Band Maid Without Holding Back - Form and Analysis
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 10. 2022
- This video analyses the form of the tune "Without Holding Back" by Band Maid. Music starts at about 1:02.
Music video:
• Video
Live versions:
• Video
#bandmaid #withoutholdingback #formandanalysis
Nice job. The more I listen to WHB, especially with a good breakdown, the more I realize just how distributed and interacting the parts are. But as always with Band-Maid, the individual lines exist for the song, never the ego.
A great in depth look at the genius of Band-Maid
素晴らしい才能を持った 子たちですよ！！、、と。
Non musician BAND-MAID lover here. Thanks for the fascinating analysis!🤘🤩🤘
You are welcome. I'm glad you got something out of it!
Fire!!!
Thanks for the analysis. Not sure why it’s taken so long for your video to pop up on my screen. I guess it’s better late than never. Cheers!
I'm glad you enjoyed it. I enjoyed making it too!
Late ☺
Intro (short) 2
Without Holding Back 8
Plus one (guitar) 1
Miku solo (loud) 8
Interlude 8
Ritornello 16
Without Holding Back 4
Plus one (drum and bass) 1
Miku solo (quieter in live) 8
Misa solo 8
Ritornello 16
Plus one (guitar) 1
Pounding theme (drums) 4
Bass solo 4
Guitar solo 8
Plus one (band) 1
Ritornello 16
Plus two (on ritornello) 2
Without Holding Back 8
Nice breakdown from a Maidiac & aficionado ! Of all the labels attached to Band Maid, prog rock usually isn’t one of them, but their instrumentals say otherwise. I found “Onset” impressive, especially live, and set a high standard, but “Without Holding Back” is next level. I grew up on great music from the 60s & 70s and Band Maid is on par with all of that music, currently they’re the best band going !
What impresses me the most about them is that they have a very wide range of musical styles. And yet she remains a Band Maid. Always...
I'm thinking I would like to do an analysis of "Onset."
@@shawngraham4155 please!
@@edhunt Here it is! czcams.com/video/e4YO4ALGURw/video.html
@@shawngraham4155 Thank you! Just subscribed earlier so didn't think to look....any chance of From Now On breakdown? Don't Be Long?
A masterful breakdown. I feel honored to be one of your first 100 subscribers!
Thanks!
Someone else observed that the guitar solo - 5:29 - uses a 'Phrygian' or classical-Spanish scale. It, the whole song actually, really reminds me of 90's Joe Satriani, for e.g. the album _The Extremist._
Sounds like Phrygian to me too. Songs like this and other instrumental songs they have done lead me to think they could do a tour like Satriani or Buckethead with just chop-heavy instrumentals.
Thanks Shawn!
I'm glad you enjoyed it!
If my discussion at the beginning is too slow for you, skip to 1:02 and see what I've done. Afterward, you can listen to my intro if you are want additional explanation.
Wonderful analysis--thanks!
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoyed it! Please subscribe!
I would be ok if they did a few songs with these longer, heavier guitar segments. Saiki would not have to sing constantly. Plus Kanami’s solos are always short.
Yes, that would be great! I did an analysis of "Onset" too. czcams.com/video/e4YO4ALGURw/video.html