National Identity Should Be Part of Education | Katharine Birbalsingh
Vložit
- čas přidán 24. 06. 2024
- This is a clip from yesterday's podcast episode with Katharine Birbalsingh. In it, she and Dr. Peterson discuss national identity and it's importance for the development of cohesion in a multicultural society.
Dr. Peterson's extensive catalog is available now on DailyWire+: bit.ly/3KrWbS8
ALL LINKS: linktr.ee/drjordanbpeterson
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life: jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
#JordanPeterson #JordanBPeterson #DrJordanPeterson #DrJordanBPeterson #DailyWirePlus
I am a homeschooling mom in Virginia. I have been devouring her material since the first clip posted. I am blown away. Thank you for introducing her to me. I hope one day I can feel comfortable sending my kids to school.
I never sent my kids to school. I taught them until they finished 12th grade. We even had a graduation ceremony for them. Their friends came over.
Remember when the dem rep lost an election after he said y’all shouldn’t have say over what kids learn? Funny times
@@prouddegenerates9056 I don't, it's still occuring.
@@prouddegenerates9056 i think that was terry howeveryouspellhislastname when he ran for governor. i'm glad we didn't get him again cuz he sucks.
@@roman111117 true. school board members are mainly democrats so who the governor is doesn't matter that much. at least, it looks like that to me. i could be wrong.
In the USA, many teachers stopped saying the pledge of allegiance bc of the word "God" and others bc of the flag's association with military power. The only place I taught where the pledge was daily, by all classrooms (and all faculty were told to stop work to participate) was a county with a military base.
My private Catholic school did pledge of allegiance
Teachers that would act that way need to be sent back to remedial constitution training. 🇺🇸
Funny. I heard from an Orthodox that signs of Possession includes fear or Sacred Icons and such.
To refuse the Pledge of Allegiance because of the word God makes it sound like they are demonically Possessed.
Instant gratification has hurt a lot,also the participation trophies...that crowd is definitely showing up more every day 😂
yeah i hate capitalism too!
Suggesting the teaching of identity is a mortal sin now days. Identity informs duty and duty informs morality. When identity is fluid, so is morality...everything breaks down.
Which is why we should teach about gender identity in kindergarten... 😅
Well put
Or rather, a rigid limited identity adopts a morality that serves to protect only that identity, at the cost of all other identities (when push comes to shove), whereas a Universal identity elicits an unrestricted sense of commonality and shared humanity towards all.
Actually well put haha! I would even say that all these results show because we are afraid to even define what identity is ('it can be anything right.......'). Let's not even talk about duty because that is a sin nowadays: 'having to do something! so authoritarian!
@JahtotheRod has just as 'Enlightened' and enlightening a perception as the person Jahto responded...
Both, applied *together* in a way as to augment each other, will help each and every family, group, town, region, county, state, region, territory, country, continent, hemisphere, social class, ethnicity, nationality, religion, gender, age, and many other 'qualities' or 'features' that too many of us 'utilize to separate' *'them' from 'us'* ...
Each of us can help everyone of to do better by understanding the others of us...
My mother, a strong advocate for teaching profession as a teacher, a principal and lecturer, would have been very pleased with Katharine!
In many major Canadian cities, the Pride flag is more common than the Canadian flag
It is in Dublin as well.
and here in America:
“where’d all the American flags go? remember when people would hang those? they’ve all been replaced by blm flags or a rainbow.” - Tom MacDonald
sad 😔
The Freedom Convoy of 2022 was actually first time in a long time where Canadian flags were seen in abundance in public
I agree, teaching well is so hard. I sometimes believe that teaching can't be taught
We need this in the US
Cultural Marxism masquerading as patriotic pride?
Pushing collectivist, statist group identification on children is reprehensible. You do realize this gypsy was part of the Socialist Workers Party, right?
Is anyone surprised that cultural Marxism is coming out of The Daily Israeli?
She read The Living Marxist magazine in college.
It’s funny, a lot of ppl nowadays will say it’s anti American to teach national pride. Not knowing it’s American values that allow for you to even feel that way.
"Allow"? Care to repeat yourself, tyrant?
Pride is not equivocal with Values.
Pride comes before the fall, it is empty self-esteem
American Nationalism is empty, yet esteemed highly
What truly, is nationally "American"? Well, the States, and the People are. Do they have a singular identity? No.
I don't have to share your value of what's "American". All we have to do, to be good neighbors, is to respect each others' property and God-given rights, and to be reciprocal in our dealings.
We need this in England because it has a rich history but nothing is made official like the idgionus people, national dress ect is either not taught or changed completely and it's so upsetting... make a separate video on the English please
Very valid point mate! Respect needs to be paid to actual Englishman. There’s few these days in the major cities as we real immigrants or have French or Irish ancestry. Since the cities are the major drivers of cultures we ended up here
England has an amazing history that should be celebrated. This is coming from an American.
As if the English aren't indigenous and have no culture of their own. Though I do believe a big part of English culture is enjoying other cultures. They found artifacts from the celtic era in England that were replicas of a style found in france. I can imagine a del boy of the day making knock of La Tiene vases.
No, England will become and has almost become a global state, no one is getting traditional England again.
Living a life of dignity✨️🙌🏻✨️ now that's teaching!
Should be heard by the Germans, where the police is not allowed to put German flag pins on their uniform during the football championship, so they don't appear too German...
If their government keeps up those shenanigans and things go bad in that country, they should not be surprised to see the black, red and yellow turn into black, white and red.
it is because we germans are supposed to hate ourselves because of WW2. Very sad our politicians hate us germans, we need some new leaders who love their own kind
eins zwei drei hier kommt die polizei !
while it's totally normal that the german police has some rainbow coloured cars and in front of every gov't building hangs a 5meter tall rainbow flag
nothing against rainbow people per se, but germany definitely has a sick relationship to its own national culture
@thormanray9090 no wonder, if nobody teaches our kids to be proud to be German that now other nationals press in with no incentive to integrate or become German in their heart and appreciate Germany for their values. I didn't learn to be proud being German, I just was! But that is different with immigrants. You can only replace nationality and values with better & convincing values. But we fail on that, so do most other European Countries.
Working in London:
I can say: We need this right through the Commonwealth!
"Being a teacher is harder than being a pilot..."
Me, knowing well that pilots would absolutely obliterate teachers in their profession if they were also teaching.
I agree with this, but believe it applies to anyone teaching a trade skill they have experienced and mastered.
That’s not what she said… you missed her point.
Dude. When you deal with People especially kids, than a Machine becomes your best friend.
In Scotland we get to be quite openly pro Scotland especially with football but it's a shame the English don't get to do that and those that do are considered louts or bigoted. It must pent up. I wonder if that's connected with the hooliganism.
Teachers used to be predominately men, not women in England, contrary to her assertions. Those men have largely disappeared with the advent of the further education of women which used to be considered a waste because no one expected women to follow a career
@@pcka12not true. I was born mid fifties. There seemed to be as many female as male teachers in state school. More women than men in a girls school I also went to
@@SSmith-dn9ib I was talking about a far longer period than that encompassed by the world wars of the 20th century, suffrage & birth control made major differences from the 1920s onwards yet we know that literacy was widespread at the time of the Civil Wars triggered by Charles the first.
My mother attended a 'maid's' school (run unsurprisingly by 'maids') but by 1944 was a commissioned officer in the ATS which was something completely inconceivable by previous generations (her father was fearful for her when she told him that she was going to OCTU).
@@pcka12 oh ok I get you.. agree . My mother-in law studied to be a MD which was rare in the forties. Here too, in the EU where I am now .
I had a female GP decades ago who would have been even older than my mother in law at the time as she was nearing retirement. If she ever retired! She was also a homeopath and interested in everything.!
She was one of the best GP' 's we ever had but we moved so lost her!
@@SSmith-dn9ib well remembered taking my mother to the funeral of a family friend who was the daughter of a friend of my grandmother the younger lady was by then in her nineties and had retired from work as a GP when the NHS was introduced because she felt it would prevent her treating her patient with the care she believed appropriate - she saw medicine as a vocation rather than a job.
Very Informative!!! Thank You for creating and broacasting!
I just finished the Daily Wire section and I’m so glad I did give the interview a chance. I had my reservations and still do but I believe in hearing people out, and I find that Katharine is rather a kindred spirit to me. I do think a bit of wise humility would do her no harm but that is true of every one of us, every day of our lives. And perhaps a bit less brash “I am right and you are all wrong” would be a sign of that wise humility but goodness knows we are all learning that. My besetting sin is excessive humility which I very well know is a form of pride and hubris. I fight against it every day because it is just as distorting to the judgement and our ability to answer the calling wherewith we are called as excessive hubris. But my lack of confidence makes me vulnerable to overly confident people like Katharine and I think I know myself well enough to know that is why I struggle with her presentation so much. I do agree on most points but not all because what a dull world it would be if we all agreed on everything.
I don’t talk about how I parent my kids, I just parent my kids, and let them be my living epistles to speak to whether I am doing a good job or not.
The best bit for me is seeing how moved Dr. Peterson was by his experience at the school and how that stayed with him. That made me so happy.
With Ruth Anne’s love ❤
This is one amazing women...!!! Nuff Respect to her for what she has done for the kids at her school, and the wider society...
I got so much respect for Jordan Peterson. Learned so much from him.
Great Britain = So successful of a Nation that we speak English everywhere all over the world, from Melbourne to Las Vegas to Cape Town. English is a magnificent language we should all take pride in it. It's so intellectually lazy to chalk everything up to imperialism.
Certainly not only children but every individual must have a Strong Personal Identity...
I’m a male airline pilot with only a highschool education. Just got absolutely cooked 😂
It sounds similar to a school here in San Diego California that was called John Muir Alternative School. K-12, it was a wonderful school with not a curriculum but we were a somewhat of a giant family learning together. Everyone went on every field trip, everyone was involved in all of the art projects, everyone was involved in the Arts. It was a wonderful time to be a child
Kids crave order and discipline. They respect their parents more when they get that which leads to a dope relationship in adulthood. It’s sad that more people don’t understand this, what a fascinating interview!
Watching the England v Denmark game unfortunately ended up as a form of detention.
Hello Doc Peterson, I wanted to ask you if you could interview Schwerpunkt on the topic. It's time we need to start talking history and the history of Tradition, especially in a Transatlantic perspective. It seems to me that the American conservative space is completely ignoring the original European history in order to appreciate Tradition and religion and their fullest.
Excellent point. A lot of American conservatives have a dismissive, ungrateful attitude towards European history, not realizing that there could be no USA without Europe, particularly England. We all rightly jump to the defense of our Founding Fathers, but far too many sit on the sidelines when the mob attacks or appropriates someone like Shakespeare. Megan McCain once called Meghan Markle a great American patriot for bullying and humiliating the late Queen Elizabeth. This is philistine behavior that we can no longer tolerate.
Should be rolled out to every school in the UK. How it was in the 90's.
I like it that you bring all kind of topic. Thank you from 2 psychology students. We also started a psychology channel and we do researh, hoping to one day know as much as you do.
I'd love to learn Canadian National Identity once I establish myself in there! ✊
what happens when you start adding other random words before identity... like racial identity, or cultural identity... As an older south African, the Identity of what is the norm and what is the government has changed 180 degrees in my lifetime.
I'm just a normal human. I don't care that much about country or even god or whatever. I believe in doing good, helping others, and I get punish almost everytime, some people always take advantage.
You dont believe in God er whatever. And your out just doing good without a pat on the back. No parade er nothing. If no one has told you yet. Good job
Your channel bio says you’re in Japan, which from my impression seems to be a country with strong sense of cultural identity. Here in the west however, I think many countries have issues regarding lack of national/cultural identity, so I think what was discussed in the video is important and relevant to us.
@heidi22209 the giving hand should not be seen by the needy
@@ryanside7095 I used to live in Japan for about 7 years. Now I'm in TaiWan. Due to my job I love to talk to people, observe and learn. I traveled to some place and I think people are the same all over the world, people have same struggle in Japan, in China, in Europe. I can see the same phenomenon in too many places. And to be honest, 20 years ago I think western country is great, now I don't think so. I do hope you guys there will get better, and be great again.
The point made at the end about 'all you're good at is exams' is because so many schools teach their kids in the UK to pass exams and keep them up the league tables. Actually educating the mind comes a distant second. Seems like she's doing both pretty nicely.
“The actual history of every country is full of shabby and even shameful doings. The heroic stories, if taken to be typical, give a false impression of it and are often themselves open to serious historical criticism. Hence a patriotism based on our glorious past is fair game for the debunker. As knowledge increases it may snap and be converted into disillusioned cynicism, or may be maintained by a voluntary shutting of the eyes… The stories are best when they are handed on and accepted as stories.” - C.S. Lewis
Trying hard to “like” and YT won’t let me. Love this!
"Odd" and "live in your heads"... I think eccentric and cerebral were the words she was looking for. All the best (classic) academics and philosophers fit this pattern.
Leave ground bare, weeds grow. And once they take root its painful to remove. Canadian classrooms leave bare ground.
I do agree from an ideological point of view, that you need to teach children what to think, especially in the home because I do not think school's should be the place where children become who they are meant to become. Schools should be iron to sharpen who parents have created. But you must also teach them HOW to think.
Your children will not live in a vacuum and will have to make decisions. And so, after you have taught them what to think application is a must. My son learned essay writing and the way it was taught in the early years was that the teachers told them what to write (what to think) and they were asked to reproduce. However, when they were tested, and topics varied, my son found it hard to apply. I decided I was going to teach him HOW to think and now connections were able to made and he moved above his peers because he was not only able to reproduce, which is a lower capability, he was able to create. And not create in a leftist domain but in the space of the ideologies me as a parent has created.
Be careful in saying teachers tend to be on the left. My question is where? Maybe Europe and America but there are many places where they are not. Some teachers tend to be on the left. Not all. You have good ideas ma'am, the tone of your school is great but be open because iron sharpens iron. You can add to your strength by listening to others.
Teaching children how to think doesn't mean they will lead, as a matter of a fact, they understand how to respect authority much better. I am a strict disciplinarian but I believe you must follow God's example, He is God and he still lets us choose him.
So bring up the child in the way it should go, yes but God also says to children to obey your parents in the lord, So he is aware that children will make decisions at some point, and you want that when they do, it is the right one. Freedom and how to think are two different things as well. I need to know, that when I am not there, and good and bad choices are presented to my children, that they make the right choice.
My son recently completed the common entrance exam and has passed for the top school in my country. He doesn't have a phone, he has a bed time, he is punished for any infractions, he is expected to be studious and clean. He also gets selected choices. Two items are being sold at school, you aren't getting both, I can choose for you, but I have trained you enough that you can make the right decision. So, he knows to choose fries over donuts because we are mindful of the level of high sugar in take at home.
So i take your point but how to think is valuable as the child progresses. He or she wont always be four.
And promptly, powerful Key- response from J.P just to start:
(Future )Performance =
General Intelligence + Consciousness(Degree).
And immediately a key- question
to myself:
Am I (!) (self-)conscious enough to succeed (wherever I wish), suppose general intelligence is okay?
It's again and again,
J.P. 'emerges' in space as
Relentless Advocate of' Wellbeing
Ecology' of Individual's Self .
And every time I try my best to find
some context to regard J.P.'s conduct as ludicrously insistent
and fail .:)
A man is devoted to the task
to a degree ( ! )
Passionately!
Amazing!
Breathes there the man, with soul so dead,
Who never to himself hath said,
This is my own, my native land!
Sir Walter Scott.
Identity is something you need to feel internally. Not something that has to be enforced by the state or the religion, and separate you from others by a rigid mentality or practices.
The example of the football match is clownesque. Yes everyone is a hard-core identitarian when is comes to sport, and it is joyful BECAUSE it is a specific occasion.
If it was part of daily national demonstrations, it would be sinister.
35 years teaching high school students: The public schools have become indoctrination camps and holding pens with gatekeepers for the labor market.... offering little to no value in exchange for a massive tax dollar input. This lady is spot on; the presented teaching methods and school policies work PERFECTLY. 1. Restricted freedoms and choices commensurate with their age and ability to absorb consequences. 2. Expectation for scholastic high performance with a determination to push all students through (note: pupils are not always students) 3. An expectation for teachers to all be high performing and hold expertise in their specialty. 4. Skills compliment knowledge by affirming its validity when applied... skills are a manifestation of knowledge, comprehension, application analysis and synthesis elevating that which is academic to the practical. But then again, what does this retired shop teacher know.
What choices do you think we used to have? I can remember so many kids miserable in HS in the early 90s before I got to that grade.
Katherine Birbalsingh is the best head teacher ever born and the most logical, enthusiastic, focussed, dedicated, driven person you're ever likely to come across.
Her school has a varied poor intake and an excellent output of holistically complete, confidently competent, well mannered, balanced, kind, hard working young go getters with solid characters who are "oppression and gender" indoctrination proof.
I think there are two sides to the coin, too much group identity erodes the ability to think apart and be separate. Maybe nationalism and other forms of group identity can have their place, but I don’t think they should be celebrated more than the ability to think alone away from the crowd
she’s talking about patriotism, which she advocates for every country. Not nationalism, which emphasizes superiority of parts of the population against others.
Brilliant questions big J. Well done.
This is crazy because I just posted a question to all canadian teachers in a very public space asking them why they feel children do not know the pledge here? Literally in French especially kids are totally disconnected from it lately. The amount of disdain for the singing of the national anthem was pretty obvious due to one reason, according to the respondants it is not part of what Teachers have to help students understand- that would be their personal choice otherwise they may face Parents arguing if there is a religious component involved! Absurdity! Why not just be proud of where you are sitting receiving your education?
I was homeless, did drugs, went into prison, where I got to know God. He changed my life. Now I have a home, a wife and a lovely year old daughter (zoe), and a stream of income that gats me $47,000 weekly. Plus a new identity - a child of God, Hallelujah!!!🇺🇲❣️♥️❤️
Excuse me for real?,how is that
possible I have struggling
financially, how was that possible?
0:02 Thanks to Kate Elizabeth Becherer
And also, I always appreciate God for his kindness upon my life
YES!!! That's exactly her name (Kate Elizabeth Becherer) so many people have recommended highly about her and am just starting with her 😊 from Brisbane Australia🇦🇺
I have heard a lot of wonderful things about Kate Elizabeth Becherer on the news but didn't believe it until now. I'm definitely trying her out
Same here, with my current portfolio made from my investments with my personal financial advisor (Kate Elizabeth Becherer) I totally agree with you
Thanks!
I’m a inner city busdriver. Belgium is playing currently in the European Soccer Championship. I was wearing a Belgian pin on my uniform. I was summoned for a talk with my superior who told me to take it off as it was offending to the majority of our clients who are African and/or Muslim. I asked what would happen if I didn’t remove it. He told me I was gonna get fired after 18 years of impeccable service.
Stupid boss. This is because leftists making home with anti EU values agendas. I can bet that the same boss will nothing to say to an algerian, marocan, sen pt russian.. Double standard !
Lol you're a bus driver. 😂😂
Being a pilot IS NOT SIMPLE. IT IS EXACTLY WHEN YOU CANNOT RELY ON AUTOPILOT THAT YOU MUST BE EXTREMELY EFFICIENT AND INTELLIGENT. GTHFOH 😂
feeling like she has next to no experience in the real world and has never, ever, had to struggle....
Yes, that was a crap point. But it shouldn't detract from her other points.
But it does highlight one of the major changes, teachers have no experience outside of their profession, but in the past people did many things before entering the field.
She is also wrong about it being traditionally female, it's a modern thing that teaching has become female dominant.
@themastertater420 that's funny, you obviously don't know much about her. I knew some would be butthurt about the pilot comment. 😂
This lady is full of it😂😂😂. But you know, her passion is good but her lack of knowledge and wisdom are big hurdles for her to form an unbiased view.
The pilot comment seemed a bit odd. You can lift up education as a difficult job without putting down on being a pilot.
I grew up poor as church mouse but was told Canada was the best country to change that. Boy Scouts taught me to be a patriot and many other things. Turned out the people that told me the I could change my childhood circumstances were right and I ain’t poor no more, Canada was good to me and for me. What the hell happened, it’s like I woke up in Bizzaro ClownWorld.
So when the left says this is too much national identity (fucking cupcakes and all) but then brings too much diversification ("radical left"). Whats the solution? I mean first it was about how we needed to be proud of diversity and now that that's too much, and were going back to being proud of strong national identity. Which one is it. Common people think its a game and that its just ideologies now or just one bad side against the other. Where is the real common ground or solution that were trying to come to? I see none in sight, but a victory for a side that was damned from the beginning anyways. We are suppose to be progressing into something new and better, not staying the same, regressing, or evolving into something we know is bad (left or right) because it really is neither that's the solution. We can find problems with everything so, where is the center of the chaos?
You can take a dane out of denmark but you cannot take the danish out of the dane.
No one can siphen of my danish-ness & sell it like bottled water at LAX.
Would that be tea brewed out of pastry crumbs?
*More Suggested Interviews For Dr. Jordan Peterson:*
Bishop Mar Mari Emmanuel
Salman Rushdie
Ricky Gervias
Drew McCoy
Dan Barker
Thomas Westbrook
Dan Mcclellan
The Line Channel
Aron Ra
The Non Alchemist Channel
Bart Ehrman
Seth Andrew’s The Thinking Atheist Channel
Trevor Poelman
Andrew Neil
Michael Burns
Tom Nicholas
Lewis Waller
TMM Channel
Sisyphus 55 Channel
Duncan Channel
Jimmy Dore
Cody Johnston
Tamim Albargouthi
Chris Hedges
Chris Mullin
George Galloway
The Kavernacle
Aardman Animations
Jane Elliott
The Vanguard
David Doel
Stephen Woodford's Rationality Rules Channel
Jon's DarkMatter2525 Channel
Amy Goodman
Abigail Thorn
Swolesome Channel
Pillar of Garbage Channel
Alexander Haley
Sam Seder
John Iadarola
Rashad Richey
Noam Chomsky
Jordan Meiselas
Leigh Mcgowan
Mike Figueredo
Norman Finkelstein
Knowing Better Channel
Dr. Hakim
Richard D. Wolff
A clear example of teaching children national pride is illustrated unequivocally in the conflict between Russia and Ukraine as it is between Israel and Palestinians. Identification with any group is inevitably divisive leading to conflict with other groups. Intellectual capacity has its place but is no guarantee for an intelligent life. Teaching children to be aware of their innate qualities and about relationships per se is far more important.
From one extreme to the other we went
Im wondering what the effects are later in life. School and study was for me always based on the pressure of the environment to perform boring and tedious tasks. I now am succesful but I wil always make bold choices and wont let me get pressured in boring tasks so yeah I have studied hard but wont do anything with those degrees. I don't think it matters al that to peer pressure kids into learning boring classes
"...except in the East, they wouldn't say 'well done' in the beginning." Yep, that's true in pretty much all East Asian cultures. Parents will never praise their kids for their accomplishments regardless of how exceptional they are. There's nothing that will ever satiate the appetite of a tiger mum.
This school is apparently different than most others. Particularly in the USA. 2:52
I Love this woman.
Yeah
Development of children's individuality trumps everything else.
🙏🏼
I absolutely despise some of the stuff this woman said, but this sounds absolutely wonderful
It’s worrying the amount of people claiming to be teachers in the US, spend time online stating how awful the US is. It’s no wonder patriotism and love of country seems to go down every year.
Do you only mean the white people?
This lady really compared fighter pilots and teachers?! 😂
Look up what Norm MacDonald had to say about teachers… “they’re the real heroes.”
PLEASE ADDRESS GENZ IN KENYA....PLEASE
These supremacists westerners will only care about Kenya's resources. Decolonize your mind, my fellow African!
DefInitely YES
Our schools contribute to the cohesion of a country and they are also a target for woke pushers, which is worrisome. I have tremendous respect for this lady and have watched several podcasts with her, but I have to say that you need far more than a high school diploma to be a pilot. My son's friend became a pilot which took 4 tough years after high school, missed parties and then hundreds of hours of practical work. I'm not sure what she was thinking of here.
Very Interesting conversation……however…….Piloting a plane is easy vs teaching is hard? And YOUR children are Tenfold over others?
Bring on these Geniuses!-? Why isn’t this news sweeping the globe? Cant wait to see the accomplishments…
What would some foreigner know about the English national identity.
Some foreigners know more about British history and national identity (not ideology) than natives.
They can teach you you shouldnt hate yourself.
Hard to say...England only taught them the language, history, and culture of England as a result of colonization
Oh grow up
I say bravo and thank you to that foreigner for actually standing up and attempting to instill into these children a sense of national identity. She is exactly the foreigner/immigrant that this country so desperately needs and thank god she chose this land to call her home. British by choice and proud of it.
We should have the American flag back in schools. We need to teach our children to be proud of being American. This is why I homeschooled until they graduated. My kids are great adults and are proud of being an American. I let them see both parties growing up so they could make an informed decision on what their political identity was. They all think the democrats are delusional. I raised them to have common sense, morals, a strong sense of self, a strong faith in God, to be respectful to their elders and have a good work ethic. They are all at the top of their fields and they are all under 45. And they are teaching their kids what I gave them.
Well my reply started off nice … ✈️
We desperately need this in Canada 🇨🇦, restoration of our identity and ties to our Nation brought back into our schools. Our Canadian ideals are being pushed out. We musn’t lose them.
Now, as I was in the midst of my penned thank you, she berated my profession. Charming.
So as a simple pilot, my under developed, yet ever working to decipher the world ‘cranial matter’ instantly took
umbrage with her.
By her statement I should be disabled to teach my craft yet find carefree pleasure when an engine fails, or while I manage a smoke/electrical emergency or have a flight control failure. In 20 plus years of flying , thus far I do not see a difference…… teaching or doing appears to be quite similar. I’m must have missed something.
She should not be fooled by skimming someone’s qualifications and creating assumption. Perhaps walk in their shoes then levy an informed opinion. There is always more below the surface to all professions. Though considering her statement again, that must be why I am so calm when flying…. Tis’ nothing of concern to operate a flying machine, regardless of the capability of the craft or the state of avionics, the weather or system failures. She is rather a bit of a goof to make such a statement. I’ve always wondered why intellects pick professions held in regard to ‘poopoo’ and stand upon. Curious why technical trades are usually at the end of their ire.
By her logic doing a thing whatever that is, is not hard. Telling someone how easy it should be is the difficult part. Their ‘blessed instruction’ from on high shall bestow all that brings success… I assume that’s the case…. she must be markedly more intelligent than I, so I will remain in wonder till perhaps advised by this teacher. :)
P.S Don’t put someone down to make yourself feel good. It’s a bad look - P.P.S Merely to illicit a similar feeling to the one that came over me; Malcolm Gladwell approves of your hair cut…... that doesn’t feel nice does it…..? Please do better next time ~ Rob
JP keep up the awesomeness - but don’t let slander slide 🤟🏻
What’s puzzling me is the nature of this Game ????
JP we need a episode about the military document FM3-39.40 everyone should print it and pass it on NOW america is in trouble and Canada will be used against us.
I think she is saying great stuff and doing great things! However, I have to stand up for pilots. It takes years and years of training to become a competent pilot and includes skills such as mechanics, math, coordination, etc. Teaching requires different skills and a good teacher is needed just as much as a good pilot. However, as a teacher, if you mess up, you live and your students live. As a pilot lots of people can die. That's why they are trying to simplify things to make the job safer. However,you go tell me how easy it is to be a pilot after you try to land a fighter jet on an aircraft carrier!
This teaching of a strong central culture is a double-edged sword. Here in Canada, we have strayed so far from a centralized culture through "diversity" and massive immigration that there's no central defining ethos.
But centralized culture can - does- also lead to hyper-nationalism and xenophobia, which very often tends towards violence against "other" and "out" groups.
It's a delicate balance, and I personally can't name one country that's successfully threaded that needle.
I believe people are feeling the effects of the lying media since the pandemic. It is not just the immigration, it is the taxes that are making people mad. We don't feel our taxes are helping us! So we start to find the culture based on all kinds of redirecting money to Ukraine. You can not deny our extra tax money is going there.
National Identity prevents factionalisation into racial and religious groups.
What a rockstar she is!
Does she have schools in America? If so I’ll send my kids there.
I want to go back to school.
I feel like there is an important difference between identifying with a sports team vs a national identity. I have always felt negatively towards strong national identity as like in sports it creates a us vs them mentality. Which is perfectly fine in a sports setting but in politics it can be very aggressive and dangerous. for example look at another country that you don't belong to that has a strong national identity and is always about me me me and so long as it benefits my country anything goes. its incredibly short sighted and completely negates any desire of cooperation that could lead to outcomes greater than any one nation could ever achieve on their own.
Excellent interview, never seen Jordan so quiet must be the Joe rogan influence 😂
Priority number one: compliance
Then education
PETERSON 100000% with u
2.02/4 😂😂 I was the most stupid of all my friends and still am...❤
Such an identity is more useful to others within a nation state than it's possessors. It is psychosocial leverage on conformity and labor availability. Are you Canadian enough to have a roll in the sale of of Canadian identity? What best defines a person is the hills on which they are and are not willing to die and not the coincidence of history of occupying an internal or external border.
Kathrine Birbalsingh is fantastic.
children need to have strong common sense and a good sense of reality
멋져 하는 거 한개씩은 있어도 되지 않을까
Beware the fowls of the air, Dr. Peterson.
Nice suit
Leo Tolstoy: Patriotism in its simplest, clearest and most indubitable signification is nothing else but a means of obtaining for the rulers their ambitions and covetous desires, and for the ruled the abdication of human dignity, reason, conscience, and a slavish enthrallment to those in power.
I'm English but I truly believe attaching your identity to lines drawn in the sand is counter productive, creating an 'us and them' attitude across humanity
Wow, Chinese and Soviet babies are scattered all over the world. It matter if they are Asian or Western. I'm suffering South Korean, so it's psychological comfort.
even Great Britain ,Canada, US, Japan… and my country
I remember having freedom week in high school. We were taught the greatness of this country, and how fortunate we were to live here. We need that now, but the screaming, foaming-at-the-mouth leftists won't allow it. It doesn't matter that most parents don't have a problem with it. The loud, obnoxious minority throws a fit until it gets its way.
Amazing lady
Oh boy.
I agree with anything Jordan Peterson says and does except his fashion sense.
it shouldnt even be a question
always pausing the envelope 😁