One community struggles with debate over decades-old fire siren

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 22. 03. 2023
  • A local community struggles with debate over a decades-old fire siren and whether or not it should be decommissioned.
    6abc.com/fire-department-sire...

Komentáře • 97

  • @ProductOfThePines
    @ProductOfThePines Před rokem +46

    absolutely disgusting how a councilman has the disrespect to say he disagrees with the fire department on why they need it. Are you a volunteer Councilman Haldeman? For you to argue with men & women that volunteer their own time, and safety to help protect YOUR community, you're arrogant asf. 100% of these firefighters are people in your own community.

    • @bottleandscrap7626
      @bottleandscrap7626 Před rokem +1

      its good

    • @ritirons2726
      @ritirons2726 Před 9 měsíci +4

      The thing he’s not thinking about, is that most firefighters are very influential people.
      They have the respect of many people in the community, the same ones that VOTE.
      The councilman should keep that in the back of his mind.

  • @FBHSswimmer2006
    @FBHSswimmer2006 Před rokem +28

    All these people complaining about the fire whistle being loud, obnoxious, and want it silenced will cry "Where is the Fire Dept" or "Is the Fire Department even on their way" if their house is on fire or their loved one is in a MVA. The fire whistle not only alerts the volunteers to come to the station, but also signals the call was received and firefighters are on their way.

    • @stephenhanneken3041
      @stephenhanneken3041 Před 3 měsíci

      The siren tells people that the call has been received. It does not guarantee that anyone will respond or how many will respond.

    • @FBHSswimmer2006
      @FBHSswimmer2006 Před 3 měsíci

      @@stephenhanneken3041​​⁠Yes that is true. My Dad’s old station has that problem. The whistle will blow twice and no one shows up.
      But I believe most of the time in this town's case that the Volunteers do show up. Like the Chief said in the video, one of his Volunteers was eating breakfast just 2 blocks away, pager never went off, but he heard the whistle and showed up.

  • @strongmermaid4651
    @strongmermaid4651 Před rokem +25

    What a bunch of selfish people

  • @tylersheehy3918
    @tylersheehy3918 Před rokem +28

    make it louder

    • @fmartinjr
      @fmartinjr Před 10 měsíci +5

      Word up. And higher mounted for more coverage

    • @mightyocelot
      @mightyocelot Před 9 měsíci

      And add more of the upgraded version. Because L to these selfish idiots

  • @fmartinjr
    @fmartinjr Před 10 měsíci +8

    And borough/town type fire company, how busy is that Company that these people are complaining about the siren like it was just put into service last week?

    • @Stargazzer811
      @Stargazzer811 Před 7 měsíci

      Lets see. Langhorne is located in southern Bucks county near Levittown, and is a northern suburb of Philly and adjacent to Trenton, NJ. There are 99 companies in Bucks county, of which most are probably fully or at least partially volunteer. From what I can find, the average number of runs for most surrounding departments is about 400 to 500 runs in a year. At 450 runs divided by 12 months rounded up, that's 38 calls a month on average. Depending on what the county SOP is regarding siren activation and if the department assists the township EMS squad with calls they may or may not sound the siren for EMS runs. If they do, that's 38 times a month that siren goes off on average. Thats about 1 to 3 times a day if calls are consistent, but since they never are you'd probably see a day with no calls followed by a day with 4 or 5. So, they are fairly busy but not nearly enough to were the siren is annoying. But I'm biased after all, I'm a fireman and a volunteer.

  • @colddeadhands5167
    @colddeadhands5167 Před rokem +22

    Of all the things to argue over......SMH

  • @fmartinjr
    @fmartinjr Před 10 měsíci +11

    Like it was never a nuisance 20 or 50 years ago? Its a Fire Siren, ding a lings, its supposed to be loud!
    Everyone petitioning to silence it..become Active members!

  • @gcannon455
    @gcannon455 Před rokem +26

    I was a FF for 25 yrs. There were times I would be outside work in my yard and my pager didn't activate if it wasn't for our station siren I wouldn't have even known we had a call. Just because there all this "new technology" doesn't mean it work any better than the old technology.

  • @garyhawkins4952
    @garyhawkins4952 Před rokem +11

    sirens at fire stations are very important ... these need to stay...what is next ?..no sirens on emergency vehicles......

    • @Stargazzer811
      @Stargazzer811 Před 7 měsíci

      Nah worse, they want to get Eurotrash sirens in places like NYC, because they are "quieter and cause residents less stress." Yeah, they also can't be heard until they are on top of you and are obnoxious sounding.

    • @kyleholmesWROM589
      @kyleholmesWROM589 Před měsícem

      ​@@Stargazzer811ATI sirens also fail constantly they are the shittiest siren company in the world

  • @wolfpacva
    @wolfpacva Před rokem +21

    The people that dont want the sirens the fire dept should not respond to those people that dont want it.

    • @TimeWisely
      @TimeWisely Před rokem +1

      Fire departments have their opinions, but they never let their bias prevent them from helping, that's what makes them so cool, they will always be there to help, no matter how you feel about them.

    • @wolfpacva
      @wolfpacva Před rokem

      @@TimeWisely some do so u dont have any idea what you are talking about

    • @TimeWisely
      @TimeWisely Před rokem

      @@wolfpacva ... wow, okay, you're quite a rude one aren't you? maybe you should look in the mirror going forward.

  • @channelobserver365
    @channelobserver365 Před 10 měsíci +11

    You don't like it Moveeee

  • @TimeWisely
    @TimeWisely Před rokem +8

    Oh boohoo, poor people get woken up :< It's an emergency siren, boss. What if you remove a siren from an ambulance? those are loud too, but does that suddenly make it acceptable? Their designed to get your attention. Just because your fancy little doohicky works 90% of the time doesn't mean they all work the same, this siren is loud, efficient, and gets the job done, who cares if it wakes you up, it can save your lives, and it will save other people's lives.

  • @user-hu2jg1ww3m
    @user-hu2jg1ww3m Před 7 měsíci +2

    I a member of a fire dept that still use the siren on the roof of our fire station .But it only is used during the day time from 730am to10pm . We have pagers and cell phones . The one reason we still use it so the public know when there is a fire and there will be members responing to the station and also during the summer that if they are using water to shut it off . I agree it doesnt need to be oparting at night.

  • @NewJerseySirensAndTrains
    @NewJerseySirensAndTrains Před 10 měsíci +8

    uhhh im gonna say keep it, it looks in good condition

  • @whatevs4531
    @whatevs4531 Před rokem +7

    Bothered by a siren I love old siren especially ww2 air raid sirens

  • @mattteixeira6077
    @mattteixeira6077 Před 10 měsíci +6

    People need realize siren let's them coming help them get life dude

  • @Petemonster62
    @Petemonster62 Před rokem +5

    Is the siren also used to warn of severe weather?

    • @HZW1712
      @HZW1712 Před 10 měsíci +2

      Maybe

    • @jonathan248
      @jonathan248 Před 9 měsíci +2

      I'd imagine not. If that's the case then firefighters would be responding to the station for severe weather but no emergency.

    • @Petemonster62
      @Petemonster62 Před 9 měsíci +2

      @@jonathan248 - The city will have 2 different ways to blow the siren - one is the siren blowing a steady tone - the 2nd is to have the siren tone repeatedly rise and fall. One is to summon the volunteer firefighters & the other is for warning of an emergency such as a tornado or enemy attack.

    • @jonathan248
      @jonathan248 Před 9 měsíci +2

      @@Petemonster62 That would make sense, but wouldn't it be difficult to educate the public on all of these variations?

    • @Petemonster62
      @Petemonster62 Před 9 měsíci +2

      @@jonathan248 The community could put it on paper, make copies for the local schools for the students to take home & share with their parents. The local newspaper, radio stations, cable access TV would also help inform the town's citizens about the siren warning codes.

  • @BigC205
    @BigC205 Před 10 měsíci +13

    new generation of Americans always have something to cry about 😭

    • @circleinforthecube5170
      @circleinforthecube5170 Před 8 měsíci +2

      you know the complaints were from boomer NIMBYS

    • @24YOA
      @24YOA Před 8 měsíci +2

      New generation? Everyone complaining is a boomer or older.

    • @theflyer4916
      @theflyer4916 Před 8 měsíci

      How true. Very fragile.

    • @charleshunziker7416
      @charleshunziker7416 Před 4 měsíci

      Like the ones who move next to an airport, then complain

    • @kyleholmesWROM589
      @kyleholmesWROM589 Před měsícem

      ​@@24YOAthe complaints are coming from democrats

  • @SylvesterTheSupernatural

    RIP FS&S STH-10

  • @Stargazzer811
    @Stargazzer811 Před 7 měsíci +4

    Oh, you guys don't like the siren? Tough. The people who save your lives rely on it to know when its time to come do exactly that. Sirens like these sound across America every single day, hundreds of times a day, calling thousands of people into action to do one of the most important and noble duties someone can ever strive to do: Saving Lives. Much like the mechanical siren on the front bumper of a fire engine or truck, that siren is a sound of Hope. When it goes off, it lets everyone know, Hey, Help is on the way. On that principle alone it should be embraced, not replaced.
    On top of that, lets not forget that sirens like that house siren are also used for storm warnings too, like when tornados roll through. If cell service gets knocked out because of a storm and than a tornado forms, that siren can be activated by county emergency services to tell residents to seek shelter. No matter how you slice it, without that siren people die. Leave it be.

    • @kennethlang5480
      @kennethlang5480 Před 5 měsíci

      What's next- No sirens on Fire Equipment.😊

    • @Keaton0801
      @Keaton0801 Před 4 měsíci +1

      Not only that, but if you’re the one calling for help from the FD, when you hear that fire siren, it signals to you that help is on the way. It gives you a sense of comfort and relief, and helps you remain calm. It’s true.

    • @Stargazzer811
      @Stargazzer811 Před 4 měsíci

      @@Keaton0801 Much in the same way mechanical sirens do. I'm biased, being that I'm in the fire service, but I do love me some Q2B.

  • @davey3884
    @davey3884 Před 4 měsíci

    "does it have to be so loud?" 🤣

  • @npcmatrix8250
    @npcmatrix8250 Před 8 měsíci +1

    Keep it. Problem is them people moved there knowing it was there.

  • @TapTapBlipBlip
    @TapTapBlipBlip Před 5 měsíci +1

    Replace the mechanical siren with an electronic one, and use the diaphone tone instead of the wail.

    • @kyleholmesWROM589
      @kyleholmesWROM589 Před měsícem

      Fuck no the volunteers that are in pager dead zones won't be able to hear an electronic siren they only cover a quarter mile area

  • @davidbrass2562
    @davidbrass2562 Před 8 měsíci +3

    What a bunch of wimps, that siren is a backup to when technology fails. They should be happy they have a fire dept. some communities don’t have one and let’s not forget the men and women who volunteer their time to respond to that whistle when it goes off.

  • @stephenhanneken3041
    @stephenhanneken3041 Před 3 měsíci

    I used to live 50 yards-if that- from a volunteer station and with a house full of people on Thanksgiving I did not hear it. It's not as foolproof as one might think.
    The fire service is 200+ years of tradition unimpeded by progress. Sirens and horns have been decomissioned in hundreds, perhaps thousands of volunteer communities and I haven't heard any reports of people dying or entire blocks burning to the ground.

  • @grovecitysirens_GCS
    @grovecitysirens_GCS Před 6 měsíci +1

    you absulutely need that siren, not every body has a phone and also there s no harm in restoring the sth10. please keep the siren and DO NOT decomission it. not only is it useful but the type is becoming rare.

  • @Mr_Toroshi
    @Mr_Toroshi Před 5 měsíci +1

    To my honest opinion,; the siren doesn't need to be decommissioned, it's probably the best choice to go to if the power's out and the siren has a battery backup system. I think the people that want to decommission the Siren just because of it's noise need to STFU.

  • @signal12hvac
    @signal12hvac Před 7 měsíci

    need two ways to alert and sirens were once part of the civil defense system. im sure if the siren was for the complainers, it wouldnt blow long enough or loud enough

  • @travelingwithhunter4383
    @travelingwithhunter4383 Před 6 měsíci +1

    If you’re bothered with the siren, then you must be bothered with first responders, so just won’t come next time

  • @werewolflover8636
    @werewolflover8636 Před 3 měsíci

    Screw these fools! They’re not even willing to pay to staff a fire department yet have the audacity to tell Firefighters that aren’t even being paid what to do? Up yours buddy!

  • @charleshunziker7416
    @charleshunziker7416 Před 4 měsíci

    It was there probably before them

  • @SFClark
    @SFClark Před měsícem

    I can understand if the siren is turned over between 2100 and 0700 hours.

  • @eugenemarria2530
    @eugenemarria2530 Před rokem

    Chester County and Philadelphia County do not use this. Cell signals are mostly efficient. Fate decrees all.

    • @FBHSswimmer2006
      @FBHSswimmer2006 Před rokem +3

      That's all well and fine for in the cities with good coverage. But when you're in a rural area with spotty cell service (still exists in 2023) the fire whistle still wins.

    • @P00katube
      @P00katube Před 11 měsíci +2

      It's high time that those communities bring back the fire station sirens!!!!!

    • @ritirons2726
      @ritirons2726 Před 9 měsíci

      Philadelphia county hasn’t had a volunteer fire company in it since 1871

    • @geebee6010
      @geebee6010 Před 8 měsíci

      Actually Goshen fire company uses a siren

  • @tracylarson1935
    @tracylarson1935 Před 9 měsíci

    I'm in camp of if you don't like the fire siren, pack up and move. Good Riddance. You are not going to risk the lives of the town safety because you don't like. The siren was there before you moved there. It simply pack crap and move back to where you came from. I love to know that my bother and sisters of service will know when emergency incident requires resources.

  • @patman7421
    @patman7421 Před 5 měsíci

    The siren has been there before a lot of the people were. If they don't like it move.

  • @ChevroletGVanMan
    @ChevroletGVanMan Před 7 měsíci

    Just Leave The Siren Alone !! The Siren Is A Vital Safety Alert System .

  • @matthewsullivan9356
    @matthewsullivan9356 Před měsícem

    I say when they go by the counclemans house everyone hits all the sirens federal q and airborne at the same time

  • @npcmatrix8250
    @npcmatrix8250 Před 8 měsíci

    Easy increase the water and sewer and property taxes. Lock into a Motorola contract. Bet they'll shut the hell up after the costs of that and wish they had the siren still. What happened where I am.

  • @charleshunziker7416
    @charleshunziker7416 Před 4 měsíci

    Necessary

  • @scottfoster2487
    @scottfoster2487 Před 3 měsíci

    Having a siren is smart,what happens in a diaster and there is no cell phones working>

  • @dandahms4473
    @dandahms4473 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Time for the snowflakes to move away if they don’t like the siren!

  • @Philly4life924
    @Philly4life924 Před 11 měsíci +2

    Sad thing alarm system does fail. K find whn u don’t get a firefighter to ur emergency don’t cry .

  • @midnightclubshow4332
    @midnightclubshow4332 Před rokem +2

    Put a ACA P-50 siren

  • @allenmiller2064
    @allenmiller2064 Před 3 měsíci

    Video i csnt believe exists

  • @ShortArmStrongArm
    @ShortArmStrongArm Před 3 měsíci

    Poor Karen

  • @aaronstreeval3910
    @aaronstreeval3910 Před rokem +2

    Being some random lad online that has no association to this community.
    I can agree it is important to keep but at the same time every time a boomer falls and can’t get up or the bumpers of two cars simply make contact. That doesn’t warrant a air raid siren to go off in the middle of town.

    • @matteom2174
      @matteom2174 Před rokem +5

      It doesn’t randomly go off for minor incidents so your concern is unwarranted. Only major accidents or fires requiring a large volunteer turnout.

  • @user-qb3zf2bq9p
    @user-qb3zf2bq9p Před 6 měsíci +1

    Leave the siren you losers! Otherwise I suggest you help out at a call

  • @bottleandscrap7626
    @bottleandscrap7626 Před rokem +1

    guddd

  • @MrBNARick
    @MrBNARick Před rokem +2

    "When my pager goes off" EXACTLY!!!! it's 2023 there is no need for sirens anymore, even the Amish volunteers I know in Lancaster county use pagers.

    • @matteom2174
      @matteom2174 Před rokem +11

      Sirens are and will always be an effective back up system.

    • @Tigers9596
      @Tigers9596 Před rokem +6

      Clearly you didn't watch the full segment lol

    • @FBHSswimmer2006
      @FBHSswimmer2006 Před rokem +7

      The Chief said a FF was at a luncheonette having breakfast just a few blocks away from the Fire Hall, his pager did NOT go off but he heard the fire whistle. He was the only driver that showed up.

    • @Tigers9596
      @Tigers9596 Před rokem +4

      @@FBHSswimmer2006 Exactly. There have been plenty of times where our pager network is down as well. We don't use our siren for fires, but I wouldn't be against changing that.

    • @FBHSswimmer2006
      @FBHSswimmer2006 Před rokem +3

      @@Tigers9596 Maybe you should bring it up. And if people get upset about the thought of it going off in the middle of the night, have it on a timer that prevents it from going off say midnight through 5 am. But still have an override if you know a pager outage is occurring.