Noam Chomsky Discusses Israel with Professor John Haas
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 11. 2022
- Noam Chomsky talks with Professor John Haas about UN Security Council Resolution 242 regarding Israel's annexation and occupation of Palestine. Accuses Israel of starving, harassing and murdering Palestinians while US supports Israel with policy decisions. War crime probes by the International Court of Justice and more.
Chomsky explains how US vetoes of resolutions that oppose their policy, as well as US military aid to Israel, have prevented a diplomatic solution.
Chomsky also critiques Israel's narrative of being a defensive and reactive force, and suggests ways to protest US policy towards Israel, such as an anti-apartheid struggle and the possibility of an international criminal court war crimes probe into the 2014 assault on Gaza.
Filmed on 3/20/2018 at the University of Arizona.
I'm guessing Chomsky has never been awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom.
He should be.
@@gary100dm Imo his contribution is beyond any national boundary. In case humanity makes it through this century, it should give him a planetary/ species award.
lol, there is a video of Chomsky laying out how every president since WW2 could be found guilty of war crimes. Must watch.
that's because he dribbles shit and thinks that the USA is the only bad actor on the world stage.
man this guy is so spot on. legend thinker. special human.
I've read him for 30 years. What he says will happen, happens. lol
I am a disabled veteran. When I see a young man taking a knee during the national anthem, It makes me proud. Some young Americans could never imagine segregation, that's a good thing.
Blacks that fought in WW1 and 2 came home to Jim Crow and were exempted from the GI-Bill just for starters.
When I hear the anthem I take my di## out.
The conscience of the world. Long live Noam!
Great comment.
He’s an Epstein boy so maybe just keep it at his foreign policy. Leave the morals out of it
oh, please. He's a denier of the Cambodian genocide and the genocide in the former Yugoslavia. He is loathed in Eastern Europe and parrots Putin's talking points on Ukraine. You are misinformed.
@@Conn30Mtenor LOL. Can you read? If you could you would not have read any of that in Chomsky.🤣
@@Conn30Mtenor Obviously you've never listened to Noam at all.
One of the few people who speaks the truth to Israel (and the US) oppression of the Palestinians and NOT be accused of being anti-semitic. I refused to be subject that gaslighting any longer!!!
We don’t need this man
Israel is supposed to present the incident to the Security Council and the relevant international organizations... etc. and a decision is taken. For example, every country is obligated to hand over members of Hamas because the leaders are not in Palestine in the first place, Israel barbaric behavior is unacceptable. It cannot be a state and act like a terrorist militia. Because the terrorist militia does not have an entity like the state and it can be held accountable. Simply put, Israel opponent is a terrorist militia, but the Palestinians who were killed their opponent is the State of Israel.
@@haifaitthat is true. we don't need his opinion either, lol
@@haifait Respectfully, the oppression of Palestine has gone on far to long. I think we need everyone we can get at this point.
Don't worry, Zionist call him anti-semitic allll the time. It's hilarious
Propaganda works so well, I thought this was such a complexed issue that it was beyond my comprehension. It seems pretty clear to me that this story is taught in a way that we don’t want to question anything. “The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing”
This man is! ❤
a turd?
@@user-cg5nx6fz5c stop projecting your father on him
I want to thank Professor Noam Chomsky to have the courage to say what is and to push us to see what is.
Well put 🙂👍.
You take their land, then move in and dare them to do anything about it.
I agree, I do have to say USA is the most bigot country. No such thing as Democracy in their own country. I sure would like to see if an American citizen is going to let a neighbor move into their property and start building on it. The difference is that Palatine has no support from any countries to help them. They had to take action on their own. Yes it was barbaric but Israel has barbaric actions they have taken to keep trying to take their land.
I'm sure the Native Americans feel the same way too.
@@aa2339Genocide is what ended the Native American uprisings. Sadly it was the poor working class that were forced to go kill so that the ruling elites could profit off the land.
Thank you all for the comments. Much appreciated. The interview took place in March 2018.
Most disturbing is that media does not report this madness.
I've started collecting his written work. Haven't yet had a chance to read it all, but I feel like it's important for me to do it. Try to give myself some balance and understanding to my education so far.
What a great mind he has and much knowledge to impart. A real light in the dark.
Just wait until you get to the parts where he denies the Cambodian and Bosnian genocides.
He's not a historian. He's made too many mistakes in the name of his political allegiances.
Go slow reading him, it can be very heavy for the heart
Lol sorry your brain is made of mush
Professor Chomsky says it the way it is. He sees through the smoke which the frenemies produce, and lays it on the table.
Another great interview professor I thank you for sharing this conversation
Many thanks!!!
Noam is my intellectual father. I got more out of one book of his than in all my college education.
Always the voice of reason.
I'll wait for Noam Chomsky 4K.
Haha literally.
where is professor chomsky nowadays , wish him health and would love to hear his views.
And a year later it only got an order of magnitude worse...
Thank you!
I would love to know what books he has in his library. If I ever knew I'd probably go bankrupt buying all of them, but oh man, what a treat.
I totally get that. i just want to learn from this man. wish he was my teacher.
One of his books, Manufacturing Consent, is a deep dive into the process of acheiving acceptance of socio-economic and political change through 'manufactured consent' as the title implies. It is also a documentary on CZcams if you prefer to watch. The CZcams video also incorporates a bio of Noam's activism and interviews throughout his career.
The book is a bit of a heavy read at times and the documentary smoothens that out.
I encourage you to read/watch.
2:50
I get the impression that if I were President and didn't do the usual American veto of the UN Security Council resolution on Israel I would somehow get shot in the head.
Correct
Abolish veto privileges in the UN and see half of global conflicts disappear in no time.
One can dream…
Y
Thanks, for a great interview
a candid wise man
Tesekkurler 🇹🇷🌷
thank you
An honorable man... a great man... an honest man... an educated man... a man of good character...
You forgot to include a naive man…a collectivist man…a socialist man…a useful fool for radical Muslims man.
Important context.
One person getting hurt over this is too much. They need to work out a peace deal. It is 2023. Almost 2024. Ask Bard how to fix it and the leaders need to do what Bard says.
I wish everyone would watch dis and would love to see him on 60 minutes for American would know what is really going on over there and why these people can't get along
Outstanding!!
The Palestinians are being unmercifully massacred. They have nowhere to run. November 7, 2023
The wisdom of this man....
A living legend!!
How can you be zionist and pro israel when Nelson Mandela, Malcolm X and even Albert Einstein were vocally against “israel”…😅
Einstein was not.., he allowed himself to be seduced gradually by zionist murdering planning, to steal an Israel
He references 2020 like it’s in the future. When was this recorded?
2018 according to the creator
At 23mins, does anyone which norman Finkelstein book in particular they are taking about?
Love him ❤
Anyone know the name of the Norman Finkelstein book Nome mentions
I think its his book "Gaza."
Nothing but respect for this guy.
🙏🏼🙏🏾🙏
Reading this end of November 2023, highly instructive. I need to learn review and understand the history of what really happened . Recall that the young Chomsky entertained the idea of joining a communal kibutz and later required police protection to speak truth about what was happening at MIT. Education, direct action to change US Foreign Policy. Please read Jeffrey Sachs address to the UN Security Council on Nov 22 calling for the 5 permanent members of the security Council to stop all four raging wars! Come to agreement! Cease all 4'wars.
16:00 the fake talking point about the 2005 "withdrawal" I've seen online so much this last 2 weeks.
Good vid. When was it filmed - Chomsky looks younger and healthier
Finkelstein's book, which they mention, came out in January of 2018, and so, it was probably filmed in early 2018.
From the video's description: "Filmed on 3/20/2018 at the University of Arizona."
What happens when you mix duplicity with diplomacy.
What’s the actual date this was filmed?
Filmed on 20 March 2018 at the University of Arizona, according to the description.
They never mention which of Norman Finklesteins books they’re talking about
Well it's March 2018...would be the one published in the preceeding months of that same year.
All of his books are great
Doesn’t matter how smart you are, there’s somebody out there just as smart as you who will completely disagree with every word you say. Funny how that works. Pick your truth I guess.
'The Setback' or حرب 1967, Harb 1967, 'War of 1967'), also known as the June War, the 1967 Arab-Israeli War or the Third Arab-Israeli War, was an armed conflict fought from 5 to 10 June 1967 between Israel and a coalition of Arab states primarily comprising Jordan, Syria and Egypt (then known as United Arab Republic ).
1967 war: Six days that changed the Middle East - BBC News
It came to a head with a full-scale air and artillery battle between Israel and Syria on 7 April, 1967. Israel routed the Syrians. The next morning young Palestinians in Jerusalem, according...
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
❤🇸🇩❤
I have watched multiple interviews with this man. He never has anything positive to say about the the country he lives in!
All you’ve got to do is believe their book and their magic guy in the sky.
👍👍✅✅
Noam Chomsky is Jewish is he not? i think yes.. i love the truth... objective reality is the best reality to live from...
Yes!!!
whatever will i do, he's just sum guy - bart simpson
Grandpa, would you please tell me a story... lol
Im not sure why this is lol to you
He takes kind of an unfair dig at Margaret Mead here but this is great
How is it unfair
Taken a bit out of context. Mead produced fairly complex work on Russian attitudes to authority that goes quite a bit further than child rearing. Granted, it's just a throwaway comment from Noam. @@idontknowmuch3441
how do you explain the exponential growth of population in Gaza if they were kept on a diet and posioned?
No birth control
Not many of us know the biblical history of Israel of who lived where or who lived with who on this land so much fought over are there a list of bullet points.Interested in the era of the Canaanites.Pretty much need that is as I may need some correcting with my present views.
My 4th favourite psycholoreallowgist after nimrod hesift and beazel
5:00
29:30
Chomsky is a fortuneteller. Oh, that peace trigge Hamas. Oh, poor realistic Hamas!
1967 war: Six days that changed the Middle East
Fifty years ago, war broke out between Israel and its neighbours. The conflict lasted just six days but its effect would last to the present day.
By 1967, Egypt was bogged down in a war in Yemen that had become its own Vietnam. It had not fought well. But Nasser could not replace Amer with a better soldier.
The Syrian army was equally politicised, and like Egypt was a client of the Soviet Union. A series of generals were rotated into power by a series of coups d'état.
Arabs talked a lot about unity, socialism and nationalism, but in reality they were deeply disunited. The Syrian and Egyptian leaderships fretted about plots allegedly instigated by the monarchies in Jordan and Saudi Arabia. Kings worried that the military populists who led Syria and Egypt would incite revolution.
After the 1948 war, Jordan and Israel came close, but not close enough, to making peace. Secret talks continued into Hussein's reign. He was aware of Jordan's weaknesses - it was mainly desert and had a large and restive population of Palestinian refugees.Syrian syndrome
War in 1967 came as a result of years of increasing tension and vicious border skirmishes between Arabs and Israelis.
The border between Egypt and Israel was relatively quiet. The biggest flashpoint was Israel's northern border with Syria, where they fought over disputed territory and Syria's attempts to divert the River Jordan away from Israel's national water grid.The Americans responded 42 minutes after the announcement from Cairo, dangling the prospect of a visit by the US Vice-President Hubert Humphrey if the crisis was averted. President Lyndon Johnson was angry.
The UN Secretary General U Thant was in the air, flying to Cairo on a peace mission when Nasser made his new threat. Nasser repeated the promise he had already made to the Americans and the Soviets, that Egypt would not fire the first shot.But U Thant concluded gloomily that unless a way could be found around the blockade of Eilat, war was certain.
Pressure to strike
i"I said… 'I'm going to recommend a war'.
"McNamara asked only two questions. 'How long?' I said it would take a week. 'How many casualties?' I said less than the war of independence, which was 6,000. McNamara said 'I read you loud and clear'."
The Americans had given a clear signal. They had been told that Israel would be going to war and had made no attempt to stop it happening.
Amit travelled back to Israel with the Washington ambassador, Abe Harman, on an aircraft full of gas masks. They arrived in Tel Aviv on the evening of Saturday 3 June.
A car took them straight to Eshkol's apartment, where he was waiting with his key ministers. Amit wanted an immediate war. Harman wanted to wait another week or so.
Daan disagreed: "If we wait for seven to nine days, there will be thousands dead. It's not logical to wait. Let's strike first and then look after the political side."
Everyone who was there had no doubt that the decision had been taken. Israel was going to war. The cabinet ratified it the next morning.
In Egypt, Nasser predicted Israel would attack on 4 or 5 June. He based his observation on the progress of an Iraqi armoured division, which was heading towards the Jordan Valley and Israel. He knew Israel would not tolerate such a change in the balance of forces.
Surprise attack
By 07:40 on 5 June, Ezer Weizman could hardly stand the suspense in the Air Force command centre in the ministry of defence in Tel Aviv.
raeli war plan depended on a surprise attack, called Operation Focus, which would destroy the Arab air forces on the ground, starting with Egypt.
They had trained for it for years and the first wave of attacks was about to go in.
Media caption,
By 20:17 it was reporting that 86 Israeli aircraft had been destroyed and that Egyptian tanks had broken into Israel. At the headquarters of the Sinai front, General Mohamed Abdel Ghani Gamasy listened "with growing horror" to what he knew was a pack of nonsense.
Years later I asked Ahmed Said why he had told outright lies on air. In his crumbling, once-grand apartment overlooking the Nile, he defended himself.
Egyptian warplanes lie destroyed on the tarmac after an Israeli Air Force pre-emptive strike June 5, 1967 against Egyptian airfields at the start of the Six-Day War.Image source, Empics
Image caption,
5 June: Egyptian warplanes destroyed on the tarmac
"You're asking people to fight, not dance… we believed the broadcasts were our most powerful weapon… many of our listeners were illiterate, so radio was the most important way to reach them."
He stayed in the job until his death in 1970. Field Marshal Amir died in mysterious circumstances. His family was convinced he was poisoned.
King Hussein of Jordan lost East Jerusalem but kept his throne. He continued his secret dialogue with Israel and made peace in 1994.
But the mood in Israel blew away any suggestion of caution as decisively as the Israeli army had dealt with the Arabs. In just under a week of war the Israeli public went from despair to the joy of deliverance.
Religious Jews believed that the victory was a miracle that had been given to them by God. Secular Israelis felt the electricity of the moment. Hanan Porat, a paratrooper who went on to become a leader of the settlement movement, never forgot the sight of his secular comrades weeping at the Western Wall, a remnant from the time of the second Jewish Temple, in East Jerusalem, a few minutes after they captured it.
faced was that Palestinians believed it was their land, and their duty to protect the holy places they venerated.
Map of Jerusalem before and after 1967
President Johnson's Middle East adviser Bob Anderson warned a month after the war that Jerusalem had a special significance for Arabs. "The Old City of Jerusalem is capable of stirring mobs in the streets to the point where the fate of our most moderate friends in the Middle East will be in jeopardy and the basis laid for a later holy war."
Some Israelis thought they might be able to trade some of the captured territory for peace, though not East Jerusalem which was enlarged with the addition of a band of territory from the West Bank and then annexed.
At a summit in Khartoum at the end of August, Arab states were in no mood to go cap in the hand to the country that had humiliated them, again. Arab leaders said there would be no negotiations, no recognition and no peace with Israel.
Paradoxically, defeat in 1967 helped kick start the Palestinian national movement. Before then the Palestine Liberation Organisation had been a puppet of Nasser, a way of containing the Palestinians rather than helping their fight for independence.
Quite a lot of research!
HOW IS IT that Gaza has plenty of missiles but not food and basic supplies? Blame HAM ASS….
They have rockets, not missiles. If someone stole your land what would you do?
16:00 staged as national trauma
Listen to Thomas Sowell talk about intellectuals talking to topics outside of their field of expertise
🤮
How does he know there was going to be a military coup?
What gives him the right to say the Humas charter is meaningless?
What gives him the right to speak of behalf of Mexico when talking about their governments opinion on USA right to exist.
Does anyone ever challenge this guy
‘By 2020, Gaza may be uninhabitable.’ Is this the quality of Professor Chomsky’s predictions?
Gaza IS uninhabitable, wel before 2020, dear.
The UN concurs.
Obviously depends on the working definition of "uninhabitable".
98% of the water is poisonous dude
Looks like he was spot on- prescient! 2024…just a few years off.
Psycho Technique.... Cheap
41:20 the first self h8tingJew _JC
Christ salvation for divine central authority substantive human rights
𝓅𝓇𝑜𝓂𝑜𝓈𝓂 ✋
I use to follow Chomsky for a long time and his views for me was absolute until a few years ago that he started supporting islamic regime in Iran and for those of you who don’t know about Iranian politics I say this categorically that this regime is evil and supporter and financier of majority of terrorists ground in particular Middle East
It has been proven to me the Chomsky belongs to to what we call liberal left and majority if not all are supporters of Palestine and are anti Israeli I do not support either side but to me as an Iranian Israel is the first line of defence against Islamic terrorist and if Israel is not there the whole west will be overridden by Islamic invasion and hence terrorism
For those who want to know more I recommend a book called The death of Europe. Which is well researched and shows a bitter truth which our grandchildren have to deal with I just don’t understand a well informed person such as Chomsky does ignore a lot of other facts and his arguments are one sided and biased
If the west did not help to overthrow the shah of Iran in 1979. None of these atrocities would have happened and Middle East would enjoy a prosperous and relative peace but it was question of cheap oil and gas and short term benefits for the large international corporations which they dictate policies to the politicians and as a result we have a Europe which every now and then there is an assault on free speech and the politicians are appeasing the Moslems and are afraid of them
I can see a dark future for Europe perhaps a civil war and you might like my views but it the truth and coming from an ex Moslem with a good knowledge of the area both in the Middle East and Europe
have you watched Manufacturing consent? It's free on CZcams.
@@genevievexxI doubt they have they sound very much propagandized
takes belief in god for otherwise good people to commit evil acts
Hamas are the good guys? This really didn't age well...
😂 Come on fool. He never said that.
25:07
@@deplaneetegmont At that time, 5 1/2 years ago there were far more atrocities against Palestinians than a couple weeks ago. That fact hasn't aged well either, but many conveniently turn a blind eye because that fits their narrative. When a nation blatantly oppresses another, there's always going to be a price to pay. It may not be at that moment, but at some point EVERYONE with a brain knew someone was going to punish the oppressor. Do I agree or condone it? No. Violence is not the answer. But I was surprised it wasn't a dirty nuclear bomb.
At this point, I do not believe there is any solution. Neither side is capable of reason.
Typical propagandized statement
No one came to his Bar Mitzvah, and Chomsky has been angry ever since.
You are angry😂
Here come the hasbara sh!t-slinger team.... As always, as expected - no arguements, just the same old sh....
@@jhegrelol you gotta come up w better reply it losing it’s importance after you copy and paste ten times. I fully agree w you but enough copy and pasting
It’s always the same, the person unable to attack the points made by the messenger, attack the messenger. His points are therefore proven.
@@MrDastardly ❤️🙏 If he does not agree with the far right government , he is called self-hater😆.
The Nazis did the same with human rights activists.
Are Noam's views even relevant these days?
retorical question?
Depends on the topic imo.
Here: absolutely.
Just have a listen at his takes on Israel/Palestine over the years. I have found few others of similar clarity and relevance.
His historically informed brain is a great asset to us all if we let it.
I’m afraid not
Yes.
Nobody is perfect. Take in as much info as you can.
Yes. Do you exist still? Pity...
When I was a student I really idolized Chomsky. Read all his books. Went to see him speak. Having grown and learn so much in the decades since it is interesting looking back and hearing him construct ideas and make kind of exaggerated and alarmist claims within this interview. I guess my intellect has out grown him now. He focuses so much on what the Israelis have done with some linguistic sleight of hand to prime your interpretation. Not a lot of examination of the why or deeper motivations. Disappointing. And yes, his stance has not aged well at all.
He does this because Israel and the West focus almost entirely on what Hamas has done. All claims made in this interview can be verified, which Chomsky often encourages people to actually do. If you've truly read all his books (which you obviously haven't) you wouldn't have written this concentrated whining because it offends your delicate Zionist sensibilities.
LOL. Quit joking. Chomsky is one of the greatest thinkers of the 20th century but you guess your intellect has outgrown him. lol He has written more books than you have read. 🤣
this is called the Dunning-Kruger effect
I heard deeper motivations. Please share your intelligence which has outgrown his. Go on, enligt us on the deeper and don't mention the past like he does.
Michael, have you pondered that maybe he is right and you are not?
He fails to truly communicate that Jewish people, aside from Israel, lived there well before Palestinians or Islam ever existed.
Palestinians were living there in 1948 - it doesnt matter what your religion is, they were living there peacefully and independently in their own communities and then the colonial settlers attacked them and displaced 750,000 of them in the Nakba in order to steal their land and build on top of it. Saying that they had ancestors that lived somewhere around there over 2,000 years ago does not give them the right to do that. It was, and is, illegal and wrong.
@@codyvandal2860 As we’re numerous Jewish communities that were oppressed and invaded by Arabs. So they were a minority and that makes it okay and gives all the land to the Arabs to claim? Please read your history; both sides.
@@onlyone1. Please get educated and be honest with the world. Can you refute the facts above?
@@onlyone1. Bnei Yehuda, Kfar Saba, Kfar Uria, Ruhama, Hartuv, Hulda, Poria, Motza, Beit SheAn…..all 1920’s and 30’s…..and these are only a part of the Jewish communities racially cleansed by the Arabs. Can you refute this?
@@doctorhadland6510actually you need to read your history and look at genetics studies. Ancestors in that area are genetically related to both Jews and Arabs (in recent history called the Palestinians). They both have a claim to that land by ancient Biblical time standards, but Palestinians have claim to land when we look at recent history as well. Romans kicked out the Jews and left the Arab people stay and named them Palestinians, they have been there ever since Jews came back and displaced them.
Palestinians deserve that land just as much as Jews. Period. Not one or the other, but BOTH. Yet Israel has done everything in their power to illegally displace them and have caused tremendous abuse to their people.
Also, just because in your perspective Jews have a right to the land, doesn’t give them a right to do what they have been doing for 75 years. Instead of reading just history, go study some morality as well.
Does anyone still listen to Chomsky after he ignorantly demonised personal health choices? He’s off my list. He does not do due diligence.
You never like him and created a false narrative to shame him. You are obvious a faschchist Ayn Rand person. or pre-happen's a Psychopathic serial killer.
@@FrancisE.Dec.Esquire Name calling is not a conversation let alone an argument. The fact is he was wrong about mandating vaccines to prevent transmission and needs to apologise to gain back our respect.
Chomsky was explicitly against mandates you know.
@@jesselopes5196 doesn’t matter how you dress it up. If you say the unvaccinated have to isolate at home and are unable to access food, healthcare and income then it’s a mandate. He was wrong. The vaccine did not prevent transmission or infection. The unvaccinated were no risk to other people especially once omicron arrived.
@@sandyfoot Your last statement is wildly false
Noam thinks the USA and Isreal are garbage. I’m surprised he hasn’t moved to Gaza, they just want to thrive after all.
Because he was born in the US. Why would he want to move to a concentration camp?