I first heard her opera performance when I was 10 years old.She was the best in Cantonese opera in HK and Canton.Her skill in singing was TOP unfortunately she was purged during the cultural revolution in 1965 and went through a difficult period. She was a country Treasure and recognised through out China.I still enjoyed watching her recorded performances.She died 4 or 5 years ago.
新馬有獨特唱腔，亦非常好聽！兩大老倌，後無來者！
祥哥一句 " 天意茫茫 " , 用京腔腦後音發聲，獨步天下
難得兩位 粵劇大老倌 重逢演出 胡不歸 相信我哋 呢 輩 未曾 欣賞過 他們 的演繹 最感遺憾 任 姐 已退休 若然 能夠 欣賞到 幾位 粵劇大老倌 的當年 藝術演繹 是多麼的 有眼福 幸好 今天 在螢幕上 能夠 欣賞 他們 遺留的 藝術 演繹 好感謝
任姐已升仙三十多年啦
祥哥唱腔一絕，聲哥造藝不差但聲線較弱，情感補足；個人覺得如以目前網上所載三位文武生的折子戲片段而論，以大碧姐的反串演出令人驚喜，唱做俱佳，唱腔婉轉和諧，情感自然流露。
Hong opera is good .
She had a beautiful vocal and her diction clear.
She and Sun both give excellent performance.
Worth watching.
經典之經典,兩位大老倌的唱做,確實已是登峰造極之境.
Thefloweregg ,'and
往事只能回味，留聲在世，可惜人千古！
I first heard her opera performance when I was 10 years old.She was the best in Cantonese opera in HK and Canton.Her skill in singing was TOP unfortunately she was purged during the cultural revolution in 1965 and went through a difficult period. She was a country Treasure and recognised through out China.I still enjoyed watching her recorded performances.She died 4 or 5 years ago.
Hong seen Leui
Pass away of age 90 years old of heart failure in hong kong saturday. and i like her performance when i was grown up.
走咗个登徒表少，入咗个咁呒老公，祥哥演成咁，真係激到薛觉先会弹反起身！
唉, 我和家母於16-12-2013前往[香港新光戲院]追悼[女姐]....行入大劇場, 看見臺中擺放著[女姐]於去年21-5-2013贈予[新光戲院]之真跡~[新光]兩字...
我隨著特首[梁振英]先生於較早前書上''沉痛哀悼''輓句之後兩頁....書寫了整版弔唁字句; 當時, 我的心很酸...
5
0 . k
王昀浚
做這㘯戲的時候，兩位老倌應該唔細，樣子巳經変了，好彩聲缐還不錯，還能記曲，不簡單，紅缐女是沒什麼做手，係感情加分
Lee Annie f
紅線女手勢十分細膩，恰到好處，大師級。
粵劇做手不可隨便,要看情況,紅線女的身段做手很有手平,不信看看搜書院.
红线女同新马仔的胡不归几时唱的？好喜欢红腔。三十几年前只有罗家宝，林小群唱的版本。
紅線女和林家聲唱嘅胡不歸仲好聽呀👍👍👍
觉得新馬師曾做得好难看。。。
新馬師曾做得唔错，有点扭离。
聲到情唔到係新馬師曾的不足，演得亦难看，不单不能把阿平的儒雅又英气演出，話晒阿平都係一位将軍黎架，反而有些猥瑣。
對呀！一啲都冇将大將軍的風格演繹出來。
慰妻戲場乃文場戲，別妻係武場，亂嗡廿四，扮專家。如此戲迷，粤劇悲哀！
無戲迷覺得新馬師曾猥瑣，是否你猥瑣覺得新馬師曾猥瑣？