Heavy Fight In Live Show | Mukalma with Khalil-ur-Rehman Qamar & Sahil Adeem | Women Rights
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- #KhalilurRehmanQamar #SahilAdeem #Ayeshajahanzeb #humanrights #womenrights #Mukalma #samaatv
Heavy Fight In Live Show | Mukalma with Khalil-ur-Rehman Qamar & Sahil Adeem | Women Rights
SAMAA TV is the top Pakistani news channel covering national news from a diverse array of fields -- from politics and current affairs, business and sports to international, entertainment and culture.
The channel aims at providing factual, in-depth and latest news as and when it happens.
Tune in to SAMAA TV to stay updated, whether at home or on the go, on all things current and relevant.
➽ Subscribe to Samaa News ➽ bit.ly/2Wh8Sp8
➽ Watch Samaa News Live ➽ bit.ly/3oUSwAP
Stay up-to-date on the major news making headlines across Pakistan on SAMAA TV’s top-of-the-hour segment. For in-depth coverage watch the bulletins.
SAMAA TV is Pakistan’s first private satellite news channel that provides live transmission simultaneously from five cities of Pakistan: Karachi, Lahore, Islamabad, Quetta and Peshawar.
SAMAA’s live news bulletins, incisive political talk shows and a wide range of programs including sports, social issues and infotainment has enabled it to position itself among the top tier news and current affairs channels of Pakistan.
SAMAA Network :
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest SAMAA News content: bit.ly/2Wh8Sp8
► SAMAA News CZcams Channel: bit.ly/2Wh8Sp8
► SAMAA Originals CZcams Channel: bit.ly/32c1qO3
► SAMAA MONEY CZcams channel: bit.ly/2EkiglJ
► SAMAA SPORTS CZcams channel: bit.ly/34jyINP
► SAMAA ISLAMIC CZcams channel: bit.ly/2LT1WMF
Keep watching SAMAA!
For latest Urdu News updates visit:
www.samaa.tv
/ samaatvnews
/ samaatv
/ samaatv
whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va8E...
Punjab Govt | CM Punjab | Punjab Assembly | Bilawal Bhutto | Imran Khan | News | Breaking News | Latest News | News Headlines | Prime Time Headlines | Samaa News | News Channel | Live News | Breaking News | Latest News | Pakistan Breaking News | Breaking News Today | News Headlines | Headlines News | Pakistan News | Headlines | Live News | News Updates | Samaa news live | Samaa | Samaa Live | Samaa News Live Streaming | Samaa CZcams Channel | Samaa Channel | Samaa Tv Live | Samaa Tv | Samaa Live Tv | Samaa Live News
Whoever came with the idea of bringing these two together deserves a raise!
katue aur unke ideal
I hope you are being
sarcastic
sahil adeem I hand shake with you in D-Chowk in the protest of palestine ( Save Gaza Campaign )
off course
❤❤true❤❤
She proved herself she is one of those 95%
Salute to you you are one of those 5%
I guess sahil didn’t know the meaning of Jahil
@@user-zd8no2my5z in Arabic language juhl is actually used for an emotional person not for illiterate.
Hahahahahah correct 💯
Tm ho jahil sahil ki anti
He is saying that 95% of the women dont know their rights that kind of jahils we are...and being a woman I agree with him..
Village ki larki education k liye London pohanch gai but islamic knowledge kiye apni country k baray cities Nahi jab sakti
Tou baat krne ka aik tareeka hota hai, jahilo ki tarah smjhata hai yeh
@@khan-pakhtun jahil aisa hi smjhe ga
@@khan-pakhtunPrhe likhe or logical logon ko jahil Nahi lgtay.
Jahilon ko zroor lgtay, kio k unhe sheesha dikhatay hain Sahil shb.
@@khan-pakhtunjo waqai jahil hain baat unhi ko chubh rhi hai😂
Yeh MERI Zindagi Ka pehla show tha Jo mujhy without script Ka LGA.
Thank you soo much for this content.
Sahil bhai say koi scripted krwana namumkin hay
Dear Azba! Girl you have just proved his point is more than 100% correct.
You are one of those 95%. Arguing and debating without knowledge.
آپ نے درست فرمایا۔۔ عائشہ خدیجہ اور فاطمہ بھی جاہل عورتیں تھیں۔ آپ یقینا میری بات کی تائید کریں گی۔
Azba asked a relevant question and logically argued .
@@queenPAKanother one from that 95% markup
Azba apni jaga 100 percent right theen kisi ko label lagana ya judge karna is very bad bhut buri cheez hai agar kisi ko aik cheez nahi atte isko matlub yay nahi ko wo jahil hai ab yay sahil adeem baar baar tagoot tagoot kar raha tha tagoot ko shirk khete hain shirk ka pata tha larki ko ab yay modern molvi new confusing words use karay gaa to kese samjh ayee gaa humesha deen ko layman language mein convey karo gay to agla banda samjhay gaa
@@queenPAK logically argued?
She said maafi mango aurat jahil nh hai tmne jahil boldya AS WELL AS aurat jahil hai to ye mard ka kasoor hai...
Hahah do contradicting statements ek hi jumle me.
59:00
As a woman i have to say:
لڑکی نے تو بات سمجھی ہی نہیں بہت ہی فضول بحث کی۔
اور یہی جہالت کا سب سے بڑا ثبوت ہے۔
Agreed sister 👌🏻💯
😂😂😂
Mein toh has raha tha pet pakad ke
Wo karna kya chah rahi thi
She’s planted by sama tv
True agree
@@shifa6874 Muttafiq... Sahae baat .. Lagta ha paid tha 😂
Samma or Dunia walo SA aisi harkton ki hi umeed Hoti
Jaisy in ki head lines Hoti
For
Viewer ship SAB Karo
Azba didn't even think about her including her in the remaining 5%. Usny usi 95% mai sign up kiya khud ko
What an epic reply: i apologize for u being jahil
This girl really showed why sahil adeem was correct
💯👌🏻
She’s so annoying raised my BP she’s not letting them talk
sahil adeem I hand shake with you in D-Chowk in the protest of palestine ( Save Gaza Campaign )
The girl became a sample of that 95% itself. What a quick and sudden proof of the statement that Sahil adeem uttered.
Mujhy lagta hai baagh gaee uss k baad nzar hi nhi aee vo taauuut wali😂😂😂😂
Ayesha jhanzaib is not listening to understand and not letting properly convey the basic end point of each analysis. She is just listening to respond.
Wo isi liye bethi hai
She is very illiterate.
Women get very emotional about this topic. I do understand her.
But she wasnt noticing that no one is talking against women rights. She was thinking emotionally.
It was a wrong choice of host.
I know right
Don't you feel she was planned here for TRP
I hope my sister Azba learns something from her discussion with Sahil Bhai. Sahil Bhai was talking common sense, but she wasn’t open to listening. She was triggered throughout the whole discussion; something seemed off with her. Her behavior was quite rude and full of hate, and she was like MAAFI MANG to everyone one.
Sahil must apologize, the woman was right.
This is most difficult thing for Ayesha jehanzaib to sit back and listen to these two guys😂😂
The host portraying herself as an annoying and highly insecure person
Sahi kaha he has given us a solution on religious basis and Mashallah Sir Khalil also gave solutions balka Always giving solutions on Moral and Ethical Values
100 % agreed.
Why she is being so rude
Yes she is not mentally focused on topic
She just used negative words. Even I got annoyed that Sahil and Khalil are defending women rights and you are here talking nonsense
Azba is proving herself jahil 😢
sahil adeem I hand shake with you in D-Chowk in the protest of palestine ( Save Gaza Campaign )
No doubt
To be exact, he stated that women are islamically ignorant. Not plain ignorant. Point is it's futile to argue with an emotional person.
ya larki live insult krwany ai thi😂😂😂😂😂
and wow you are one of those 5%.
The host needs to practise some emotional intelligence
That girls level of knowledge is too little to argue about the topic that she asked Sahil to apologise for. She stood up for women without studying about the subject .. 😢 embarrassed herself im front of millions
Sahi bola Sahil Adeem ne, akal ka parda daal rakha hai kuch aurton ne.. proof bhi mil gaya.. how difficult was it to understand in the very first go.. ghoom ke phir aa jaati hain anchor 10 min k baad, sir aap kyun nahi kar rahe.. Sahil : kar to rahe hain, website dekhein jo abhi thodi der pehle bhi bataya tha..
Pakistan should remove Islamic from its constitution.. what a failed society
sahil adeem I hand shake with you in D-Chowk in the protest of palestine ( Save Gaza Campaign )
Ayesha didn't have any homework regarding Sahil Adeem. it's khamkhaw ki debate.
انھیں عقل کی اندھی جاھل دو ٹکے کی عورتوں میرے نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ نے وہ عزت دلائی جو مرد سے تین گناہ ھے۔اب بتائے غلط کون عزت دلا نے والا یا عورت کو دو ٹکے کی یا جاھل کہنے والا؟؟؟
Very true her she even cant understand the points just k aurat kya kry
Sahil adeem never claimed to be an islamic scholar or motivational speaker.
He is just trying to open up people's minds with his knowledge.
A great combination of two great personality.
Agree with Sahil Adeem ❤
two insanely jahil personalities
@@mustafaayubkhan go ahead and prove it
More like Jaahil adeem
He did 💁 thori bongian maro sahil adeem ki trah. Khod kehta ha me leader hon mjhe mohre chaiye jo sochen na khod
Disappointing how Samaa Manages to put together such an amazing panel but always manages to put a female host who's always interrupting the conversation
True she's so irritating
'' Ap maafi mangein, nhi nhi mafi maangein'' She showed tantrums like she is talking to her bf 😂
Soo truee😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Obviously very typical of every jahil mentality. She has no idea of graceful bringing up. May be she never seen any decent person in her life.
Hahaha well said
And she was right. Sahil is Jahil.
this anchor is so much annoying and very immature.she needs lots of work on her job skills.
بالکل میرا بھی یہی خیال ہے ۔
Yes
Her job is just reading the cards not using her brain😅
Yahi toh jahalat hai😂
Nearly all of our shows hosts and anchors are like this.
پہلے قانون نافذ کرو ہمارے ملک میں انصاف نہیں ھے
You do not understand the struggle behind a woman being divorced with kids and no financial backing😢
😢😢😢😢
Exactly, these disgusting men say all these things about women as always. Despite never even once putting themselves in our shoes
‘ Tahoot’….. ‘ ……..”to go beyond the measure”. Denoting a focus of worship other than God. IE. Idols. Demons. Pagan sacrifices. Etc Etc ‘. The Islamic scholar’s reply to the young woman’s retort/question (asking him to apologise for calling all women as ‘jaahil’), was totally at a tangent to the comment made. When he brought up the term ‘ Tahoot ‘, in his reply. Thereby, very cleverly sidestepping the answer to the comment made. And taking the conversation in a maze of absolutely unrelated direction. In a very condescendingly, aggressive manner.
Amazing words by khalil rehman for sahil adeem""""main iss shakhs k alawa kisi ko sacholar maanta he nahi"💓💓💓
Same ❤❤❤❤
sahil adeem I hand shake with you in D-Chowk in the protest of palestine ( Save Gaza Campaign )
This was the best moment
18:06 Great Answer and Statements SAHIL ADEEM ❤❤
kon kon fb se reel dekh k pura show dekhne aya 🤣
Same ma tiktok se😂
such a healthy debate with intellectual minds
After watching first 20min of this episode jitna orat ky haq mein mardoon ny bola ha kisi aur ny nahi bola, phir bhi logon ko problem ha. Haad ha.
Is mein to shak nahi ke dono ne ourton ke haq mein bola, magar Sahil Adeem ke 95% ourton ko jahil kehney per larki ka protest bhi jaiz hai. Bajaye maafi maangney ke Lafz Tawoon mein uljha kr larki ko hi jahil keh dia🤔😡
Yes, because these men are educated
@@knitlve512 Jee mardon ko zyada shaadyon par uksana education hai...aur mard agar pichley aurat sey ijazat lya beghair shaadi kary gaa to us surat main jo sotely behn bhayion main problems aaajaatey hain unka kya .....
Bhai jan lafz tawoon nahi tagoot(طاغوت)hai@@whitz811
Sahil Adeem is the only person who actually comes up with a solution for the problem, not just talkig for the sake of talking.
His solutions create 10 times bigger problems
Ha ha ha.
@@opimusno12012elaborate your thoughts can you?
Host did a good job but was outnumbered by two men with the same perspective supporting each other and circumventing host’s questions.
Pahle to Khatoon reference mang rahi thi jab reference de diya to bol rahi hai ki Arabi ki aayat padh rahe hain women 😂
57:39 video cut jahan us ladki ne aayat as a proof demand kari aur sahil adeem ne on the spot di
59:11 video cut kardi jahan us ladki ki jahalat ki wajah se uski bezzati hui thi
Full video kahn milegi?
Exactly!
Intellectual 10:37
Don't worry, it's viral . Everyone knows the truth.
Kaha par hai full video @@JohnDoe-zj6xf
Azba is crying while reading the comments 😂😂
Azba
نے اپنی بے عزتی خود کرواٸی ہے عوام سے ۔ مطالعہ کرتی اور سوچتی کہ کیا کہہ رہی ہے لوگ علم دیکھتے ہیں اور زبان کی نوک دیکھتے ہیں ۔
😅
Yeh Ghalat baat hai .. 😂
As a woman I totally agree with sahil adeem and Khalil ur Rehman
THE WAY THEY DESCRIBE THE WHOLE ISSUE THAT WAS AMAZING AND THANK YOU AYESHA FOR GUIDING US FOR SUCH AN IMPORTANT ISSUE.
I agree, if in a country there is no justice, equality, freedom of speech and human rights then how can we have so-called 'women rights' and meet their demand of being totally independent?
She is thinking jahil is gali is ko english me bol dete os ko bora na lagta 😊
😂😂😂""anti liberal semtic"
U R brain wash Jahadi
landy ki liberal hogi vo pakka. Jo aksar sleeveless shirt pehan k wanna be western bany ki koshis kar k bari khush hoti hn.
😂
@@sairawaqar9180 😂😂😂 point
😂😂😂😂
She just listened the word jahil and ignored all the context, and all she wanted was to listen a sorry for her satisfaction 😂.
Sird aik bat ..audience main plz thoray say educated log bitha diya krain ..azba was there to represent a woman ...but she couldn't deliver our point views ..she just started fighting..
Darhaqeqat ye khwateen haqooq ke chakr mai sunny Leoni bana chati hain😂
😂😂😂
Say that for your mother and sisters as well
Jahaalt ki hadd h k ap is comment ko likhna fakhr samjh rahe ho
hahhhha
I totally agree with sahil and khalil saheb
The trio is amazing and finally for the first time , been able to fully understand Khalil Sir as well over women rights issue . The addition of Sahil Adeem is Gold . I think they should permanently take him on panel too as hes a man of wisdom and it would generate good trp
She had a negative mindset about being in 95%. 😂
جب تک شریعت نافذ نہیں ہو گی
کوئی مسئلہ حل نہیں ہو گا
Shariat to awrat ko adhi aqal, abhi gawahi or abhi wirasat ka hamil makhlooq samajhta hain.
Agreed
اسلام وعلیکم ورحمت اللہ
شریعت کے نفاذ کی ابتداء خود سے پھر اپنے گھر میں پھر اللہ کی زمین پر
اج اور ابھی سے شروع کرنا ہے وقت ضرور لگے گا مگر کامیابی حاصل ہو گی کیونکہ فرد سے گھر اور گھر سے معاشرہ بنتا ہے
@@gudagi2391agr apko ye baten pta hen to ye bhi pta hoga k is k.peechy reason kya hy😊 adha adhora knowledge na seekhen or na aagy pohnchain plzz
تم سب نے خود پر قرآن نافذ کرلیا ہے؟😑
Sahil adeem and sir khaleel Ur Rehman !!!!! Both of the best things to happen to Pakistani youth 😍❤️❤️❤️❤️
I clearly didn't understand that what was the anchor doing the whole show after getting all of her questions beautifully answered. two great controversial personalities are gathered at your show. They answered you at 100% percent and you put them again at 0
Not the host or the audience fit for sahil sir's presence
"..aap mujhe Arbi mein Aayat suna rahe hain... Maafi maange aur mere sawaal ka jawaab dein.."
Proved Sahil Adeem's case why females need education..
Sorry to say, ye dono admi kitny batameez, short tempered hein🤔😱
@@shahpar4107 yes, you should be sorry to say this. Agreed.
Go watch the full video now.
@@00786faiz I really don't hav time to watch these arrogant, sick minded men.. U go ahead!
@@shahpar4107 ye dono nahi. Wo larki aik badtameez insaan thi
@@kashifihsan bilkul
2 min silence for that girl😂
21 topon ki salaami aap k lye ....aap un 5% main sey hain
@@opimusno12012 na msg krty to mujhe pta na chla k ap usky bhai hain
@@abdullahsaleem6807 Wow aap sey waqai aisy hi bekar baat ki tawaku thee kyunki aap ka ustaad saahil adeem hai....anyways sorry if you felt insulted in anyway...that was not my motive
@@opimusno12012 ap search krn ayat jhutla rahi larki ur iska mtlb smjhty?
She is not a girl , she is a mature aurat
I really want to emphasize the fact that the host has NOT done her homework on her guests especially Sahil adeem! Also want to highlight the fact that the video has been cut wrongfully in several places such as
57:39 video got cut when that girl demanded sahil to give a verse as proof and sahil gave it on spot!
59:11 video was cut where that girl was shown her face in the mirror and was taken to the cleaners because of her extremely arrogant attitude...
We need more scholars like Shil Adeem even more than more...
Jahalat ki had tab hoti hai jab jahil ko "jahil" lafaz ka bhi pata na ho
Sahil kay andar tak Taoot ghsa hua hai, buhot jahil admi hai
Good show. More of this is needed. The host needs to stop being so cringy.
These two are real intellectuals who have mutual respect for each other ❤
Azba if you are reading this comment then remember you proved that you are among those 95%
Ajeeb tamasha hai Pakistani media par😊
KHALI-LULL TYPE PHILOSPHERS KI BAHOOT JARURAT HAI SOCIETY KO...
Ao mil kar es tamashey mein shmail ho jaeyen
This is a great intellectual conversation jisko app tamasha ke rahy hain
MashaaAllah tabarakAllah Sir Sahil and Sir khalil
Sir Sahil ki baat prove ho gaye both males were amazing but ladies proved Sir Sahil is 100 percent right
This is one of the most vile and shocking things I've seen. So crazy to have so many people brainwashed into thinking that sort of conduct is ok!
She proved that sahil adeem was right 😂❤
This woman is super intelligent,she is not going to listen and understand.
Exactly
At least she is not dumb like you
Azba jahil hai mai is bt pr maafi mngta hun k isy pta ni tha ye jahil ha kmaal bt 😂😂😂. Amazing reply by sahil bhai
21 topon ki salami aap k lye ke aap un 5% main sey ho
Apko taggoot ka mtlb pta tha ?
بہت ہی عمدہ مکالمہ ہم ترس چکے ہیں ایسی گفتگو کے لیے ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Happy to see these conversations happening in Pakistan. This is what will take country to the right direction in the long term.
In the case of a woman having the support and strength, she does go for separation and custody. And Pakistani laws for divorce unjustly support women.
But the majority of the women don't have that support. They don't have a place to go and everyone around them disowns them. They end up compromising and suffering.
And many of the men suffer in the same way. Less than women but they definitely do suffer.
Unfortunately, I have observed that whoever has some power over the other will utilize that to be unjust and abuse the other.
Sahir is right ❤ smjhne wale smjh rahe hain
Why did you cut the clip at 58 min, where Sahil recited the quranic verse in arabic, and you also cut where qaleel ur rehman told that girl to leave.
It's such a shame. As a national TV channel, you guys hide the truth.
The lady was right to ask that question. Adeem is an ignorant person. knows nothing beyond God. Making a blanket srtatement that 95% women are Jahil is such an ignorant and offensive statement.
وومن رائٹ یہی کیا کم ہے کہ وہ دو مردوں کے درمیان بیٹھی سوال و جواب کر رہی ہے۔
کیوں مرد فرشتے ہیں جو عورت ان کے پاس بیٹھ کر بات نہیں کر سکتی
Sai 😂😂😂.. Hades main h ky aurat taarhi pasli sy paida ki giy h .. so usy sedha krny ki zarorat nahi wrna bycahri Tot jy gi
just for sahil adeem here
That aurat was obsessed with him to say sorry! Nothing else!
My question is... Woman rights or human rights alag alag q mention kiye ja rhy 😂😂😂😂
Exactly yhi tu amjhana h ... woman khud ko insan nahi smjhty kya
His whole point was to speak up against oppression but through the right channel and DO NOT BACK DOWN AT ALL!
it's really a worth full and outstanding mukalma and teachings which sahil and Khalil sb presents. is trhan k intellectuals ki qoum ko need hai. please invite them more and more and more
Khalil sahb not coming slow Very funny jab he said agli dafa isay yahan bethao😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Please promote these level of talk shows.
Sahil Adeem and Khalil ur Rehman both are gems of Pakistan.❤❤❤❤
Hyy shail adeem lines .sir ya wala pressure zyda h akhirat ka kam h . Love u sahil bhai .
Sahil is Jahil. Tahoot uskay andar tak ghusa hua tha.
Sahil Adeem Sab Grt salute You ❤
The girl's way of talking was disrespectful but sahil adeem still talked in a respectful manner and called her beti and Appp !! But khalil ur rehman's wayy was worsee !! Ghalt ko sai k sath durust kren na k aur ghalt kr k !! Sahil adeem knows how to correct a person even without humiliating others !
Exactly!! Khalil ur Rehman hamesha badtameezi pe utar aate hayn
Don't censor the show, it takes away from the meaning of "Mukalma"
The girl is being so unreasonable!
She's a Misandrist
What a great and such a educational programe۔ I appreciate to samaa tv to take such a good initiative instead of volger night show and morning shows۔ this tupe of prgrammes are really needed for Pakistan community ۔
What else do you want to enlighten the Women rights
I believe that issues exist and then there are external bodies which utilize this to spread chaos and break the society.
That’s a mind blowing episode ❤❤
I like the way when Khalil Ur Rehman speak he is very humble ❤
Great scholar of a time Sahil Adeem
I love sahil adeem and his smile😂😂😂❤
These men in the panel dont want generalization against men when incidents involving male culprits are mentioned, but have no obstacle in generalizing against women who raise their voices for opressed women.
That girl is so annoying! She is just lusty to get viral
Asl ma orat ko begarat mard psnd h . Rok tok krny wala usy zehr lgta h. This comment is summery of this series.
This is called manipulation and controlling
You love to gaslight girls
Han ye bat orat asal m apna ap mardon ko dikha k Khush hoti ha
ہمارے معاشرے میں عورت ہی مظلوم ہے اور بایک وقت ظالم بھی۔ اسکی مثال یہ ہے کے جب ایک مرد شادی کرتا ہے تو اس پہ واجب ہے کے وہ اپنی بیوی اور آنے والی نسلوں کے لیے گھر بنائے ۔ اسلام میں جوائنٹ فیملی سسٹم کا کوئی کونسیپٹ نہیں ہے مگر یہاں بھی ایک ماں اپنے بچے کو گھر بنانے سے روکتی ہے کے میرا بیٹا میری نگاہوں سے دور نہ رہے۔
kon kon tiktok pay video dhk ke aya he 😂😂
We need one sahil sb in every house. I think then this society will be changed. I'm a huge fan of sahil adeem
Politicians
Islamic Scholars
Parents
Teachers
Sab k sab Sahil Adeem per char dortay hain
Why can't we just accept our failure our mistake our ignorance n lack of knowledge this is literally the first step towards progress hum kum az kum apni galhti to maanain k we don't have the Islamic knowledge rather than being arrogant disrespectful n embarrassed infront of the whole world
Reply
According to Qasir raja ye Desi feminist Our desi secular hai.. 😂
Kon?
Sahi
Sahil adeem deserve other 5% women in audience because this legend is way ahead of time
Comment section dekh kr sukoon hua hai, nai to viral shorts me comments parh parh kr tension ho ryi thi bohat.... well done sir
Pak society at its worse .
Ap morning show dekho na phir. Usme bari azmat hai na
Jao saas bahu kay dramay dekho.
pajeet spotted
To undo your 🧠 washing goto Awaz e haq uncensored channel
is larki jesa aik adha piece har khandan main maujood hai.
Zain chaa Gaye o totally agree 👍
2 3 minimum pieces confirm
😂😂😂
Bhoot khoob...
Hats off to Sir Sahil Adeem and Khalil Sahab on answering in a logical way
Wishing more courage and wisdom to lady who raised question!