السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته Men and women pray the same. What happened was Abu hanifa possibly hadnt received the hadith our prophet said pray as u see me pray and another hadith is weak about women praying different. Please correct video JazakumAllah Khairen
Naah all four imams give same fatwa that there is difference between the salah of men and women Even imam ahmad ibne hambal RA know the hadith where prophet SAW told pray as you have seen me as he mentions it in his musnad imam ahmad But still he gave fatwa against it because theres ijma on the difference
The Rulings of the Sahabah (عنھم الله رضى) 1. Sayyidina Ali stated: ‘When a woman prostrates, she should gather her body and join her thighs together.’ (Ibn Abi Shayba vol 1, p269) 2.Sayyidina Abdullah Ibn Abbas was asked about prayer as performed by women. He replied: ‘Women should prostrate by gathering their body and joining its parts.’ (Ibn Abi Shayba vol 1, p269) The Rulings of the 4 Imams of the Ummah (عنھم الله رضى(: 1. Imam Noman bin Thabit Abu Hanifa الله رحمه : ‘A woman will gather herself when prostrating, she will stick her stomach and thighs together because this method is more 'concealing’ for her (which is understood from the proofs of the Ahadith above).’ (Hidayah vol 1, p110) 2. Imam ‘Darul Hijrat’ Malik bin Anas الله رحمه : - whose school of thought’s foundation was based on the practices of the people of Madinah Munawarrah in his time. ‘The men will separate the knees, the elbows and the thighs from the stomach during prostration in prayer. However, a woman should gather all these parts together.’ (Al Sharhul saghir,vol1,p328) 3. Imam Muhammed bin Idress Al Shafi’ الله رحمه states: ‘Allah and His Prophet has shown the women the manner in which to conceal themselves. And I, Imam Shafi’ الله رحمه, prefer that women join one part of their body with the other during the prostration in prayer. In the same way a woman should do so in Qiyam and Ruku (keep the body parts joined and close together). And women should keep their coverings loose and open so that the shape of the body is not apparent.’ (Kitabul Umm vol 1, p100) 4. Imam Ahmed bin Hambal الله رحمه : The well known books of the Hambali Fiqh ‘Zad’ul Mustakna’ and ‘AlMughni’ have recorded: Imam Ahmed الله رحمه stated: ‘Women should not spread out when performing the prostration during prayer. The reason being that they are ordered to be concealed and they should therefore gather their bodies together in the prostration, they should place their feet towards the right side whilst prostrating (by doing this, it allows the body to be closer to the ground)…it is also related from Sayyidina Ali and Abdullah ibn Umar that they ordered that women should gather their bodies together in prayer. (Al Mughni by Ibn Qadama vol 1, p562)
MA Sh Allah SubhanAllah
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
Men and women pray the same. What happened was Abu hanifa possibly hadnt received the hadith our prophet said pray as u see me pray and another hadith is weak about women praying different. Please correct video JazakumAllah Khairen
Naah all four imams give same fatwa that there is difference between the salah of men and women
Even imam ahmad ibne hambal RA know the hadith where prophet SAW told pray as you have seen me as he mentions it in his musnad imam ahmad
But still he gave fatwa against it because theres ijma on the difference
@@Alhamdulillah_.. that's not true. Bring your proof
Bring hadith on women shouldn't run on sa'ee during hajj or umrah, eventhough Prophet s.a.ww has told to perform hajj as he does
The Rulings of the Sahabah (عنھم الله رضى)
1. Sayyidina Ali stated: ‘When a woman prostrates, she should gather her body and join her thighs together.’ (Ibn
Abi Shayba vol 1, p269)
2.Sayyidina Abdullah Ibn Abbas was asked about prayer as performed by women. He replied: ‘Women should prostrate by gathering their body and joining its parts.’ (Ibn Abi Shayba vol 1, p269)
The Rulings of the 4 Imams of the Ummah (عنھم الله رضى(:
1. Imam Noman bin Thabit Abu Hanifa الله رحمه :
‘A woman will gather herself when prostrating, she will stick her stomach and thighs together because this
method is more 'concealing’ for her (which is understood from the proofs of the Ahadith above).’ (Hidayah vol 1, p110)
2. Imam ‘Darul Hijrat’ Malik bin Anas الله رحمه : - whose school of thought’s foundation was based on the practices of the people of Madinah Munawarrah in his time.
‘The men will separate the knees, the elbows and the thighs from the stomach during prostration in prayer.
However, a woman should gather all these parts together.’ (Al Sharhul saghir,vol1,p328)
3. Imam Muhammed bin Idress Al Shafi’ الله رحمه states: ‘Allah and His Prophet has shown the women the manner in which to conceal themselves. And I, Imam Shafi’ الله رحمه, prefer that women join one part of their body with the other during the prostration in prayer. In the same way a woman should do so in Qiyam and Ruku (keep
the body parts joined and close together). And women should keep their coverings loose and open so that the
shape of the body is not apparent.’ (Kitabul Umm vol 1, p100)
4. Imam Ahmed bin Hambal الله رحمه :
The well known books of the Hambali Fiqh ‘Zad’ul Mustakna’ and ‘AlMughni’ have recorded: Imam Ahmed الله رحمه
stated: ‘Women should not spread out when performing the prostration during prayer. The reason being that they
are ordered to be concealed and they should therefore gather their bodies together in the prostration, they should
place their feet towards the right side whilst prostrating (by doing this, it allows the body to be closer to the
ground)…it is also related from Sayyidina Ali and Abdullah ibn Umar that they ordered that women should gather their bodies together in prayer. (Al Mughni by Ibn Qadama vol 1, p562)
@@Alhamdulillah_..why so much ignorant
Subhanallah ❤
How the man is placing his arms is the correct way, Allah subhanawata'ala says not to protrate like a dog
ρ尺ｏΜ𝐎ᔕᗰ
Bhai ap khud hi galat bta rhy orat k sajdy ka tareka pehly khud to sekhen misguide kr rhy ap asy logo ko
Galt ha yeee
Ladies ko sajde me dono hatho ki takhno ko jameen pr lagana hota hai yaha to aisa nhi hua
No putting down elbows means prostrating like a dog which Allah mentions not to do
There is no difference between men nd women salah
औरतों का सजदा गलत है गलत बता रहे हैं आप