I personally dont interpret the question as confusion but more of jarvis trying to learn what he should put his mental resources into calculating for stark. Kind of like a chat bot asking how can they help.
The entire arc that Tony has regarding his father is one of the best representation of a father-son relationship of this sort. One of my favorite arcs in the MCU current movie line up.
Agreed. He respects and has learned so much from his father, and yet it is a rocky, imperfect, broken, relatable relationship they share. It is refreshing to see a father-son dynamic that is not 100% perfect and storybook-like, nor is it 100% horrible and abusive. It becomes more interesting and insightful the more we think about it BECAUSE it is in the uncertain, gray area where real growth happens.
@@StateGenesyswell they had the technology to make the super soldier syrum, got the hold of the tesseract, managed to make a vibranium shield, and laser guns. So yeah I think they already have things that could have also scanned the tesseract.
You see the problem with the equation his father created he had to keep it a secret but on the other hand they at the time didn't have the technology capable of being able to apply that equation, knowing the next generation AKA his son would come up to create the technology leaving the stepstones behind for tony to find.
So true. His achievements were in time way before Tony when majority of the tech that's handy during Tony's time wasn't even there. He still managed to invent so much.
'Rediscovering a new element' Tony knew exactly what this was, didn't take credit for it and it goes on to show how much respect and trust he had towards his father ❤
How are you holding up? Sending strength and It’s cool your Dadd continues to show up for you like this, it’s no coincidence this video popped up the way it did.
@@W1LD_4C3s he finally visited me, and i grabbed him and said don't leave, and he said, "why not? You'll be fine." I'm still trying to figure that one out..
"I'm limited by the technology of my time. What is and always will be my greatest creation... you " I always look forward to forgetting this movie just so I can watch it again
This is something i miss from early MCU. Everything felt more, realistic isn't rhe right word, but more grounded. More avereage person. I say this as he holds a hologram i realise. But he took his dads model in a car, nowadays i feel he'd just go "Hey show a copy of Stark expo model"
I think in general I just miss when everything wasnt just “this hero now has nanotech” as much as it just was a natural progression of thw technology in the movies, it really should have stayed exclusively with iron man. But even despite that, I miss when he had clunkier iron man suits. Like you could actually feel the weight of these suits. Plus I just like the aesthetic of legit armor rather than nanoskin morph suits.
I’ve realised this watching the infinity sage back. Like the iron man suits themselves in the early films seemed realistic and I believe it could actually be real, then I get to infinity war and switch off my brain and stop thinking about it 😂
funny how humans are naturally inclined to straight edges, sharp corners, etc but the universe *gravitates* (pun intended) towards curved/round shapes. look at yourself, a flowing river, a blade of grass in the wind. neat thing i realized while exploring orders of magnitude
I think it was a particle accelerator since the entire piping was circular. He just hit a triangular piece of metal of some element, collided the two to make the new element (Badassium)
The Storyboarding artist who created this scen is out of this world. He literally studied physics, electronics and then presented it in a very simplified yet believeable format with the use of futuristic hypothetical technology.❤
I heard a theory that Howard new element he couldn't reproduce was derived from his experience working with the then ssr studying hydras weapons that were powered by the teseract, in other words Tony build his own infinity stone to power his suit going forward and that's what protects him in the first avengers movie is his synthetic teseract canceling out lokis mind stone/ magic stick
It was only until I recently watched What If that I realised this (potentially) is the atomic structure of vibranium. Would explain how Howard was able to discover it, he likely had a chunk of it left over front when he built Caps shield
The way we're going now, most new elements being discovered are only stable for actual seconds before immediately decaying to an island element (elements which are stable for years rather than seconds), we are actually on the verge of finding a new island element which has been theorized for years, it's called island of stability in the world of super heavy elements
@@josephwodarczyk977 Ok so there's a diagram that shows the stability for most atoms existent and theoretical, almost everything below Lead/82 is good (Except for 43, Technetium. There have been studies on it, and it proposes there are a second valley of stable elements after a certain number. Y'know valence electrons and how certain numbers are more stable then others? Yea there's that for atoms and shi.. And there's a certain number that is supposedly more stable than the others hence the 2nd valley
@@pixynowwithevenmorebelkanb6965unfortunately it’s probably a relative island (2 seconds before decay vs not known to decay). Bobby Broccoli did a really good analysis of Element hunting in his Ninovium Video, you should check it out
@@thegoldenatlas753 merely theorising is not enough for chemists, it's applying the knowledge and actually physically creating the element itself that is the problem
@@Melonist not really. For synthesis of new element , you need it's data or blueprint which is not made by Tony which means he did not invent it. Howard invented it. Tony synthesised it using his technology. This is like Edison. Edison didn't create shit. He just made a better filament and got named "inventor of light bulb"
No one was disturbed that when people looked into the tesseract, it rewrote something in their brain to recreate a power source / something to manage immense power kind of like in that game Dead Space where some people tried to build an ancient artifact that creates a cult and mutations.
Man I really hope we can make stuff like this eventually just because I just know how much more productive I would be if I could play around with stuff like that
I still dont understand how the city diorama didn't get damaged while it was being transported by stacking it together, inside a tight space of an open-roof car cabin speeding through windy areas.
The element he discovers or creates is called vibranium, howard stark knew about vibranium as he made the shield for captain america, but had use an alloy of vibranium and iron as the amount was less.
Tony respects and has learned so much from his father, and yet it is a rocky, imperfect, broken, relatable relationship they share. It is refreshing to see a father-son dynamic that is not 100% perfect and storybook-like, nor is it 100% horrible and abusive. It becomes more interesting and insightful the more we think about it BECAUSE it is in the uncertain, gray area where real growth happens.
I’m glad that over the course of the MCU up to phase III, Tony’s development with his relationship with his father grew over the course of multiple films starting with the first 1 talking about how absent of a father Howard was to him to Endgame where he claims he can only think of the good times with his father.
I always think about how hard it is to act like you’re doing something smart. Like the writers and actors and SFX teams had to work together very closely to make this scene even semi-believable.
It's not just straight or so called serious or method acting, it's actually all those behaviour patterns or gestures which RDJ do so casually or effortlessly that make his presence as Mr Stark so interior to watch. That's why no one can replace him not only in the Iron man but as Sherlock homes or any other roles which have such vulnerabilities. Benedict Sherlock was already perfect but RdJ Sherlock is so vulnerable abd interesting to watch, Benedict Sherlock need strong script and method acting but RDJ Sherlock need RDJ to show such little behaviours or gestures apart from scripted ones
What he doesn't realize is that that is his father's wife's work, but his father's wife's work was the tesseract... Which means Tony Stark created a infinity Stone for the new element in his Ark Reactor
If he wasn’t rich before, he would be after that. Discovering a new element like that, everything that comes after it, Stark would get complete recognition from it. His father might have helped guided him, but only Stark with the technology he had could have found it out.
Still taking me to school. Remember how mike look up at Ali ? He said he is a legend not because he is legend, he is legend because he achieve it and still walking his child to school.
Until we all figure out Tony was adopted. Which astonishes me how many people don’t actually know that. Really wish they implemented that into the movies. When he went back in time and talked to Howard I think he accidentally made the Arno stark timeline where tony never got adopted
This scene alone is why I don’t understand why people hate iron man 2 so much. It was literally a trend to hate this movie for so long. Yeah the writing is wonky in certain aspects but the Tony/Howard bit of this story was so heartfelt
" what is and and always will be.. my greatest creation is you.. "
~ Howard Stark
That was so beautiful. It gave me butterflies in my stomach lol
Fr
Read the retcon on Tony's orgins that's kinda literal.
aw his dad said that?!
@@mariakara2419iron man 2 I think, right after Nick Fury scene at the donut shop
really here I'm just impressed by the implications of Jarvis being both confused and capable of asking him what he's trying to do.
He's adaptable I guess. Also a human before :/
@@NaisanSamaTony didn't turn real life Jarvis into an AI....
I personally dont interpret the question as confusion but more of jarvis trying to learn what he should put his mental resources into calculating for stark. Kind of like a chat bot asking how can they help.
@@HouseHoldAdventuresno shit Sherlock
@@HouseHoldAdventuresoh really? How shocking...
I just think it's so impressive that rdj didn't see a single thing, yet he made it look so cool
holy crap. I never been though about that. That’s some good acting.
I think it was the other way around but still gotta give him props for the emotions 😁
guy was a drug addict. i think he knows how to see things that dont exist
Shoutout to them editors, vfx artist, they are the real hero in every superhero movies.
nah it isn't that hard, just watch enough anime
RDJ interaction with jarvis and other non-existence objects is top notch. He was born for this character.
I love his interactions with Dummy the Robot in the first Iron Man movie it's like he's talking to a real person phenomenal acting
@@johnrockyryan 💯
Dad was still teaching him beyond the grave a father's knowledge never gets done teaching his children
Also saved his life
@@Thickimus_Dank
Having a father is not cringe...
@@Thickimus_Dank
*A great father
@@croc-kun53 what can I say. He's an average fatherless kid
@@krishnachoubey8648 Why is it a thing to make fun of fatherless kids when it's their dad who died or left them
The entire arc that Tony has regarding his father is one of the best representation of a father-son relationship of this sort. One of my favorite arcs in the MCU current movie line up.
Agreed. He respects and has learned so much from his father, and yet it is a rocky, imperfect, broken, relatable relationship they share.
It is refreshing to see a father-son dynamic that is not 100% perfect and storybook-like, nor is it 100% horrible and abusive. It becomes more interesting and insightful the more we think about it BECAUSE it is in the uncertain, gray area where real growth happens.
I just realised and remembered his father built captin America shield so he knew about vibranium
And he scanned the tesseract too and got that data to analize for years
Me to bro at the same time
E too
@@danielvazquez3885he scanned it with what? They didn’t have the technology yet.
@@StateGenesyswell they had the technology to make the super soldier syrum, got the hold of the tesseract, managed to make a vibranium shield, and laser guns. So yeah I think they already have things that could have also scanned the tesseract.
@@TomJezhuZCruiz If not scanned, than Analysed and tested
You see the problem with the equation his father created he had to keep it a secret but on the other hand they at the time didn't have the technology capable of being able to apply that equation, knowing the next generation AKA his son would come up to create the technology leaving the stepstones behind for tony to find.
If he left it around in laymen’s terms someone else would’ve got to it first hence why he did this. Knowing his son would figure it out
@@nyankittyxp4521 exactly 💯
"my greatest creation is you"
Holy run-on sentence, bat man
The world has a lot of brain power, so somebody would of figured something like that out 10 years after his death.
"Death for almost twenty years, still taking me to school " Tony Stark. Tells how much intelligent his father Howard Stark is.
So true. His achievements were in time way before Tony when majority of the tech that's handy during Tony's time wasn't even there. He still managed to invent so much.
Yeah man that's what the video tells us
Dead internet theory
Dead
and he uses rediscover honoring his fathers discovery first
"Dead for almost 20 years. And still taking me to school."
Damn, isnt that the most badass line about dad ever?
*stark driving down the road with 4 massively oversized sticks of ram*
He probably downloaded those. x'D
@@natomiltary4573i downloaded an extra 32gb yesterday, now i doubled my montors pixels
Thats his company model
'Rediscovering a new element' Tony knew exactly what this was, didn't take credit for it and it goes on to show how much respect and trust he had towards his father ❤
I lost my dad last Friday... the things my dad taught me and is still teaching me have been absolutely amazing for my life.. love you dad
❤
My condolences. 👐
How are you holding up?
Sending strength and It’s cool your Dadd continues to show up for you like this, it’s no coincidence this video popped up the way it did.
@@W1LD_4C3s he finally visited me, and i grabbed him and said don't leave, and he said, "why not? You'll be fine." I'm still trying to figure that one out..
He loves you too ♥️
That's nothing, my daddy taught me how to crush beer cans with my forehead, and how to chase tail!
Now you have head hurt and a abused dog
@@leonmlinaric4608He was joking
I just do it in one hand
And tony didn't need to be taught
@@leonmlinaric4608/whoosh. They were both joking
>go to Walmart
>buy potato
>buy butter
>buy bacon
>combine at home
>"walmart.. you crafty minx.."
How could you forget the grated cheese?
Seriously...
1. CZcams shorts commenter realizes how genius his father was
No entiendo la broma.
🤔
I don't get it...
Javis' voice is so clam. It's like" Sir. You just discover a new element...and we also run out of toilet paper."😅
"I'm limited by the technology of my time. What is and always will be my greatest creation... you "
I always look forward to forgetting this movie just so I can watch it again
OMG SAME! It's been a while since I've watched them, so I might do that again, just once I've finished watching the defenders series.
This is something i miss from early MCU. Everything felt more, realistic isn't rhe right word, but more grounded. More avereage person. I say this as he holds a hologram i realise. But he took his dads model in a car, nowadays i feel he'd just go "Hey show a copy of Stark expo model"
I think in general I just miss when everything wasnt just “this hero now has nanotech” as much as it just was a natural progression of thw technology in the movies, it really should have stayed exclusively with iron man. But even despite that, I miss when he had clunkier iron man suits. Like you could actually feel the weight of these suits. Plus I just like the aesthetic of legit armor rather than nanoskin morph suits.
I’ve realised this watching the infinity sage back. Like the iron man suits themselves in the early films seemed realistic and I believe it could actually be real, then I get to infinity war and switch off my brain and stop thinking about it 😂
True. Its because they made Tony Stark as a normal human guy with ups and downs. They left this mindset with other movies.
@@4Core100this is such a wierd phenomenon. Power creep in a movie saga
noticed this stark difference (pun intended) between iron man movies and every other MCU movies, the black panther movies especially
“So that means the nucleus would be here”. In the center. He truly is a genius.
I bet he knows what the powerhouse of a cell is
@@ilbro7874chondriamito!!
Howard knew Tony could figure out what he could not... incredible foresight.
Wish we had this tech in the modern world
Apple Vision Pro is pretty close to this
True
@@SausageRollEnjoyerhahaha no. Not even close.
Let's be honest it would be used for porn or by v tubers
@@kuratse205close enough tho
funny how humans are naturally inclined to straight edges, sharp corners, etc
but the universe *gravitates* (pun intended) towards curved/round shapes. look at yourself, a flowing river, a blade of grass in the wind.
neat thing i realized while exploring orders of magnitude
Maybe because edges and corners seem more tangible while curves rounded surfaces seem almost abstract.
And as a matter of fact he created this element with laser beams and pipe wrenches. What a guy.
I think it was a particle accelerator since the entire piping was circular. He just hit a triangular piece of metal of some element, collided the two to make the new element (Badassium)
The Storyboarding artist who created this scen is out of this world. He literally studied physics, electronics and then presented it in a very simplified yet believeable format with the use of futuristic hypothetical technology.❤
I heard a theory that Howard new element he couldn't reproduce was derived from his experience working with the then ssr studying hydras weapons that were powered by the teseract, in other words Tony build his own infinity stone to power his suit going forward and that's what protects him in the first avengers movie is his synthetic teseract canceling out lokis mind stone/ magic stick
Wow, thats a very cool theory and explains why Loki couldnt use the mind stone powers on Tony
Iirc the "new" element was vibrainium
@@kamuikadet6538no it's not
It was only until I recently watched What If that I realised this (potentially) is the atomic structure of vibranium. Would explain how Howard was able to discover it, he likely had a chunk of it left over front when he built Caps shield
Iirc this element was the product of his study of the tesseract
a movie on his 'father' would be great
We should start a petition
Ending at the Winter Soldier part
He casually said he was rediscovering a new element like he does it regularly
YES ADD MORE MUSIC I LOVE OVERLAPING MUSIC
It's to prevent copyright ban from Marvel
the sound of that v10 will always make me happy
For me, the most inspiring scene of the trilogy, creating a new element to support your build n blast from past Wow!
The way we're going now, most new elements being discovered are only stable for actual seconds before immediately decaying to an island element (elements which are stable for years rather than seconds), we are actually on the verge of finding a new island element which has been theorized for years, it's called island of stability in the world of super heavy elements
How the hecc would that work? Don't electrons just always want personal after a certain point? Why would that stop?
@@josephwodarczyk977 Ok so there's a diagram that shows the stability for most atoms existent and theoretical, almost everything below Lead/82 is good (Except for 43, Technetium. There have been studies on it, and it proposes there are a second valley of stable elements after a certain number. Y'know valence electrons and how certain numbers are more stable then others? Yea there's that for atoms and shi.. And there's a certain number that is supposedly more stable than the others hence the 2nd valley
@@pixynowwithevenmorebelkanb6965unfortunately it’s probably a relative island (2 seconds before decay vs not known to decay). Bobby Broccoli did a really good analysis of Element hunting in his Ninovium Video, you should check it out
@@pixynowwithevenmorebelkanb6965And we haven't found the target proton/electron/neutron amounts for this yet?
@@thegoldenatlas753 merely theorising is not enough for chemists, it's applying the knowledge and actually physically creating the element itself that is the problem
His father had the same level of brains, just didn't have the same level of tools to use 😊😂
Fun fact : your Childs Will have 5 IQ when he grow up, more smarter than yours right now.
“i’m rediscovering a new element” is such a hard line 😭
So just remember. Tony didn't create a new element. Howard did. Tony just rediscovered it and made it using his engineering skills
In general, the person who synthesises an element is considered to be its discoverer.
@@Melonist not really. For synthesis of new element , you need it's data or blueprint which is not made by Tony which means he did not invent it. Howard invented it. Tony synthesised it using his technology.
This is like Edison. Edison didn't create shit. He just made a better filament and got named "inventor of light bulb"
Did you even hear him? He specifically said'I'm Rediscovering a new element'
@@RahulSharma-vp1fv many people say Tony literally created the element not giving Howard any credit and talking like Tony is master mind.
This is vibranium
Meanwhile my dad: "Pull my finger son"
And U r his son!! What do you expect!!?😂😂
The fact that even the AI needed to ask him wtf he was doing lmao
No one was disturbed that when people looked into the tesseract, it rewrote something in their brain to recreate a power source / something to manage immense power kind of like in that game Dead Space where some people tried to build an ancient artifact that creates a cult and mutations.
Dominic Cooper and John Slattery really made the character of Howard Stark lovable especially in the later movies and agent carter
I'm impressed that the writers thought about this
Man I really hope we can make stuff like this eventually just because I just know how much more productive I would be if I could play around with stuff like that
Rdj in these high visual effect scenes always looked so fucking cool
Love that they had him say rediscover instead of discovering a new element
I still dont understand how the city diorama didn't get damaged while it was being transported by stacking it together, inside a tight space of an open-roof car cabin speeding through windy areas.
really good glue lol
@@thelseemsus6020 I mean, in a universe where superheroes exist and aliens speak perfect english, this is a valid reason lmao
That additional music is really throwing this off
The element he discovers or creates is called vibranium, howard stark knew about vibranium as he made the shield for captain america, but had use an alloy of vibranium and iron as the amount was less.
Played the part so well cause he played his self .. never will be repeated. He deserved this come back as well
man this is probably his dads way to make sure the kids his and his wife didn't cheat like "if you cant even solve this your not my kid"
Dude, take a break from the internet, you are severely contaminated
why was that ur first thought you fuckin weirdo 💀
I'm more impressed on how the model fitted and didn't broke in the car during the entire ride
He is such a great actor.🐐
This scene was always my favourite
“Even Dead, I’m The Hero”
E. D. I. T. H.
This element is an infinity stone.
He would look so silly without the effects.😂
Especially when he enhanced the round thing lol (element?)
Imagine your father somehow STILL saving your life even though he's been gone for 20 years
Parents are awesome❤
Am i the only one who wishes Tony got a chance to just sit down and talk with his dad man to man?
Kinda like how Thor did with his mom.
Tony respects and has learned so much from his father, and yet it is a rocky, imperfect, broken, relatable relationship they share.
It is refreshing to see a father-son dynamic that is not 100% perfect and storybook-like, nor is it 100% horrible and abusive. It becomes more interesting and insightful the more we think about it BECAUSE it is in the uncertain, gray area where real growth happens.
I’m glad that over the course of the MCU up to phase III, Tony’s development with his relationship with his father grew over the course of multiple films starting with the first 1 talking about how absent of a father Howard was to him to Endgame where he claims he can only think of the good times with his father.
That hologram computer system alone is crazy.
The rediscovering show his respect to his father
y’all are missing the part where he hid the element in the EXPO
In conclusion, tony had the Space Stone in his chest the whole time.
"Dead for 20 years, still taking me to school" - a proud son said
I like how human the AI in Marvel are except Friday. Jarvis and Ultron were literally one of a kind since they are able to be confused or angry.
the world knew how genius he was long before tony was even born...
“Shall I include the Belgian waffle stands?”
I always think about how hard it is to act like you’re doing something smart. Like the writers and actors and SFX teams had to work together very closely to make this scene even semi-believable.
Imagine he gets into even a minor accident and ruins the model completely before being able to have Jarvis scan it
Geniuses from the past are 💯 more reliable and we should learn from them the most
You are now not stark, you are doom to us
This music fits so well lmao, only time it has enhanced the video tbh
Honestly its impressive tony was able to do this while his arc reactor was posioning him
It's not just straight or so called serious or method acting, it's actually all those behaviour patterns or gestures which RDJ do so casually or effortlessly that make his presence as Mr Stark so interior to watch. That's why no one can replace him not only in the Iron man but as Sherlock homes or any other roles which have such vulnerabilities. Benedict Sherlock was already perfect but RdJ Sherlock is so vulnerable abd interesting to watch, Benedict Sherlock need strong script and method acting but RDJ Sherlock need RDJ to show such little behaviours or gestures apart from scripted ones
"I am limited by the technology of my time"
Dead for almost 20 years, and still taking me to school.
So amazing to think that Howard Stark saved his son even after he (Howard) was dead.
I love how bro has an R8 spyder and shoves the equipment on the passenger side
That element made him millions in the jewelry business😂
"should i include the Belgium waffle stands?"
Jarvis
If this scene actually use the backsound, it will feel crazy 🎉
The vfx artists were just too good look at the visuals man damn 💀
Terrence Howard’s been watching this and thought he too can rediscover the periodic table 😂
What he doesn't realize is that that is his father's wife's work, but his father's wife's work was the tesseract... Which means Tony Stark created a infinity Stone for the new element in his Ark Reactor
I think he ended up naming the new element something “badassadium”or whatever which I think is “badass” and hilarious 😂😂😂
This is what Tony ends up putting in him for his power source right?
That means dad saves his son’s life from the grave. That’s badass. 🤯
Hearing Vision's voice is just amazing.
Thanks dad .
wish my dad was proud enough to say that to me like how Howard said to his son Robert
Seems like yesterday when little me assumed this scene would be only happen in the far future. Now GPT makes me feel like this everyday 🤣.
If he wasn’t rich before, he would be after that. Discovering a new element like that, everything that comes after it, Stark would get complete recognition from it. His father might have helped guided him, but only Stark with the technology he had could have found it out.
Still taking me to school. Remember how mike look up at Ali ? He said he is a legend not because he is legend, he is legend because he achieve it and still walking his child to school.
I’m surprised all the little buildings didn’t go flying when he drove with it in his car lol
“Dead for almost 20 years and Still taking me to school”
average 2024 chat gpt experience:
Until we all figure out Tony was adopted. Which astonishes me how many people don’t actually know that. Really wish they implemented that into the movies. When he went back in time and talked to Howard I think he accidentally made the Arno stark timeline where tony never got adopted
your vocals and singing is so good and you are so beautiful ❤❤❤
This scene alone is why I don’t understand why people hate iron man 2 so much. It was literally a trend to hate this movie for so long. Yeah the writing is wonky in certain aspects but the Tony/Howard bit of this story was so heartfelt
He says. I'm limited by the tech of his time and I'm thinking.
"Just make it?"
And yet he was more pissed about Bucky killing his mom
At this point Jarvis is just unrestricted chatgpt 4o....( Which already exists)