It's not even about getting more icing, not really. It's just that a cake that doesn't have that top icing doesn't feel like a complete cake. If someone gave me like a giant piece of cake but it's just the bottom half of it, i'd be like where's the rest of it. If they gave me a small piece of cake with all the layers, i'd be like this is a tiny piece of cake, but without feeling like something is missing
@@myyou7335but that's not fair😂 life's not fair. Cupcake his way is better because I'm not eating that she manhandled the s*** out of that cake. It's 90% fingerprints😂
Correcting her defeated the whole purpose of the question. It's about thinking outside the box, and coming up with a solution by yourself is much better than knowing the answer beforehand and trying to diminish her creativity
@@Catherine.Dorian. Yes, and the most elegant solution involves building a separate support structure to complete the puzzle... Granted, needing to create the support structure may be balanced out by each slice having equal composition, but I personally don't care about the superficial details of cakes that render this benefit; I'd rather consider the cake as any arbitrary, stout cylinder. Thinking in such terms makes the original method much more interesting and surprising, not least because any individual can do it easily by themselves, without the need of some support structure which I doubt anyone would actually bother to create for the sake of solving a low-stakes puzzle like this one.
Hers is definitely better, if not because of the end result, than at least for the fact she thought out of the box. Riddles like this is just reaching an end result that meets the requirements, in a way that obeys the restrictions, and thats what she did. It doesn't matter whether or not you do it in the way intended with the riddle, if you think there should be only one way to do it, and it turns out there are multiple ways to get there, than there is a problem with the riddle, not with her solution
I have never seen it done the way shd did it, so for creativity she wins, i also live how she just jumped strait in with no hesitation. But i actualy dont like icing so i would enjoy your way more.😊
Getting to the right answer but with a different method, it's honestly more valid because his interpretation implies the cake is in a static space and cannot be reformed or moved after a cut but the wife applies realistic logic, instead of theoretical logic.
Hers were actually equal so she wins, but I don’t agree that it’s the better method because you had to stick your fingers into every single slice for it to work. If I saw someone legitimately do that I would not want cake anymore and be very disappointed, because I love cake 😂
I was thinking parchment paper it and cutting it sideways. Messes up the icing but to be fair you're eating it after it's sliced photos and stuff are before.
Honestly, yeah, she came up with a better solution. 8 roughly equal slices of cake in 3 cuts, versus 4 pieces that have almost no icing and four that have comparatively too much.
I like the girls better. As an older sibling i need things to be fair or all war will break loose😂 I also loved how you said “cut the cake” and she went straight in.- and WHY was the cake with icing in the OVEN!?😂
Wes was more accurate due to the fact that he left the cake as it was while only making 3 cuts. But it wasn't stipulated that you couldn't rearrange the cake while cutting it so she's correct too, I guess. lol
her way, because you can do the same thing without stacking it and still get eight slices, he cut the layers which are usually frosted in between meaning he’d have an unequal distribution of frosting💗
I'm sorry Wes but SHE did it better because her way is more FAIR for those of us who enjoy our cake with more icing
what about those of us who prefer less icing?
@@thelostcause1562 just scrape the icing off to the side.
It's not even about getting more icing, not really. It's just that a cake that doesn't have that top icing doesn't feel like a complete cake. If someone gave me like a giant piece of cake but it's just the bottom half of it, i'd be like where's the rest of it. If they gave me a small piece of cake with all the layers, i'd be like this is a tiny piece of cake, but without feeling like something is missing
@@tsumichama this is the right answer
@@myyou7335but that's not fair😂 life's not fair. Cupcake his way is better because I'm not eating that she manhandled the s*** out of that cake. It's 90% fingerprints😂
"that's not how you do it" you asked her to answer. She gave the correct answer. 🤣
She gave A correct answer. A solution is a solution, just cuz it's not his solution doesn't make it wrong lol
@@stormiexnights I would argue her solution is the better one because the pieces are actually equal
@@KwBradley I mean it's a lot more difficult to do, so I disagree. They're pretty much squishing the whole cake lol
@stormiexnights he literally called her way the wrong way. I think its fair if she gets to say his is the wrong way back
@@bingolinging what does that have to do with what I said
I love how you pull a fully decorated cake out of the oven 😆
With a glove like it was hot :-)
He had to reheat the cake of course. What are ya a heathen who doesn't reheat their cake?
Sometimes people may store it there for a moment, especially if there are pups❤😊
@@Blake-pk3zyfair point but why the oven mitt then? 🙂
@@Igmus who tf eats hot cake?
How math teachers be like when you used a different formula to get the right answers 😂
Never..
It was not writing down the way you solved it that made your grade low
@@12many4you IT WAS BOTH FOR ME. 🥹 Childhood trauma activated.
She did it way better! 😂
Lol she actually had a good point
She understood the assignment too well.
By destrpying the decoration?
@@robbiecale3327 It's gonna get destroyed in your mouth anyway ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
She could’ve done the second cut normally
@@Mr-Raptor She could have moved the cake into a line for the final cut and not smooshed it into a stack covered in fingerprints.
Husband gets outplayed on his own game😅
I love how she chose chaos and came out correct.
Correcting her defeated the whole purpose of the question.
It's about thinking outside the box, and coming up with a solution by yourself is much better than knowing the answer beforehand and trying to diminish her creativity
But if she couldn’t cut the leaning tower of 4 cakes stacked on top of each other by herself…?
Especially since her way was significantly better
@@charleskolozsvary8714It didn’t say she couldn’t make some sort of a support structure to keep the cake up lol.
Let it go, he's dumb as hell
@@Catherine.Dorian. Yes, and the most elegant solution involves building a separate support structure to complete the puzzle... Granted, needing to create the support structure may be balanced out by each slice having equal composition, but I personally don't care about the superficial details of cakes that render this benefit; I'd rather consider the cake as any arbitrary, stout cylinder. Thinking in such terms makes the original method much more interesting and surprising, not least because any individual can do it easily by themselves, without the need of some support structure which I doubt anyone would actually bother to create for the sake of solving a low-stakes puzzle like this one.
Cutting a cake like that has gotta be illegal (referring to the second one)
"you want that bottom corner?" , stop, he's already dead! 🤣
OOoh "That's not how you do this riddle..." is driving me crazy! There is OBVIOUSLY more than one way to do anything!!! 🤣
Well, yes, but most riddles dont have multiple solutions.
@@Markcrazeerso are you saying her solution was wrong? Or not what he was expecting
Most riddles are stupid
@Markcrazeer I don't really think of that as a "riddle". Maybe just a neat trick? To me, riddles are literature, words.
I think he sounded excited when he said it, which makes me glad. He's delighted to see her find a new answer.
Neurodivergence at work
Real
As an ND I completely agree 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I am… divergent 🧍🏾
i love these kinda riddles " nooooo you need to solve in a spesific way I only learned from internetttt stopppp"
Hers is definitely better, if not because of the end result, than at least for the fact she thought out of the box. Riddles like this is just reaching an end result that meets the requirements, in a way that obeys the restrictions, and thats what she did. It doesn't matter whether or not you do it in the way intended with the riddle, if you think there should be only one way to do it, and it turns out there are multiple ways to get there, than there is a problem with the riddle, not with her solution
She just outsmarted every mathematician
“Here’s a riddle. You only have to solve it the way I want it to.”
*end quote
to."
@@oblivion1924 sorry what? 😂😂
@@SankuSaikat ya didn't end the quote
She outsmarted you, nice try bro
WIFE WINS
Somebody’s mad they got outsmarted by a BOSS
I have never seen it done the way shd did it, so for creativity she wins, i also live how she just jumped strait in with no hesitation. But i actualy dont like icing so i would enjoy your way more.😊
Both solutions valid, however hers was better because I felt like she thought more outside the box.
"Yeah that might be better"
Wise words my friend, wise words 🤝
"If its stupid but it works, it isnt stupid."
- US Military proverb
Damn both of those cakes look incredible.
Shame that the second had to be butchered like that.
That's like my math teacher telling me i didn't do the solution correctly because i didn't use his method 😂😂
Sometimes the correct answer isn't the only right answer
She did it her way. Gotta respect that
“That’s not how you do the riddle!!”
Then your riddle is wrong!!!
I want cake now.
"I reject your rules and use my own" his wife probably
Second one is definitely the intended solution to the riddle, but I have to agree with her haha.
That woman mastered the recursive problem solving
Kristen totally the winner!!!
He had the second cake ready to demonstrate !!!
The fact that she didnt need to stack the second cut, but did anyway, is hilarious
she's getting smarter.
She not only did it, but did it WAY better than the "proper" solution!😂
I love how he pulled the cake out of the oven bare hand at first then used the mitten
Getting to the right answer but with a different method, it's honestly more valid because his interpretation implies the cake is in a static space and cannot be reformed or moved after a cut but the wife applies realistic logic, instead of theoretical logic.
Piece of cake 🎂
😎
Correction: 8 pieces of cake, Lol
@BraveSoda By the end of the vid: 16 pieces 😉
"They're not equal" while hers on the background extremely wobbly
This woman worked smarter, harder and more accurately in accordance to the rule of "equal pieces". ❤
I like her solution better. You get both layers that way.
I knew Wes's answer... but her Answer IS SO MUCH BETTER
Hers preserved the layered experience, so I vote for hers 😂
JESUS JUST CUT THE CAKE NORMALY AND ITS JUST THREE CUTS OMG
I was agreeing with you and then realised it's 4 cuts
It's the " Watch you fingerss. WATCHHH YOURRR FIIIINGERSSSS!" for me🤣
Hers were actually equal so she wins, but I don’t agree that it’s the better method because you had to stick your fingers into every single slice for it to work. If I saw someone legitimately do that I would not want cake anymore and be very disappointed, because I love cake 😂
I was thinking parchment paper it and cutting it sideways. Messes up the icing but to be fair you're eating it after it's sliced photos and stuff are before.
Yeah that's what I was thinking. Her way not only need two people to pull off but they both put their hands all over the cake slices.
People usually wash their hands before touching food
@@dDoodle788 washed or not I wouldn’t want to eat one of her pieces
She ran rings around you 😂. Definition of outside the box. Woman's a genius.
It's like math when you do the wrong equation, but got the right answer
Bro she's thinking outside the box we have found the new Albert Einstein😂
She’s definitely the students who doesn’t care about reading or listening to all the requirements before proceeding 😂
Let’s just eat the cake!
Lol, it's the epitome of "there are 2 types of people" 😂
she came up with a better solution and outsmart her husband, im impressed!
Takes a fully frosted cake out the oven
100% she crushed this one. That’s likely genuinely thinking outside the box.
She's a genius. 😂
pulling out a fully decorated cake out of the over without an oven mitt on your hand 😭 genious
Definitely hers was better. The request was equal pieces, but in his solution, the bottom and top pieces are not at all equal.
The problem lies with how he formulated the riddle
Those cakes look so freaking good. Why not do a test like this in carrot cake?! It breaks my heart to see such beautiful cakes be cut like that.
I squealed when I got this one immediately.
Cut it horizontally first.
Then cut a cross vertically.
As anyone who watches Taskmaster can attest, finding the loophole caused by poor wording in a task is always half the fun.
I just baked a perfectly iced cake 🎂 😂
Honestly, yeah, she came up with a better solution. 8 roughly equal slices of cake in 3 cuts, versus 4 pieces that have almost no icing and four that have comparatively too much.
“Wife right” smart man
The guys answer are same size but not equal. The ladies are (maybe not perfect) equal.
lmao the oven mise en scene as if you just baked it yourself
Both are right. I love it 😂
The first was AWESOME
I like the girls better. As an older sibling i need things to be fair or all war will break loose😂
I also loved how you said “cut the cake” and she went straight in.- and WHY was the cake with icing in the OVEN!?😂
Her solution is definitely better. It would work for 16 pieces in 4 cuts without having 4D world!
Yep she beat it with an even better answer. Go wife!
As a software developer this is every user stress test I've ever held.
"stop stop why would you do that? That's not how you do that"
"Do you want this bottom corner of a circular cake?"
Literally set this question for my son a few weeks back for his Birthday. Took a while but he got it.
I am not a baker but I think fully decorated cake don't come directly out of oven.
The white cake was the obvious answer but I like her answer better because it's just amazing
That's a quadratic equation with two solutions.
If someone handed me a slice of cake cut from the middle without frosting or center filling I'd take back my bday present to them.
She's genius and dangerous and right.
I like her way better!
Okay, but did ANYONE NOT notice, that he removed a cake along with it's "icing" straight from oven🤣🤣🤣
I think if you just cut it normally, like a pizza, that solves the riddle.
Hers was much better!!❤
Not taking an iced cake out of the oven LMAO
She gets points for thinking outside the box but I give this one to Wes.
I gotta disagree I think she outsmarted him this time. Aw screw it they have cake quick I'll distract them you grab a slice!
@@DeathclawJedi free the cake!
Squirrl’s got my back!
@@WesBarker yeah man!
literally she smashed the frosting on top and half the pieces look like they got smashed too
Sorry random not him taking the cake out the oven with the non glove hand . Was it even hot lol ? That was funny 😁🤣😂
There's more than one way to skin a crying alligator. - Bruce Lee Jr.
Wes was more accurate due to the fact that he left the cake as it was while only making 3 cuts. But it wasn't stipulated that you couldn't rearrange the cake while cutting it so she's correct too, I guess. lol
I love how he had the frosted cake in the oven and used an oven mit😂😂😂😂
I want to solve the mystery of why he pulled a FROSTED CAKE out of the OVEN!
good thing you frosted it before baking. otherwise we wouldn't have thought you bought it.
Love her she’s a gem!
Wifey's a badass! 😂
"It's not equal!" Say that to the person who has no frosting on top or bottom.
Equal pieces =/= pieces of equal size, for cake necessarily. His solution proves that, despite being the theoretical correct answer.
Could have kept them across eachother when cutting it for the last time instead of stacking 4 pieces
When you use a different solution but still get the same answer:
her way, because you can do the same thing without stacking it and still get eight slices, he cut the layers which are usually frosted in between meaning he’d have an unequal distribution of frosting💗