5 Things I Wish I Knew About Substrates for Planted Aquariums
VloĆŸit
- Äas pĆidĂĄn 19. 06. 2024
- I mostly work with inert (nutrient-free) planted tank substrates, so here's what I've learned so far.
đ SUBSCRIBE so you wonât miss my latest video: / @girltalksfish
đż BECOME A MEMBER for bonus content: / @girltalksfish
đ MATERIALS I USED
ⶠEasy Root Tabs: www.aquariumcoop.com/products...
ⶠCoarse black sand: www.petco.com/shop/en/petcost...
ⶠCaribSea Eco-Complete: amzn.to/3adYtSb
ⶠSeachem Flourite black sand: amzn.to/3aggaAD
ⶠAquarium plants: www.aquariumcoop.com/collecti...
ⶠPlant weights: www.aquariumcoop.com/products...
ⶠStraight tweezers: amzn.to/3tWQW1Z
ⶠAngled tweezers: www.aquariumcoop.com/products...
(As an Amazon Associate, I may earn commissions from the links above. Also, I work for Aquarium Co-Op but do not receive commissions from their links.)
đ RESOURCES
ⶠHow to Plant Live Aquarium Plants: www.aquariumcoop.com/blogs/aq...
ⶠHow to Set Up a Planted Tank with Sand: ⹠How to Set Up a Plante...
đŠ EXTRAS
ⶠInstagram: / girltalksfish
ⶠMerch store: teespring.com/stores/girltalk...
ATTRIBUTION
Music from Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsound.com/referra... (if you use my referral link, I get 1 month free đ)
Osmocote root tabs from www.ebayshopkorea.com/itm/100...
Monte carlo attached to stone by MD Fish Tanks from âą Aquascape Tutorial: En...
Monte carlo and kuhli loaches by Aquarium Co-Op from www.aquariumcoop.com/products...
#girltalksfish #nanofish #plantedaquarium
*Need more planted tank hacks? Check out my whole series of "5 things I wish I knew" about planted aquariums:* czcams.com/play/PLlBBJ7xBuqub-rl6z7cnGfSp_rUoyGN0U.html
Its gonna die I really don't want to find the fish dead but no one has answered my question directly by that time it would be dead way too late & have died pleal(
I think you should make a list of nano fishes for beginners.
I really enjoy watching your awesome videos. I do have a question for you on soil substrate. I watch a video of Cory from Aquarium CO-OP and he mentioned that soil based substrates eventually get depleted of nutrients. That being said soils have high CEC therefore they shouldnât run out of nutrients? Would they not be able to absorb it from the water column?
And last indefinitely? Thanks
Thanks
How long does it take for the water to clear up after adding substrate I used one like yours
Girl talks fish mentioned me.....I've made it đ (thanks for the shout out đ)
I was thinking the same thing... I was like hey! I watch MD Fish Tanks and he totally does this.
I've totally been binging your content recently! Lots of love for your low tech aquascapes. đ
Two mentions MD, my eyebrows went up when I heard his name
We always knew you'd make it eventually!!!..........LOL :)
@@GirlTalksFish thank you đ
Another note for those pesky plants that love to float out of the substrate: let them grow longer roots, bundle the roots together and push them down into the substrate, then drag in a direction where you have room. This forces a line of roots under the soil and pulls the plant's base down into the substrate. This is especially effective in coarser substrates with more depth.
Oh I totally forgot to mention that trick! Thank you so much for mentioning it. And much appreciation for your previous helpful comment that I ended up referring to in this video. :)
Not a criticism, more of a question: I would have thought the opposite about the roots. Cut them short and lightly anchor the plant in place. If the plant is healthy it will quickly want to regrow its roots and they will make their way into the substrate and become better anchored.
I have always been of the impression that if a plant already has a substantial root system then itâs roots will grow much more slowly and will take longer to become anchored. Wouldnât this work better? Or am I missing something?
@@aaronws9561 if the roots are too small to hold it down, growing them out to act as an anchor helps, if they have very long roots, you can trim to 1.5-2" to anchor but encourage new growth
I go bare bottom with Aquponic.
Less hassle
@@BentleyPascoe what would you recommend bundling them together with?
When putting aquarium coop's root tabs in your tank,put a pin hole in the end of the root tab and it will not float. Makes it MUCH easier.
Oh yeah, I forgot that trick! Thanks so much for mentioning for others to read. đ
Thank you havent used them yet but just got them in the mail
Omg brilliant!!â„ïžâ„ïž
@@GirlTalksFish no problem. Anything I learn from cory is my duty to pass on.
Poisons the tank.
Your the most straight forward aquarium owner I know. You make it way easier for me to go off and do my own research about individual topics without feeling overwhelmed
Wish I knew to go deeper with my substrate. Adding more substrate in a fully planted tank is a pain in the backside.
Look at, The Secret History living inside your tank. He have a video on it. đ
I'm grateful I went deep despite the longer cycling and trickier initial balancing. 'Treat it like a plant.' Now, learn lasagna gardening ABOVE ground- now, you can think of aquascaping!
It's not really that big of a deal.
@@voluntaryismistheanswer I never connected how similar the 2 are!
Thank you for sharing, now I have a better reference when I am teaching people about either.
@@csharpe5787 I will need to check that out. One of the reasons I have usually kept my substrate a bit thinner is to avoid anaerobic pockets. Does the video cover dealing with this problem?
Really enjoy your videos. As a 67 yr old grandma who has had aquariums off and on for many years, things change, and I have learned so much from your videos, so I subscribed. Keep up the excellent work, and I will review your previous videos and look forward to the next one! By the way, your children are precious.
The method I use for planting is that I dig a shallow pit, then I plant it in the middle of that pit. Then I push the displaced substrate back into the pit, which purposefully buries the plant too deeply in the substrate. Finally, I gently pull on the plant to bring it up to the right height. This really secures the plant in, and it apparently also positions the roots more naturally. It does involve getting both your arms in the tank but I don't mind.
Yes! That's exactly what I do when I use my hands. Thanks for describing it so eloquently. I just wish my 20 gallon high tank wasn't so deep. :P
@@GirlTalksFish I'm barely 5'... all tanks are too deep, lol
It's very important that I watch this. I have absolutely no plans to ever start an aquarium (I'm just not in a stable life position for it) but I need to understand planted aquarium substrates. Why? You ask. Because it's important!
If you're never going to have an aquarium then learning a bunch about aquariums is technically a waste of your time, but it is interesting enough to want to learn just for the sake of knowledge
I actually watch MD Fishtanks and other channels you mention that are well developed. But I really appreciate your videos! You make it feel more understandable and achievable for a hobbyist who will have just like 1 or 2 tanks.
For sure Iâm wanting to start one tank I bought, but itâs proving to be expensive and confusing.
Pro tip:
You are doing fine going slow. Research...then sit with it.
I started a 4' build project 3 months ago.
I am still buying/procuring/preparing the things I need.
Typically, it takes me 8 months from first purchase to actually getting water in the tank, so I have everything right the first time.
I've kept aquariums since 1975....
Take your time and enjoy it, your plants and fish will thank you... and it will be stress reducing as the hobby was originally intended.
fantastic reminder, thank you for sharing! wonderful to hear that you've been in the hobby so long and are still taking it slow and enjoying :)
fishkeeping and aquascaping is really really fun. should've started this hobby many years ago.
I did a LOT of research for what substrate to use for my planted nano tank (15 gal). I chose crushed lava rock for my bottom layer, inert Eco Complete for middle, topped with med course sand. I use root tabs for rooted plants and Easy Green liquid for the floating water column plants. So far quite happy with my results.
One common thing i did from the internet is to put normal organic potting mix at the bottom and cap it off with a thicc layer of your cheap substrate. Unless you want algae fun-fest, don't let the soil seep to the water column. It works for me, so might as well share it to other peeps who may not know what a dirted tank is.
Good organic Canadian sphagnum peat for the tannin and soft water lovers.
Tips for planting a hex tank: put on a bathing suit, stand on a chair, plunge half your body in the water while holding the plant with your hand so you can reach the bottom. Make sure you have towels down so you dont drip all over the floor when you come up for air. đ
đ I am at that state and love it so much I'm buying a new one on CL
đ€Łđ€Łđ€Ł
So much truth, lol
I'm that person using soil from my own compost pile mixed with gravel then topped with something decorative to help keep it all in place.
Definitely reccomend many water changes and time before adding animals if doing this! I think I'll be using the frozen dirt idea in future though! I've always relied on liquid aquarium fertilizer as tabs floating away annoys me.
This is my first video of yours I've watched and I found it to be very be informative. I accidentally stumbled across it. I also found comfort with you mentioning Aquarium Co op. I plan on checking out your other videos now too! Thank you so much for taking the time to share.âșïž
I just love listening to you, you cut straight to the point, you really know what you're talking about and you always come about with such great tips and tricks. A huge plus is also your personality and voice, perfect for making videos! You're brilliant :)
I've trusted Aquarium Co-Op and Cory for YEARS. Happy to add you to my list of trusted aquarists!
Glad to see im not only person having a trust list. When i was just beginning i literally had it written on a paper
I watched you as a beginner and now that i have had a tank for 4 months I have a much better appreciation of your tanks and tips. Nice work!
Love these videos. I am learning so much as this is my first time planting live plants. My wife doesnât like them much but I think they look great! Thanks for making these videos!
Irene, for the carpeting plants I do something similar to MD. I use a drop of crazy glue to attach the grass to a small pebble and wedge it at soil level. âșïž
This is an amazing video- you give your experience and supplement with other experienced fishkeeper's advice. I had a bit of a disaster on my fiest tankmlast night amd this literally addressed every problem!
đČOMG I've learned so much in just this one video. I have a ten gallon planter and have been having issues. I am subscribing for more, thank you
To keep plants down, I put a small rock w an elastic to the roots. It's way easier, and wont mess up dirted tank as much. Less damage to the roots too, dont have to keep smushing them back down
Thank you for this, I was gifted a 20 gallon tank and putting a game plan together. Iâm going to layer the eco sub with a sand on top or eco where I plant only. Way to may options on what to do with a tank but I usually do a tank with what I have on hand. I got some beautiful colorful rocks and stones from Lake Ontario, driftwood from my Cabin lake in Belgrade Lakes, Maine. Rocks were just cleaned and sanitized, driftwood next.
Good video, one thing that's really helped me is plant weights. they're doing well for me in a new tank with Fluval Stratum. It's so lightweight and coarse, it doesn't hold anything in easily. It's REALLY frustrating trying to get rotala or staurogyne to stay in the dirt, I got plant weights from buceplant, very cheap strips of a very soft non reactive metal. I just cut a tiny little strip the size of a brad nail off with scissors, and squeeze it onto the stem. Just a tiny bit of weight reduces the buoyancy so plants won't float away, and the strip of metal acts like an anchor to boot. If you're done playing aquarium plant whack-a-mole, get some weights and be done with it, so glad I found them.
Thank you! Great tips and so nice of you to mention MD Fish Tanks and Cory of Aquarium Co-op.
All your tank settings are so beautiful! Its like a magical forest vibe. You should add like a fake decor of a redhead mushroom. I think it will look extremely cute
Glad to hear MD fish tanks mentioned
Excellent excellent excellent. Thanks Irene. Iâm having all those problems with tweezers, roots, and root tabs. Iâm afraid to grab the root tabs too hard because they break (happened yesterday). Iâm afraid to grab the plant stems too hard with the tweezers because it can cut through the stems. Thanks for giving us permission to just use the ultimate tweezers - our fingers!
There was a lot of relief with that one! đ
Always informative đ love the shout out to md
Great video! You hit all the points I was curious about.... I started a pandemic 45gal planted tank with guidance from good fish store. I did it right with the substrate, cycle, timed light, co2, liquid fertilizer etc. It was amazing until a few months ago where diff types of plants would either flourish or die off. Plants with biggest root system would do best. I've stayed steady with maintenance. Im thinking my substrate nutrients are used up?.... Just moved so now I get to relaunch the tank properly. Put all the plants in buckets. Have the fish in a 10gal for now using the same filter. I heavily vacuumed the gravel nefore removal and kept 20gal of the old tank water. Do you think fertilizer tabs would revitalize?
Very informative as always.â€ïž
I love the pasiĂłn of how you explain everything.
Haha Iâm back watching this video for a third time since it was uploaded and yet again taking away newly learned skills. Thanks so much, I just had to comment as this has been a great help!!
For the algorithm! Keep up the good work. And thanks for the KH help on the CO-OP forum!
Thanks for the amazing content.
Great info again! Love your videos. With root tabs, you can use a plastic tubes a plexiglass rod. Get one that's about the size of the diameter of the gel-tab. Push the gel-tab into the tube, and stab that into the substrate at a 45-degree angle, and use the plexiglass rod to pushed the tab into the substrate.
Another tip. To prevent the gel-tabs from floating by poking a hole in it with a safety pin đ§·
Niiiice! I'm going to have to make one of these and try it out because I use root tabs in all of my tanks.
What wonderful information on a big topic!! I do use some expensive Aqua soils sometimes... I've also gone with capping it with 3 in of sand... It really does wonders â„ïžđ
Really great points on the mulm!!
Thank you for covering root tabs and fertilizers!!
And I also love that you covered the different types of plants and how to plant them đâ„ïžđż
Oh my goodness use two sets of tweezers đđ best tip ever!!!!!
Brilliant đđâ„ïž
I aways wondered about the rockwool thanks for that tip too đ€
Love your videos Irene thank you so much for all you do and share!! I hope you have a very blessed day and a Happy Valentine day!!!â„ïžđđżđđżđ
Yay, so glad you enjoyed the video! Thank you so much for spending the time to comment on my content. I see how much time and effort you put into writing them, and I'm so happy to know that you like my channel. :)
Possibly the most informative video under 10 minutes ever made đđ đđ±âŒïž
Awesome video! Very helpful. Thanks
This is a great video. Thanks for the tips!
All ive learned for my aquarium ive learned from you thank you irene
Super cute! great info as well!
Really love your videos! They are very informative!
Awesome tips as always, thanks Irene!!
Thank you- very informative and helpful!
I love the âgravel base, sand topperâ tip! I find that sand is really good at keeping new plants in place. Also, I definitely use the 2 tweezer tip!
Haha, I'm glad to hear I'm not the only crazy one using 2 tweezers.
Me too.
đŻ
I use wooden chop sticks. Can't stand the thought of cold metal pressed against my plants.
I think I'm gonna use that method for my tank
I love your videos †Iâm starting with this hobby and itâs been really nice finding girls to follow and learn from â€
Great vid. Thanks!
Thank you for this!! I really needed this
Just the video I was looking forâŠthanks for sharing!!
Great video! Mentioning other You tubers was a great way to utilize other peoples methods, love it!
Yes, there is so much great information out there and I love learning from others. I try to give credit whenever I can remember the source.
Thank you very much for shearing information. I have difficulty in planting Hygrophila difformis got to try one of your methods.
Thank you so much for the good information
Invaluable tips, thank you
You really do your research. And I enjoy listening to you. Great video. Likedđ
I enjoyed your video... it's nice to see another female in the hobbie! I've had high nutrient substrate for some time now with a heavily planted tank and now thinking of putting the nutrient substrate into mesh media bags and then cover with gravel and top up with natural light sand, as MD does in some of his videos. I'm tired of the algae from the nutrients and I dont have time for water changes very often, especially being a large tank (250L). Thanks for validating the high nutrient soil and algae.
sweet tank, I like how everyone is getting along in peace.
All your videos are so helpful!
Thanks for the tweezer tips.
Thanks for this video!
This is great info! Thanks!
Clay balls are another way of getting nutrients to heavy root feeders, they are working great on my Cryptocoryne's and Swords.
Great video, as always!
Cool video! Thanks!đ€đ€
Great tutorial!
Great video, thank you.
Another great video, big thanks for the great useful content
I used aqua clay topped with a shell grit/sand mixture which I then topped with a not-to-thick layer of pool filter sand in my re-setup of a 145-litre tank. I couldn't be happier with the experiment. đđ
Thank you for the great advice đđ
Good stuff - very informative
Just got myself pearlscale goldfish and im starting my aquascaping after my fish have established. Thanks for all the great tips!đ
Wait what, that's not the right order.
That explains why I've been having trouble with all my carpeting plants!
Amazing tank really beautifulđđđ
This is timely well as I'm re working an aquarium and stuck on substrate choices. đđâ€
Excellent, informative video!
thank you! đ you just helped me with my decision, which saved a lot of time đ
I like the idea of the carpeting plant being planted into the substrate. Countless hours trying to replant little bunches of hairgrass. The green wool-like stuff the plants come in are ok to leave in the fish tank. . . Indefinitely?
Do you find that vacuuming your gravel is necessary? And if so, how do you avoid vacuuming your finer substrates (like if you use sand)?
We went to the river years ago and scope up gravel for my aquariums.
I have used it and reusued it. It works great for plants and fish as that is what is in their natural habitat.
Some great tips thanks đ
For planting carpeting plants: get some thin plastic coated gardening wire (garden centres sell them in reels) and cut many 2 inch lengths. Bend the top 5th back around and voila: mini tent pegs that keep your carpeting plants secure until they take root then simply remove. :)
Love your tshirt. I usually cap my substrate with sand. Itâs easier for me to plant in.
Capping is everything lol
Great tips, thank you. Also +1 for use of the word 'mulm'! and great to see kuhlii loaches!
coolest tips there and yes the soil need to be think as well cheers
Finally! someone talks about the difficulty of planting plants!
Great video. Thank you
Really helpful â€ïž
Great tips!
Great idea for carpeting the bottom with a rock. Thanks for the great tips!
Very helpful video
Great Video!!
Your videos have helped me out so much with my 10 gal.. in about a year my friend is moving away and leaving his 40 gal. with me, that substrate cost will get pretty expensive so where I can cut the costs I probably will.
What substrate are your using for your 10 gal?
love your vid that help me alot : >
I agree the whole add this stuff every x amount of time thing makes no sense. Watch your plants carefully and they will tell you what time it is. After a while you will note more or less of a rythm too it. Cut that period slythly shorter et voila. I have had tanks where every month was required and in other situations i got away with twice a year. In our hobby " it depends" is a good part of the answer for many if not most of the questions.
There's too many variables, it's like a recipe- if you are a novice it's a roadmap, don't veer!, but if you grasp the basics, it's unnecessary as me needing one to bake bread. You observe, and react accordingly.
Good tips. I wish i had watched it before i started my 60-gallon cube. Oh well, part of becoming good at something is some failure in the beginning. One thing i did is use mesh bags, and besides being difficult to plant things, I'm not sure it's going to work tempted to tear it down and start over.I guess I will see. God bless you!
Irene, your AR mini is so pretty! I'm fighting algae right now. Also Irene is one of my favorite names!
Nice teaching moment
Hearing the first tip made me so relieved. I began an aquarium a few weeks ago and as all my plants started rapidly growing, I realised a carpet would just put the whole thing together. Sadly, due to the price, I could only get sand as my substrate and relied on tab and liquid fertilisers. I was told there was no hope in growing a carpet with just sand, but I think now I'm confident to give it a try.
You should make your take like half sand and half gravel so you can grow different stuff
@@favian8435 actually that's a good idea, thanks :)