake of technique.
In general itâs not pleasing to the ear. Stevie Ray bends one note it moves you, and it has 20 more melody than the finger gymnastics these guys are doing.
honestly I think there's Tim Henson and there's everyone else trying to copy him. Don't know though, hard progressive never been my cup of tea and all, but I guess Tim and Polyphia just made this trend a reality. Don't feel the groove help me! Get the gimmick tho
Some very pleasant sounds and absolutely extraodinary technique, but if ever the criticism of everything sounding the same within a genre could be applied...this is it
I think this stuff sounds super pleasant as a style to jam in for a few minutes, but not as a whole ass genre. I could never listen to an entire album of just that
I agree 100 % ... Give me Steve Morse for an hour any time !!! ... After first 2 I went to make coffee ! ...
A good bit of their albums have listenable songs. It's not only show off stuff like this. czcams.com/video/s8V5VtMCDV0/video.html
i dont care what other peole say, i love these players and they deserve all the success they have. Ichika Nito is my favorite, far from the best but his tone and creativity are fantastic.
No Melody that would stay with me. Leaves me cold. All amazing players.
I think that Tim Henson does it pretty well. A lot of the Polyphia songs stick with me. A couple from Ichika too. But in a lot of cases it can feel like there's too much going on for me to really connect with it. I love the music, but I love it in a very different way to the other music I listen to
They are absolutely incredible, but the style of music feels like AI generated music to me.
@@Johnnysmithy24 Hit the nail on the head
@@Johnnysmithy24 But I get the impression that may be what they intend?
@@Laurikiwi Thatâs a possibility
Tim's style seemed a lot heavier before he got all his tats. I'm also glad you put Manuel first, he really does stand apart from the rest.
MGF is the absolute goat in this genre. Happy you crowned him with the first place
Chon is so good. Groovy and tight af.
You should make a Top 5 Blues Virtuosos list. And have guys like Gary Moore, Joe Bonamassa, SRV etc
One needs a meth rock to play math rock
Guess I'll keep boomer bending....
Is really impressive, almost disturbing, watching them at moving their fingers so maniacally fast...only that they miss to make music.
is it because they are not playing the cliché pentatonic licks over a backing track while making weird faces ?
@@zmlhezmlhe4843 Its mostly major in tonality and its too "pretty". The harmonies here are totally cliche and its mainly technique driven. Have these guys heard of dissonance?
Bro, seem you're irritated by my comment, how old are you, 11/12?!? What do "pentatonic shredders" have to do with it: don't you know anything else? ? There is an infinity of other music and there are countless other players to be heard out here, who are far more versatile and exceptionally virtuosic, more than these niche shredders. Listen, look around, grow a little, broaden your mind if you can: don't stay limited.
when I hear or read those old farts (I'm only 70) saying that young generations have nothing to say or to give I remember why I don't have many friends
Iâm sorry, but this just doesnât sound musical to me at all. It sounds like someone asked an AI to write a song on guitar. Iâve heard Atari 2600 soundtracks that were more musical than this stuffâŠthen again, I also think Shawn Lane is the pinnacle of the art of electric guitar and plenty of people think Kieth Richards or Slash are the âbestâ. Thereâs no accounting for tasteâŠ
So while this style doesnât stir my puddinâ I AM happy to know that itâs out there and that the people playing and listening have something that they love and can kinda think of as âtheirsâ like I do with guys like Lane and Lenny Breau.
Thatâs exactly what I thought, it feels like AI music.
And I also fully agree on Shawn Lane, he is the one.
All very clever but a bit boring after about 30 seconds. The last guy was quite impressive but I could only listen to him for a short while. It's still good to see people pushing the boundaries of the guitar though. Keep it up fellas đ
I would thrown Charlie Robbins in there he has skills as well
Surprised you didn't mention Charles Caswell from Berried Alive. That guy is an alien
What is the name of the riff at 2:25 plsss
That was nice but i thought the riff that broke the internet is Tim Henson's one from that one polyphia song
Manuel đ
Idk but Ichika can be number 2 if you used his 2016-2017 clips
Thomas Erak is the GOAT for me.
Not necessarily the best technician, but he's like Mathcore Hendrix.
This aint music. It's sounds like lack of direction and frustration. But it does show technique though.
Word đđ»
Anyone else thinks it feels like AI music?
I think it sounds cool asf for like a moment, but Iâd never be able to listen to a full album of this.
Agreed. Most of these artists probably never get laid. They're just boring and got too much time on their hands
Next up we have our Top 5 Chemistry guitarists, Geography Guitarists, Physics guitarists and English guitarists.
You could have chose so many other examples for Tim Henson you just happened to choose the worst examples
I absolutely admire the techniques and virtuosity these guitarists display but... Much of it sounds the same. In short: brilliant guitarists, boring to listen to.
Yep
Not sure why you guys called "math rock". I would have titled top 5 guitarist that use unconventional or hybrid techniques.
Also I totally disagree with some posters who said this wasn't music or just music for the sake of technique.
The best of all in this style is Charlie Robbins and you don't even mentioned him...
I'll take Stevie Ray Vaughn for 500 Alex.
In general itâs not pleasing to the ear. Stevie Ray bends one note it moves you, and it has 20 more melody than the finger gymnastics these guys are doing.
Sounds ferry..
This sounds more like playing piano
Iâm sorry man, Tim Henson is #1 all day!
honestly I think there's Tim Henson and there's everyone else trying to copy him. Don't know though, hard progressive never been my cup of tea and all, but I guess Tim and Polyphia just made this trend a reality. Don't feel the groove help me! Get the gimmick tho
These players will be our only hope to stop A.I.!đ
Yep, AI meets their match
They have incredible talent, but Iâll be honest, I canât stand this type of music for the most part. It sounds like AI generated music to me
No thank you.
That certainly take hours and hours of practice though.
This type of guitar playing is just a mess but Tim Henson is a very melodic player and stands off from the others
Sobrevaloran a estos guitarristas. Sin duda son muy buenos y de muy alto nivel técnico. Pero aquà los elevan como que fueran el olimpo de la guitarra jajaajka .....no se comparan con los mejores guitarristas, shreders de los 90 y para que hablar de los grandes jazzistas de fusión y jazz rock....
muchos de esos son aburridisimos, literal paul gilbert,yngwie malmsteen etc son cracks pero sus composiciones son un asco solo tocan patrones y arpegios en distintas tonalidades y ya. Lo que hace grandes a estos tipos modernos aparte de la velocidad y técnicas es que eso lo aplican de una manera mas musical y melódica que esos guitarristas de antes , es decir cuando las usan tienen un contexto y sentido que forman parte de la canción
Bunch of show off trick techniques thrown together with no musicality.
Boring, its technically great and melodically rubbish....
Clever but boring
Boring af