No Concubines/No Slaves in Quran (ENGLISH) | Meaning of ما ملکت ایمانکم|Reply to LIES in God's name

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 17. 10. 2022
  • Video in English.
    Malakat aymanukum ما ملکت ایمانکم does NOT mean slavery. There are NO concubines / harems / sex slaves in the Islam of the Quran.
    An academic response to these allegations against God.
    #slavery
    #Islamicslavery
    #concubine
    #sexualslavery
    #humantrade
    #mahr
    #fitna
    #conditionsofnikah
    #mahar
    #bridalgift
    #bridalmehndi
    #interfaithharmony
    #interfaithmarriage
    #hindumuslim
    #hindumuslimlovestory
    #muslimhindu
    #shadi
    @Mufti Tariq Masood Speeches
    @Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza - Official Channel
    @IRC TV
    @Dr. Farhat Hashmi
    @Tariq Jamil
    @Yasir Nadeem al Wajidi
    @Pakistani Mufti
    @Mufti Fazal Hamdard
    @MUHAMMAD SHAIKH
    @Islamic Awakening
    @Awaz E Haq Official
    @Qaiser Ahmed Raja
    #polygamy
    #4wives
    #multiplewives
    #pluralmarriages
    #nikah
    #shadi
    #surahnisa
    #suratnisa
    #nikahislami
    #nuslimshadi
    #mehndi
    #rukhsati
    #walima
    #halala
    #talaq
    #FemalesInIslam
    #womeninislam
    #zakar
    #untha
    #rijal
    #nisa
    #hijab
    #genderequality
    #GenderInQuran
    #FemalesInQuran
    #AuratInQuran
    #GenderInIslam
    #MultipleMarriages
    #polygamy
    #ViolenceAgainstWomen
    #4:34
    #islam
    #quran
    #qurandiscussion
    #qurandebate
    #islamdiscovery
    #questionsandanswers
    #quraish
    #makkah
    #hajj
    #parda
    #alhajj
    #tawaf
    #umrah
    #almasjidannabawi
    #kaaba
    #almoses
    #hijabers
    #almasjidalharam
    #masjidalharam
    #qurbani2k21
    #qurbanistatus
    #qurban
    #quranichajj
    #surahfeel
    #kaaba
    #makkah
    #mecca
    #QuranVSAhadith
    #LearningQuran
    #QuranCentric
    #QuranVsSunnah
    #QuranAlone
    #Kalamullah
    #QuranicTerms
    #QuranicMustalahat
    #AbbasidIslam
    #Shirk
    #Al Moses
    #TaqlidiIslam
    #Mullah
    #Mushrik
    #MuhammadCharacter
    #QuranTranslation
    #QuranUrdu
    #QuranHindi
    #LiveConversation
    #Live
    #TheftPunishment
    #CutHand
    #ChoppingHands
    #CapitalPunishment
    #CapitalPunishmentInIslam
    #Punishment
    #Quran
    #ShareQuran
    #LaylatulQadr
    #AlMoses
    #NightofPower
    #Ramadan
    #Ramzan
    #Slavery
    #SexualSlavery
    #Londiyan
    #Laundiyan
    #SlaveryInIslam
    #Shirk
    #marvelousquran
    #TheMarvelousQuran
    #mushrik
    #QuranTranslation
    #ReadingQuran
    #UnderstandingQuran
    #LearningArabic
    #Arabic
    #AlMoses
    #QuranicArabic
    #Ramadan
    #Ramzan
    #Fasting
    #Eid
    #Roza
    #MarriageAyesha
    #MarriageAisha
    #Ayesha
    #Aisha
    #ProphetMuhammadandAyesha
    #ProphetMohammadandAisha
    #AyeshaAge
    #ChildMarriage
    #UnderageMarriage
    #MarriageWithChildren
    #Nikah
    #Pedophilia
    #MolanaTariqJameel
    #MolanaTariqMasood
    #TariqMasood
    #MuftiYasir
    #MuftiYasirNadeemalwajidi
    #MuftiWajidi
    #IndianIslam
    #MarvelousQuran
    #QuranvsHadith
    #PakistaniIslam
    #ZakirNaik
    #DrZakirNaik
    #Salat
    #Salaat
    #Namaz
    #Nimaz
    #Deen
    #QuranicTerms
    #SalatAurNamazkafarq
    #EngineerMuhammadAli
    #Islam
    #Quran
    #Barelvi
    #Barelwi
    #TableeghiJamaat
    #MolanaTariqJameel
    #TariqJameel
    #MuhammadSheikh
    #Parvezi
    #QuranCentric
    #Tuqoos
    #TariqMasood
    #MolanaTariqMasood
    #PeghameHaqq
    #Musalleen
    #killinfidel
    #killkafir
    #kafirKon
    #kafir
    #debatewithmuslim
    #muslimvsnonmuslim
    #muslimvsexmuslim
    #sachwala
    #halal
    #muftifazalmahmood
    #muftimubashir
    #muftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
    #muftiyasirnadeemalwajidirefuted
    #responsetomuftiyasirnadeemalwajidi
    #muftiyasirnadeemalwajididebunked
    #muhammadsmarriage
    #muhammadsmarriagerefuted
    #muhammadmarriagewithaisha
    #muhammadsmarriagetozainab
    #muhammadcharacter
    #answeringislam
    #answeringchristianity
    #viral
    #contradictioninquran
    #quraniccontradiction
    #contradictioninislam
    #islamiccontradiction
    #indianexmuslimsahil
    #islam
    #quran
    #exmuslim
    #indianexmuslim
    #sachwala
    #quran
    #leftislam
    #zafarheretic
    #harissultan
    #ghalibkamal
    #mehleej
    #mahleej
    #aminasardar
    #jaidevi
    #indianmuslim
    #exposeislam
    #extremism
    #islamicextremism
    #exmuslimvsmuslim
    #neerajatri
    #tufailchaturvedi
    #muftitareeqmasood
    most subscribed channel
    #muftitariqjameel
    #ahlehadees
    #barelvy
    #sunni
    #shia
    #keralaimam
    #apostasy
    #talaq
    #tripletalaq
    #sudarshannews
    #wasimrizvi
    #indianexmuslimsahil
    #Sunday
    #Hijab
    #ZeeNews
    #IndiaTV
    #MuslimWomen
    #whyileftIslam
    #indianexmuslimsahil
    #islamic #islam #allah #muslim #islamicquotes #quran #muslimah #allahuakbar #deen #dua #makkah #sunnah #ramadan #hijab #islamicreminders #islamicpost #prophetmuhammad #love #muslims #alhamdulillah #jannah #islamicart #muhammad #instagram #islamicreminder #pakistan #madinah #namaz #madina #bhfyp
    #islamicquote #subhanallah #ummah #islampost #islamicposts #art #urdu #prophet #quranquotes #urdupoetry #follow #hadith #islami #prayer #kuran #like #instagood #dawah #instaislam #pray #loveislam #m #life #hijrah #india #bhfyp #islamquotes #peace #hajj #quranverses
    #indianexmuslimsahil #exmuslimsahil
    #leftislam #exmuslim #IndianExMuslimSahil #Islam #kafir
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 168

  • @BismilKhan-fz3ef
    @BismilKhan-fz3ef Před 3 měsíci +5

    This Ramadan , I decided to understand the Quran , I started with an English translation I read these translated verses and that was so painful and hard for me to accept that Islam allows such an evil conduct I knew from heart that it can’t be possible something is wrong I went to pray tahajjud I cried in the prayer and asked Allah that if it’s not true then find me a source a sign that it’s not true and after making dua I picked my phone to do a research about this topic and your video just popped up , now I am so grateful to Allah for this video ❤ that Allah showed me that there is no such evil conducts Islam allows thankyou so much brother , may Allah grants you highest rank in jannah , I am so grateful to Allah that he places such understanding , intellectual in the hearts of people like you that even after so many scholars and a huge no of muslims believing this he put guidance in your heart to find the right interpretation and to make people aware of what is wrong is wrong even after so many people believe in this , I am so grateful to Allah that I am blessed with such knowledge after seeing your video I am encouraged to learn Arabic by myself and to read and understand Quran by my own without any translation , thankyou so much brother please keep going on you are doing such a great work , indeed you are a beautiful creation of Allah blessed with knowledge and guidance !!!

  • @sf.72
    @sf.72 Před rokem +21

    Salaamun alaikum .my son who prayed five times .fasted regularly and performed tarawee was almost at the verge of leaving islam .this rang bell of panic for me .that was turning point and i started looking what is wrong .thanks to allah me and my children are blessed with truth .

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +6

      Salamun alaikum, that's great to hear!
      We should separate Allah's instructions from humans'.

    • @hello_worLd6104
      @hello_worLd6104 Před rokem +3

      Check the marvelous Qur'an channel plss

  • @msikaworld7516
    @msikaworld7516 Před 10 měsíci +6

    I knew from my heart there was no slavery in the Qur'an, I didnt know how to prove it, but i knew with all my strength. It didnt make sense, or that God would just be a sympathiser of the existing culture not one that expects man to be transformed and enlightened, through his revelation.
    Imagine my relief in finding your video. If anyone thinks owning slaves is okay is no submitter. Something must be wrong with you.

  • @user-hb1zo6fd5w
    @user-hb1zo6fd5w Před rokem +3

    Thank you so much
    God forbid these r the Ayat that always made me uneasy and always thought a day will come when I’ll come to know the real meaning of these ayat
    I being a woman who always asked Allah why women folk are not even near to equality to men .
    U cleared them all.
    May Allah bless u.

  • @shaheednoor9983
    @shaheednoor9983 Před rokem

    Slm from Cape Town South Africa u really open my mind Allah bless u with your good work

  • @sheikhahmadmushtaq9406
    @sheikhahmadmushtaq9406 Před rokem +10

    Great Hush! is over. Great purging has begun. Keep going bro.

  • @rabbitvee321
    @rabbitvee321 Před rokem +2

    very happy to find ur channel, brother pelase create another or secondary english only channel, because its much eassier for us people around the world to know your shared understanding of (alquran) the reading, hopefuly it will be a reality in the future n maybe a patreon too so we able to also share with u for ur expense, im really hopeful, and maybe also an episode numbering so it will be much eassier for us to search, peace be upon u brother n may god guide us all amin ❤, btw for me personally islam is not an administrative religion n god's name is not allah, god is the god ilah is allah, i think its better if we not left some word untranslated when we try to translate "the reading", when we talk in english we should say it the god not allah to prefent missintepretation because lot of people think that the gods name ia allah but its not

  • @hash7373
    @hash7373 Před 11 měsíci +1

    جزاك الله خير

  • @TADABUR-AL-QURAN-ALKAREEM
    @TADABUR-AL-QURAN-ALKAREEM Před 3 měsíci +1

    Brilliant AL MOSES BROTHER, KEEP IT UP 👍 👍 👍 .

  • @UALIS123
    @UALIS123 Před rokem +2

    Dear Mosa, I know off-topic but, I am confused about this verse 9:51 and, I couldn't rationally justify it to my friends. Can you make a podcast on this verse, please?

    قُل لَّن یُصِیبَنَاۤ إِلَّا مَا كَتَبَ ٱللَّهُ لَنَا هُوَ مَوۡلَىٰنَاۚ وَعَلَى ٱللَّهِ فَلۡیَتَوَكَّلِ ٱلۡمُؤۡمِنُونَ ۝٥١

  • @bellkeycemyran883
    @bellkeycemyran883 Před rokem +2

    Hey I really appreciate the analysis and interpretation you have here. I'm an English speaker and it's been my understanding that nikah has always meant marriage/intercourse in Qur'an and even in modern Arabic. Could you explain how you came to the definition of nikah as contract and not marraige?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      I'll leave you to double check meaning of nikah in classical Arabic dictionaries.
      In Quran, it most def isn't to do with intercourse.

  • @tayyibanoor6396
    @tayyibanoor6396 Před rokem +5

    sir I almost quit islam but then found thi channel

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +2

      Alhamdulillah

    • @tayyibanoor6396
      @tayyibanoor6396 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD Sir do you think the true muslims will rise again
      Cause I wanna do something for islam for Allah but what can I do? how can I play my part?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      @@tayyibanoor6396 Allah is lord of ilm. Go learn and make the world better than you found it

    • @tayyibanoor6396
      @tayyibanoor6396 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD how can I do so I'm just by myself in this

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +2

      @@tayyibanoor6396 medicine, science, business. Go study and work hard

  • @soarose
    @soarose Před 7 měsíci

    Salam Moses , is their an inconsistency in one of your translations or is it explained some other way :
    70:30 [in the first slide ends with ] "except from their partners ot thise under their care"
    Where as
    70:30 [in the slide after]
    "except from their wives or those whose care they're under"
    One would mean they're the carers and one would mean they're the ones cared for.
    Is that a problem in the translation or is there a way to explain it ?

  • @rayyanali9260
    @rayyanali9260 Před rokem

    thnx a new koran alone channel

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +3

      probably better to call it a Quran centric channel.

  • @helpertron8054
    @helpertron8054 Před rokem +1

    I really appreciate your work in trying to get the true translation. But I don't understand the verse even when translated in English. What does the verse mean and how does that relate to me?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Which verse?
      Regardless the intention is to show that the Quran has got nothing to do with slavery

  • @fairoozsadaf3450
    @fairoozsadaf3450 Před rokem

    May God bless you brother may God bless ameen 🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @rashiqraquib1641
    @rashiqraquib1641 Před rokem

    22:40 Maybe my understanding of Arabic is poor, but how could it be translated as "those whose care they are under?" It seems like a stretch to me, but again I don't have a strong grasp of Arabic yet. Could you please explain? JazakhAllah khair.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Those who own their care = others like nurses in charge of others (like you).
      Azwaj isn't wives. Will cover it one day

  • @earnesteffort8115
    @earnesteffort8115 Před rokem +2

    Assalamu Alaikum,
    It would be great if you please give the name or link of the dictionary where you found the translation or meaning of Ma Malakat Aimanukum/Hum. Then I could at least start convincing my housemates and close relatives. Because things are so ingrained in people's minds that they won't believe without reliable evidence.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      SA, within the Quran, you can look at the root word and how it's used.
      There is little need to go to dictionaries for this term

  • @dankhulani9324
    @dankhulani9324 Před rokem

    Yes ,his cousin Ali could have given the proper understanding, no doubt in the knowledge of what it all meant,this is how we wouldn't go astray by some one giving g the wrong understanding of the Ayat

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      'Allah' gives hidayah and fahm of the Quran to who wishes for it.
      'No' human can give it to us.
      I don't argue: you can make your own choice

  • @rokyadiakite2395
    @rokyadiakite2395 Před rokem +1

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @yudiarianto498
    @yudiarianto498 Před rokem +1

    Excelent and convincing.
    Despite several issue may lead to dis construction the current belief.
    But it is okay.
    Question: I agree the words “nikah” can be translated as a contract between parties (as your translation IMHO) then how about marriage?
    Since in my understanding you seemed to translate nikah, ajwad, and nisa, are about “business” or in general terms, then how God regulates marriage and who can be married?
    Or, in loose terms: how a relationship (sexually) between two genders is valid in God’s eye?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      I've talked about 'gender' in depth in Urdu, and how we've short changed women.
      In short, there is no 'marriage' instructions in the Quran. A Nikah can be an application of the overall mafhoom but nothing inherently to do with gender based relationships

    • @yudiarianto498
      @yudiarianto498 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD Got it.
      So, it is understood that there is no Quranic regulation for divorce (thalaq) as traditionally understood?
      Then, thalaq is something like “agreement cessation” or how to end a contract?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +4

      @@yudiarianto498 Correct.
      Quran talks to the nafs and not the 'male' gender

  • @sedicfaremerteve
    @sedicfaremerteve Před 5 měsíci

    ur amazing… why u stop making more video with that kind of explanation?

  • @raeheedbrown3728
    @raeheedbrown3728 Před rokem +2

    I just want to be guided and I want to correct translation like this one. Is there a way Mr. Moses do you have a translation English translation?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Sorry I have no intention of doing a translation.
      Keep practising the Quran and Allah will guide you

    • @raeheedbrown3728
      @raeheedbrown3728 Před rokem +1

      @@AlMosesPhD yes, sir, I sure will and please pray for me until then peace be with you

  • @AliveSince1975
    @AliveSince1975 Před rokem

    Greetings Brother.
    Have you made a video on the Quranic definition of Rajul and Nisa’a?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Yes, but not in English

    • @AliveSince1975
      @AliveSince1975 Před rokem +3

      @@AlMosesPhD maybe a English version in the future Insha’Allah

  • @mohammedamin9201
    @mohammedamin9201 Před rokem

    Salaam brother do you have a copy of your translation of the quran I can get.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Salam, no I have not translated the full mushaf

  • @fairooslebbe3000
    @fairooslebbe3000 Před rokem

    Go ahead Moses
    May God shower mercy on you

  • @irfanahmad3715
    @irfanahmad3715 Před rokem

    Salam Brother, have you translated 4:11, 4:12 and 4:23, what is your view on these verses

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Salam, I'll cover them in the Urdu series when i return to it

  • @ServanT-of-Allah-
    @ServanT-of-Allah- Před rokem

    Salam everyone

  • @alhassanjabir-td5ue
    @alhassanjabir-td5ue Před 4 měsíci

    Salam brother. تحرير رقبة is also translated as freeing a slave. Please I will like to have a clear understanding of that. Thank u.

  • @filmdramashorts
    @filmdramashorts Před rokem

    Salaat ki video kab anni hai

  • @mt000mp
    @mt000mp Před 6 měsíci +1

    Brother Moses , do you think this video needs some updating? or is this video has already a solid foundation?
    Salam.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 6 měsíci

      No man's understanding is perfect.
      Take whatever's good from here, then keep improving.

  • @zarabees2123
    @zarabees2123 Před rokem

    I really like your channel but please make them in English. You only have one or two in English. Your channel can reach more Muslim viewers.

  • @AK-hp4rj
    @AK-hp4rj Před rokem

    Where in the Quran can I read about marriage, then?

  • @powerofknowledge2356
    @powerofknowledge2356 Před rokem

    Hi which transaction you recommend to read in Urdu or English

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Best to cross-reference and use many.
      English, the most rational one I can recommend is M Asad for his footnotes.

    • @fairooslebbe3000
      @fairooslebbe3000 Před rokem

      So far no one is correct as a complete.

    • @Oxygen11115
      @Oxygen11115 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD
      M Assad uses hadith

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      @@Oxygen11115 Yes. His, to me, is still one of the most 'rational' complete translations. Best is to always cross reference and discard the translator's brackets

    • @shaheednoor9983
      @shaheednoor9983 Před rokem

      Slm could pkease give mecyour understanding of sura 3 verse 7

  • @raeheedbrown3728
    @raeheedbrown3728 Před rokem +1

    Is there a way I can get this proper translation of the Quran?

    • @raeheedbrown3728
      @raeheedbrown3728 Před rokem +1

      @@duartecboc8028 thank you my brother. I love you for this I really appreciate it. I am highly grateful.

    • @duartecboc8028
      @duartecboc8028 Před rokem

      @@raeheedbrown3728 hope you found them,in quran roots page you have a pdf with all roots and meanings.
      Good traveling, and may allah open youre horizons of understanding quran, peace and blessings from (lisbon-portugal)old Alandalus

    • @cooperbatu
      @cooperbatu Před rokem +1

      @@duartecboc8028 salam brothers I would also like to get a proper translation but I couldn't see your previous messages. If you could share that again that would be very helpful.

  • @mt000mp
    @mt000mp Před 6 měsíci

    I'm not sure about the three's and four's here... are these things really numbers??
    why would would God ascribe arbitrary quantities or prescribing times.
    maybe these so-called "numbers" are actually qualities,
    and these so-called "time" are the aims / functions.

  • @raeheedbrown3728
    @raeheedbrown3728 Před 11 měsíci

    Hello and peace dr Moses. While watching your video I heard you say the Quran does not mention marriage, does that mean no marriage just connecting to someone?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 11 měsíci

      Marriage is a form of a nikah--not the only form

    • @raeheedbrown3728
      @raeheedbrown3728 Před 11 měsíci

      @@AlMosesPhD I research that word nikah it said a contract. So you’re saying that marriage is some sort of a contract. Forgive me if I’m misunderstanding you, but I don’t wanna be misguided. If I want to get with a woman, we sign a contract? Or it’s nothing at all? I’m still learning forgive my ignorance

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 11 měsíci

      If you speak urdu, please watch the Nikah vids

    • @raeheedbrown3728
      @raeheedbrown3728 Před 11 měsíci

      @@AlMosesPhD no I do not speak Urdu I’m English and that’s the only language that I know that’s why I’m trying to get a lot of clarification on the interpretation but I’m really interested and I just wanna be guided so I really want to know this because this is interesting. If it does not name that pacifically, then how do a man and a woman come together in a commitment

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 11 měsíci

      @@raeheedbrown3728 in short, I didn't find the Quran talking about a specific form of nikah.
      I'll like to cover this topic properly in English so will leave it at that for now

  • @DrSohailSAhmed
    @DrSohailSAhmed Před rokem +2

    Asalamoalykum.
    I'm unable to understand where you're deriving your translations from? They're so confusing…
    You claim that the entire Muslim scholarship introduced meaning into the Quran that had nothing to do with Allah's Religion but you failed to produce the source that you use to derive all the various meanings. How exactly did you come up with the correct meanings for the words (without using the traditional Arabic dictionary)?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      SA,
      If you understand Urdu/Hindi, you can watch the playlist 'Quran and Aurat' to see the foundation laid

  • @o56_idress_ahmed_ee32

    Where are you from?

  • @rashidjawaid3779
    @rashidjawaid3779 Před rokem

    Excellent Mosa👍

  • @hello_worLd6104
    @hello_worLd6104 Před rokem +1

    Aap Mumbai se ho?

  • @GorgeousMia
    @GorgeousMia Před rokem

    Can u make a video on multiple marriages of men n women both. The decision one should make . Can a women go for multiple marriage???

  • @mahfouz7142
    @mahfouz7142 Před 4 měsíci

    Just watched the whole video. Due to the ultimate understanding of this being contingent on the understanding of other key terms, i wish you would have started by explaining them first. It makes it difficult because you are essentially presenting us with a concept that we can only really consider once we have the background, which in this case for most of us is not possible unless we speak urdu.
    I feel that you're on the right track and the notion makes sense. However when you substitute the meanings of the terms into the verses sometimes it just reads like absolute jibbererish and doesnt make any sense. Just sounds like a bunch of words that lack any real meaning. I probably am not articulating what im thinking that well, but i hope you get what i mean.
    Also, seeing that you've concluded that there is no mention of slavery in the quran, do you then consider slavery as permissable? Would you say it depends on the society and norm? Do you get where i am going with this? You made statements about homosexuality and paedophilia not being forbidden or wrong or fahisha because they were not, according to your understanding, mentioned in the quran. Do you see how you are inconsistent with your application of your logic if you believe slavery is wrong. In both instances, through reflection and logical deduction, and in keeping with the theme of the quran, you must arrive at only one conclusion: homosexuality, paedophilia and slavery are all evil and unnatural acts that are a detriment to society and lead to its decay.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 4 měsíci +1

      Don't put words in my mouth please: re-watch the third video in Rasul Lut series re paedophilia / homosexuality.
      Re the other question: The Quran's whole msg is about freeing the human: from ideas that wear him down mentally and bodily.
      Refer to the Quran and tell me Allah forbade you from freeing the raqaba, helping those under burden, the masakin, the mustazafeen.

    • @mahfouz7142
      @mahfouz7142 Před 4 měsíci

      @@AlMosesPhD not putting words in your mouth brother. Either you believe slavery is a good thing, which is bad or you believe it is a bad thing, which proves my point thst logical deduction and common sense prevail.
      I dont get what you're asking me to do in the last paragraph, can you please reiterate?

    • @mahfouz7142
      @mahfouz7142 Před 4 měsíci +1

      @@AlMosesPhD also, and please dont take this as an attack because i genuinely agree with most of what you're saying, how do you come up with definitions for words? Do you refer to lexicons, do you refer to the nunetics thing? What is the methodology you use?
      I personally use lexicons, context and the quran itself (consistency of application) to form an understanding, but the more i delve into this the deeper the rabbit hole gets.
      One thing that's on my mind now is how there are several readings of the quran, hafs, warsh etc and how these readings can have different texts. How does the promise of preservation fit into this scenario? Where does this leave the truth seeker? How do we choose the right one kr differentiate between them for that matter? Look forward to your responses

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 4 měsíci +1

      @mahfouz7142 brother, please watch the third video as it covers this.
      I'll cover methodology in the next video. Already covered in urdu.
      No multiple qiraat, just one. Again I've covered this but not in English

  • @salihahmetaj
    @salihahmetaj Před rokem

    Dear Al Moses,
    I am very glad that I've found your channel a few days ago. Seems to me that you're doing a great job. I'll proceed with some comments or questions.
    The key question is regarding the verse 51:56. As I cannot speak nor understand Arabic, PLEASE tell me which meaning is accurate:
    a. 51.56 And I did not create the jinn and mankind except TO WORSHIP ME
    or
    b. 51.56 And I did not create the jinn and mankind except TO WORSHIP
    The emphasis is on "ME", is there one ore not. Please answer me. And we will, God willing, will continue discussing.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +2

      Salam,ibadah is not worship but to carry out the mission given by Allah (there is 'me' in the ayah).
      I've talked on it in Urdu, maybe one day in English too.

    • @salihahmetaj
      @salihahmetaj Před rokem +2

      @@AlMosesPhD Thank you very much for your reply. I know that IBADAH doesn't mean WORSHIP. Qur'an itself defines it:
      Verse 3:51, seems to me, makes a connection between IBADAH and STRAIGHT PATH. It is clear from this verse that who does IBADAH is on the STRAIGHT PATH.
      Verse 6:151 explains what HARAM means, or at least teaches us that HARAM is not only forbidden. At the same verse a list of DOs and DON'Ts begins and the list continues with the verse 6:152.
      In the verse 6:153 God informs us that if we follow the list mentioned in two previous verses, we would be in HIS STRAIGHT PATH.
      So the conclusion, in my opinion, is that doing IBADAH, is nothing else than behave as THE Human (in best meaning of the term) being.
      Therefore, by changing of the meaning of IBADAH to WORSHIP is the most damaging act of so called ULEMAs, immediately after the Prophet's death till today, done to the God's Original Revelation.
      Why so?
      Because WORSHIP, in my opinion, is something very abstract, not measurable, impractical and completely useless.
      In others side True IBADAH, as I understand, consists of concrete, measurable, practical acts of being in servitude to each other with the aim of betterment of communities in this planet and as a result being a good candidate to have enjoyable place in Afterlife.
      To conclude it is very difficult to understand the Revelation, because the so called ULEMAs for 1400 years distorted key concepts of ITS meanings. To tell the truth I am really afraid for myself and others who are aware that we have the Revelation with such distorted meanings of the key concepts.
      Therefore it will be very nice that all of you who have good knowledge of the Qur'aniq Language to join your efforts in explaining key concepts and terms.
      Thank you very much once again and continue your very valuable work.
      God bless you and your Family.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +2

      @@salihahmetaj Keep reading brother. You're on the right

    • @salihahmetaj
      @salihahmetaj Před rokem +2

      @@AlMosesPhD I'll do. But I and a lot of people like me, need help from you and others like you in understanding the key concepts and terms.
      Thank you and, God willing, offer us more materials in English, if you can.
      God bless you.

  • @rahulshubh8103
    @rahulshubh8103 Před rokem

    Is premarital sex haram?

  • @Apsua72
    @Apsua72 Před rokem +1

    I think the reason why it is not for women to marry multiple men is obvious. If a man marries several women, one knows who the father is, but if a woman were to marry several men, one would not know whose child it is. that makes sense. we also know from history that some prophets had more than one wife like abraham, jakobus, David or salomon. some translations make sense but some are pretty strange. I think it's human nature to make mistakes but don't overdo it. peace

  • @mohdkamil1095
    @mohdkamil1095 Před rokem

    Sa .Mosa bhai me hidi Urdu samajhta hu or shayad zyadatar aapko log usi zban me sunna chahenge. or ha me inglish ki mukhalifat nhi kar raha hu

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      SA, buhat logon nay English mein bhi kaha tha.

    • @mohdkamil1095
      @mohdkamil1095 Před rokem +1

      @@AlMosesPhD sa .ha koi bat nahi lekin hame bhi yad rakhna guzarish he aapse

  • @rayyanali9260
    @rayyanali9260 Před rokem +1

    btw what r your views on sam gerrans?

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Intelligent guy too stuck up on conspiracies and a biblical worldview that doesn't match up with Quran

    • @Ishtanara
      @Ishtanara Před rokem +1

      @@AlMosesPhD
      What do you think of his method of translation ?
      I appreciated his effort and commitment. Just didn’t agree with everything but he said he is open to being critiqued and welcomes it

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      @@Ishtanara his inherent biases come through his translation.
      This is part of being human

  • @mohammadzeeshan7074
    @mohammadzeeshan7074 Před rokem

    Salam, as you told there is no details for humans marriage in the quran? But quran is fully detailed and marriage is top most part of an human life why allah would leave that point??

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Salam, 'shadi' is a contract, so comes under the overall guidelines.
      Were'nt people doing shadi before the Quran?

  • @sadafali377
    @sadafali377 Před rokem +1

    Sir did you make a video on head coverings of women i.e. khimaar...if yes then tell me..if no .then kindly make on it..

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Not yet

    • @sadafali377
      @sadafali377 Před rokem +1

      @@AlMosesPhD ok sir . Kindly make a video on this topic of women head and face covering

    • @cheryllang98
      @cheryllang98 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD yes pls!!

    • @laylaali5977
      @laylaali5977 Před rokem +1

      The Quran recommends both men and women to dress modest but it doesn’t say women should cover their head head coverings are just tradition for both men and women

    • @sadafali377
      @sadafali377 Před rokem +1

      @@laylaali5977 yes but I want to have a deeper look in the verses of holy Quran about dress code as Al Moses is making other videos. I just want to know the exact words of Allah.

  • @amiros_2001
    @amiros_2001 Před 6 měsíci

    Okay, if polygamy is Evil, then explain how the prophet had multiple wives. The Quran proves he had multiple wives, there's no where to escape it

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před 6 měsíci

      Take a deep breath brother, then re-read the Quran carefully.
      Don't jump to conclusions or mud slinging.

  • @mohdfadzilshuhaimiramli5789

    Are you another Quran only guy?

  • @syedabdullahmujtehdi1534

    Salaam
    I can't believe you have dedicated almost 2 weeks, just for defending the Quranic ayaath pertaining to slavery in Islam.
    Those muftis and social media CZcamsrs are adamant on defending traditional Islamic (other than Quran) sources. They will not accept our points and we will not accept their points.
    Please continue videos on Nisa series. It looks like your efforts will not change their point of view, even if you explain each and every ayath related to "Maa Malakath aymaan"
    They will counter your points in another 6 hour CZcams video. And it will go on in an endless circle.
    Let them live in their andh bhakti. You did more than enough to prove their understanding as false, biased and inhumane opinion.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +4

      Salam, I needed to do my bit.
      Even if the grand stars of YT or traditional scholars refuse, the ordinary muslim will listen.

    • @Kop901aklopq
      @Kop901aklopq Před rokem +1

      It's duty to share truth.....by uploading video or by sharing the same video

    • @Ishtanara
      @Ishtanara Před rokem +1

      @@AlMosesPhD
      For every person who is against you and defend the traditional view. There maybe two or more in the background who’s eyes are opened.

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      @@Ishtanara inshallah

  • @dankhulani9324
    @dankhulani9324 Před rokem

    This is Y he said to follow the quraan and his family. ,in order for us not to go astray!!!!

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      'Family'? Allah's messenger was told to use only one thing as a reminder: the Quran

    • @dankhulani9324
      @dankhulani9324 Před rokem

      Yes this is what was reported that he said in the last sermon

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      Up to you. That 'tradition' has three versions.

  • @rehaankhan9546
    @rehaankhan9546 Před rokem

    Aurat ko face cover karke rakhna aur mard ka face khula hua Aisa kyu

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem

      aisi koyi bat nahi hay.
      Mein isay cover karun ga

  • @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086
    @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086 Před rokem +1

    islam allowed man to have four wives

    • @AlMosesPhD
      @AlMosesPhD  Před rokem +1

      Sad for men, but no.
      Watch 'Quran aur Aurat' series

    • @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086
      @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086 Před rokem

      @@AlMosesPhD please do not confuse whats your point prohpet and sahaba had many wives

    • @__Amira__
      @__Amira__ Před rokem

      @@naqeeb-e-inqelab4086 Allah advise to married 1, because man can not be just to multiple wives.

    • @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086
      @naqeeb-e-inqelab4086 Před rokem

      @@__Amira__whats your point allah advised one but man is allowed to keep four wives in islam if he can afford

    • @__Amira__
      @__Amira__ Před rokem

      @@naqeeb-e-inqelab4086 it's not about afford. Allah know that most men can not be just! Hence He advised to married 1. Quran 4:3

  • @arifmohammed7832
    @arifmohammed7832 Před 3 měsíci

    Why u r lies there is slavery in Quran

  • @amiros_2001
    @amiros_2001 Před 6 měsíci +1

    So the sahaba were wrong, the salaf were wrong, the early scholars were wrong and the late scholars were wrong? ... And you, in 2023 just figured out what the Quran actually means? I'd rather leave Islam than follow your sect

    • @omarsalim9562
      @omarsalim9562 Před 4 měsíci

      hhh why are u mad do u believe in quran or scholars😅

    • @amiros_2001
      @amiros_2001 Před 3 měsíci

      @omarsalim9562 I believe in the Quran, not a washed up understanding of it.
      The Quran tells us that it's a clear book (15:1), if no one understood it for 1400 years, then it's not a clear book.
      I invite you to believe in the Quran and leave this misguidance.

  • @TheRightness-nx1gq
    @TheRightness-nx1gq Před 2 měsíci

    Don't twist the Ayaths of Allaha, if malakath aimanukum is the children can it be treated as that of wives... What foolish interpretation is giving by you