Cheap Vs Expensive 6,000# Mini Excavators!
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 05. 2023
- Welcome back! This is basically part 2 of the 6,000# Chinese mini excavator journey. you can watch the initial review and video at • 6,000 Pound Diesel Chi...
Before you go saying that Yanmar is a crappy off brand machine I would encourage that you go do some research. They were the original inventors of the mini excavator and make some of the best Diesel engines in the world.
Make sure to check out digitsupplyco.com to get entered in the dozer giveaway that ends in just over a week!
The Chinese machine with a enclosed cab is a great deal for a gentlemen farmer but if you need the machine for work everyday the Yanmar is probably worth the investment.
A narrow and deep bucket would make a huge difference on the cheap excavator
You have the best channel for heavy equipment content, incredibly funny and informative at the same time.
The skinnier bucket will slice into the ground much easier; this was not a real digging comparison between machines, only the buckets. Swap buckets then see how it goes.
The Chinese machine was labouring fairly hard when trying to break out but that could be the bucket as well. Either way it’s still a very capable machine. For the price it sure beats hiring one all the time.
It's not about speed or towing on a jobsite, but price point and excavating power or lift
I’ve owned a yanmar for 11 years the best small tractor for the money. Work horse. Sips fuel. Thanks from. Sc
Make sure to give this a like and follow! its totally FREE and helps me out a lot!
Great video! Subscribed. We’ve literally just been talking about this very thing.
Loving this comparison. Greetings from Springfield Missouri 🤘
tbh for alot of usecases and applications, the chinese one is a no brainer for 15k. thats some value, especially if you can add aircon ;D
Hell yeah finally the full video!
Hope you enjoyed
There's a lot of videos on Chinese equipment out there. I like this one because you've done a fair comparison between a quality machine and a budget Chinese excavator. Most guys who buy those Chinese loaders and diggers are DIY'ers and homeowners who don't use the equipment daily in a commercial setting.
Exactly right!
Well duhh 😂
Thanks for the obvious
Hmm so by going with the Yanmar I can save about 10 seconds when digging a shallow grave. Good to know, good to know 🤫
That wasn't even fair. It's like running the wrong end of a spoon through a bucket of ice cream vs the shovel end of the spoon. Most people that have multiple buckets for a full size or mini hoe could tell you a trenching bucket is easier on the pumps. The only real benefit I see is stability and traction.
How much extra you paying for that 5 seconds got me messed up lol. Have fun with that
buy American dont be a trader
@@jleighgod8149look up the nearly half a billion a 1/4 US steel mills are profiting. Then come back and say that.
@@jleighgod8149 You mean “USA made “ even then most parts aren’t even made in USA
This past spring i was in the position of either buying a brand new chinese 3 ton or a 20 year old Kobelco 3 ton and decided to go with the Kobelco. I know theres parts available and the chinese quality is just not there yet.
i have putchased chinese attachments in the past and have always spent money on repairs or having to get parts custom machined to work.
I’m at these cross roads as well. Chinese parts are relatively cheap compared to big brand machines. Imagine replacing a track motor on a Chinese one vs kubota or cat ect. $600 for a Chinese one and it would be at least a few thousand for the latter.
I think the china unit has a fixed displacement pump, so it's just fast all the time.
If it had a variable displacement pump like every other machine. I think it'll give that yanmar a run for its money...
But it's built at a price point.
Great video yet again love it man so glad u got a big one to try out
Ive loved useing the yanmar as a rental for our projects. That said, we are considering buying the Agro so we can spread out jobs and not be in such a rush. Looks like a solid platform. That said, def agree with the yanmar quality. Operating without pump whine and stable movement. The more expensive systems purr like a smooth cat. Also love the coke bottle layout vs obese tub o lard. But at less than half price and intermittent use its hard to complain about agro.
Great video very well made keep it up
Just posted a video of my Chinese mini excavator paired up with the TMK 150 tree sheer! Crazy how productive you can make a cheap machine!
Pump is made by same co. as most, Eaton. I have one.
Great test! Moar!
for extra pulling power you want as much weight to the back of the machine for as much advantage as possible. you also risk flipping over backwards, but thats the balance. Also you V tread was the wrong direction for best traction. Great video though
Im gonna have to sub to this channel😂. Keep them coming i cant wait for the next one👍👍👍
The cheap digger sounds like it’s about to stall out every time it takes a scoop. The Yama has a constant rev when digging
Can I ask if you know how to get to the battery?
How much would it cost to retrofit the Chinese excavators (small and bigger one) with new hydraulic hoses with quick release fittings?
Yanmar is definitely not an "off-brand", like you said.
If you're going to test two machines try and put a experience driver on them
Agreed, and use the same bucket!
Even the cheap one is too expensive for me 😂but with that sorta money I’d deffo buy a modern tractor
great video man. made me laugh a few times. Im seriously interested in buying a machine from china. I'm looking at a 4 Ton excavator. Im up in the great white north here in Canada but id imagine the prices would be similar. what are you all in after imports and buying it from the factory?
Look at UHI brand, i went to see them in person and they are the best looking chinese diggers. They really are the highest quality of them. I ordered a UME12P. They are a little pricier than the generic chineese but i think they're worth it.
If it takes 30 seconds to dig half a hole, how long does it take to dig a whole hole?
(A lot of times)
If you're *just digging dirt* and *not lifting* a heavy load, it's better to have the *blade at the back;* ..to get that *dig force* and not pop the front end up every time :-)
That's not been my experience at all.
I found a hitachi zx60 with a cutting blade and cab for 15,000 dollars, this is shipping, insurance, and freight. The machine is 54 hp, and weighs 6 tons. Low hours in good shape. Is this a good deal? It ships out of china
Is it legit? A lot of stuff is counterfeit in China.. Great price but make sure it's real
At least your a pro and not some.....( Insert description here). And have practical knowledge of trenching and dirt work. Love the channel
I look at it... If buying brand new if people have 50K to spend then yammer would be the way to go.. but if not then maybe the 15K is the way to go and Perkins engine is a good motor I had farm tractors with the same motor and here it is over 30 years later and they are still running very strong... And on any thing anyone buys there's always room for improvement to make it way better....
The Yanmar dug effortlessness. I could hear the other one straining when digging. A very nice machine, but wow 50K new? For wow, for the price difference the smaller one wasn’t all that bad. But how long would it last also would be extremely important. Nice video!
Yanmar also had a narrower bucket which makes it easier to pull through the ground
If buying Chinese 15K one after you get it as lots of people do is buy after market stuff to make improvements to make it better Perkins engine are good motors my dad had farm tractors that had Perkins engine in them and over 30 years later they are still running very strong
Well! Longevity depends on many factors. The Chinese stuffs like this machine runs for around 3 years and then off to the scrap yard. On the other hand, if you have extra parts and a proper mechanic service from the company that you bought it from, then you can make it work longer actually. Although, as I said, it all depends. My mate when he started off his gardening/landscaping company, he bought a cheap Chinese machine, and then bought a used Jcb from the profit of that. The most important aspects are service and spare parts!!
Im shocked you only have 10k subs. Your channel will blow up with content like this
I hope so man! glad you like it
50k vs 15 K ! i will take 15 k for DIY projects ! My local dealer wants 24 k for same Chinese exc
It would have been interesting to see if you put both facing the truck and the blade down and then used the stick/boom/bucket curl to see if either one would have pulled the truck forward.
Great video! Does the cheap one have heat and ac with cab? I still would prefer the cheaper one only because I would use it around my mini farm and I don’t count my time. Because time is money when you use them for your business
Yanmar is absolutely NOT an offbrand. They have probably better engines than Kubota and I own Kubota stuff. I plan to get an Yanmar SV40 in the coming months,
Great info, means alot for us China machine buyers! Thx
Perfect ❤
I've heard it said that the Japanese focus on quality and the Chinese focus on reducing the cost as much as possible.
It’s not even a question if your contracting . The down time on that Chinese machine when running it 9 hrs a day would be horrendous. Chinese one would be ok for the weekend warrior .
Great comparison! Now let’s see you add some air conditioning on that Chinese mini! I went at looked at the same excavator at Richie bros auction in Tipton and the headliner had fallen down on that one too 😂
$15,000 vs $50,000 - no need to go any further.
Plus parts for these Chinese machines are way cheaper than any big brand machines
Can the pumps be replaced on the Chinese machine, and if so, how much approximately to replace them?
Standard Eaton pump
You know if you swap few parts the china ones work great for about 90% for what most people will use them for
you started the cheap one pulling the truck where the other 1 stopped been able to pull it
i would have to say Kubota and Hitachi are my favorite
JCB make a really nice digger with brilliant hydraulic package but maybe not going to the US.😊
Im curious about how that Ali Express unit you gave away compares. lol
He did a video on comparing those two already
Did a video!czcams.com/video/aHSiWWRl3dU/video.html
Love Yanmar!!
Iv ran the yanamar an I told super to haul it to the scrap. Could pick nothing up very weak
The Yanmar appears to have a bigger bucket which would move more material in the same time .
Here me out here, if size and weight was exact I think china would have kept up with those test. Now as far as the pull test, the tread on china was running backwards. I almost wonder if it would have done it or broke. Lol
There's no way that thing make 25 hp.
The yanmar engine, supposedly lower hp, dig harder and never ever bog down.
the Perkins does. Very high reving compared to the Yanmar. The bogging has to do with the type, and quality of hydraulic pumps. Better designs and higher torque pumps can do more with less
diesel creek intro , anyone else notice that?
The snaller excavator are not like thr bigger one. Use the boom an stick along with the bucket. Insted just curling the bucket like you done with chinese one. In my opinion they have there advantages but both are weak. An you have a bigger bucket on the chinese one so its going make the surface area plowing in a lil harder verse a smaller bucket.
How much did you actually pay for the unit and where did you buy? Thank you!
Think he said $14K at auction. Can buy from the distributor for $19K. They are putting these on auction around the country - saw one sell for $10K and another as high as $21K, with median around $16K (need to add in buyer's premium for auction prices). Even at $19K+tax, I think they may make sense for small ranch/homestead. But at $20K, you are getting close to used prices for older name-brand machines (maybe $25K range). Personally, I'd pay more to find a good used name-brand - they are so much more precise/user-friendly than Chinese stuff (better hydraulic pumps/motors/valves/design).
Great video comparison. This may help the Chinese manufacturing to up its parts and quality, and companies ie @Yanmar to reduce theirs as more and more of these imports flood the U.S/Canadian/worldwide market.
Yanmar are in all of the sub 50hp class John Deere tractors. Surprised anyone would try to knock a product with decades of reliability.
Takeuchi used to run yanmar engines and were dead nuts reliable but then the feds and there exhaust laws hit and they swapped to kubota engines.... just not the same machines since then...
Nante?
More expensive wins. It's obvious because it cost 3 times more. But... is it 3 times better than cheap one?
I like how he always speak equally and give them a fair opinion!!
Ive watched every one of these chinese tractor videos youve done. Are the name brand ones better? Of course! Are they 3 times better??? Im thinking not... Especially not for the diy just likes to play woth giant toys kinda guy like me...
I mean the bucket is half the size on the cheapo one so not really equal is it
All you gotta do is lower the acceleration and you would have better control on the cheap one 😂
as the old saying goes , compare apples to apples . not oranges to lemons. but for me and my little place the Chinese would do just great.
For 35k you could buy yourself a decent used truck and trailer to haul it, maybe a case of beer too
Iam sure the chain drive system creates slop in the movement.
I think ill stick with my Komatsu equipment. Komatsu equipment is by far the smoothest strongest dozers and hoes on the market in my opinion. I would take a Komatsu dozer over any brand period. By far the best dozers. That yanmar does look alot like a Komatsu mini.
Well....similar in specs but looks like your kidneys stayed intact on the yanmar. Did you enjoy the bronc ride on the chinexcavator?😅
try popular chinese brands Liugong, Sany, XCMG, SDLG
Caterpillar is not running Perkins anymore. My 259d3 has a Kubota
they use to a lot in the multi terrain loaders. apparently the 3.3 Kubota has noting but problems with CAT and Tak machines
@@dig_it_starnes5222 They are absolute turds that’s for sure. My 262b gets used more than the 259d. Should have got a skid with the yanmar but I’ve never had anything outside of CAT and JLG
Both need More Cowbell!
Lmao
Everything needs more cowbell
Can you compare LiuGong with Yanmar?
How about use them for 10 years and then do a comparison.
would need back surgery after owning the china one. like to see how many repairs would have to be done after a few thousand hours.
Let’s put a JCB To the test
The Yanmar isn't $30,000 better...
Most concerning to me about Chinese equipment is you’re one component away from owning a boat anchor. After sales support is crucial .
All name brand components just lower end for a quarter the price it's a hydraulic pump 3 hydraulic motors and 5 hydraulic cylinders not much else to go wrong
They put the loop on the back of the bucket for a reason
There isn’t one on the Chinese mini. Was trying to keep it fair
Did you call locates in before you dug? Safety first, lol
Hi Do you need some great lighting for your car to help you better driving, off-road. We're the pro auto lighting manufacturer for nearly 20 year and we're looking for sponsorship!
Little biased but good video but you put the same bucket on both then you get same results but for a regular guy the Chinese wins hands down
AGT What is the company?
Agrotk is the same I believe.
@@t.p.9232 ？
@@GOPHERS_PC10 AGT is also sold under the name "Agrotk"
@@t.p.9232ok
yanmar is great
I like Yanmar and Takeuchi better than cat, bobcat and John Deere.
So 3 to one ratio
10 seconds difference 😂
yanmar is far from offbrand. they make all the deere motors
5000usd,come to me
50k = 3 machines 😂 no thank
Yanmar is the best for your money. The very best is Deere. Between the machines shown, the Yanmar is the only machine I would spend money on.
Deere minis are 1000000% Hitachi machines built in Japan.
Not anymore. Their contract ended. I believe wacker neuson will make the frames starting soon
@@dig_it_starnes5222 my dealer hasn't heard anything on that yet. Still have Hitachi/deere on the lot. Wacker cant even keep up with there own manufacturing. I would never purchase anything other than minis built in Japan. Us builds junk . Sad but true
@@dig_it_starnes5222 doesn't mean anything. Every deere machine built to date is Hitachi. Contract ended yes but deere still purchasing from Hitachi. I did hear about wacker a while back haven't seen anything. And if deere designed there own larger lines not going to happen over night .
@@dig_it_starnes5222 Pity, Japan revolutionized modern excavators with precise controls and much-higher pressures. They ran rings around the 215/225/235/245 Cat stuff at 75% of the price. Cat threw in the towel after a few years and partnered with Mitsubishi to learn how to build a modern excavator. We bought a new grey market Cat EL200B- came with a Mitsubishi engine for about half what Cat wanted for the exact same (except Cat-powered) machine sold domestically. The Mitsubishi engine was fantastic - quiet/fuel-efficient and zero problems.
@@dig_it_starnes5222those are for markets outside the US. Theyre still Hitachi until Deere has their own design up and going
The review already started with a bias. 😂
Gotta consider yanmar had smaller bucket easier to dig in compacted ground and just wondering how much you have used a yanmar like that one and how much you have on the one....more experience on the yanmar would go to the reason some of the ease of operation....kinda sound biased
You might prefer yanmar over bobcat,,,but it is still an off brand machine....
Korea's Doosan bought Bobcat - I'd take Japanese-built Yanmar's vs Korean-built Bobcat's.