Yeah it still hurts but I recommend you should move on like I am not forcing you but with my experience, I got depressed and I was just so stressed because of that but I haven't fully moved on because of the point that its fudging hard
Thats what i said, Sunny is was never the same after Jessica's "departure" (kicked out). She was more distracted and a little distant from the group, not that she had any problems with them but a little more different.
@@sabreenasnow119 I'm not sure, i always saw Jessica closer to Tiffany and Yuri. But i wouldn't doubt that Sunny was very close to her or maybe found kicking her out of the group unfair.
well, they did have to do the video four times (2 with Jessica and 2 w/o) so I’m guessing by the third or fourth they must have been kinda tired and over it lol
as someone who's been a sone since 2011 and was there when the whole debacle happened, it's so obvious everyone felt better once jessica left - jessica included. they all moved on and people should too!
@@EriamMalfoy i've been a fan since Run Devil Run and saying that everyone felt better is not true. Jessica was the member that trained the longest, the 1st member to be revealed, one of the 2 main vocalists and literally got kicked out for no justifiable reason. She got blacklisted in her own country and got hated on by rumors that they were not true at all spread by SM to make her look bad. And till this day she is still suffering from that. They literally destroyed her career and life but i'm glad She is Okay now. Idk about the other members but some of them seemed really troubled once they kicked Jessica out
You can still see the angelic smile of Sunny there in OT9 1:46 ...You can feel the sadness in ot8 version seems like they were forced to redo the last mv without their Jessica just make the camera angles, make over and filter enhanced in ot8 version to hide all those emotions.
Even the jessica's im goin to find my heart, in ot9 version sunny is kinda more energized but in ot8 ver she is kinda a lil bit lazy. Sunny is never be the same :(
honestly i think the difference in enthusiasm is 90% that... they'd recorded the whole thing once already, there's no excitement over it being a new song or promotion they're doing, it's literally just extra work. i liked some of the elective hand-gestures more in the earlier version, though.
JESSICA!!! I'm crying that jessica was the first one to be removed from Girls Generation! later then Tiffany, Sooyoung and Seohyun left S.M but not Girls Generation... lucky! please return all my queens back!! 😫
@@LeonardoPimentel20 well i am a Stay fyi and when that person left the group, i can see that there is one empty spot and i kinda feel sad at that time and feel empty. But nah idc about it now yeah you're right Stray Kids shines with 8 members
@@coolerthanyou2534 also Stray Kids had better opportunities as OT8 plus they were OT9 only for about 2 years, but Jessica was in the group for 7 YEARS.SHE WAS A MAIN VOCAL LIKE TAEYEON, FANS LOVED HER BECAUSE SINCE SHE WAS AMERICAN SHE, TIFFANY AND SUNNY WERE LIKE A BRIDGE BETWEEN OUR CULTURES/LANGUAGES. She was in ITNW, Gee, Genie, Oh, RDR, The Boys, IGAB, Mr Mr and so many titles we can't just pretend they would reach as much as they did without her, that's what pisses most of the OT9 stans. And just in case, I'm not underestimating the other 8 members, they wouldn't reach as far if any of them weren't there either.
@@byeol_mmd 100% Snsd isn’t snsd without ot9 because that’s what made them known for who they are. Stray Kids was held back by Woo-jail, they’re doing fine without him
I really liked how this song is distributed. Even thought Hyo gets the least amount of lines as in most of the songs, you can actually hear her on both verses and she even got a center in the final chorus. Is like this song was made for the dance line to shine, not only because of the hard choreography itself (which also shows the vocal line can dance hard as well) but because the dance line sings the verses and then the vocal line switches to the pre-chorus when in most songs is the other way around. Each of them takes turns to sing and everybody switches lines on the second verse. Also in the 3 choruses, there's always a dance line member at the center (YoonA on 1st, Yuri on 2nd, and Hyo on final) while Sooyoung got the "I'm going to find my heart" part on the final pre-chorus because vocal line was doing the high notes/ad-libs. And finally, every dance line member but Hyo got one of Jessica's lines, which would normally be given to TTS (Tae still got her high note, which was obvious considering Sica was also a main vocal) so it prooves what I already said: This song was *meant* for the dance line. I just wish we could have seen OT9 performing it live as well as the korean version.
If you just watch the OT8 version alone, you won't quite be able to put your finger on what feels off. Side by side with OT9... wow OT8 shows girls who are great artists and performers, but while there is professionalism in it, their hearts are not. If that was their debut performance, they'd not have caught on, because comparatively, it's lifeless. OT9 has a spark, an energy that lends crispness and impact to their moves, and life to their smiles. It's dynamic. You can *feel* their moves, the way a good martial arts movie or manga makes you feel - believe in - the impact of each hit.
I agree OT9 has more energy and they really enjoy what their doing, but OT8 they still have professionalism and they are still giving us that energy but it's not the same as before because deep inside they are still sad after Jessica was force to leave the group and the company. Because SNSD without Jessica it's still heartbreaking...
I miss Jessica so much..imagine start listen to kpop because of SNSD and jessica is my first ever bias,I never changed bias back then and almost quit kpop because of she leave..its hard for me
2:31 even though i do like the colour grading, lighting and camerawork in the ot8 version more (especially with the camerawork on taeyeon being significant better focused on and better centring of the members in frame and camera movement during sooyoung's part (and sooyoung leading that bit being refreshing)), i feel like jessica doing the second part of the bridge in the ot9 version was better, even if the camerawork was weaker.
2021 and I’m still sad. She was so excited about this song in her show with Krystal. Even the rest of the girls just don’t look as happy filming it a second time as ot8, regardless of what their feeling were towards Jessica at that point. The ot8 video is visually better because the ot9 wasn’t finished, it didn’t have its final touches or final editing. When people first heard this song, before the ot9 leaked, people could tell Jessica was meant to sing in it, they accurately guessed which high notes were hers and everything. I just think that her exit from SNSD and SM wasn’t worthy of who she is, and it hurt everyone involved. Definitely SM’s fault.
The OT9 video has better colors in the daylight scene. The sky is blue (OT8 the sky is almost non-existent) and the ground pops out more (in the OT8 video it also does but mostly it's washed out by the sun). It goes the other way in the evening scene with OT8 looking better (also they did not forget to turn on the light when Taeyeon did the interlude/bridge in the Korean version). As people will tend to have preferences in terms of how each member looks, so can't comment on them (although Yoona looks stunning in both :) ). As for the dancing, I don't know. It looks like the dancing has a bit more pop to it on OT8 but considering they had to re-shoot it, I guess they felt they had to show they could still carry the performance post-Jesssica. Jessica almost bumped into Hyo-yeon at 2:01 and she is known for losing her place in performances so typical Ice Princess till the very last performance.
As weird as seeing them not being 9, I must admit the camera man did a much better job in OT8 and the stylist as well, the girls look prettier with some of the hair styles.
i actually think the ot9 version was hastily put together to promote the ot8 version lool sm has leaked shit before. but they would NEVER leave a shot of jessica walking to position like that in a real mv. and even compare it to the ot8 version and see its missing a clip right there. makes me think a lot of it was put together but never polished up bc they didn't need it to be polished
but the camera were at different levels even if you pause it, hyoyeon's head was lowered and leveled in the ot9 compared to the ot8 om the beginning of the hairflip 🤔 and taeyeon was smiling in the right side back with her bangs, i think then hyoyeon's hair was higher right before the hairflip ends but before taeyeon's high note ends its the same hairstyle with the ot8 wherein both taeyeon and hyoyeon are captured in the center of the framed. then when it came to hyoyeon's hairflip with her hair on the right side spread out you can see taeyeon on the right with different hairstyles for both vids. they probably did multiple cuts of which stayed and which were replaced on that specific part. right before it zooms out to the full group you can see taeyeon's ot9 mr. mr. bangs but when it finally zoomed out there were only 8 in the ending of the ot9 ver. sorry if my explanation is confusing 😂
I think is because they had to learn every step being just 8, being 9 I guess they danced in diferent positions, maybe they were a little bit confused. That's why I think😊
@@KHtrinity1 what i dont understand is jessica have talked about it to her (former) friends snsd and sm. but why suddenly it become a problem? there is now way she would not talk about it and disscuss it. but maybe we will never now and it will become mistery.
Mary Rose Aque apparently it’s 1 4 and 6 faults (if they did do a voting). this is from a deleted chinese article which apparently they asked jessica what happened.
They are really good together the 9 members of the group they look more position in the video with the 9 members i miss then so mucho please comeback again
Their smiles on the OT8 version look so fake this is SM's fault It's like SM is forcing them to just smile and think that jessica didn't even freaking exist
People are ignoring the best part about this: this proves they kicked Jessica of the group. If you know a member is going to leave you won't waste time on including her in a video is she won't be around to promote or simply be there. But they filmed her and then filmed without her again. Because SM lied.
tbh they went all out on this MV because it was Jessica's last, they were supposed to do the Tokyo Dome, and then she'd leave. Something happened that made all that happen sooner, so they had to reshoot everything on a moment's notice. I doubt SM kicked her out, they wasted so much money on this fiasco that CMIYC is still the most expensive comeback ever in kpop (accounting for re-shoots and all the packaging they had top burn and do again). It's not like a group can kick out a member if there's contract left. My guess is Jessica sued SM for big money if her contract wasn't terminated and it was cheaper to re-do the comeback material than to pay her.
@@ghostlyapples SM can afford to pay an artist if they need to, and probably they have clausules to avoid paying them, lol. Also, if she was going to leave, SHE would have to pay them for early extintion of the contract, not viceversa. If she was smart, she would simply wait until her contract was over and walk away debt free. Nah, this video proves they simply had enough of her and kicked her out, and I'm not blaming the other members, I've always said SM is the main culprit here (although I'm kinda side eyeing Taeyeon still).
People this days, acting up like you’ll know the real reason why Jessica was kicked out of the group.. Are ya’ll there? Are ya’ll freaking there when she was kicked out. If not then shut the fuck up..
film wise, I like the version without Jessica better (i think it was filmed a bit better - it looks newer). But I still prefer the version with Jessica, it just feels better.... it feels right.
the ot8 version is what every yoona fan ever wanted. a song whose concept adapts 100% to yoona and where her lines are so appropriate. ot9 is always gonna be nostalgic since I was Yoonsic but seeing yoona shining this way on ot8 makes my heart happy. also am I the only who thinks is hella weird that 3 months later the set was exactly the same as in the original filming?
It just makes me fell sad and angry because SM deleted the OT9 version just like why that's Jessica's final mv in SNSD and they deleted it.SM are you on drugs?😂😂😂 But seriously though why?😢
@Sephora Ndaya Mutubile i always thought Jessica was innocent, but never blamed snsd tho. But didn't know she is this rude. They say taeyeon break her friendship with jessica thats shes a fake friend, but actually jessica is the fake friend. When taeyeon got bash because of malicious incident, where Jessica created the latter didn't say anything because of course people hate will transfer to her that she deserves it because she's the one who went clubbing.
Tiffany cantik banget pas di ot9 😍 Berharap mereka comeback lagi dan senang banget kalau jessica bisa ikut Doa terbaik selalu buat snsd, tetap support apa yg mereka jalanin sekarang 😘
Can you tell me why they shood two version of it one ot8 and one ot9 I know that Jessica was kicked out, but I kinda think it's strange that they first film it wiht her then without her, did they film this month apart or what?
@@marmalade751 Preparations for a comeback start long before it is released. When they started preparing the CMIYC comeback Jessica was still in the group, then they fired her, so they had to re-record the MV
@@amylovesfredastaire wow... That's really harsh, imagine you first film it with your members and then out of nowhere have to leave... The atmosphere in the studio must have been awkward at that time....
It's 2021 and the girls' 14th anniversary just passed. As a SONE since 2011, I already accepted the fact that SNSD is OT8 already but forever OT9 in my heart. SNSD and Jessica would also be happy if us SONEs and Golden Stars would be happy for what they are now, how far did they have come, and what did they achieve since 2015. Let's be happy for their successes for what makes them happy now. 💙
It looks kind of like in OT8 they were a little off timing wise and in OT9 the moves synched better with the music. OT8 they seemed more serious too, where as OT9 everyone was more happy and energetic. Will always be OT9 for me, but doesn't stop my appreciation for them being OT8.
Jessica's look best in ot9 but camerawork in ot8 is much better..
nct trash
True
Agree
Agree. The revision mv version had better editing; but the original mv had more feels.
I’m imagining that they were cut in the middle of editing when Jessica left
Wow, exactly my thoughts. Glad to read it from someone else.
2019 and it still hurts...
Yeah it still hurts but I recommend you should move on like I am not forcing you but with my experience, I got depressed and I was just so stressed because of that but I haven't fully moved on because of the point that its fudging hard
2020 and it still hurts as well
in the last jessica is ok, and GG and the girls have the bad karma there,
@@diegoanthonyherrera9952 wdym bad karma?? They're enjoying their life
Life in the dungeon lmaoooo
The other difference with these two mv's was Sunny, smiling in one, no expression in the other.
she was never the same again...
Thats what i said, Sunny is was never the same after Jessica's "departure" (kicked out). She was more distracted and a little distant from the group, not that she had any problems with them but a little more different.
@@Akielus1987 was she the closest to Jessica?
@@sabreenasnow119 for what i see i think yes maybe yoona and fany was too
@@sabreenasnow119 I'm not sure, i always saw Jessica closer to Tiffany and Yuri. But i wouldn't doubt that Sunny was very close to her or maybe found kicking her out of the group unfair.
When Jessica and Taeyeon sing the high note ... Their voice blend really well and I can't take my eyes off Jessica ...
I never thought I'd get emotional watching a dance/bop MV like this one did. As a SONE since debut, this hits hard
2022 and i still cant accept that jessica leaving snsd just like that
Same
Same 😭💔
she never came out, they took her out
Me too
She never leave she was kicked out.
2:53 their voice are blending together!!!!
But TAEYEON did it better.
@@talygg1 No, it's just Taeyeon's voice is louder. Jessica's better.
@@Nayeonlyone never TAEYEON is the best
TaengSic >>>> any other main vocal kpop duo ngl
@@talygg1that’s was Jessica
Sunny looks more energetic with jessica
Yeah the moment the vid plays you can catch that feeling
Yup can't say no to that,sunny literally looks more energetic in the ot9 version of catch me if you can
yess 😢
well, they did have to do the video four times (2 with Jessica and 2 w/o) so I’m guessing by the third or fourth they must have been kinda tired and over it lol
She’s was happy
2:52 Bless your ears with TaengSic high notes
I feel like the editing team put more work into the ot8 one , the ot9 one looks slightly awkward idk , I miss ot9 💕
LOL
i think the editing also helped cover the missing hole without jessica
@@gracezb1 Yeah but, its just me or they acctually use some of the scenes OT9 in the OT8 video because almost all the Hyo scenes are the same.
@@larerey9301they did
Woah I didn't realize I got these replies or likes oof. This is new to me. Anyways. I watched this again and I still feel the same way.
I don’t care how many ways people justify it, SNSD isn’t the same without Jessica and the hole is felt from here up to today. OT9 forever
Of course Jessica is the main vocalist along with Taeyeon so everything sounds much different
Here it is shown that Jessica was not needed, she is really dancing too badly in this video.
Tiffany is doing worse @@talygg1
as someone who's been a sone since 2011 and was there when the whole debacle happened, it's so obvious everyone felt better once jessica left - jessica included. they all moved on and people should too!
@@EriamMalfoy i've been a fan since Run Devil Run and saying that everyone felt better is not true. Jessica was the member that trained the longest, the 1st member to be revealed, one of the 2 main vocalists and literally got kicked out for no justifiable reason. She got blacklisted in her own country and got hated on by rumors that they were not true at all spread by SM to make her look bad. And till this day she is still suffering from that. They literally destroyed her career and life but i'm glad She is Okay now. Idk about the other members but some of them seemed really troubled once they kicked Jessica out
You can still see the angelic smile of Sunny there in OT9 1:46 ...You can feel the sadness in ot8 version seems like they were forced to redo the last mv without their Jessica just make the camera angles, make over and filter enhanced in ot8 version to hide all those emotions.
And 3:05 too!
@@mdchstr 😭😭and I'm still hoping for an ot9🤡🤡
Yeah they all look more empowered in OT9 and their stylists did a good job with makeup, and hairstyle.
I agreee
Even the jessica's im goin to find my heart, in ot9 version sunny is kinda more energized but in ot8 ver she is kinda a lil bit lazy. Sunny is never be the same :(
Imagine having to shoot twice for the hardest and the most tiring choreography in SNSD's dance history
The hardest choreo in girl group history
honestly i think the difference in enthusiasm is 90% that... they'd recorded the whole thing once already, there's no excitement over it being a new song or promotion they're doing, it's literally just extra work.
i liked some of the elective hand-gestures more in the earlier version, though.
I'm kinda curious in the OT8 version did they remove Jessica's voice? Or not?
@@yumemijabami881 yes. They redistribute jessica part to other members.
@i am now cursing you for life really? I already watched it and it looks like the same level as 'You Think'
If you're an hater, just leave
Aww Sunny’s smiling so much in the one with Jessica 💔
Truee, I've noticed Sunny since Jess left, it's like Jess's departure took the sunlight out of Sunny! Want to see her bright smile again
@@annann6598 same when they refilm the MV with OT8 Sunny looks very sad compare with the one with Jessica.
JESSICA!!! I'm crying that jessica was the first one to be removed from Girls Generation!
later then Tiffany, Sooyoung and Seohyun left S.M but not Girls Generation... lucky!
please return all my queens back!! 😫
Tarrow420 what do u mean they left???
+Tarrow420 they did not want to renew their contracts of S.M you mean?
Actutally Taeyeon removed Jessica!
Lucas Domingues how do you know ? I think sm Kicked Jessica . But someone said they havent a good friendship
@@lucasdomingues849 why?
When a 9 member group lost a member, it seems like they lost more than one because it feels empty. I can feel the emptiness at the empty spot.
Stray Kids can't relate, they are shining even more with only 8 members
@@LeonardoPimentel20 well i am a Stay fyi and when that person left the group, i can see that there is one empty spot and i kinda feel sad at that time and feel empty. But nah idc about it now yeah you're right Stray Kids shines with 8 members
@@coolerthanyou2534 also Stray Kids had better opportunities as OT8 plus they were OT9 only for about 2 years, but Jessica was in the group for 7 YEARS.SHE WAS A MAIN VOCAL LIKE TAEYEON, FANS LOVED HER BECAUSE SINCE SHE WAS AMERICAN SHE, TIFFANY AND SUNNY WERE LIKE A BRIDGE BETWEEN OUR CULTURES/LANGUAGES. She was in ITNW, Gee, Genie, Oh, RDR, The Boys, IGAB, Mr Mr and so many titles we can't just pretend they would reach as much as they did without her, that's what pisses most of the OT9 stans. And just in case, I'm not underestimating the other 8 members, they wouldn't reach as far if any of them weren't there either.
@@LeonardoPimentel20 sorry but not! After jessica was cut out! Nathing was the same
@@byeol_mmd 100% Snsd isn’t snsd without ot9 because that’s what made them known for who they are. Stray Kids was held back by Woo-jail, they’re doing fine without him
Shout out to the guy who broke into SMs premises and leaked this video 😂❤️
did that really happen ? or was it just a sm staff who leaked it
I really liked how this song is distributed. Even thought Hyo gets the least amount of lines as in most of the songs, you can actually hear her on both verses and she even got a center in the final chorus. Is like this song was made for the dance line to shine, not only because of the hard choreography itself (which also shows the vocal line can dance hard as well) but because the dance line sings the verses and then the vocal line switches to the pre-chorus when in most songs is the other way around. Each of them takes turns to sing and everybody switches lines on the second verse. Also in the 3 choruses, there's always a dance line member at the center (YoonA on 1st, Yuri on 2nd, and Hyo on final) while Sooyoung got the "I'm going to find my heart" part on the final pre-chorus because vocal line was doing the high notes/ad-libs. And finally, every dance line member but Hyo got one of Jessica's lines, which would normally be given to TTS (Tae still got her high note, which was obvious considering Sica was also a main vocal) so it prooves what I already said: This song was *meant* for the dance line. I just wish we could have seen OT9 performing it live as well as the korean version.
THIS
2:53 What a beautiful combination
Sunny more energic with jessica!!! 😰😰😰
If you just watch the OT8 version alone, you won't quite be able to put your finger on what feels off. Side by side with OT9... wow
OT8 shows girls who are great artists and performers, but while there is professionalism in it, their hearts are not. If that was their debut performance, they'd not have caught on, because comparatively, it's lifeless.
OT9 has a spark, an energy that lends crispness and impact to their moves, and life to their smiles. It's dynamic. You can *feel* their moves, the way a good martial arts movie or manga makes you feel - believe in - the impact of each hit.
I agree OT9 has more energy and they really enjoy what their doing, but OT8 they still have professionalism and they are still giving us that energy but it's not the same as before because deep inside they are still sad after Jessica was force to leave the group and the company. Because SNSD without Jessica it's still heartbreaking...
Yup you're right
Probably because they had aleady shot it a few days prior. The same video, dance, outfit, locations. Cant be mad at them for being less enthusiastic
0:43 Yuri and Jessica and 2:53 Taengsic Harmonizing HEAVEN
Yuri and Jessica is new harmony that surprise.
I love Sica’s and Taeyeon’s voices together at this part 2:53
Yess...their combo is perfect
That pair always nailed it together
2 voices and sounds like one powerful voice.
The foundation of all SNSD song.
Deadly combination
I miss Jessica so much..imagine start listen to kpop because of SNSD and jessica is my first ever bias,I never changed bias back then and almost quit kpop because of she leave..its hard for me
Ahh that's my story exactly
Thats my story
same
Combination highnote jessica with taeyeon that perfect
2:31 even though i do like the colour grading, lighting and camerawork in the ot8 version more (especially with the camerawork on taeyeon being significant better focused on and better centring of the members in frame and camera movement during sooyoung's part (and sooyoung leading that bit being refreshing)), i feel like jessica doing the second part of the bridge in the ot9 version was better, even if the camerawork was weaker.
2021 and I’m still sad. She was so excited about this song in her show with Krystal. Even the rest of the girls just don’t look as happy filming it a second time as ot8, regardless of what their feeling were towards Jessica at that point. The ot8 video is visually better because the ot9 wasn’t finished, it didn’t have its final touches or final editing. When people first heard this song, before the ot9 leaked, people could tell Jessica was meant to sing in it, they accurately guessed which high notes were hers and everything. I just think that her exit from SNSD and SM wasn’t worthy of who she is, and it hurt everyone involved. Definitely SM’s fault.
Wow Hyo shined the best and looked the best in both she’s amazing
OT9 WIN
The OT9 video has better colors in the daylight scene. The sky is blue (OT8 the sky is almost non-existent) and the ground pops out more (in the OT8 video it also does but mostly it's washed out by the sun). It goes the other way in the evening scene with OT8 looking better (also they did not forget to turn on the light when Taeyeon did the interlude/bridge in the Korean version).
As people will tend to have preferences in terms of how each member looks, so can't comment on them (although Yoona looks stunning in both :) ). As for the dancing, I don't know. It looks like the dancing has a bit more pop to it on OT8 but considering they had to re-shoot it, I guess they felt they had to show they could still carry the performance post-Jesssica. Jessica almost bumped into Hyo-yeon at 2:01 and she is known for losing her place in performances so typical Ice Princess till the very last performance.
I love Taeyeon’s bang in OT9 version.
@@icy6005 and Tiffany’s :)
their hairstyles in ot9 gives of a lot mr. mr. vibes because they filmed this during mr. mr. era 😂💓
It has no fog in ot9 version
well if no one told me where to be I'd be looking for my place too....
With Jessica ofc...
ot9 is the best team
I remember this when it came out..such a controversy then. I miss the original lineup, followed them since debut 😭
I still love Jessica voice 😢
As weird as seeing them not being 9, I must admit the camera man did a much better job in OT8 and the stylist as well, the girls look prettier with some of the hair styles.
maybe except yoonas hair
i actually think the ot9 version was hastily put together to promote the ot8 version lool sm has leaked shit before. but they would NEVER leave a shot of jessica walking to position like that in a real mv. and even compare it to the ot8 version and see its missing a clip right there. makes me think a lot of it was put together but never polished up bc they didn't need it to be polished
3:13 I am amazed seeing that Hyoyeon unnie hair-flipped were exactly same!!!! 😎🥰😍
It the same clip. The last part of ot9 mv doesn't have jessica
but the camera were at different levels even if you pause it, hyoyeon's head was lowered and leveled in the ot9 compared to the ot8 om the beginning of the hairflip 🤔 and taeyeon was smiling in the right side back with her bangs, i think then hyoyeon's hair was higher right before the hairflip ends but before taeyeon's high note ends its the same hairstyle with the ot8 wherein both taeyeon and hyoyeon are captured in the center of the framed. then when it came to hyoyeon's hairflip with her hair on the right side spread out you can see taeyeon on the right with different hairstyles for both vids. they probably did multiple cuts of which stayed and which were replaced on that specific part. right before it zooms out to the full group you can see taeyeon's ot9 mr. mr. bangs but when it finally zoomed out there were only 8 in the ending of the ot9 ver.
sorry if my explanation is confusing 😂
Idk abt u guys but ot9 seems more organized
I also felt the same. Like the ot8 feel not so organized
I think is because they had to learn every step being just 8, being 9 I guess they danced in diferent positions, maybe they were a little bit confused. That's why I think😊
This comeback is probably the worst era😢
@@abnercataina2366 True. The song was great but some Sones were sad, some were enraged, some confused because of what happened to Jessica, OT8 and SM.
They shoot cmiyc ot9 ver. same time in mr mr era
Its really little weird bcuz Jessica always be infront line but feels empty without her
It makes me feel sad :'(
2:05 look at Sunny's performance she's energetic in the ot9 but not on the ot8
It still breaks my heart not seeing Jessica with the group. I originally saw the 8 member version. The 9 member one seems so surreal to me.
I come back to 2:53 everyday just to hear what heaven sounds like
I miss Jessica, our Ice Princess :(
Watch Jessica's official yt channel. Let's support Jessica together
why jessica leave group
@@gn1367 she was forced to leave by SM it wasnt her choice to leave
@@korikewl0151 she was forced to leave because she broke the conditions of her contract by starting a business while being in. SNSD
@@KHtrinity1 what i dont understand is jessica have talked about it to her (former) friends snsd and sm. but why suddenly it become a problem? there is now way she would not talk about it and disscuss it. but maybe we will never now and it will become mistery.
Sica's voice can't be replaced. They're not the same since she was forced out
It hurts really bad since I literally grew up listening to them...
dont leave seohyun, sooyoung, tiffany and jessica pls come back
I miss Jessica so much 😭😭😭 my heart hurts after finding out that she was kicked out by SM. There is nothing wrong pursuing your own dreams.....
Mary Rose Aque apparently it’s 1 4 and 6 faults (if they did do a voting). this is from a deleted chinese article which apparently they asked jessica what happened.
Watch Jessica's official yt channel. Let's support Jessica together
anna vel what is that numer mean ? I dont get it, pls
@@annavelxoxo did those members not like jessica at all??
@@gettheshiny3353 I think the numbers mean members in age order, like taeyeon is oldest so she is 1
wow yoona looks great in both :P
the members are more energetic in OT9 version
2022 and still hope sica and gg reunion 😭
2023 and it still hurts. I MISS MY OT9 ; (
They are really good together the 9 members of the group they look more position in the video with the 9 members i miss then so mucho please comeback again
okay but both of Hyoyeon's hairflips SLAPPED 💓💓💓
Blessing your ears 2:53 😢
😭😭
I still believed that OT9 MV was finished! Whoever got a hold of that leaked SM was probably behind it and cut the original OT9 ending.
Their smiles on the OT8 version look so fake this is SM's fault
It's like SM is forcing them to just smile and think that jessica didn't even freaking exist
Sure, i feel
actually some of the members coed her out 1 4 and 6
reminder: i got this from an article that was from 2014, it was soon later deleted
Wait, I commented this? omg, HAHAHAHA.
@@annavelxoxo i think 5 also coed her
@@annavelxoxo who is that?
its 2021 and i still count how many of them in a group pic
OT9 is the superior version and Sica left a huge void in SNSD after she left.
2023.12 still hurts
2020 and i’m still hurt:(
it's 2021 and i still can't get over it
How lovely Sunny's reaching out how she really love and she missed Jessica😥💔
People are ignoring the best part about this: this proves they kicked Jessica of the group. If you know a member is going to leave you won't waste time on including her in a video is she won't be around to promote or simply be there. But they filmed her and then filmed without her again. Because SM lied.
tbh they went all out on this MV because it was Jessica's last, they were supposed to do the Tokyo Dome, and then she'd leave. Something happened that made all that happen sooner, so they had to reshoot everything on a moment's notice. I doubt SM kicked her out, they wasted so much money on this fiasco that CMIYC is still the most expensive comeback ever in kpop (accounting for re-shoots and all the packaging they had top burn and do again). It's not like a group can kick out a member if there's contract left. My guess is Jessica sued SM for big money if her contract wasn't terminated and it was cheaper to re-do the comeback material than to pay her.
@@ghostlyapples SM can afford to pay an artist if they need to, and probably they have clausules to avoid paying them, lol. Also, if she was going to leave, SHE would have to pay them for early extintion of the contract, not viceversa. If she was smart, she would simply wait until her contract was over and walk away debt free. Nah, this video proves they simply had enough of her and kicked her out, and I'm not blaming the other members, I've always said SM is the main culprit here (although I'm kinda side eyeing Taeyeon still).
People this days, acting up like you’ll know the real reason why Jessica was kicked out of the group.. Are ya’ll there? Are ya’ll freaking there when she was kicked out. If not then shut the fuck up..
@@taengoo_ss526 go stream Taeyeon's music and let the rest of us speculate if we want.
@The RedSmasher she can be whatever she wants, as long as she allows the rest of us the freedom to do the same and talk about whatever we want.
film wise, I like the version without Jessica better (i think it was filmed a bit better - it looks newer). But I still prefer the version with Jessica, it just feels better.... it feels right.
it's that it factor they have as a group! also did you know, Jessica was the first to be added to SNSD
Watch this again in 31.5.2022.
the ot8 version is what every yoona fan ever wanted. a song whose concept adapts 100% to yoona and where her lines are so appropriate. ot9 is always gonna be nostalgic since I was Yoonsic but seeing yoona shining this way on ot8 makes my heart happy. also am I the only who thinks is hella weird that 3 months later the set was exactly the same as in the original filming?
The background is all CGI over a chroma key, the only thing that is actually "there" is the floor
With Jessica it sounds better
OT9
2021 it still make me cry and miss them so bad!
Ot9 is better. They seem more into it.
2021 and it still hurts.
Ot9 will always be the best. But here I am supporting GIRLS' GENERATION whatever happens 👌😭😭💝💖💜💗💕
It just makes me fell sad and angry because SM deleted the OT9 version just like why that's Jessica's final mv in SNSD and they deleted it.SM are you on drugs?😂😂😂
But seriously though why?😢
Yes the fact that they released Divine MV with Jessica on it after they kicked her out but rerecord Catch Me If You Can makes me even more angry
Wait, I commented this? HAHAHAHAHA.
@@jenzelsantos then CZcams delete "Divine" mv . Glad some peoples has downloaded it and uploaded in CZcams.
Serves her well
@Sephora Ndaya Mutubile i always thought Jessica was innocent, but never blamed snsd tho. But didn't know she is this rude. They say taeyeon break her friendship with jessica thats shes a fake friend, but actually jessica is the fake friend. When taeyeon got bash because of malicious incident, where Jessica created the latter didn't say anything because of course people hate will transfer to her that she deserves it because she's the one who went clubbing.
One thing I notice in between these two MV: SUNNY
Jessica
They're a lot prettier and soulful in the first shoot tho
Tiffany cantik banget pas di ot9 😍
Berharap mereka comeback lagi dan senang banget kalau jessica bisa ikut
Doa terbaik selalu buat snsd, tetap support apa yg mereka jalanin sekarang 😘
Sunny looks more energetic in OT9
2019 still can't move on 😭😭😭💔
I love both but honest from deep in my heart I love OT 9 version..😍😍😍😍
Its 2022 and i am still crying
You can tell the difference here
1:00
and here
1:48
Yup. 😭
2:37 Who is the brown haired girl with the headband? And the tanned one at 0:46 or 1:32
ZRAM ZRAM the one with the headband is Sooyoung. The tan one is Yuri
@@Music_Lover0612 I think the one in 2:37 is sooyoung or jessica and the tanned one is yuri
💙 💙 💙 💙
💙 💙 💙
💙 💙 OT9
💙 💙 💙
💙 💙 💙
💙 💙 OT8
Still hurts.
2021 and still hurt.
I'll never get over Girls' Generation no longer being 9 members
Can you tell me why they shood two version of it one ot8 and one ot9 I know that Jessica was kicked out, but I kinda think it's strange that they first film it wiht her then without her, did they film this month apart or what?
@@marmalade751 Preparations for a comeback start long before it is released. When they started preparing the CMIYC comeback Jessica was still in the group, then they fired her, so they had to re-record the MV
@@amylovesfredastaire wow... That's really harsh, imagine you first film it with your members and then out of nowhere have to leave... The atmosphere in the studio must have been awkward at that time....
It's 2021 and the girls' 14th anniversary just passed. As a SONE since 2011, I already accepted the fact that SNSD is OT8 already but forever OT9 in my heart. SNSD and Jessica would also be happy if us SONEs and Golden Stars would be happy for what they are now, how far did they have come, and what did they achieve since 2015. Let's be happy for their successes for what makes them happy now. 💙
2.54 , when i heard ot8 's catch me if u can version at the first time, i just knew that this part must be belongs to sica..😭😭
Rizka Hami that’s true
Watch Jessica's official yt channel. Let's support Jessica together
SNSD didn’t only lost Jessica and her beautiful voice, but also lost their perfect formation
I don't care if the video has low quality 😭 I just want my ot9 back ❤😍😭💔
We've been wishing that for so long 💔😣😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
1:49 look at the difference...
Camera work on the OT8 is so much better. And Taes hair looks better in 8 too, more close ups of the girls.
It looks kind of like in OT8 they were a little off timing wise and in OT9 the moves synched better with the music. OT8 they seemed more serious too, where as OT9 everyone was more happy and energetic. Will always be OT9 for me, but doesn't stop my appreciation for them being OT8.
IDK. But taeyeon and Fany was extra pretty in the ot8 ver. I prefer the whole hair and make up in the ot8 ver.
my eyes while watching ⬅️➡️⬅️➡️⬅️
2021 and still looking for OT9 content
The harmony of Jessica's notes with taeyeon:c
OT9 STILL THE BEST
taeyeon changed a lot between the two versions 🥰 she only gets prettier as time goes by
2020 and it still hurts