I respectfully disagree…… Melissa auf der Mayr as bassist and James Iha before his departure for a perfect circle was far superior to the Zeitgeist lineup. Machina and the machines of god was the Apex of The Smashing Pumpkins. Every song on featured on that album were perfect. I will say that this track, bleeding the orchid, and doomsday clock were phenomenal but not enough to make the Zeitgeist lineup stand against the 2000s Pumpkins. I’m glad Iha returned…. Really hoping Machina part Two comes soon!
sometimes ithink there's songs musicians dont get their due for because theyve already done so much....this is one of em...this is a great! alt rock song
mainstream music is in such a bad place right now. SP are are on of the only bands out there that makes real music. Even if you don't think this is as good as old SP we still need to support them. And hey Billy is a genius so he will just keep comin out wit better stuff.
you have got to be kidding me, jimmy isn't a yes man. why would he have to agree with anyone? he's probably one of the greatest drummers in rock now. billy is lucky to have him, not the other way around
YES!!! Thankyou!!! Finally a proper Pumpkins fan. I'm sick of people Whining about the music being about modern situations an without james an darcy. SP4ever! x
yeah, that's true. i don't get people complaining about Jeff not being lively.. because it's not like Iha was. When I saw them in Asheville I thought the new members did fine. (of course I saw them the night Billy coaxed Jeff in to playing with his teeth, lol)
Don't give a fuck what he does now. He was the best during Gish and Siamese Dream. MCIS was also big time. I'm thrown way back to why I still care about this guy. Growing up, he was the shit. Freak is an awesome song. Eh.....
yep, he quit after the tour. they say billy will continue as smashing pumpkins with all touring musicians. i think its dead now. jimmy's drumming can't be replaced
thats because on the cd its Billy playing bass, lead, and rhythm guitar. He's also doing backing vocals too. When recording Zeitgeist, Billy didn't have his live crew yet. After the album was recorded he recuited the live crew like on Live Earth. That may be reason why all the songs sound better live off of Zeitgeist.
I don't know if I ever responded to this, but I know all my friends do, but I mean I'm talking about in general. It seems like even the hardcore fans were a little divided though. Anyways, when I posted that comment I don't think I completely understood the way pumpkins had been boxed in by their hits, which I think contributed as well to a general aura of disappointment with Zeitgeist upon its release. I didn't listen to them then, so this is really just based on what I've read since.
Billy will always be stunning and amazing... But i still want to see him play with his original pumpkins members- D'Arcy, Jimmy, and James... I miss "THE SMASHING PUMPKINS"
While I understand that viewpoint, and I did see that interview, that interview was filmed before she had talked about her solo album. It is pure speculation to say either way.
thanks alot to you guys for letting me know who were the orignal memebers were. and to PaidYouOff how am i being lazy, i just asking other sp fans a question. though it is my fault that i didnt find them earlier. oh and i bout melion collie and the infinite, one word......awesome
This song alone was worth buying Zeitgeist for.
Yup.
And Doomsday clock!
That whole album was insanely good. It's incredibly underrated and honestly maybe my favorite overall Pumpkins album with Siamese Dream.
It sure was...which is why I bought it when it came out
This song is very shoegaze. The droning feedback, the white noise strumming, it's all so beautiful.
Jimmy Chamberlain is a terrific drummer!
This is a stunning song.
I remember being in 9th grade and this was the song that made me find the Smashing Pumpkins. Been in love with them since.
Those synths are amazing
RIGHT!/? I love how he combines hard rock with shoe gaze in this one.
Don't give a shit if a lot of orginal bandmembers left. This band is still awesome. And I love this song. Thnx for uploading.
Probably the best song on the very good new album from the Smashing Pumpkins.
Next to the original lineup, this was the best version of the Pumpkins. Ginger Reyes and Lisa, the keyboardist, kicked ass.
I respectfully disagree…… Melissa auf der Mayr as bassist and James Iha before his departure for a perfect circle was far superior to the Zeitgeist lineup. Machina and the machines of god was the Apex of The Smashing Pumpkins. Every song on featured on that album were perfect. I will say that this track, bleeding the orchid, and doomsday clock were phenomenal but not enough to make the Zeitgeist lineup stand against the 2000s Pumpkins. I’m glad Iha returned…. Really hoping Machina part Two comes soon!
Nicole was definitely the most talented pumpkin bassist on record.
Still hear the MBV influence in them to this day.
This album was incredible very underrated
This is what they call a wall of sound approach...
Just saw this play this song live last nite. Absolutely Incredible
I love billy corgan!!! This song should have been big!!! its really good!!! i love this song live!!!
Shoegaze for the win.
Feels like home.
I don't know why, but I really find this song moving. More so than "Tonight, Tonight" even...I can't put my finger on it.
Same
sometimes ithink there's songs musicians dont get their due for because theyve already done so much....this is one of em...this is a great! alt rock song
Billy Corgan is the best... Good sounds til now. Thank you to the Pumpkins, old and new
That Is What We Need, That Is What We Love.
aside from the original line up this is in my opinion the second best.
I love this song. And I love this performance 🖤
I love Ginger.
Still one of the best Pumpkins song since 2007.
Excellent song, one of the greatest.
This song is so good, it reminds me of the feel that Zwan had.
Love the grungy guitar.
Such a great song! Great album!
that's the best song of this album
I loved Zeitgeist.
I feel a coming age now
I feel a dawn in me
A certain sun keeps rising
On my belief in you
so beautiful.
This is a great song!
nice one billy
my favorite song off the album btw
great stuff
i love this song
SP must to come in Brazil...
Ginger is the cutest of the 4 bassists!
lovely
mainstream music is in such a bad place right now. SP are are on of the only bands out there that makes real music. Even if you don't think this is as good as old SP we still need to support them. And hey Billy is a genius so he will just keep comin out wit better stuff.
What do u think of everything they're doing now
This is great.
you have got to be kidding me, jimmy isn't a yes man. why would he have to agree with anyone? he's probably one of the greatest drummers in rock now. billy is lucky to have him, not the other way around
Thanks a lot for posting. 5 stars. Great album
hey adore was friggin awesome
Эта песня разорвала мою душу в облаках!
underrated song
Well said Zeonoid.
great song !!!
Hey man thanks for sharing this (literally)
Thanks for posting the link to the really high quality version! YOU ROCK!!!
my fav. from the new album
my second-best SP lineup.
YES!!! Thankyou!!! Finally a proper Pumpkins fan. I'm sick of people Whining about the music being about modern situations an without james an darcy.
SP4ever! x
Alto sonido mágico.
looks like a hot little brittney murphy playin bass....yeeeeaaahh
this song is like if _Machina II_ was made by Zwan, or something like that…
I cried to the Moon. Trist is my Man.
love the shoegaze vibe, one of Corgan's best
Love this
:) this made me sooo happy today
me too, they were the best
i don't know why people complain about the new members not being lively on stage, thats not what the smashing pumpkins are about.
quality music
yeah, that's true. i don't get people complaining about Jeff not being lively.. because it's not like Iha was.
When I saw them in Asheville I thought the new members did fine. (of course I saw them the night Billy coaxed Jeff in to playing with his teeth, lol)
Jeff is awesome. So glad he's still in the band.
Don't give a fuck what he does now. He was the best during Gish and Siamese Dream. MCIS was also big time. I'm thrown way back to why I still care about this guy. Growing up, he was the shit. Freak is an awesome song. Eh.....
pumpkins wouldn't be the pumpkins without his voice. its unique and it fit the earlier angst driven songs best
Ginger Reys the 3 best of bassist for a smashing pumpkins heuejejen
Damn she's hot!
my gawd, Ginger looks amazing.
billy is and always will be the pumpkins
its really a dream pop song
17 years ago in twelve days..
Great drumming here..
Thats the way he kills I guess
agree 100%
Il mio pezzo preferito da Zeitgeist
smashing punkins play in sudamerica in december i hope they play in PERU !!!!!
yep, he quit after the tour. they say billy will continue as smashing pumpkins with all touring musicians. i think its dead now. jimmy's drumming can't be replaced
just a soooo great vid thx 4 upload :) greez
omfg yes finally someone who agrees
thanks for posting...
Yes, I'm aware of that.
wheres the video gone, it was on youtube a while back but can't find it anymore :(... this live version is still awesome though
i hate people that complain they should get the band back together, they have been invited back multiple times but they turned billy down each time
This is why billy is my hero
genial poesía hecha música !!!
thats because on the cd its Billy playing bass, lead, and rhythm guitar. He's also doing backing vocals too. When recording Zeitgeist, Billy didn't have his live crew yet. After the album was recorded he recuited the live crew like on Live Earth. That may be reason why all the songs sound better live off of Zeitgeist.
and it was GOOD. more than that.
BJORK was there in novemeber i hope smashing pumpkins play too in Peru !!!!!
I want to see more shots of the keyboard player.
comment on billy for all u want. i still love they way he is and the new pumpkins. as a fan, we should support them and their decisions
2:16 - 2:30 i want the sound of my death to be like that, so peacefull
SPEAK THE TRUTH
Very good!
I don't know if I ever responded to this, but I know all my friends do, but I mean I'm talking about in general. It seems like even the hardcore fans were a little divided though. Anyways, when I posted that comment I don't think I completely understood the way pumpkins had been boxed in by their hits, which I think contributed as well to a general aura of disappointment with Zeitgeist upon its release. I didn't listen to them then, so this is really just based on what I've read since.
i love this song...
i think that´s SP is the same of the past...
Billy will always be stunning and amazing... But i still want to see him play with his original pumpkins members- D'Arcy, Jimmy, and James... I miss "THE SMASHING PUMPKINS"
While I understand that viewpoint, and I did see that interview, that interview was filmed before she had talked about her solo album. It is pure speculation to say either way.
thanks alot to you guys for letting me know who were the orignal memebers were. and to PaidYouOff how am i being lazy, i just asking other sp fans a question. though it is my fault that i didnt find them earlier. oh and i bout melion collie and the infinite, one word......awesome
oooh on my birthday too!!
Every album's gotta have a radio single
so true
yessssssah.