종현이 30대 40대는 얼마나 성장했을지 궁금하고 보고싶다 추억으로만 남기엔 너무 아까운 천재아티스트 종현이 참 이 먄 저 말 하고싶고 들려주고 싶은 따뜻한 말이 많은데 아주 먼 미래겠지만 다시보게되면 하고싶은 대화 밀린 대화 나누며 우리한테 해준 따뜻한 말들 위로들 이젠 우리가 돌려주며 서로채워주며 위로하며 보고싶다 따뜻한 샤이니 오이니 행복하자
5 things that i really appreciate everytime SHINee's performing 1. The quality voice of the boys 2. The visual 3. The outfit 4. The supportive shawols 5. The beauty of shating star
Also when Onew smiled and said “you did well” and looked up, it kind of lifted up my spirit. I mean seeing him being able to smile remembering Jonghyun, it helps me to cope and start to move forward. It comforted me in a way. Sigh look at the boys being strong for us shawols ♥️
I really hope so. Hope that they could sing all three releases. I wouldn't mind if they add in "All day, all night", "Who waits for love" and "I say". Turn Mama into a Shinee concert. ❤️❤️❤️
I feel that at the end of year awards will be special SHINee mini-stages (at least I hope so) as a celebration w/ peers and industry of all 5 members' accomplishments.
I wanna hug them. The way Jinki looked up after saying "You did well" and when he smiled made me tear up. 😭 I know we're still in the process of healing. Let's not forget our angel and keep him in our hearts. Let's heal together.
When Jinki oppa says "you've done well" and looks up, I once again realize, that he is the most strongest leader a group ever had, you've done well to jinki oppa 💕
Kathy0741 agree. Even I don't know what the meaning of the lyrics ( I want to searching the meaning, but I am afraid that it can makes me more sad. Because just saw they perfomance its already make me cry )
It's like I can never live the true reality fo his death, then this song comes on and then onew says 수고했어 and it hits me like a ton of bricks all over again
I'm sure they feel the same as you do. It is so impossibly hard to face the reality that beautiful Jonghyun took himself out of all of our lives. Our minds protect our hearts by fooling us that he is just away for a little while and not forever. They are singing this song with a lot of bravery. Bless them, they're in so much pain....
I still cant... I just feel like there's conflict on schedule that Jonghyun cant make it to this comeback... my heart says he will come back😭😭 i really cant💔
+Navya Bhutia There was a situation, of which full details have not been and will not be released, regarding his father, who was in some way absent throughout his childhood; he was predominantly raised by his mother, and something regarding the situation with his father began his depression. I would presume that being a public figure certainly didn't help, for two reasons. One would be feeling a disconnect with "normal" people, and an inability to connect with what would be his peers, resulting in loneliness. The second, as mentioned by Super Junior's Leeteuk on Super TV, is a loss of his own sense of self; the side you show to the public is not necessarily the real you, and living in this persona for long enough may cause self doubt regarding identity (I don't know if this is what Jjong felt, but he would be in a similar situation to Teuk, therefore I believe this to be relevant). We will never have the full details, however, and this is merely my speculation based on articles and logic. I hope this helps though...
it takes a lot of guts to be where the boys are today...i am not a shawol but seeing them performing and how shawols are....shinee and shawol become 1...united by the story they share...everyone...you did weĺl too...you can do this..
such a beautiful song. everytime i listen to this song, i can feel the sincerity, and i cant hold my tears. and the ending of this video makes me cry even more, Jinki :""" Thank you SHINee, so proud of you
I'm so grateful for everything they did in these last months... they didn't have to do it, but they did it anyway and it's been a great source of comfort for us but also for them I think. Let's rely on each other and let's keep walking together on this road for a long time ❤ I'll always love these amazing 5 boys.
"There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories" "Our voices are flying We know it will reach you wherever you are" "May 25, 2008 [debut date] boys shining brightly" "We're facing each other We're still the same We're still the boys who are dreaming" "Until the very end" "You did well" 😭😭😭😭😭😭 Strikes to my heart. Bull's eye. And then a thousand tears. You did well boys
this is by far the best camera work of this performance. the cameramen shot the boys' faces that sung their part, even when they did adlibs. i really love it. thank you so much MBC. and of course, shinee did well, jonghyun did well.
tea fany What were the ad libs ? All I caught was Key doing a beautiful extra trill higher which gave me the chills it was so evocative and emotive. These guys are such artists.
NO SONG will be ever written as beautiful as this. THE BEST TRIBUTE any members, friends, and brothers could ever give to AN ANGEL. Saranghaeyo SHINee.. FOREVER5.
![SHINee - Our Page | 샤이니 - 네가 남겨둔 말 [Music Bank / 2018.07.06]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UlSi2klVjO8/mqdefault.jpg)
![SHINee - Our Page | 샤이니 - 네가 남겨둔 말 [Music Bank / 2018.07.06]](/img/tr.png)
![[Comeback Stage]SHINee - Tonight , 샤이니 - Tonight Show Music core 20180630](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VpPT1QKNTy0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[SHINee's BACK] Ep.5 Our page (ENG SUB)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PFNYrfmbKWA/mqdefault.jpg)
수고했어 라는 네글자가 이렇게 마음 아플지 몰랐는데 .. 5명 모두 샤이니 해줘서 고마워
맞아요 민호의 저음 목소리가 ㄴ너무 장 어울려요!
아니면 징기가욧???
수고했어 라는 진기 가사와 표정을 보고 진짜 엉엉 울어버리고 말았어요. 뭔가 저도 위로받는 느낌이네요..
이때활동했던 무대들은 못 보다가 이제 봅니다. 대단하고 감사하고 덕분에 살아갈 힘을얻어요 샤이니 계속 멋진 활동 보여줘요❤
한 명의 자리가 내눈엔 커보였는지 몇 년 동안이나 무대를 제대로 마주하지 못하다가 이번 컴백이 되어서야 똑바로 볼 수 있게 되었어 다음 컴백도 그다음 컴백도 다함께 같이 가자 고마워💕💕
이 노래 무대만 보면 무조건 울어서 자주 못 보는 노래 ㅎㅎㅎ 종현이가 생각날 때마다 꼭 챙겨보게되는 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
종현아 올해 샤이니가 벌써 데뷔 15주년이야! 멤버들이 오랜만에 뭉치는 만큼 다치지 않고 활동할 수 있게 지켜줘! 보고싶다 사랑해🩵
진기거 수고했어 얘기하면서 하늘을 올려다보고 웃는게 종현이한테 하는것같아서 슬프다 사랑해 김종현
I AM CRYING WHEN JINKI LOOKED UP I AM CRYING
I'm totally crying with you! TT
me too;(
Me tooo
you are not alone!!:"(
you're not alone.
샤이니는 여전히 앞으로도 계속 다섯명이야 그사실은 변치않아 사랑해 이마음이 전해졌으면 좋겠지만... 다섯명 모두다 너무 사랑하고 고마워 사랑해 이진기 사랑해 김종현 사랑해 김기범 사랑해 최민호 사랑해 이태민
마이샤이니월드 보고 이 무대를 처음 봤어 그동안 마주하기 힘들었던 것들이 하나둘씩 괜찮아졌었는데 이 노래는 차마 못듣겠더라고 34살의 종현이는 어땠을지 너무 궁금하다 너무너무 보고싶어! 나중에 꼭 다시만나자 사랑해
종현이 30대 40대는 얼마나 성장했을지 궁금하고 보고싶다 추억으로만 남기엔 너무 아까운 천재아티스트 종현이 참 이 먄 저 말 하고싶고 들려주고 싶은 따뜻한 말이 많은데 아주 먼 미래겠지만 다시보게되면 하고싶은 대화 밀린 대화 나누며 우리한테 해준 따뜻한 말들 위로들 이젠 우리가 돌려주며 서로채워주며 위로하며 보고싶다 따뜻한 샤이니 오이니 행복하자
5 things that i really appreciate everytime SHINee's performing
1. The quality voice of the boys
2. The visual
3. The outfit
4. The supportive shawols
5. The beauty of shating star
Ps World your comment made me smile :)
I think you spelled shining wrong
I smiled reading this too.
@@jenos__smile9662 if you're talking about the fifth point, it's really called shating star 😂😂
Nithi Haruhi lol
이노래는 진짜 샤이니 콘서트때 꼭들어야해서 해줫으면❤
종현이에게 가사 그리고 진심을 가득 담은 목소리 다 전해졌으리라 생각해요
샤이니 멤버들 다 지켜봐주고 있을거임
헐 태민 너무 예브다 이때 샤이니 종현 일 이후 처음 낸 앨범같은데 좋다좋아...❤
Also when Onew smiled and said “you did well” and looked up, it kind of lifted up my spirit. I mean seeing him being able to smile remembering Jonghyun, it helps me to cope and start to move forward. It comforted me in a way. Sigh look at the boys being strong for us shawols ♥️
웃는모습이 이쁜 모자가 세상제일 잘어울리는 종현오빠....
3년이라는 시간이흘렀으니 이제는 다시 돌아올때가 됬네....
언제든지 돌아와줘....되도록이면 빨리....
애가 견디기 힘들었다는데 왜 돌아오라 그래요
Jinki at the end :(((
Jamie Wickham who's jinki?
حفصة Jinki is Onew 😂😂
"You did well"
Hafsa B. 0:23 thats him
@@hafsa1698 Onew is jinki
Jinki's smile at the end
진기 기범 민호 태민 너무 고마워 그리고 5hinee 사랑해 마지막까지 함께 채우자 우리
when I hear the phrase 'You did well' my tears are always falling
how do they not break down while singing this..?
Sooty Soot ikr 😢
Sooty Soot Jinki already shed his tears after recording TT
@@bhua3416 they probably bottled their feelings up
I really hope they could preform this song at mama or another big award show so all fandoms can hear it
SpoopyKpop same! I wish they can perform three titles from the story of light
Chenhsuan Lin oh my 😍
yes pls!!!
I really hope so. Hope that they could sing all three releases. I wouldn't mind if they add in "All day, all night", "Who waits for love" and "I say".
Turn Mama into a Shinee concert. ❤️❤️❤️
I feel that at the end of year awards will be special SHINee mini-stages (at least I hope so) as a celebration w/ peers and industry of all 5 members' accomplishments.
진심은 어떻게서든, 어느 형태로든 전해지니까. 우린 그걸 잘 알잖아. 그치?
샤이니 모두가 평안하고 행복하길 기도해봅니다 마음으로 늘 응원할게요
아 진짜 최근에 푸른밤 매일 듣고도 괜찮았는데… 그냥 종현오빠 보고싶다~ 사후세계가 있다면, 정말 꼭 행복만 했으면. 모두에게 사랑을 주고 간 만큼 사랑받았으면. 이런 생각만 했는데, 이거 보니가 엉엉 눈물이 나와요… 샤이니 영원해 사랑해 다섯 명 다 사랑ㅎ ㅐ
진짜 보고싶다 종현아...나도 모르게 피했었는데 더이상 피하지 않고 마주할게.담담하게 극복해볼게 좋은 말 많이 남겨줘서 너무 고맙고 수고했어..그 곳에선 먹고싶은것도 마음껏 먹고 행복하게 편히 쉬길 바랄게..
3:47 눈물나 에바야..ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아픔을 나눌 수 있는 노래가 있다는게 참 위로가 되는 것 같다
고맙고 사랑해 그리고 그리워
비욘라 보다가 울음 꾹 참는 온유 보고 다시 보러옴.. 항상 응원할게 고마워 사랑해 💙
우린 영원히 다섯이야 마지막까지 함께 채우자
샤이니 팬이라 행복해
진짜 온유 목소리 장난 아니네요..ㅠㅠ 특히 마지막에 수고했어 라고 하늘 올려다 보는거 너무 울컥하게 되네요..ㅠㅠ
They way Onew looked up at the end though 😢
새벽에 울컥했네 가사가 너무 예쁘다
와.. 소름 돋았어.. 샤이니 고마워.. 종현아 사랑해..
I wanna hug them. The way Jinki looked up after saying "You did well" and when he smiled made me tear up. 😭 I know we're still in the process of healing. Let's not forget our angel and keep him in our hearts. Let's heal together.
😞😞
우리의 페이지 마지막까지 함께 채우자. 영원히 사랑해💎
When Onew says "You did well", he looked above and smiled 😇 What an angel...
이 노래만 들으면 너무 눈물이 나오는데 오랜만에 제대로 듣네 종현아 잘있지? 아주 긴 여행을 떠나는 중이라고 들었어 그 여행에서는 원하는거 맘껏하고 행복하게 지내야해 부디 사랑해 우리 자몽, 우리 쁘띠
썸네일의 저 토끼를 보고 그냥 지나칠 수가 읎넹,,
POWER VOCALS
I love how the camera show the view of Shawol Lightsticks near the end and SHINee harmony is very beautiful 😍❤💘❤❤❤
When Jinki oppa says "you've done well" and looks up,
I once again realize, that he is the most strongest leader a group ever had, you've done well to jinki oppa 💕
Jee linki who that is?
@@zanibaji onew
what really hurt me is how broken he was when he received the news, I think he really is strong to heal in his own way T_T
2024년에도 본다 우는 건 그리워서 그래 슬프다기 보다는 그리워서 우는거지
전부다 고마워 그냥 한때 아니 지금까지도 내 기쁨과 위로가 되어줘서 잊지 않을게
아직 어디선가 숨 쉬고 있을것 같고 웃고 있을것만 같아 우리 꼭 다시 만나자 그때는 힘들지 말고 항상 행복해줘 사랑해 고마워
이 무대를 보기까지 얼마나 오래 걸렸는지 몰라 오늘도 사랑해
종현이형.....
떠나기전에는 꿈에도 모르던 평범한 가수였지만....
지금은 너무 그리워....
가기전에 샤이니에 관심을 가졌어야 했어...
미안해...
그리고 사랑해 종현이형...
노래 너무 눈물난다ㅠㅠ
수고했어
종현 오빠는 하늘나라에서 편안하게 잘 있을거에요!! 샤이니 끝까지 사랑하고 응원할게요!!♥♥
사랑해 모두가 영원히 잊지않고 너를 기억해 기억속에서 살아가는사람은 영원해.
my tears just flooding down my face every single time hearing this song. I am so proud of them. Thank you for your hardwork, 5HINee❤❤❤
Kathy0741 agree. Even I don't know what the meaning of the lyrics ( I want to searching the meaning, but I am afraid that it can makes me more sad. Because just saw they perfomance its already make me cry )
SHINee x PHINee Reading the translation of the lyrics will surely flood your house 😭😭😭😭😭
SHINee forever i just did that now and i break the soon as i reached the chorus and reached my peak at the 수고했어 part😭😭😭
Kathy0741 same goes here... always as in ALWAYS...
SHINee x PHINee read the lyrics. It really shows the members feelings about Jonghyun 😊
보고싶어 진심이야
This song deserves to win some music shows 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Their voices are beautiful. Their performance, the stage, the outfit, all of perfect. Screentime for shawols 😭
Jinki looks so peaceful & contended towards the end 🙌
I can not be more grateful with SHINee.
Whoever did the captions" Shinee world really appreciates it".
Thank you😊
:)
Please protect and support my boys 🙏🙏
It's like I can never live the true reality fo his death, then this song comes on and then onew says 수고했어 and it hits me like a ton of bricks all over again
aznfangrl612 ikr i feel less alone now that you posted this
I'm sure they feel the same as you do. It is so impossibly hard to face the reality that beautiful Jonghyun took himself out of all of our lives. Our minds protect our hearts by fooling us that he is just away for a little while and not forever.
They are singing this song with a lot of bravery. Bless them, they're in so much pain....
You are not alone with that but it's okay to miss a person dearly
정말 수고했어..
Jinki..
SHINee I love you so much, so proud of you guys ❤
jinki's sweet smile when he looked up
I still cant... I just feel like there's conflict on schedule that Jonghyun cant make it to this comeback... my heart says he will come back😭😭 i really cant💔
Why was he in depression?
+Navya Bhutia
There was a situation, of which full details have not been and will not be released, regarding his father, who was in some way absent throughout his childhood; he was predominantly raised by his mother, and something regarding the situation with his father began his depression. I would presume that being a public figure certainly didn't help, for two reasons. One would be feeling a disconnect with "normal" people, and an inability to connect with what would be his peers, resulting in loneliness. The second, as mentioned by Super Junior's Leeteuk on Super TV, is a loss of his own sense of self; the side you show to the public is not necessarily the real you, and living in this persona for long enough may cause self doubt regarding identity (I don't know if this is what Jjong felt, but he would be in a similar situation to Teuk, therefore I believe this to be relevant).
We will never have the full details, however, and this is merely my speculation based on articles and logic. I hope this helps though...
온유 표정이 쭉 어두웠다가 "수고했어"라고 속삭일 때 만큼은 웃는 거... 너무 짠하다ㅠㅠ 참.. 마음 아프네
I'm thankful that the camera captured the moment of Jinki saying "You did well" and looking up with a smile ;_;
오랜만에 들으러 왔어 보고 싶다
가사 진짜너무 좋다
항상 응원하고 있어요 사랑합니다❤️
WHY ONEW SO DAMN HANDSOME ???!!!!!!!....his SMILE, his VOICE...everything just PERFECT !
너무 수고했어요 절대 안 잊을게요 정말.. 잘자요
온유 민호 키 태민 열심히 하는 모습 보면서 눈물이 나네요 항상 응원 을하고 있을깨요 건강 조심하고 행복해요 사랑합니다 💜
Onew whispered then looked up at the sky! it's touching! Jonghyun…😭🤧❤
샤이니가 좋은게 같이부를때 어우러지는게 청량하서 좋음
잘버텨줘서고마웡
it takes a lot of guts to be where the boys are today...i am not a shawol but seeing them performing and how shawols are....shinee and shawol become 1...united by the story they share...everyone...you did weĺl too...you can do this..
종현 오빠뿐만 아니라 진기 오빠 기범 오빠 민호 오빠 태민 오빠 모두 진짜 정말정말 수고했어 늘 빛나는 5HINee 영원해
such a beautiful song. everytime i listen to this song, i can feel the sincerity, and i cant hold my tears. and the ending of this video makes me cry even more, Jinki :""" Thank you SHINee, so proud of you
아직도 웃는 얼굴이 생각나는 우리 오빠!! 늘 미안하고 보고싶어.. 거기서는 행복해야해~!!
vocals vocals vocals...only Shinee in kpop are so perfect...Jinki smile to sky after you did well is so sweet
It will hurt, whatever we lost is lost 😔
when onew sing you did well at the end and look up i swear it just break my heart fighting shinee and onew i hope you will be okay
가사가 구구절절 너무 이쁘면서 슬프다
I'm so grateful for everything they did in these last months... they didn't have to do it, but they did it anyway and it's been a great source of comfort for us but also for them I think.
Let's rely on each other and let's keep walking together on this road for a long time ❤
I'll always love these amazing 5 boys.
항상 행복했으면 좋겠다 💙💎
Onew smile
JINKI IS THE MOST PRECIOUS HUMAN BEING IN THE WORLD
"There are five overlapping hands, tears and memories"
"Our voices are flying We know it will reach you wherever you are"
"May 25, 2008 [debut date] boys shining brightly"
"We're facing each other We're still the same We're still the boys who are dreaming"
"Until the very end"
"You did well"
😭😭😭😭😭😭
Strikes to my heart. Bull's eye. And then a thousand tears. You did well boys
오이니 영원히 사랑해💚
this is by far the best camera work of this performance. the cameramen shot the boys' faces that sung their part, even when they did adlibs. i really love it. thank you so much MBC. and of course, shinee did well, jonghyun did well.
tea fany What were the ad libs ? All I caught was Key doing a beautiful extra trill higher which gave me the chills it was so evocative and emotive. These guys are such artists.
In our page... They will always be 5. Until the last chapter come.
it always hit me hard when it comes to 2008 05 25
jungbebeeh and the 5 hands overlapping. 😭😭
The stage is beautiful. Their voices are beautiful. Their harmonies are beautiful. 5hinee is beautiful! ☆☆☆☆☆
진짜 보고싶다...
Who will believe that Minho and key are rapper with their melodious voice💚💚💚💚
this is really beautiful.... vocals, lyrics, the boys themselves ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 수고했어 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Shawols are the best fandom ever. Keep shining.
The camera work in this perf is just amazing! Jinki smiling at the end and looking up tho...
To whomever who put the subtitle, GOD BLESS YOU and THANK YOU.
여전히 슬픔.....ㅜ 오랜만에 이 노래 듣는데 오열중.....ㅜ
NO SONG will be ever written as beautiful as this. THE BEST TRIBUTE any members, friends, and brothers could ever give to AN ANGEL. Saranghaeyo SHINee.. FOREVER5.