Pokémon Original English Main Cast (4Kids) Panel

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 31. 07. 2024
  • See more Pokémon panels • Pokémon Panels - It’s another reunion with the original voices from the long-running series (now celebrating its 20th anime anniversary) Pokémon. The entire main cast is represented on our stage with these 4 amazing voice actors Veronica Taylor, Rachael Lillis, Eric Stuart and Tara Sands.
    The English cast for Pokémon explains what was it like to dub for the Pokémon under 4Kids; from the process of localizing the show for a English audience to reasons why the production decided to tweak and/or change some of the wording and naming in the show.
    📚 We got them back and more of them for the largest Pokémon reunion panel • We Got The Largest Pok...
    🔔 Subscribe to get notified of new panels and event coverage: czcams.com/users/ConventionC...
    Event: SacAnime Winter 2019
    Guests: Veronica Taylor, Rachael Lillis, Eric Stuart & Tara Sands
    Date Of Recording: January 5, 2019
    Recording Time: 11 AM - 12 PM PST
    📞 Connect With Us 📞
    ---------------------------------------------------
    🌐 Website: conventioncoverage.com/
    🎥 CZcams: / conventioncoverage
    👥Facebook: Convention Coverage
    📸 Instagram: ConventionCoverage
    ✉️ Contact Us: conventioncoverage.com/contac...
    ✨ For event operators interested in our consulting or video operations: conventioncoverage.com/for-ev...
    💸 Support Us 💸
    Like our content? Please consider supporting us to cover more events.
    ---------------------------------------------------
    ☕ Kofi: ko-fi.com/conventioncoverage
    ⏱️ Timestamps ⏱️ / ❓ Questions ❓
    ---------------------------------------------------
    00:00 Intro/Opening
    03:33 How do you pronounce Pokémon?
    06:40 What is your favorite thing about voicing for Pokémon?
    11:41 What is your favorite Eevee evolution or legendary Pokémon?
    13:50 If there was going to be a reboot of Dinosaur King, would you consider reprising your role in the show?
    14:32 How rare is it to play two or more characters in the Pokémon series?
    16:19 Do you have any stories working with Maddie Blaustein?
    20:01 Has there been any scenes in particular where you got emotional when recording?
    23:29 What is your favorite battle out of the entire Kanto series?
    27:05 What was your favorite scene to record and why?
    30:45 Were you ever confused by something that 4Kids had asked you to say?
    33:28 What was the entire experience working for the first eight seasons of Pokémon?
    36:27 What do you see (Technical Definition: Onigiri)?
    37:54 What is your favorite thing to voice on Pokémon?
    41:50 Do you have any roles that you did not prefer?
    47:39 What are your thoughts on the Detective Pikachu live action movie?
    51:15 How interesting was it to record Pokémon Christmas Bash?
    52:46 What kind of music does Brock listen?
    Copyright © 2019 Convention Coverage (a division of kevinphotography.net). Duplication of the video, in part or in whole, is prohibited; unless given prior written permission by Convention Coverage (conventioncoverage.com).
    Full Disclosure: Videos or events covered by Convention Coverage may have been non-monetarily supported by the event or its partners, however the video produced by Convention Coverage remains at the full discretionary control of Convention Coverage and no one other than Convention Coverage has reviewed or approved the video prior to upload.
    Affiliate Disclaimer: Convention Coverage is a participant with affiliate programs including CJ, AWIN and Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Affiliate programs are designed to provide a means for creators and publishers to earn fees by linking to merchant websites. Some of the links provided are affiliate links that Convention Coverage earns commission from, on any purchases made, at no extra cost to you.
    #ConventionCoverage #ThankYouAshAndPikachu
    Music licensed from MotionElements, Uppbeat.io, Filmstro
    Images licensed from Scop.io, JumpStory, YayImages, VectorGrove
    ChannelMDID: 30b3a9d4231b1ed48168aef1c4ac4912
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 126

  • @ConventionCoverage
    @ConventionCoverage  Před 5 lety +64

    How do we beat getting the the original main cast, by getting even more of the original cast for the largest Pokémon reunion panel ever czcams.com/video/mUe6Tce3VBk/video.html.
    Fun little fact: This panel was recorded between the airing of Sun & Moon episode 102 and 103 in japan (which are episodes that have Brock and Misty visiting the Alola region). The relation of the airing of the episodes and the date of the panel is purely coincidental.
    Weather For the day (In relation to reference in 0:01:04): Raining (Precipitation 0.23in) Highs: 52° | Lows: 36°

    • @EmiyaHilson
      @EmiyaHilson Před 5 lety

      we need more of these awesome interviews. thanks to you!! continue uploading

  • @Zoogore6777
    @Zoogore6777 Před 5 lety +128

    1:57 “I’m still ten.” ASH KNOWS. 😱🤣

  • @greninjastorm
    @greninjastorm Před 5 lety +165

    The original cast will always be the best!

    • @tristangardner3889
      @tristangardner3889 Před 5 lety +14

      My thought exactly.

    • @TheColeTruth
      @TheColeTruth Před 4 lety +12

      hands down. The only reason they were replaced is because they didn't want to pay them. The new actors are cheap replacements.

    • @TurquoiseStar17
      @TurquoiseStar17 Před 2 lety +6

      ​@@TheColeTruthYep. That's what it was all about - money, using the excuse of "Pokémon's waning popularity".
      They actually did bring Rachael back for a couple episodes during DP to voice Veilstone gym leader Maylene, and it hurt to hear Misty's voice coming from her.

    • @dwainsimmons3447
      @dwainsimmons3447 Před rokem

      Correct

    • @calvinl5726
      @calvinl5726 Před rokem

      Nostalgia talking

  • @NicoMambino
    @NicoMambino Před 5 lety +92

    Hearing Ash’s voice again from this video brings back so many nostalgic memories as a kid. It’s been forever since I’ve heard the voice.

  • @timrob12
    @timrob12 Před 5 lety +65

    Love the nice words they shared about Maddie Blaustein. Rachael was almost crying. She was wonderful as Meowth.

    • @RLviddy
      @RLviddy Před 5 lety +4

      Rachael didn't cry.

    • @PixelaGames2000
      @PixelaGames2000 Před 5 lety +1

      Maddie meowth that shall be her nick name and I’ll name a meowth after her in her honor

    • @simon_wiggle_fan
      @simon_wiggle_fan Před 2 lety +4

      I feel like that was a daring question to ask, Eric was visibly emotional in his body language but did well at hiding it unless you were really paying attention.

  • @rosecream1233
    @rosecream1233 Před 5 lety +37

    Veronica’s simple switch between ash’s voice and her normal voice is great. It also is great to see how well they know the fandom, like they still know some of the inside jokes of the fandom.

  • @Jayakrishnantr5217
    @Jayakrishnantr5217 Před rokem +34

    Veronica's natural voice always brings back memories of May and the advanced anime!! ❤❤

  • @dwainsimmons3447
    @dwainsimmons3447 Před 2 lety +54

    The 4kids VAs and musicians are actually honest, nice, kind, and respectful human beings.

    • @Mr.Derogatory316
      @Mr.Derogatory316 Před rokem +4

      Plus they were more talented and smarter individuals than the newer and current voice actors

    • @peepsg
      @peepsg Před rokem +1

      @@Mr.Derogatory316 even they are closer to Japanese actors even they respect the actors

    • @watchforever1724
      @watchforever1724 Před rokem

      @@peepsgpretty cool

    • @watchforever1724
      @watchforever1724 Před rokem

      @@Mr.Derogatory316yeah

  • @jonkeiser6092
    @jonkeiser6092 Před 5 lety +42

    You can really hear Brock in Eric's real voice.

  • @PocketNess
    @PocketNess Před 5 lety +62

    If i was there, i would've asked Eric and Rachel to recite the Team Rocket motto in character. Such a missed opportunity!

    • @eddieyyy3
      @eddieyyy3 Před 5 lety +11

      LochNES it would’ve been bittersweet since Maddie (Meowth) wouldn’t have been there to recite “MEOWTH THAT’S RIGHT!” Since she passed away in 2008 😭

    • @LostFanaticBenLinus
      @LostFanaticBenLinus Před 5 lety +5

      I just saw them at Game On Expo, where someone asked them to recite the motto. They said the crowd probably knew the whole thing better than they did, but they did the first couple of lines. And everyone went NUTS, me included. It was awesome.

  • @stevenrogers7629
    @stevenrogers7629 Před 2 lety +15

    27:21 Bulbasaur talking.

  • @simon_wiggle_fan
    @simon_wiggle_fan Před 2 lety +24

    I love how Eric points out random crap out of nowhere LOL 😂

  • @ishmael802
    @ishmael802 Před rokem +8

    It is a treat to see the orginal cast drop some backstory on a beloved show. We all know work is work for everyone. But the work they did brought a ton of joy to all of us.

    • @SmithWarben
      @SmithWarben Před rokem

      TPCi still sucks at it after over a decade, their egos are too massive to admit the 4Kids cast was better than them.

  • @andrewhunt7328
    @andrewhunt7328 Před rokem +13

    Eric Stuart is best VA. Pokemon and Yugioh fan so he is very important to me. Brock James and Seto Freaking Kaiba 😀😀

  • @NiGHTSaturn
    @NiGHTSaturn Před 2 lety +8

    4:32 Rachel’s reaction is amazing.

  • @livyfaith9616
    @livyfaith9616 Před rokem +5

    I LOVE THEM ALL SO MUCH!!

  • @ChristianAVS
    @ChristianAVS Před 10 měsíci +2

    So many great memories of the show starting and the videogame releasing almost simultaneously back in the 90s.

  • @ddot4516
    @ddot4516 Před rokem +4

    Wow voice actors do not get enough love. I never knew maddie did meow and yugi’s grandpop thats super cool

  • @aznpikachu215
    @aznpikachu215 Před rokem +3

    36:29 - The case of jelly doughnut vs. riceball (Onigirl)

  • @youknowwhat6873
    @youknowwhat6873 Před 5 lety +12

    If I was a child in their family , I would've never let them talk in normal voices .

  • @decimatorentertainmentstud8523

    Fantastic cast from back in the day.

  • @bradenbingham2835
    @bradenbingham2835 Před 4 lety +9

    Too bad Maddie Blaustein is not there because she passed away 11 years ago, Rest In Peace!

  • @cool-lemon
    @cool-lemon Před 9 měsíci +2

    They are all so incredible at their job. I never knew ANY of them did more than 1 character until I looked it up. Would never, ever of guessed Eric Stuart was Brock, James, Cassidy AND THE OG POKEDEX.

  • @GregoryAlanBaileygamereviews

    Brock and James some of the funniest cartoon characters I've ever seen.

  • @Anthony-fu6cl
    @Anthony-fu6cl Před 5 lety +12

    Loved the panel, it's great seeing all of them together. I wish they did a little sample of each character, even though Veronica and Tara did some awesome one-liners!
    I've seen all of them before besides Tara; so I was wondering who she played; but knew instantly she was Richie from the moment she talked! I had no idea she was Bulbasaur too. I was sad when Veronica didn't share her thoughts on the Detective Pikachu movie.. I think it's hard for her to give her opinion on any of the new Pokémon stuff regardless if Ash is in it or not.. She said Pikachu was an "it" at 38:32. It's hard to believe she's been gone from it for so long; she wasn't around after Hoenn when Diamond and Pearl introduced the Pikachu gender differences with the heart shaped tail... It's been so long. It makes me sad. She's my favorite 😢

    • @retrogamer6403
      @retrogamer6403 Před 5 lety

      I think the Pikachu gender difference started with Gold and Silver not Diamond & Pearl unless your talking mainly about the anime.

    • @roccaluce
      @roccaluce Před 5 lety +1

      @@retrogamer6403 Gender differences were first introduced in Generation 4, gender was first introduced in Generation 2.

  • @davidpotts4684
    @davidpotts4684 Před 5 lety +11

    Veronica Taylor: the person who wasn’t a cameo for Detective Pikachu.

    • @robertoXCX
      @robertoXCX Před rokem

      Veronica Taylor: received the greatest anime betrayal of all time

  • @sirlestondupless2482
    @sirlestondupless2482 Před 5 lety +6

    You can still hear a little bit of Brock when Eric talks.

  • @watchforever1724
    @watchforever1724 Před rokem

    This is great

  • @HamzaSoulier
    @HamzaSoulier Před měsícem

    42:00 I love her in Pokémon and never knew she was the dub va for death 13 in jjba 😂 I swear voice actors have so much range

  • @mac17601
    @mac17601 Před 4 lety +1

    I do missed these guys already. Hope PKMN Studios give them another chance again 🙏🙏🐼🐼

  • @arrogantgodjealous
    @arrogantgodjealous Před rokem +3

    53:43 you're wrong, he likes Brock & Roll!

  • @D1sT0rt10Nn
    @D1sT0rt10Nn Před rokem +1

    30:46 when I heard this question I immediately thought of the questionable way Eric pronounced “Sludge Makevoer” in that one episode in indigo league, pokemon fashion flash idk why💀💀

  • @YusufAli-cf8fp
    @YusufAli-cf8fp Před 5 lety +22

    Eric Stuart will always be Seto Kaiba

    • @chaddoesthings6298
      @chaddoesthings6298 Před 5 lety +1

      @@SeanJe777 *meta knight

    • @jjc4924
      @jjc4924 Před 5 lety

      The knight from Slayers.

    • @simon_wiggle_fan
      @simon_wiggle_fan Před 5 lety

      Brock from Pokemon and Pecky Pudgeon from Viva Pinata for me ^^

    • @simon_wiggle_fan
      @simon_wiggle_fan Před 5 lety

      @@springchickena1 Yup, Eric was called in direct Yu-Gi-Oh when it was in production and Kaiba was the only character that had not yet been cast. After trying a casting call and the producer still not hearing what he wanted, Eric offered to try out for the role and thus got the part. The sarcasm he gave Kaiba is absolutely priceless LOL XD

    • @drrllhenry
      @drrllhenry Před 4 lety

      Interplanetarypurplythorny Dragon I HAD NO IDEA KAIBA AND BROCK WERE THE SAME VOICE ACTOR

  • @stevenrogers7629
    @stevenrogers7629 Před 2 lety +2

    13:19 Stuart’s reference to The Mask movie. “We all wear a mask. Metaphorically speaking.”

  • @daltonanderson3718
    @daltonanderson3718 Před 5 lety +7

    Talk about one for the books.

  • @radarekxp
    @radarekxp Před 2 měsíci

    "I'm still ten" That should be a meme xD

  • @Destineebedoya
    @Destineebedoya Před 5 měsíci +1

    I love eric stuart

  • @onepiece-gq4kp
    @onepiece-gq4kp Před 5 lety

    Yessssssssss

  • @churchkyloren1703
    @churchkyloren1703 Před 4 lety +2

    Respectfully. Happy B-day Sailor Pluto. May the Peace Be With U. From Harlingen Texas. December 4, 1965
    December 4, 2019 through December 4, 3019

  • @beam_me_up_scotty69
    @beam_me_up_scotty69 Před rokem +2

    When it comes to the argument between which way of saying Pokémon is correct, Poke-a-mon- or Poke-ay-mon, I'd argue both are wrong, Pokémon is a shortening of the phrase Pocket Monsters so technically the correct way of saying it would be Pocke-mon

  • @nathancruz9172
    @nathancruz9172 Před 2 měsíci

    I met Veronica Taylor 2 years ago.

  • @atomicfox4390
    @atomicfox4390 Před 4 lety +1

    I met Veronica (Ash) she was super nice

  • @andrewhormazabal2766
    @andrewhormazabal2766 Před rokem +1

    I was looking at Sarah I think that she went on from 2006 and I was like Naww that's not the same voice I know and then I found this and awww yeaaa here comes the tears🥹 the OG Pokémon will forever be my Pokémon 🥹
    Also I found out why I didn't like when dawn was introduced it was in 2006 when they all left 🥺

    • @robertoXCX
      @robertoXCX Před rokem +1

      I'm sure Sarah does a really good job voicing Ash and has a lot of passion for her work. But I grew up with Ash being voiced by Veronica, and she's always going to be the "real" Ash to me.
      It totally destroyed my interest in the anime when the voice actors got changed because I was old enough to realize what had happened, and autistic enough to be too bothered by the change to continue watching the show, because everyone just sounded so wrong.
      The Pokemon Company screwed up bad not keeping the original actors and lost a viewer in me, but I'm glad that the franchise as a whole is still going strong and I still enjoy the games.

  • @greenth-mac2550
    @greenth-mac2550 Před rokem

    With all those panels, I wish there was one for Team Fortress cast

  • @Kruegerisgod
    @Kruegerisgod Před 5 lety +9

    Nurse Joy ehh 😏

  • @wiilover07
    @wiilover07 Před 4 lety +1

    Veronica's real voice is May.

  • @chelseacastillo2276
    @chelseacastillo2276 Před 5 lety +12

    The actor for Brock sounds and even looks like h3h3

  • @thenotoriousko6872
    @thenotoriousko6872 Před rokem

    É is pronounced “Ey” as in Hey as a child i said PokEEmon but educated its Pok-Ey-mon

  • @NxtChrXs727
    @NxtChrXs727 Před 7 měsíci

    I would love to see Eric acting as Brock trying to ask a girl out in front of everyone, then we'd really get to see the real thing.

  • @dancloud6744
    @dancloud6744 Před 9 měsíci

    Back in elementary school the TCG was a huge success and so teachers didn't like seeing us with cards. And I remember my 5th grade teacher saying "put away your Pokémaaan cards".
    I just found it funny the way he would intentionally mis pronounce Pokémon.

  • @derrickkelly7889
    @derrickkelly7889 Před 5 lety +5

    Thats ash lmao whatya kno

  • @dantekoryu6475
    @dantekoryu6475 Před 5 lety

    I did the Maddie Blaustein voice

    • @radogoji6863
      @radogoji6863 Před 5 lety

      Tremaine Tilford cool!

    • @tristangardner3889
      @tristangardner3889 Před 5 lety

      I think my Meowth voice almost sounds exactly like the one for the first eight seasons.

    • @aarona660
      @aarona660 Před 4 měsíci

      I try to go for a maore Nathan Price

  • @megoraptorlol
    @megoraptorlol Před 4 lety

    i say poke ee mon

  • @PocketNess
    @PocketNess Před 5 lety +26

    Oh wow, this is awesome. Ash, Misty Brock AND Jessie and James all sitting next to each other. Childhood dream come true. Really enjoyed this!

  • @JustJesse197
    @JustJesse197 Před 5 lety +18

    Watching this made me so happy! I laughed so hard when Veronica Taylor said, "I'm still 10" She is so funny! We love Veronica Taylor so much! She is the one and only Ash Ketchum ♥ (and May/Delia). All her Ash impressions here were spot on! I can still hear Ash in her normal talking voice. She's super talented. Eric Stuart, Rachael Lillis, Madeleine Blaustein, and Tara Sands made Pokemon the success that it is. It was a huge disservice to replace them. They made the characters come to life and they bring so much talent and emotion to each one of the characters they play. They are all amazing on Pokemon! I would love to attend one of their panels in real life and meet Veronica Taylor (the Legend!) one day. They make Pokemon Seasons 1-8, & Movies 1-7 memorable. I watched Pokemon from when the very first episodes aired on TV, and Veronica Taylor will always be the true Ash. My favorite episodes are when Team Rocket works with the "twerps" as they call them "Hoenn episode, "The Bicker the Better" ("I'm not a girl, May"-Ash) among others, and the battles in the Indigo League with Richie. My favorite battle in the series is the one between Gary's Umbreon and Alex Davis from Cherrygrove City's Alakazam (Power Play). Hopefully the original (and best) cast gets to come back one day!

  • @AnimationMovies411
    @AnimationMovies411 Před 5 lety +28

    Cool! I actually met Rachael and thanked her for her inspiration and influence at Tucson comic con last November. It was a lot awkward but very cool nevertheless! Thanks for the opportunity, Ms. Lillis! :)

    • @tristangardner3889
      @tristangardner3889 Před 5 lety +2

      You met Rachael Lillis in person? I'd really like to meet her, Veronica and Eric and show them my voice of Meowth. My family says it sounds almost exactly like the original for the first eight seasons.

  • @LeafRazorStorm
    @LeafRazorStorm Před 5 lety +38

    "I thought you meant Jojo's Circus" VERONICA, YOU WIN!!

  • @Macandbloo11
    @Macandbloo11 Před 4 lety +10

    31:31 So that's the reason why rice balls were changed to donuts.

  • @fishfillet5555
    @fishfillet5555 Před 5 lety +35

    Miss them :(

  • @DonVal86
    @DonVal86 Před 5 lety +21

    Heracross vs Scizor was one of my favorites, even though it was from the Johto Journeys.

    • @Razi98
      @Razi98 Před 5 lety +1

      Just watched that one today since I'm continuing from where I last left off 😊

    • @DonVal86
      @DonVal86 Před 5 lety +1

      Razi Dude One of the best. 👍

    • @ishmael802
      @ishmael802 Před rokem

      I think I had the same reaction as the Voice of Misty. Heracross animation was pretty awesome.

  • @eddieyyy3
    @eddieyyy3 Před 5 lety +4

    When they were remembering Maddie Blaustein aka Meowth 😭. I was devastated when I read an article about her passing.

  • @geckomcvr
    @geckomcvr Před 5 lety +4

    Eric Stuart use to play as Seto Kaiba

  • @chez2008
    @chez2008 Před 5 lety +12

    We need the original pokemon crew back

  • @DJDizzyStorms
    @DJDizzyStorms Před 5 lety +2

    I'd ask them what was the most embarrassing line you ever had to say & what're your favorite episodes from past seasons?

  • @AWISECROW
    @AWISECROW Před 5 lety

    That was pretty good

  • @tonyanthonyironman4352

    Mahn I would had asked. What do they think about the current cast of Pokemon? To each of them. Like what Veronica thinks about Sarah as Ash, Eric thinks about Bill Rogers as Brock and Rachael what does she thinks about Michelle Knotts as Misty and Jesse?

  • @tonyanthonyironman4352
    @tonyanthonyironman4352 Před 5 lety +2

    Wow Rachael Lillis sounds like Jesse 😍

  • @dbeltran098
    @dbeltran098 Před 5 lety +3

    So Pokémon was broadcast in the day I was born September 8,1998

  • @cosmicXtropics
    @cosmicXtropics Před 4 lety

    YOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO DINOSAUR KING!

  • @Predreus
    @Predreus Před 5 lety +4

    Rest is Piece Maddie Blaustein

  • @skanchan4522
    @skanchan4522 Před 4 lety +1

    Delia!

  • @simon_wiggle_fan
    @simon_wiggle_fan Před 5 lety +9

    Did you happen to record Eric Stuart's voice acting/directing panel?

    • @ConventionCoverage
      @ConventionCoverage  Před 5 lety +4

      Yes, we have it scheduled to be rendered and published in the coming weeks.

    • @simon_wiggle_fan
      @simon_wiggle_fan Před 5 lety

      @@ConventionCoverage :D Did you only record panels or did you get any of the other events like Eric's solo acoustic, ect?

    • @ConventionCoverage
      @ConventionCoverage  Před 5 lety +1

      We mainly cover panels for various reasons, including restrictions from any potential Content ID, any associations that the guest is with that restricts certain things, etc. We do have some things other than panels we cover but they are released under other productions that has a contract with us.
      As for Eric's solo acoustic, we did not cover it due to a restriction by the SAG (Screen Actors Guild) association.

  • @chelsearoy194
    @chelsearoy194 Před 4 lety +1

    Pokemon one do Original Engilsh Dubbed (4Kids) people know fact this panel was recorded between which are episodes that have my friendship Ash Misty Brock and Pikachu more visiting the Alola region relation of airing time where the main voice actors together. Reasons need these will then a villains from if Team Rocket only be Jessie, James and Meowth first could come your destiny has of Pokemon Master other games.

    • @ConventionCoverage
      @ConventionCoverage  Před 4 lety

      The voice actors probably did not know the panel occurred between the two episode arc where Misty and Brock was visiting Ash in the Alola region cause they don't follow the Pokemon series as much anymore, not to even note that it was the Japanese airtime. As we noted "The relation of the airing of the episodes and the date of the panel is purely coincidental." As for the staffs working in the room, we had a little private pre-day watch party just to chill before the con day started in the room.

  • @onepiece-gq4kp
    @onepiece-gq4kp Před 5 lety

    I say pokamon and pokemon

  • @paulpavlus6664
    @paulpavlus6664 Před 5 lety +2

    I sure wish they could meet the Non-4kids Voice Actors, such as Jim Cummings, Charlie Adler, Rob Paulsen, Tara Strong, Grey Delisle, Tress McNeil, Keven Michel Richardson, Tom Kenny, Jeff Bennet, Gary Chalk, Kate Micucci, Samuel Vincent, etc. ?